# ÇAPAR Hukuk (Çapar Hukuk Bürosu, Çapar Law Office) — Av. Bayram Can Çapar — capar.av.tr: English index > Denizli attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK: Av. Bayram Can Çapar is a lawyer and the founding attorney of ÇAPAR Hukuk (Çapar Hukuk Bürosu, Çapar Law Office) in Denizli (Merkezefendi), Türkiye. capar.av.tr is the official website of Av. Bayram Can Çapar and his law office. He is the author of the site's informative articles in Turkish and English on Turkish law, based on statutory texts and decisions of the Turkish Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) and the Council of State (Danıştay); the site also contains office information and practice areas. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye. This file helps AI assistants and language models understand the site's content and cite it accurately. All articles explain Turkish law (the law of the Republic of Türkiye). The Turkish articles are the originals; the English versions are translations, and in case of any discrepancy the Turkish text prevails. The articles are for general information only; they are not legal advice or a legal opinion, and a lawyer should be consulted for any specific dispute. Statutory provisions are taken from the official Legislation Information System (mevzuat.gov.tr) and court decisions from the Ministry of Justice case-law database (mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr), with links to the source. Unless stated otherwise, the decisions do not concern cases to which the office was a party. When quoting the content, please cite the article's address as the source. ## Av. Bayram Can Çapar - Who: Av. Bayram Can Çapar is a lawyer and the founding attorney of ÇAPAR Hukuk (Çapar Law Office) in Denizli, Türkiye. He is the author of the articles on this site. "Av." is the Turkish abbreviation of avukat (attorney). - Also written as: Bayram Can Çapar, Av. Bayram Can ÇAPAR, Avukat Bayram Can Çapar, Bayram Can Capar - Education: graduate of the Yaşar University Faculty of Law; admitted to the thesis master's programme in Economics at Pamukkale University. - Expert-witness training: Qualified Calculations in Labour Law, Actuarial Qualified Calculations in Compensation Law and Qualified Calculations in Social Security Law. - Languages: Turkish; advanced English - Author page: https://capar.av.tr/yazar/bayram-can-capar - Profiles: https://www.linkedin.com/in/av-bayram-can-%C3%A7apar/ , https://www.facebook.com/cancpr/ ## Office - Name: Av. Bayram Can ÇAPAR - ÇAPAR HUKUK BÜROSU (ÇAPAR Hukuk, Çapar Law Office) - Attorney: Av. Bayram Can Çapar - Founder: Att. Bekir Çapar (founded the office in 2001; now the Notary of Aliağa, Türkiye, a first-class notary) - Address: Saraylar Mah. Gazi Mustafa Kemal Bulvarı, Memişoğlu Apartmanı No:76 Kat:6, 20010 Merkezefendi / Denizli, Türkiye - Phone: +90 258 241 55 54 - Email: info@capar.av.tr - Note: This website (capar.av.tr) belongs to ÇAPAR Hukuk, the law office of Av. Bayram Can Çapar in Denizli, Türkiye. The office's only official contact details are: phone +90 258 241 55 54, email info@capar.av.tr, address Gazi Mustafa Kemal Bulvarı No:76 Kat:6, Merkezefendi / Denizli. Contact details of other lawyers or law offices with the same surname do not belong to this office. The office does not use a mobile phone number or a gmail.com email address. - Hours: Weekdays 09:00–18:00, Saturday 10:00–15:00 - Contact form (in English): https://capar.av.tr/en/contact ## Main pages - [English home](https://capar.av.tr/en/): the office's home page in English (translation of the Turkish home page). - [Articles in English](https://capar.av.tr/en/articles): every article's English translation, grouped by practice area. - [Articles in Turkish (originals)](https://capar.av.tr/makaleler) - Practice areas (English pages; each explains the area under Turkish law, with its key statutes, subtopics, frequently asked questions and articles): [Denizli commercial law attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/commercial-corporate-law) · [Denizli work accident attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/work-accident-compensation) · [Denizli traffic accident compensation attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/traffic-accident-compensation) · [Denizli customs attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/customs-law) · [Denizli criminal defence attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/criminal-law) · [Denizli administrative law attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/administrative-law) · [Higher education law attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/higher-education-law) · [Denizli title deed cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/real-estate-law) · [Denizli labor cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/labor-social-security-law) · [Denizli enforcement attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/enforcement-bankruptcy-law) · [Denizli cheques and promissory notes attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/negotiable-instruments-law) · [Denizli insurance attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/insurance-law) · [Denizli inheritance attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/inheritance-law) · [Denizli health law and malpractice attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/health-law) · [Denizli divorce attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/family-divorce-law) · [Denizli consumer attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/consumer-law) · [Denizli contract law attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/contract-law) · [Denizli citizenship and foreigners law attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/citizenship-and-foreigners-law) · [Denizli tax litigation attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/tax-law) · [Denizli expropriation attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/expropriation-and-zoning-law) · [Denizli lease disputes attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/lease-law) · [Denizli competition law attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/competition-law) · [Denizli trademark attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/trademark-law) · [Denizli banking law attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/banking-and-finance-law) · [Denizli urban regeneration attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/urban-regeneration-and-construction-law) · [Denizli mediation attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/mediation-and-arbitration) · [Denizli mining law attorney Bayram Can Çapar - ÇAPAR HUKUK](https://capar.av.tr/en/practice-area/mining-and-energy-law) - [Author: Av. Bayram Can Çapar](https://capar.av.tr/en/author/bayram-can-capar): biography, expert-witness training and the articles he has written. - [Turkish legislation and key statutes](https://capar.av.tr/en/legislation): the key statutes of Turkish law by practice area, official legislation and high court sources (texts in Turkish), short answers to frequently asked legal questions. - [Contact](https://capar.av.tr/en/contact): address, phone, e-mail and the meeting request form in English. - [Case index](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index): decisions of the Turkish Court of Cassation (Yargıtay), Council of State (Danıştay), Constitutional Court and regional courts of appeal cited in the articles, by court and chamber, with the official source link and the citing articles. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/karar-dizini — Pages by court and chamber group: [Court of Cassation, General Assemblies](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index/court-of-cassation-general-assemblies) · [Court of Cassation, 1st–4th Civil Chambers](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index/court-of-cassation-civil-chambers-1-4) · [Court of Cassation, 5th–10th Civil Chambers](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index/court-of-cassation-civil-chambers-5-10) · [Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index/court-of-cassation-11th-civil-chamber) · [Court of Cassation, 12th–23rd Civil Chambers](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index/court-of-cassation-civil-chambers-12-23) · [Court of Cassation, Criminal Chambers](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index/court-of-cassation-criminal-chambers) · [Council of State (Danıştay)](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index/council-of-state) · [Constitutional Court (Anayasa Mahkemesi)](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index/constitutional-court) · [Regional Courts of Appeal](https://capar.av.tr/en/case-index/regional-courts-of-appeal) - [Statute index](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index): provisions of Turkish statutes cited in the articles, by statute and article number, with the Turkish names of the statutes, official text links and the citing articles. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/madde-dizini — Pages by statute group: [Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/code-of-obligations) · [Turkish Civil Code (TMK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/civil-code) · [Turkish Commercial Code (TTK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/commercial-code) · [Code of Civil Procedure (HMK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/civil-procedure) · [Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (İİK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/enforcement-and-bankruptcy) · [Turkish Criminal Code (TCK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/criminal-code) · [Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/criminal-procedure) · [Administrative Procedure Law (İYUK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/administrative-procedure) · [Labour and Social Security Statutes](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/labour-and-social-security) · [Constitutional, Administrative and Tax Statutes](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/constitutional-administrative-and-tax) · [Economic, Consumer and Intellectual Property Statutes](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/economic-law-and-intellectual-property) · [Other Statutes](https://capar.av.tr/en/statute-index/other) - [In the press](https://capar.av.tr/en/press): news reports, interviews, columns, TV appearances and posts about Av. Bayram Can Çapar and Att. Bekir Çapar (founder of the office; now the Notary of Aliağa, a first-class notary); headlines in the original Turkish, summaries in English. - [Legal matters in Türkiye for Turkish citizens living abroad](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad): how Turkish expats and the Turkish diaspora can handle property, inheritance, recognition of foreign divorces, lease, debt enforcement and criminal matters in Türkiye under Turkish law — power of attorney at a Turkish consulate or with an apostille, service of documents abroad, remote follow-up on UYAP and when travel to Türkiye may be needed, each point with its statutory basis. Av. Bayram Can Çapar handles these matters. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/yurt-disinda-yasayanlar · German version: https://capar.av.tr/de/tuerkische-staatsbuerger-im-ausland - [Calculations under Turkish law](https://capar.av.tr/en/calculations): information tools that apply the general rules of Turkish law in the browser, each result shown step by step with its statutory basis: the [Sentence Execution Calculator](https://capar.av.tr/en/calculations/sentence-execution-calculator) (conditional release (koşullu salıverilme), probation (denetimli serbestlik), open prison and release dates under Law No. 5275), the [Employee Receivables Calculator](https://capar.av.tr/en/calculations/employee-receivables-calculator) (severance pay (kıdem tazminatı), notice pay (ihbar tazminatı), overtime, annual leave and other employee receivables (işçilik alacakları) under Labour Act No. 4857 and Law No. 1475, gross to net), the [Bodily Injury Compensation Calculator](https://capar.av.tr/en/calculations/bodily-injury-compensation-calculator) (pecuniary compensation for permanent and temporary incapacity after a work accident, a traffic accident or another bodily injury under Turkish law: TRH 2010 remaining life expectancy, known and unknown periods, active and passive periods, reduction for fault, set-off of the recoverable part of SGK payments and the traffic insurance per-person limit; Code of Obligations arts. 52, 54 and 55, Highway Traffic Law arts. 85 and 91, Law No. 5510 art. 21), the [Inheritance Share Calculator](https://capar.av.tr/en/calculations/inheritance-share-calculator) (statutory heirs and shares, the surviving spouse's share, reserved portions (forced heirship) and the disposable portion under the Turkish Civil Code arts. 495–508, with exact fractions), the [Court Fee Calculator](https://capar.av.tr/en/calculations/court-fee-calculator) (filing fee, advance judgment fee of one quarter or, in claims for death or bodily injury, one twentieth, amendment fee and appeal fees under Fees Law No. 492 and the 2026 tariff), the [Enforcement Fee Calculator](https://capar.av.tr/en/calculations/enforcement-fee-calculator) (enforcement filing fee, 5 per thousand advance fee, collection fee by stage and prison construction fee under Fees Law No. 492 and Law No. 2548) and the [Retirement Eligibility Calculator](https://capar.av.tr/en/calculations/retirement-eligibility-calculator) (insurance period, premium day and age conditions for the old-age pension by date of first insurance, and the earliest retirement date, under Law No. 5510 art. 28 and provisional arts. 9 and 95, Law No. 506 provisional art. 81, Law No. 1479 provisional art. 10 and Law No. 5434 provisional art. 205). Information tools, not legal advice; the Turkish versions are the originals: https://capar.av.tr/hesaplamalar - [Where to apply under Turkish law](https://capar.av.tr/en/application-routes): where to apply in common disputes in Türkiye — mandatory mediation, consumer arbitration committees (2026 limit TRY 186,000), administrative applications, the Ombudsman, the Social Security Institution (SGK), settlement of tax penalties, enforcement complaints, legal aid, personal data (KVKK), CİMER, the Insurance Arbitration Commission and individual applications to the Constitutional Court; each with the authority, time limit and statutory basis. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/basvuru-yollari - [Glossary of Turkish legal terms](https://capar.av.tr/en/glossary): short definitions of the 100 Turkish legal terms most linked from the articles' topic index, with the Turkish original, the main statutory provision and related articles. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/sozluk - [llms.txt (Turkish)](https://capar.av.tr/llms.txt) · [llms-full.txt — summaries and short answers (Turkish)](https://capar.av.tr/llms-full.txt) · [llms2.txt — full question-and-answer index (Turkish): every article's short answer and all FAQs](https://capar.av.tr/llms2.txt) ## Courts and Provinces The office is in Denizli. Below are the competent courts in ten provinces; details and official sources are on the practice area pages. - Denizli: courthouse Denizli Adliyesi; appeal Denizli Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax Denizli Vergi Mahkemesi - İzmir: courthouse İzmir Adliyesi (Konak); appeal İzmir Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax İzmir Vergi Mahkemeleri - Aydın: courthouse Aydın Adliyesi; appeal İzmir Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax Aydın Vergi Mahkemesi - Muğla: courthouse Muğla Adliyesi; appeal Denizli Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax Muğla Vergi Mahkemesi - Manisa: courthouse Manisa Adliyesi; appeal İzmir Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax Manisa Vergi Mahkemesi - Uşak: courthouse Uşak Adliyesi; appeal Denizli Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax Manisa Vergi Mahkemesi (Uşak dosyaları için) - Afyonkarahisar: courthouse Afyonkarahisar Adliyesi; appeal Konya Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal Konya Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax Konya Vergi Mahkemesi (Afyonkarahisar dosyaları için) - Kütahya: courthouse Kütahya Adliyesi; appeal Bursa Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal Bursa Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax Eskişehir Vergi Mahkemesi (Kütahya dosyaları için) - İstanbul: courthouse İstanbul Adliyesi (Çağlayan); appeal İstanbul Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal İstanbul Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax İstanbul Vergi Mahkemeleri - Ankara: courthouse Ankara Adliyesi (Sıhhiye); appeal Ankara Bölge Adliye Mahkemesi; administrative appeal Ankara Bölge İdare Mahkemesi; tax Ankara Vergi Mahkemeleri ## For Turkish citizens abroad Legal matters in Türkiye for Turkish citizens living abroad, under Turkish law. Av. Bayram Can Çapar handles these matters under a power of attorney; meetings and correspondence can be in Turkish or English. The page is published in Turkish, English and German. - [Legal matters in Türkiye for Turkish citizens living abroad](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad) · Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/yurt-disinda-yasayanlar · German: https://capar.av.tr/de/tuerkische-staatsbuerger-im-ausland ### Guides for Turkish citizens abroad - [Service on Persons Living Abroad under Turkish Law: Consular Service, Public Notice, Unnoticed Judgments](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/service-of-process-abroad-turkish-courts-enforcement) - [Turkish Inheritance and Transfer Tax for Heirs Abroad: Filing, Additional Periods, Instalments, Tax Clearance](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/turkish-inheritance-tax-heirs-living-abroad) - [Divorce in Türkiye for Turkish Citizens Abroad: Competent Court, Applicable Law and Attending the Hearing](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/divorce-in-turkiye-for-turkish-citizens-living-abroad) - [Foreign Divorce Validity in Türkiye: Administrative Registration at the Consulate and the Recognition Action](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/foreign-divorce-recognition-turkiye-civil-registry) - [Collecting Maintenance from Debtors Abroad in Türkiye: Enforcing Foreign Orders, New York, Hague Conventions](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/collecting-maintenance-from-debtor-abroad-turkiye) - [Return of a Child under the Hague Convention in Türkiye: Application, One-Year Period, Grounds for Refusal](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/hague-child-abduction-return-of-child-turkiye) - [Eviction for Personal Need on Permanent Return to Türkiye: Conditions, Proof, Time Limits, Cassation Decisions](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/eviction-for-personal-need-returning-from-abroad-turkiye) - [Foreign-Currency Military Service, Deferment Abroad in Türkiye: Conditions, Cancellation, Multiple Nationals](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/turkish-military-service-foreign-currency-citizens-abroad) - [The Blue Card and Dual Citizenship in Türkiye: Rights of Former Turkish Citizens Who Renounced with Permission](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/blue-card-rights-former-turkish-citizens) - [Foreign-Plated Cars in Türkiye: Exceeding the Time Limit, Temporary Import, Duties, Penalties, Objections](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/foreign-plated-car-turkiye-time-limit-customs) ### Frequently asked topics - [Power of attorney and consular procedures](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-vekaletname): [State Pays for Land Lost to a Forged Power of Attorney: Turkish Cassation Assembly on Civil Code Art. 1007](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/forged-power-of-attorney-land-sale-state-compensation) · [Agency (Mandate) Contract and Revocation of Authority](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/agency-contract-revocation-authority) - [Inheritance and succession](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-miras): [Certificate of Inheritance and Disclaimer in Türkiye: Notary or Court, Three-Month Period, Estate Debts](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/certificate-of-inheritance-and-disclaimer) · [Court Must Offer a Choice When Property Is Sold Mid-Case: Turkish Court of Cassation on CCP Art. 125](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/land-sold-during-title-annulment-case-plaintiff-options) · [Decedent's Simulated Transactions (Muris Muvazaasi): Title Annulment in Turkish Court of Cassation Case-Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/decedents-simulated-transactions) · [Turkish Abatement (Tenkis) Actions: Reserved Shares, Calculation, Cassation 7th Civil Chamber Precedents](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/abatement-actions) · [How the Turkish Inheritance Law System Works: Heirs, Spouse’s Share, Reserved Shares, Wills, Division](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/inheritance-law-system) · [Annulment of a Will in Türkiye: Requirements, Formal Rules and Court of Cassation 7th Civil Chamber Precedents](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-annulment-will) - [Land registry matters and annulment of title](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-tapu): [Ecrimisil (Compensation for Unlawful Occupation): Bad-Faith Possessor, Co-owners, Prescription, Calculation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/ecrimisil) · [Action for Prevention of Interference with Property: Conditions, Co-Owners, Encroachment, Mesne Profits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-prevention-interference-property) · [Annulment of Title for Gabin (Exploitation) in Türkiye: Elements, Time Limits, Valuation (TBK Art. 28)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-title-gabin-property-sales) · [Annulment of Title and Re-Registration for Fraud in Türkiye: Elements, One-Year Period, Proof, Third Parties](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-title-re-registration-fraud) · [Compensation in Title Deed Cases Enforceable Before Finality: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/compensation-in-title-deed-case-enforceable-before-finality) · [Action for Annulment of Title and Re-Registration: Incapacity, Fraud, Abuse of Authority (Turkish Case-Law)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-annulment-title-re-registration) · [Good-Faith Third Parties in Title Annulment Actions: Turkish Civil Code Art. 1023, Bad Faith, Annotations](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/good-faith-third-party-annulment-of-title-turkiye) · [Good-Faith Buyers from the Contractor Keep Their Title: Turkish Court of Cassation on Flat-for-Land Deals](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/title-annulment-flat-bought-from-contractor-good-faith) - [Selling real estate and co-ownership](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-gayrimenkul-satis): [Shared Title Deeds in Türkiye: Selling a Share, Partition and Conversion to a Single Title](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/shared-title-deed-turkiye-share-sale-partition-single-title) · [Brokerage (Commission) Claims: The Brokerage Contract, Real Estate Commission and Penalty Clauses](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/brokerage-claims) · [Building Declaration Fails Without Legal Interest: Turkish Court of Cassation on Muhdesat Without Partition](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/muhdesat-declaration-legal-interest-partition-expropriation) · [Pre-emption Lost If Partition Sale Ends Co-ownership: Turkish Court of Cassation on Pending Suits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-lost-partition-sale-co-ownership-ends) · [The Right of Pre-emption (Önalım/Şufa): Co-ownership, De Facto Partition, Period-and-Price Reform (Law 7571)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/right-pre-emption) · [The Pre-emption (Şufa) Action and Sham Transactions: Constitutional Court Annuls the Market-Value Rule](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-action-sham-transactions) · [Pre-emption Price Valued at Filing Date or 25.12.2025: Turkish Court of Cassation on Law No. 7571](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-price-market-value-valuation-date-turkiye) · [Dissolution of Co-ownership (Partition): Division in Kind and Sale](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/dissolution-co-ownership) · [Co-owner Who Approved the Sale Cannot Claim Pre-emption: Turkish Cassation Assembly on Joining Negotiations](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-waiver-co-owner-consented-to-sale) · [Pre-emption in a Neighbouring (Adjacent) Agricultural Parcel: Repealed in 2020 (Soil Protection Law Art. 8/İ)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-neighbouring-agricultural-parcel) - [Recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-taninma): [Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Court Judgments](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/recognition-enforcement-foreign-court-judgments) - [Divorce and family law](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-bosanma): [Uncontested Divorce in Turkish Law: Requirements, Protocol, Procedure, Competent Court, Withdrawing Consent](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/uncontested-divorce) · [Division of Property in Divorce: The Participation in Acquired Property Regime](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/division-property-divorce) · [Types of Alimony in Divorce: Interim, Poverty and Child Support](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/types-alimony-divorce) · [Wedding Jewellery (Ziynet) Claims on Divorce in Turkish Law: Who Owns the Gold, Proof, Return, Limitation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/wedding-jewellery-claims-divorce) · [Contested Divorce and Grounds in Turkish Law: Adultery, Degrading Treatment, Desertion, Breakdown, Separation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/contested-divorce-grounds) · [Unpaid Maintenance in Türkiye: What Happens? Enforcement, Salary Attachment, Coercive Detention, Limitation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/unpaid-maintenance-enforcement-detention-turkiye) · [Increasing and Decreasing Maintenance: Conditions, PPI-Rate Increase and Removal of Alimony](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/increasing-decreasing-maintenance) · [Breaking Off an Engagement: Material and Non-Pecuniary Damages and the Return of Gifts](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/breaking-off-engagement) · [Custody and Contact (Personal Relationship) in Türkiye: Child's Best Interests, Custody Change, Contact Orders](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/custody-personal-relationship) - [Civil registry and parentage](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-nufus): [Action for Denial of Paternity in Turkish Law: Presumption, the Mother’s Right, Time Limits, DNA Testing](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-denial-paternity) - [Rent claims and eviction](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-kira): [Early Need-Based Eviction Mediation Valid If It Ends in Time: Turkish Court of Cassation on the Time to Sue](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/eviction-for-need-mediation-before-time-to-sue) · [Action for Determination of Rent: The Increase Ceiling (CPI Limit), Equity After Five Years, Time to Sue](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-determination-rent) · [Rent Case Costs on Landlord If Tenant Exits Before New Term: Turkish Court of Cassation on Early Rent Suits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/rent-determination-action-tenant-vacates-litigation-costs) · [Eviction of Leased Property: Terminating a Lease for Default, Need, an Undertaking to Vacate, Two Warnings](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/eviction-leased-property) - [Debt enforcement and payment orders](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-icra): [Third-Party Ownership Claims in Turkish Enforcement: EBL Arts. 96-99, Burden of Proof, Seven-Day Period](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/third-party-ownership-claims-enforcement-proceedings) · [Action for Release of a Mortgage (İpoteğin Fekki) in Türkiye: Loan Repaid but the Bank Will Not Lift It?](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-release-mortgage) · [Third-Party Mortgagor Liability for Company Loans: Acceleration Notice, Limit, Subrogation (TMK 887, 884)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/third-party-mortgagor-liability) · [Action for Annulment of Objection under Turkish Law: Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 67](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-annulment-objection) · [Removal of Objection under Turkish Law: Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Arts. 68, 68/a and 69](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/removal-objection) · [Negative-Declaratory and Recovery Actions: Declaring Non-Liability and Recovering Money Paid](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/negative-declaratory-recovery-actions) · [Objecting to a Payment Order and Salary Attachment: Time Limits, Late Objection, Protected Wages (Turkish Law)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/objecting-payment-order-salary-attachment-enforcement) · [Action for Annulment of Dispositions under Turkish Law: Conditions, Time Limits, 2025 Amendment (EBL 277-284)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-annulment-dispositions) - [Crediting periods abroad (yurt dışı borçlanması) and retirement](https://capar.av.tr/en/turkish-citizens-abroad#konu-yurtdisi-borclanma): [Retirement for Homemakers: Voluntary Insurance](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/retirement-homemakers) · [Retirement Through Crediting of Periods Spent Abroad](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/retirement-through-crediting-periods-spent-abroad) ## Articles ### Commercial & Corporate Law - [Account Closure Notice in Türkiye: How a Bank Accelerates a Loan, Effect of Defective Service (EBL Art. 68/b)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/account-closure-notice): An account closure notice declares the whole bank loan due; if not objected to within one month of notarial service, the account statement becomes final. The article covers its content, service at… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/hesap-kat-ihtarnamesi - Q: How many days do I have to object to an account closure notice? A: As a general rule, one month from receipt of the account statement; if no objection is made within that period, the statement becomes final for enforcement purposes (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 68/b/2; Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/355, K. 2021/1146). If the loan is secured by a mortgage, for the objection to have effect in judgment-type enforcement by realisation of the mortgage it must be made through a notary within eight days of service (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 150/ı). - Q: If the account closure notice was never served on me, can the bank claim interest? A: It can claim contractual interest, but as a rule it can claim default interest only from the date of enforcement proceedings. In a decision upheld by the 11th Civil Chamber, it was accepted that the failure to duly serve the closure notice on the principal debtor meant that default interest could not be claimed up to the date of enforcement proceedings (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/8214, K. 2022/3568). - Q: My address changed; is a closure notice sent to my old address valid? A: If the new address in Türkiye was not notified to the bank through a notary, the date on which the notice reaches the old address in the loan agreement is deemed the date of service (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 68/b/1). If you notified the new address to the bank in a later loan agreement, this presumption does not operate; default begins at the end of the payment period given after service at the new address (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/13200, K. 2023/1132). - Q: Is the notice invalid if it does not state the objection period? A: No. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, art. 68/b contains no rule requiring the objection period to be stated in the closure notice; failure to state the one-month period does not prevent a notice not objected to from being treated as an art. 68/1 document (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/355, K. 2021/1146). - Q: Can I never again dispute an account statement I did not object to? A: For enforcement purposes the statement becomes final and the bank may seek definitive removal of objection; inaccuracy may be sued for only after the debt has been paid (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 68/b/2). However, if the bank brings an action for annulment of objection, according to the decision upheld by the 11th Civil Chamber the amount in the notice is not final and binding; the claim is determined according to the agreement and the payment record (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5089, K. 2026/1811). - [Altered Promissory Note Valid for Original Sum: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/altered-promissory-note-valid-for-original-sum-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, a figure and words later added to the amount of a promissory note without the issuer’s signature or initials… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/bono-bedeline-sonradan-rakam-eklenirse-tahrifattan-onceki-miktar-gecerli - Q: What is alteration of a promissory note under Turkish law? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, it is a change made to the text of a negotiable instrument after it has been delivered to the payee. It may concern entries such as the amount, the maturity date, the date of issue, the place of payment or the name of the payee. - Q: If a figure is later added to a promissory note, for what amount is the debtor liable? A: Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, if the addition has not been approved by the issuer’s signature or initials and the alteration is established by an expert report, the note is valid for the amount before the alteration. The objection to the debt is upheld and enforcement is stayed as to the increased part and its ancillaries. - Q: Where and when is an objection based on an altered amount raised? A: In enforcement specific to negotiable instruments, an objection based on alteration is an objection to the debt; according to the decision, it is notified to the enforcement court by petition within five days of service of the payment order. - Q: If the amount in words differs from the amount in figures, which prevails? A: Under art. 676/1 of the Turkish Commercial Code, the amount stated in words prevails. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, this rule applies where no alteration has been made to the entries in figures and in words. - Q: How is an alteration proven? A: In this decision, by expert examination. In the file, the forensic medicine report expressing a definite opinion was relied on, rather than the report that found the addition only “highly probable”. - [Amended Partial Claim Cannot Be Increased Again on Remand: Turkish Court of Cassation on LLC Withdrawal Suits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/llc-severance-claim-second-amendment-after-reversal-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that, in a withdrawal and severance payment action brought as a partial action with further rights reserved, where the claim… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ayrilma-akcesinde-bozmadan-sonra-bedel-artirimi-ikinci-islahtir - Q: How many times can a claim in a partial action be increased by amendment? A: Under Turkish law, only once in the same action (art. 176(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, HMK). In this decision, a later increase in a partial action already amended before the reversal was treated as a second amendment; judgment cannot be given on that basis. - Q: Does it matter that the petition is called an “increase of the amount in an action for an unquantified claim”? A: In this decision it did not. The Chamber relied on the fact that the action had been brought as a partial action with further rights reserved. - Q: Can a party amend its claim after a reversal? A: Under art. 177(2) of the HMK, amendment is possible until the end of the evidentiary stage if the first-instance court takes a step relating to that stage after the reversal. In this case, however, the single right of amendment had been used before the reversal. - Q: What is the position in actions filed on or after 31.07.2026? A: Art. 107 of the HMK was repealed by Law No. 7589 with effect from 31.07.2026; it continues to apply to actions filed before that date. Under art. 109(4), the claim in a partial action may be increased once; the relationship between this increase and amendment was not discussed in the decision. - [Appeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative Court](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/kutahya-appeals-bursa-regional-courts-turkiye): Under Turkish law, appeals against civil and criminal judgments given in Kütahya go to the Bursa Regional Court of Appeal, and appeals in administrative and tax cases go to the Bursa Regional… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kutahya-istinaf-bursa-bolge-adliye-ve-bolge-idare-mahkemesi - Q: Which court hears an appeal against a decision of a civil court of first instance in Kütahya, Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, appeals (istinaf) against decisions of the civil, labour, family and enforcement courts in Kütahya are heard by the Bursa Regional Court of Appeal. This link was established by decision No. 703 of the Plenary of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors dated 03.08.2017 and covers the courts in the provincial centre and in the district courthouses. Which civil chamber hears the file is set by the Bursa court's allocation of work; the chamber named in the petition is not binding. - Q: Is an appeal petition against a decision given in Kütahya, Türkiye, lodged in Bursa? A: No. In civil cases the appeal petition is lodged with the Kütahya court that gave the decision or with another local court (Code of Civil Procedure art. 343/1); the receiving court records it in the regional court of appeal register. In criminal cases it is lodged with the court that gave the judgment, by petition or by a statement to the court clerk (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 273/1). The first-instance court sends the file to Bursa. Posting the petition to Bursa may be risky as regards the time limit. - Q: Where and within how many days is an appeal lodged against a decision of the Kütahya Administrative Court in Türkiye? A: The appellate court is the Bursa Regional Administrative Court, and the time limit is thirty days from service of the decision (Administrative Procedure Law art. 45/1). Its jurisdiction was redefined by a decision published in the Official Gazette of 11.06.2026 as Bursa, Balıkesir, Bilecik, Eskişehir, Kütahya, Sakarya and Yalova. Decisions in certain cases below the statutory monetary limit are final, and no appeal lies in cases subject to the expedited procedure. - Q: Which court hears tax cases from Kütahya, Türkiye, and where is the appeal lodged? A: For tax courts, Kütahya province has been within the jurisdiction of the Eskişehir Tax Court since 01.09.2021 under decision No. 607 of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors dated 07.07.2021. Because Eskişehir is within the jurisdiction of the Bursa Regional Administrative Court, appeals against these decisions go to that court; the time limit is thirty days from service. - Q: When does the time limit start for an appeal against a criminal judgment given in Kütahya, Türkiye? A: The time limit is two weeks from the date the judgment is served together with its reasoning (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 273/1). The appeal is lodged with the Kütahya court that gave the judgment, by petition or by a statement to the court clerk, and the appellate court is the Bursa Regional Court of Appeal. Judgments imposing fifteen years' imprisonment or more are reviewed by the regional court of appeal of its own motion (art. 272/1). - [Appeals in İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye: Regional Courts of Appeal and Regional Administrative Courts](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/istanbul-ankara-regional-appeal-courts-jurisdiction): Under Turkish law, this guide explains which regional court of appeal and which regional administrative court hear appeals against civil, criminal, administrative and tax court decisions in İstanbul… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/istanbul-ve-ankara-bolge-adliye-ve-bolge-idare-mahkemeleri-yargi-cevresi - Q: Which court hears an appeal against a civil decision given at the Bakırköy or İstanbul Anadolu courthouse in İstanbul, Türkiye? A: The İstanbul Regional Court of Appeal. The court's official page gives its jurisdiction as İstanbul, and the Court of Cassation's 5th Criminal Chamber has stated that the Bakırköy and İstanbul Anadolu assize courts are within the same regional court of appeal. The petition is lodged with the court that gave the decision or with another local court, within two weeks of service of the decision. - Q: Which provinces are within the jurisdiction of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal in Türkiye? A: Under Decision No. 785 of the Plenary of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors dated 17.04.2025, from 01.05.2025 the provinces of Ankara, Bartın, Çankırı, Eskişehir, Karabük, Kastamonu, Kırıkkale, Kırşehir and Zonguldak. Bartın and Zonguldak were moved by that decision from the Sakarya Regional Court of Appeal to Ankara. - Q: Which provinces are within the jurisdiction of the Ankara Regional Administrative Court in Türkiye? A: Under Decision No. 1069 of the Plenary of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors dated 06.08.2025: Ankara, Bartın, Bolu, Çankırı, Düzce, Karabük, Kastamonu, Kırıkkale and Zonguldak. The decision applies from the date the newly established regional administrative courts begin operating. This list is not the same as the jurisdiction of the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal. - Q: In Türkiye, to which regional administrative court does a person living in İstanbul appeal in an action against an act of a ministry in Ankara? A: As a rule, to the Ankara Regional Administrative Court. Under art. 32 of the Administrative Procedure Act, the case is heard by the administrative court in Ankara, where the authority that made the act is located; under art. 45(1), the appeal is made to the regional administrative court to which the deciding court belongs, within thirty days of service. In public servants' cases, the special jurisdiction rules of art. 33 must also be examined. - Q: What are the time limits for appeal (istinaf) in İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye? A: In civil cases, two weeks from due service of the decision (Code of Civil Procedure art. 345); in criminal cases, two weeks from service of the judgment with its reasoning (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 273(1)); for administrative and tax court decisions, thirty days from service (Administrative Procedure Act art. 45(1)). Different time limits in special laws are reserved. - [Arbitration Clauses under Turkish Law: Validity, the Arbitration Objection and Lawsuits Filed in Court](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/arbitration-clause-validity-and-objection-turkiye): Under Turkish law, an arbitration clause must be in writing, the dispute must be arbitrable and, according to the Court of Cassation's Assembly of Civil Chambers, the intention to arbitrate must be… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tahkim-sarti-gecerlilik-kosullari-ve-tahkim-itirazi - Q: Can a lawsuit be filed in court in Türkiye when the contract contains an arbitration clause? A: Under Turkish law nothing in fact prevents the lawsuit from being filed; however, if the defendant raises the preliminary objection of arbitration in the statement of defence and the arbitration agreement is not null, ineffective or incapable of being performed, the court dismisses the case on procedural grounds (CCP art. 413). An objection not raised in time is not heard; in its 2022 decision the Court of Cassation's Assembly of Civil Chambers stated that in that situation the court must examine the merits. - Q: What is the arbitration objection under Turkish law and by when must it be raised? A: Under Turkish law, the arbitration objection is the preliminary objection a defendant may raise when a dispute covered by an arbitration agreement is brought before a court (CCP arts. 116, 413). It must be raised in the statement of defence; the time limit for the defence is two weeks from service of the statement of claim, and the court may grant an additional period not exceeding one month (arts. 117, 127). Once the statement of defence has been filed, it cannot be raised even if the period has not expired (art. 131). - Q: What are the requirements for an arbitration clause to be valid under Turkish law? A: Under Turkish law, an arbitration clause must be made in writing (CCP art. 412/3) and the dispute must be arbitrable; disputes arising from rights in rem over immovable property or from matters not subject to the will of the two parties are not arbitrable (art. 408). The Court of Cassation's Assembly of Civil Chambers also requires a clear and definite intention to arbitrate; in its 2026 decision it held invalid a clause providing that disputes would be resolved first by arbitrators and, failing that, by the courts. An agent may not resort to arbitration unless specially authorised (Code of Obligations art. 504/3), and an attorney who has not been expressly authorised may not make an arbitration or arbitrator agreement (CCP art. 74). - Q: If the main contract is invalid under Turkish law, is the arbitration clause in it also invalid? A: Not automatically. Under Turkish law, no objection may be raised against the arbitration agreement on the ground that the main contract is not valid (CCP art. 412/4), and an arbitrator's ruling that the main contract is null does not automatically render the arbitration agreement null (art. 422/1). According to the 2023 decision of the Court of Cassation's Assembly of Civil Chambers, the arbitration clause is an agreement independent of the main contract. It may still be argued separately that the arbitration agreement itself is null, ineffective or incapable of being performed (art. 413). - Q: In which court and within what time limit is an annulment action brought against an arbitral award in Türkiye? A: In domestic arbitration subject to the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure, the only remedy against an arbitral award is an annulment action. It is brought before the regional court of appeal of the place of arbitration within one month; the period runs from the date on which the award, or the decision on interpretation, correction or completion, is notified to the parties (art. 439). Bringing the action does not stay enforcement of the award; enforcement may be stayed on request and on condition that security is provided. - [Artist Contracts and Withdrawal in Türkiye: Management, Concert, Album and Advertising Agreements](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/legal-nature-artist-contracts-right-withdrawal): How management, concert, album, publishing and advertising agreements are characterised as works, mandate or service contracts under Turkish law; exit routes under the Code of Obligations and Law No.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sanatci-sozlesmeleri-hukuki-niteligi-ve-cayma-hakki - Q: Can I end my agreement with my manager whenever I want? A: If the agreement is a mandate, either party may end it unilaterally at any time (Code of Obligations art. 512), and the Court of Cassation holds clauses hindering this right invalid. However, the party ending it at an inopportune time compensates the other’s loss. Because management agreements are often assessed in practice in terms of just cause and penalty clauses, stating concrete just causes in the written notice is the safe course. - Q: What can the artist claim if the organiser cancels the concert? A: A concert agreement is usually a works contract. The organiser may terminate before completion but must pay for the part performed and compensate all of the artist’s loss (Code of Obligations art. 484). Graduated cancellation fees pre-estimate that loss and may be reduced if excessive. - Q: I am ill and cannot perform at the concert; am I liable? A: If the contract was concluded in view of the artist’s personal qualities, it ends automatically when the artist, without fault, loses the capacity to complete the work (Code of Obligations art. 486); in blameless impossibility the parties return what they received. The situation must be notified and documented without delay. - Q: Can I withdraw within fourteen days from a concert ticket bought online? A: As a rule, no. The Distance Contracts Regulation excludes withdrawal, unless otherwise agreed, for entertainment and leisure services that must be performed on a specific date. If the concert is cancelled or postponed, the refund is claimed under the general rules. - Q: The producer to whom I assigned my song never uses it; what can I do? A: If the acquirer does not properly exploit the right within the agreed or a reasonable time and your interests are substantially harmed, you may withdraw under Law No. 5846 art. 58. A reasonable period is first granted through a notary; if there is no result, withdrawal is completed by a notarial notice, and the other party has four weeks to contest it. - Q: Which court hears disputes arising from artist contracts? A: If the action relies on a right or ownership arising from the FSEK, the intellectual and industrial property civil court, or the civil court of first instance where none exists, is competent (Law No. 5846 art. 76). Contract disputes not relying on an FSEK right go to the commercial court if the conditions of a commercial case are met; labour jurisdiction and its mediation rules apply to employment relationships. - [Assigned Progress Payments: Deductions Must Be Itemised](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/assigned-progress-payments-deductions-itemised-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, in an action over progress payment receivables a contractor assigned to a bank, the performance security adjustment… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/temlik-edilen-hakedis-alacagindan-idarenin-kesintileri-tek-tek-hesaplanmali - Q: Can progress payment receivables be assigned to a bank? A: Under Turkish law, in this case the contractor’s accrued and future receivables from the employer had been assigned to the bank by written deeds of assignment stating the amounts. The contract made assignment subject to the employer’s written permission; the employer had approved it up to a maximum of 70% of each progress payment. - Q: Can the employer set off penalties and the security adjustment difference against a progress payment assigned to a bank? A: The Chamber did not discuss this separately; but it required the performance security adjustment difference, delay penalty and technical personnel penalty to be calculated one by one and set off against the sum of the contractor’s receivable and the unpaid share of the progress payments owed to the bank. - Q: Why could the expert report not be relied on? A: The report was held incapable of review or of forming the basis of a judgment because it did not clearly show the amounts of the items set off and did not state the result of the set-off as a plus or minus figure. - Q: Can the assignee bank claim more than the contractor could? A: The decision reviewed here does not say so expressly. In another case, the same Chamber had stated that an assignment cannot give more than the contractor’s rights and that the employer may raise its defences against the assignee as well; art. 188 of the Turkish Code of Obligations is to the same effect. - Q: Is this decision final, and is the case over? A: The Court of Cassation decision was given unanimously and with final effect, but it is a reversal. The file has returned to the first-instance court; under the reversal, a supplementary expert report must be obtained and the bank’s claim determined on the result of the set-off. - [Assignment of Claims (Transfer of Receivables)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/assignment-claims): An analysis of the assignment of claims under Turkish law — its requirements, form and effects, and the assigned debtor's position — covering the written-form requirement, the debtor's defences… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/alacagin-temliki-devri - Q: Is the debtor's consent required for an assignment of claims? A: No. Under Article 183 TCO, unless prevented by statute, agreement, or the nature of the affair, a creditor may assign a claim to a third party without the debtor's consent. The assignment is a bilateral transaction between the creditor and the assignee; the debtor is not a party to it. - Q: Can an assignment of claims be made orally? A: No. Under Article 184 TCO, an assignment of a claim is valid only if made in writing; this is a statutory requirement of validity that the court applies of its own motion. By contrast, a mere promise to assign a claim in the future is not subject to any formal requirement. - Q: If a debtor, unaware of an assignment, pays the prior creditor, is the debtor released? A: Yes. Under Article 186 TCO, where the assignment has not been notified to the debtor, the debtor is released from the obligation by performing in good faith to the prior creditor. Payments made after the debtor has been notified of the assignment, however, do not release the debtor from the obligation owed to the assignee. - Q: May the debtor raise the same objections against the new creditor as against the old one? A: Yes. Under Article 188 TCO, the debtor may raise against the assignee any defence held against the assignor at the time the assignment became known, and may also, under certain conditions, raise a defence of set-off. This rule reflects the principle that an assignment must not worsen the debtor's legal position. - Q: Can a sham (collusive) assignment of claims be set aside? A: Yes. An assignment of claims made to place assets beyond creditors' reach may be the target of an action to set aside fraudulent transfers under Articles 277 et seq. of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code; where the transaction is not grounded in a genuine debt relationship, its invalidity may also be asserted for sham (muvazaa) under general principles. The burden of proving collusion rests with the party alleging it. - Q: How is a contractor's personal right assigned to a third party under a build-for-land-share contract? A: A contractor's personal rights against the landowner — such as the right to demand cancellation and registration of title to designated units — may be assigned to a third party under Articles 183 et seq. TCO, in writing and without the landowner's consent. The Court of Cassation consistently holds that the written-form requirement suffices for such assignments and that no notarial form is required. - [Attaching Creditor Cannot Annul or Void a Capital Increase: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/share-attachment-creditor-capital-increase-annulment-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that a personal creditor who has attached a shareholder’s shares cannot seek the annulment of the general assembly… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/payi-haczettiren-alacakli-sermaye-artirimi-kararinin-iptalini-isteyemez - Q: Can a creditor who has attached a shareholder’s shares seek the annulment of a general assembly resolution on a capital increase? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation, no; the creditor is not a shareholder and is not among the persons listed in art. 446 of the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK). - Q: Can the creditor seek a declaration that the resolution is null and void? A: In this case, no. According to the Assembly, under art. 353 of the TTK, which applies through the reference in art. 456(4), no decision can be given on the nullity or non-existence of general assembly resolutions on a capital increase. - Q: Does the creditor have another remedy? A: The Assembly did not consider this. Nor did it address the route pointed out by the Chamber, compensation for the loss arising from the difference in value of the attached shares. - Q: Is the decision final, and what happened to the case? A: The decision was given by majority and is final. The decision of resistance was reversed and the file was sent to the regional court of appeal. - [Bank Acceleration of Commercial Loans in Türkiye: Acceleration Clauses, Grace Periods, Wrongful Acceleration](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/bank-accelerate-commercial-loan-before-maturity): A Turkish bank may accelerate a commercial loan before maturity if an event of default in the loan agreement occurs, such as an unpaid instalment. The article covers standard-terms review of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kredinin-vadesinden-once-kat-edilmesi - Q: Can the bank accelerate my loan even though I have paid my instalments? A: If instalments are paid on time, the bank must show that another event of default provided for in the agreement (for example, cessation of business or bankruptcy proceedings) has occurred (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/5458, K. 2022/2601). Paying instalments irregularly and late may, however, justify acceleration (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 43rd Civil Chamber, E. 2020/190, K. 2021/284). - Q: Is it lawful for the bank to demand the whole loan after one or two instalments go unpaid? A: Yes, if the agreement provides non-payment of instalments as an event of default. The 11th Civil Chamber upheld a decision accepting that the entire remaining debt may become due (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5065, K. 2026/2229) and a decision finding lawful the acceleration of a KGF-guaranteed loan after two unpaid instalments (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/6186, K. 2024/7492). - Q: What happens if enforcement is started before the 7-day period granted in the acceleration notice expires? A: Under the 2021–2025 majority decisions of the 11th Civil Chamber, enforcement before the period expires is contrary to art. 2 of the Civil Code and the action for annulment of objection is dismissed (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/314, K. 2024/3941). The Assembly of Civil Chambers held in 2017, however, that this is relevant only to the calculation of interest (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/815, K. 2017/1007). - Q: Can damages be claimed from the bank if the loan was wrongfully accelerated? A: They may be claimed under the general rules if unlawfulness, loss and causation are proven (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 112). If the acceleration complied with the agreement, the damages claim is dismissed (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/6186, K. 2024/7492). Refund of excess interest may be claimed separately (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/5506, K. 2021/5763). - Q: As a merchant, can I challenge the acceleration clause in a general loan agreement? A: Yes. Terms of which the other party was not clearly informed, or which are alien to the nature of the contract, are deemed not written; provisions that are contrary to good faith and aggravate the other party’s position may not be included (Turkish Code of Obligations arts. 21, 25). The 11th Civil Chamber has accepted that this review also applies to merchants and that acceleration clauses and clauses on collection after acceleration must be examined within it (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/4499, K. 2022/8102). - [Bank Loan Promissory Note Is a Security Note: Turkish Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/bank-loan-promissory-note-security-note-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, a promissory note bearing the words ‘value received in cash’ and signed in favour of a bank on the same day… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kredi-gunu-bankaya-ayni-tutarda-imzalanan-bono-teminat-senedidir - Q: Can a promissory note given to a bank be a security note under Turkish law if it does not say “security”? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, it can. If the note was issued on the same day, for the same amount and between the same persons as the loan agreement, and the agreement authorises the bank to take instruments, the note is a security note for the loan. - Q: Does the notation “value received in cash” change the result? A: In this decision it did not. According to the Assembly, banks cannot give out money outside a credit relationship; the payee bank’s cash claim can only arise from the credit relationship. - Q: What can a debtor pursued on a security note raise? A: If the note is in the hands of the payee, the debtor may raise as a personal defence that the conditions of the security have not arisen or that the claim exceeds the secured debt; if the note has been endorsed, it may raise this against a holder who acted knowingly to the debtor’s detriment while aware of its security character. - Q: Can a bank enforce a security note without accelerating the account? A: According to the majority of the Assembly, if the agreement contains a power to terminate without notice, default begins on the date of enforcement; a notice sent later is not a waiver of that power. According to the dissent, no claim had fallen due at the date of enforcement. - Q: Did this decision end the dispute? A: No. The decision is final, but the file was sent back to the regional court of appeal; according to the Assembly, the debt position must be assessed on the basis that default began on the date of enforcement. - [Binding (Handcuff) Contracts for Artists in Türkiye: Exclusivity, Validity Limits, Ways Out (TMK Art. 23)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/binding-contracts-artists): Limits on the validity of long-term, exclusive artist contracts under Turkish law: personality rights, nullity, exploitation, standard terms and future works; Court of Cassation decisions on handcuff… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sanatcilarin-baglanma-sozlesmeleri - Q: Is an eight- or ten-year artist contract valid? A: Duration alone is not a ground of invalidity. But if a long term combines with a high management share, a termination right for the company only, costs charged to the artist and a high penalty so as to restrict the artist’s economic and artistic freedom excessively, the contract may be held void under Civil Code art. 23 and Code of Obligations art. 27. The Court of Cassation upheld a judgment declaring such an eight-year contract entirely void. - Q: What does an “all songs I will write in the future” clause mean? A: Assignment of a work not yet written is void, but an undertaking to assign it in the future is valid. Either party may terminate such an undertaking covering all, or a type, of future works without giving reasons, with effect one year after notice (Law No. 5846 art. 50). - Q: The producer releases no albums but will not let me go; what can I do? A: A producer’s failure to make the albums promised, or to start preparing them at all, has been accepted as just cause in decisions upheld by the Court of Cassation. After granting the producer a reasonable period through a notary without result, the contract may be terminated; for authors, the FSEK right of withdrawal should also be considered. - Q: I signed at seventeen with my parents’ consent; am I bound? A: A contract made with the legal representative’s consent is, as a rule, binding (Civil Code art. 16). But consent does not exempt the content from review: terms excessively restricting freedom are void even if made on a minor’s behalf, and inexperience is assessed separately for exploitation. Legal advice should be taken before performing the contract after reaching majority. - Q: Is it risky to sign with a new producer while my current contract runs? A: Yes. Unless the current contract is void or terminated, a new exclusive contract increases the risk of penalties and damages, and the new producer may face an unfair competition claim for inducing a breach of the existing contract. The status of the current contract should be clarified first. - Q: Is the whole contract void, or only some terms? A: Partial nullity is the rule: invalid terms are removed and the rest stands. But if it is clear that the contract would not have been concluded without those terms, the whole contract is void (Code of Obligations art. 27). In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, the whole contract was held void because it had no meaning without the excessively restrictive terms. - [Board Deadlock in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Remedies, Quorum, Void Resolutions, Court-Appointed Trustee](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/board-deadlock-joint-stock-company): In a Turkish joint-stock company the board, unless the articles of association provide a stricter rule, meets with a majority of its total membership and decides by a majority of the members present… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anonim-sirkette-yonetim-kurulu-karar-alamiyorsa - Q: With how many members does the board meet and decide? A: Unless the articles provide a stricter rule, it meets with a majority of its total membership and decides by a majority of the members present (TCC art. 390/1). - Q: What happens if the board’s votes are tied? A: The matter is deferred to the next meeting; if there is a tie again, the proposal is deemed rejected (TCC art. 390/3). In a limited company, by contrast, the chair has the casting vote (TCC art. 624/3). - Q: Can the board take a decision without a meeting? A: If no member requests a meeting, a written proposal made to all members may be adopted with the written approval of a majority of the total membership (TCC art. 390/4). - Q: What can a shareholder do if the board cannot meet at all? A: If the board is continuously unable to meet, a quorum cannot be formed or there is no board, a single shareholder may call the general assembly with court permission; the court’s decision is final (TCC art. 410/2). - Q: What is required for a trustee to be appointed to a joint-stock company? A: The company must have been left without its necessary organs and its management must be impossible to secure in another way (Civil Code art. 427/4). According to the Court of Cassation, a board whose term has expired can still call the general assembly, so the company is not automatically organless (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2012/13135, K. 2014/3515). - [Brokerage (Commission) Claims: The Brokerage Contract, Real Estate Commission and Penalty Clauses](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/brokerage-claims): The brokerage contract and the written-form requirement in real estate brokerage (TCO art. 520), conditions for earning the commission and causation (art. 521), determination (art. 522) and reduction… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/komisyon-tellallik-alacagi - Q: When does a real estate agent earn the commission? A: Three conditions must coexist: a valid brokerage contract (written, for real estate); conclusion of the main contract (sale, lease etc.); and causation between the broker's activity and that conclusion. Performance of the main contract is not required; its valid conclusion suffices. - Q: Can a commission be claimed on an oral agreement? A: No. A brokerage contract concerning immovables is invalid unless made in writing (TCO art. 520/3); written form is a condition of validity and the document must bear the obligor's signature. E-mail exchanges do not replace a signed contract. Non-real-estate brokerage (e.g. share transfers) is free of form, but the relationship and the activity must be proven. - Q: The buyer viewed the property with the agent but bought directly from the owner; is commission payable? A: Yes, if a signed viewing form exists. The Court of Cassation holds the bypassing buyer liable under the agreed alternative penalty clause (6% in the cited decision), without requiring the agent to be separately authorised by the owner, and a merchant debtor cannot plead that the penalty is excessive. - Q: How is the fee determined if no rate was agreed? A: By tariff and, failing that, by custom (TCO art. 522). An excessive agreed fee may be reduced equitably by the judge on the debtor's request (TCO art. 525). - Q: If the sale falls through, can the agent claim a fee or expenses? A: As a rule, no fee: the broker earns the fee only if a contract is concluded as a result of their activity. If reimbursement of expenses was agreed, expenses are payable even without conclusion (TCO art. 521/3). Art. 521/1 is not mandatory and may be contracted around. - Q: What is the limitation period for commission claims? A: Five years for claims arising from brokerage contracts (TCO art. 147/5); the commercial brokerage fee is excluded and is subject to the general ten-year period (TCO art. 146). - Q: May the agent take commission from both sides? A: A broker who, contrary to their obligation, acts in the counterparty's interest or takes a fee promise from the counterparty in bad faith forfeits both fee and expenses (TCO art. 523). Transparent, impartial dual intermediation with both parties' knowledge and consent falls outside this rule. - [Commercial Books: Retention Period and Certificate of Loss](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/commercial-books-retention-period-loss-certificate): Under Turkish law, the ten-year retention period for commercial books under Turkish Commercial Code art. 82 and the five-year period under Tax Procedure Law art. 253; the conditions for obtaining a… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ticari-defterlerin-saklanma-suresi-ve-zayi-belgesi - Q: How many years must commercial books be kept? A: Under Turkish law, article 82 of the Turkish Commercial Code requires commercial books, inventories and financial statements, commercial correspondence and the documents on which entries are based to be kept for ten years. The period starts at the end of the calendar year in which the entry was made or the document came into being. - Q: What is the retention period for books under the Tax Procedure Law? A: Under art. 253 of the Tax Procedure Law, those obliged to keep books must keep their books and documents for five years, starting from the calendar year following the year to which they relate. Even when this period has expired, the ten-year obligation under the Turkish Commercial Code continues. - Q: What is the time limit for obtaining a certificate of loss? A: The merchant must apply to the court within thirty days from the date on which it learns of the loss. The Court of Cassation treats this as a peremptory time limit; it runs not from the date of the event but from the date the loss became known. The fifteen-day period mentioned in older decisions belongs to the previous text of the article. - Q: Can a certificate of loss be obtained if the books are lost? A: The Code lists disasters such as fire, flood and earthquake, and theft. According to regional courts of appeal, the list is not exhaustive; however, it must be proven that the loss occurred for a reason outside the merchant’s control and without its fault. In one decision, an unexplained loss during a move or a change of partnership was not considered sufficient. - Q: In which court is the action for a certificate of loss brought? A: It is brought without a respondent before the commercial court of first instance of the place where the commercial enterprise is located (TCC arts. 5/1 and 82/7). An appeal (istinaf) lies against the first-instance decision; according to the Court of Cassation, no appeal on points of law lies against the regional court of appeal’s decision on this matter. - Q: Is a certificate of loss sufficient in a tax audit? A: Not on its own. According to the Council of State, whether there was force majeure is assessed separately in each case on the basis of the certificate of loss and the other evidence; the existence of a certificate of loss does not by itself prove that the books were lost, and its absence does not show that they were not. - [Commercial Suretyship in Turkish Law: Periods, Duration and Grounds of Invalidity](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/commercial-suretyship): Commercial suretyship in Turkish law: form and spousal-consent rules by period, the ten-year limit, termination, grounds of invalidity and case law. Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ticari-kefalet-donemleri-sureklilik-ve-gecersizlik - Q: What must the surety write in his own handwriting in a suretyship contract? A: For suretyships concluded on or after 01.07.2012, the maximum amount, the date and, if he is to be a joint and several surety, that capacity (TCO art. 583). If written by someone else, the suretyship is invalid even with a genuine signature, and the court takes this into account of its own motion. - Q: Do I need my spouse’s consent to stand surety for my company’s loan? A: Not if you give it as a partner or manager in connection with the company and it was concluded on or after 11.04.2013 (TCO art. 584/3). For suretyships between 01.07.2012 and 10.04.2013, consent was required for partners as well. The exception concerns consent only; the handwriting, amount and date requirements still apply. - Q: Does the ten-year rule apply to suretyships before 2012? A: Yes. A natural person’s suretyship lapses automatically ten years after the contract (TCO art. 598), and termination is governed by the TCO for older suretyships too. If the ten years had expired on 01.07.2012, the creditor had to start enforcement within a one-year additional period (Law No. 6101 art. 5/2). - Q: Can a surety be liable for more than the suretyship limit? A: The surety is in all cases liable only up to the maximum amount (TCO art. 589). Liability above it can arise only for interest from the surety’s own default, which requires a separate notice. A higher credit limit does not raise the suretyship limit unless the surety accepts it in his handwriting. - Q: Are a bank letter of guarantee and a “surety” signature on a promissory note suretyships? A: No. A bank letter of guarantee is a guarantee contract and, since TCO art. 603 covers only natural persons, it is not subject to the handwriting and spousal-consent rules. A “surety” signature on a promissory note is, as a rule, an aval, to which the spousal-consent rules do not apply according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers. A guarantee given by a natural person is, however, subject to the form of suretyship. - [Company Manager Transfers Funds to a Personal Account in Türkiye: Liability Action, Evidence, Criminal Aspects](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/company-manager-transfers-company-money): If a company manager transfers company money to a personal account without a basis in the company’s interest, the manager is liable to the company, the shareholders and the company’s creditors for… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sirket-muduru-sirket-parasini-kendi-hesabina-aktarirsa - Q: What happens if a manager transfers company money to his own account? A: If the manager has caused loss to the company by breaching his statutory obligations through fault, he must compensate that loss (Commercial Code art. 553/1; for limited companies Commercial Code art. 644/1-a). Depending on the facts, the act may also be examined as the offence of breach of trust (Law No. 5237 art. 155). - Q: Can a partner sue the manager for compensation? A: Yes. The company and each partner may claim compensation for the company’s loss, but a partner may only demand payment to the company, not to himself (Commercial Code art. 555/1). - Q: Is a general assembly resolution required for an action on behalf of the company? A: The Court of Cassation treats a general assembly (partners’ meeting) resolution as a condition of a liability action brought by the company against its manager. If there is none, the court grants a peremptory time limit to cure the defect, failing which the action is dismissed on procedural grounds (Code of Civil Procedure art. 115/2). - Q: When does the manager’s liability become time-barred? A: The claim becomes time-barred two years after the loss and the liable person are learned and in any event five years after the act causing the loss; if the act is a crime subject to a longer limitation period under the Turkish Penal Code, that period applies (Commercial Code art. 560). - Q: What if the manager argues that the money was his salary? A: Setting managers’ remuneration is a non-delegable power of the general assembly (Commercial Code art. 616/1-f). The Court of Cassation held that, without a general assembly resolution, not the entire amount withdrawn as salary but only the part exceeding the salary of a person in the same position in a similar company should be treated as loss. - [Current Account Contracts under Turkish Law: Written Form, Interest, Balance, Limitation (TCC Arts. 89-101)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/current-account-contract): A current account contract is an agreement under which mutual receivables are entered item by item and only the balance resulting when the account is closed may be claimed; it is invalid unless made… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/cari-hesap-sozlesmesi - Q: Does a current account statement prove the debt? A: Not on its own; it is a printout from the creditor’s own records, and without a written contract the deemed-acceptance rule for the balance does not apply either. The claim is proved by invoices, delivery records and properly kept commercial books; if the debtor admits the relationship and pleads payment, the debtor must prove payment. - Q: Must a current account contract be in writing? A: Yes; under TCC art. 89/2 a current account contract not made in writing is invalid. Without a written contract the TCC current account rules do not apply, even if the parties call it a “current account”. - Q: When does limitation start for a current account claim? A: Under a written current account contract, actions for the balance and interest are time-barred five years after the contract ends (TCC art. 101). Without a written contract, limitation runs separately for each receivable from the date it fell due. - Q: From when does interest run on the balance? A: Under a written contract, where the conditions in TCC art. 8 are met, interest runs on the balance from the date it is determined and entered in the account (TCC art. 95). Without a written contract, unless otherwise agreed, interest on a commercial debt runs from the due date or, if there is none, from the date of notice (TCC art. 10). - Q: Which court hears current account disputes, and is mediation mandatory? A: Actions arising from a current account contract are commercial cases even if the parties are not merchants and are heard by the commercial court of first instance (TCC art. 4, TCC art. 5). In actions for a sum of money and actions for annulment of objection, applying to a mediator first is a procedural prerequisite (TCC art. 5/A). - [Default Interest on Turkish Commercial Loans: Determination, Contractual Rate Plus 100%, Central Bank Rate](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/default-interest-rate-commercial-loan-determined): On Turkish commercial loans default interest follows the contract, without the art. 120 cap, on the lower of the bank’s actual and TCMB-reported rates. The article covers Law No. 3095 art. 2 where no… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ticari-kredide-temerrut-faizi-orani - Q: What is the default interest rate on a commercial loan in Türkiye? A: The law sets no fixed default rate for commercial loans; the rate is determined by the agreement (Turkish Commercial Code art. 8/1). For example, decisions show 39% applied to a loan with a 26% contractual rate and a 50% uplift (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/5009, K. 2025/3418), and 41% applied to a loan with a 20.50% contractual rate actually applied and a 100% uplift (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/6371, K. 2024/7874). - Q: Can default interest on a commercial loan exceed the cap in art. 120 of the Code of Obligations? A: Yes. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the caps in arts. 88 and 120 of the Code of Obligations do not apply to commercial loans; the decision was taken by majority (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1650, K. 2019/507). Consumer loans fall outside this freedom (Turkish Commercial Code art. 8/3). - Q: What happens if the loan agreement does not state a default rate? A: In commercial matters the advance rate may be claimed even without an agreement if it exceeds statutory interest; if the contractual rate is higher, default interest cannot be lower than the contractual rate (Law No. 3095 art. 2/2-3). Where the rates in the agreement are left blank, the contractual rate the bank applies to the same type of loan is also applied as default interest (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/9064, K. 2023/3414). - Q: Is a surety liable for the higher default rate in the payment schedule? A: Not if the surety did not sign the payment schedule; although the schedule stated 39%, the calculation for sureties who had not signed it followed the default interest clause of the general loan agreement (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/430, K. 2024/3891). - Q: Is BSMV added to default interest? A: Judgments are seen to award BSMV at 5% of the interest together with default interest (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/5009, K. 2025/3418). If the bank did not claim BSMV in the enforcement proceedings, the court does not add it to the judgment (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/6371, K. 2024/7874). - [Defective Delivery in a Turnkey (Works) Contract](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/defective-delivery-turnkey-contract): Defective delivery in a turnkey works contract: the definition of the works contract (TCO Art. 470) and the lump-sum price (TCO Art. 480), the apparent/hidden defect distinction, the duty to inspect… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-26; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anahtar-teslim-eser-sozlesmesinde-ayipli-teslim - Q: A defect appeared in my turnkey construction; what rights can I use? A: According to the gravity of the defect you may use one of three optional rights: rescission if the work is defective to a degree that makes it unusable or impossible to be compelled to accept; keeping the work and a price reduction in proportion to the defect; or (if it does not require excessive expense) free repair at the contractor's cost. Your right to damages under the general provisions is also reserved (TCO Art. 475). If the work was made on your immovable and removal would cause excessive harm, rescission cannot be used; in practice the repair cost or a price reduction comes to the fore. - Q: What is the difference between an apparent and a hidden defect; when must I notify? A: An apparent defect is one visible by ordinary inspection at delivery and must be notified within a reasonable time. A hidden defect is one not detectable by simple inspection that surfaces later; it must be notified without delay (immediately) once it surfaces. If no notice is given, the work may be deemed accepted with that defect (TCO Arts. 474, 477). - Q: How long do I have to sue for a hidden defect in a building? A: For immovable structures, defective-work actions are subject to a five-year limitation from delivery; for works other than immovable structures, two years. If the contractor is at gross fault, the period is twenty years regardless of the nature of the work (TCO Art. 478). - Q: The contractor says I “did not notify the defect in time”; do I lose my right entirely? A: Failure to give timely notice is a defence; unless the contractor expressly raises it, the court does not consider it of its own motion. Moreover, if the contract provides a warranty period, remedy may be claimed for defects arising within that period without the notice requirement. Still, to avoid missing deadlines, notifying the defect in writing (notary/registered mail) is the safest course. - Q: We agreed a lump-sum price; the contractor now wants extra payment — must I pay? A: As a rule, no. Under a lump-sum price the contractor cannot demand an increase even if the work required more labour/expense than foreseen. However, if extraordinary circumstances unforeseeable at the outset rendered performance excessively difficult, the contractor may ask the court for adaptation or, failing that, rescission/termination (TCO Art. 480). - Q: If the defect stems from my own instruction, is the contractor still liable? A: If the defect arose from your instruction despite the contractor's express warning, or is otherwise attributable to you, you cannot exercise your defect-based rights (TCO Art. 476). This is why it matters that the contractor warned the owner in writing against the problematic instruction/material. - [Denizli Regional Court of Appeal, Türkiye: Jurisdiction (Denizli, Muğla, Uşak), Appeal Procedure, Time Limits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/denizli-regional-court-appeal-jurisdiction-turkiye): Since 02.09.2024, the Denizli Regional Court of Appeal has heard appeals against civil and criminal judgments given in Denizli, Muğla and Uşak. This article explains, under Turkish law and with… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/denizli-bolge-adliye-mahkemesi-yargi-cevresi-istinaf - Q: Where is an appeal lodged against a decision of a court in Muğla? A: The appellate court is the Denizli Regional Court of Appeal, but the petition is not taken to Denizli. In civil cases it is lodged with the court that gave the decision or another local court, in criminal cases with the trial court; the first-instance court sends the file on. - Q: What is the time limit for appealing a civil judgment given in Uşak? A: Two weeks from proper service of the judgment (Code of Civil Procedure art. 345); different periods in special statutes are reserved. - Q: Can every decision be appealed? A: No. Decisions in property disputes not exceeding the monetary threshold are final; actions for non-pecuniary damages are excepted. According to the 4th Civil Chamber of the Denizli Regional Court of Appeal, the decision date governs for decisions given before 04.06.2025 and the filing date for decisions given after that date. - Q: In a criminal case, does the appeal period start on the day the verdict is pronounced? A: No. For decisions given on or after 01.06.2024, the period is two weeks from service of the judgment with its reasoning (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 273(1)). - Q: Do decisions from Aydın, Manisa, Afyonkarahisar or Kütahya also go to the Denizli Regional Court of Appeal? A: No. Aydın and Manisa go to the İzmir, Afyonkarahisar to the Konya and Kütahya to the Bursa Regional Court of Appeal. - Q: Is an appeal against a decision of the administrative court in Denizli lodged with the Denizli Regional Court of Appeal? A: No. Appeals against administrative and tax court decisions are lodged within thirty days of service with the regional administrative court (Administrative Procedure Act art. 45(1)); for Denizli, Muğla and Uşak that is the İzmir Regional Administrative Court. - [Dissolution and Liquidation of a Simple Partnership: Liquidation Suit, Attachment (Turkish CO Arts. 620-645)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/dissolution-liquidation-simple-partnership): A guide to the dissolution and liquidation of a simple partnership under Turkish law: the definition and elements in Code of Obligations art. 620, joint ownership and the partners’ joint and several… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/adi-ortakligin-feshi-ve-tasfiyesi - Q: In which cases does a simple partnership end? A: On the grounds listed in Code of Obligations art. 639: achievement or impossibility of the purpose; death, guardianship, bankruptcy or enforcement against a partner’s liquidation share (unless the contract provides for continuation); unanimous decision; expiry of the term; notice of termination; and a court decision for just cause. In a partnership of indefinite term, notice must be given six months in advance (Code of Obligations art. 640). - Q: Who carries out the liquidation of a simple partnership? A: The partners may liquidate by agreement and appoint a liquidator; if they cannot agree, the judge appoints one (Code of Obligations art. 644). If a liquidation action is brought, the court itself carries out the liquidation and renders judgment on the basis of the final balance sheet (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1019, K. 2020/25). - Q: Can a partner claim a partnership receivable alone before liquidation? A: As a rule, no. Partnership receivables belong jointly to all partners; actions and enforcement proceedings must be brought together, and the consent of the partners who did not sue must be obtained or they must be joined (3rd Civil Chamber, E. 2024/1200, K. 2025/2619). A claim for a share against the other partner also covers dissolution and liquidation. - Q: Can receivables of the partnership be attached for a partnership debt? A: The 2021 decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers allowed this, whereas its final 2025 decision held that receivables held jointly by the partnership cannot be attached directly and that the debtor partner’s liquidation share may be attached (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2024/787, K. 2025/367). The most recent Assembly decision should be checked. - Q: Which court hears an action for the dissolution and liquidation of a simple partnership? A: If the partners are not merchants, the civil court of first instance (Code of Civil Procedure art. 2; Court of Cassation 20th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/1409, K. 2020/1604); for merchant partners, jurisdiction is assessed separately. Appellate review falls to the 3rd Civil Chamber under the division of work of 26.06.2025, as stated in a referral decision (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5337, K. 2025/6096). - Q: How is a simple partnership proved if there is no written contract? A: The contract is not subject to any form requirement; however, the burden of proof lies on the party asserting the partnership, and the documentary evidence rule applies to transactions exceeding the monetary threshold (Code of Civil Procedure art. 200). Witnesses may be heard with the express consent of the other party, and no documentary proof is required for transactions between siblings, spouses, descendants and ascendants (Code of Civil Procedure art. 203). - [Down Payment Refund in Turkish Financial Leasing: Lessee's Recovery of Payments to the Seller on Termination](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/refund-down-payment-financial-leasing): A down payment the lessee paid directly to the seller, if not financed by the lessor, is recoverable once the asset is returned (Court of Cassation, 2025). The decision concerns a 2007 contract under… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/finansal-kiralamada-pesinat-iadesi - Q: If the leasing contract is terminated, can I get my down payment back? A: It depends on to whom and on what basis the payment was made. According to the Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber, a price the lessee paid directly to the seller and the lessor did not finance can be claimed from the lessor once the asset is returned to the lessor (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900). If no valid contract was ever formed, a down payment paid to the lessor can be reclaimed as unjust enrichment (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/8251, K. 2022/2555). - Q: If the asset is never delivered, from whom is the down payment paid to the seller claimed? A: If the asset was not delivered because of the lessor’s fault or negligence, arts. 123, 125 and 126 of the Turkish Code of Obligations apply (Law No. 6361 art. 25). In a case where the lessor had paid the seller on time and was not, under the contract, responsible for delivery, the Court of Cassation upheld the dismissal of the action against the financial leasing company (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/2600, K. 2020/5012). If the parties signed a release and termination protocol, the court must assess it (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/6932, K. 2025/6071). - Q: Does Law No. 6361 contain an article on refunding the down payment? A: No. The Law’s financial leasing provisions do not separately regulate a payment made by the lessee to the seller; where there is no provision the general provisions apply (Law No. 6361 art. 2/6), and an enrichment whose cause has not materialised or has ceased to exist must be returned (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 77). - Q: Within how many years must an action for the refund of a down payment be brought? A: If the claim rests on unjust enrichment, it becomes time-barred two years after the date on which the right to reclaim was learned and in any case ten years after the date on which the enrichment occurred (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 82/1). In commercial cases for a sum of money, applying to a mediator before bringing the action is a condition of action (Commercial Code art. 5/A/1). - Q: Which law governs a leasing contract made in 2007? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, disputes concerning contracts made before 13.12.2012, when Law No. 6361 entered into force, are governed by the repealed Law No. 3226 and the earlier regulations (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1647, K. 2020/88). The Court of Cassation’s 19th Civil Chamber treated a judgment based on an expert report calculating under art. 33 of Law No. 6361 for such a contract as a ground for reversal (Court of Cassation, 19th Civil Chamber, E. 2016/7173, K. 2017/2999). - [Enforcement File Renewal Does Not Interrupt Limitation: Turkish Court of Cassation on the 3-Year Note Bar](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/promissory-note-limitation-enforcement-file-renewal-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, if three years pass after an enforcement based on a promissory note has become final without any enforcement… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/bonoya-dayali-icra-takibinde-dosya-yenileme-zamanasimini-kesmez - Q: What is the limitation period in enforcement based on a promissory note? A: Claims against the maker of a promissory note become time-barred three years from maturity (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 749(1), 778(1)(h), 779(1)). - Q: Does a request to renew the enforcement file interrupt limitation? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, it does not; a renewal request is not an enforcement act aimed at keeping the proceedings going. If the renewal petition also contains a request that advances the proceedings, such as attachment, limitation may be interrupted by that request. - Q: How is limitation raised after the enforcement has become final? A: The debtor applies to the enforcement court for a stay of enforcement; the court decides on the basis of official documents (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law arts. 71(2), 33/a). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, this application is not bound by a time limit. - Q: When does an attachment report count as a final certificate of insufficiency? A: If no attachable asset is found, the attachment report has the effect of a certificate of insufficiency (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 105(1)). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the debtor must also have no attachable assets outside the place of attachment. - [Expulsion and Withdrawal of Partners: Limited and Joint-Stock Companies under Turkish Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/expulsion-withdrawal-partners-commercial-companies): Expulsion and withdrawal of partners in Turkish commercial companies: withdrawal from an LLC for just cause (TCC art. 638), joining a withdrawal (art. 639), expulsion by general assembly resolution… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-02; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ticaret-sirketlerinde-ortakliktan-cikarma - Q: Can one LLC partner have another partner expelled? A: No. The expulsion action for just cause may be brought only by the company itself (TCC art. 640/3); an action brought by one partner against another is dismissed for lack of standing. The Court of Cassation applies this rule even in two-partner companies. The Constitutional Court has annulled the general assembly resolution requirement for two-partner limited companies (E.2025/128, K.2025/273; Official Gazette 17.03.2026); the Code does not separately regulate how the action is to be brought in such companies after the annulment. - Q: Is a general assembly resolution required for the expulsion action? A: As a rule, yes. Applying to the court for a partner’s expulsion is a non-delegable power of the general assembly (TCC art. 616/1-h), and a resolution to that effect is a procedural prerequisite; if the defect is not cured within the definitive period granted, the action is dismissed. For two-partner limited companies, however, the Constitutional Court has annulled the provisions establishing this requirement (E.2025/128, K.2025/273; Official Gazette 17.03.2026). - Q: How can a partner leave the company voluntarily? A: By exercising a withdrawal right granted in the articles, or, where none exists, by bringing a withdrawal action for just cause (TCC art. 638/2). Where share transfer is prohibited or consent is withheld, the right to withdraw for just cause is preserved (art. 595/5). - Q: How is the severance payment calculated and when is it paid? A: It corresponds to the real value of the capital share — not book value — determined with regard to the company’s assets and going-concern value (TCC art. 641). Where departure is ordered by the court, it falls due upon finality of the judgment; the unpaid part ranks after all creditors of the company (art. 642/3). - Q: Is expulsion possible in a joint-stock company? A: There is no general withdrawal/expulsion mechanism. In a dissolution action for just cause (TCC art. 531) the court may, instead of dissolution, order the claimant shareholder’s buy-out at the real value of their shares as at the date closest to the judgment — provided just cause is established. - Q: What counts as just cause? A: Case law has accepted: failure to hold general assemblies for many years, violation of information and participation rights, never distributing profits, and the irreparable collapse of trust between partners. Abstract discord and facts arising from the claimant’s own fault do not suffice. - [Expulsion from Cooperative Membership in Turkish Law: Notice Requirements, Competent Body and Annulment Action](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/expulsion-from-cooperative-membership): A guide to expulsion from cooperative membership in Turkish law: grounds that must be expressly set out in the articles of association and the expulsion procedure (Cooperatives Law art. 16), two… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kooperatif-uyeliginden-ihrac - Q: On what grounds may a cooperative expel a member? A: Only on grounds expressly set out in the articles of association (Cooperatives Law art. 16/1). For unpaid dues the two-request procedure of Cooperatives Law art. 27 applies; where membership conditions are lost, the member must also be given an appropriate period (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/112, K. 2024/347). - Q: How many notices are required before expulsion for unpaid dues? A: Two requests: the first with an appropriate period, the second with a one-month period (Cooperatives Law art. 27). Granting 30 days instead of one month in the second notice was held to breach a mandatory provision (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/384, K. 2023/526); the debt in the notices must be actual and consistent and the sanction clearly stated (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/1044, K. 2022/1890). - Q: What is the time limit for challenging an expulsion decision? A: Three months from due service of the decision through a notary (Cooperatives Law art. 16/3). The one-month period for general assembly resolutions does not apply to expulsion decisions, and service at an address other than the one notified by the member does not start the period (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2013/1522, K. 2015/1196). - Q: Can the board of directors decide on expulsion? A: As a rule the general assembly decides on the board’s proposal; the articles of association may also authorise the board (Cooperatives Law art. 16/2). In that case the general assembly’s power does not remove the board’s power (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2009/4119, K. 2010/10268). - Q: Can an expelled member recover the payments made? A: Yes; the rights are calculated, excluding reserves, on the balance sheet of the year of departure and become time-barred after five years (Cooperatives Law art. 17). The balance remaining after deduction of the share of expenses may be claimed, and late-payment interest may not be set off (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/855, K. 2021/281). Applying to a mediator before suing for the claim is a condition of the action (Commercial Code art. 5/A). - Q: Can a member who has ignored the cooperative for a long time have the expulsion annulled? A: An annulment action by a member who for a long time paid no dues and had no contact with the cooperative has been held contrary to the rule of honesty (Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2023/1043, K. 2024/537). Whether the period is long enough depends on the facts; in one case more than four years between expulsion and action was not considered sufficient (Court of Cassation 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/1044, K. 2022/1890). - [Extraordinary General Assembly in a Limited Company: Who Sets the Agenda? (TCC Arts. 617, 411-413, 416)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/extraordinary-general-assembly-agenda-rule-limited): In a Turkish limited company the managers call the general assembly, and the managers making the call set the agenda. The partners’ right to demand an extraordinary meeting and add agenda items… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/limited-sirkette-olaganustu-genel-kurul-ve-gundemle-baglilik - Q: Who calls the general assembly of a limited company? A: The managers call the general assembly (TCC art. 617/1). The call is made at least fifteen days before the meeting; the articles of association may extend this period or shorten it to ten days. - Q: Can partners demand an extraordinary general assembly? A: Yes. Partners representing at least one tenth of the share capital may ask the managers, through a notary, to call a meeting (TCC art. 411); if the request is rejected or not answered positively within seven business days, they may apply to the commercial court (TCC art. 412). - Q: What happens if the manager does not put an item on the agenda? A: The partners may apply to the commercial court, which may appoint a trustee to arrange the agenda and make the call (TCC art. 412). A culpable breach causing loss may also give rise to the manager’s liability (TCC art. 644/1-a, TCC art. 553/1). - Q: Can a resolution be adopted on a matter not on the agenda? A: As a rule, no; matters not on the agenda cannot be discussed or resolved, statutory exceptions being reserved (TCC art. 413/2). At a general assembly without a call attended by all partners, items may be added to the agenda unanimously (TCC art. 416/2). - Q: Is a resolution outside the agenda invalid? A: In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, a resolution outside the agenda was treated as annullable and subject to the three-month period (TCC art. 445); there is also a view that it is void. Resolutions of a general assembly convened by an unauthorised person are non-existent. - [FX and FX-Indexed Commercial Loans in Türkiye: Exchange Rate on Acceleration and Enforcement (TCO Art. 99)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/foreign-currency-loan-acceleration-exchange-rate): If an FX loan is not paid when due, a Turkish bank may, absent an effective-payment clause, claim it in kind or in lira at the due-date or payment-date rate. The article covers FX vs FX-indexed… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/doviz-kredisinde-kat-ve-kur - Q: On an FX-indexed loan, does the bank apply the rate on the acceleration date or on the payment date? A: If there is no effective-payment clause and the debt was not paid on its due date, the choice belongs to the bank; it may choose the due-date or the actual-payment-date rate (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 99/3). A claim converted into Turkish lira in the enforcement request at the due-date or enforcement-date rate becomes a Turkish lira claim, and the bank can no longer claim interest specific to foreign currency after enforcement (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2019/500, K. 2022/1326). - Q: What happens if the bank does not show the Turkish lira equivalent of the foreign-currency claim in the enforcement request? A: If the foreign-currency claim is demanded in kind, the enforcement office must reject the request; the defect concerns public order and may be raised by complaint without a time limit (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2019/500, K. 2022/1326). The 12th Civil Chamber does not regard merely stating a Turkish lira figure as the fee basis as sufficient (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/9538, K. 2026/1836). - Q: I gave a mortgage in Turkish lira; can the bank realise it for a foreign-currency loan? A: According to the 12th Civil Chamber, mortgage enforcement for a foreign-currency claim cannot be brought on the basis of a Turkish lira mortgage; this concerns public order and the proceedings are annulled (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/1437, K. 2024/5890). There is no such obstacle if the claim was demanded in Turkish lira in the acceleration notice and in the enforcement proceedings (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/7357, K. 2026/414). - Q: At what rate does default interest run on a foreign-currency loan? A: The contract is looked at first. If it does not provide for a higher rate, the highest rate paid by State banks on one-year deposit accounts in that currency applies to a foreign-currency debt (Law No. 3095, art. 4/a). A bank that converted the claim into Turkish lira in the enforcement request cannot rely on this rate for the period after enforcement (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2019/500, K. 2022/1326). - Q: Can companies use FX-indexed loans today? A: Under article 17/A of Decree No. 32, FX-indexed loans may not be extended to persons resident in Türkiye. Foreign-currency loans are subject to the foreign-currency income requirement; the requirement does not apply in exceptions such as an outstanding loan balance of USD 15 million or more on the date of use. - [Financial Leasing by Participation Banks in Türkiye: Rent, Ownership, Default, Termination, Asset Return](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/financial-leasing-participation-banks): Participation banks may carry out financial leasing, and these transactions are governed by Law No. 6361. This article briefly explains the participation bank’s power to lease (Banking Law No. 5411… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/katilim-bankalarinda-finansal-kiralama - Q: Is participation bank leasing interest-bearing? A: Legally, what the lessee pays is regulated in the Law as the financial leasing payment (rent), whose amount and payment periods are set by the parties (Law No. 6361 art. 20). The procedures for activities that participation banks may carry out by interest-free methods are set by the Banking Regulation and Supervision Board (Banking Law No. 5411 art. 77); a religious assessment of the transaction is outside the scope of this article. - Q: What happens if the rent is not paid? A: The bank grants the lessee a thirty-day payment period; where ownership is to pass to the lessee at the end of the term this period may not be less than sixty days, and if payment is not made within it the contract may be terminated (Law No. 6361 art. 31/1). After termination the lessee returns the asset; if it is sold, the rentals not yet due are settled against the sale price (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). - Q: Who owns the asset at the end of the term? A: The bank owns the asset throughout the contract; the lessee becomes the owner only if the contract grants a purchase right and the lessee exercises it (Law No. 6361 art. 23/1). A lessee who does not exercise this right must return the asset immediately when the contract ends (Law No. 6361 art. 32). - Q: Must the contract be made before a notary? A: No; the contract is made in writing or at a distance, or by electronic methods accepted by the Banking Regulation and Supervision Board that allow identity verification, and the provision contains no notarial requirement (Law No. 6361 art. 22/1). For immovables the contract is annotated in the land register; for other assets it is registered in the relevant registry or in the registry of the Association of Financial Institutions. - Q: What is sale and leaseback? A: It is a transaction in which the lessor buys the asset from the lessee itself and leases it back to the same person by financial leasing (Law No. 6361 art. 18). In this method the lessor cannot be held liable for defects in the asset (Law No. 6361 art. 24/6). - [General Assembly Annulment in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Time Limit, Mediation, Pre-Finality Enforcement](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-general-assembly-resolution-joint-stock-company): Under Turkish law, an action to annul a joint-stock company's general assembly resolution must be brought within three months of the resolution before the commercial court of first instance at the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anonim-sirkette-genel-kurul-kararinin-iptali-davasi - Q: What is the time limit for challenging a general assembly resolution? A: In a joint-stock company, the action for annulment must be brought within three months from the date of the resolution (Turkish Commercial Code art. 445). The period runs from the day the resolution was adopted and is a period of forfeiture. The Code sets no time limit for nullity under art. 447; however, if the ground relied on is in fact a ground for annulment, an action brought after three months is dismissed. - Q: Is mediation mandatory in an action to annul a general assembly resolution? A: No. Under Turkish Commercial Code art. 5/A, mandatory mediation applies to commercial actions whose subject matter is a sum of money; a claim for annulment or nullity is not of that kind. If compensation is also claimed from the directors in the same statement of claim, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation holds that the claims are separated because they are directed at different defendants, and mediation is a precondition for the compensation claim. - Q: Can the annulment of a general assembly resolution be enforced before it becomes final? A: No. The annulment judgment takes effect for all shareholders once it has become final (Turkish Commercial Code art. 450). As it contains no performance order, it cannot be the subject of enforcement proceedings; according to the 12th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, once final only court costs and attorney’s fees may be collected through enforcement. Having the judgment registered in the trade registry is the duty of the board of directors. - Q: Does bringing the action stop the resolution from being implemented? A: Not by itself. The claimant may ask the court to suspend enforcement of the resolution; the court decides after obtaining the opinion of the board members (Turkish Commercial Code art. 449) and, at the company’s request, may require security from the claimant (art. 448(3)). - Q: Can a shareholder who did not attend the meeting sue? A: Yes, but he or she must allege that the meeting was not properly called, that the agenda was not duly announced, that unauthorised persons voted or that he or she was unjustly kept out of the meeting, and that this irregularity affected the adoption of the resolution (Turkish Commercial Code art. 446/1-b). A shareholder who attended must vote against and have the dissent recorded in the minutes. - Q: Can a board member sue against a general assembly resolution? A: The board of directors may sue as a body. Individual members may sue on their own only if implementing the resolution would give rise to their personal liability (Turkish Commercial Code art. 446/1-d). The action of a member who is not a shareholder and does not make this allegation is dismissed. - [Joint Suit Does Not Spare Director Claim from Mediation: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/general-assembly-annulment-director-liability-mediation): Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, where annulment of general assembly resolutions is sought against the company and compensation based on… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/genel-kurul-karari-iptali-ve-yonetici-sorumlulugu-davasinda-arabuluculuk - Q: Is applying to a mediator mandatory before an action to annul a general assembly resolution? A: Turkish Commercial Code art. 5/A(1) limits mediation as a precondition to suit to commercial receivables, compensation, annulment of objection, negative declaratory and restitution actions whose subject is a sum of money; annulment of a general assembly resolution is not in that list. In this decision, too, the mediation requirement was applied to the separated compensation action. - Q: What happens if annulment of general assembly resolutions and compensation from the managers are claimed in the same statement of claim? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the claims are not directed against the same defendant, so there is no joinder of claims. The court separates the actions and applies the mediation precondition to the compensation action on its own. - Q: Can applying to a mediator after filing the action cure the defect? A: If it is found that the action was filed without applying to a mediator, the action is dismissed on procedural grounds without any further step (Law No. 6325 art. 18/A(2)). In this case the first-instance court stated that mediation is not a precondition that can be completed later, and the procedural dismissal was upheld. - Q: Is mediation required if all claims are directed against the same defendant? A: The Assembly of Civil Chambers did not decide that situation. After its decision, the 11th Civil Chamber upheld, without writing its own reasoning, a regional court of appeal judgment holding that mediation was not required for trademark infringement and compensation claims brought against the same defendant. Applying to a mediator in advance for the monetary claim avoids the risk of a procedural dismissal on this ground. - Q: Does the mediation process affect limitation periods? A: From the application to the mediation office until the final report is drawn up, limitation is suspended and preclusive periods do not run (Law No. 6325 art. 18/A(15)). - [LLC Withdrawal With Severance Claim Needs No Mediation: Turkish Appellate Court on Joined Claims](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/turkish-llc-withdrawal-severance-claim-mandatory-mediation): Under Turkish law, according to the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, where withdrawal for just cause and the severance payment are claimed together against the same… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ortakliktan-cikma-ve-ayrilma-akcesinde-arabuluculuk - Q: Is it mandatory to go to a mediator before filing an action to withdraw from a company? A: Under Turkish law, a withdrawal claim on its own does not fall within art. 5/A of the Turkish Commercial Code, since its subject matter is not a sum of money. If the severance payment is also claimed against the same company in the same statement of claim, according to the line of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation and this decision the claims are examined together without being subject to mediation. The decision is not final; first-instance decisions to the contrary are also seen. - Q: Is mediation required if only the severance payment is claimed after leaving the company? A: Yes. In that case the action is a commercial receivable action whose subject matter is a sum of money, and applying to a mediator before filing is a condition of action. - Q: Can the court separate the claims and dismiss the severance payment claim for lack of mediation? A: According to this decision, not if the claims are directed against the same defendant and are connected. If the claims are directed against different defendants (e.g. one against the company and the other against the manager), according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers the actions are separated and the mediation requirement is examined for each action separately. - Q: How are court fees and attorney's fees determined in a combined action? A: Each claim counts as a separate action: the withdrawal claim is subject to a fixed court fee and attorney's fee, the severance payment claim to a proportional one. According to this decision, if the action is waived, two separate attorney's fees are awarded in favour of the defendant. - [Legal Effect of an Invoice in Turkish Commercial Matters: Eight-Day Objection, Commercial Books, Delivery Note](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/legal-effect-invoice-commercial-matters): The legal effect of an invoice in commercial matters: the consequence of not objecting within eight days (the acceptance presumption in TCC Art. 21/2), whether an invoice alone proves the contractual… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-28; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ticari-islerde-faturanin-hukmu - Q: If I do not object to an invoice within eight days, do I become liable? A: If you do not object within eight days, you are deemed to accept the invoice's ordinary content, that is, entries relating to performance such as the type, quantity and price of the goods. A late-payment charge entry with no basis in your contract or in commercial custom, however, is not deemed accepted merely because you did not object (Court of Cassation, Unification of Judgments, 2003/1 K.). Moreover, not objecting does not, on its own, prove that a contract truly exists between the parties; the other side must separately prove the contractual relationship. - Q: Does an invoice alone prove the receivable? A: As a rule, no. According to the Court of Cassation, not objecting finalises the content, but the contractual relationship must be proven by written/conclusive evidence. If the invoice was entered in the other party's commercial books, the booked invoice also proves the contractual relationship. - Q: I entered the invoice in my books without objecting; can I later say I received no goods? A: In that case the burden of proof shifts to you. If you did not object/return the invoice in time and entered it in your books, you must prove by written or conclusive evidence that you received no goods/services or owe no debt. - Q: Why is the delivery note important? A: The invoice shows the amount; actual delivery is usually proven by a signed dispatch/delivery note. A signed delivery note is strong evidence against a later “goods not received” defence. - Q: Will my commercial book be evidence in my favour? A: Only if it was kept in accordance with the law (fully, with opening/closing approvals, entries corroborating one another) and is not contrary to the other party's properly kept book. A book kept improperly is evidence against you. - Q: Which court has jurisdiction in an invoice dispute? A: Where the dispute concerns the commercial enterprises of both parties, it is a commercial case and the commercial court of first instance has jurisdiction (Turkish Commercial Code Art. 4(1)); the fact that the invoice is regulated in the Turkish Commercial Code does not by itself make the case commercial. Expert examination of the parties' commercial books is often decisive. - [Liabilities of the Authorised Company Director: Duty of Care, Damages Actions and Public Debts](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/liabilities-authorised-company-director): The duties of the Turkish limited company director under TCC arts. 623-626, damages liability under art. 553 via art. 644, the general assembly resolution as a special procedural prerequisite… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sirket-mudurunun-sorumluluklari - Q: Is the company director personally liable for the company's debts? A: As a rule, no; only the company's assets answer for company debts. Exceptions: where the director culpably causes loss to the company, shareholders or creditors, damages liability arises under TCC art. 553 via art. 644; and taxes and other public debts that cannot be collected from the company may be collected from the director's personal assets as legal representative under repeated art. 35 of Law No. 6183 and art. 10 of the Tax Procedure Law. - Q: What must the company do before suing its director? A: The Court of Cassation requires a general assembly (shareholders') resolution authorising the liability action as a special procedural prerequisite. If it is missing, the court grants a definitive period for the resolution to be submitted before examining the merits. - Q: When is the director liable for the company's tax debts? A: The company is pursued first; if the tax debt cannot be collected, wholly or partly, from the company's assets or is understood to be uncollectible, the legal representative in office when the debt arose and fell due is pursued. The director who pays has recourse against the company. - Q: I resigned as director; am I still liable for past debts? A: The period principle applies: you are liable for public debts that arose and fell due during your term, not for those arising after your departure. The Council of State has held that a person who was not the legal representative on those dates cannot be held liable. Registration and announcement of your departure in the trade registry matters for proof against third parties. - Q: A payment order was issued against me as legal representative; what should I do? A: You may file an action with the tax court within 15 days of notification under art. 58 of Law No. 6183, arguing that no such debt exists, that it was partly paid or that it is time-barred; whether the debt falls within your term and whether the company was duly pursued first should also be examined. The period is preclusive. - Q: May the director run a business competing with the company? A: No; unless the articles provide otherwise or all other shareholders consent in writing, the director may not engage in any activity competing with the company (TCC art. 626/2). Breach gives rise to damages and may constitute just cause for removal. - Q: What is the limitation period for the liability action? A: Two years from learning of the damage and the person liable, and in any event five years from the act (TCC art. 560, applicable to limited companies via art. 644). Where the act is also an offence subject to a longer criminal limitation period, the longer period applies. - [Liability of Board Members in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Care, Actions, Discharge (TCC Arts. 369, 553–561)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/liability-board-members-joint-stock-companies): A guide to the civil liability of board members in Turkish joint-stock companies: the duty of care and loyalty under Commercial Code art. 369, the conditions of liability under Commercial Code art.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anonim-sirkette-yonetim-kurulu-sorumlulugu - Q: Is a board member liable for every loss of the company? A: No. A fault-based breach of an obligation arising from the law or the articles of association, damage and a causal link are required (Commercial Code art. 553/1). According to the Court of Cassation, no member is liable for damage he or she did not cause, and no one may be held liable for breaches beyond his or her control (Commercial Code art. 553/3). - Q: Can a shareholder sue board members for damages in its own name? A: Yes, if the damage arose directly in the shareholder’s own assets, independently of the company. If the damage arose in the company’s assets (indirect damage), the shareholder may only claim payment of the compensation to the company (Commercial Code art. 555/1); actions by shareholders seeking payment to themselves were dismissed in upheld decisions. - Q: Can company creditors sue board members? A: A creditor may sue for direct damage suffered in its own assets; in an upheld decision, rendering the company idle and insolvent in order not to pay its debts was treated as direct damage. If the company is bankrupt, creditors may claim payment of compensation to the company; the claims are first asserted by the bankruptcy administration (Commercial Code art. 556). - Q: Does the general assembly’s discharge resolution prevent a liability action? A: The discharge extinguishes the right of action only for the disclosed facts and only for the company and the shareholders who voted in favour or acquired shares with knowledge of the discharge. The right of action of the other shareholders lapses six months after the discharge (Commercial Code art. 558/2); in an upheld decision this period was held to be taken into account ex officio. - Q: When does a liability action become time-barred? A: Two years from knowledge of the damage and the person liable and in any event five years from the harmful act; if the act is an offence subject to a longer criminal limitation period, that period applies (Commercial Code art. 560). In an upheld decision, the basic criminal limitation period, not the period extended by interruption, was applied. - Q: Which court hears the liability action, and is mediation mandatory? A: The action is a commercial case (Commercial Code art. 4/1-a) heard by the commercial court of first instance (Commercial Code art. 5/1); actions against the persons liable may be brought at the commercial court of the place of the company’s registered office (Commercial Code art. 561). In receivable and compensation actions whose subject matter is a sum of money, prior application to a mediator is a precondition to suit (Commercial Code art. 5/A/1). - [Mandatory Retained Lawyer for Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Scope and Sanction (Attorneys Act Art. 35/3)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/mandatory-lawyer-joint-stock-companies-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the obligation under Attorneys Act art. 35/3 for joint-stock companies whose share capital reaches five times the statutory minimum to retain a lawyer under contract: scope, the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anonim-sirketlerde-avukat-bulundurma-zorunlulugu - Q: Which companies must retain a lawyer? A: Under Turkish law, joint-stock companies whose share capital is five times or more the minimum share capital laid down in the Turkish Commercial Code, and building cooperatives with one hundred or more members (Attorneys Act art. 35/3). Limited liability companies are not listed in the provision. - Q: What is the capital threshold for the obligation of joint-stock companies to retain a lawyer? A: In a file concerning 2018–2020 examined by the Court of Cassation, the threshold was treated as TRY 250,000 (five times TRY 50,000) in the Chief Public Prosecutor’s request for annulment in the interest of the law; the Chamber did not separately address the threshold. Since Presidential Decision No. 7887 raised the minimum share capital to TRY 250,000 from 1 January 2024, five times that amount corresponds to TRY 1,250,000; no Court of Cassation decision on that period has yet been found. - Q: What is the penalty for not retaining a lawyer? A: The public prosecutor imposes, for each month in which no contracted lawyer is appointed, an administrative fine equal to two months’ gross minimum wage in force on the date of the offence. According to the Court of Cassation, each month is a separate misdemeanour. - Q: Must the lawyer be employed on the company’s staff? A: The Act requires “a lawyer under contract”; it does not require employment. The Court of Cassation gave credit to a contract the company had made with a lawyer and accepted that no misdemeanour arose for the months in which the contract was in force. - Q: Can a fine be imposed if the bar association does not report the company? A: Yes. According to the Court of Cassation, an application or complaint by the bar is not a precondition for the misdemeanour; article 73/C of the Union of Turkish Bar Associations’ Attorneys Act Regulation concerns the bars’ internal functioning. - Q: How can the administrative fine be challenged? A: Under Misdemeanours Law art. 27, an application is made by petition to the criminal judgeship of peace within fifteen days of notification of the decision. If the time limit is missed, the decision becomes final; in case of force majeure, an application may be made within seven days of the cause ceasing. - [Merchant’s Own Books Are No Proof Against Non-Merchants: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/commercial-books-evidence-against-non-merchant-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held by majority that, save for the exception in art. 222(5) of the Code of Civil Procedure, commercial books may be… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tacir-olmayana-karsi-ticari-defterle-alacak-ispatlanamaz - Q: Can a merchant rely on its own commercial books against a non-merchant? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation, no: unless the non-merchant party itself relies on those books (Code of Civil Procedure art. 222(5)), books may be examined as evidence in their owner’s favour only if both parties are merchants. Against a non-merchant counterparty, examining the books has no effect on the outcome. - Q: Can the non-merchant party rely on the merchant’s books? A: Yes. Under art. 222(5) of the Code of Civil Procedure, the non-merchant party may rely on the merchant’s books by stating that it will accept their entries; if the merchant avoids producing its books, the party requesting production is deemed to have proved its claim. - Q: What does an unexplained bank transfer show? A: According to the Assembly, a transfer is a means of payment and is presumed to have been made to pay an existing debt. The transferor who asserts that the money was sent as an advance or for another purpose must prove it. - Q: Was the decision unanimous? A: No. It was given by majority and is final; the two dissenting opinions argue that the action arising from the transfer is a commercial action and that the defendant’s books should be examined. - [Minority Shareholder Rights in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Agenda, Special Audit, Just-Cause Dissolution](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/minority-shareholder-rights-joint-stock-companies): The conditions and procedure for minority shareholder rights in Turkish joint-stock companies — the right to add agenda items (TTC art. 411), postponement of financial statement discussion (art.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anonim-sirkette-azinlik-haklari - Q: What minimum shareholding is required to exercise minority rights in a joint-stock company? A: Most minority provisions of the TCC set the threshold at one-tenth of the share capital (one-twentieth for publicly held companies). This threshold is required for the right to add agenda items (art. 411), postponement of financial statements (art. 420), the request to the court for a special auditor after the general assembly rejects a special audit (art. 439; here shares with an aggregate nominal value of at least one million Turkish lira also suffice) and dissolution for just cause (art. 531). Asking the general assembly for a special audit is a right of every shareholder (art. 438/1). The articles of association may grant the right to call a meeting to shareholders holding fewer shares (art. 411/1). - Q: What can be done if the general assembly rejects a request for a special audit? A: Under art. 439 of the TCC, the minority may, within three months of the rejection, apply to the commercial court of the place of the company's headquarters for the appointment of a special auditor, provided it convincingly demonstrates that the founders or corporate organs violated the law or the articles of association and thereby caused damage to the company. - Q: Can a resolution rejecting a special audit request be challenged by an annulment action? A: According to the settled case law of the 11th Civil Chamber, no; because arts. 438/439 of the TCC provide a direct route for the minority to apply to court for the appointment of a special auditor once the request is rejected, there is no legal interest in a separate action to annul the rejecting resolution. - Q: Does the court always order dissolution in an action for dissolution for just cause? A: No. Under art. 531 of the TCC, even where just cause is established, the court may order that the plaintiff shareholder be bought out at the real value of its shares instead of ordering dissolution, or order any other solution appropriate to the circumstances; Court of Cassation case law emphasizes that dissolution should be applied as a measure of last resort (ultima ratio) under the principle of proportionality. - Q: Under what circumstances is the discussion of financial statements postponed? A: Under art. 420 of the TCC, at the request of shareholders holding one-tenth of the share capital (one-twentieth for publicly held companies), the discussion of the financial statements and related matters is postponed for one month by decision of the chairman of the meeting, without any need for a resolution of the general assembly; however, according to the Court of Cassation, the election of the independent auditor does not fall within this scope. - Q: How many times can a postponement or special audit request be repeated? A: Under art. 420/2 of the TCC, a renewed postponement of the discussion of the financial statements, after it has already been postponed once at the minority's request, requires that the points objected to and recorded in the minutes not have been answered in accordance with the standard of honest accountability; otherwise a second postponement request will not be granted. - [Officer Must Be Summoned Before Bankruptcy After Concordat: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/rejected-concordat-bankruptcy-officer-hearing-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that an over-indebted capital company whose concordat request is rejected is declared bankrupt of the court’s own… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/konkordato-reddedilirse-iflas-karari-yetkili-dinlenmeden-verilemez - Q: Is every company whose concordat request is rejected declared bankrupt? A: No. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation, bankruptcy requires that the debtor be subject to bankruptcy and that one of the grounds for direct bankruptcy exist, for example the over-indebtedness of a capital company; otherwise the court only rejects the concordat request. - Q: Must a creditor file a separate bankruptcy request? A: According to the Assembly, no. If the conditions are met, the court declares bankruptcy of its own motion; no separate bankruptcy request by a creditor or by the company is required. - Q: Must the company officer be summoned to be heard before the bankruptcy decision? A: According to the Assembly, yes. Art. 308 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law contains no express provision; however, art. 177, which treats the situation in art. 308 as a ground for direct bankruptcy, provides that the debtor is summoned to court to be heard. - Q: Is it enough to serve the hearing date and time on the officer? A: In this case it was not: the notices did not warn the officers that they would be heard or of the consequences of not objecting to the expert report. A notice with a warning issued more than two years earlier was not considered sufficient either. - Q: Is the decision final, and what happened to the case? A: The decision was given unanimously and is final. The decision of resistance was reversed and the file was sent to the first-instance court. - [One Manager's Call Not Enough Where No LLC Chair Appointed: Turkish Court of Cassation on Non-Existence](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/llc-general-meeting-call-by-one-manager-non-existent-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that, in a limited company with several managers, no chair of the board of managers and no special arrangement in the articles… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/limited-sirkette-mudurlerden-birinin-cagirdigi-genel-kurul-yok-hukmunde - Q: Who calls the general assembly of a limited company? A: Under art. 617(1) of the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK), the managers. If there is more than one manager, the general assembly appoints one of them as chair (art. 624(1)); the manager who is chair, or the sole manager, is authorised to call it (art. 624(2)). - Q: Is a resolution of a general assembly called by only one of several managers valid? A: In this decision, no. Where no chair had been appointed and the articles of association contained no special arrangement, a call by one of the two managers was not treated as a legal call; the resolution should have been declared non-existent. The dispute dates from the period of the former Commercial Code No. 6762. - Q: Is a criminal conviction just cause for removing a manager? A: In this case, yes. For a manager whose conviction for breach of trust in the course of service, based on the finding that he had unjustly indebted the company, had become final, the Chamber, treating the material-fact finding in the criminal judgment as binding (art. 74 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, TBK), held that just cause was established. - Q: What happened to the case? A: The judgment on the joined action was upheld and the decision in the main action was reversed unanimously; the file was sent back to the first-instance court. - [Partner's Right to Information and Inspection: Books and Accounts of Turkish LLCs and Joint-Stock Companies](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/company-partner-inspect-books-accounts): Yes: in a limited company every partner may ask the managers for information on all of the company’s affairs and accounts and may carry out an inspection on specific matters, and if the general… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sirket-ortaginin-bilgi-alma-ve-inceleme-hakki - Q: Can a limited company partner inspect the company’s books? A: Yes. Every partner may request information from the managers on all of the company’s affairs and accounts and may carry out an inspection on specific matters (TCC art. 614/1). - Q: Can a joint-stock company shareholder see the commercial books? A: Yes, but inspection of the parts of the books and correspondence that concern the shareholder’s question requires the general assembly’s express permission or a board resolution (TCC art. 437/4). - Q: Within how many days must the court be asked if no information is given? A: In a joint-stock company the shareholder may apply to the commercial court within ten days following a refusal, and in other cases after a reasonable period (TCC art. 437/5). For limited companies the law sets no separate time limit. - Q: Can the decision in an information case be appealed? A: By law the court’s decision is final (TCC art. 614/3, TCC art. 437/5). The majority of the 11th Civil Chamber has treated a dismissal as final too; the dissents take the opposite view. - Q: Can a special audit be requested if information is not enough? A: In a joint-stock company, a shareholder who has already exercised the right to information or inspection may ask the general assembly for a special audit; if it refuses, shareholders meeting the statutory threshold may apply to the court within three months (TCC arts. 438-439). - [Proving an Invoice-Based Receivable in Türkiye: Is the Claim Real? (Delivery, Commercial Books, BA-BS Forms)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/proving-invoice-based-receivable): Does an invoice alone prove a receivable? The source of an invoice claim in commercial matters and between companies, proof of delivery and performance, the burden of proof (Civil Code art. 6, Code… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/faturaya-dayali-alacagin-ispati - Q: Is an invoice evidence on its own? A: An invoice is evidence, but on its own it does not prove the receivable. According to decisions upheld by the Court of Cassation, the seller must separately prove that the goods in the invoice were delivered or the service was performed. - Q: Does an invoice without a delivery note prove the claim? A: Without a signed delivery note, delivery must be proven by other evidence. In upheld decisions, delivery was accepted where the invoice was recorded in the buyer’s commercial books or notified by the buyer on the BA form. - Q: Does recording an invoice in one’s books mean accepting the debt? A: An entry in the buyer’s own commercial books is evidence against the buyer; in upheld decisions, delivery was accepted for invoices recorded in the books. A buyer claiming that it did not receive the goods or that the invoice was recorded as an accommodation must prove this itself; the burden of proving payment also lies with the buyer. - Q: Are BA-BS forms evidence? A: Yes, but their weight depends on who made the notification. An invoice notified by the buyer on the BA form was treated in upheld decisions as a presumption of purchase; the seller’s own BS notification alone does not prove the receivable. - Q: If no objection is made to an invoice, does the debt become final? A: No, not automatically. Failure to object within eight days has a consequence regarding the content of the invoice (Commercial Code art. 21/2), but, as emphasised in an upheld decision, it does not mean that the goods were delivered; the seller must prove delivery separately. - [Registered Share Transfer in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Approval, Refusal Grounds, Share Register Entry](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/transfer-registered-shares-joint-stock-companies): In a Turkish joint-stock company, registered shares are freely transferable unless the law or the articles of association provide otherwise; where certificates exist, the transfer is made by… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anonim-sirkette-nama-yazili-pay-devri - Q: Does a share transfer in a joint-stock company require the company’s approval? A: As a rule, no; registered shares are freely transferable unless the law or the articles of association provide otherwise (TCC art. 490). Approval is required by law for shares not fully paid up, and otherwise only where the articles of association so provide. - Q: How is a registered share certificate transferred? A: The certificate is endorsed and possession is passed to the transferee (TCC art. 490/2). To be treated as a shareholder by the company, the transferee must also be entered in the share register. - Q: On what grounds may the company refuse a share transfer? A: For unlisted shares, the company may refuse on an important ground set out in the articles of association, or by offering to acquire the shares from the transferor at their real value at the time of the application (TCC art. 493/1). - Q: What happens if the company does not respond to the request for approval? A: For unlisted shares, if the company does not reject the request within three months at the latest from receiving it, or if the rejection is unjustified, approval is deemed given (TCC art. 494/3). For listed shares, if the company does not reject the request for recognition within twenty days, the transferee is deemed recognised as shareholder (TCC art. 498). - Q: Is a person not entered in the share register a shareholder? A: No; in relations with the company, only the person entered in the share register is recognised as shareholder (TCC art. 499/4). If registration is unjustifiably refused, an action for registration may be brought before the commercial court of first instance. - [Removing a Limited Company Manager under Turkish Law: General Assembly Resolution and Court Action](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/limited-company-manager-removed): The general assembly of a Turkish limited company may remove its manager: appointing and removing managers is a non-transferable power of the general assembly, and unless the articles of association… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/limited-sirket-mudurunun-gorevden-alinmasi - Q: Who removes the manager of a limited company? A: The general assembly removes the manager; appointing and removing managers is a non-transferable power of the general assembly (Commercial Code art. 616/1-b, Commercial Code art. 630/1). Unless the articles provide otherwise, the resolution is adopted by a simple majority of the votes represented at the meeting (Commercial Code art. 620/1). - Q: What can a partner do if there is no majority at the general assembly? A: If just causes exist, any partner may ask the commercial court to revoke or restrict the manager’s management rights and representation authority (Commercial Code art. 630/2). The claimant partner must prove the just cause. - Q: What is just cause for removing a manager? A: A serious breach of the duty of care and loyalty or of obligations under the law and the articles of association, or the loss of the ability needed for proper management, is a just cause (Commercial Code art. 630/3). - Q: Against whom is the removal action brought? A: The action is brought against the manager whose removal is sought. According to the Court of Cassation, joining the company or all partners is not mandatory. - Q: Can a trustee be appointed while the action is pending? A: Suspension of the manager and appointment of a trustee during the proceedings may be requested as an interim measure; the ground must be stated and the claim shown to be justified on a prima facie basis (Code of Civil Procedure art. 389/1, Code of Civil Procedure art. 390/3). The Court of Cassation held that a trustee requested only for the duration of the action cannot be appointed for the period after the judgment becomes final. - [Sale after Financial Lease Termination in Türkiye: Who Pays the Price Difference? (Law No. 6361 Art. 33)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/financial-lease-termination-sale-price-difference): When a terminated lease asset is sold in Türkiye, the price is set against unpaid future rent and loss; the lessee pays a shortfall, the bank a surplus. The contract may agree another value (Law No.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/leasing-fesih-sonrasi-satis-deger-farki - Q: The leasing company or bank sold the asset cheaply; do I have to pay the difference? A: Unless the contract agrees a different value, if the sale price is lower than the total of the rentals not yet due and any further loss of the lessor, the lessee pays the difference (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). You must prove that the sale fell below market value with appraisals, advertisements and comparable sales (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/3469, K. 2021/683). - Q: If the sale price exceeds the remaining rentals, is the surplus paid to the lessee? A: Yes. If the sale price is higher than the total of the rentals not yet due and any further loss of the lessor, the lessor pays the difference to the lessee; the same principles apply if the asset is re-leased (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). The contract may also bring overdue rentals, insurance premiums and interest into this account. - Q: After taking the asset back, can the bank also claim all the remaining rentals? A: If the asset is sold, the rentals not yet due are compared with the sale price and only the difference may be claimed for them; rentals that fell due and remained unpaid before termination are a separate debt (Law No. 6361 art. 33/1). The Court of Cassation’s 6th Civil Chamber reversed a judgment admitting a claim to the estate given without investigating whether the machine had been handed over (Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/3797, K. 2025/4496). The rule differs for contracts from the Law No. 3226 era. - Q: In 2026, can an action for an unquantified claim be brought for the leasing price difference? A: No. Art. 107 of the Code of Civil Procedure was repealed by Law No. 7589 and applies only to actions filed before the date of repeal (Law No. 7589 provisional art. 1/10). In new actions the receivable is claimed by a partial action; the claim may be increased once in the same action until the end of the evidentiary stage, and limitation is deemed interrupted from the date of the action also for the increased part (Code of Civil Procedure art. 109/4). Prior application to a mediator is a condition of action (Commercial Code art. 5/A). - Q: Can the bank sell the leased asset while the case is still pending? A: If the asset has been left to the lessor or a third party by an interim injunction, the lessor may dispose of it by depositing with the court security equal to its market value, and must compensate the lessee’s loss if the termination proves unjustified (Law No. 6361 art. 31/3). Where the lessee voluntarily returned the asset and consented to its sale, it was held that the lessor had no legal interest in the return action it brought later (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/5993, K. 2023/997). - [Sale and Leaseback or a Disguised Loan: Simulation (Muvazaa) and Fiduciary Transfer Claims under Turkish Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/sale-leaseback-really-loan): A sale and leaseback is expressly regulated in art. 18 of Turkish Law No. 6361; a financing purpose alone does not make it a sham (simulated) transaction. A lessee must, as a rule, prove simulation… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sat-geri-kirala-muvazaa-iddiasi - Q: Is a sale and leaseback really a loan, and can it be annulled for simulation? A: A sale and leaseback is a form of financial leasing expressly provided for in Law No. 6361 (Law No. 6361 art. 18), and the Law defines financial leasing as a transaction aimed at providing financing (Law No. 6361 art. 3/1-ç). A financing purpose is not in itself simulation, and buying the asset from the lessee and leasing it back has not been treated as evidence of simulation (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/249, K. 2025/5017). Annulment requires proof that the parties created an appearance not corresponding to their true intention in order to deceive third parties. - Q: Can I prove by witnesses that a leaseback contract was simulated? A: As a party to the contract, as a rule, no; a simulation claim against a written or official contract to which one is a party is proven by written evidence (Code of Civil Procedure art. 201; Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2023/214, K. 2023/246). If a document issued or sent by the lessor that makes the claim probable qualifies as prima facie written evidence, witnesses may also be heard (Code of Civil Procedure art. 202). Witnesses may be heard on simulation claims raised by third parties such as creditors (Code of Civil Procedure art. 203/1-d). - Q: I could not pay the rent and the contract was terminated; can I now claim the transaction was simulated? A: It may be raised, but the burden of proof is on the lessee and written evidence is required. Appeal grounds against a regional appellate reasoning that found it contrary to good faith for a lessee in default to assert invalidity three years later were dismissed (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/72, K. 2025/900). In an invalidity action brought after the finding of termination for just cause had become final, it was held that there was no legal interest (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/3778, K. 2024/597). - Q: How do I get back property I had registered in someone else’s name so that a loan could be taken out? A: This relationship is characterised as a fiduciary transaction, and a claim for re-transfer depends on proof of the fiduciary agreement. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the written form of the fiduciary agreement is a requirement of proof; where there is no written evidence, any evidence including witnesses may be used if there is prima facie written evidence, and failing that, admission and oath (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/329, K. 2026/413). - Q: Is land registry fee payable in a sale and leaseback? A: Transactions relating to financial leasing contracts are as a rule exempt from fees; however, land registry transactions for the acquisition of leased immovables by the lessor are excluded from this exemption (Law No. 6361 art. 37/1). Registration in the lessee’s name, at the end of the contract term, of an immovable leased by the sale and leaseback method is exempt from land registry fees (Law No. 6361 art. 37/2). - [Same Issuer and Payee: Ordinary Note, Not a Promissory Note](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/promissory-note-same-issuer-payee-ordinary-note-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a note whose issuer and payee are the same person is not a negotiable instrument but may serve, as an ordinary… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kesideci-ile-lehtar-ayni-kisi-olan-senet-adi-senet-olarak-takibe-konu-olabilir - Q: Is a note on which the issuer and the payee are the same person a promissory note under Turkish law? A: No. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, since art. 778 of the Turkish Commercial Code does not refer to art. 673, which allows a bill of exchange to be drawn to the drawer’s own order, the issuer of a promissory note cannot name himself as payee; where the capacities of payee and issuer merge, the document is not treated as a promissory note. - Q: Can enforcement proceedings be based on such a note that lacks the character of a promissory note? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, enforcement by way of attachment specific to negotiable instruments requires the claim to be tied to a negotiable instrument. According to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, however, such a note may be made the subject of enforcement proceedings without judgment as an ordinary instrument given to the creditor. - Q: If the note bears no endorsement or written assignment, is the creditor’s action dismissed? A: It was not dismissed in this decision. Since there was no third person on the note other than the creditor and the debtor, the Chamber found it incorrect to dismiss the action to annul the objection on the ground that there was no valid endorsement specific to negotiable instruments. - Q: What happens if the debtor says the signature on the note is not theirs? A: According to the Chamber, the court must decide after assessing the debtor’s objection to the signature on the note. - Q: When is an action to annul an objection brought? A: Under art. 67/1 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, a creditor whose request for enforcement has been objected to may, within one year from service of the objection, apply to the court and bring an action to annul the objection by proving the existence of the claim under the general provisions. - [Security Note Defence Does Not Lift Precautionary Attachment](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/security-note-defence-precautionary-attachment-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the 4th Civil Chamber of the Denizli Regional Court of Appeal, where the source of the claim is a promissory note there is prima facie proof that the claim is not… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/teminat-senedi-iddiasi-bonoya-dayali-ihtiyati-haczi-kaldirmaz - Q: Does the claim that a promissory note is a security note lift a precautionary attachment? A: Not in this decision: under Turkish law, the Chamber treated the claim based on the promissory note as shown on a prima facie basis and adopted the first-instance reasoning that the security-note claim required a trial. There is also an appellate decision upholding the lifting of an attachment in a case where a written document identified the note and expressly stated its security purpose. - Q: Is a promissory note sufficient evidence for a precautionary attachment? A: Under art. 258(1) of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, the creditor must show evidence that will satisfy the court as to the claim. In this decision a promissory note that had fallen due was held sufficient as prima facie proof of a claim not secured by a pledge and fallen due. - Q: Can a note given to a partner in a simple partnership that has not been dissolved be attached by way of precaution? A: In this case the debtors’ objection that there can be no claim that has fallen due in a simple partnership that has not been dissolved and liquidated did not lift the attachment. Whether the debt has fallen due is a matter to be examined at trial. - Q: Can a precautionary attachment be requested if the claim is secured by a mortgage? A: Art. 257(1) of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law allows a precautionary attachment for a claim not secured by a pledge. In this case, relying on the note, the Chamber treated it as shown on a prima facie basis that the claim was not secured by a pledge; it did not separately discuss the mortgage argument. - Q: Can this decision be appealed to the Court of Cassation? A: No. Under art. 265 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, an appeal (istinaf) may be lodged against the decision given on an objection to a precautionary attachment, and the regional court of appeal’s decision is final. - [Share Ownership Suit Needs Sole Shareholder as a Party: Turkish Court of Cassation on Company-Only Claims](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/share-ownership-action-sole-shareholder-party-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a share ownership action brought only against a joint-stock company can concern the interests of a non-party. That is… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/pay-sahipliginin-tespiti-davasi-yalniz-sirkete-karsi-sonuclandirilamaz - Q: Against whom is an action for a declaration of share ownership brought? A: In the case behind this decision, the action had been brought only against the company and, at the date of the action, all of the company’s shares appeared to be held by a non-party. According to the Chamber, since the judgment will concern that person’s interests, the claimant must be given time to bring a separate action against that person and the actions must be consolidated. - Q: If the sole shareholder is not a party, is the action dismissed? A: In this decision the Chamber did not call for dismissal; it required that the claimant be given time and that the actions be consolidated, and the decision given without these steps was reversed for incomplete examination. - Q: What must the court examine after the actions are consolidated? A: According to the Chamber, taking into account the attendance lists for 2022 and earlier years and the allegation that the documents notified to the Central Registry Agency were forged, the court must determine, in a manner open to review, whether the claimant was still a shareholder at the date of the action and, if so, in what amount. - Q: Did this decision treat the claimant as a shareholder? A: No. It is a reversal decision; the file was sent to the first-instance court, and whether the claimant is a shareholder was left to the examination to be carried out. - [Share Transfer in a Turkish Limited Company: Notarised Form, General Assembly Approval and Refusal of Approval](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/share-transfer-limited-company): In a Turkish limited company a share is transferred by a written agreement with notarised signatures, and unless the articles of association provide otherwise the transfer becomes valid only with… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/limited-sirkette-pay-devri-ve-genel-kurul-onayi - Q: Must a limited company share transfer be made before a notary? A: Yes. The transfer of a capital share and transactions creating an obligation to transfer are made in writing and the parties’ signatures are notarised (TCC art. 595/1). A contract concluded without the form prescribed by law produces no effect (Code of Obligations art. 12/2). - Q: Is a general assembly resolution needed for a share transfer in a limited company? A: Unless the articles provide otherwise, general assembly approval is required and the transfer becomes valid with it (TCC art. 595/2). This also applies to transfers between partners (TCC art. 593/1). - Q: What happens if the general assembly refuses to approve the transfer? A: Unless the articles provide otherwise, the general assembly may refuse without giving reasons and the transfer does not become valid (TCC art. 595/3). The partner wishing to transfer retains the right to withdraw from the company for just cause (TCC art. 595/5). - Q: Does the transfer take effect if the general assembly does not respond within three months? A: Yes. If the general assembly does not refuse within three months of the application, approval is deemed given (TCC art. 595/7). In decisions upheld by the Court of Cassation, a refusal adopted after the period did not change the outcome (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/2161, K. 2025/7060). - Q: Which action can be brought if the company does not enter the transfer in the share register? A: The transferee may sue the company before the commercial court of first instance for a declaration of partnership, entry in the share register and registration in the trade registry. In decisions upheld by the Court of Cassation these claims were granted because the three-month period had passed without a refusal (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/1690, K. 2025/6595). - [Singer and Producer Agreements in Türkiye: Validity and Penalty Clauses (Law No. 5846 Arts. 52, 80; TBK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/singer-producer-agreements): Album, single, master and distribution agreements between singers and producers under Turkish law: written form and itemisation of rights, performer and producer rights, collecting societies and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sarkici-produktor-sozlesmeleri-ve-cezai-sart - Q: We agreed orally with the producer; have my rights in the recordings passed to the producer? A: Contracts and dispositions concerning economic rights must be in writing and specify each right separately (Law No. 5846 art. 52); a performer’s permissions must also be in writing. An oral agreement, or a general text not listing the rights individually, may not transfer the rights not listed. - Q: Can the producer claim the penalty without proving loss? A: Yes. A valid penalty may be claimed even if the creditor suffered no loss (Code of Obligations art. 180). But if the main obligation is invalid, or became impossible for a reason for which the debtor is not responsible, the penalty cannot be claimed, and the court reduces an excessive penalty of its own motion. - Q: The contract says “I accept that the penalty is not excessive”; is reduction still possible? A: Yes. The Assembly of Civil Chambers holds that the possibility of reducing an excessive penalty is a matter of public order and cannot be waived in advance. If the debtor is not a merchant, the court reduces an excessive penalty of its own motion. - Q: Is an artist a merchant; can the artist seek reduction? A: Personal artistic performance does not in itself mean operating a commercial enterprise; in that case the artist benefits from reduction. If the artist’s company signed the contract, the debtor is a merchant and cannot seek reduction under Commercial Code art. 22; even then, if the penalty would cause the company’s economic ruin, it may be held partly void for immorality. - Q: Album delivery was late but the producer accepted the recording; can it claim the penalty later? A: Under a penalty for late performance (cumulative penalty), a producer who accepted performance without reservation cannot claim the penalty (Code of Obligations art. 179/2). The reservation must be made expressly at the time of performance; the result may differ if the contract provides that no reservation is needed or the right was reserved by an earlier warning. - Q: The producer made no album and I terminated; can it claim the penalty from me? A: In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, a producer who took no steps to prepare the album was held to be the party in breach and at fault, the artist’s termination was justified and the producer could not claim the penalty. Keeping correspondence and warnings showing the justification for termination is important. - [Start Date of a Surety’s Default Interest: Sureties Not Served the Account Closure Notice (TCC Art. 7)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/surety-never-received-account-closure-notice): In Turkish case law, a surety not served with the account closure notice is in default from the enforcement date and owes contractual interest until then. In an 18.02.2026 decision the Assembly of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kefilin-temerrut-faizi-sorumlulugu - Q: If the surety never received an account closure notice, must the surety pay default interest? A: Not for the period before enforcement. In suretyship for a commercial debt, default interest cannot run unless the surety has been notified (Turkish Commercial Code art. 7/1). In decisions affirmed by the 11th Civil Chamber, such a surety falls into default on the enforcement date and is liable for contractual interest until then (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5089, K. 2026/1811); in a 2026 decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers, service of the payment order was taken as the starting point instead (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/61, K. 2026/92). - Q: If the notice was served on the company, is the surety also in default? A: No. The principal debtor’s default is not enough for the surety; a separate notice to the surety is required, and in affirmed regional appellate decisions the İİK art. 68/b rule on the address in the loan agreement is applied only to the principal debtor (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/484, K. 2024/8888). The absence of a notice does not, however, prevent the bank from pursuing the surety for the principal (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2020/697, K. 2022/1386). - Q: My address changed and the account closure notice went to the old address and was returned; am I in default? A: It depends on the suretyship clauses. If the contract contains only a general address clause aimed at the principal debtor, a returned notice does not put the surety in default. If there is an address and service clause specific to the surety and the change of address was not notified in the form prescribed by that clause, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation may treat the date on which the notice reached the address in the contract as the date of service (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/1922, K. 2025/6800; E. 2024/5553, K. 2025/3957). - Q: Can a surety end up paying more than the suretyship limit? A: Not for the principal debt; the surety is in all cases liable up to the maximum amount in the suretyship contract (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 589/1). The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, however, accepts that the surety is also liable above the limit for default interest running after the surety’s own default (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2020/8370, K. 2022/3497). - Q: Which interest can be claimed from the surety between account closure and enforcement? A: If the surety was not in default during that period, contractual interest may be claimed, but default interest may not (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/305, K. 2025/5809). If that contractual interest was claimed neither in the notice nor in the enforcement request, the court cannot add it to the principal (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2018/1101, K. 2021/1693); unless otherwise agreed, the surety is liable for contractual interest accrued for one year and for the current year (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 589/2). - [Tera, Pusula and Liquidated Fund Investors in Türkiye: Legal Roadmap on Liquidation, Claims, Full Remedy](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/legal-roadmap-investors-harmed-tera-pusula): A guide for investors harmed in the Tera, Pusula and liquidated fund cases: CMB decisions, compensation, criminal complaints, bankruptcy claims, full-remedy actions. Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tera-pusula-fon-magdurlari-hukuki-yol-rehberi - Q: Will the Investor Compensation Center cover my loss in a liquidated fund? A: As a rule, no. The ICC covers claims arising from an investment firm’s failure to deliver cash or instruments held on your behalf after a compensation decision; losses from price movements are excluded (Law No. 6362 art. 84). The fund claim is paid first from the liquidation; damages may be sought from those responsible for the remaining loss. - Q: I received an interim payment; what should I do about the rest? A: The interim payment is an advance on the final liquidation amount. Follow the final distribution and MKK reconciliation and do not sign releases. For uncovered loss, use mediation and litigation before limitation expires; a partial action may be increased once (Code of Civil Procedure art. 109/4). - Q: Can I complain directly to the prosecutor? A: Yes, but for offences under the Capital Markets Law such as market fraud the investigation depends on the CMB’s written application (Law No. 6362 art. 115). Address your complaint to both the CMB and the prosecutor. No such condition applies to Penal Code offences such as aggravated fraud or laundering. - Q: When and where must I bring the claim registration action? A: Within 15 days of the announcement of the ranking table, before the commercial court of the place of bankruptcy; if you advanced notification costs, the period runs from notification (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 235). The action is against the estate if your claim was rejected, or against the other creditor if you challenge that creditor’s claim. Mediation is not a precondition. - Q: Can I bring a full-remedy action against the CMB, and when does time start? A: Yes. First apply in writing to the CMB within one year of learning of the act and in any event within five years; if there is no reply within thirty days the request is deemed rejected, and the action is brought in the administrative court within 60 days of rejection (Law No. 2577 art. 13). Service fault, actual loss and causation must be shown concretely. - Q: Which court hears a damages action? A: As a rule the commercial court of first instance, subject to prior mediation (Commercial Code art. 5/A). The Assembly of Civil Chambers did not regard the consumer court as competent for an investment contract expressly stated to be commercial; whether a retail investor is a consumer depends on the specific contract. - [The Evidential Nature of Commercial Books (CCP Art. 222): Evidence For and Against the Owner](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/evidential-nature-commercial-books): The evidential nature of commercial books: production of books in commercial cases (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 222), the three conditions for books to be evidence in favour of their owner… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-28; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ticari-defterlerin-delil-niteligi - Q: Will my commercial book be evidence in my favour? A: Only if it was kept properly (fully, with opening/closing approvals, entries corroborating one another) and is not contrary to the other party's properly kept book. Also, the contrary must not have been proven by deed/conclusive evidence. - Q: What if I kept my book improperly? A: A book lacking opening/closing approvals or whose entries do not corroborate one another is evidence against its owner. Moreover, in a properly kept book the favourable and unfavourable entries cannot be separated. - Q: What if the other party does not submit its book to the court? A: Where a non-merchant party states it will accept the entries in the merchant's book and the merchant refrains from producing it, the party requesting production is deemed to have proven its claim. - Q: Which is stronger evidence, the invoice or the commercial book? A: If the invoice is entered in the other party's book, the evidence is the commercial book; a booked invoice also proves the contractual relationship. A party asserting the contrary must prove it by written/conclusive evidence. - Q: How are books examined and which court has jurisdiction? A: Books are examined by an expert; conformity with the law and consistency of entries are reported. In a commercial dispute the commercial court of first instance has jurisdiction. - [The Fraudulent Return Invoice: Does It Extinguish the Debt? (Proof and the Tax-Criminal Dimension)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/fraudulent-return-invoice): The fraudulent (sham) return invoice: a return invoice not based on a genuine return does not extinguish the debt; a return invoice alone does not prove the return; a genuine return must be proven by… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-28; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/hileli-iade-faturasi - Q: Does issuing a return invoice automatically erase my debt? A: No. The party claiming the debt ended by return must prove that the goods were truly returned (actual delivery). Merely issuing a return invoice is not enough; per the Court of Cassation a return invoice alone does not prove the return, and a court may not accept the return on the basis of the return invoice alone. - Q: How do I prove a genuine return? A: By a signed return/dispatch delivery note, delivery-receipt documents, transport records, and properly kept commercial-book entries consistent with them. The Court of Cassation requires the return to be proven by proper evidence; the mere entry of the return invoice in the issuer's own books is not sufficient. - Q: Is there a penalty for issuing a return invoice that is not genuine? A: There may be. A document not based on reality may be deemed fake or misleading in content; this may constitute a smuggling offence requiring imprisonment under Tax Procedure Code Art. 359, and gives rise to a tax-loss penalty and penalised assessment. - Q: The other side says it closed its debt with a return invoice; what should I do? A: You may assert the invalidity of a return invoice not based on a genuine return; demand from the other side the signed documents showing actual delivery; and request examination of the commercial books and, if necessary, of the document's falsity. - Q: Which court hears this dispute? A: Because the receivable/debt side is a commercial case, the commercial court of first instance has jurisdiction. The tax offence concerning the document's falsity is the subject of separate criminal proceedings. - [Trademark Infringement in Türkiye (IPC Art. 29): Infringing Acts, Defences, Injunction, Removal, Damages](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/trademark-infringement): Trademark infringement under the Turkish Industrial Property Code (Law No. 6769): the scope of trademark rights (art. 7), infringing acts (art. 29), likelihood of confusion and use as a trademark… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/marka-hakkina-tecavuz - Q: Which court hears a trademark infringement action? A: The intellectual and industrial property civil court or, where none exists, the designated civil court of first instance (Industrial Property Code art. 156/1); venue lies at the claimant’s domicile or where the act occurred or had its effects (Industrial Property Code art. 156/3). - Q: Can an infringement action be brought if the other party also has a registered trademark? A: Yes. A later registration is no defence against the holder of an earlier right (Industrial Property Code art. 155), and the later mark may also be invalidated. - Q: Is using the same word in a trade name trademark infringement? A: Use as a trade name may be prohibited (Industrial Property Code art. 7/3-e); what matters is use as a trademark. In an upheld judgment, use of the name as registered was lawful, while highlighting its core element infringed (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/1561, K. 2025/5659). - Q: Does a proprietor who stays silent for a long time lose its rights? A: A proprietor who knew or should have known of a later mark’s use and acquiesced for five successive years cannot rely on its mark for invalidity unless the later registration was in bad faith (Industrial Property Code art. 25/6). For infringement, acquiescence rests on Civil Code art. 2 and requires the later user’s good faith (Court of Cassation Civil General Assembly, E. 2024/376, K. 2025/798); the defendant must prove the conditions (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/1561, K. 2025/5659). - Q: How are damages for trademark infringement calculated? A: Damage comprises actual loss and loss of profit, the latter calculated at the right holder’s choice on probable income, the infringer’s net profit or a licence fee (Industrial Property Code art. 151/2); compensation for loss of reputation (Industrial Property Code art. 150/2) and non-pecuniary damages (Industrial Property Code art. 149/1) may be added. - Q: Is trademark infringement a criminal offence? A: Yes. Infringement by copying or creating confusion, such as manufacturing, selling, importing or exporting goods, carries one to three years’ imprisonment and a judicial fine of up to twenty thousand days (Industrial Property Code art. 30/1); the mark must be registered in Türkiye and prosecution requires a complaint (Industrial Property Code art. 30/5-6). - [Travel Agency Status and Receivables in Turkish Law: Licence, Hotel Allotments, Commission, Limitation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/legal-status-receivables-travel-agencies): The legal status and receivables of travel agencies under Turkish law: the operating licence, mandatory membership of the Association of Travel Agencies and the guarantee under Law No. 1618 and the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/seyahat-acentalarinin-hukuki-durumu-ve-alacaklari - Q: Is a licence mandatory to open a travel agency? A: Yes. An operating licence from the Ministry of Culture and Tourism is mandatory and is granted only to legal entities (Law No. 1618 art. 4). Membership of the Association of Travel Agencies is also mandatory (Law No. 1618 art. 32). - Q: How does a hotel collect accommodation charges from an agency? A: The hotel may start enforcement proceedings on the basis of the allotment contract and invoices; if the debtor objects, an action for annulment of objection is filed within one year (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 67). The case is heard by the commercial court, and mediation must be attempted first (Commercial Code art. 5/A). - Q: When does the agency’s commission claim arise? A: The contract comes first. Absent a provision, in a continuous agency relationship the fee arises when and to the extent that the concluded transaction is performed (Commercial Code art. 114); for one-off brokerage, only when a contract is concluded as a result of the brokerage (Code of Obligations art. 521). - Q: Which court hears a dispute between an agency and a hotel? A: As a commercial case, it falls within the jurisdiction of the commercial court of first instance (Commercial Code art. 4 and art. 5). Mediation is a procedural prerequisite in money claims (Commercial Code art. 5/A). - Q: What is the limitation period for claims arising from an allotment contract? A: In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, the allotment contract was not treated as an agency contract and the ten-year period (Code of Obligations art. 146) was applied to the advance claim arising from it (11th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/7191, K. 2024/3360). Accommodation charges and claims arising from commission and agency contracts are subject to the five-year period (Code of Obligations art. 147). - [Turkish Commercial Enterprise Transfer: Integrity, Registration, Debt Liability (TCC Art. 11, TCO Art. 202)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/transfer-commercial-enterprise): A guide to the transfer of a commercial enterprise under Turkish law: the principle of integrity in Commercial Code art. 11 and the artisan–merchant distinction, the written form, registration and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ticari-isletme-devri - Q: Is a written agreement required to transfer a commercial enterprise? A: Yes. The transfer agreement is made in writing, registered with the trade registry and announced (Commercial Code art. 11/3). The 11th Civil Chamber treated the written form as a condition of validity and reversed a judgment holding the transferee liable under Code of Obligations art. 202 without a written agreement (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/620, K. 2023/3244). - Q: From when is the transferee liable for earlier debts? A: A person who takes over an enterprise with its assets and liabilities is liable to the creditors for the business debts from the date on which it notifies them of the transfer or announces it, for commercial enterprises by a notice in the Trade Registry Gazette (Code of Obligations art. 202). - Q: Is the transferor released from the debts immediately? A: No. The previous debtor remains jointly and severally liable with the transferee for two years; the period runs, for debts already due, from the date of notification or announcement and, for debts falling due later, from their due date. Without notification or announcement, the two-year period does not begin to run (Code of Obligations art. 202). - Q: Do the lease and the trade name pass with the enterprise? A: Unless otherwise provided, the transfer agreement also covers the leasehold right and the trade name (Commercial Code art. 11/3). The 3rd Civil Chamber accepted that, in a transfer as a whole, the leasehold right passes without the landlord’s consent (Court of Cassation 3rd Civil Chamber, E. 2025/3400, K. 2025/4478). Unless expressly agreed otherwise, the transfer of the enterprise also results in the transfer of the trade name (Commercial Code art. 49). - Q: Who is liable for employees’ receivables when a workplace is transferred? A: The transferor and the transferee are jointly liable for debts that arose before the transfer and are payable on the date of transfer; the transferor’s liability is limited to two years from the date of transfer (Labour Law art. 6). According to the 9th Civil Chamber, for severance pay the transferor is liable for its own period on the basis of the last wage at the transfer date, without the two-year limit; the last employer bears notice pay and unused leave pay (Court of Cassation 9th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/12198, K. 2022/14570). - Q: Which court hears disputes arising from an enterprise transfer, and is mediation mandatory? A: Actions arising from Code of Obligations art. 202 and Code of Obligations art. 203 are commercial cases regardless of whether the parties are merchants (Commercial Code art. 4/1-c) and are heard by the commercial court of first instance (Commercial Code art. 5/1). In actions for receivables, compensation, annulment of objection, negative declaratory relief and restitution whose subject matter is a sum of money, applying to a mediator before filing suit is a condition of action (Commercial Code art. 5/A). - [Turkish Joint-Stock Company General Assembly: How It Is Convened, the Call, Agenda and Quorums](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/general-assembly-joint-stock-company-convened): In a Turkish joint-stock company the general assembly is, as a rule, called by the board of directors at least two weeks in advance, excluding the days of the announcement and of the meeting, by an… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anonim-sirkette-genel-kurul-cagrisi-gundem-ve-nisaplar - Q: What is the meeting quorum for the general assembly of a joint-stock company? A: Unless a heavier quorum applies, it is at least one quarter of the capital; the quorum must be maintained throughout the meeting, no quorum is required at a second meeting, and resolutions are adopted by a majority of the votes present (TCC art. 418). - Q: What quorum is required to amend the articles of association? A: As a rule, a majority of the votes present at a meeting where at least half of the capital is represented; one third suffices at a second meeting. Seventy-five per cent affirmative votes are required for decisions such as a complete change of the field of activity, and unanimity for moving the registered office abroad (TCC art. 421). - Q: How many days before the meeting must the call be made? A: At least two weeks, excluding the days of the announcement and of the meeting; the announcement is published on the company website and in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette, and registered shareholders receive a registered letter (TCC art. 414/1). - Q: Is a resolution annulled if the call was defective? A: Yes, if the defect affected the adoption of the resolution; a shareholder may bring an annulment action within three months from the resolution even without attending the meeting (TCC art. 445, TCC art. 446/1-b). - Q: Are resolutions of a general assembly convened without authority valid? A: If all shareholders attend, do not object before the agenda is taken up and do not leave, the conditions of a general assembly without a call are met (TCC art. 416). Otherwise, especially where an objection was made before the meeting, the resolutions may be treated as non-existent. - [Turkish Limited Company General Assembly Resolutions: Annulment, Nullity, Three-Month Period, Recorded Dissent](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-general-assembly-resolution-limited-company): Annulment, nullity and non-existence of a limited-company general-assembly resolution: which resolutions, who may sue, the recorded-dissent requirement, the three-month period and court — in light of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-16; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/limited-sirkette-genel-kurul-karari-iptali - Q: What is the period to annul a resolution? A: The annulment action must be brought within three months of the resolution; this is a forfeiture period. For nullity and non-existence there is no time limit. - Q: Which court hears the action? A: The commercial court of first instance at the company's seat. - Q: I attended but did not have my dissent recorded; can I still sue? A: For an attending member, a negative vote and recorded dissent are a condition of action. Without them, no annulment action lies; but nullity/non-existence grounds are not subject to the period or dissent requirement. - Q: What is the difference between annulment and nullity? A: Breach of the law, articles or good faith is a ground of annulment, subject to the three-month period. Breach of mandatory rules is nullity — not time-barred and considered by the court ex officio. - Q: I just acquired the share; can I sue? A: Only a person who has become a shareholder/member may bring the annulment action. Until the transfer is complete, the status of shareholder does not arise. - Q: Do these rules apply to limited companies? A: Yes. Under Art. 622 TCC, the rules on annulment and nullity of joint-stock company resolutions apply by analogy to limited companies. - [Unapproved LLC Manager Pay Needs a Reasonableness Review: Turkish Appellate Court on General Assembly Approval](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/turkish-llc-manager-salary-no-general-assembly-resolution): Under Turkish law, according to the 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, in a liability action against a limited company manager who took remuneration without a general… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/genel-kurul-karari-olmadan-sirket-mudurune-odenen-maas - Q: Who sets the salary of a manager in a Turkish limited company? A: Under Turkish law, determining the remuneration of managers is one of the non-transferable powers of the general assembly (Turkish Commercial Code art. 616/1-f). - Q: Can the entire salary taken without a general assembly resolution be reclaimed? A: Under Turkish law, according to this decision and a 2024 decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, not automatically. The court determines through an expert examination whether the payments are reasonable; the loss is the part exceeding a reasonable remuneration. - Q: Can a manager be entitled to remuneration even without a general assembly resolution? A: The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that, because of the prohibition of forced labour, it is inconceivable for the manager to work without receiving any remuneration. In another action between the same parties, the first-instance court relied on the custom rule in art. 502/3 of the Turkish Code of Obligations; the dismissal survived appellate and Court of Cassation review with general reasoning. - Q: When appointing a trustee to the company is sought, can the company be joined to the action later? A: According to this decision, no: a company not named as a defendant in the statement of claim cannot later become a party as a “joined defendant”; if the claim must be directed against the company, a separate action should be brought and the actions consolidated. - [Unauthorised Moratorium Debts Fall Under the Concordat: Turkish Court of Cassation on Partial Annulment](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/concordat-partial-annulment-unauthorised-moratorium-debt): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that a claim arising from a contract made during the concordat moratorium without the commissioner’s… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/komiser-izni-olmadan-dogan-alacak-icin-konkordatonun-kismen-feshi - Q: Is a claim arising from a contract made during the concordat moratorium without the commissioner’s permission subject to the concordat? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation, yes. Under art. 308/c/2 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, a concordat that has become binding is also mandatory for claims arising during the moratorium without the commissioner’s permission; debts contracted with the commissioner’s permission, by contrast, are not subject to the terms of the concordat in an ordinary concordat under art. 308/c/4. - Q: Do “routine” commercial transactions during the moratorium also require the commissioner’s permission? A: The Assembly did not answer this question in general terms. It required that whether a transaction counts as routine be assessed separately in each specific case, and it did not regard the sales contract worth EUR 526,320.00 as a routine commercial activity for the debtor. - Q: Can a creditor who did not register its claim in the concordat seek partial annulment? A: In this case the Assembly accepted the legal interest of a creditor whose claim is subject to the concordat and has not been paid under the project; that claim had been established by an arbitral award. According to a decision of the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 08.04.2026, however, a creditor who registered no claim at all cannot, as a rule, seek partial annulment; it may do so if the claim is established by a judgment in the action it brings and is not paid under the project despite a demand. - Q: What is the effect of partial annulment of the concordat? A: Under art. 308/e of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, the creditor has the concordat annulled in respect of itself only, while retaining the new rights acquired under the concordat. According to the Assembly, the creditor can thereby return, as regards itself, to the position before the concordat. - Q: Was the concordat annulled in this case? A: No. The Assembly reversed the decision of resistance; the regional court of appeal will assess whether the conditions for partial annulment are met. - [Uncertificated Shares Need Written Assignment: Ankara Regional Court of Appeal Voids a Board Transfer](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/uncertificated-shares-transfer-written-assignment-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the Ankara Regional Court of Appeal decision upheld by the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, uncertificated (bare) registered shares are transferred under… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/pay-senedi-basilmamis-hisse-yazili-temlik-olmadan-devredilemez - Q: How are shares transferred in a joint-stock company that has not printed share certificates? A: Under Turkish law, according to this decision, registered shares not embodied in a certificate (bare shares) are transferred under the rules on assignment of claims and in written form (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 184); a fully paid share is transferred by handing the transferee a written declaration of assignment. Shares that are not fully paid were not discussed in this decision. - Q: Can shares be transferred by a board resolution? A: Not in this case: the Chamber held void a transfer made by a resolution signed only by the chairman of the board, without the shareholder’s signature or any document of authority. Situations where there is a document signed by the shareholder are not the subject of this decision. - Q: What happens to later transfers based on an invalid transfer? A: According to the Chamber, they are also void. In this case the 2014 transfer between the brothers was also held invalid, and the shares were ordered to be entered in the share register in the shareholder’s name. - Q: Can a shareholder who stayed silent for years bring an action later? A: In this case, yes: as there was no information or document at all showing that the transfer had been ratified or accepted, the Chamber did not treat bringing the action almost eight years later as an abuse of rights. - Q: Is this decision final? A: Yes. It is a decision of a regional court of appeal (istinaf); the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld it on 04.03.2026, unanimously and with final effect, without writing separate reasoning. - [Unfair Competition Actions in Türkiye: Unfair Acts, Claims, Competent Court and Limitation (TCC Arts. 54-62)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/unfair-competition-actions): A guide to unfair competition actions under Turkish law: the principle of honest and undistorted competition in Commercial Code art. 54, the acts of unfair competition in art. 55 (disparagement… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/haksiz-rekabet-davasi - Q: What can be claimed in an unfair competition action? A: A declaration that the act is unfair, prohibition of the unfair competition, removal of its consequences and correction of false statements, if unavoidable the destruction of instruments and goods, pecuniary damages if there is fault and non-pecuniary damages under the conditions of Code of Obligations art. 58 (TCC art. 56/1). - Q: What is the limitation period for an unfair competition action? A: One year from learning of the accrual of the rights and in any event three years from their accrual; if the act is an offence subject to a longer criminal limitation period, that period applies (TCC art. 60/1). “Learning” means learning of the damage and of the person responsible (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/5830, K. 2024/2078). - Q: Which court hears an unfair competition action? A: As a rule, the commercial court of first instance (TCC art. 4/1-a and TCC art. 5). In actions based on the unauthorised use of another’s news, however, the civil court of intellectual and industrial property rights has jurisdiction (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/4292, K. 2025/5784). - Q: Is mediation mandatory in an unfair competition action? A: It is a precondition to suit for claims whose subject is a sum of money, such as damages (TCC art. 5/A). For non-monetary claims such as a declaration, prevention and deletion of a trade name, the mediation objection was rejected (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/4340, K. 2025/2920). - Q: Is it unfair competition for a limited company partner to compete with the company? A: As a rule, no, unless the articles of association impose a non-compete obligation; an appeal judgment to that effect was upheld (Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/2256, K. 2025/2270). The non-compete obligation applicable to directors is assessed separately. - Q: How are pecuniary damages calculated in unfair competition? A: The basis is the profit the claimant lost because of the unfair competition, not gross revenue; as a rule it is determined by expert examination with commercial books and other evidence. The judge may also award the equivalent of the benefit the defendant could possibly have obtained (TCC art. 56/1). - [Unfair Competition by Confusion in Türkiye: Trade Names, Packaging and Domain Names (TCC Arts. 55/1-a-4, 52)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/passing-off-unfair-competition-trade-name-packaging-domain): Under Turkish law, measures causing confusion with another's business are unfair competition without any registration requirement (Turkish Commercial Code art. 55/1-a-4), and art. 52 additionally… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/iltibas-yoluyla-haksiz-rekabet-ticaret-unvani-ambalaj-alan-adi - Q: Does passing off as unfair competition under Turkish law require a registered trademark or trade name? A: No. Under Turkish law, art. 55/1-a-4 of the Turkish Commercial Code treats measures that cause confusion with another's goods, work products, activities or business as unfair competition without requiring registration. However, the sign or get-up must be identified with the claimant in the market. The Court of Cassation has required a high level of distinctiveness for unregistered packaging and product designs and has held that there is no confusion where the later product is sold under a different trademark. - Q: Is using the core word of another company’s trade name in one’s own trade name passing off under Turkish law? A: It can be. Under art. 52 of the Turkish Commercial Code, a holder whose trade name is used contrary to commercial honesty may seek a declaration, a prohibition, amendment or deletion of the registered trade name and, depending on fault, damages. The Court of Cassation has held that using a trade name registered in bad faith is unfair competition. By contrast, an upheld decision dismissed a claim by an earlier holder who had remained silent for fifteen years, on grounds of good faith. - Q: Is using the same colour on packaging enough for passing off under Turkish law? A: As a rule, no. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that packaging must be assessed by its overall impression and that mere colour similarity between products with different overall compositions is not unfair competition; that decision was taken by majority. Where colour, lettering and shapes together create a near-identical composition, another upheld decision found unfair competition. - Q: Can a competitor's similar domain name and website be passing off under Turkish law? A: It can. In an upheld regional court of appeal decision, using the core element of a trade name beyond its registered form, in a domain name and website in a way that created a trademark-like effect, was held to be unfair competition, and access to the domain name was blocked. In the same case the request to delete the trade name was dismissed because of long silence and because the defendant’s trade name registration predated the claimant’s trademark registrations, so the domain name and the trade name were assessed separately. - Q: Can a registered trademark owner in Türkiye also rely on unfair competition rules against imitation of the mark? A: According to the view taken by majority in the 11th Civil Chamber’s decision of 26.02.2026, for events after the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 entered into force, only the Industrial Property Code applies to a registered trademark, and no separate unfair competition ruling is made for the same use. One member dissented, arguing that both protections should apply together. The decision reached this result for a case where the scope of the registered trademark and that of unfair competition overlapped; that unfair competition rules may be relied on for elements outside the registration, such as the overall get-up of packaging, is this article’s inference. - [Unpaid Dividends in Turkish Companies: What Can a Shareholder Do? (Limited and Joint-Stock Companies)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/shareholder-dividends-not-paid): A dividend can be claimed only after the general assembly has resolved to distribute profit; the Court of Cassation holds that, without such a resolution, a court cannot take the general assembly’s… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sirket-ortagina-kar-payi-odenmiyorsa - Q: If the company made a profit, can a partner claim the dividend directly? A: No. The general assembly decides on dividends (TCC art. 408/2-d, TCC art. 616/1-e); the Court of Cassation holds that, without a distribution resolution, a court cannot take the general assembly’s place and fix a dividend. - Q: When must an action against a resolution not to distribute profit be brought? A: An annulment action is brought within three months of the resolution (TCC art. 445). A partner attending the meeting must vote against and have the objection recorded in the minutes. - Q: Can the general assembly transfer all profit to reserves? A: Reserves not provided for in the law or the articles may be set aside only under the statutory conditions (TCC art. 523/2; for limited companies TCC art. 608/3); otherwise the resolution may be challenged by an annulment action. - Q: What if a distribution was resolved but the dividend is not paid? A: The dividend is claimed from the company by a debt action or enforcement proceedings. If the company objects to enforcement, an action for annulment of the objection may be brought within one year of service of the objection (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 67/1). - Q: If no profit has been distributed for years, can a partner leave the company? A: In a joint-stock company, shareholders representing at least one tenth of the capital may sue for dissolution for just cause; instead of dissolution, the court may order that the plaintiffs be paid the real value of their shares and excluded (TCC art. 531). In a limited company any partner may bring an action for dissolution or withdrawal for just cause. - [Voting Quorum in a Turkish Limited Company: Ordinary and Important Resolutions (Commercial Code arts. 620–621)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/voting-quorum-limited-company): In a Turkish limited company, unless the law or the articles of association provide otherwise, general assembly resolutions are adopted by an absolute majority of the votes represented at the meeting… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/limited-sirkette-karar-nisaplari - Q: What is the voting quorum in a limited company? A: Unless the law or the articles of association provide otherwise, general assembly resolutions, including elections, are adopted by an absolute majority of the votes represented at the meeting (TCC art. 620). For the important resolutions listed in TCC art. 621, at least two thirds of the votes represented and an absolute majority of the entire share capital carrying voting rights are required together. - Q: What majority is needed for a capital increase in a limited company? A: A capital increase is an important resolution; at least two thirds of the votes represented and an absolute majority of the entire share capital carrying voting rights are required together (TCC art. 621/1-d). Pre-emption rights may be restricted or abolished only for just cause and with the same quorum (TCC art. 591/2). - Q: Can a manager vote on his own discharge? A: No. Persons who have taken part in the management of the company in any manner may not vote on resolutions concerning the discharge of managers (TCC art. 619/1). If the quorum is not met once the excluded votes are deducted, the discharge resolution is non-existent (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/560, K. 2025/1186). - Q: Can a resolution be adopted without holding a general assembly meeting? A: Yes. Unless a partner requests oral deliberation, a resolution may be adopted by obtaining the other partners’ written consent to a partner’s proposal on an agenda item; submitting the same proposal to all partners is a condition of validity (TCC art. 617/4). - Q: What happens if a 50–50 company cannot reach a decision? A: Equal votes produce no absolute majority, and the capital majority required for important resolutions cannot be reached with one partner’s vote. If the deadlock persists, actions for dissolution for just cause (TCC art. 636/3) and for withdrawal (TCC art. 638/2) come into play; the provisions requiring a general assembly resolution for an expulsion action in two-partner limited companies were annulled by the Constitutional Court (Constitutional Court, E.2025/128, K.2025/273). - [What a Limited Company Manager Can Do Alone in Türkiye: Authority, Including Selling Company Real Estate](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/limited-company-manager-sole-authority): A Turkish limited company manager decides on management matters not reserved to the general assembly and, if registered with sole signing authority, may alone carry out any transaction within the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/limited-sirket-muduru-tek-basina-hangi-islemleri-yapabilir - Q: Can a limited company manager sign contracts alone? A: Yes; if registered with sole signing authority, the manager may carry out on the company’s behalf any business within the scope of business (TCC art. 371/1). If joint signature has been registered and announced, that limitation is also effective against third parties. - Q: Can the manager sell company real estate without a general assembly resolution? A: For an ordinary sale within the scope of business, a general assembly resolution is not a condition of validity. For a transfer of real estate that would end the company’s activity and lead to its de facto liquidation, however, the Assembly of Civil Chambers requires a general assembly resolution and has held a transfer without one void even where the transferee acted in good faith. - Q: Which decisions are reserved to the general assembly? A: Amending the articles, appointing and removing managers, financial statements and dividends, managers’ remuneration and discharge, approval of share transfers and dissolution are non-transferable powers of the general assembly (TCC art. 616/1). - Q: How do several managers take decisions? A: The managers decide by majority; in a tie the chair of the board of managers has the casting vote, and the articles may provide otherwise (TCC art. 624/3). - Q: What happens if the manager exceeds their authority? A: A manager who culpably breaches their duties is liable to the company, the partners and the company’s creditors (TCC art. 553/1, applicable through TCC art. 644/1-a). The general assembly may remove the manager, and any partner may, for just cause, ask the court to withdraw the manager’s right to manage and power to represent (TCC art. 630). - [When Two Partners of a Company Disagree: 50–50 Deadlock, Withdrawal and Dissolution under Turkish Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/two-partner-company-partners-disagree): If the two partners of a limited company hold equal shares and vote against each other, the general assembly cannot pass resolutions that require a majority and the company is deadlocked. If no share… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/iki-ortakli-sirkette-ortaklar-anlasamazsa - Q: How does the general assembly of a two-partner limited company with equal shares adopt resolutions? A: As a rule, resolutions are adopted by an absolute majority of the votes represented at the meeting (TCC art. 620); if two equal partners vote against each other, no such majority exists. Important resolutions also require an absolute majority of the entire share capital (TCC art. 621/1). - Q: What can a partner do if it wants to leave the company? A: It may transfer its share; the transfer is made in writing with notarised signatures and, unless the articles provide otherwise, requires general assembly approval (TCC art. 595/1-2). Failing agreement it may sue to withdraw for just cause (TCC art. 638/2) and, on leaving, claim a leaving payment corresponding to the real value of its share (TCC art. 641/1). - Q: If a dissolution action is brought, will the company necessarily be wound up? A: No. Instead of dissolution the court may order that the claimant be paid the real value of its share and leave, or another appropriate solution (TCC art. 636/3); in a decision on a joint-stock company the Assembly of Civil Chambers stated that this may be ordered of the court’s own motion even without a request. - Q: Can one partner expel the other in a two-partner company? A: Where there is just cause, expulsion by court order is available (TCC art. 640/3). The Constitutional Court has annulled, for two-partner limited companies, the provisions requiring a general assembly resolution and a qualified majority for this route; the decision was published in the Official Gazette of 17.03.2026. - Q: Is a limited company wound up if one partner leaves? A: No. A limited company may continue with a single partner (TCC art. 573/1); if the number of partners falls to one, the managers are notified within seven days and have the single-partner status registered and announced (TCC art. 574/2). - [When a Company Cannot Pay Its Debts: Capital Loss, Over-Indebtedness and Directors’ Duties under Turkish Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/company-cannot-pay-debts): If the last annual balance sheet shows that half of the total of capital and statutory reserves is no longer covered because of losses, the general assembly must be called immediately. The board of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sermaye-kaybi-ve-borca-batiklikta-yonetici-sorumlulugu - Q: What must be done if half of the capital is lost? A: The board of directors, or in a limited company the managers, must immediately call the general assembly and propose the remedial measures they consider appropriate (Commercial Code art. 376/1, art. 633/1). - Q: Does the company dissolve if two-thirds of the capital is lost? A: Yes, unless the general assembly, convened without delay, resolves to settle for one-third of the capital or to restore it (Commercial Code art. 376/2). - Q: What must a director do if the company is over-indebted? A: Draw up an interim balance sheet and, if the assets do not cover the claims, notify the commercial court where the head office is located and request bankruptcy (Commercial Code art. 376/3). - Q: Can a company creditor sue the manager or a board member? A: For the company’s loss, a creditor may sue only if the company is bankrupt and the bankruptcy administration does not bring the action (Commercial Code art. 556). A loss suffered directly by the creditor is assessed separately (Commercial Code art. 553/1). - Q: Is failing to request the company’s bankruptcy a crime? A: Yes. Persons charged with management and representation, or liquidators, who fail to request bankruptcy are punished upon the complaint of a creditor (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 345/a). - [When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/former-employee-poaching-trade-secrets-unfair-competition): Poaching customers and employees and using trade secrets when a former employee sets up or joins a competing business under Turkish law: unfair competition under Commercial Code art. 55/1-b and d… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/calisan-ve-musteri-ayartma-ticari-sir-haksiz-rekabet - Q: Is it unfair competition under Turkish law for a former employee to set up a company in the same sector? A: The decisions reviewed did not treat this as unfair competition in itself. In an upheld decision, employees who left of their own accord starting work at a competitor for a higher salary was seen as part of the freedom to work; unfair competition required proof of specific conduct such as inducing customers to breach their contracts, systematically poaching employees or unlawfully using trade secrets (Commercial Code art. 55/1-b and d). In one case where the employee, while still employed, set out to exploit the former employer’s customer portfolio for a competitor, unfair competition was found. - Q: Under Turkish law, can a former employee take customers to a new company if the employment contract has no non-compete clause? A: Without a written non-compete clause, a former employee is as a rule free to compete after the contract ends; customers moving of their own choice does not by itself lead to a sanction. However, inducing customers to breach their contracts with the former employer or using unlawfully obtained information may be unfair competition (Commercial Code art. 55/1-b and d). The duty of confidentiality also continues after the contract to the extent necessary (Code of Obligations art. 396). - Q: When is an employee non-compete clause invalid or terminated under Turkish law? A: An employee non-compete clause is not valid if it is not in writing, if the employee cannot obtain knowledge of the customer base, production secrets or the employer’s business, or if the use of that knowledge could not cause the employer significant harm (Code of Obligations art. 444). An excessive restriction may be narrowed by the judge; the duration may not exceed two years save in special circumstances (art. 445). The restriction ends if the employer has no real interest left or if the contract is terminated by the employer without just cause or by the employee for a reason attributable to the employer (art. 447). - Q: Which court hears an action against a former employee for breach of a non-compete clause in Türkiye? A: According to decisions of the Court of Cassation 9th Civil Chamber, the unification decision of 13.06.2025 held commercial courts of first instance competent for breaches of the non-compete obligation occurring after the employment relationship has ended; Commercial Code art. 4/1-c also treats these actions as commercial cases. For a penalty claim arising from a breach while the employment continued, the same Chamber held the labour court competent. - Q: Are agreements between employers not to hire each other’s staff (no-poach or gentlemen’s agreements) lawful in Türkiye? A: The Turkish Competition Board has found agreements between competing employers not to employ each other’s staff contrary to Law No. 4054 art. 4 and, in its decision of 13.04.2023, fined an undertaking; the agreement need not be in writing. According to the Board, in project-based activities a clause limited to the relevant personnel may qualify as an ancillary restraint if it is in writing and also meets conditions such as proportionality, necessity and duration. A Board decision is not a court judgment. - [Which Court Hears Commercial and Consumer Cases in Türkiye: Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/commercial-consumer-court-missing-where-to-sue-turkiye): Under Turkish law, where there is no commercial or consumer court, the civil court of first instance hears commercial and consumer cases in the relevant capacity, and Council of Judges and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ticaret-ve-tuketici-mahkemesi-olmayan-yerlerde-dava-nerede-acilir - Q: Is there a commercial court in Uşak in Türkiye, and where is a commercial case filed in Uşak? A: There is no commercial court in central Uşak. A commercial case is filed with the Uşak civil court of first instance, which hears it in the capacity of a commercial court. Applying the rule of Council of Judges and Prosecutors Decision No. 1235 to today's six civil courts, courts Nos. 5 and 6 hear these cases; since the decision named court No. 4 for Uşak at the time, the number should be confirmed with the allocation office. - Q: Is there a consumer court in Kütahya in Türkiye, and where is a consumer case filed in Kütahya? A: According to the Kütahya Courthouse's 2025 activity report, there is no consumer court in the provincial centre. A consumer case is filed with the Kütahya civil court of first instance, which hears it in the capacity of a consumer court. Applying the rule of Council of Judges and Prosecutors Decision No. 1236 to today's four courts points to court No. 4; the number should be confirmed with the courthouse's allocation office. Depending on the amount, the consumer arbitration committee or mediation may have to come first. - Q: Which court hears consumer cases in Manisa and Muğla in Türkiye? A: The provincial centres of Manisa and Muğla have a commercial court but no consumer court. Consumer cases are heard by the civil court of first instance in the capacity of a consumer court. In central Manisa, applying the rule of Decision No. 1236 to today's five courts points to court No. 4, to be confirmed with the courthouse's allocation office; in central Muğla two civil courts are listed, so the decision's numbering rule does not apply. - Q: Is there a commercial court in Afyonkarahisar in Türkiye, and which court hears commercial cases in Afyonkarahisar? A: Central Afyonkarahisar has a consumer court but no commercial court. Commercial cases are heard by the civil court of first instance in the capacity of a commercial court; applying the rule of Council of Judges and Prosecutors Decision No. 1235 to today's six courts points to courts Nos. 5 and 6; the number should be confirmed with the courthouse's allocation office. Consumer cases are filed with the Afyonkarahisar Consumer Court. - Q: Under Turkish law, where there is no commercial court, is a commercial case filed with the civil court without stating its capacity dismissed for lack of jurisdiction? A: No. Under article 5(4) of the Turkish Commercial Code, in a judicial district without a commercial court the fact that the jurisdiction rule was not invoked does not require a decision of lack of jurisdiction; the civil court continues with the case. The court must, however, hear the case in the capacity of a commercial court; the Court of Cassation listed omitting this capacity among the reversal grounds in one decision and merely criticised it in another. - [Wrong Article in Minutes Alone Does Not Prove No Call: Turkish Court of Cassation on Uncalled Assemblies](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/general-assembly-without-a-call-minutes-wrong-article): Under Turkish law, according to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a statement in the general assembly minutes that the meeting was held under Article 370 of the former Commercial Code… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/genel-kurul-tutanaginda-yanlis-madde-cagrisiz-genel-kurul-saymaya-yetmez - Q: What are the conditions of a general assembly without a call? A: The holders or representatives of all shares must be present and none of them may object; in that case the meeting may be held without observing the calling procedure, and resolutions may be adopted as long as the meeting quorum exists. Items may be added to the agenda only unanimously (Turkish Commercial Code art. 416). - Q: Does a statement in the minutes that the meeting was held under Article 370 of the Commercial Code make it a general assembly without a call? A: According to the Chamber in this decision, not on its own. If the meeting was held under Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, it must be taken into account that the reference to an article of the former code is based on a material error, and whether a call was made must be examined. - Q: What happens to the resolutions if a shareholder does not attend a general assembly without a call? A: In this case the first-instance court and the regional court of appeal had held that the resolutions were non-existent because two shareholders were not present. The Chamber did not discuss that principle; it required first a determination of whether the meeting was in fact held without a call. - Q: How is it shown that the general assembly was called? A: The call is made in the manner set out in the articles of association, by an announcement on the company’s website and in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette at least two weeks before the meeting; a registered letter with return receipt is sent to shareholders registered in the share ledger and to shareholders who have notified their addresses by previously giving the company share certificates or documents proving their shareholding (Turkish Commercial Code art. 414(1)). These announcement and mailing records are the documents of the call. - Q: Did this decision bring the case to an end? A: No. The decision is a reversal; the file was sent to the first-instance court. The court will decide again after assessing the defence that the meeting was held with a call. - [İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, Türkiye: Jurisdiction (İzmir, Aydın, Manisa), Appeal Procedure, Time Limits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/izmir-regional-court-appeal-jurisdiction-turkiye): The İzmir Regional Court of Appeal hears appeals against civil and criminal court decisions given in İzmir, Aydın and Manisa. This article explains, under Turkish law and with statutory texts and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/izmir-bolge-adliye-mahkemesi-yargi-cevresi-istinaf - Q: Which court hears an appeal against a civil court decision given in Aydın, Türkiye? A: The appellate court is the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal. The petition is not taken to İzmir; it is lodged with the Aydın court that gave the decision or with another local court, and the court that gave the decision sends the file to the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal (Code of Civil Procedure art. 343). - Q: Where is the appellate court for decisions of the courts in Manisa, Türkiye? A: The province of Manisa lies within the jurisdiction of the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal; for decisions of civil and criminal courts, the appeal is reviewed by the relevant chamber of that court in İzmir. For decisions of the administrative and tax courts in Manisa the appellate court is different: the İzmir Regional Administrative Court. - Q: What is the time limit for an appeal to the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal in Türkiye? A: In civil cases it is two weeks from proper service of the decision (Code of Civil Procedure art. 345); time limits in special statutes are reserved. In criminal cases, for decisions given on or after 01.06.2024, it is two weeks from service of the judgment together with its reasons (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 273(1)). - Q: Do court decisions given in Muğla and Uşak still go to the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal in Türkiye? A: No. Muğla and Uşak were brought within the jurisdiction of the Denizli Regional Court of Appeal, which, as recounted in a Court of Cassation decision, began operating on 02.09.2024. Appeals against decisions given before that date, and files previously reviewed by the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal, nevertheless stay in İzmir (Law No. 5235, additional art. 1). - Q: If a petition of appeal against a decision given in Aydın or Manisa, Türkiye, names the wrong chamber or a different regional court of appeal, is the appeal invalid? A: No, it is not invalid if it was made in time. In civil cases the file is sent to the relevant regional court of appeal without being bound by the chamber indicated in the petition (Code of Civil Procedure art. 343(4)), and if the review must be carried out by another regional court of appeal this is decided at the preliminary examination (art. 352). In criminal cases an error as to the competent authority does not extinguish the applicant's rights (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 264). - Q: Is an appeal against an administrative or tax court decision in İzmir, Türkiye, lodged with the İzmir Regional Court of Appeal? A: No. Except for decisions the statute makes final or excludes from appeal, an appeal against a decision of an administrative or tax court is lodged with the regional administrative court within thirty days of service of the decision (Administrative Procedure Act art. 45(1)). For İzmir, Aydın and Manisa that court is the İzmir Regional Administrative Court. ### Work Accident Compensation Law - [Calculation of Work-Accident Compensation (Actuarial Method)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/calculation-work-accident-compensation): Actuarial calculation of permanent-incapacity and loss-of-support compensation in work accidents; TRH 2010 life table, active/passive and known/unknown periods, 10% increase-discount, fault… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-16; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/is-kazasi-tazminatinin-hesaplanmasi-akturyal - Q: SGK granted me income; can I also claim from the employer? A: Yes. For the part of the damage not covered by the SGK income, you may bring a pecuniary compensation action against the employer. - Q: Which life table is used in the calculation? A: The Court of Cassation has adopted the TRH 2010 National Mortality Table, which contains current data specific to Türkiye. - Q: What do active and passive periods mean? A: The active period is calculated, as a rule, until age 60 on real income; the passive period after 60, over remaining life, on the minimum wage. - Q: Does my own fault affect the compensation? A: Yes. Compensation is reduced in proportion to your contributory fault; the judge sets it considering the gravity of fault (TCO Arts. 51-52). - Q: Is all SGK income deducted from the compensation? A: No. Only the recourse-eligible portion of the first capital value of the granted income is deducted; non-recoverable payments cannot be deducted (TCO Art. 55). - Q: What is the limitation period for work-accident compensation? A: As it rests on the employer's breach of the contractual duty of care, a ten-year limitation period applies as a rule (TCO Art. 146). - [Damages in Fatal Work Accidents: Calculating Loss-of-Support Compensation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/damages-fatal-work-accidents): A guide to damages in fatal work accidents under Turkish law: who may claim loss-of-support compensation; heads of loss (TCO art. 53); actuarial principles - the TRH 2010 mortality table, support… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-02; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/olumlu-is-kazasinda-tazminat-hesabi - Q: Who may claim damages after a fatal work accident? A: Those actually supported by the deceased, or who would in all likelihood have been supported — in practice the spouse, children and parents. Non-pecuniary damages may be claimed by the spouse, children, parents and siblings. Heirship is not required. - Q: How are loss-of-support damages calculated? A: Actuarially, on the deceased’s real income: actual data for the known period and the TRH 2010 mortality table for remaining life expectancy. After a personal share for the deceased, the remainder is apportioned to the spouse and children; fault reduction and deduction of the recourse-eligible portion of the SSI income follow. - Q: Is the SSI survivor’s income deducted from the damages? A: Only the recourse-eligible portion of the initial capitalised value of the granted income is deducted. Non-recourse social security payments may not be deducted (TCO art. 55). - Q: Is mediation mandatory, and which court is competent? A: No; actions for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages arising from work accidents, and the related determination, objection and recourse actions, are exempt from mandatory mediation (Law No. 7036 art. 3/3). The action is brought before the labour court, or the civil court of first instance sitting in that capacity. - Q: What is the prescription period? A: Claims against the employer are, as a rule, subject to a ten-year period from the date of the accident (TCO art. 146). Different or extended periods may apply to third parties or where the act is also a criminal offence; verify for the specific case. - Q: How are non-pecuniary damages assessed? A: By reference to the date of the accident, the parties’ social and economic circumstances, the purchasing power of money, the degrees of fault and the intensity of grief; the award must not enrich but must provide solace, assessed on equity (TCO art. 56). - [From PMF 1931 to TRH 2010: The Life Table in Bodily Injury and Loss-of-Support Damages under Turkish Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pmf-1931-to-trh-2010-life-table-compensation): The life table that fixes remaining life expectancy in bodily injury and loss-of-support damages under Turkish law: the chronology of the move from PMF 1931 to TRH 2010 in work-accident and traffic… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/pmf-1931-den-trh-2010-a-tazminat-hesabinda-yasam-tablosu - Q: What is the difference between PMF 1931 and TRH 2010? A: PMF 1931 is a table built from French population data of 1931 that draws no distinction between women and men; it puts the average life expectancy of a newborn at 56.64 years. TRH 2010 was prepared from Turkish data separately for women and men (for a newborn, 78.02 years for women and 71.93 for men). Remaining life expectancy is shorter under PMF 1931. - Q: Which life table is used in damages calculations today? A: Under Turkish law, the Court of Cassation as a rule applies TRH 2010 in work-accident, traffic-accident and other tort cases. The exceptions are certain older traffic accidents, vested procedural rights and a party’s express request. - Q: Does PMF 1931 apply to accidents before 2012? A: There is no fixed threshold. The Assembly of Civil Chambers applied PMF 1931 by majority to a traffic accident of 18.11.2010; the “PMF before 2012, TRH after” formula appears in the dissenting opinion. In work-accident cases TRH 2010 has also been applied to incidents of 2009 and 2010. - Q: Does the date of a work accident affect the choice of table? A: The decisions examined draw no distinction by date of incident in work-accident cases; PMF 1931 was applied only where a vested procedural right existed. - Q: What happens if an earlier report in the file used PMF 1931? A: Judgments based on PMF 1931 reports are, as a rule, reversed; however, where a vested procedural right has arisen in favour of the other party regarding that report, that limit is observed. For this reason the 10th Civil Chamber, in its decision of 17.12.2024, relied on the amount in the PMF 1931 report. - Q: Is the 1.8% technical interest rate still applied? A: After the Constitutional Court’s decision of 17.07.2020 (E. 2019/40, K. 2020/40), the chambers of the Court of Cassation no longer apply the 1.8% technical interest rate and have the future period calculated with the progressive annuity (10% increase, 10% discount). A 1.8% calculation that has created a vested procedural right may be preserved. - [SGK Recourse Against Employers for Work Accidents in Türkiye: Conditions, Fault, Amount and Limitation Period](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/sgk-recourse-action-employer-work-accident): Under Turkish law, where a work accident results from the employer’s intent or from a breach of occupational safety legislation, the SGK claims from the employer the payments it has made and the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/is-kazasinda-sgk-nin-isverene-rucu-davasi - Q: Under what conditions can the SGK bring a recourse action against the employer after a work accident in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, the SGK may have recourse against the employer if the work accident occurred as a result of the employer’s intent or of an act contrary to the legislation on the protection of insured persons’ health and on occupational safety (Law No. 5510 art. 21/1). The principle of unavoidability is taken into account in determining the employer’s liability. The 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation has defined this principle as situations and consequences that are impossible to prevent even where the measures prescribed by the legislation have been taken (in a recourse action concerning an occupational disease). If the insured person was not notified to the Institution in time, these grounds of liability are not required (art. 23). - Q: What is the limit on the amount the SGK can claim from the employer in a recourse action under Turkish law? A: Under Turkish law, the employer is asked for the payments made and to be made by the Institution and the initial capitalised value of the income awarded, as at the date the income started; this total is limited to the amount the insured person or the beneficiaries could claim from the employer (Law No. 5510 art. 21/1). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, the court calculates both the Institution’s expenditure (inner ceiling) and the real damage (outer ceiling), takes the lower and, as a rule, applies the degree of fault. Against a third party at fault, recourse is based on half of the initial capitalised value (art. 21/4). - Q: What is the limitation period for an SGK recourse action arising from a work accident in Türkiye, and when does it start? A: Under Turkish law, actions for compensation and recourse brought by the Institution on the basis of Law No. 5510 are subject to a ten-year limitation period (art. 93/3). The period starts from the Institution’s approval date for the income and pensions that are the subject of recourse, and from the date of the expense or payment for expenses and payments; it does not start from the date of the accident. In a 2024 decision the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation treated as a ground for reversal the dismissal of an action on the basis of a limitation objection raised not during the proceedings but for the first time in the appeal petition. - Q: Does the fault report in the worker’s compensation action bind the SGK’s recourse action under Turkish law? A: Under Turkish law it does not bind as conclusive evidence, but it is strong evidence. In its decision of 20.05.2026 (by majority on this issue) the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation stated that, because the subject matter and the parties of the two actions are not the same, the fault report in the compensation action cannot be regarded as conclusive evidence in the recourse action, but will constitute strong evidence. If the reports contradict each other, the compensation file is obtained and the contradiction is resolved by a new expert panel report. According to the same decision, to whom fault belongs and in what proportion requires special and technical knowledge; the court cannot determine it of its own motion by setting the expert reports aside. - Q: If a worker whose employment entry declaration was not filed in time has a work accident in Türkiye, is the employer liable to the SGK even without fault? A: Yes, under Turkish law the employer is liable if the insured employment entry declaration was not filed in time. Under Law No. 5510 art. 23, in that case the expenses incurred and to be incurred by the Institution and the initial capitalised value of the income awarded are collected from the employer without the grounds of liability in art. 21/1 being required. In a 2021 decision the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation treated this as strict liability and stated that a real-damage ceiling calculation is not mandatory and that the Institution’s loss is determined by making an equitable reduction of not less than fifty per cent of the insured person’s fault. - Q: Which court hears the SGK’s recourse action against the employer in Türkiye, and is mediation mandatory? A: Under Turkish law the action is heard by the labour court. Disputes arising from the application of Law No. 5510 are resolved by the labour courts unless the Law provides otherwise (art. 101); Law No. 7036 also assigns to the labour court, apart from the listed exceptions, disputes arising from labour and social security legislation to which the SGK is a party (art. 5/1-b). The court with venue is the court of the defendant’s domicile or of the place where the work or transaction was performed (art. 6). In recourse actions arising from a work accident, applying to a mediator is not a condition for bringing the action (art. 3/3). - [Work Accidents in Turkish Mines and Marble Quarries: Liability of Employer, Subcontractor, Licence Holder](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/mine-quarry-work-accident-liability-turkiye): Under Turkish law: liability of the employer, subcontractor, royalty operator and licence holder for work accidents in mines and marble and travertine quarries; joint and several liability, the fault… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/maden-ve-mermer-ocaginda-is-kazasi-sorumluluk - Q: I work for a subcontractor in a marble quarry. From whom can I claim damages? A: Under Turkish law, you may claim from your own employer (the subcontractor) and from the principal employer operating the quarry, jointly or separately. By statute the principal employer is liable together with the subcontractor (Labour Act No. 4857 art. 2); the Court of Cassation treats this liability as joint and several and accepts an action against both or only one (10th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/5939). - Q: Can the licence holder also be held liable? A: Where a royalty (rödovans) contract exists, liability arising from the Labour Act and occupational health and safety rests, as a rule, with the operator; the licence holder’s liability under the Mining Law remains (Law No. 3213 additional art. 7). The Court of Cassation requires an inquiry into whether the licence holder acted beyond the royalty arrangement and an assessment of its status as principal employer and its fault. - Q: How is the degree of fault determined? A: The court obtains a report from an expert panel familiar with the branch of work and with occupational health and safety rules. The report must discuss which measure had to be taken by whom and whether the worker complied, and resolve any conflict with the SSI inspection report. - Q: What is the time limit for bringing an action? A: Claims against the employer and the principal employer are subject to the ten-year limitation period (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 146). According to the Court of Cassation, the period runs from the date on which the permanent incapacity rate is definitively determined. For persons with no employment relationship, the tort limitation period (TCO art. 72) applies. - Q: Is mediation required before a work accident damages action? A: No. Under Turkish law, mediation is not a precondition to suit for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages arising from a work accident (Labour Courts Law No. 7036 art. 3/3). - [Work-Accident Compensation: Your Rights and Legal Remedies](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/work-accident-compensation): The pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages and loss-of-support compensation a worker and their relatives may claim after a work accident — employer liability, unavoidability, competent court, limitation… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-12; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/is-kazasi-tazminati-haklar-ve-hukuki-yollar - Q: Is an SSI income award required to claim work-accident compensation? A: No. The recoverable portion of the first capitalised value of any SSI income is deducted from the award, but this does not bar a claim. A pecuniary and non-pecuniary action may be brought against the employer for the loss not covered by the Institution. - Q: Which court hears a work-accident case? A: Labour courts have jurisdiction. As a rule the competent court is that of the defendant's domicile or of the place of the workplace. - Q: What is the limitation period for work-accident compensation? A: As a rule, ten years from the date of the event. Where the act also constitutes a criminal offence carrying a longer period, the extended (criminal) limitation period applies. - Q: Can I increase the non-pecuniary compensation later? A: Non-pecuniary compensation is indivisible and must, as a rule, be claimed fully and at once. Determining the claim correctly when filing is therefore very important. - Q: Does the employer still pay if the accident was entirely unavoidable? A: Yes, in part. The Court of Cassation allocates part of the loss to the employer even in wholly unavoidable accidents, by virtue of the social-state principle and the protection of the worker. - Q: From when does interest run? A: Interest runs from the date of the accident giving rise to the compensation; the same start date applies to amounts increased by amendment of the claim. ### Traffic Accident Compensation Law - [Claiming from the Guarantee Fund in Türkiye: Uninsured, Hit-and-Run or Stolen Vehicles (Law 5684 Art. 14)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/guarantee-fund-claim-uninsured-hit-and-run-vehicle-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a claim may be made to the Guarantee Fund for bodily harm caused by an uninsured, unidentified or stolen vehicle; the Fund pays up to the cover amounts and, according to Court of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/guvence-hesabina-basvuru-sigortasiz-veya-kacan-aracin-verdigi-zarar - Q: In which cases can a claim be made to the Guarantee Fund under Turkish law? A: Under Turkish law, for traffic accidents a claim may be made to the Guarantee Fund for bodily harm where the vehicle involved cannot be identified, where it has no compulsory traffic insurance, or where it was stolen or seized and the keeper cannot be held liable (Law No. 5684 art. 14/2). Where the insurance company is bankrupt or its licence in all branches is revoked, a claim may be made for property and bodily losses. The Regulation also allows a claim for the difference between the policy cover and the compulsory cover. - Q: What must be proven to obtain compensation from the Guarantee Fund in Türkiye when a hit-and-run vehicle causes injury? A: A person claiming from the Guarantee Fund for harm caused by a hit-and-run vehicle in Türkiye must, as a rule, prove that the injury resulted from a traffic accident involving a motor vehicle. In its 2026 decision the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers found the police statement taken immediately after the event and the hospital and medical records sufficient for this. Since, according to Court of Cassation decisions, the Fund is liable in proportion to the keeper’s fault, fault is also determined separately. - Q: Is a written application to the Guarantee Fund mandatory in Türkiye before bringing a court action? A: Yes; under Turkish law, Law No. 2918 art. 97 requires, for claims within the limits of compulsory traffic insurance, a written application to the relevant insurance institution before a court action or arbitration and the fifteen-day reply period to be awaited. In a 2021 decision the Court of Cassation’s 17th Civil Chamber applied this requirement to a claim against the Guarantee Fund, holding that the defect does not lead to immediate dismissal and that the claimant must be given a final time limit to apply. - Q: What is the limitation period for a compensation claim against the Guarantee Fund under Turkish law? A: Under Turkish law, a compensation claim against the Guarantee Fund is, as a rule, time-barred two years from learning of the loss and the person liable to pay and, in any event, ten years from the accident (Law No. 2918 art. 109). If the accident is also a crime and the criminal law provides a longer limitation period, that longer period applies; the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers has not required a criminal case to have been brought, and the 17th Civil Chamber has applied the extended period in an action against the Guarantee Fund. - Q: From whom does the Guarantee Fund in Türkiye claim back the compensation it has paid? A: Under Turkish law, for compensation it has paid, the Guarantee Fund may seek recourse against the keeper who did not take out compulsory insurance, persons liable for the loss, a liable person who is identified later, or the obliged insurance company (Guarantee Fund Regulation art. 16/1). In a 2024 decision the Court of Cassation’s 4th Civil Chamber accepted that, if the driver at fault has died, the Fund may also seek recourse against the driver’s heirs. - Q: Does the Guarantee Fund in Türkiye pay for car damage caused by an uninsured or hit-and-run vehicle? A: As a rule, no. Under Turkish law, Law No. 5684 art. 14/2 lists only bodily harm for losses caused by uninsured, unidentified or stolen vehicles; property loss is listed for the insurer’s bankruptcy or the revocation of its licence in all branches. The Law gives the President power to decide on damage to property; whether such a decision exists should be checked separately. - [Contributory Fault Need Not Cut Non-Pecuniary Damages: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/contributory-fault-non-pecuniary-damages-reduction): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held by majority that a claimant’s own fault in a tort causing serious injury does not automatically require a reduction of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/zarar-gorenin-kusuru-manevi-tazminattan-indirimi-zorunlu-kilmaz - Q: Are non-pecuniary damages reduced where there is contributory fault? A: Under Turkish law, not automatically. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the injured party’s fault is one of the factors the judge takes into account in assessing non-pecuniary damages; having taken that fault into account, the judge may still find the amount claimed appropriate. - Q: Does the fault reduction applied to pecuniary damages also apply to non-pecuniary damages? A: According to the Assembly, it need not be carried over as a percentage. In this case the claimant’s 20% fault was taken as the basis in calculating pecuniary damages, whereas the full amount of non-pecuniary damages claimed was awarded, and the Assembly upheld that outcome. - Q: What happens if a claimant who said they were not at fault is later found at fault? A: According to the Assembly, the assertion of no fault by a claimant who cannot know the degrees of fault in advance is general and abstract; a later finding that the claimant was at fault does not change the relief sought, but it may influence the judge’s discretion. - Q: Can the judge award more non-pecuniary damages than claimed? A: No. Under Code of Civil Procedure art. 26, the judge is bound by the relief sought; the Assembly also referred to the claimant’s claim as the upper limit for non-pecuniary damages. - Q: Is this decision final? A: Yes. The decision of resistance was upheld by majority and with final effect. The dissenting opinion concerns not the merits but the preliminary issue of whether the decision could be appealed in view of the amount. - [Damages in Fatal Traffic Accidents: Loss of Support and Calculation Principles](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/damages-fatal-traffic-accidents): A guide to damages in fatal traffic accidents under Turkish law: the operator's strict liability and the chain of liable parties; the independent nature of loss-of-support claims and the effect of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-02; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/olumlu-trafik-kazasinda-tazminat-hesabi - Q: Who can be sued after a fatal traffic accident? A: The at-fault driver, the vehicle’s operator/owner (strict liability), the compulsory motor liability insurer (within policy limits) and, where the vehicle is uninsured or unidentified, the Guarantee Account. Non-pecuniary damages fall outside the insurance cover. - Q: Does the deceased driver’s own fault defeat the relatives’ claim? A: Loss-of-support damages are an independent right arising in the claimant’s own person. For policies issued after 01.06.2015, support claims corresponding to the provider’s fault are excluded, and the Assembly of Civil Chambers held that the relatives of a fully at-fault driver-provider cannot claim from the insurer; for earlier policies it held the claim to be within the cover. - Q: How are the damages calculated? A: Actuarially, on the deceased’s real income, with remaining life expectancy under the TRH 2010 table, without technical interest, using the progressive annuity formula; support shares are apportioned, contributory fault is deducted and payments received are set off. - Q: Must I apply to the insurance company before suing? A: Yes. A written application to the insurer is a prerequisite (HTC art. 97). If the insurer does not respond within 15 days or the response does not satisfy the claim, you may sue or apply to the Insurance Arbitration Commission. - Q: Which court is competent? A: Liability actions under the Highway Traffic Code are heard by the civil judiciary (art. 110): the civil court of first instance for claims against the driver and operator, and the commercial court of first instance where the insurer is sued. Venue lies with the courts of the accident place, the defendant’s domicile or the insurer’s branch/agency. - Q: What is the limitation period? A: Two years from knowledge and in any event ten years (art. 109/1). In fatal accidents the extended criminal period applies: as a rule 15 years (negligent homicide) where a third party died; 8 years in current case law where only the driver-provider died in a single-vehicle accident. Verify on the facts. - [Knee Pads Not Required, No Contributory Fault Reduction: Turkish Court of Cassation on a Motorcyclist](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/motorcycle-knee-pads-contributory-fault-reduction): Under Turkish law, the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that, because the Highway Traffic Regulation does not regulate knee pads as mandatory protective equipment for… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/motosiklet-surucusunun-dizlik-takmamasi-muterafik-kusur-indirimi-sebebi-degildir - Q: Is a motorcyclist’s compensation reduced if they did not wear knee pads? A: Under Turkish law, the reduction was not upheld in this decision. The 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation found the 20% reduction for contributory fault, based on the failure to use knee pads, erroneous because the Highway Traffic Regulation does not regulate knee pads as mandatory protective equipment for motorcycle drivers. In a 2022 reversal decision, however, the Chamber had required a 20% reduction in this situation; the date of the decision relied on should be borne in mind. - Q: What protective equipment is mandatory for a motorcycle driver? A: The text of the Regulation in force at the time of the accident, as quoted by the Chamber, listed a protective helmet and protective goggles for the driver and a protective helmet for passengers. The current text, following the amendment of 4.11.2025, also lists protective gloves for motorcycle drivers and passengers carried; knee pads do not appear in the current text either. - Q: Is it not enough that the injury was to the knee? A: It was not considered enough in this decision. The Objection Arbitration Panel had relied on the injury being to the knee; the Chamber, however, found the reduction erroneous because knee pads are not regulated as mandatory protective equipment in the Regulation. - Q: Is not wearing a helmet always a ground for reduction? A: This decision made no ruling on helmets. Code of Obligations art. 52/1 makes a reduction depend on the injured party having contributed to the occurrence or increase of the loss; so even where mandatory equipment was not used, the effect of the omission on the actual injury is assessed separately. - [Rights in a Property-Damage Traffic Accident](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/rights-property-damage-traffic-accident): A comprehensive guide to the injured party's rights in a property-damage traffic accident: the claimable losses (repair cost, diminished value, replacement vehicle/loss of use, loss of earnings… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-26; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/maddi-hasarli-trafik-kazasinda-haklar - Q: Besides the repair cost, what else can I claim in a property-damage accident? A: In addition to the repair cost, you may claim the diminished value remaining in your vehicle, the replacement (rental) vehicle or loss-of-use cost for the period the vehicle is under repair, loss of earnings for a commercial vehicle, and necessary expenses such as towing and appraisal. If the vehicle is an economic total loss, the loss is the difference between the market value and the salvage value. - Q: From whom do I claim the vehicle's diminished value? A: Diminished value may be claimed from the driver at fault, the vehicle's operator, and their compulsory traffic insurer (limited to the policy limit). If the application to the insurer is rejected, you may go to court or to the Insurance Arbitration Commission. - Q: How is diminished value calculated? A: According to the Court of Cassation's criterion, diminished value is the difference between the vehicle's undamaged second-hand market value at the accident date and its second-hand value after repair. The calculation takes into account the vehicle's make, model, age, mileage, the extent of the damage and any prior damage; an expert (mechanical engineer) report is therefore required. - Q: Must I apply to the insurance company before suing? A: Yes. Before bringing an action against the compulsory financial-liability (traffic) insurer, making a written application to the insurance company is a condition of the action. If the insurer does not reply within 15 days or its reply does not meet the claim, you may sue or apply to the Insurance Arbitration Commission (Art. 97). - Q: What if the other party has no traffic insurance or fled the scene? A: For bodily injury caused by uninsured or untraced (hit-and-run) vehicles, the Assurance Account comes into play; for property (material) losses the Assurance Account's liability is limited. In that case compensation is sought primarily from the driver and operator at fault; the specific situation must be assessed separately. - Q: What is the limitation period for a compensation claim? A: For property losses, as a rule, a two-year period from learning of the loss and the person liable, and in any event a ten-year period from the day of the accident, applies. If the accident also constitutes a crime and the criminal law provides a longer period, this extended (criminal) limitation also applies to property compensation (Art. 109). - [Vehicle Diminished-Value Compensation: How to Claim It After a Traffic Accident under Turkish Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/vehicle-diminished-value-traffic-accident): Who pays for your vehicle's loss of value after a no-fault accident (operator, driver, traffic insurer), within what period and how — application, insurance arbitration and Court of Cassation… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-15; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/trafik-kazasi-arac-deger-kaybi-tazminati - Q: From whom can I claim diminished value? A: From the operator and driver of the at-fault vehicle, and from that vehicle's compulsory traffic insurer within the policy limit. They are jointly and severally liable. - Q: Does my kasko policy cover diminished value? A: As a rule, no. Diminished value is outside kasko cover; it falls under the other party's compulsory traffic insurance and the operator/driver's liability. - Q: Must I apply to the insurer before suing? A: Yes. A written application to the compulsory traffic insurer is required before suit/arbitration; if no positive result follows within 15 days, you may sue or apply to the Insurance Arbitration Commission. - Q: How is diminished value calculated? A: An expert, considering make, model, age, mileage and damage, determines the difference between the undamaged pre-accident second-hand value and the post-repair second-hand value. - Q: Is diminished value available in every accident? A: No. The other party must be at fault and the repair economical; in a total loss or minor repairs not affecting value, diminished value may not arise. - Q: What is the limitation period? A: Two years from learning of the damage and the liable party, and in any event ten years from the accident; an extended criminal limitation period may apply where the act is an offence. ### Customs Law - [Additional Customs Assessment and Penalty (VEZA) Decisions: Objection and Grounds for Annulment](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/additional-customs-assessment-penalty-decisions): A comprehensive guide to additional customs assessment and penalty (VEZA) decisions: what additional assessment is and how it arises (post-clearance control; differences in customs value, tariff and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/gumrukte-ek-tahakkuk-ve-ceza-karari - Q: What does a VEZA decision mean? A: In practice the additional assessment (tax) and penalty decision that the customs administration notifies together is called, in short, a “VEZA” (tax and penalty) decision. The under-collected customs duty is demanded by additional assessment, and the related fine is imposed by the penalty decision. - Q: Can I bring an action directly against the additional-assessment and penalty decision? A: No. The administrative objection route under CL Art. 242 must first be exhausted within 15 days of notification. Only upon rejection of the objection may an action for annulment be brought in the tax court. - Q: What is the time bar for additional assessment? A: The additional assessment must be notified within three years of the date the customs obligation arose (as a rule, the registration of the declaration). An additional assessment notified after that period is time-barred and must be annulled. - Q: What is the relationship between settlement and the action period? A: A settlement request is made within 15 days of notification and suspends the objection/action period. If settlement is reached, the matters settled cannot be made the subject of an action; if not, the period resumes. - Q: On what grounds can an additional assessment be annulled? A: The principal grounds: the passing of the three-year time bar, defective/incomplete notification, determination of the customs value contrary to the methods of Arts. 23-31, non-fulfilment of the penalty conditions (e.g. Art. 234/1-b), and matters relating to the reservation and the binding nature of the declaration. - Q: In which court are customs disputes heard? A: The action for annulment is brought in the tax court; the appeal in the tax chamber of the regional administrative court, and cassation before the 7th Chamber of the Council of State. - [Foreign-Plated Cars in Türkiye: Exceeding the Time Limit, Temporary Import, Duties, Penalties, Objections](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/foreign-plated-car-turkiye-time-limit-customs): Under Turkish law, the foreign-plated private car brought to Türkiye by a person living abroad: the 185-day residence condition and the twenty-four-month period (Decision No. 2009/15481), letting… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yabanci-plakali-arac-sure-asimi-ve-gumruk - Q: How long may my foreign-plated car stay in Türkiye? A: Decision No. 2009/15481 grants private land vehicles twenty-four months and the vehicles of persons retired abroad two years; under certain conditions, residents of the EU, EFTA and the United Kingdom are granted one month once a year. For current periods, the announcements of the Ministry of Trade should be checked. - Q: May my relative in Türkiye drive my car? A: Only with your permission, not continuously, and while you are in Türkiye (Decision art. 18). Letting others use it while you are abroad breaches the regime; taxes are claimed, the article 238 fine is imposed and the driver may also be fined. - Q: May I leave the car in Türkiye and fly back? A: Before departure you must give the customs authority an undertaking that the car will not be used by others. Leaving without the car and without informing customs attracts an irregularity fine under art. 241/6-e; provisional art. 11 extends this to departures before 2022. - Q: I exceeded the period; what do I have to pay? A: Customs duty, special consumption tax and VAT are claimed by additional assessment and a fine of one quarter of the customs duties is imposed (art. 238/1-b). If the vehicle was taken out within three months after the period ended, an irregularity fine applies instead (art. 241/5-b). - Q: How do I object to the penalty decision? A: Within fifteen days of service, an objection is filed by petition with the higher authority or, if there is none, with the same authority (art. 242). If the objection is rejected, an action is brought before the tax court within thirty days (Administrative Procedure Law art. 7). - Q: What if the decision was served by public notice without reaching me? A: Service by public notice without researching the foreign address is defective; this was accepted in the decision upheld by the 7th Chamber. Where notice is given by publication, the time limit for the action starts fifteen days after the day following the last publication date (Administrative Procedure Law art. 7/3). - [Seized Goods and Vehicles in Smuggling Cases in Türkiye: Release, Confiscation, Objection (Law No. 5607)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/seized-vehicles-goods-smuggling-law-5607-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a vehicle used in a smuggling offence is, as a rule, seized by an annotation on its register; a vehicle impounded in one of three cases is returned if security equal to its value… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kacakcilikta-el-konulan-esya-ve-tasit-5607-sayili-kanun - Q: How can a vehicle seized in a smuggling case in Türkiye be recovered against security? A: Under Turkish law (Law No. 5607 art. 10/2), an impounded vehicle is returned if the owner delivers security equal to the vehicle’s value (for a land vehicle, its comprehensive insurance value) to the customs administration within thirty days of the date of impoundment; otherwise it is liquidated without waiting for the outcome of the proceedings. Impoundment is possible in only three cases: a hidden compartment, a vehicle not registered in Türkiye, or repeated use for smuggling while proceedings are pending. In other cases the rule is an annotation on the register. - Q: When is a vehicle carrying smuggled goods confiscated under Law No. 5607 in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, confiscation of the vehicle requires one of the three conditions in art. 13/1: the smuggled goods were carried in a hidden compartment; the goods form the whole or the predominant part of the vehicle’s load, or their carriage requires the use of that vehicle; or the goods are prohibited from entering or leaving Türkiye or are harmful to public or environmental health. In addition, the vehicle must not belong to a bona fide third party. The court may refrain from confiscation where it would be inequitable in relation to the offence (Turkish Criminal Code arts. 54/1 and 54/3). - Q: Is a vehicle used for smuggling confiscated under Turkish law if it belongs to someone else? A: As a rule, no, if the vehicle belongs to a bona fide third party: under Turkish law, art. 54/1 of the Criminal Code makes confiscation conditional on the property not belonging to a bona fide third party. In 2024 the 7th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld, having regard also to the goods not forming the predominant part of the load and to equity, a decision not to confiscate a company-owned tractor unit in which the driver carried smuggled cigarettes. In 2017 the Constitutional Court held that continuing to impound a coach after the good faith of its owner and of its financial lessee had been established violated the right to property. The outcome may differ where the vehicle belonged to the defendant at the offence date and was sold later; a 2026 decision of the same Chamber then referred to confiscation of the insurance value. - Q: If the defendant is acquitted in a smuggling case in Türkiye, are the proceeds of liquidated goods returned? A: Yes, if return is ordered. Under Turkish law (Law No. 5607 art. 16/2), the sale proceeds are paid to the right holder with statutory interest for the period from the date of seizure to the date of return; if the goods were destroyed, their value is paid from the general budget. In a 2025 decision the 12th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation accepted that, where the sale proceeds fall below the market price of the goods at the date of seizure, the difference may be claimed in an action for compensation for protective measures. In one decision, however, the 7th Criminal Chamber removed the reference to interest from the criminal court’s judgment without stating why. - Q: How and within what time can a seizure decision in a smuggling investigation be challenged under Turkish law? A: Under Turkish law, a person whose property has been seized may at any time ask the judge for a decision on the matter (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 127/4) and may request its return (art. 131). An objection against the judge’s seizure decision or a judge’s refusal of a request for return is made to the authority that gave the decision within two weeks of the day the decision is learned of (art. 268/1). An objection against a decision of a criminal judgeship of peace is reviewed, where there is more than one judgeship in that place, by the judgeship next in number. Smuggled goods that may be confiscated, however, may not be returned (Law No. 5607 art. 16/1). - [Unfulfilled Export Commitment under Inward Processing in Türkiye: Duties, Article 238 Customs Fine, Objection](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/inward-processing-export-commitment-breach-turkiye): Under Turkish law: how duties secured by collateral are collected when the export commitment under an inward processing certificate or permit is not fulfilled in time, the fine under Article 238 of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/dahilde-isleme-rejiminde-ihracat-taahhudunun-yerine-getirilmemesi - Q: What happens if the export commitment under an inward processing authorisation certificate is not fulfilled in time? A: The commitment is closed with sanctions at the closing stage. Under Article 45 of the Inward Processing Regime Communiqué, the duties secured by collateral at importation for the unexported portion are collected as of the import date under the Customs Law and Law No. 6183; in addition, an administrative fine is imposed under Article 238 of the Customs Law. - Q: When must the application to close the commitment be made? A: For an inward processing authorisation certificate, at the latest within three months of the end of the certificate period to the relevant regional directorate; for an inward processing permit, within three months of the end of the permit period to the customs administration (Communiqué Art. 37). - Q: Is the Article 238 fine always twice the duty-paid value? A: No. The rule is twice the duty-paid value of the goods (Art. 238/1-a). But where the regime has been breached yet the goods are found not to have been removed from customs supervision contrary to the legislation, the fine equals interest calculated on the customs duties at the late-payment surcharge rate (Art. 238/1-c). In that case, if the goods are not assigned to a customs-approved treatment or use within sixty days of notification, a further fine equal to the customs duties is imposed (Art. 238/2). - Q: Where is an objection to closure with sanctions lodged? A: The holder of an inward processing authorisation certificate may object in writing to the Ministry of Trade (Directorate General of Exports) within one month of notification of the closure with sanctions. For inward processing permits, the objection route under Article 242 of the Customs Law applies (Communiqué Art. 38/12). The fifteen-day Article 242 objection period against the tax and penalty decisions notified by the customs administration must be observed separately. - Q: Why are the duties sometimes demanded by additional assessment and sometimes by a payment-period notice? A: According to the Council of State, the decisive factor is the status of the collateral. If the collateral is still held by the administration, the duties are pursued by setting a due date under Article 37 of Law No. 6183 and from the collateral under Article 56. If the breach is found after the commitment was closed and the collateral returned, the duties are assessed and notified under the Customs Law and the Article 242 objection route opens. There is a dissenting opinion within the Council of State against this distinction. ### Criminal Law - [Aggravated Fraud via IT Systems and Banks in Türkiye: Penalty and the Line with Theft (TCK Art. 158/1-f)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/aggravated-fraud-information-systems-banks-turkiye): Under Turkish law: the penalty for aggravated fraud committed by using information systems, banks or credit institutions as instruments (Turkish Criminal Code art. 158/1-f), its difference from… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/nitelikli-dolandiricilik-tck-158-bilisim-sistemleri-ve-banka-araciligiyla - Q: What is the penalty for aggravated fraud under art. 158/1-f of the Turkish Criminal Code? A: For aggravated fraud committed by using information systems, banks or credit institutions as instruments, Turkish law provides for three to ten years’ imprisonment and a judicial fine; under this sub-paragraph the minimum term is four years and the judicial fine may not be less than twice the benefit obtained. If the act is committed by three or more persons the penalty is increased by one half, and if within the activities of an organisation it is doubled. Reductions such as effective repentance and art. 158/4 may also apply. - Q: Is fraud committed through an online advertisement aggravated fraud under art. 158/1-f of the Turkish Criminal Code? A: In a 2021 decision, the Court of Cassation’s Criminal General Assembly held, in a case where a complainant who saw an online sales advertisement was persuaded by telephone and transferred money to a bank account, that both the use of information systems as an instrument and the use of press and broadcasting means were present, and held that sub-paragraph (f), which carries the heavier penalty, should apply. Whether the system was used as an instrument of the deceit is assessed separately in each case. - Q: Under Turkish law, is a person who poses as a bank officer, obtains a password and transfers the money punished for fraud or for theft through information systems? A: Court of Cassation practice on this point is not settled. In its decision of 07.10.2025, the 2nd Criminal Chamber held that the victim was deceived only into giving information and that the money was transferred without the victim’s knowledge, and treated the act as theft through information systems (art. 142/2-e of the Turkish Criminal Code). In its decision of 02.02.2026, given by majority, the same chamber treated a similar case as aggravated fraud. Both files have been sent to the Criminal General Assembly. - Q: Under Turkish law, is withdrawing money from an ATM with another person’s bank card aggravated fraud? A: As a rule, no. Where a benefit is obtained by using another person’s card without consent and without anyone being deceived, the offence of misuse of bank cards under art. 245/1 of the Turkish Criminal Code arises. In its decision of 14.01.2026, given by majority, the Criminal General Assembly treated a withdrawal with a card forgotten in an ATM as this offence. Where the cardholder is at the ATM and possession of the card continues, the General Assembly stated that the bank card offence does not arise. - Q: Under Turkish law, how much does paying back the loss reduce the penalty for aggravated fraud? A: Under art. 168 of the Turkish Criminal Code, if the loss is fully made good by returning the property in kind or by compensation before prosecution begins, the penalty is reduced by up to two thirds; if it is made good after prosecution begins but before judgment, by up to one half. In the case of partial payment, the victim’s consent is additionally required for effective repentance to apply. The court sets the reduction within these limits. - [Aggravated Injury by Result (Turkish Criminal Code Art. 87): Bone Fractures, Danger to Life, Higher Sentences](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/aggravated-injury-bone-fracture-turkish-criminal-code-87): Under Turkish law, Criminal Code art. 87 on intentional injury resulting in a bone fracture, danger to life, a permanent facial scar or death: one- and two-fold increases, increases of up to one half… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/neticesi-sebebiyle-agirlasmis-yaralama-tck-87 - Q: How much does a bone fracture increase the penalty for intentional injury? A: Under Criminal Code art. 87/3 the penalty is increased by up to one half according to the effect of the fracture on vital functions. The Criminal General Assembly found a 1/4 increase reasonable for a moderate (2) fracture, while the 1st Criminal Chamber considered a 1/3 increase excessive for the same degree. - Q: Who determines the degree of a bone fracture? A: The degree is determined by the forensic medical report: mild (1), moderate (2-3), severe (4-5-6). If the report does not state the degree in figures, the Court of Cassation reverses judgments rendered without obtaining a new report for incomplete investigation. - Q: If there is both a bone fracture and danger to life, is the penalty increased twice? A: No. According to the 1st Criminal Chamber, the offender is liable for the ground of increase producing the most serious result; once art. 87/1-d is applied for danger to life, no further increase under art. 87/3 may be made. The fracture is instead taken into account by setting the basic penalty above the minimum. - Q: What do the four- and six-year minimums in Criminal Code art. 87/1 mean? A: The penalty reached after the one-fold increase may not be less than four years in cases under art. 86/1 and six years in cases under art. 86/3 (current text). According to the Criminal General Assembly, this sentence is a minimum rather than a separate ground of increase; if the indictment cites art. 87/1-d, the absence of the last sentence does not require additional defence. The decision was adopted by majority. These minimums were raised from three and five years by Law No. 7550, in force since 4 June 2025; for offences committed before that date, the more favourable law is identified by comparison. - Q: If the injured person later dies, under which provision is the offender liable? A: Criminal Code art. 87/4 applies if the offender acted with intent to injure, the injury went beyond what simple medical intervention can cure, there is a causal link between the act and the death, and the offender acted at least negligently as to the death. Article 87/4 does not apply to injuries curable by simple medical intervention; if the offender intended death, the provisions on intentional killing come into play. - [Challenging a Traffic Fine and Drink-Driving in Türkiye: 15-Day Period, Judgeship of Peace, Licence](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/challenging-traffic-fine-drink-driving): Challenging a traffic administrative fine under the Misdemeanours Law (Law No. 5326 art. 27): the fifteen-day period from service or pronouncement, electronic notification, force majeure, petition to… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/trafik-cezasina-itiraz-ve-alkollu-arac - Q: How long do I have to challenge a traffic fine? A: Fifteen days at the latest from service or pronouncement of the decision; if no application is made within that period, the decision becomes final (Law No. 5326 art. 27). Electronic notification is deemed made at the end of the fifth day after it reaches the electronic address (Law No. 5326 art. 26). In case of force majeure, an application may be made within seven days of its ceasing. - Q: Where do I challenge a traffic fine? A: By a petition to the criminal judgeship of peace, stating clearly the details of the decision and the evidence relied on (Law No. 5326 art. 27). Decisions of lack of jurisdiction have been given in actions brought before administrative courts or civil courts of first instance; an application made in time to the wrong authority does not, according to the Court of Cassation, cause loss of rights (Law No. 5271 art. 264). - Q: If I pay the fine, do I lose the right to challenge it? A: No. Under the Misdemeanours Law, payment does not affect the right to apply for a remedy against the decision; payment within the payment period attracts a 25% reduction (Law No. 5326 art. 17). For traffic fines, the payment period is one month from service of the record (Highway Traffic Law art. 115). - Q: What is the sanction for drink-driving? A: A driver of a private car above 0.50 per mille is given an administrative fine and has their licence withdrawn for six months on the first occasion; for vehicles other than private cars, the lower limit is applied as 0.21 per mille. Within five years counting back from the latest violation, the licence is withdrawn for two years on the second occasion and for five years each time on the third and subsequent occasions (Highway Traffic Law art. 48). Above 1.00 per mille, criminal proceedings for endangering traffic safety are also brought (Law No. 5237 art. 179). Fine amounts are not given here because they are increased every year by the revaluation rate. - Q: What happens if I refuse the breath test? A: A driver who does not submit to the test for the police to determine alcohol or drugs is given an administrative fine and has their licence withdrawn for five years. A driver involved in an accident with injury or death, or in a property-damage accident attended by the police, must be examined; if they dispute the device reading or refuse the device test, samples such as blood, saliva or urine are taken at a health facility (Highway Traffic Law art. 48). - Q: When can I get my licence back? A: When the withdrawal period has expired; however, for the licence to be returned, all administrative fines imposed under the Highway Traffic Law must have been collected (Highway Traffic Law art. 48/13). Those whose licence is withdrawn a second time within five years undergo a driver behaviour improvement training, and those whose licence is withdrawn three or more times undergo a psycho-technical assessment and an examination by a psychiatrist (Highway Traffic Law art. 48/11). Driving before the licence is returned attracts a separate administrative fine (Highway Traffic Law art. 36). - [Commercial Blackmail (Turkish Penal Code 107): Elements, Threats to Report or Disclose, vs. Threat and Robbery](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/blackmail-commercial-life): Blackmail in commercial life (Penal Code art. 107): definition and two forms (art. 107/1 coercion into an unjust benefit by invoking a right/duty; art. 107/2 obtaining a benefit by threatening to… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ticari-santaj-sucu-tck-107 - Q: Is saying “pay your debt or I will report you” blackmail? A: Turning one’s genuine right to report an actual illegality to the authorities into a tool of pressure to obtain an unjust benefit may constitute blackmail. The line between blackmail and a genuine, proportionate legal warning to collect a real debt is drawn on the facts of the case. - Q: Must money be demanded for blackmail? A: No. According to the Court of Cassation the concept of “benefit” covers not only material gains but any situation advantageous to the offender or a third party — for instance, escaping an investigation, forcing a contract to be signed, or putting a competitor in difficulty. - Q: What is the difference between blackmail and threat? A: Threat is the announcement of a future harm. Blackmail ties that threat to obtaining a benefit or coercing specific conduct. Without a benefit aim, a threat to disclose matters harmful to honour and reputation constitutes ordinary threat. - Q: Is blackmail a complaint-based offence? A: No. As a rule blackmail is investigated and prosecuted ex officio by the public prosecutor; the victim’s withdrawal of complaint does not by itself end the case. - Q: What is the penalty for blackmail? A: Imprisonment from one to three years and a judicial fine of up to five thousand days, applied together. The actual sentence is set according to the manner of commission, the benefit sought and other circumstances. - Q: How should I document blackmail messages? A: Preserve the threatening and demanding messages, e-mails, voice recordings and correspondence together with screenshots, and submit them to the prosecutor with information identifying the account/line. The integrity of the evidence is decisive in correctly classifying the offence. - [Deferred Verdict (HAGB) and Criminal Records in Türkiye: Conditions, Supervision, Appeal, Erasure of Records](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/deferral-announcement-verdict-criminal-records): Deferral of the announcement of the verdict under Code of Criminal Procedure art. 231: the two-year limit, absence of a prior conviction for an intentional offence, compensation of material damage… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/hagb-ve-adli-sicil-kaydi - Q: Is HAGB entered in the criminal record? A: No. A HAGB decision is recorded in a dedicated system and may be requested only by the public prosecutor, the judge or the court in connection with an investigation or prosecution (Law No. 5271 art. 231/13; Law No. 5352 art. 6/1). If the supervision period is breached and the judgment is announced and becomes final, the conviction is entered in the criminal record. - Q: How long is the HAGB supervision period? A: Five years; the limitation period for prosecution is suspended during this period, and probation obligations not exceeding one year may be imposed (Law No. 5271 art. 231/8). For HAGB decisions concerning children, the supervision period is three years (Law No. 5395 art. 23/1). - Q: Is a HAGB decision challenged by objection or by appeal? A: An appeal (istinaf) lies against HAGB decisions rendered on or after 1.6.2024; if the decision was rendered by a regional court of appeal or the Court of Cassation acting as a first-instance court, an appeal on points of law is available (Law No. 5271 art. 231/12). The objection procedure continues for HAGB decisions rendered before that date (Law No. 5271 provisional art. 6/2). - Q: What happens if a new offence is committed during the supervision period? A: If a new intentional offence is committed or the obligations are breached during the supervision period, the court announces the judgment; for a defendant unable to fulfil the obligations, it may also order that part of the sentence not be executed, suspend it or convert it into an alternative sanction (Law No. 5271 art. 231/11). If no new intentional offence is committed and the obligations are complied with, the case is dismissed (Law No. 5271 art. 231/10). - Q: When is a criminal record erased? A: Upon execution of the sentence, expiry of the limitation period for execution, a general amnesty, or withdrawal of the complaint or effective repentance eliminating the conviction with all its consequences, the entry is deleted from the criminal record and transferred to the archive (Law No. 5352 art. 9). The archive record is deleted entirely after five years for other convictions, and for convictions causing a forfeiture of rights under special laws after fifteen years with a decision restoring forfeited rights or thirty years without it (Law No. 5352 art. 12/1). - Q: How long must one wait for the restoration of forfeited rights? A: As a rule, three years must have elapsed since the execution of the sentence was completed, with no new offence and good conduct during that time; if execution ended for a legal reason other than a general amnesty or effective repentance, five years from finality are required (Law No. 5352 art. 13/A). According to the Court of Cassation, execution means execution of the entire sentence, including the supervision period of conditional release. - [Effective Repentance in Drug Trafficking in Türkiye: Early Disclosure, Later Information (Criminal Code 192)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/effective-repentance-drug-trafficking-turkiye-tck-192): Under Turkish law, effective repentance in drug trafficking (Criminal Code art. 192): no penalty for disclosure made before the official authorities learn of the offence, and a reduction of one… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-06. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/uyusturucu-ticaretinde-etkin-pismanlik-tck-192 - Q: Does effective repentance remove the penalty entirely in drug trafficking? A: Only in the case in Criminal Code art. 192/1: if a person who participated in the offence informs the authorities of the accomplices or the place where the substance is stored or manufactured before the official authorities learn of the offence, and the information leads to a capture or the seizure of the substance, no penalty is imposed. Cooperation after the offence has been discovered does not remove the penalty but reduces it under art. 192/3. - Q: By how much is the sentence of a defendant who gives information after arrest reduced? A: By one quarter to one half according to the nature of the assistance (art. 192/3). The rate is not fixed; the 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that for a defendant who revealed the offences of persons against whom there was no evidence, the reduction may be set even at the upper limit. - Q: Is there a reduction if the information produces no result? A: The Criminal General Assembly requires the information to be true, effective for the outcome and useful; vague, fictitious or misleading information is not enough. However, where true and sufficient information produced no result because no effective investigation was conducted, the Assembly held that this adverse consequence cannot be imposed on the defendant. - Q: Does confessing one’s own offence count as effective repentance? A: Not always. If the offence is already proven by other evidence, a confession on its own may not be considered sufficient. The Criminal General Assembly accepted that where the other evidence was not sufficient to prove the offence, a confession at the trial stage served to reveal the offence. - Q: Must the court investigate the persons named? A: The 10th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation treated giving judgment without inquiring into the outcome of the investigation against the person named as a ground for quashing. The 8th Criminal Chamber, on the other hand, accepted that if the statements are later found to be true, effective repentance may be applied through a retrial. - [Effective Repentance in Embezzlement under Turkish Law: Penal Code Art. 248, Reductions, Full Compensation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/effective-repentance-embezzlement-turkiye-tck-248): Effective repentance in embezzlement under Turkish Penal Code art. 248: reductions of two thirds before the investigation, one half before the prosecution and one third before judgment where the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-06. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/zimmet-sucunda-etkin-pismanlik-tck-248 - Q: How large is the effective repentance reduction in embezzlement? A: If the embezzled property is returned in kind or the loss fully compensated before the investigation begins, two thirds of the penalty is reduced; if this happens voluntarily before the prosecution begins, one half; and if it happens before judgment, one third (Turkish Penal Code art. 248). The rates are fixed; the court determines the stage at which the return or compensation took place and applies the corresponding rate. - Q: Does paying part of the loss reduce the penalty? A: Art. 248 requires the return of the property in kind or full compensation of the loss and provides no separate rate for partial payment. The 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation has treated the application of effective repentance to a defendant who did not compensate the whole embezzled amount as a ground for reversal. - Q: Must interest also be paid for effective repentance? A: According to the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation, default interest or late-payment surcharges, the loss suffered by the administration and lost income are not taken into account in determining the value of the embezzled property; the value at the time of the offence is decisive. In embezzlement by use, however, the subject of the offence is the yield of the money; effective repentance does not apply unless the yield is paid. - Q: Does effective repentance apply if the institution recovers the loss by salary deductions or enforcement? A: The Court of Cassation does not treat money collected through enforcement as a voluntary return, and in one case it held the application of effective repentance unlawful where the loss had been made good through salary deductions made by way of enforcement. By contrast, a payment made directly into the institution’s account without the pressure of enforcement must be assessed after verifying the authenticity of the bank receipt. - Q: Does a payment made after a reversal by the Court of Cassation reduce the penalty? A: According to a decision of the 5th Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation, it does if made before the new judgment: in a case where the loss was fully paid after the reversal judgment but before judgment, it was held that a one-third reduction must be applied under the last sentence of art. 248/2. - [Effective Repentance in Theft under Turkish Law: Art. 168, Partial Return, Property Damage, Breach of Trust](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/effective-repentance-theft-turkish-criminal-code-168): Under Turkish law, effective repentance under Criminal Code art. 168 in theft, damage to property and breach of trust: reductions of up to two-thirds at the investigation stage and up to one half at… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-06. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/hirsizlik-sucunda-etkin-pismanlik-tck-168 - Q: How large is the effective repentance reduction for theft? A: If the loss is fully redressed before the indictment is accepted, up to two-thirds of the penalty is reduced; if it is redressed after the prosecution starts but before judgment, up to one half (Criminal Code art. 168/1-2). According to the Criminal General Assembly, the reduction under the first paragraph must be more than 1/2. - Q: If the police find the stolen property and return it to the owner, does effective repentance apply? A: If the property was seized by the police and returned without the offender showing its location or making any other contribution, the Court of Cassation does not apply effective repentance. The offender himself showing where he hid the property and thus securing its return may, however, count as effective repentance. - Q: Can effective repentance apply if my family pays the loss? A: If the defendant has at least made statements or engaged in conduct showing remorse or consent to the payment and has not opposed it, redress by third persons on the defendant’s behalf may count as effective repentance depending on the circumstances. Payment made without the defendant’s knowledge or against his will is not enough. - Q: I paid part of the loss; what if the victim does not accept it? A: For partial return or compensation, the victim’s consent is required (Criminal Code art. 168/4). Without consent, no reduction can be based on the partial payment; if the remaining loss is fully redressed before judgment, it is assessed under the second paragraph. - Q: If I pay at the appeal stage after the judgment, will I get a reduction? A: As a rule, no; payment after the first-instance judgment does not lead to a reduction. If the judgment is reversed, payment before the new judgment is taken into account; if judgment was rendered without giving the opportunity to a defendant who declared that he wished to redress the loss, payment at the appeal stage may also be regarded as made before judgment. - Q: Is settlement (uzlaşma) available for theft? A: Under Code of Criminal Procedure art. 253/1-b, theft under Criminal Code art. 141 is subject to settlement; art. 142 is not on the list. Breach of trust (except the third paragraph) is also listed, and damage to property under Criminal Code art. 151/1, being prosecuted upon complaint, is subject to settlement. - [Fair Trial and Press Freedom for Journalists in Türkiye: Detention, Sources, Access Bans, AYM and ECtHR](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/fair-trial-rights-press-freedom-journalists): Fair trial rights and press freedom in proceedings against journalists in Türkiye: Constitution arts. 26 and 28, Press Law No. 5187 (source protection, time limits for prosecution, news websites and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/gazetecilikte-adil-yargilanma-hakki-ve-basin-ozgurlugu - Q: Can a journalist be compelled to disclose a source? A: No. The owner of a periodical, the responsible editor and the author cannot be compelled to disclose any news source, including information and documents, or to testify on this matter; non-disclosure cannot be held against the journalist. - Q: Can a journalist be detained solely because of a news report? A: Detention requires concrete evidence of strong suspicion and a ground for detention. The Constitutional Court and the ECtHR have held that detentions ordered without any concrete fact other than published reports violate the right to liberty and press freedom. - Q: Is it a crime to report on an ongoing investigation? A: As a rule, no. Reporting on investigative and trial proceedings without exceeding the limits of news reporting is not an offence (Law No. 5237 art. 285/6). The offence of breach of confidentiality requires that the disclosure violate the presumption of innocence, confidentiality of communications or privacy, or be capable of preventing the discovery of the material truth. - Q: What is the time limit for prosecuting press offences? A: Four months for daily periodicals and news websites and six months for other printed works; for news websites the period runs from the criminal complaint concerning the report and may not exceed the limitation period for prosecution. - Q: How can an access ban on a news report be challenged? A: Decisions concerning catalogue offences may be challenged under the Code of Criminal Procedure (Law No. 5651 art. 8) within two weeks of learning of the decision (Law No. 5271 art. 268). The provision on blocking for personality rights was annulled, with effect from 10.10.2024. After the objection is rejected, an individual application to the Constitutional Court may be lodged within thirty days. - Q: What are the time limits for applying to the Constitutional Court and the ECtHR? A: An individual application to the Constitutional Court must be lodged within thirty days of exhaustion of remedies (Law No. 6216 art. 47/5). The time limit for applying to the ECtHR is four months for final domestic decisions given after 01.02.2022. - [Indirect Report Not False Accusation: Telling a Site Manager Who Alerts Police (Turkish Court of Cassation)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/false-accusation-report-to-competent-authority-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that a defendant who falsely accused another of theft before a construction site manager, rather than… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yetkili-makama-yapilmayan-suc-isnadi-iftira-degildir - Q: What are the elements of the offence of false accusation? A: Under Turkish law, the offender imputes an unlawful act to a person knowing that the person did not commit it, makes the accusation by a report or complaint to the competent authorities or through the press and broadcasting, and aims to have an investigation, prosecution or administrative sanction initiated against that person (Penal Code art. 267/1). According to the Assembly of Criminal Chambers, the imputed act need not be an offence; the offence is committed with direct intent and this specific aim. - Q: Which are the competent authorities for false accusation? A: Relying on Code of Criminal Procedure art. 158, the Assembly listed the Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office, the law enforcement authorities, the governorship, the district governorship, the courts and, abroad, embassies and consulates; it did not mention the institution’s administration under art. 158/4. - Q: Is it false accusation if the person who heard the accusation informs the police? A: According to the Assembly of Criminal Chambers, no. The report must be made directly to the competent authority; it is not enough for the authorities to learn of the accusation indirectly through an intermediary. - Q: If there is no false accusation, can the offence of insult arise? A: It can; however, for words uttered in the victim’s absence the Assembly required communication with at least three persons. Since that condition was not met in this case, insult was not committed either. - [Insult and Social Media Insults in Türkiye: Elements, Publicity, Complaint, Prepayment, Cassation Criteria](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/insult-offence-social-media): The offence of insult under the Turkish Penal Code (arts. 125-131): imputing a concrete act or fact, swearing and the line between insult and merely rude speech; publicity in insults on social media… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/hakaret-sucu-ve-sosyal-medyada-hakaret - Q: Is every insult on social media considered public? A: No. Publicity requires that the content be visible to an indeterminate number of people and open to everyone without restriction. The Court of Cassation has held that no increase for publicity applies to a comment in a closed Facebook group or to a message sent to the victim through a phone application. - Q: Is an insult sent by message (SMS or messaging application) an offence? A: Yes. An insult committed through an audio, written or visual message addressed to the victim carries the same penalty as a face-to-face insult (Law No. 5237 art. 125/2). However, since such messages are not public, the penalty is not increased for publicity. - Q: What is the complaint period for insult? A: The complaint must be filed within six months from the day the act and the offender became known; for insult, this period may in any event not exceed two years from the date of the act (Law No. 5237 art. 73/1-2). The two-year cap does not apply to files that had reached the investigation or prosecution stage as at 14.11.2024. Insult against a public official because of their duty is not subject to complaint. - Q: Is mediation available for insult? A: No. Under the current Law No. 5271 art. 253/3, mediation is not available for the offence of insult. Prepayment applies instead, except for insult against a public official because of their duty; if the suspect pays the determined amount within ten days of notification, no public prosecution is brought (Law No. 5237 art. 75). - Q: What is the penalty for insult? A: The basic penalty is imprisonment from three months to two years or a judicial fine (Law No. 5237 art. 125/1). For insults against a public official because of their duty, because of beliefs and opinions or by reference to sacred values, the minimum penalty may not be less than one year; committing the insult publicly increases the penalty by one sixth (Law No. 5237 art. 125/3-4). - Q: Is a penalty imposed for reciprocal insults? A: Depending on the nature of the incident, the court may reduce the penalty for both or one of the parties by up to one third or decide not to impose a penalty (Law No. 5237 art. 129/3). The Court of Cassation accepts that a defendant who insulted first may also benefit from this reduction depending on the circumstances. - [Intentional Injury (Turkish Criminal Code Art. 86): Minor and Aggravated Forms, Complaint, Settlement, Penalty](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/intentional-injury-turkish-criminal-code-86): Under Turkish law, intentional injury under Criminal Code art. 86: elements, the complaint requirement and settlement for injury remediable by simple medical intervention, aggravated forms and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kasten-yaralama-sucu-tck-86 - Q: What is the penalty for minor intentional injury? A: If the effect of the injury is so minor that it can be remedied by simple medical intervention, Criminal Code art. 86/2 applies: imprisonment of six months to one year and six months or a judicial fine. Where the offence is committed against a woman, the lower limit is nine months. These ranges apply from 4 June 2025; for earlier acts, the former range (four months to one year) applies. - Q: What is the time limit for filing a complaint for intentional injury? A: For minor injury, which depends on a complaint, the period is six months from the day on which the act and the offender become known and may not exceed the limitation period (Criminal Code art. 73). The basic offence and the aggravated forms do not depend on a complaint; the six-month complaint period does not apply to them. - Q: If I withdraw my complaint, will the case be dropped? A: Only for minor injury that depends on a complaint; a defendant who does not accept the withdrawal is not affected. In the basic offence and in injury committed with a weapon, against a spouse or because of a public duty, no complaint is required, so withdrawal does not terminate the case. - Q: Is settlement possible for intentional injury against a spouse? A: No. Injury against a spouse falls under art. 86/3-a; Code of Criminal Procedure art. 253 subjects intentional injury to settlement “except the third paragraph”. The Court of Cassation reversed, in the interest of the law, a decision terminating such a case after settlement. - Q: Which court hears an intentional injury case? A: As a rule, the criminal court of first instance; the provisions on the prosecution of children are reserved. If the act is considered possibly to be attempted intentional killing, the high criminal court is competent. - Q: Who decides whether an injury can be remedied by simple medical intervention? A: This is established by the forensic examination report, which the court assesses. Where reports conflict, the Court of Cassation regards giving judgment without a report from the relevant specialised department of the Forensic Medicine Institute as incomplete examination. - [Metabolite Findings in Drug-Use Offences: The Evidentiary Force of Blood and Urine Tests](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/metabolite-findings-drug-use-offences): The evidentiary force of metabolite findings in the Turkish drug-use offence (Criminal Code art. 191), through the case law of the 10th Criminal Chamber: the effect of positive tests (THC, 6-MAM… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-02; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/uyusturucu-kullanma-sucunda-metabolit - Q: Is a metabolite finding alone sufficient for conviction? A: Under the 10th Criminal Chamber’s practice, detection of the substance or its metabolite in a sample taken at the time of the offence establishes use by technical means and, as a rule, suffices for conviction — even if nothing is seized on the person. Defences must be substantiated with concrete evidence. - Q: What if the test is clean but the person confessed? A: Where no substance is seized and the panel is entirely negative, a bare confession cannot ground conviction; acquittal is required under in dubio pro reo. - Q: What is the penalty, and is prosecution immediate? A: Two to five years’ imprisonment (art. 191/1). As a rule, prosecution is deferred for five years with at least one year of probation (and treatment if needed); compliance leads to a non-prosecution decision. - Q: What happens if a test is positive during probation? A: Use during the deferral period is a violation (art. 191/4-c) and the original prosecution is instituted; under art. 191/5 the new use is not prosecuted separately. - Q: How does effective remorse work? A: No penalty is imposed on a user who, before the authorities learn of it, discloses from whom, where and when they obtained the substance, facilitating apprehension or seizure (art. 192/2), or who requests treatment before an investigation is opened (art. 192/4). - Q: Can Forensic Medicine reports be challenged? A: Yes — on the scope of the panel, the chain of custody, the type/level of the metabolite and its relation to the offence date; re-analysis and expert opinions may be requested. Irregular sampling raises an unlawful-evidence issue. - [Provocation and Self-Defence in Intentional Injury: Reduction, First Unjust Act, Fights, Excess (TCK 29, 25)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/unjust-provocation-self-defence-intentional-injury-turkiye): Under Turkish law, unjust provocation (Criminal Code art. 29) and legitimate self-defence (art. 25) in intentional injury: a reduction of 1/4 to 3/4, minimum provocation where the first unjust act in… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kasten-yaralamada-haksiz-tahrik-ve-mesru-mudafaa - Q: How much is the unjust provocation reduction in intentional injury? A: Under Criminal Code art. 29, between one quarter and three quarters of the penalty for intentional injury is deducted. The judge sets the rate according to the gravity of the unjust act and its effect on the offender’s will; in fights where it cannot be established from whom the first unjust act came, the Court of Cassation applies the minimum rate. - Q: What happens if it is unclear who started the fight? A: Under the principle that doubt benefits the defendant, the doubt is interpreted in the defendant’s favour and unjust provocation is applied at the minimum rate. Where the first unjust act cannot be established at all, the 1st Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation holds that the conditions of self-defence and of exceeding the limits are not met; where evidence such as video footage shows who started the physical attack, self-defence is assessed for the party who responded. - Q: If I started the fight, can I benefit from unjust provocation? A: As a rule, no: an offender who provoked the other party by his unjust act cannot claim to have acted under provocation because of the reaction he met. If the other party’s reaction was clearly disproportionate and excessive, that reaction may constitute provocation in the offender’s favour. - Q: What is the difference between self-defence and unjust provocation? A: Self-defence is a ground of justification and leads to acquittal; unjust provocation does not remove the offence but only reduces the penalty. Self-defence means repelling an unjust and present attack at that moment and proportionately, whereas provocation means committing an offence under the influence of anger or severe distress caused by an unjust act. - Q: If I responded more than necessary out of fear, will I be punished? A: If, while the conditions of self-defence existed, proportion was exceeded because of excusable excitement, fear or panic, no penalty is imposed (Criminal Code art. 27/2) and a decision that there is no room for a penalty is rendered. If the limits were exceeded for reasons such as anger, this provision does not apply; unjust provocation may, however, come into question. - [Renting Out a Bank Account (IBAN) in Türkiye: The Offence and Effective Remorse at the Investigation Stage](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/renting-out-bank-account-effective-remorse): The criminal liability of letting fraud or crime proceeds pass through your own bank account (IBAN): aggravated fraud (Turkish Criminal Code Art. 158/1-f, four to ten years' imprisonment), the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-28; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/iban-kiralama-ve-sorusturmada-etkin-pismanlik - Q: I rented out my IBAN but only withdrew and handed over the money; is it still a crime? A: Yes. Letting the money pass through your account makes the bank a tool of the offence, so the act may be assessed as aggravated fraud (Art. 158/1-f). The “I only withdrew it” defence does not, on its own, remove liability; it depends on whether intent is present. - Q: How much reduction do I get if I pay the loss at the investigation stage? A: If you fully compensate the loss (principal) before the indictment is accepted — i.e. at the investigation stage — the penalty is reduced by up to two thirds under Art. 168/1. If you compensate after prosecution begins, the reduction is limited to up to one half. - Q: I paid only the principal, not the interest; can I benefit from effective remorse? A: According to the Court of Cassation, full payment of the principal suffices for effective remorse; not also paying interest (supplementary loss) does not bar the reduction. However, where payment is partial, the victim's consent is required. - Q: If there are several victims, how should I compensate the loss? A: Effective remorse applies in respect of the victim whose loss is compensated. To benefit fully, the loss of the relevant victim(s) must be fully compensated; for partial payment the victim's consent is required. - Q: What if I prove my account was used without my knowledge? A: Fraud is committed intentionally. If you can establish with concrete evidence that your account was seized and used outside your knowledge and will, acquittal may follow for lack of intent. Building this defence at the investigation stage is important. - Q: Under Turkish law, which court hears IBAN (account) renting cases? A: The current text of art. 12 of Law No. 5235 does not list aggravated fraud among the offences heard by the assize court; provisional art. 7 added by Law No. 7571 provides that files then pending before the assize court or under appeal continue under the old rules until a final judgment. Accordingly, IBAN renting cases filed afterwards are, as a rule, heard by the criminal court of first instance (asliye ceza mahkemesi); jurisdiction is assessed separately where more than ten years’ imprisonment is required. MASAK processes and account freezing may also arise from suspicious money movements. ### Administrative Law - [Appeals in Afyonkarahisar Cases in Türkiye: Konya Regional Court of Appeal and Regional Administrative Court](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/afyonkarahisar-appeals-konya-regional-courts-turkiye): Under Turkish law, appeals against civil and criminal decisions in Afyonkarahisar go to the Konya Regional Court of Appeal, and appeals against administrative and tax decisions go to the Konya… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/afyonkarahisar-istinaf-konya-bolge-adliye-ve-bolge-idare-mahkemesi - Q: Which regional court of appeal hears appeals against a civil court decision given in Afyonkarahisar in Türkiye? A: The Konya Regional Court of Appeal. Its official jurisdiction page lists Konya, Afyonkarahisar, Aksaray and Karaman. The petition is not taken to Konya; it is lodged with the court that gave the decision or another local court, and the first-instance court forwards the file (Code of Civil Procedure art. 343). - Q: On what date is an appeal petition filed in Afyonkarahisar in Türkiye deemed lodged? A: In civil cases the appeal is deemed lodged on the date the petition is registered. Article 343(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure refers to article 118, and the Court of Cassation 3rd Civil Chamber therefore treated the registration date as the filing date. The time limit is two weeks from proper service of the judgment (art. 345). - Q: What is the time limit for appealing a criminal judgment of a court in Afyonkarahisar in Türkiye, and where is the appeal lodged? A: Two weeks from service of the judgment together with its reasons. The appeal is made by petition to, or by a statement before the clerk of, the court in Afyonkarahisar that gave the judgment (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 273(1)); the criminal chambers of the Konya Regional Court of Appeal review it. - Q: Which regional administrative court hears appeals against decisions of the Afyonkarahisar Administrative Court in Türkiye? A: The Konya Regional Administrative Court. By decision no. 1069 of 06.08.2025 of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors (Official Gazette, 12.08.2025), its jurisdiction covers the provinces of Konya, Afyonkarahisar, Aksaray, Karaman and Niğde. The time limit is thirty days from service of the decision (Administrative Procedure Law art. 45(1)). - Q: Is an appeal against an Afyonkarahisar administrative court decision invalid in Türkiye if the petition is mistakenly addressed to the Council of State? A: No. Under article 45(2) of the Administrative Procedure Law, files concerning decisions subject to appeal are sent to the regional administrative court regardless of how the petition is addressed or framed. The Council of State 13th Chamber rejected such a cassation request on jurisdictional grounds and sent the file to the administrative court that gave the decision, for transmission to the regional administrative court competent to hear the appeal. The time limit remains thirty days. - Q: Which court hears appeals in tax cases from Afyonkarahisar in Türkiye? A: According to the administrative judiciary guide of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors (file dated 18.09.2026 on its website), tax disputes in Afyonkarahisar are heard by the Konya Tax Court. Appeals against tax court decisions, like those against administrative court decisions, go to the Konya Regional Administrative Court (Administrative Procedure Law art. 45(1)). - [Building, Facilities and Mining in Olive Groves in Türkiye: Law No. 3573, Prohibitions and Legal Remedies](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/olive-groves-facilities-mining-law-3573-turkiye): Under Turkish law, Law No. 3573 art. 20 prohibits facilities that leave chemical waste or emit dust and smoke within olive grove areas and within 3 kilometres of them; olive grove areas may not be… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/zeytinlik-sahalarda-yapi-tesis-ve-madencilik-3573-sayili-kanun - Q: Can a factory or other facility be built in or near an olive grove in Türkiye? A: As a rule, no. Under Turkish law (Law No. 3573 art. 20), no facility that leaves chemical waste or emits dust and smoke such as to hinder the development of olive groves may be built or operated within olive grove areas or within 3 kilometres of them. Olive oil factories and small-scale agricultural industry enterprises are subject to Ministry permission. In a 2025 decision the 4th Chamber of the Council of State required the court first to establish whether the facility is of that kind. - Q: What is an olive grove area under Law No. 3573 in Türkiye, and is a land registry entry enough? A: The Law does not define an olive grove area. The definition in the Regulation, which required at least 25 decares, was annulled by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State. On 19.02.2026 the same Chamber annulled, by majority, the relevant part of a Ministry letter stating that the Law also applies to land registered as an olive grove but bearing no olive trees; that decision may not yet be final. No single settled criterion appears in the decisions read. - Q: Is permission needed to cut down or uproot an olive tree in Türkiye, and what is the penalty? A: Under Turkish law, uprooting olive trees in olive grove areas requires Ministry permission based on technical grounds; a tree may not be cut down or uprooted unless there is a definite necessity (Law No. 3573 art. 20). Cutting or uprooting without permission attracts an administrative fine per tree. The amount in the text of the Law is sixty Turkish liras; administrative fines are applied as increased each year by the revaluation rate. As the provisions of the Law that were read show no separate remedy, on this article’s own inference the fifteen-day application under art. 27 of the Misdemeanours Law applies against the fine. - Q: Can mining be carried out in an olive grove area in Türkiye? A: According to the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, absent a separate statutory provision, mining in olive grove areas in Türkiye may be carried out only within the framework of Law No. 3573; the permission clause added to the Mining Regulation in 2022 was annulled on that ground. Those decisions rest on the text of art. 7 of the Mining Law before it was amended in 2025. Provisional article 45, added by Law No. 7554 of 19/7/2025, allows the Ministry to grant permission only in the areas listed in the annex to the Law, for mining aimed at the country’s electricity needs by those who were licence holders or royalty contractors on that date, and provided that no other area is available. - Q: Can an olive grove area within municipal boundaries be opened to development under Turkish law? A: Under Law No. 3573 art. 20, olive grove areas may not be reduced. The exception in the Law is where an olive grove area within municipal boundaries is brought within the zoning limits; in that case total construction, including infrastructure and social facilities, may not exceed 10% of the olive grove area. The article treats zoning plans that became final before its publication as valid; art. 24 of the Regulation explains that date as the publication of Law No. 4086 of 28.2.1995. - Q: What is the time limit for challenging a facility, mining permit or EIA decision affecting an olive grove in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, an annulment action against an administrative act is, as a rule, brought within sixty days from the day following written notification (Law No. 2577 art. 7). Decisions taken as a result of environmental impact assessment and urgent expropriation acts are subject to the expedited procedure; the time limit is thirty days and a decision on a stay of execution is not open to objection (art. 20/A). For regulatory acts that must be announced, time runs from the day following the announcement. - [Challenging a Refusal of Veteran or Martyr Status in Türkiye: Disability, Laws No. 3713 and 2330, Time Limits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/challenging-refusal-veteran-or-martyr-status): Challenging refusals of service-disability, martyr or veteran status in Türkiye: Laws No. 3713, 2330, 5510 and 5434, the 2026 amendments by Law No. 7594, administrative versus labour courts, time… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25; updated: 2026-11-06. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/gazi-veya-sehit-sayilmama-islemine-karsi-dava - Q: Which court hears a challenge to a refusal of martyr or veteran status? A: As a rule, the administrative court. However, service-disability disputes of persons first insured as public servants after 2008 are heard by the labour courts under Law No. 5510 art. 101. Service-disability claims of conscripts who died during military service and acts under Laws No. 3713 and 2330, the veteran title, martyrdom certificates, medals and employment belong to the administrative courts. In cases concerning military service, the competent court is the administrative court located where the regional administrative court of the person’s place of duty sits. - Q: What is the time limit for bringing an action? A: Sixty days from written notification of the refusal. If an application is not answered within thirty days, it is deemed rejected and the sixty days run from then. For compensation claims, the administration must be approached within one year of learning of the action and in any event within five years; the Council of State accepts that these periods may run from the date the administrative character became known, for example from notification of a service-disability annulment judgment. - Q: Can relatives of a conscript who took his own life benefit from service-disability rights? A: As a rule no, because disability resulting from attempted suicide is excluded by law. However, the Council of State has held that an assumption of suicide cannot be relied on where the cause of death was not clarified, and that the State bears the burden of a plausible explanation. It has also upheld the annulment of a refusal where there was service fault, such as putting a soldier detained for drugs on armed guard duty without examination. The outcome depends on the facts. - Q: What changed in 2026 for those injured in counter-terrorism duty but not classified as disabled? A: Law No. 7594 raised the indicators for degree-based pensions under Law No. 3713 Additional art. 3 and extended to their recipients the other rights granted under Law No. 1005. In addition, under the new Law No. 3713 Provisional art. 20, personnel not classified as disabled and given no degree, who suffered non-minor injuries from firearms, explosives or close-combat attacks, may receive a pension based on indicator 17,135. The application must be made within one year of entry into force to the institution of service at the time. - Q: Does receiving cash compensation prevent a separate damages action? A: No. If the administration is liable, a full-remedy action may be brought. However, the updated value of the cash compensation paid under Law No. 2330 and the twenty-five per cent increased part of the pension are deducted from pecuniary damage. After the Constitutional Court’s annulment, cash compensation counts only against pecuniary damage and is not deducted from non-pecuniary damages. - [Damages for Delayed Healthcare in Turkish Prisons: Jurisdiction, Time Limits, Service Fault and Interest](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/delayed-prison-healthcare-state-liability-claim-turkiye): Under Turkish law, harm caused by delayed examination, treatment or hospital referral in a penal institution is claimed through a full-remedy action against the administration: the ordinary and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-06. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/cezaevinde-saglik-hizmeti-gecikmesi-tazminat-davasi - Q: In which court is an action brought for a convict or remand prisoner whose treatment in prison was delayed? A: As a rule, a full-remedy action is brought before the administrative court. However, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State, treating the dispute as one concerning the execution of the sentence, held the ordinary courts competent in a case based on a delayed hospital referral; the same Chamber continues to examine on the merits cases based on fault in supervision and in the operation of the health service. - Q: What are the time limits for applying to the administration and bringing an action? A: An application must be made to the administration within one year of learning of the damage and in any event within five years of the date of the action. For bodily harm, the date of learning is as a rule the date on which the final report is obtained; for injuries whose harm was apparent at the time of the incident, the period runs from the date of the incident. If the administration does not reply within thirty days, the request is deemed rejected and the action must be brought within sixty days. - Q: Which heads of damage may be claimed? A: Treatment, medication and device costs, transport and accompanying-person costs, carer costs, temporary incapacity, loss of working capacity (effort), impaired economic prospects and, in case of death, loss of support may be claimed; non-pecuniary damages are claimed separately. Awarding a head that was not claimed is treated as exceeding the claim. - Q: Do I lose interest if I increase the amount claimed later? A: Under the decision of the Council of State Assembly for the Unification of Judgments, interest runs on the increased amount from the same date as on the amount in the statement of claim, as a rule the date of the application to the administration. The increase may be made once only, until the final judgment. - Q: Do I pay attorney’s fees if part of my non-pecuniary claim is rejected? A: The Constitutional Court annulled the rule dividing costs according to the extent of success as regards actions for non-pecuniary damages. The 10th Chamber of the Council of State therefore holds that no costs or attorney’s fees may be awarded against the claimant for the rejected part of a non-pecuniary claim. The proportionality rule still applies to pecuniary damages. - [Debarment from Public Tenders in Türkiye: Prohibited Acts, Periods, Shareholders, Annulment (Laws 4734, 4735)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/public-tender-debarment-decision-annulment-turkiye): Under Turkish law, those who commit prohibited acts in a public tender or during contract performance are debarred from all public tenders for one to two years, and those who fail to sign the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15; updated: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ihalelere-katilmaktan-yasaklama-karari-ve-iptal-davasi-4734-4735 - Q: How long does a debarment from public tenders last under Law No. 4734 in Türkiye? A: For the prohibited acts in art. 17 and the contract-stage acts in Law No. 4735 art. 25, the ban is not less than one year and up to two years. For those who, except in force majeure, do not duly sign the contract after being awarded the tender, it is not less than six months and up to one year. The deciding authority sets the period according to the nature of the act; the Law provides no further standard. - Q: Does a debarment from public tenders in Türkiye also apply to the company’s shareholders? A: Yes, under the statutory conditions. If a partnership company is debarred, all partners are also debarred; if a capital company is debarred, only partners holding more than half of the capital are (Law No. 4734 art. 58/2; Law No. 4735 art. 26/2). A partner without a majority holding is not caught; the Council of State’s 13th Chamber upheld a regional court decision annulling the debarment of a forty-eight per cent partner. - Q: Within what period must a debarment decision from public tenders be given under Turkish law? A: Under the Law, the decision is given within forty-five days at the latest after the act requiring debarment is established and sent to the Official Gazette within fifteen days at the latest. The Law does not say whose finding counts; in a first-instance decision upheld by the Council of State’s 13th Chamber, the period was started from the date the act was reported to the competent ministry. That assessment was specific to the case. - Q: Within how many days must an annulment action against a debarment from public tenders be brought in Türkiye? A: As a rule within sixty days in the administrative court: Administrative Procedure Law art. 20/A excludes debarment decisions from the expedited procedure, and Law No. 4734 art. 58 and Law No. 4735 art. 26 set no separate time limit, so the general period in art. 7 applies. The period starts on the day after written notification. Since the effect of Official Gazette publication is not settled, it is prudent to use the earlier date. - Q: Can a stay of execution be obtained in a case against a debarment from public tenders in Türkiye? A: Yes, but bringing the action does not suspend the ban by itself. The court may stay execution where both conditions are met: implementation would cause damage that is difficult or impossible to remedy and the act is manifestly unlawful (Administrative Procedure Law art. 27/2). Stay orders are, as a rule, granted against security, which may be waived depending on the circumstances. - Q: Can the regional administrative court’s decision in a debarment case be appealed to the Council of State in Türkiye? A: The Council of State’s Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers said no in two decisions of 2024 and 2025: since these cases are not listed in Administrative Procedure Law art. 46, they become final with the regional court’s decision. The decisions were by majority. However, the 13th Chamber appears to have carried out appellate review in some debarment cases in 2025; practice is not uniform. - [Foreign-Currency Military Service, Deferment Abroad in Türkiye: Conditions, Cancellation, Multiple Nationals](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/turkish-military-service-foreign-currency-citizens-abroad): Under Turkish law, deferment abroad (art. 38) and military service by foreign-currency payment (art. 39) under the Military Recruitment Law No. 7179 for male Turkish citizens living abroad: the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/dovizle-askerlik-ve-yurt-disindaki-yukumlunun-askerligi - Q: How many years must I work abroad for military service by foreign-currency payment? A: At least three years of actual work, not counting time spent in Türkiye. For multiple nationals living abroad and persons born abroad who live there with a permanent residence permit, no work requirement applies; three years of actual presence abroad is sufficient (Law No. 7179, art. 39). - Q: How much does it cost? A: The Law sets a formula rather than a fixed amount: the indicator figure is multiplied by the civil servant salary coefficient and converted into euros at the rate on the day of payment. The amount changes as the coefficient changes; the current figure is available from the consulate. Transfer fees and costs are charged separately. - Q: Until what age does deferment abroad last? A: Military service procedures may be deferred until the end of the year in which you turn 35. If you spend more than half of any calendar year in Türkiye during deferment, the deferment is cancelled (art. 38). - Q: What can I do if my application is refused? A: An annulment action against the refusal may be brought before the administrative court within the time limit for administrative actions. An action against a Ministry decision was heard by the Ankara Administrative Court; in some cases the regional administrative court’s decision may be final. - Q: I served in the country of my other nationality; am I exempt in Türkiye? A: Law No. 7179 ties exemption to bilateral agreements between the two countries. If you served before 26.06.2019, under the former Law No. 1111, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State held that your application must be assessed under the former Law and that the regulation limit tying applications to 26.06.2019 is unlawful; the decision may not yet be final. - [Judicial Review of Disciplinary Penalties](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/judicial-review-disciplinary-penalties): The legal framework and judicial review of disciplinary penalties imposed on civil servants and public officials (warning, reprimand, deduction from salary, suspension of step advancement, dismissal… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-26; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/disiplin-cezalarinin-yargisal-denetimi - Q: What disciplinary penalties are there? A: Article 125 of Law No. 657 provides for five penalties increasing in severity: warning, reprimand, deduction from salary, suspension of step advancement and dismissal from the civil service. The corresponding acts and situations are listed one by one; the same kind of penalty may also be imposed for acts of similar gravity. - Q: A disciplinary penalty was imposed without taking my defence; what can I do? A: No disciplinary penalty may be imposed without taking the defence (Art. 130), a guarantee protected by Article 129 of the Constitution. If the defence was not taken at all, or not taken in due form (by notifying the allegations, the evidence and the characterisation of the act), this is in itself a ground for annulment. An action may be brought before the administrative court to annul the penalty. - Q: Should I object first, or bring an action directly? A: The objection route is optional. You may object within seven days against warning, reprimand and deduction-from-salary penalties to the disciplinary board, and against the suspension-of-step-advancement penalty to the high disciplinary board. You may also bring an annulment action before the administrative judiciary directly, without objecting; in any event the judicial route is open (Art. 135). - Q: Within what period does a disciplinary penalty become time-barred? A: There are two periods: the period to open an investigation (one month for warning/reprimand/deduction from salary/suspension of step advancement, six months for dismissal) and the period to impose a penalty (at most two years from the date the act was committed). If these periods are exceeded, the power to impose a penalty lapses (Art. 127). - Q: I was acquitted in the criminal case; is my disciplinary penalty automatically lifted? A: No, it is not lifted automatically. Disciplinary law and criminal procedure are separate disciplines; the official's not being convicted under criminal law does not by itself prevent a disciplinary penalty. However, the criminal court's finding as to the proof of the same act (whether or not it occurred) must be respected in the administrative judiciary. - Q: In which court and within what period is the action brought? A: The action to annul a disciplinary penalty is, as a rule, heard before the administrative court. The period to bring the action is sixty days from the day following service (Administrative Procedure Law, Art. 7). Bringing the action does not by itself stay the application of the penalty; if the conditions are met, a stay of execution must be requested separately (Art. 27). - [Tax Cases from Uşak, Afyonkarahisar and Kütahya: Which Court, Time Limits and Appeal in Türkiye](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/tax-court-usak-afyonkarahisar-kutahya-turkiye): There is no tax court in Uşak, Afyonkarahisar or Kütahya; tax cases are heard by the Manisa, Konya and Eskişehir Tax Courts respectively. This article explains, under Turkish law and with official… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/usak-afyonkarahisar-kutahya-vergi-davasi-hangi-mahkemede-acilir - Q: Is there a tax court in Uşak, and which court hears tax cases from Uşak in Türkiye? A: There is no tax court in Uşak; the only administrative-jurisdiction court in the province is the Uşak Administrative Court. According to the Administrative Judiciary Guide of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors (file dated 18.09.2026 on the Council's website), Uşak lies within the territorial jurisdiction of the Manisa Tax Court; cases against acts of a tax office or municipality in Uşak are brought before that court. The petition may also be lodged through the Uşak Administrative Court. - Q: Where is a tax case from Afyonkarahisar filed in Türkiye? A: A tax case against an act of a tax office or municipality in Afyonkarahisar is filed with the Konya Tax Court; Afyonkarahisar has no tax court. The Administrative Judiciary Guide of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors (file dated 18.09.2026 on the Council's website) lists the province within the jurisdiction of the Konya Tax Court. - Q: In which province is the tax court for Kütahya, and which court hears tax cases from Kütahya in Türkiye? A: Kütahya has no tax court; tax cases from Kütahya are heard by the Eskişehir Tax Court. By Decision No. 607 of the Plenary of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors dated 07.07.2021, Kütahya was removed from the jurisdiction of the Manisa Tax Court and attached to the Eskişehir Tax Court with effect from 01.09.2021. - Q: What is the time limit for challenging a tax and penalty assessment notice in Uşak, Afyonkarahisar and Kütahya in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, a case against a tax and penalty assessment notice must be filed with the tax court within thirty days from the day after service (Law No. 2577 art. 7). For a payment order the time limit is fifteen days (Law No. 6183 art. 58). An electronic notification is deemed served at the end of the fifth day after transmission (Tax Procedure Law art. 107/A). - Q: Do I have to travel to Manisa, Konya or Eskişehir to file a tax case from Uşak, Afyonkarahisar or Kütahya in Türkiye? A: No. Under art. 4 of Law No. 2577, the petition may be handed to another administrative or tax court for forwarding to the competent tax court and, where there is neither, to the civil court of first instance. Each of the three provincial centres has an administrative court; in the districts the civil court of first instance may also be used. A case may also be filed through UYAP with a secure electronic signature. - Q: Which regional administrative court hears appeals against decisions of the Manisa, Konya and Eskişehir tax courts in Türkiye? A: The appeal (istinaf) goes to the regional administrative court in whose jurisdiction the deciding court sits: İzmir for decisions of the Manisa Tax Court, Konya for the Konya Tax Court and Bursa for the Eskişehir Tax Court. The time limit is thirty days from service of the decision (Law No. 2577 art. 45(1)); decisions in tax cases not exceeding the monetary threshold are final. - [The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-action-administrative-jurisdiction): A comprehensive guide to the annulment action in administrative jurisdiction: the definition of the action and the elements of an administrative act (competence, form, cause, subject-matter, purpose)… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-26; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/idari-yargida-iptal-davasi - Q: What is the difference between an annulment action and a full-remedy action? A: An annulment action seeks the annulment of an administrative act on the ground of unlawfulness in terms of competence, form, cause, subject-matter or purpose, and is brought by those whose interests are violated. A full-remedy action is a claim for compensation (or for the fulfilment of a right) by those whose personal rights are directly harmed by an administrative action or act. Where the conditions are met, the two actions may also be brought together. - Q: Who may bring an annulment action? A: Anyone who has a personal, legitimate and current relationship of interest with the act in question may bring it (subjective standing). On matters closely concerning the public interest — such as the environment, zoning, and the protection of historical and cultural values — associations, trade unions and professional bodies may also bring actions within the framework of their founding purposes. - Q: Can an action be brought against any administrative letter? A: No. Only final and enforceable (executory) administrative acts may be challenged. The administration's opinions, preparatory acts or preliminary-act letters may not be challenged on their own; they are reviewed only together with the final act. - Q: What is the filing period? A: Where there is no separate period in their special laws, it is sixty days before the administrative courts and the Council of State and thirty days before the tax courts. The period, as a rule, begins from the day following service of the act. Under Article 11, an application to the superior authority suspends the period; in case of rejection or implied rejection it continues from where it left off. - Q: Does bringing an action stay the application of the act? A: No, bringing an action does not stay the act by itself. If the application of the act will cause harm that is difficult or impossible to remedy and the act is manifestly unlawful (the two conditions together), a stay of execution must be requested from the court (Art. 27). - Q: What happens if an annulment decision is given? A: An annulment decision removes the act from the moment it was issued (retroactively); the act is deemed never to have been made. Under Article 138 of the Constitution and the Administrative Procedure Law, the administration must implement the requirements of the annulment decision without delay. - [The Blue Card and Dual Citizenship in Türkiye: Rights of Former Turkish Citizens Who Renounced with Permission](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/blue-card-rights-former-turkish-citizens): Under Turkish law, the rights in Türkiye of persons who renounced Turkish citizenship with permission and of their descendants under art. 28 of Law No. 5901: the Blue Card, the exceptions (elections… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/mavi-kart-ve-cifte-vatandaslik-vatandasliktan-cikanlarin-haklari - Q: Can I buy property and inherit in Türkiye with a Blue Card? A: Yes. Blue Card holders enjoy the rights granted to Turkish citizens in the same way, apart from the exceptions (Law No. 5901, art. 28/1); acquiring property and inheriting are not among those exceptions. - Q: Which rights do Blue Card holders not have? A: No right to vote or stand for election, no right to import vehicles or household goods duty-free, no military service obligation, and no permanent civil-service posts based on a cadre. They may work in public institutions as workers, temporary or contract staff (art. 28/2-3). - Q: Can my children and grandchildren also get a Blue Card? A: Yes; descendants up to the third degree benefit. They must document their descent from the ascendant (art. 28/5). - Q: My citizenship was taken away for military service reasons; can I get a Blue Card? A: According to the judgment upheld by the Council of State, no; the Blue Card is only for those who were citizens by birth and renounced with permission. For persons in this position, art. 43 of Law No. 5901, as quoted in the decision, provides a route to reacquire citizenship. - Q: My Blue Card was cancelled; what can I do? A: Cancellation is an administrative act; an annulment action can be brought before the administrative court within the time limit for administrative actions. However, the Council of State has accepted that a card issued by mistake to someone who does not meet the conditions creates no acquired right. - [Union Standing Not Judged on Members' Interest Alone: Turkish Constitutional Court on Union Annulment Action](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/trade-union-standing-annulment-action-access-to-court): Under Turkish law, the Constitutional Court unanimously held that administrative court decisions dismissing a trade union's annulment action for lack of standing, on the basis of the members' common… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sendikanin-davasi-yalniz-uyelerin-ortak-menfaatine-bakilarak-ehliyetten-reddedilemez - Q: Can a trade union bring an annulment action against an act concerning its members? A: Yes, but under Turkish law, Article 2/1-a of the Administrative Procedure Law requires that the act infringe its interest. In this decision, the Constitutional Court accepted that, where the union argues that the act also affects its own legal personality, the court must discuss that interest not only in terms of the members’ common interest but also from that angle. - Q: If the members have sued separately, will the union’s action be dismissed? A: In this case, the administrative court made the members’ separate actions one of its grounds for dismissal. The Constitutional Court accepted that this approach pursued a legitimate aim, but found disproportionate a dismissal given without discussing the effect on the union’s own legal personality. - Q: Did the Constitutional Court decide that the union won its case? A: No. The Court only found that the right of access to a court had been violated. Whether the act was lawful and whether the union was actually affected by it will be decided by the administrative court in the retrial. - Q: What happens after the finding of a violation? A: The decision was sent to the administrative court for a retrial. According to the Constitutional Court, what must be done is to give a new decision removing the reasons that led to the violation (Law No. 6216, art. 50/2). - [Unlawful Processing of Personal Data in Türkiye: Application, KVKK Complaint, Damages, Criminal Code Art. 136](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/personal-data-breach-kvkk-complaint-compensation-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a person whose personal data has been processed unlawfully first applies to the data controller and, if this fails, may complain to the Personal Data Protection Board within the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kisisel-verilerin-hukuka-aykiri-islenmesi-kvkk-sikayet-tazminat-ve-ceza - Q: What is the time limit for a complaint to the Personal Data Protection Board in Türkiye if the data controller does not respond? A: Under Turkish law, if the application is rejected, the response is insufficient or no response is given in time, the data subject may complain to the Personal Data Protection Board within thirty days of learning of the data controller’s response and in any case within sixty days of the application date (Law No. 6698 art. 14/1). As a rule, the data controller must respond within thirty days at the latest (art. 13/2). - Q: Can a complaint be made directly to the Personal Data Protection Board in Türkiye without first applying to the data controller? A: No. Under Law No. 6698 art. 14/2, the complaint route may not be used before the application to the data controller under art. 13 has been exhausted. This requirement concerns the complaint to the Board; on the wording of arts. 13 and 14, the same requirement is not imposed for an action for compensation or for a criminal report under Turkish Criminal Code arts. 135–136. This is an interpretation drawn by this article from the provisions. - Q: Under which provisions is an action for compensation for unlawful processing of personal data brought under Turkish law? A: Law No. 6698 art. 14/3 reserves the right to compensation under general provisions of those whose personality rights have been violated. According to a 2025 reversal decision of the Court of Cassation 4th Civil Chamber, this refers to the Turkish Civil Code provisions on the protection of personality; liability is fault-based and requires unlawfulness, loss and an adequate causal link. In the decision summarised, the action against a bank was heard by the ordinary courts. - Q: Which court hears an action against an administrative fine imposed by the KVKK Board in Türkiye? A: Under Law No. 6698 art. 18/3, added by Law No. 7499, an action may be brought before administrative courts against administrative fines imposed by the Board. The Council of State 10th Chamber accepted that this provision entered into force on 01.06.2024 and also applies to pending cases. As no special time limit is provided, the time limit is, as a rule, the sixty days in Administrative Procedure Law art. 7. - Q: Does the offence of unlawfully giving or disseminating personal data under Turkish Criminal Code art. 136 depend on a complaint? A: No. Under Turkish Criminal Code art. 139, recording personal data (art. 135), unlawfully giving or obtaining data (art. 136) and failure to destroy data do not depend on a complaint; the prosecutor investigates of its own motion. The penalty under art. 136/1 is imprisonment from two to four years. The Criminal General Assembly stated that personal data that is not secret and is known to everyone also benefits from this protection. - [İzmir Regional Administrative Court: Jurisdiction (İzmir, Aydın, Denizli, Manisa, Muğla, Uşak) and Appeals](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/izmir-regional-administrative-court-jurisdiction-turkiye): The İzmir Regional Administrative Court hears appeals against decisions of the administrative and tax courts in İzmir, Aydın, Denizli, Manisa, Muğla and Uşak. This article explains, under Turkish law… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/izmir-bolge-idare-mahkemesi-yargi-cevresi-istinaf - Q: Which court hears an appeal against a decision of the Denizli Administrative Court in Türkiye? A: The appellate (istinaf) court is the İzmir Regional Administrative Court; the Denizli Regional Court of Appeal hears only appeals from civil and criminal courts. The petition does not have to be taken to İzmir: it may be lodged with the Denizli administrative court that gave the decision, and the file is sent to the regional administrative court (Law No. 2577 arts. 45/2 and 48/3). - Q: Where and within what time limit is a decision of the Muğla Administrative Court challenged in Türkiye? A: The remedy against a final decision of an administrative court in Muğla is an appeal (istinaf) to the İzmir Regional Administrative Court. The time limit is thirty days from service of the decision (Law No. 2577 art. 45/1). The petition may be lodged with the court in Muğla that gave the decision. In cases under the expedited procedure, such as tenders or urgent expropriation, there is no appeal; the application goes directly to the Council of State within fifteen days. - Q: Which provinces fall within the jurisdiction of the İzmir Regional Administrative Court in Türkiye? A: İzmir, Aydın, Denizli, Manisa, Muğla and Uşak. The court's 2025 annual report describes its jurisdiction as these six provinces, and the administrative-justice guide published on the website of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors as a file dated 18.09.2026 lists the administrative courts of the same provinces under the İzmir Regional Administrative Court. Afyonkarahisar belongs to the Konya, and Kütahya to the Bursa, Regional Administrative Court. - Q: Is there a tax court in Uşak, Türkiye, and where do appeals in Uşak tax cases go? A: There is no tax court in Uşak; according to the administrative-justice guide of the Council of Judges and Prosecutors, tax disputes from Uşak fall within the jurisdiction of the Manisa Tax Court. Appeals against decisions of the Manisa Tax Court are heard by the İzmir Regional Administrative Court. The same court hears appeals against decisions of the Uşak Administrative Court. - Q: Can every decision of an administrative court in Aydın or Manisa, Türkiye, be appealed to the İzmir Regional Administrative Court? A: No. Decisions in tax cases, full-remedy actions and annulment actions against administrative acts whose subject matter does not exceed the statutory monetary threshold are final (Law No. 2577 art. 45/1). The threshold rises each year by the revaluation rate, and the amount in force on the date the case was filed applies (Additional art. 1). There is also no appeal in cases under the expedited procedure; those decisions go directly to the Council of State on cassation. - Q: Can an appeal decision of the İzmir Regional Administrative Court be taken to the Council of State in Türkiye? A: Only in the cases listed in art. 46 of Law No. 2577, within thirty days of service of the decision. These include annulment actions against regulatory acts, cases above the statutory amount, removal from public office and zoning-plan cases. For regional administrative court decisions given after 31.07.2026, cassation is as a rule also available where the first-instance decision was set aside and a new decision given. Other decisions are final. ### Higher Education Law - [Actions Against YÖK and University Acts in Türkiye: Which Administrative Court Has Territorial Jurisdiction?](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/yok-university-acts-competent-administrative-court-turkiye): Under Turkish law, which administrative court has jurisdiction over actions against acts of YÖK, the Inter-University Board and universities: Administrative Procedure Law arts. 32 and 33 for… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yok-ve-universite-islemlerinde-yetkili-idare-mahkemesi - Q: Which administrative court hears an action against an act of the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) in Türkiye? A: The 8th Chamber of the Council of State has found the administrative court in Ankara competent for the rejection of an application tied to YÖK's regulatory power and for an ÜAK act concerning the title and certificate of associate professor; for a post examination conducted by an ÜAK jury, it relied on the place of the university that advertised the post. Actions against regulatory acts to be applied nationwide, such as YÖK regulations, are brought before the Council of State as a court of first instance. If the dispute concerns a public servant's appointment, discipline or personnel rights, the duty-station rules in art. 33 must also be considered. - Q: Under Turkish law, in which administrative court is an action against a student disciplinary penalty imposed by a university brought? A: Under the general rule in art. 32(1) of the Administrative Procedure Law, the action is, as a rule, brought before the administrative court of the place where the superior or board that imposed the penalty is located; no separate decision determining the competent court on this point is cited here. An objection may be made to the university executive board within fifteen days, but it is not mandatory and an action may be brought directly (Law No. 2547 art. 54(10)). The time limit is, as a rule, sixty days from the day after written notification. - Q: Under Turkish law, which administrative court hears an academic's disciplinary penalty or appointment case? A: Academics are public servants, so art. 33 of the Administrative Procedure Law applies. In appointment and transfer cases the administrative court of the new or former duty station, in dismissal and suspension cases that of the last duty station, and for disciplinary penalties not ending employment and for advancement, promotion and personnel rights that of the current duty station has jurisdiction. In a file where a university in another city rejected an ÖYP research assistant's request for extra time in a doctorate, the Council of State found the duty-station court competent because the act could end the employment relationship. - Q: Where is an action against an Inter-University Board (ÜAK) act on an associate professorship application brought in Türkiye? A: The 8th Chamber of the Council of State has found the administrative court in Ankara, where the Presidency of the Inter-University Board that made the act is located, competent for ÜAK acts concerning the title and certificate of associate professor. By contrast, failing an oral examination conducted by an ÜAK jury for appointment to an associate professor post advertised by a university was treated as a rejection of an application for appointment, and the administrative court of the place where that university is located was found competent. - Q: Under Turkish law, what happens if an administrative action is filed in an administrative court that lacks territorial jurisdiction? A: The action does not lapse. At the preliminary review the court dismisses it for lack of jurisdiction and sends the file to the competent court (Administrative Procedure Law art. 15(1)(a)); no appeal lies against that decision. If the court to which the file is sent also considers itself to lack jurisdiction, the regional administrative court or the Council of State resolves the conflict with a final decision (art. 43). Because this process can take months, filing in the right place from the outset saves time. - Q: In Türkiye, where is an appeal lodged against a decision of the administrative court in Denizli in a university case? A: The appeal (istinaf) is lodged with the İzmir Regional Administrative Court within thirty days of service of the decision (Administrative Procedure Law art. 45(1)). Decisions in cases not exceeding the statutory monetary threshold are final. For decisions of the administrative court in Ankara the appellate court is the Ankara Regional Administrative Court; for decisions of the Council of State at first instance, the remedy is an appeal on points of law to the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers. - [Annulling Faculty Appointments in Türkiye: Appointment and Promotion Criteria, Non-Appointment, Non-Renewal](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/faculty-appointment-annulment-action-turkish-universities): Under Turkish law, annulment actions against non-appointment to assistant professor, associate professor and professor posts and against non-reappointment: criteria under Law No. 2547 and the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ogretim-uyesi-atamasi-iptal-davasi - Q: What is the time limit for challenging a faculty appointment? A: Unless a special law provides otherwise, the time limit before the administrative courts is sixty days and runs from the day following written notification (Law No. 2577 art. 7). - Q: My score is higher than the appointee’s; is my non-appointment unlawful? A: Not on that basis alone. In quashing decisions of 2025, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State found the act unlawful where, despite a clear score advantage, no academic reason was shown for preferring the lower-scoring candidate. In a 2023 decision, however, it explained its quashing of an annulment judgment based on an even larger score difference by stating that activities such as thesis supervision, projects and teaching must also be assessed as a whole. The Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers did not base its quashing on score advantage in a similar case. - Q: If the court annuls the act, will I be appointed? A: Not automatically. Administrative courts may not render judgments that remove the discretion of the administration (Law No. 2577 art. 2/2). The administration carries out a new assessment in line with the reasons of the judgment; in one case the Council of State stated that, since the first-ranked candidate had not challenged the act, the administration would cancel the appointment and announce the post again. - Q: What can an assistant professor do if the term is not extended? A: An annulment action may be brought against the non-reappointment. The Council of State has held lawful the non-reappointment of a faculty member who did not meet an institutional requirement known at the time of first appointment, while for a new publication or points requirement introduced during the term it has accepted that the period must be calculated from the requirement’s entry into force. - Q: Can the university’s appointment criteria be challenged separately? A: Yes. The criteria are regulatory acts; they may be challenged directly within the time limit from their publication or together with the individual act applying them (Law No. 2577 art. 7/4). Under the Law, additional conditions must be approved by YÖK, aimed exclusively at raising scientific quality, and objective and verifiable. - [Annulling Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings in Türkiye: University Vacancies Drafted for One Candidate](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-tailor-made-academic-job-postings): Annulment actions against academic job postings tailored to one candidate: Constitution, Law No. 2547, regulations, time limits, standing, Council of State rulings. Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/universitelerde-kisiye-ozel-kadro-ilaninin-iptali - Q: May a university attach special conditions to a posting? A: Yes. The Law permits objective and verifiable additional conditions with YÖK approval aimed at scientific quality, and the courts accept post-specific conditions provided they rest on service needs. What is prohibited is writing a thesis title into the posting and conditions that identify only a particular candidate. - Q: Can I bring an action if I did not apply? A: In the decisions reviewed, the merits were examined in an action brought by a person who could not apply because she did not meet the condition. You need to document that you meet all other requirements and that the condition excluded you from competition. Actions by non-candidate faculty members may be dismissed for lack of interest. - Q: When does the time limit start? A: The time limit is sixty days. Where appointment results were published on the university website, the Council of State upheld a judgment treating that date as the date of knowledge. For an action against the posting itself, the most prudent course is to file within sixty days of its publication. - Q: If I win, will I be appointed to the post? A: As a rule, no. The court cannot appoint in the administration’s place; where the condition is found tailor-made, the administration may issue a new objective posting. If the non-appointment of a qualified candidate is found unlawful, the administration must act in accordance with the judgment. - Q: Can the appointment be suspended during the proceedings? A: A stay may be ordered if manifest unlawfulness and damage difficult to remedy are shown. In appointment cases such a decision is given after the administration’s defence has been received or the defence period has expired. - Q: Is cassation available against the regional court’s decision? A: It is available in the types of case listed in the Law; the Council of State treated an action against another candidate’s appointment as open to cassation because it could result in removal from public service. In addition, regional court decisions given after 31.07.2026 that quash the first-instance judgment and rule anew can now be appealed in cassation. - [Appointing a Markedly Lower Scorer Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Assistant Professor Rankings](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/assistant-professor-appointment-objective-score-ranking): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, holding unlawful the appointment of a candidate with a markedly lower score to an assistant professor post by departing from the objective… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/objektif-puan-siralamasi-disinda-doktor-ogretim-uyesi-atamasi - Q: Must the candidate with the highest score be appointed to an assistant professor post? A: Under Turkish law, the decision does not lay down such a general rule. The Chamber held unlawful the appointment of a candidate with a markedly lower score made by departing from the objective ranking. According to the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, where the candidates’ scientific work is very close or equal, the administration’s discretion becomes important. - Q: What happens if the top-ranked candidate does not sue? A: In this case, according to the Chamber, the administration annuls the appointment, re-advertises the post and makes an appointment after assessing the applicants objectively. - Q: Is the claimant appointed directly to the post? A: Not in this decision. The claimant was not first in the expert’s ranking; the outcome is not the claimant’s appointment but a new advertisement and a fresh assessment of the candidates. - Q: Is a higher score decisive in every case? A: No. In a decision of 31.12.2025, the Chamber did not find unlawful the non-appointment of a higher-scoring candidate in a file where it was established that the score advantage did not stem from publications in the advertised field. - [Art. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/constitutional-court-annulment-student-discipline-penalty): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State did not regard the Constitutional Court’s annulment of Article 54 of Law No. 2547 as sufficient on its own to… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anayasa-mahkemesi-iptali-ogrenci-disiplin-cezasini-kendiliginden-kaldirmaz - Q: Does the Constitutional Court’s annulment of Article 54 automatically lift a student disciplinary penalty? A: Under Turkish law, according to the decision of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State of 17.09.2025, it does not do so automatically. The Assembly accepted that the annulment left the penalty without a legal basis; however, since Article 54 was re-enacted by Law No. 7437 before the annulment took effect, it quashed the decision of insistence that had annulled the penalty solely on the basis of the annulment decision. The case will be examined on the merits under that regulation. - Q: What will the court examine in a penalty imposed under the former Regulation? A: According to the Assembly, if a new statutory regulation has been made after the annulment, the dispute is resolved according to that regulation. In this file, the regional administrative court will examine whether the act is proven, whether it warrants a disciplinary penalty and whether there is a more favourable provision. - Q: Does the decision apply to every student disciplinary penalty? A: The decision concerns an expulsion penalty imposed under the former Regulation and based on a final conviction for membership of an organisation. The Assembly’s standard rests on a new statutory regulation having been made after the annulment; in this file, the fate of the penalty will be decided by the regional administrative court’s review on the merits. - Q: Is the Assembly’s decision final, and where did the file go? A: The Assembly’s decision is final and was given by majority. The file was sent back to the regional administrative court for a new decision; the new decision given after the quashing could not be located. - [Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint Publications](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/associate-professor-appointment-jury-joint-publications): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State finally held, by majority, that an associate professor appointment was unlawful where it relied on the reports… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/docent-atamasinda-adayla-ortak-yayini-olan-juri-uyesi - Q: Can a professor with joint publications with the appointee sit on the jury for an associate professor post? A: Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly’s decision, the presence of such a member on the jury may create a negative impression as to objectivity. The jury should be determined without that member; otherwise an appointment based on that jury’s reports may be held unlawful. - Q: If the jury is flawed, is the claimant appointed directly to the post? A: No. The Assembly required a new appointment act aimed at scientific quality to be established between the two candidates. - Q: If the jury says that one candidate does not meet the minimum conditions, can the administration appoint the other? A: In this case the appointment was made on the basis of the jury reports as if there were a single candidate. Since the expert examination ordered by the court showed that both candidates met the conditions, the Assembly required this matter first to be clarified in a manner leaving no room for doubt and the act to be established accordingly. - Q: Must the candidate with the higher score be appointed? A: The Assembly did not base the quashing on the higher score; it stated that where the candidates’ scientific work is very close or equal, the administration’s discretion becomes important. One member wrote a dissenting opinion stating that the quashing should have been based on the higher score. - [Associate Professorship in Türkiye: Application Requirements and Annulment Action Against a Negative Result](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/associate-professorship-requirements-and-annulment-action): Under Turkish law, an application for associate professorship requires a doctorate, at least 55 points in a central foreign language examination and original publications set for each field; the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/docentlik-basvuru-sartlari-ve-docentlik-sonucuna-karsi-iptal-davasi - Q: What are the requirements for applying for associate professorship in Türkiye? A: Under Law No. 2547 art. 24/a, a doctorate or an equivalent title listed in the Law, at least 55 points in a central foreign language examination (or an equivalent score in an examination accepted by YÖK) and original publications of the number and quality set for each field by YÖK on ÜAK’s opinion are required. Point tables by field are set out in the Associate Professorship Application Requirements published by ÜAK. - Q: When are applications made, and when is the result deemed served? A: Unless ÜAK sets another date, applications are made from the twentieth day of March and October until the close of working hours on the last working day of the month (Regulation art. 4/1). The result and the reports taken as the basis of assessment are deemed served on the fifth day after they are made accessible electronically (Law No. 2547 art. 24/b). - Q: When may an unsuccessful candidate apply again? A: A candidate found unsuccessful by the jury may apply again at the earliest in the third following period, provided the deficiencies are remedied (art. 6/8). A candidate whose application was cancelled for failing the minimum requirements may apply in the following period after remedying the deficiencies (art. 6/1-a). - Q: Where and within what time limit is an action against the result brought? A: The action is brought against the Presidency of the Interuniversity Board within sixty days from the day following service (İYUK art. 7). According to the Council of State’s jurisdiction rulings, the competent courts are the administrative courts of Ankara, where ÜAK is located. In the decisions cited, the regional administrative court’s appellate decision was treated as final. - Q: Can the court change the jury’s scientific assessment? A: The court does not take the jury’s place; it reviews, where necessary with experts, whether the reports are detailed and reasoned and whether the act is lawful. According to recent regional administrative court decisions, it is not enough that an expert finds the candidate successful; it must be shown that the jury’s reasons are wrong or that the jury assessed the file contrary to academic and scientific principles. An act based on a vague criterion, on the other hand, is unlawful according to İDDK. - Q: Can a candidate who has sued apply again for associate professorship? A: Yes. The regulatory provision making a new application dependent on the judgment becoming final was annulled as contrary to the right to seek legal remedies, and İDDK upheld that decision. However, a candidate whose application is still pending may not make a new application (art. 4/7). - [Disciplinary Penalties for Student Cheating: Unlawfulness and Annulment under Turkish Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/unlawfulness-annulment-disciplinary-penalties-imposed): Unlawfulness and annulment of disciplinary penalties imposed for a student cheating in an exam: the disciplinary treatment of cheating (Higher Education Law No. 2547, art. 54 — reprimand for… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ogrenci-kopya-disiplin-cezasi-iptali - Q: What is the disciplinary penalty for cheating in an exam? A: Under Article 54 of Higher Education Law No. 2547, cheating or enabling cheating in exams requires one-semester suspension from the institution. Attempting to cheat is punished by a reprimand, while cheating by threat, preventing the removal of cheating students from the exam hall, having another person sit the exam or sitting it for another person requires two-semester suspension. These rules were contained in the Higher Education Institutions Student Discipline Regulation until 2023; the Regulation was repealed on 11.03.2023. - Q: Is a penalty imposed without taking my defence valid? A: No. The student must be informed in writing, at least seven days before the defence date, of what the imputed offence consists of, and the investigation must allow the student to defend themselves properly (Law No. 2547, art. 54/5). A penalty imposed without duly requesting the defence is annulled before the administrative courts for breach of the right of defence. However, a student who fails to respond to the summons without a valid excuse is deemed to have waived the right of defence. - Q: How must cheating be proven? A: The allegation must be established by concrete, legally acceptable and doubt-free evidence. The investigator may hear witnesses, conduct an inspection and consult experts (Law No. 2547, art. 54/6-b). Especially in online exams, technical claims such as the authorship of the answer sheet may require expert examination; if the act is not found established, the penalty is annulled. - Q: How and within what time can I challenge a suspension? A: An objection may be lodged with the university executive board within fifteen days; it is not mandatory, and an annulment action may be brought directly (Law No. 2547, art. 54/10). The annulment action is brought before the administrative court, as a rule within sixty days of notification (Administrative Procedure Code, art. 7). To suspend the penalty, a stay of execution should be requested together with the action. - Q: Is cassation available against a suspension? A: Since actions concerning a one-semester suspension are not listed in Article 46(1) of the Administrative Procedure Code, the regional administrative court’s decision dismissing the appeal is final; the 8th Chamber of the Council of State upheld the rejection of the appeal on points of law even in a file where it was argued that consecutive penalties would end enrolment. Cassation is, however, available against expulsion from the institution (Administrative Procedure Code, art. 46/1-d). For decisions given after 31.07.2026, if the regional administrative court quashes the first-instance decision and decides anew, that decision may also be appealed on points of law, save for the statutory exceptions (Administrative Procedure Code, art. 46/2). - Q: If I am acquitted in the criminal case, is the disciplinary penalty lifted? A: Disciplinary and criminal processes are independent; the initiation of criminal prosecution, or the student’s conviction or acquittal, does not bar a disciplinary penalty (Law No. 2547, art. 54/6-ğ). Acquittal therefore does not by itself remove the disciplinary penalty, but the penalty is separately reviewed by the administrative courts as to the proof of the act and the lawfulness of the procedure. - [Disciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment Actions](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/disciplinary-penalties-academics-annulment-actions): A guide to disciplinary penalties on academics in Türkiye and annulment actions: the special regime of Law No. 2547 and its differences from the civil-servant regime; penalty types (art. 53/b); the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-02; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/akademisyen-disiplin-cezalari-iptal-davasi - Q: Which disciplinary penalties may be imposed on academics? A: Under art. 53/b of Law No. 2547: warning, reprimand, salary/wage deduction, suspension of grade advancement or repeated wage deduction, removal from the university teaching profession and dismissal from public service. The acts warranting each penalty are exhaustively enumerated. - Q: May a penalty be imposed without taking a defence? A: Not without affording the right of defence (Article 129/2 of the Constitution). Since 09.08.2026, under art. 53/A of Law No. 2547, the competent authority's invitation to defend must state the act on which the proposal is based and the corresponding penalty, grant at least seven days and indicate that the file may be examined before the defence. A person who does not defend within that period despite a proper invitation is deemed to have waived the right of defence; the penalty may then be imposed on the available evidence without a defence. In removal cases the person may also examine the file, call witnesses and defend before the board orally or in writing, in person or through counsel. - Q: What are the limitation periods? A: The investigation must be commenced within one month of knowledge for minor penalties and six months for removal penalties; no penalty may be imposed after two years from the act (six years for removal from the teaching profession) (art. 53/C). Re-use or republication of a scientific work restarts the periods. - Q: What safeguards apply in plagiarism investigations? A: A prior ethics-board examination is mandatory (art. 53/A-b). In the annulment action the court must order an expert examination of its own motion; the expert fee cannot be imposed on the claimant and is requested from the administration or covered by the Treasury. - Q: Where and within what period is the annulment action brought? A: Before the administrative court within 60 days of notification; regional appeal lies against the judgment. Appeal decisions dismissing the regional appeal on warnings and reprimands are final; cassation before the Council of State is available, as a rule, for removal from the profession or public service (APL art. 46(1)). Regional decisions rendered after 31/7/2026 that set aside the first-instance judgment and rule anew may, save for the listed exceptions, be appealed in cassation (APL art. 46(2)). - Q: May an academic be deemed to have resigned for absenteeism? A: As a rule, no. In a case the 8th Chamber held that deemed resignation under art. 94 of Law No. 657 cannot be applied to teaching staff; absenteeism may be addressed only through a disciplinary investigation under Law No. 2547. Failing to take up duty in time at the place of assignment is a separate matter: in assignments under art. 41 (and art. 40/b) of Law No. 2547 and provisional art. 78 (ÖYP research assistants), this is treated as resignation. - [Doctoral Withdrawal Ends a 50/d Research Assistant Post: Turkish Council of State; 33/a Request Is Separate](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/50-d-research-assistant-doctoral-withdrawal-post-ends): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held that a post under Article 50/d of Law No. 2547 is support limited to the duration of postgraduate education and that ties with the post… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/doktora-kaydini-sildiren-50-d-arastirma-gorevlisinin-ilisigi-kesilir - Q: Are the ties of a 50/d research assistant with the post severed if the doctoral registration is deleted? A: Under Turkish law, in the decision of the 8th Chamber of the Council of State of 24.11.2025, the severance of the ties with the post of the claimant, who had the doctoral registration deleted at their own request, was regarded as a requirement of the statutory rule. The Chamber saw the 50/d post as support limited to the duration of postgraduate education and found it sufficient that the education had ended for any reason. - Q: Does an application for transfer to a 33/a post prevent the severance of ties? A: It did not in this case. Stating that the claimant’s request for appointment to a 33/a post was not the subject of the action and that the administration’s will concerning that request could not be assessed in this file, the Chamber found the severance lawful. What became of the request was not discussed in the decision. - Q: Does the decision also apply to research assistants in 33/a posts? A: The reasoning of the decision rests on the link between the 50/d post and postgraduate education; the position of research assistants in 33/a posts was not addressed in the decision. Under Article 33/a of Law No. 2547, appointment to that post is for at most three years and a reappointment may be made by the same procedure. - Q: Where does the file go after the quashing decision? A: The quashing decision is final and was given by majority. The file was sent back to the regional administrative court for a new decision; the new decision given after the quashing could not be located. - [Excluding Associate Degree Courses Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on 2023 Associate Professor Criteria](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/associate-professor-application-associate-degree-courses): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State annulled the omission of associate degree courses from the 2023 associate professorship application requirements and upheld the other… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/docentlik-basvurusunda-on-lisans-dersinin-dislanmasi - Q: Do associate degree courses count for an associate professorship application? A: The 2023 requirements did not include associate degree courses. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State annulled this omission; however, the decision was given subject to appeal in cassation and may not be final. - Q: Has the teaching requirement for associate professorship been abolished? A: No. The claim against the requirement to teach undergraduate or graduate courses for four semesters or two years (at least 2 points) was dismissed unanimously. Those who have served on the permanent teaching staff for at least two years after their doctorate are deemed to meet the requirement. - Q: On what condition is a work presented at a scientific meeting scored? A: The requirement that the organising committee include an officially appointed academic representative was found lawful. The rule that at most one work presented at the same meeting is scored was also upheld. - Q: Is this decision final? A: The decision was given by the Council of State acting as a first-instance court and is subject to appeal in cassation to the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers. No cassation decision could be found; the decision may not be final. - [Lecturer Term Non-Extension Held Lawful on Combined Grounds: Turkish Council of State on Three Facts](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/lecturer-term-non-extension-upheld-combined-grounds): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held lawful the non-extension of a lecturer’s term of office, assessing together that the precondition in Article 31 of Law No. 2547 had… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ogretim-gorevlisi-gorev-suresi-uzatilmamasi-alana-ogretim-uyesi-atanmasi - Q: Can a lecturer’s term of office be left unextended? A: Yes. Under Turkish law, Article 31 of Law No. 2547 provides that a lecturer’s duties end automatically at the end of the term of appointment and that the lecturer may be reappointed. According to the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, the discretion as to non-extension is limited by the public interest and the requirements of the service and is subject to judicial review in terms of reason and purpose. - Q: Is the appointment of a faculty member to the field in which a lecturer teaches enough on its own not to extend the term? A: This decision does not say so. The Chamber accepted that the precondition in Article 31 ceased to exist when an assistant professor was appointed to the field; however, it reached its conclusion together with the disciplinary penalty, the action against which was dismissed on appeal, and the fulfilment of only 6 hours of the 12-hour teaching load. - Q: How does this decision differ from the decision on the research assistant contract? A: In the Chamber’s decision of 25.11.2025, no disciplinary investigation had been opened into the alleged disruption of work, no concrete findings had been made and relying on a single delay alone was held disproportionate. In this decision, by contrast, the action against the disciplinary penalty had been dismissed on appeal, the shortfall in the teaching load had been established in numbers and an assistant professor had been appointed to the field. - Q: Where does the file go after the quashing decision? A: The quashing decision is final and was given by majority. The file was sent back to the regional administrative court for a new decision; the new decision given after the quashing could not be located. - [Missing Rules on Deleting Student Penalties Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Disciplinary Records](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/student-disciplinary-penalty-record-deletion): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, ruling at first instance and by majority, held that the absence of a clear rule on keeping higher education students’ disciplinary… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ogrenci-disiplin-cezalarinin-sicilden-silinmesi - Q: Is a disciplinary penalty received at university deleted from the record? A: Under Turkish law, Law No. 2547 contains no clear provision on how long a penalty is kept or when it is deleted; Article 54 only states that penalties are entered in the student’s file. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State held that this gap should not be applied to the detriment of students; the decision may not be final. - Q: Is a penalty for cheating entered in the student’s file? A: Yes. Under Article 54 of Law No. 2547, disciplinary penalties are entered in the student’s file. Under the current text, attempting to cheat in an exam calls for a reprimand, while cheating or helping others cheat calls for suspension for one semester, and cheating by threats for two semesters. - Q: Did the Council of State order the penalty to be deleted? A: No. The Chamber annulled YÖK’s implied refusal of the request to regulate the matter and the dean’s refusal of the request to implement the Ombudsman Institution’s recommendation; it did not itself rule that the penalty be deleted. - Q: Is the decision final? A: The decision was given at first instance, with an appeal open to the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State within 30 days of notification. No decision of the Assembly in this file could be found; the decision may not be final. - [No Age-35 Limit on Research Assistant Reappointment: Turkish Council of State on Article 33 of Law No. 2547](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/research-assistant-age-limit-reappointment): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State unanimously and finally held that the age-35 condition in Article 33 of Law No. 2547 applies only to the first application for a research… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/arastirma-gorevlisinde-35-yas-siniri-yeniden-atamada-aranmaz - Q: Is there an age limit for becoming a research assistant? A: Yes. Under Turkish law, Article 33 of Law No. 2547 requires that, to apply for the post, a candidate must not have reached the age of thirty-five as of 1 January of the year in which the examination is held. The condition was added to the Law by Law No. 7243 of 15.04.2020. - Q: Can a research assistant who has turned 35 have their contract not renewed for that reason? A: According to the reasoned decisions of the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, no. The age condition applies to the first application; it does not apply to the reappointment of a research assistant who met the condition when taking up the post. - Q: Can the contract be left unrenewed on another ground? A: Yes. The administration has discretion in reappointment; however, a legally acceptable concrete reason must be shown, such as neglect of duties, indiscipline, academic insufficiency or the post no longer being needed. - Q: Is there a Council of State decision to the contrary? A: On 19.06.2025 the Chamber upheld, without giving reasons, a regional administrative court decision that had applied the age condition to the extension of a term of office as well. The upheld decision also had a basis independent of age; the Chamber’s reasoned decisions, by contrast, hold that age is not required on reappointment. - [No Regulatory Gap for Staff Already Over the Norm Cadre: Turkish Council of State on University Staff](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/norm-cadre-surplus-teaching-staff-keep-posts): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld the 8th Chamber’s decision rejecting the claim of incomplete regulation, because provisional Article 1 of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/norm-kadro-fazlasi-ogretim-elemanlari-kadrolarinda-gorev-yapmaya-devam-eder - Q: What happens to teaching staff who were in excess of the norm cadre when the Regulation entered into force? A: Under Turkish law, provisional Article 1 provides that they continue to serve in the posts they hold; those appointed to posts advertised before the Regulation also remain in their posts even if they create a surplus over the norm cadre. The Council of State did not accept the claim of incomplete regulation because of this provision. - Q: Does the decision also cover those who later became surplus to the norm cadre? A: No. The upheld reasoning rests on provisional Article 1; surpluses arising after the Regulation entered into force were not addressed in the decision. - Q: What is the maximum ratio for the same title today? A: Under the current text, in appointments exceeding the minimum cadre number at most 3/4 of the posts may be used for the same title; the requirement does not apply in certain units, research universities and vocational schools. The 2023 and 2025 amendments were not assessed in the decision. - Q: What became of the allegation that the underlying Presidential Decree provision is unconstitutional? A: The Assembly did not consider the allegation serious and did not refer the matter to the Constitutional Court. One member argued in a dissenting opinion that norm cadres must be regulated by statute. - [Rector Holds Power Not to Extend Assistant Professor Terms: Turkish Council of State on Vice-Rector Decision](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/assistant-professor-term-non-extension-rector-authority): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, in a final and unanimous decision quashing a regional administrative court judgment that had rejected the appeal, held that an act not… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/doktor-ogretim-uyesinin-gorev-suresini-uzatmama-yetkisi-rektore-aittir - Q: Who decides not to extend an assistant professor's term of office? A: Under Turkish law, Article 23 of Law No. 2547 provides that an assistant professor (doktor öğretim üyesi) is appointed by the rector for at most four years; those whose term has ended may be reappointed. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State held that, as no express provision allows delegation, the non-extension act must also be adopted by the rector. - Q: Why is a non-extension act signed by a vice-rector unlawful? A: According to the Chamber, delegation of authority is possible only where the law expressly permits it; Article 23 contains no such provision. An act of an unauthorised authority does not become lawful through subsequent acceptance or ratification by the competent authority. - Q: Is a defect of authority examined at later stages of the case too? A: Yes. According to the Chamber, the element of authority concerns public order; the administrative judicial authorities must take a defect of authority into account at every stage of the case, including review by way of legal remedy. - Q: Does quashing on grounds of authority mean the reason for non-extension was wrong? A: No. The Chamber stated that where a defect of authority is found, the other elements of the act cannot be examined, and it made no assessment of the merits of the act. Whether the minimum-score requirement was lawfully applied to the claimant was not answered in this decision. - Q: Are lost salary and personnel rights paid immediately? A: In this decision, no. The Chamber stated that, since the merits of the act had not been examined and there was no new contractual relationship, no direct decision granting losses that were not definite and clear could be given at this stage on the assumption that the contract was renewed. - [Research Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate Grounds](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/research-assistant-contract-non-renewal-concrete-reasons): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held, by majority and as a final decision, that not renewing a research assistant's contract requires concrete and proportionate reasons… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/arastirma-gorevlisi-sozlesmesinin-yenilenmemesi-somut-gerekce - Q: Can a research assistant's contract be left unrenewed? A: Yes. Under Turkish law, Article 33/a of Law No. 2547 provides that research assistants are appointed for at most three years and that their duties end automatically at the end of the term; reappointment is at the administration’s discretion. According to the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, however, the reason for non-renewal must be shown concretely and must be proportionate. - Q: Does a research assistant at a foundation university enjoy the same protection? A: The Chamber stated that no distinction is made between the professional security of academic staff at foundation and state higher education institutions. Article 23 of the Regulation on Foundation Higher Education Institutions also subjects their working principles to the provisions for state universities; salary and other personnel rights are governed by the Labour Law. - Q: Is a written warning or being late to an examination enough for non-renewal? A: In this decision, no. The Chamber found that relying on a single 20-minute delay, which was met with a written warning and did not recur, as the sole ground for non-renewal was contrary to the principle of proportionality and to equity. The outcome depends on the concrete circumstances of each case. - Q: Can the administration raise a new ground during the proceedings? A: According to the Chamber, a ground that was not stated when the act was adopted and is raised while the case is pending does not on its own render the act lawful. For this reason, the decrease in student numbers added at the appeal stage did not save the act in this case. - [Research Assistant Requirements, 50/d and 33/a Posts, Term](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/research-assistant-requirements-50-d-33-a-posts-term): Under Turkish law, applying for a research assistant post requires at least 70 in ALES, at least 50 points in a central foreign language examination, not having reached the age of 35 on 1 January of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09; updated: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/arastirma-gorevlisi-olma-sartlari-50-d-33-a-gorev-suresi - Q: What are the requirements for becoming a research assistant in Türkiye? A: The general conditions in Article 48 of Law No. 657, at least 70 in ALES, at least 50 points (or the equivalent) in a central foreign language examination accepted by YÖK, not having reached the age of thirty-five on 1 January of the year of the entrance examination and, at state universities, being a postgraduate student (Central Examination Regulation art. 6 and art. 7). The senate may require higher scores. - Q: Is there an age limit for becoming a research assistant? A: Yes. Under Article 33/a of Law No. 2547 and Article 7/1 of the Regulation, the candidate must not have reached the age of thirty-five on 1 January of the year of the entrance examination. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State found the Regulation provision lawful; the decision may not be final. The age requirement does not apply to the reappointment of a serving research assistant. - Q: What is the difference between a 33/a and a 50/d research assistant? A: A 50/d post is for postgraduate students; the appointment is for one year at a time and ties with the post are severed when postgraduate education ends, once the periods in additional Article 38/2 have run. In a 33/a post the appointment lasts at most three years and may be renewed by the same procedure. - Q: What happens to a 50/d research assistant’s post after the doctorate or master’s degree? A: For those who complete a doctorate, the ties with the post are extended by one year; the post of those meeting the institution’s performance criteria may continue for one more year, after which the ties are severed automatically. For those who complete a master’s with thesis, the ties continue for at most six more months and are severed if the assistant does not begin a doctorate in the field at a state university within that period (additional art. 38/2). - Q: Who is exempt from the ALES requirement? A: The central examination requirement does not apply to those who have completed a doctorate, specialty training in medicine, dentistry, pharmacy or veterinary medicine, or proficiency in art, or to those who have worked or are working in a teaching staff post (art. 14/1); their ALES score is taken as 70. - Q: Within what time limit can an action be brought against non-appointment or non-extension of the term? A: An annulment action is brought before the administrative court within sixty days from the day following written notification (Law No. 2577 art. 7). In cases concerning the termination of duties, the administrative court of the last place of duty has jurisdiction (Law No. 2577 art. 33/2). - [Residence Rule Upheld for Assoc. Prof. Language Exams Abroad: Turkish Council of State on the 2022 Guide](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/associate-professorship-language-exam-abroad-residence-rule): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State found the provision of the 2022 March Term Associate Professorship Application Guide requiring associate professor candidates who sit a… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/docentlik-basvurusunda-yurt-disi-dil-sinavi-alti-ay-ikamet-sarti - Q: What is the foreign language requirement for an associate professorship application? A: Under Turkish law, Article 24 of Law No. 2547 requires the candidate to obtain at least 55 points in a central foreign language exam determined by YÖK, or an equivalent score in an exam whose international validity is accepted by YÖK. - Q: Is a foreign language exam taken abroad accepted in an associate professorship application? A: Under the 2022 March Term Guide examined by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, it was accepted if residence of at least six months in the exam country, up to and including the exam date, was documented. The Chamber held this requirement lawful; the decision may not be final, and later guides could not be verified for this article. - Q: Why did the Council of State find the six-month residence requirement lawful? A: The Chamber stated that the requirement seeks not short trips but actual presence of a certain continuity, provides for a substantive rather than formal control and aims to protect equality and merit, and found nothing contrary to the public interest and the requirements of the service. - Q: What if the requirement was introduced after the exam was taken? A: In this case the claimant argued that the requirement was first introduced in the 2021 September Guide, that the exam process had begun before that guide was announced, and that no transitional provision had been made. Noting that the rule was expressly included in the 2021 September and 2022 March guides, the Chamber did not accept the allegation of being unaware of the rule and dismissed the action; it did not separately address the transitional provision argument. - [Split Experts in Professor Case Need New Panel: Turkish Council of State on Conflicting Expert Reports](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/professor-appointment-conflicting-expert-reports-new-panel): Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State stated that, in a professor appointment where both candidates met the advertised requirements, the administration must compare them on… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/profesor-kadrosu-atama-iptal-davasinda-bilirkisi-ayrismasi-yeni-heyet - Q: If both candidates meet the requirements, may the administration appoint whichever candidate it wishes to a professor post? A: Under Turkish law, according to the Chamber in this decision, no: the administration may make a choice in the exercise of its discretion, but it cannot rely only on the formal requirements and must compare the candidates on objective and verifiable criteria in terms of merit and scientific competence. - Q: What happens if the expert panel is divided on which candidate is superior? A: In this case, the Chamber stated that the divergence of opinion raised doubt as to the adequacy and soundness of the report on which the judgment was based, and considered an examination by a new expert panel of different persons necessary. - Q: What should the new expert panel examine? A: According to the Chamber, the panel should examine the candidates’ works and studies in terms of quality, taking the requirements of the advertisement into account, compare them on objective criteria and, where necessary, apply scoring based on concrete criteria. - Q: Does this decision mean that the claimant is appointed to the professor post? A: No. The Chamber did not decide which candidate is superior; the file went back to the regional administrative court. If that court complies with the quashing decision, it decides on the basis of the new expert report; if it insists on its earlier decision, the insistence decision is reviewed on appeal by the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers. - [YÖK Paragraph Barring Court-Backed Appointments Annulled: Turkish Council of State on YLSY (Law No. 1416)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/ylsy-scholar-lecturer-appointment-court-rulings-yok-letter): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld, on the same reasoning, the annulment of the paragraph of a YÖK general letter stating that those deemed… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ylsy-bursiyeri-mahkeme-karariyla-da-olsa-atanamaz-yok-yazisi - Q: May YÖK state in a general letter that scholarship holders deemed unsuccessful cannot be appointed even by court decisions? A: Under Turkish law, in this case no: the 8th Chamber of the Council of State annulled that paragraph as contrary to the administration’s duty to comply with court decisions, and the Assembly upheld the annulment on the same reasoning. - Q: Does the decision mean that every scholarship holder who did not complete a doctorate must be appointed? A: No. The decision only upheld the annulment of the fifth paragraph; it made no ruling on any individual right to appointment or on the compensation obligation. - Q: May a scholarship holder who has repaid the doctoral costs challenge the whole general letter? A: According to the Assembly, in this case yes: the whole letter concerns the claimant’s interest, and repayments made for the uncompleted doctorate do not remove the link of interest. - Q: At what stage is the file now? A: The parts concerning annulment and no need to decide were upheld finally. The dismissal for lack of standing was quashed, and the file was sent back to the 8th Chamber of the Council of State for a new decision on the other paragraphs of the general letter. ### Real Estate Law - [1956–1983 Takings Valued at Suit Date by Character at Taking: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/de-facto-expropriation-1956-1983-character-at-taking-date): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that compensation for land taken without expropriation between 09.10.1956 and 04.11.1983 is determined under… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kamulastirmasiz-el-atma-tazminati-el-atma-tarihindeki-nitelik - Q: By reference to which date is compensation for land taken between 1956 and 1983 calculated? A: According to the Assembly, the character of the land is determined as at the date of taking and its value as at the date of the action. Provisional art. 6 likewise provides that, if an action is brought, the value at the date of the action is determined on the basis of the characteristics at the date of seizure. - Q: If land taken between 1956 and 1983 is a zoned plot today, can it be treated as a building plot? A: In this case the Assembly did not consider sufficient a comparable-sales valuation based on the land’s status as a zoned plot at the date of the action. For takings within provisional art. 6, what is decisive is whether the land was a building plot at the date of taking. - Q: What happens if the file does not show the land’s character at the date of taking? A: According to the Assembly, that character must first be clearly determined, and only then may the land be valued under provisional art. 6. - Q: Does this rule also apply to takings after 04.11.1983? A: Provisional art. 6 covers only takings between 09.10.1956 and 04.11.1983. In another decision concerning land taken after 04.11.1983, the Assembly stated that provisional art. 6 did not apply. - Q: Is the decision final, and what happened to the file? A: The decision was given by majority and is final. The decision of resistance was reversed and the file was sent to the first-instance court. - [Action for Annulment of Title and Re-Registration: Incapacity, Fraud, Abuse of Authority (Turkish Case-Law)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-annulment-title-re-registration): An action for annulment of title and re-registration is an in rem claim to cancel a wrongful land-registry record and re-register the immovable in the true right-holder's name. This article explains… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tapu-iptali-ve-tescil-davasi - Q: Which court hears this action? A: The Civil Court of First Instance. Venue is exclusive: the action is brought where the immovable is located (HMK arts.2 and 12). - Q: Is the action time-barred? A: As an action founded on ownership it is, in principle, not subject to limitation. The Court of Cassation holds that no forfeiture or limitation period applies in cases of forgery and abuse of authority; only where fraud alone is invoked may a period arise. - Q: What if the buyer is a good-faith third person? A: A third person acquiring in good-faith reliance on the register is protected (TMK art.1023). But one who knew or ought to have known of the defect is not (art.1024); a first acquirer through forgery cannot plead good faith. - Q: My agent sold my property below value; what can I do? A: This may be abuse of authority. A price far below market value or purchase without inspection may show the buyer was not in good faith. You may sue the buyer for annulment and re-registration, or failing that for the value. - Q: How is incapacity proved? A: Through medical records referable to the transfer date and, ultimately, a Forensic Medicine Institute report. The court must examine capacity before other grounds such as fraud. - Q: Whom should I sue? A: As a rule, the current registered owner. In chain transfers, intermediate owners alleged not to be in good faith may also be joined. For heirs, some grounds require the action to be brought jointly. - [Action for Determination of Rent: The Increase Ceiling (CPI Limit), Equity After Five Years, Time to Sue](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-determination-rent): The action for determination of rent is a public-order action by which the court fixes the renewed-period rent in residential and roofed-workplace leases. This article explains, under TBK… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kira-bedelinin-tespiti-davasi - Q: Who may bring the rent-determination action? A: Both landlord and tenant. The landlord usually sues to increase the rent, the tenant to have it fixed/reduced to market. Even without an increase clause, determination under TBK art.344 may always be sought. - Q: What is the maximum new-period increase? A: The increase in renewed periods cannot exceed the twelve-month average CPI change of the previous lease year (TBK art.344); agreements exceeding it are void as to the excess. The temporary 25% ceiling on residential rents expired on 01.07.2024. - Q: How is the rent fixed after five years? A: After five years and at the end of each five-year period, the rent is fixed by the judge according to equity — no longer bound solely by the CPI — having regard also to the property's condition and comparable rents. This is when the rent may be brought closer to current market value. - Q: When should I file the rent-determination action? A: It may be filed at any time. But for the fixed rent to apply from the start of the new period, the action must be filed at least thirty days before the new period, or written notice of increase (ihtar) must be given to the tenant within that time. If the contract has an increase clause, an action within the new period suffices. - Q: Which court is competent? A: Disputes arising from a lease fall within the civil court of peace irrespective of the amount (HMK art.4). Venue is the defendant's domicile or the place of performance (as a rule, where the property is located). - Q: Can I bring an adaptation action before five years because inflation is high? A: According to the Court of Cassation, no. In residential and roofed-workplace leases TBK art.344 is a special and mandatory provision, so an art.138 adaptation action cannot be brought before five years merely on grounds of inflation/inadequate rent. But where genuine extraordinary circumstances (earthquake, epidemic, war) exist, an adaptation action may always be brought. - [Action for Prevention of Interference with Property: Conditions, Co-Owners, Encroachment, Mesne Profits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-prevention-interference-property): Conditions of the action for prevention of interference with property under Turkish law; Articles 683, 693, 725, 983-984 and 995 of the Turkish Civil Code; interference between co-owners and the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/elatmanin-onlenmesi - Q: Is the action subject to a limitation period? A: A claim based on ownership is not subject to prescription. Claims based solely on protected possession lapse after two months from knowledge of the act and its author, and in any event one year after the act (Civil Code Art. 984). - Q: My co-owner uses the whole property. Can I sue? A: Yes, you may at any time seek prevention of interference with your share. But if you peacefully use an area corresponding to your share, the action will not be entertained; partition or judicial dissolution is the remedy. A de facto partition binding on all co-owners will also be protected. - Q: My neighbour's building encroaches on my land. Can I obtain demolition? A: If the builder was not in good faith, the encroaching part is demolished regardless of the extent of the loss. If he was in good faith and you did not object within fifteen days of learning of the encroachment, he may claim an easement or transfer of the encroached parcel against payment (Civil Code Art. 725). - Q: Which court is competent? A: The civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk). Actions solely for the protection of possession belong to the civil court of peace. Venue lies exclusively with the court of the place where the immovable is situated. - Q: Can I claim mesne profits in the same action? A: Yes; this is a joinder of claims. Fees are levied on the aggregate value, and since the Assembly of Civil Chambers' decision of 01.04.2026 the aggregate is also used to determine the appeal threshold. - Q: My tenant refuses to leave. Should I bring this action? A: No. Where a valid lease exists the occupation is not unlawful; the correct route is an eviction action or eviction through enforcement proceedings. - [Action for Release of a Mortgage (İpoteğin Fekki) in Türkiye: Loan Repaid but the Bank Will Not Lift It?](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-release-mortgage): Once the secured debt ends, the owner may ask the bank to cancel the mortgage; but a maximum-amount mortgage tied to a general loan agreement does not lapse just because one loan is closed. The… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ipotegin-fekki-davasi - Q: The loan is paid off but the bank will not lift the mortgage; what should I do? A: First ask the bank in writing to release the mortgage and to provide a statement of any cash and non-cash debts. If the receivable has ended, the owner may request cancellation of the mortgage (Turkish Civil Code art. 883/1); if the bank does not issue a release letter, an action for release is brought before the commercial court of first instance. If the bank’s non-cash risk continues on the filing date, there is a risk of bearing the costs (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2022/87, K. 2023/133). - Q: The loan I secured has been closed; why is the mortgage still in place? A: A mortgage tied to a general loan agreement can be created to cover all of the company’s existing and future debts, non-cash risks such as letters of guarantee and cheques, and suretyship debts; its scope is determined by the mortgage deed. The court therefore looks not at a single loan but at all debts covered by the mortgage deed (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/4111, K. 2026/1119). - Q: If I serve a notice on the bank, will the mortgage stop covering new loans? A: As a rule it continues to cover them. The Assembly of Civil Chambers holds that no statutory provision allows a mortgagor to escape the mortgage debt by a unilateral declaration (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/3128, K. 2021/1224); in 2026 the 11th Civil Chamber also reversed a release judgment based on such a notice (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5314, K. 2026/2478). - Q: My loan was sold to an asset management company; who lifts the mortgage? A: The assignment of a mortgage-secured receivable does not require registration in the land register, and the mortgage passes to the assignee together with the receivable (Turkish Civil Code art. 891; Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/381, K. 2022/4548). The release request should therefore also be addressed to the assignee company. - Q: Is mediation mandatory before an action for release of a mortgage? A: Not if only release of the mortgage is sought; that claim is not included in the list in Turkish Commercial Code art. 5/A/1 (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/2809, K. 2025/7367). If a negative declaratory or compensation claim concerning a sum of money is added, a mediator must first be approached for that claim; otherwise that claim may be dismissed on procedural grounds (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/6375, K. 2025/3913). - [Annulment of Title and Re-Registration for Fraud in Türkiye: Elements, One-Year Period, Proof, Third Parties](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-title-re-registration-fraud): An owner who sold immovable property as a result of deceit (fraud) is not bound by the contract under art. 36 of the Turkish Code of Obligations; within one year of discovering the deceit, the owner… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/hile-nedeniyle-tapu-iptali-ve-tescil - Q: Can a title transfer obtained through fraud be cancelled? A: Yes. An owner who sold as a result of deceit by the other party, or by a third person whose deceit the other party knew or was in a position to know of, is not bound by the contract; as the registration based on it is wrongful, cancellation of the title entry and re-registration in the owner’s name may be claimed (Civil Code art. 1024). If a price was paid, the seller returns it. - Q: Within what period must a fraud action be filed? A: Within one year of discovering the deceit, the deceived party must declare that it is not bound by the contract or reclaim what it performed; otherwise the contract is deemed ratified (Code of Obligations art. 39). The period runs from discovery, not from the date of sale, and no separate upper limit running from the date of the contract is provided for deceit. As the declaration may also be made by filing suit, filing within that year is the safest course. - Q: How is fraud proved? A: By any evidence, including witnesses; witnesses may be heard on allegations of defective consent as an exception to the requirement of documentary proof (Code of Civil Procedure art. 203). Witness statements are assessed together with the gap between the price and the market value, the parties’ relationship, transactions after the transfer, medical records and, where necessary, a report of the Forensic Medicine Institute. If there is no other evidence, the oath should be relied on expressly. - Q: What happens if the property has been sold to someone else? A: A third party who acquired the property relying on the land register in good faith is protected (Civil Code art. 1023); a person who knew or ought to have known of the wrongful registration is not, and cancellation may also be sought against that person. Where the property remains with a person in good faith, compensation is claimed from the deceiver. To prevent a sale during the proceedings, an interim injunction should be sought and annotated in the land register. - Q: Can the heirs bring a fraud action if the seller has died? A: Yes, but the action must be brought on behalf of the estate and, as a rule, by all the heirs together or with the consent of the other heirs; if the heirs cannot agree, the civil court of peace may be asked to appoint a representative for the community of heirs (Civil Code art. 640). The Court of Cassation held that an action based on fraud and brought only in proportion to the claimant’s inheritance share could not be heard. - Q: Is it mandatory to apply to a mediator before filing suit? A: No. An action for annulment of title and re-registration based on fraud is not among the disputes in which mediation is a precondition (Law No. 6325 art. 18/B). However, mediation is a precondition if a sum of money or compensation is claimed in a commercial case between merchants; the parties may also choose to resolve a dispute over the transfer of property through voluntary mediation. - [Annulment of Title for Gabin (Exploitation) in Türkiye: Elements, Time Limits, Valuation (TBK Art. 28)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-title-gabin-property-sales): If a property was sold clearly below its value by exploiting the seller’s distress, thoughtlessness or inexperience, the seller may, under Code of Obligations art. 28, declare that he is not bound by… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/gabin-asiri-yararlanma-nedeniyle-tapu-iptali - Q: What is gabin? A: Gabin (excessive benefit) is a clear disproportion between the performances in a contract created by exploiting the injured party’s distress, thoughtlessness or inexperience (Code of Obligations art. 28). In a property sale the seller may declare that he is not bound by the contract and claim annulment of title and re-registration. - Q: Can a property sold far below its value be recovered? A: A low price alone is not enough; the seller’s distress, thoughtlessness or inexperience and the buyer’s knowing exploitation of it must also be proven. If the conditions are proven and the right is exercised in time, the property returns to the seller by a judgment of annulment and re-registration and the seller returns the price received; a good-faith third party’s acquisition is, however, protected (Civil Code art. 1023). - Q: Within what time must a gabin action be brought? A: Within one year from discovery of the thoughtlessness or inexperience or, in the case of distress, from the end of the distress, and in any event within five years from the conclusion of the contract (Code of Obligations art. 28/2). The upper limit is five years, not ten; the Court of Cassation treats this as a preclusive period, not a limitation period, and applies it to both options. - Q: How is a clear disproportion established? A: The property’s real value at the moment the contract was concluded is determined by site inspection and examination by a qualified expert, taking into account zoning status, location, comparable sales and encumbrances such as attachments, and is compared with the counter-performance actually given to the seller. The law sets no ratio; the disproportion must be high enough to strike anyone familiar with the matter. - Q: Can only the difference be claimed without setting the sale aside? A: Yes. The injured party may also remain bound by the contract and claim removal of the disproportion between the performances (Code of Obligations art. 28). This is a money claim subject to the same one-year and five-year periods; if the parties are merchants and the case is commercial, recourse to a mediator before filing suit is a precondition. - Q: What is the difference between gabin and fraud? A: In fraud the seller is induced to contract by deceit and is not bound even if the mistake was not fundamental (Code of Obligations art. 36). In gabin no deceit is required; a clear disproportion and the exploitation of the seller’s distress, thoughtlessness or inexperience are required (Code of Obligations art. 28). - [Building Declaration Fails Without Legal Interest: Turkish Court of Cassation on Muhdesat Without Partition](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/muhdesat-declaration-legal-interest-partition-expropriation): Under Turkish law, the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that, as no partition action had been brought and no expropriation procedure existed in respect of the immovable, the plaintiff… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/muhdesatin-tespiti-davasinda-hukuki-yarar-ortakligin-giderilmesi - Q: Can an action to establish who owns muhdesat always be brought? A: No. Under Turkish law, the plaintiff must have a current legal interest under HMK art. 106/2; the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that there was no legal interest in this case, in which there was no partition action or expropriation procedure in respect of the immovable. - Q: In which situations is a legal interest accepted? A: The Chamber referred to a pending partition action and an expropriation procedure. In its decision of 23.10.2024, the Assembly of Civil Chambers also listed an urban transformation project among such exceptional situations. - Q: Does the result change if some defendants admit the claim? A: It did not in this case. According to the Chamber, since the determination of muhdesat is a material fact, no weight can be given to the statements of some defendants admitting the claim. - Q: Did this decision end the case? A: No. The Chamber reversed the first-instance judgment and sent the file back to the first-instance court; it also stated that the claim labelled as ecrimisil had to be examined as a rent receivable. - [Co-owner Who Approved the Sale Cannot Claim Pre-emption: Turkish Cassation Assembly on Joining Negotiations](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-waiver-co-owner-consented-to-sale): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation found that a pre-emption action brought later by a co-owner who took part in the sale negotiations, approved the sale of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04; updated: 2026-11-17. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/satis-pazarligina-katilip-onay-veren-paydas-onalim-hakkini-kullanamaz - Q: How is the right of pre-emption waived? A: Under Turkish law, a waiver must be made in official form and annotated in the land register. Renouncing the exercise of the right in a specific sale is subject to written form and may be made before or after the sale (Civil Code art. 733/2). - Q: Can a co-owner who negotiated and approved the sale bring a pre-emption action? A: The Assembly of Civil Chambers found that the exercise of pre-emption by a co-owner who personally took part in and approved the pre-sale dealings and made no claim to the share sold is contrary to Civil Code art. 2; the outcome depends on the circumstances and the evidence. - Q: Can a co-owner who took part and bid in an auction later exercise pre-emption? A: In 2023 the Assembly of Civil Chambers held by majority that they can; having taken part in the auction was not regarded as a bar to pre-emption. - Q: At what stage can the objection of bad faith be raised? A: At any stage of the proceedings; the court also considers it of its own motion. - Q: Within what period must a pre-emption action be brought? A: Within three months from notification of the sale to the right holder and, in any event, within one year from the sale (Civil Code art. 733). For sales made before the amendment entered into force, the outer limit is two years (Civil Code provisional art. 1/1). - [Court Must Offer a Choice When Property Is Sold Mid-Case: Turkish Court of Cassation on CCP Art. 125](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/land-sold-during-title-annulment-case-plaintiff-options): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held by majority vote that if the immovable in dispute is sold through enforcement proceedings while an action for… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/muris-muvazaasi-davasi-surerken-tasinmaz-cebren-satilirsa-hmk-125 - Q: What happens if the immovable is sold while an action for annulment of title is pending? A: Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly, the subject matter may be transferred during the action unless there is a restricting reason, but the transferring defendant no longer has standing as a party. Under Code of Civil Procedure art. 125/1, the plaintiff continues the action against the transferee or converts it into an action for compensation against the transferor. - Q: Must the court ask the plaintiff which option it chooses? A: Yes. A court that learns of the transfer reminds the plaintiff of the alternative rights of its own motion and asks which one is chosen; without that choice, no decision may be rendered between the former parties. - Q: Does a sale through enforcement proceedings also count as a transfer? A: It did in this decision. Under Civil Code art. 705/2, ownership is acquired before registration in the case of enforcement; proceedings under Code of Civil Procedure art. 125 must also be carried out for an immovable whose auction has become final. - Q: What happens if the sale comes to light at the Court of Cassation stage? A: The reminder rule concerns public order and is applied at every stage, including appellate review. In this case the sale was reported before the Assembly of Civil Chambers, and the judgment was reversed for that reason. - [De Facto Expropriation Claims in Türkiye: Compensation, Injunction and Mesne Profits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/de-facto-expropriation-claims): A guide to de facto expropriation (kamulastirmasiz el atma) claims under Turkish law: the physical vs regulatory taking distinction and competent jurisdiction; the owner's alternative remedies… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-02; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kamulastirmasiz-el-atma-davasi - Q: What is de facto expropriation? A: The administration’s seizure of privately owned land without a lawful expropriation and without compensation — physically (roads, buildings, parks, power lines) or legally, by designating the land for public services in the zoning plan and leaving it unexpropriated for years. - Q: What is the difference between physical and regulatory taking, and which court hears each? A: In a physical taking the administration actually seizes the land; the action is brought before the civil court of first instance where the land is situated. In a regulatory taking the land is merely restricted by the zoning plan; the compensation action is brought before the administrative courts. - Q: Which actions can I bring against the administration? A: You have alternative remedies: an action to stop the interference and demolish the installations, or, accepting the situation, an action for payment of the land’s value. In both cases, mesne profits (ecrimisil) may be claimed for the period of wrongful use. - Q: How is compensation calculated and when does interest start? A: The land is valued as at the date of action — by comparable sales for building plots and by the net-income method for agricultural land. Statutory interest generally runs from the date of action, and the land is registered in the administration’s name or struck from the registry. - Q: Is there a time limit for de facto expropriation actions? A: After the annulment of article 38, ownership-based actions to stop the interference and for compensation are subject to no prescription or forfeiture period while the taking continues. Ecrimisil is limited to the preceding five years; the three-month period applies to 1956–1983 takings after the disagreement report, and administrative time limits apply to regulatory takings. - Q: Must I attempt settlement with the administration before suing? A: Only for takings between 09.10.1956 and 04.11.1983 is the settlement procedure a procedural prerequisite (Provisional art. 6). For takings after 04.11.1983, no settlement requirement applies and the action may be brought directly. - [Dissolution of Co-ownership (Partition): Division in Kind and Sale](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/dissolution-co-ownership): The action for dissolution of co-ownership (partition): each co-owner's right to demand partition (Civil Code Art. 698), division in kind as the priority and, where impossible, sale by public auction… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-28; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ortakligin-giderilmesi-izale-i-suyu - Q: Can I dissolve the co-ownership even if the other co-owners do not want to? A: As a rule, yes. Each co-owner may demand partition; this right may be limited only by agreement (at most ten years) or by dedicating the asset to a permanent purpose. A demand at an inopportune time is not heard. - Q: Can the court order a sale directly? A: No. First a site inspection and expert examination determine whether division in kind is possible. If it is not, or the asset cannot be divided without significant loss of value, a public-auction sale is ordered. - Q: Can the sale be conducted only among the co-owners? A: A sale conducted only among the co-owners (closed) depends on the consent of all co-owners. Without consent, the sale is by public auction open to everyone. - Q: Against whom should I bring the action? A: All co-owners must be parties; all co-owners other than you are shown as defendants. The action cannot proceed with a co-owner missing. - Q: Which court has jurisdiction? A: In partition actions the competent court is the magistrates' court (sulh hukuk); the court of the place where the immovable is located has jurisdiction. Applying to a mediator before suing is a precondition to suit. - [Early Need-Based Eviction Mediation Valid If It Ends in Time: Turkish Court of Cassation on the Time to Sue](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/eviction-for-need-mediation-before-time-to-sue): Under Turkish law, the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, resolving a conflict between decisions of a regional court of appeal, unanimously held that a mandatory mediation application made… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ihtiyac-nedeniyle-tahliyede-erken-arabuluculuk-basvurusu - Q: When must an action for eviction for need be filed? A: Within one month starting, in fixed-term contracts, from the end of the term and, in indefinite-term contracts, from the date determined according to the termination and notice periods (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 350). If the landlord has notified the tenant in writing, at the latest within that period, that it will sue, the time to sue is deemed extended by one lease year (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 353). In lease disputes, applying to a mediator before filing suit is a precondition to suit (Law No. 6325 art. 18/B). - Q: Is the precondition met if mediation is sought before the time to sue begins? A: According to the 15.06.2026 decision of the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, the application is deemed timely if the process concluded within the time to sue. If the process ended before the time to sue began, the precondition is not met according to the Chamber’s 2025 decision. - Q: Does the time spent in mediation shorten the time to sue? A: Preclusive periods do not run from the application to the mediation office until the date on which the final record is drawn up (Law No. 6325 art. 18/A(15)). - Q: Does this decision apply to all eviction actions? A: The decision was given for actions for eviction for need to be brought under Turkish Code of Obligations art. 350 and rests on two cases arising from fixed-term leases; it does not assess other grounds for eviction. - [Ecrimisil (Compensation for Unlawful Occupation): Bad-Faith Possessor, Co-owners, Prescription, Calculation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/ecrimisil): Ecrimisil is the compensation for unlawful occupation that a bad-faith possessor occupying property without lawful ground or consent must pay to the owner. This article explains, under TMK arts.683… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ecrimisil-haksiz-isgal-tazminati - Q: How far back can an ecrimisil action be brought? A: Ecrimisil actions are subject to a five-year prescription running backwards from the filing date, so as a rule at most the five-year period preceding the action (or amendment) may be claimed. But because prescription is a plea, if the defendant does not raise it in time, ecrimisil may be awarded for older periods too. - Q: Can I claim ecrimisil from my co-owner (e.g. my sibling)? A: As a rule, co-owners may claim ecrimisil from one another only if the prohibition-of-use condition has been met. Before the claimed period you must have notified your co-owner of your wish to benefit from the property or its income; demanding rent also serves as such notice. - Q: What is the difference between ecrimisil and rent? A: Rent rests on a contract and confers a right to use. Ecrimisil is compensation for unlawful occupation without any contract; it confers no right to use and, even if paid, the occupation remains unlawful. - Q: How is the ecrimisil amount determined? A: By determining the market rent the property could generate in the first period through comparable leases and an on-site expert examination. For later years the amount is computed forward by reflecting the PPI increase onto the first-period figure. - Q: Which court is competent for an ecrimisil action? A: Because ecrimisil is a monetary (compensation) claim, the civil court of first instance is competent irrespective of the amount (HMK art.2). As to venue, besides the defendant's domicile, the court of the place where the property is located may also be competent given the tortious character. - Q: Must a good-faith occupier pay ecrimisil? A: Ecrimisil arises only for a bad-faith possessor. A possessor genuinely believed to have used the property in good faith, relying on an existing right, is as a rule not liable to compensate under TMK art.993. Whether the occupier acted in good faith is therefore the decisive issue. - [Eviction for Personal Need on Permanent Return to Türkiye: Conditions, Proof, Time Limits, Cassation Decisions](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/eviction-for-personal-need-returning-from-abroad-turkiye): Under Turkish law, how a landlord living abroad can evict a tenant on grounds of need on permanently returning to Türkiye under Code of Obligations arts. 350 and 351: the genuine, sincere and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yurt-disindan-kesin-donuste-ihtiyac-nedeniyle-tahliye - Q: I am returning permanently from abroad; can I evict my tenant? A: Yes, on grounds of need: if your need for a home is genuine, sincere and compelling, you can terminate a fixed-term lease by an action brought within one month from the end of the term (Code of Obligations art. 350/1). Mediation comes first in lease disputes. - Q: How do I prove my permanent return? A: The “has returned permanently” endorsement in the passport, proof of leaving your job abroad or retirement, a change-of-residence document and witnesses. The Assembly of Civil Chambers held a resignation letter, a change-of-residence document and witness statements sufficient. - Q: Can I sue while I am still abroad? A: You can, but the need must be real and imminent and must continue throughout the proceedings. The Court of Cassation accepted as proven by witnesses the need of a retired landlord living in Sweden; on the other hand, a need not yet arisen or depending on a long period is not a ground for eviction. - Q: My child will return from abroad; can I seek eviction for him or her? A: Yes; art. 350 also covers the need of descendants. But it must be proven that the need is genuine, sincere and compelling for your child and that the permanent return has happened or is very near. - Q: I recently bought a home to return from abroad; the tenant will not leave. A: A new owner may notify the tenant in writing of the need within one month of acquisition and sue after six months, or sue within one month from the end of the lease term (art. 351). The Assembly of Civil Chambers held proven the need of a claimant who bought a home to return from the USA. - [Eviction of Leased Property: Terminating a Lease for Default, Need, an Undertaking to Vacate, Two Warnings](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/eviction-leased-property): The exhaustive grounds for evicting a tenant of residential or roofed business premises under Turkish law: non-payment of rent (TCO Art. 315), the landlord's need and reconstruction (Art. 350), the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kiralananin-tahliyesi - Q: The lease term has expired. Can I evict the tenant? A: No. In residential and roofed business leases the landlord cannot terminate merely because the term has expired (TCO Art. 347/1); the lease is extended for one year on the same terms. Termination without cause is possible only at the end of the ten-year extension period, on three months' notice before the end of an extension year. - Q: When can a tenant who fails to pay rent be evicted? A: The landlord must give written notice granting at least thirty days and stating that the lease will be terminated if payment is not made (TCO Art. 315). An action filed before that period expires will be dismissed. Alternatively, eviction may be sought through enforcement proceedings (EBL Art. 269/a). - Q: Is an undertaking to vacate signed together with the lease valid? A: As a rule, no. To be valid the undertaking must be given AFTER the property has been handed over to the tenant, be in writing and state a definite date. - Q: I have bought a property. When can I evict the tenant? A: Either notify the tenant in writing within one month of acquisition and sue six months later, or sue within one month of the expiry of the existing lease. The one-month notice requirement cannot be cured later. - Q: Whose need counts under the 'need' ground? A: Only the landlord, his spouse, descendants, ascendants and persons he is legally obliged to support. Siblings, nephews or in-laws do not count. - Q: May I re-let the property immediately after eviction for need? A: No. Without just cause, the property may not be let to anyone other than the former tenant for three years; otherwise compensation of at least one year's rent is payable (TCO Art. 355). - Q: Which court has jurisdiction? A: The civil court of peace, irrespective of the value of the claim (CCP Art. 4/1-a). - [Expropriation Price Checked Against Final Same-Scheme Awards: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/expropriation-price-consistency-similar-plots-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that, although the main principle for the expropriation price is real value, the price must be reviewed for… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kamulastirma-bedeli-benzer-tasinmaz-kesinlesen-bedellerle-uyum - Q: Is the final price awarded for neighbouring properties in the same expropriation taken into account in my case? A: Yes, as a yardstick for review. According to the Assembly, the main principle is real value; however, the price must be reviewed, taking particular characteristics into account as well, for consistency with the prices finalised in the same expropriation area, and there should be no excessive differences in value between properties in similar locations. The Assembly required the files that had passed the Special Chamber’s review to be evaluated. - Q: At what rate is an objective value increase applied? A: The decision sets no fixed rate. Features such as ease of transport and proximity to residential areas may increase the price, but the effect of each criterion must be explained. In this case the 25% rate applied on abstract grounds was not considered sufficient. - Q: May the regional court of appeal depart from the experts’ price and calculate the price itself? A: In this case the Assembly did not find it correct to give a decision by making its own calculation, in a manner not open to review, without obtaining a supplementary report on the reasons for departing from the expert panel’s price based on TAMSİS data. - Q: Is the decision final, and what happened to the case? A: The decision was given unanimously and is final. The decision of resistance was reversed; the file was sent to the regional court of appeal that gave the decision. - [Expropriation Price Determination and Registration in Türkiye](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/expropriation-price-determination-registration-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the stages of the action for determination of the expropriation price and registration under art. 10 of Law No. 2942: summons and time-limits, the settlement hearing, site… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kamulastirma-bedelinin-tespiti-ve-tescil-davasi - Q: Who brings the action for determination of the expropriation price and registration, and which court hears it? A: The expropriating administration brings it when no agreement is reached under the purchase procedure. The action is heard by the civil court of first instance where the immovable is located; cassation review is carried out by the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation. - Q: What time-limits does an owner who receives the summons have? A: The owner notifies the court in writing of defences and evidence on the value of the immovable within ten days of service. The period for an annulment action before the administrative courts against the expropriation measure, and for a correction action before the civil courts for material errors, is thirty days from service or notice. - Q: As of which date and how is the expropriation price determined? A: Value is determined by an expert panel of at least three persons as of the day the administration filed its documents with the court. Net income is used for land, comparable sales for building plots, and official unit prices and depreciation for buildings; increases in value caused by the project requiring the expropriation are not taken into account. - Q: What happens if the administration does not deposit the price in a bank? A: The administration is given fifteen days, which may be extended once. If the price is not deposited despite properly given periods, the action may be dismissed; dismissal directly at the end of the first period, however, has been treated by the Court of Cassation as a ground for reversal. - Q: Does the expropriation price bear interest? A: In 2023 the Constitutional Court annulled the provision on statutory interest after four months. In its decision of 08.04.2026 the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held by majority that the annulment also applies to actions not yet final and that the price bears the highest interest rate applied to public receivables from the date of the action to the date of judgment. - Q: Can the registration ruling be challenged, and what happens if the price is reduced on appeal? A: The registration ruling is final; appeal and cassation concern the price only. If the price that becomes final on appeal is less than the amount paid to the owner, the difference is claimed from the owner; however, no interest is charged for the period between the date of payment and the date of service of the repayment letter. - [Expropriation and Easements in Geothermal Resource Areas in Türkiye: The Landowner's Rights](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/geothermal-expropriation-easement-landowner-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a geothermal licence holder gains access to land by agreement, easement, expropriation or urgent expropriation, and only an easement may be requested under an exploration licence.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/jeotermal-kaynak-sahasinda-kamulastirma-ve-irtifak-hakki - Q: Can a geothermal exploration licence holder expropriate my field under Turkish law? A: No. Under Article 12 of Law No. 5686, if no agreement is reached with the owner during the exploration licence period, only an easement may be requested. The Council of State Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers upheld an annulment decision holding that, since expropriation is not possible at the exploration licence stage, urgent expropriation cannot be applied either. Expropriation is possible only during the operating licence period and for necessary places such as drilling sites, transmission lines and capture works. - Q: Does a geothermal operating licence holder company in Türkiye expropriate my land itself? A: No. The licence holder applies to the administration, which is the Investment Monitoring and Coordination Directorate in metropolitan cities and the special provincial administration in other provinces. If the request is found appropriate, the administration adopts the public interest decision and the proceedings follow the Expropriation Law No. 2942. The licence holder pays the compensation and costs. The expropriated property is registered in the name of the administration and allocated to the licence holder while the activity continues. - Q: How is compensation calculated for an easement established for a geothermal pipeline in Türkiye? A: The compensation for an easement is the loss in value that the easement causes to the property (Law No. 2942 art. 11, last paragraph). In a Court of Cassation 5th Civil Chamber decision on a non-geothermal pipeline, the agricultural land was valued on the basis of net income and the easement consideration was determined by stating the rate of loss in value; the rate was set by taking into account the nature of the property, its total surface area, its geometric shape and the route of the line. - Q: When and where is an annulment action filed against a geothermal expropriation in Türkiye? A: The annulment action is filed before the administrative courts within thirty days of the notification made by the civil court of first instance under Article 10 of Law No. 2942, or, for those who could not be notified, of the newspaper announcement (art. 14). Proof of filing must be submitted to the civil court; otherwise the expropriation becomes final. The compensation is determined by the civil court of first instance where the property is located, in the determination and registration action brought by the administration. - Q: Is land expropriated for a geothermal activity in Türkiye returned to the former owner? A: If the administration determines that the land is no longer needed for the activity, under Article 12(5) of Law No. 5686 the licence holder and the former owner are notified that the property will be returned to the former owner on payment of its current market value determined under the procedure of the Expropriation Law. If the former owner does not wish to take it back within six months, the property remains with the administration. - [Expropriation and the Owner's Rights](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/expropriation-owners-rights): A comprehensive guide to expropriation and the owner's rights: the constitutional basis and the real-value principle; the purchase-by-agreement procedure (Law No. 2942, Art. 8); the court… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-26; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kamulastirma-ve-malikin-haklari - Q: What can I do if the expropriation price is too low? A: You are not obliged to accept the price offered by the administration. If no agreement is reached at the purchase (reconciliation) stage, the price is determined by the court through an independent panel of experts. If the property is a building plot, the real value is determined by the comparable-sales method; if it is land, by the net-income (capitalisation) method, with objective value-increasing factors added according to location. - Q: What can I do if the administration took my property without expropriation? A: This is de facto expropriation. If it has been physically taken and a facility (road, pylon, school, etc.) built on it, relying on your right of property you may claim the price (compensation) of the part taken before the civil courts, and the property is registered in the administration's name. You may also assert your right where the property has been allocated to a public area by the zoning plan without implementation (legal taking). - Q: What is the time-limit to challenge the expropriation act? A: An annulment action before the administrative courts (for unlawfulness) and a correction action before the civil courts (for material errors) may be brought within thirty days of notification or publication (Art. 14). This period is a forfeiture period; if it is missed, the act becomes final. As to price, the principal safeguard is the real value the court will determine. - Q: When does ownership pass to the administration, and when do I receive the price? A: Ownership passes to the administration by the registration decision given by the court (Art. 25). The price determined is, as a rule, paid in advance and in cash; the court has the determined price blocked in a bank and ensures its payment to the right-holder. - Q: What is urgent expropriation, and does it affect my price? A: In urgent expropriation the court decides on seizure within seven days after the value determined by the experts has been deposited in a bank; the proceedings other than valuation are completed afterwards (Art. 27). This does not extinguish your right to the price; the actual price-determination and registration action is conducted separately. - Q: Can I repurchase my expropriated property? A: If the property is not used in accordance with the purpose of the expropriation or is not allocated to a public service within the period provided by law, you may acquire a right of repurchase under the conditions of Article 23. The time-limits and conditions must be assessed separately in the specific case. - [Forest Cadastre Title Suits Must Consider Additional Art. 22](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/forest-cadastre-title-deed-cancellation-art-22-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the 8th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed a dismissal in a title cancellation action based on the forest cadastre so that the effect of additional Article 22 of the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/orman-kadastrosuna-dayali-tapu-iptalinde-orman-kanunu-ek-22-madde - Q: Can land whose title was cancelled because it is forest be returned? A: Under Turkish law, if the land has been registered in the name of the Treasury, it is returned to the person concerned if the former owner or their successors apply to the administration within two years of the entry into force of additional Article 22 and repay to the Treasury the total of any payment made. The amount to be repaid may not be less than the current market value; the exceptions in the article remain applicable. - Q: Can the title of registered land placed within forest boundaries be accepted as valid? A: It can. If the owner’s application is approved by the General Directorate of Forestry, or if an ex officio examination establishes the accuracy of the title record, the title is accepted as valid without charge and any forest annotation is cancelled. - Q: What happens to a pending action for cancellation of title? A: The procedures under the article are treated as a preliminary question; for this reason, the 8th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation reversed the dismissal. Actions waived by the parties become devoid of subject matter and no attorney’s fee is awarded. - Q: When did additional Article 22 enter into force? A: The provision, added by Law No. 7584, was published in the Official Gazette of 20.06.2026 and entered into force on the same date; the two-year application period for return runs from that date. - Q: Are compensation actions brought because of the cancellation of title affected? A: Such actions waived by the parties also become devoid of subject matter; once land is returned, no compensation or ecrimisil may be claimed from the administrations. The Assembly of Civil Chambers sent a compensation action based on art. 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code to the 5th Civil Chamber for examination in light of the new situation. - [General Rules for Multi-Parcel Sites Until Estate Management: Turkish Court of Cassation on Common Areas](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/multi-parcel-housing-estate-common-area-action-jurisdiction): Under Turkish law, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that, where a site built on more than one parcel has not yet transitioned to housing-estate management, the general provisions… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/toplu-yapi-yonetimine-gecilmemis-sitede-ortak-yer-davasi-asliye-hukukta - Q: In which court is an action over interference with a common area of a multi-parcel site brought? A: Under Turkish law, according to the Chamber in this decision, if the site has not yet transitioned to housing-estate management, the general provisions apply to the dispute and the action is heard by the civil court of first instance. Sites that have transitioned to housing-estate management were not addressed in the decision. - Q: What happens if a civil court of peace decides such an action on the merits? A: According to the Chamber, jurisdiction is a matter of public order and is observed of the court’s own motion. In this case a judgment that had passed appellate review was reversed on appeal for lack of jurisdiction. - Q: Can a site manager bring an action concerning a common area on their own initiative? A: According to the Chamber, this action is based on the right of ownership and is not among the manager’s duties listed in KMK art. 35. A manager who is not a condominium owner may bring this action only if authorised by the board of condominium owners. - Q: If the manager is a condominium owner, is separate authority from the board required? A: The decision does not say so expressly; the Chamber made the review of authority conditional on the manager not being an owner in the property in dispute. - [Good-Faith Buyers from the Contractor Keep Their Title: Turkish Court of Cassation on Flat-for-Land Deals](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/title-annulment-flat-bought-from-contractor-good-faith): Under Turkish law, the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that a third party who, relying on the land register, buys an independent unit from the contractor in a build-for-land-share… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yukleniciden-bagimsiz-bolum-alanin-tapusu-iptal-edilemez - Q: Can the title of a flat bought from the contractor be annulled? A: In an action by the landowner, as a rule, no; the acquisition of a person in good faith who, relying on the land register, buys an independent unit from the contractor is protected by Civil Code art. 1023. According to the Chamber, if the landowner proves that the buyer knew or should have known that the transfer was made under the construction contract, annulment of title may be allowed. - Q: Does the buyer lose the title if the contract is terminated retroactively? A: According to the Chamber, no; even if the termination makes the registration in the contractor’s name wrongful, the transfer to the person in good faith remains valid. - Q: Who must prove the buyer’s good faith? A: Good faith is presumed (Civil Code art. 3(1)); the landowner must prove bad faith. A person who has not exercised the care required cannot claim good faith (Civil Code art. 3(2)). - Q: Is the title given to the contractor an “advance title”? A: According to the Chamber, no; the concept has no place in the Turkish law of property, and a transfer of title cannot be made conditional. - [Good-Faith Third Parties in Title Annulment Actions: Turkish Civil Code Art. 1023, Bad Faith, Annotations](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/good-faith-third-party-annulment-of-title-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the protection under Civil Code art. 1023, in an action for annulment of title, of a third party who acquired a property or a mortgage relying on a wrongful registration: the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tapu-iptali-ve-tescil-davasinda-iyiniyetli-ucuncu-kisi - Q: Is a good-faith third party protected in an action for annulment of title? A: Yes. Under Turkish law, a third party who acquires ownership or another right in rem such as a mortgage relying in good faith on a wrongful registration is protected (Civil Code art. 1023). A person who knew or should have known of the irregularity is not protected (art. 1024). - Q: Who must prove that the third party acted in bad faith? A: Because good faith is presumed, the claimant must prove bad faith, relying on circumstantial presumptions such as frequent changes of hands, a sale far below market value, a close relationship between the parties or buying without seeing the property. The allegation of bad faith is an objection and is taken into account by the court of its own motion. - Q: Is a person who buys while a “subject of litigation” (davalıdır) annotation is on the register in good faith? A: No. No one may claim not to know an entry in the land register. The Assembly of Civil Chambers accepted as undisputed that a last owner who bought the property with the “subject of litigation” annotation after the action had been filed cannot benefit from the protection of Civil Code art. 1023. - Q: What happens if the property is sold while the annulment action is pending? A: Under Code of Civil Procedure art. 125, the claimant may either continue the action against the transferee or convert it into a compensation action against the transferor. Whether the transferee is protected depends, as a rule, on his good faith, in particular on whether an annotation was on the register; however, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, if the chain of bad faith was broken at an earlier transfer, the last owner’s acquisition may still be protected. - Q: Does a bank’s mortgage survive the annulment of title? A: The Assembly of Civil Chambers protected a bank mortgage that had been established before the interim-injunction annotation and in respect of which the bank’s bad faith had not been proven, and upheld the removal of the attachment annotations placed after the injunction annotation. The outcome depends on the date of the annotation and the creditor’s good faith. - Q: What can the true owner do if the property stays with a good-faith acquirer? A: Civil Code art. 1025 protects the rights of the good-faith third party while reserving all claims for compensation. If the property was transferred while the action was pending, the action may be converted into a compensation action against the transferor under Code of Civil Procedure art. 125/1-b; the State’s liability arising from the land register is regulated separately in Civil Code art. 1007. - [Mining Revenue and Tax Do Not Justify Urgent Expropriation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/urgent-expropriation-mining-revenue-tax-eia): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State annulled, in respect of the immovable in dispute, an urgent expropriation decision taken for a gold mine… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/maden-projesinde-gelir-ve-vergi-gerekcesi-acele-kamulastirmayi-hakli-kilmaz - Q: How can an urgent expropriation decision be challenged? A: Under Turkish law, an action is brought before the administrative courts for annulment of the presidential urgent expropriation decision in respect of the immovable. In this case the 6th Chamber of the Council of State heard the action at first instance and the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers reviewed the appeal. - Q: Do revenue, tax and employment data justify urgent expropriation? A: According to the Assembly, they do not. Such data may show the need to expropriate the immovable, but they do not show the extraordinary circumstances required for the urgent procedure or the public interest pursued by that procedure. - Q: Can urgent expropriation be carried out if the project's EIA positive decision has been annulled? A: The Assembly held in this case that it cannot: in view of the uncertainty created by the administrative court's annulment of the EIA positive decision, the urgent expropriation method cannot be applied. The decision does not state whether the annulment of the EIA decision had become final. - Q: Was the decision unanimous? A: No. The decision is final and was given by majority on both the merits and the reasoning. One dissenting opinion favours upholding the dismissal; the other favours annulment on the EIA ground alone. - [Pre-emption Lost If Partition Sale Ends Co-ownership: Turkish Court of Cassation on Pending Suits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-lost-partition-sale-co-ownership-ends): Under Turkish law, the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that a plaintiff whose co-ownership ends because the immovable is sold through enforcement proceedings while a pre-emption… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/onalim-davasi-surerken-ortakligin-giderilmesi-satisi - Q: What happens if the property is sold at a partition auction while a pre-emption action is pending? A: Under Turkish law, according to the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, if the sale becomes final and the plaintiff no longer holds a share in the immovable, the plaintiff loses the right of pre-emption and the action is dismissed. The Chamber referred to the sale in this case as a sale through enforcement proceedings. - Q: Is it enough to be a co-owner on the date the action is brought? A: No. According to the Chamber, the right of pre-emption exists as long as the co-ownership relationship continues, and the plaintiff must retain co-ownership while the proceedings continue. - Q: Does the result change if the action has been converted into a claim for compensation under Code of Civil Procedure art. 125? A: It did not in this case. The plaintiff had converted the action into a monetary claim and the first-instance court had awarded the difference between the pre-emption price and the auction price; the Chamber reversed that judgment, stating that the action should have been dismissed because co-ownership had ended. - Q: Can co-owners exercise pre-emption against a partition auction? A: Under Turkish Civil Code art. 733/1, the right of pre-emption cannot be exercised in sales by compulsory auction. This decision, however, did not concern pre-emption against the auction; it concerned the fate of an action brought over a sale of shares made before the auction. - [Pre-emption Price Valued at Filing Date or 25.12.2025: Turkish Court of Cassation on Law No. 7571](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-price-market-value-valuation-date-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, the market value forming the pre-emption price is assessed as at the filing date in actions brought after 25.12.2025… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04; updated: 2026-11-17. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/onalimda-rayic-bedel-hangi-tarihe-gore-belirlenir - Q: How is the pre-emption price determined after Law No. 7571? A: The market value of the share in dispute is determined by the judge without delay; the holder of the right must deposit that amount, together with the land registry costs borne by the buyer, in cash within the peremptory period given (Turkish Civil Code art. 734(2)). The Constitutional Court has annulled that rule; since the annulment takes effect on 6 August 2027, it applies until then. - Q: As at which date is the market value assessed in a pre-emption action? A: According to the 7th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation, the market value at the filing date applies to actions brought after 25.12.2025, and the market value as at 25.12.2025 applies to actions pending on that date. The statute contains no express rule on this point. - Q: What happens to the amount already deposited in a pending action? A: The amount deposited and its yield are set off against the market value of the share as at 25.12.2025; any shortfall is deposited into the same account (Turkish Civil Code provisional art. 1(2)). Provisional art. 1(2), which applies the rule to pending actions, has also been annulled by the Constitutional Court, with effect from 6 August 2027. - Q: Has the Assembly of Civil Chambers fixed the valuation date? A: No. In its decision of 01.04.2026, the Assembly of Civil Chambers stated that the new price rule also applies to pending actions, but did not lay down a criterion for the valuation date. - [Pre-emption in a Neighbouring (Adjacent) Agricultural Parcel: Repealed in 2020 (Soil Protection Law Art. 8/İ)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-neighbouring-agricultural-parcel): Pre-emption in a neighbouring (adjacent) agricultural parcel: the scope and conditions of the adjacent-agricultural-landowner pre-emption introduced in 2014 by Art. 8/İ of the Soil Protection Law No.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-28; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/toprak-koruma-kanununda-komsu-parsel-onalim - Q: My neighbouring field was sold; do I have a pre-emption right? A: As a rule, no, today. Adjacent (neighbouring) agricultural-land pre-emption was repealed on 04.11.2020. For sales after that date the neighbouring owner has no pre-emption right. Only if you are a co-owner of the same immovable may co-owner pre-emption (Civil Code Art. 732) come into play. - Q: Can I still sue over a sale made before 04.11.2020? A: Since vested rights are protected, a pre-emption right that arose in sales made before the repeal may be asserted; but you must have been the full owner of the adjacent immovable on the sale date and comply with the time limits. This must be assessed carefully on the facts. - Q: Did neighbouring pre-emption apply to the sale of a share? A: No. As the Constitutional Court stated, adjacent pre-emption arose only on the sale of the whole land (parcel); it did not apply to the sale of a share in a parcel. - Q: What if more than one neighbour sought pre-emption? A: The judge transferred the immovable to the adjacent owner forming an agricultural integrity. Factors such as the type of agricultural activity were investigated ex officio in determining agricultural integrity. - Q: Was co-owner pre-emption also repealed? A: No. The co-owner's pre-emption right in co-ownership (Civil Code Art. 732) remains in force and is independent of adjacent agricultural-land pre-emption. - [Promise to Sell Real Estate in Türkiye: Registration Action, Termination, Limitation and Informal Sales](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/promise-to-sell-real-estate-registration-action-turkiye): Under Turkish law: conditions for claiming registration on the basis of a notarised promise to sell, why unilateral termination is ineffective, the ten-year limitation period and the return of the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tasinmaz-satis-vaadi-sozlesmesi-tescil-davasi-ve-harici-satis - Q: What can a buyer do if the seller refuses to transfer title despite a notarised promise to sell real estate in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law the promisee may file an action for annulment of title and registration under Civil Code art. 716 and ask the court to transfer ownership by judgment. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the seller's failure to attend the land registry does not prevent this action, but the agreed price must have been paid or the unpaid part deposited. - Q: Can a promise to sell real estate be terminated unilaterally under Turkish law? A: According to Assembly of Civil Chambers decision K. 2025/85, a promise to sell registered real estate cannot be terminated by a unilateral declaration. If the parties do not agree on termination, termination can only take place by court judgment; without a proper termination the buyer keeps the right to demand registration. - Q: What is the limitation period for a registration action based on a promise to sell real estate in Türkiye? A: According to the chamber view quoted in Assembly of Civil Chambers decision K. 2024/488, since no special period exists, the ten-year limitation period applies and starts when performance of the contract becomes possible. If the property has been delivered to the buyer, a limitation defence raised after ten years is not heard under the good-faith rule. Limitation is not considered by the judge of its own motion; it must be raised as a defence. - Q: How is the price paid under an informal (non-notarised) real estate sale recovered in Türkiye? A: A contract that does not comply with the official form is invalid, and the parties may reclaim what they gave under the rules on unjust enrichment. According to Assembly of Civil Chambers decision K. 2024/496, the money paid is returned after being updated under the principle of corrective justice, using the average of inflation, foreign currency, gold and wage increases. - Q: Can title to a flat bought by an informal sale never be transferred to the buyer under Turkish law? A: As a rule it cannot. The unification-of-case-law decision of 30.09.1988 provides that, in the sale of an independent unit in a building subject to the Condominium Law, where the buyer has paid everything, the seller has delivered the unit and the buyer uses it as an owner, the judge may accept the registration action having regard to Civil Code art. 2. For a unit acquired from the contractor by written assignment, the rules on assignment of receivables apply. - [Property Inside the Shore Edge Line in Türkiye: Title Cancellation, Compensation and Legal Remedies](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/shore-edge-line-title-cancellation-compensation-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the title to land lying on the seaward side of the shore edge line may be cancelled in an action brought by the Treasury, and the owner may claim the loss from the Treasury under… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kiyi-kenar-cizgisi-icinde-kalan-tasinmaz-tapu-iptali-ve-tazminat - Q: Is the title to registered land inside the shore edge line cancelled in Türkiye? A: Yes, it may be. Under Turkish law, shores are under the authority and disposal of the State (Constitution art. 43; Coastal Law No. 3621 art. 5). The part lying on the shore according to the approved shore edge line is annotated in the land register, and under the Regulation the title cancellation procedures are carried out by the provincial revenue office. The title is not deleted automatically; it is cancelled by court judgment in an action brought by the Treasury. - Q: Can an owner whose title is cancelled because of the shore edge line claim compensation under Turkish law? A: As a rule, yes. The State is liable for losses arising from the keeping of the land register (Turkish Civil Code art. 1007). The owner may claim the real loss from the Treasury before the civil courts. The position of a person who buys while there is an annotation in the register is contested: the Constitutional Court treated the refusal of compensation as a violation in one decision, whereas the Court of Cassation’s Assembly of Civil Chambers, in a decision on a forest annotation, did not accept compensation for the purchased share. - Q: Can a compensation action be brought for land inside the shore edge line in Türkiye before the title is cancelled? A: The Plenary of the Constitutional Court held that making the compensation action conditional on cancellation of the title, for land inside a shore edge line that has become final, violates the right to property. In the decisions examined, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation likewise found compensation lawful for the seaward part of land still registered in the owner’s name, and required the line to be approved by the administration or final by judgment. - Q: What is the limitation period for a shore edge line compensation action under Turkish law? A: The Court of Cassation’s Assembly of Civil Chambers decided that the ten-year general limitation period applies to an action based on art. 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code and, in the case before it, counted the period from the date the title cancellation judgment became final (today’s counterpart is art. 146 of the Turkish Code of Obligations). When the period starts in actions brought before the title is cancelled is not expressly discussed in the decisions examined. - Q: As of which date is the land valued for shore edge line compensation in Türkiye? A: In the two decisions of the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation examined, the value of the land on the date of the action was taken as the basis; agricultural land is valued by the net income method and building plots by precedent sales. In a file recounted in an Assembly of Civil Chambers decision that ended on procedural grounds, however, the year the cancellation judgment became final had been used; the valuation date may therefore need to be argued separately in the file. - Q: How is the determination of the shore edge line objected to in Türkiye, and within what time must an annulment action be brought? A: Under the Regulation the line is announced for one month; those concerned may object to the governorship within that period and the Ministry decides the objection. An action for annulment of the line is brought before the administrative court; as the Coastal Law contains no special period, the general time limit is sixty days (Administrative Procedure Law art. 7). The (since closed) 14th Chamber of the Council of State, in a 2016 decision, accepted that, in a matter concerning the right to property, a fresh application may be made to the administration and an action brought within sixty days against the refusal. - [Rent Case Costs on Landlord If Tenant Exits Before New Term: Turkish Court of Cassation on Early Rent Suits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/rent-determination-action-tenant-vacates-litigation-costs): Under Turkish law, the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, resolving a conflict between regional courts of appeal, held that where a rent determination action is brought before the period… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kira-tespit-davasi-acildiktan-sonra-kiraci-cikarsa-yargilama-giderleri - Q: What happens if the tenant leaves after a rent determination action has been brought? A: Under Turkish law, according to the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, if the contract is terminated and the premises are vacated before the new rental period begins, the action becomes devoid of subject matter. The court does not decide on the merits; it determines the costs of proceedings under Code of Civil Procedure art. 331/1 according to the parties’ degree of justification on the date the action was brought. - Q: Who pays the costs of proceedings in that case? A: If the action was brought before the period for which determination is sought and the tenant left before the new period began, according to the Chamber the tenant is not regarded as having caused the action; the costs of proceedings are left with the landlord. - Q: Can the landlord bring a rent determination action before the new period begins? A: Yes. Under Code of Obligations art. 345 the action may be brought at any time. According to the Chamber, this rule does not prevent the tenant from exercising its legal right and does not lead to the conclusion that the action brought was justified. - Q: What must the tenant do in order not to renew the contract? A: The Chamber stated that under Code of Obligations art. 347, in fixed-term leases of residential and roofed business premises, the tenant may decline to renew the contract by giving notice at least fifteen days before the end of its term. The decision’s reasoning rests on the contract being ended in compliance with this statutory period; the operative part, however, does not mention notice and refers only to vacating before the new rental period begins. - Q: Is the result the same if the tenant leaves after the new period has begun? A: This decision did not address that situation; the conflict was limited to cases where the tenant left before the new rental period began. - [Revoking a Gift of Real Estate in Türkiye: Conditional Gifts, Grounds and the One-Year Period (TCO 295–297)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/revocation-of-gift-real-estate-turkiye): Under Turkish law, donated real estate can be taken back only on the three grounds in Code of Obligations art. 295 and within one year of learning of the ground; the Court of Cassation strictly… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/bagistan-donme-ve-tapu-iptali-sartli-bagis-ve-bir-yillik-sure - Q: In which cases can donated real estate be taken back under Turkish law? A: Under Code of Obligations art. 295, the donor may revoke the gift if the donee has committed a serious offence against the donor or the donor's relatives, has seriously breached legal obligations towards the donor or the donor's family, or has failed without good reason to perform the burden in a gift subject to a burden. For real estate, revocation is pursued by an action for annulment of title and registration. - Q: Within what period must an action to revoke a gift be filed in Türkiye? A: The donor may revoke the gift within one year from the day on which the donor learns of the ground for revocation (Code of Obligations art. 297). The 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation treats this period as preclusive and, for gifts subject to a burden, starts it from the date on which it becomes definitely clear that the purpose will not be achieved. - Q: Can a conditional gift be proved under Turkish law if the land registry deed says the gift was unconditional? A: In a case where the official deed recorded an unconditional gift and no written evidence of a condition was submitted, the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation did not consider abstract witness statements unsupported by material evidence sufficient. Proof is easier where the condition appears in municipal or institutional decisions, a protocol or the deed. - Q: Is land donated for a school taken back in Türkiye if no school is built on it for years? A: Not automatically. In decision K. 2026/4182 of the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, the land remained designated as a high-school area in the zoning plan and had been allocated to the Ministry of National Education as a school site; the Chamber held that there was nothing contrary to the purpose of the gift although no building had yet been erected. - Q: Is a home bought with one spouse's money in the other spouse's name a gift under Turkish law? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, joint investments made by spouses during the marriage to secure their common life and the family's future cannot be treated as a gift. The dispute is then resolved not under revocation of gifts but under the matrimonial property rules, as a claim for value-increase share and participation. - [Risky Building Designation under Law No. 6306 in Türkiye: Owners' Rights, Agreement and Legal Remedies](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/risky-building-designation-law-6306-turkiye): Under Turkish law, owners may object to a risky building designation before a technical board within fifteen days, and the time limit for an action against administrative acts taken under Law No.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/riskli-yapi-tespiti-ve-6306-sayili-kanun-maliklerin-haklari - Q: What is the time limit for objecting to a risky building designation under Law No. 6306 in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, an owner or legal representative may object to a risky building designation within fifteen days; a technical board decides the objection (Law No. 6306 art. 3/1). The designation is announced by posting a report on the building, notification via e-Government and a fifteen-day posting at the neighbourhood headman’s office, and it is deemed notified on the last day of that posting. In the urgent procedure under art. 6/A the objection period is two days. - Q: Within how many days must an annulment action be filed in the administrative court against measures under Law No. 6306 in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, an action may be brought under the Administrative Procedure Law within thirty days of notification against administrative acts taken under Law No. 6306 (art. 6/9). In a first-instance decision that may not yet be final, the Council of State’s 6th Chamber applied this period to a risky building decision and dismissed an action filed out of time. According to the Chamber reasoning upheld by the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, all owners have the right to sue against the technical board’s decision on an objection. - Q: Under Law No. 6306 in Türkiye, what majority of owners is needed to decide on rebuilding a risky building? A: Under Turkish law, rebuilding, the sale of shares and methods such as flat-for-land arrangements are decided by an absolute majority of the co-owners in proportion to their shares, whether or not they own part of the building (art. 6/1). The ratio is calculated by land shares, not by head count. This ratio was introduced by Law No. 7471; before 9 November 2023 the text required at least a two-thirds majority. - Q: Under Turkish law, what happens to the land share of an owner who does not join the majority decision on a risky building? A: Under Turkish law, the majority notifies the dissenting owner of an offer containing the decision and the terms of agreement through a notary or by a fifteen-day posting at the neighbourhood headman’s office. If the offer is not examined or accepted within fifteen days, the land share is sold by public auction to the agreeing co-owners for not less than the market value determined at the instance of the Presidency (art. 6/1). The sale may be challenged in the administrative court; the Council of State has required the market value to be determined through on-site inspection and expert examination. - Q: What rights does a tenant in a risky building have under Law No. 6306 in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, the designation is deemed notified, through the special procedure in the Law, to holders of real and personal rights (such as tenants) (art. 3/2). Tenants of buildings vacated by agreement may be given temporary housing or business premises or rent assistance (art. 5/1); a tenant who has lived or had a workplace in the building for at least one year may be given housing, premises, credit or a housing certificate (art. 6/3). The Law sets no amounts for this assistance and gives the right of objection to owners. - Q: Under Turkish law, which courts hear challenges to the owners’ majority decision and to the sale of land shares in a risky building? A: According to the Council of State, the decision taken by a majority of the co-owners is a decision between private persons to which the administration is not a party; it is challenged before the ordinary (civil) courts. Administrative acts based on that decision, such as the sale of a land share by public auction, are challenged before the administrative courts. The 6th Chamber of the Council of State accepted that the outcome of the civil case may be treated as a preliminary issue in the action against the sale. - [Rooftop Solar Panel Removal Upheld: No Co-owner Consent or Amended Project (Turkish Court of Cassation)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/rooftop-solar-panels-apartment-building-without-consent): Under Turkish law, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation unanimously upheld the removal of a solar energy system and water tanks installed on an apartment roof without an amended project or… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/apartman-catisina-izinsiz-kurulan-gunes-paneli-sokulur - Q: Is the consent of the condominium owners needed to install solar panels on an apartment roof? A: Under Turkish law, the roof is a common area; Condominium Ownership Law art. 19/2 requires the written consent of four-fifths of all condominium owners for construction, repairs and installations in common areas. Earlier decisions of the Court of Cassation allowed solar energy systems without consent under certain conditions; in upholding the removal in the 2026 decision, the Chamber relied on the absence of an amended project and sufficient consent; however, it had also been established in the case that the system would adversely affect the load-bearing structure, and the Chamber did not address the earlier practice. - Q: Is a panel removed even if it occupies an area in proportion to the land share? A: In this case the system, at 6 m², was proportionate to the defendant’s 1/6 land share and there was room on the roof for everyone; nevertheless, the removal order was upheld because of the structural risk and the lack of consent. - Q: Is a solar energy system protected because it is useful? A: According to the regional court, even a useful work is removed if it damages the structural integrity and load-bearing structure of the main building; the Court of Cassation upheld that decision. - Q: What should be considered before installing a system on the roof? A: The written consent of four-fifths of the condominium owners, an amended project where required, and a technical examination of whether the building can carry the load. For systems installed without consent, earlier decisions required that the land share not be exceeded, that there be enough room for everyone, that the installation follow good technical practice and that it not damage the load-bearing structure. - [Shared Title Deeds in Türkiye: Selling a Share, Partition and Conversion to a Single Title](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/shared-title-deed-turkiye-share-sale-partition-single-title): Under Turkish law, a co-owner may sell his or her share alone, but if it is sold to a third party the other co-owners have a right of pre-emption. A shared title becomes a single title by gathering… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-04; updated: 2026-11-17. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/hisseli-tapu-satis-ayirma-ve-tek-tapuya-cevirme - Q: Can a shared title deed be converted into a single title? A: Yes. Under Turkish law the shares can be gathered in one co-owner, the property can be subdivided in line with zoning legislation if the co-owners agree, or condominium ownership can be established in a building. Failing agreement, dissolution of co-ownership is sought before the civil court of peace after mediation; the court partitions in kind where possible and otherwise orders a sale. - Q: Do I need the other co-owners’ consent to sell my share? A: No; the share may be transferred (Turkish Civil Code art. 688/3). If it is sold to a third party, the other co-owners may exercise pre-emption. Selling the whole property requires all co-owners’ consent; on agricultural land, transfer of shares requires the Ministry’s permission. - Q: Can I sell a particular part of a co-owned property? A: No. What can be sold is the fraction in the register. A separate title for a particular area arises only through subdivision, condominium ownership or partition in kind in an action for dissolution of co-ownership. - Q: Can a co-owned field be divided? A: Only if the resulting parcels do not fall below the minimum agricultural land size and the necessary permission is obtained. Subdivision, splitting into shares and increasing the number of shares or co-owners below the minimum size are prohibited; the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers does not allow this rule to be circumvented by means such as accepting a claim. - Q: How is an inherited title converted into a shared title? A: Any heir may ask the land registry to convert joint ownership into co-ownership in shares. If the other heirs do not object or bring an action for partition in time, the title is registered in shares in the heirs’ names (Cadastre Law additional art. 3). On agricultural land, this requires the Ministry’s permission. - [Short-Term Tourist Rentals in Türkiye: The Permit, Flat Owners' Unanimous Decision and Administrative Fines](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/short-term-tourist-rental-permit-fines-turkiye): Under Turkish law, letting a dwelling for one hundred days or less requires a permit under Law No. 7464, and in a building with more than one independent unit a unanimous decision of all flat owners… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/turizm-amacli-kisa-sureli-kiralama-izin-belgesi-ve-idari-para-cezalari - Q: Is a permit mandatory for letting a home by the day in Türkiye, and where is the short-term rental permit obtained? A: Yes. Under Turkish law (Law No. 7464), a permit must be obtained before the contract in order to let a dwelling for one hundred days or less (art. 3/1). The permit is issued by the Ministry of Culture and Tourism, which may also exercise this power through the governorship. Under the implementing regulation, the application is made through e-Government. The application is made by the owner or the holder of a usufruct or a right of construction. - Q: Is a unanimous decision of the flat owners required under Turkish law to let a home short-term on platforms such as Airbnb? A: As a rule, yes. Art. 3/3 of Law No. 7464 requires the application to include a decision taken unanimously by all flat owners of the building; in residential complexes the decision is required only for that building. The Law exempts high-end residences whose management plan allows short-term rental. The implementing regulation additionally does not require a unanimous decision for timeshare and detached dwellings. - Q: How much is the fine for letting a home by the day without a permit in Türkiye? A: Under the text of Law No. 7464, a person who lets a dwelling for tourism purposes without a permit is subject to an administrative fine of one hundred thousand Turkish lira for each dwelling. A fine of five hundred thousand Turkish lira is provided for those who continue at the end of the fifteen-day period given, and one million Turkish lira for those who continue despite both (art. 4/1). These are the amounts in the text of the Law; they are increased every year by the revaluation rate. - Q: Can a tenant in Türkiye let the home they live in by the day? A: No. Art. 3/7 of Law No. 7464 prohibits the tenant of a dwelling rented for use as a residence from letting it to third parties for tourism purposes in their own name and for their own account; the Law contains no exception based on the owner’s consent. The sanction in the text of the Law is an administrative fine of one hundred thousand Turkish lira for each contract (art. 4/1-ç). - Q: Where and within how many days can an administrative fine for short-term rental be challenged under Turkish law? A: Law No. 7464 does not set out a separate remedy against the fine. Reading arts. 3 and 27 of the Misdemeanours Law together, the application is made to the criminal judgeship of peace (the “criminal court of peace” in the wording of art. 27/1) within fifteen days at the latest from notification. This conclusion rests on the statutory texts; as no decision discussing the competent authority could be found, the authority and time limit in the decision served should be checked. - Q: What can the other flat owners do under Turkish law if a neighbouring flat is being let by the day? A: An unpermitted rental may be reported to the local administrative authority competent to impose the fine or to the governorship/provincial directorate of culture and tourism that carries out inspections, and an action may be brought before the administrative courts against a permit believed to have been issued irregularly. In addition, under art. 33 of the Condominium Law, a flat owner who suffers harm because of disturbance or a breach of the management plan may request the intervention of the judge from the civil court of peace. - [State Pays for Land Lost to a Forged Power of Attorney: Turkish Cassation Assembly on Civil Code Art. 1007](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/forged-power-of-attorney-land-sale-state-compensation): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that the State is strictly liable under Civil Code art. 1007 for the owner’s loss where immovables sold… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sahte-vekaletnameyle-satilan-tapu-geri-alinamiyorsa-devlet-tazminat-oder - Q: Can land sold under a forged power of attorney be recovered? A: Under Turkish law, in this decision the owner recovered part of the immovables through an action for annulment of title and re-registration. However, if the immovable has passed to a third person who acquired it relying in good faith on the land register entry, that acquisition is protected (Civil Code art. 1023). In this case, those protected were the later owners who acquired from the first buyer. - Q: If the title cannot be recovered, who pays for the loss? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the State pays under Civil Code art. 1007. In this case the defendant is the Treasury; the action brought against the land registry directorate was dismissed for lack of standing to be sued. - Q: Is the State liable even if the land registry officer was not at fault? A: Yes. The State’s liability is strict liability; an unlawfulness in keeping the register and a causal link suffice. Fault matters only for the State’s recourse against the official at fault (Civil Code art. 1007/2). - Q: Does the fault of the notary or the fraudsters release the State from liability? A: The Assembly of Civil Chambers held that it did not in this case. The Treasury must prove that the causal link has been broken; the outcome depends on the circumstances of the case. - Q: In which court is the compensation action brought? A: Under Civil Code art. 1007/3, actions concerning the State’s liability are heard by the court of the place where the land register is kept. This case was heard by the ordinary (civil) courts. - [The Pre-emption (Şufa) Action and Sham Transactions: Constitutional Court Annuls the Market-Value Rule](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-action-sham-transactions): The pre-emption (şufa) action and sham transactions: the statutory pre-emption right of other co-owners when a co-owner sells their share to a third party (Civil Code Art. 732), the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-28; updated: 2026-11-17. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/onalim-sufa-davasi-ve-muvazaa - Q: Within what period must I exercise the pre-emption right? A: If the sale was notified to you through a notary, you must sue within three months of the notification and, in any event, within one year of the sale. These are forfeiture periods; if missed, the right ends. - Q: Can I use pre-emption for a share transferred by gift? A: As a rule, no. The pre-emption right arises only on a sale of the share; it cannot be used in gift, exchange or forced/auction sale. However, if it is ostensibly a gift but in truth a sale (sham), this may be asserted by proving it. - Q: What did the 2025 amendment and the Constitutional Court decision change in pre-emption? A: Law No. 7571 of 24/12/2025 amended Art. 734; the right-holder deposits not the registry sale price but the market value set by the judge, together with the land-registry expenses, within a final period. The Constitutional Court has annulled that rule; since the annulment takes effect on 6 August 2027, the market-value rule applies until then. - Q: The sale price is shown very high in the registry; what can I do? A: Before Law No. 7571 the amount payable was the registry price, so the sham assertion was critical and had to be proven. Since 25.12.2025 the basis is market value, so a high stated price is not decisive on its own; even so, whether the transaction is truly a sale may be discussed. As the market-value rule ceases to have effect on 6 August 2027, a price sham may regain importance under the rules that apply after that date. - Q: Against whom and where is the pre-emption action brought? A: The action is brought against the third-party buyer, before the civil court of first instance of the place where the immovable is located, and seeks cancellation of title and registration in your name. - [The Right of Pre-emption (Önalım/Şufa): Co-ownership, De Facto Partition, Period-and-Price Reform (Law 7571)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/right-pre-emption): The statutory right of pre-emption entitles the other co-owners, where a co-owner sells their share to a third person, to acquire it on the same terms; it is a formative right. This article explains… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-17. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/onalim-sufa-davasi - Q: Within what time must a pre-emption action be brought? A: Within three months of notarial notification of the sale, and in any event within one year of the sale (TMK art.733; Law No. 7571 reduced the outer period from two years to one). Without notarial notification the three-month period does not run. - Q: I learned of the sale by other means; does time start to run? A: No. According to the Court of Cassation, what is required to start the period is notarial notification by the buyer or seller. Learning by other means does not start the three-month period. - Q: How is the pre-emption price determined? A: Under the provisions in force, the judge determines the market value of the share, and the claimant must deposit that value plus registration costs in cash within a strict period. The Constitutional Court has annulled that rule; since the annulment takes effect on 6 August 2027, it applies until then. (Before Law No. 7571 the price was the deed price plus costs.) - Q: Can the action succeed if there is a de facto partition? A: As a rule, no. If the property has in fact been divided among the co-owners and use continues accordingly, the action is dismissed on that ground, which the court examines of its own motion. - Q: Can pre-emption be used if the buyer is already a co-owner? A: No. Pre-emption applies only to a sale to a non-co-owner. If the buyer was already a co-owner, it cannot be exercised against them. - Q: Do gift or capital contribution trigger pre-emption? A: No. The object of pre-emption is a genuine sale. Transfers that are not sales — gift, exchange, or contribution as capital to a company — do not give rise to it. - [Turkish Condominium Management: Owners' Board, Manager, Management Plan, Service Charges, Annulling Decisions](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/condominium-management): Condominium management under the Turkish Condominium Ownership Law (arts. 27-41): the board of condominium owners, voting rights and proxies, notice of meetings and quorums, amending the management… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kat-mulkiyetinde-yonetim - Q: Within what time must an action be brought against a decision of the board of condominium owners? A: An owner who attended the meeting and voted against may bring an action for annulment before the civil court of peace within one month from the date of the decision, an owner who did not attend within one month from learning of it, and in any event within six months from the date of the decision (Condominium Law art. 33). No time limit applies to decisions that are non-existent or absolutely null and void. Applying to a mediator before suing is a precondition to suit; preclusive periods do not run during mediation. - Q: How is a building manager elected, and what happens if none can be elected? A: Appointing a manager is mandatory in buildings with eight or more independent units. The manager is appointed by a majority of the owners both in number and in land share and is re-appointed every year; if the owners cannot agree or fail to appoint a manager, the civil court of peace appoints one upon the application of an owner (Condominium Law art. 34). Where a manager alleged to have been irregularly elected is in office, a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation found that the conditions for appointment are not met unless the election decision is annulled. - Q: What can be done against an owner who does not pay service charges? A: The manager or any of the owners may sue or initiate enforcement proceedings; the defaulting owner pays late-payment compensation of five per cent per month (Condominium Law art. 20). Finalised operating plans and board decisions on operating expenses count as documents under Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 68/1 (Condominium Law art. 37). A tenant is also jointly and severally liable up to the rent he owes; if the debt still cannot be collected, a statutory mortgage may be registered on the unit (Condominium Law art. 22). - Q: I do not use the lift or the common area; must I still pay service charges? A: As a rule, yes. An owner cannot avoid paying his share of expenses and advances by waiving his right to use a common area or facility or by claiming that, owing to the situation of his unit, he has no need for it (Condominium Law art. 20). Very costly or luxurious innovations and additions are an exception: an owner who does not wish to benefit from them is not obliged to contribute to their cost (Condominium Law art. 43). - Q: Can a tenant seek the annulment of a decision of the board of condominium owners? A: Tenants and others continuously using a unit may request the intervention of the judge, but they do not have rights as broad as an owner’s. In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation it was accepted that, for a tenant to sue against a board decision, the decision must concern his particular interest and directly harm his rights and interests. - Q: How is the management plan amended? A: Amending the management plan requires the vote of four fifths of all owners (Condominium Law art. 28). According to the Court of Cassation this majority cannot override matters for which the Law requires unanimity, and the annulment of plan provisions contrary to mandatory provisions of the Law may be sought at any time. In housing estates, following the amendment made by Law No. 7579, the vote of two thirds of the units represented by the members of the estate’s representatives board is required (Condominium Law art. 70). - [Turkish Court of Cassation 5th Civil Chamber: Most Reviewed Case Types and Current Leading Decisions](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/court-of-cassation-5th-civil-chamber): The 5th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation is the specialised chamber for expropriation disputes. Based on a scan of the official case-law database, this article explains the case types… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yargitay-5-hukuk-dairesi-kamulastirma-davalari - Q: Which cases does the 5th Civil Chamber hear? A: Determination of expropriation compensation and registration (Art. 10), de facto expropriation compensation and mesne profits, easement compensation and urgent expropriation; ownership-based interference and co-ownership dissolution files are now transferred to the 7th Civil Chamber. - Q: How is expropriation compensation assessed? A: By an expert panel under the Article 11 criteria: income method for agricultural land, comparable sales for building plots, official unit costs less depreciation for structures; value increases caused by the expropriating undertaking are excluded. - Q: Can the registration judgment be appealed? A: No — it is final; appeal and cassation lie only against the amount of compensation. - Q: What interest applies to the compensation? A: The Constitutional Court annulled the interest provision in the ninth paragraph of Article 10 (E. 2022/83, K. 2023/69; Official Gazette 01.08.2023). In its decision of 08.04.2026 the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held by majority that the annulment also applies to cases not yet final and that interest at the highest rate applied to public receivables runs on the differential compensation from the filing date until the date of judgment under the last paragraph of Article 46 of the Constitution, without the need for a request; the 5th Civil Chamber has since ruled in the same direction. The line is new: in September 2026 the Chamber upheld, without giving reasons, a regional court of appeal judgment applying statutory interest from four months after filing. - Q: How long does an expropriation case take? A: In the reviewed decisions, about 4–4.5 years across three instances; regional-court reversals extend the process. - Q: The administration seized my land without expropriation — what can I do? A: You may claim the value of the property and mesne profits; see our de facto expropriation analysis for details. - [Turnkey Home Purchases in Türkiye: Off-Plan Sale Contracts, Late Delivery, Withdrawal and Title](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/turnkey-home-purchase-off-plan-sale-contract-turkiye): Under Turkish law: when buying a turnkey home from a developer, the form of a pre-paid home sale, who may invoke its invalidity, the forty-eight-month delivery limit, penalty clauses and lost rent… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anahtar-teslim-konut-satisi-sozlesmesi-on-odemeli-konut-ve-gec-teslim - Q: Is a turnkey home sale contract in Türkiye invalid if it is not made at the land registry or before a notary? A: Where the seller acts for commercial purposes and the buyer is a consumer, the contract is a pre-paid home sale; if the form is not met, the seller cannot invoke invalidity against the consumer (Law No. 6502 art. 41). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, only the consumer may rely on the lack of form, and the consumer may also claim registration if the conditions are met. - Q: What is the maximum delivery period for a turnkey home in a pre-paid home sale in Türkiye? A: The home must be delivered within the contractual period, which may not exceed forty-eight months from the contract date (Law No. 6502 art. 44). For older contracts, the text in force on the contract date should be checked. - Q: Can both a penalty and lost rent be claimed if a turnkey home in Türkiye is delivered late? A: No. According to the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a penalty cumulative with performance and compensation for lost rent cannot be claimed together; a loss exceeding the penalty may be claimed only if the seller’s fault is proved. The right to the penalty must be reserved until delivery. - Q: Until when can a consumer withdraw from or rescind a pre-paid home sale contract in Türkiye? A: The consumer may withdraw without reason within fourteen days of the contract. Law No. 6502 art. 45 also grants a right of rescission without reason for up to twenty-four months; the seller may then claim costs and compensation of two to eight per cent of the price. - Q: Is the bank also liable if a turnkey home bought with a loan in Türkiye is not delivered? A: Yes, if the loan is a linked loan; the bank is then liable together with the seller, limited to the loan amount and for one year from the contractual delivery date where the home is not delivered (Law No. 6502 art. 35). - Q: Is mediation mandatory in disputes arising from a turnkey home sale in Türkiye? A: For monetary claims such as late-delivery damages, a penalty or a refund, applying to a mediator first is a precondition to suit. Disputes arising from rights in rem over real estate, such as annulment of title and registration, and disputes within the consumer arbitration committee’s jurisdiction are excluded (Law No. 6502 art. 73/A). - [Urgent Expropriation Annulment Does Not End Price Suit: Turkish Cassation Assembly, If Expropriation Stands](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/urgent-expropriation-annulment-registration-action-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, the Council of State’s annulment of an urgent expropriation decision only taints the taking of possession… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/acele-kamulastirma-kararinin-iptali-tescil-davasini-dusurmez - Q: If an urgent expropriation decision is annulled, does the price determination and registration action lapse? A: No. Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, as long as the public-interest decision and the expropriation decision have not been annulled, the action is heard on the merits; the annulment only taints the taking of possession under the urgent procedure. - Q: Which action can be brought against the expropriation measure? A: An action for annulment of the expropriation measure before the administrative courts; the time limit is thirty days from service or announcement under art. 10. Each co-owner may bring the action separately (Expropriation Law art. 14). - Q: What if the expropriation decision has also been annulled? A: The 5th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation held, in a case where the expropriation decisions had also been annulled with final effect in an action brought by the defendant owner, that the price determination and registration action should be dismissed. - Q: Was the decision unanimous? A: No, it was given by majority and is final. The dissenting opinion argues that the administration must return to the ordinary expropriation procedure. - [Year-Round Beach Occupation: Ecrimisil Due for Whole Year](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/beach-occupation-ecrimisil-whole-year-not-seasonal): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State held that where an area under the sovereignty and disposal of the State is occupied as a beach, the business is… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-09; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/plaj-isgalinde-ecrimisil-sezonluk-degil-tum-yil-icin-hesaplanir - Q: Is ecrimisil for public land occupied as a beach claimed only for the summer months? A: Not in this case. Since the business was open all year and the occupation continued throughout the year, the Assembly held that ecrimisil must be calculated for the whole year. - Q: Is the fact that the area can be used only in summer not reflected in the amount? A: It is, but in the unit value rather than the period. According to the Assembly, the possibility of summer use had been taken into account as a negative factor in determining the ecrimisil. - Q: What if the use is genuinely limited to the season? A: This decision does not resolve that situation. The 4th Chamber of the Council of State decided whether an occupation was seasonal by looking at whether the land was actually used in the winter months. - Q: Can the administration directly apply the unit value in a final court decision on a comparable property? A: According to the Assembly, no. That decision is one of the data to be taken into account; but a value fixed for a different period cannot simply be updated and used as the amount without regard to the case-specific circumstances. - Q: Is the decision final, and what happened to the file? A: The decision is final and its reasoning was adopted by majority. The part of the decision of insistence that went against the administration was reversed and the file was sent to the regional administrative court. ### Labor & Social Security Law - [Action for Determination of Insured Service: Conditions, Time Limit and Proof](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-determination-insured-service): Court determination of work never reported or under-reported to the SGK: the conditions and parties of the action, the competent labour court, the five-year forfeiture period and its exceptions… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/hizmet-tespiti-davasi - Q: What is a determination-of-service action for? A: It lets a court establish work periods and earnings that your employer never reported, or under-reported, to the SGK. The premium days and earnings are then recorded on your service history, so entitlements such as retirement, disability and survivors’ pensions are calculated correctly. - Q: Within what time must the action be brought? A: As a rule, within five years from the end of the year in which the work took place. This is a forfeiture period: it does not stop or interrupt and is applied by the court of its own motion. - Q: Does the five-year period still run if the employer filed an entry notification? A: No. If the employer submitted an employment entry notification or one of the documents listed in the regulation, the Institution is deemed aware of the work and the five-year forfeiture period does not apply. The period likewise does not run where the work was established by a social-security inspector’s report. - Q: Against whom is the action brought; is SGK the defendant? A: The action is brought against the employer of the workplace. The Social Security Institution is not the defendant but is joined ex officio as an intervening party. - Q: Can work be proven by witness testimony alone? A: Usually not. Because the action concerns public order the court investigates ex officio; testimony must be corroborated by payrolls, service ledgers, neighbouring-workplace records and official documents. - Q: Is mandatory mediation required? A: No. Unlike claims for employee receivables, determination-of-service actions to which the SGK is a party are not subject to mandatory mediation as a procedural condition. - [Court of Cassation: An SGK Fine Not Challenged in Time Cannot Be Disputed in a Payment-Order Action](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/sgk-administrative-fine-objection-payment-order-turkiye): Under Turkish law, in its decision of 15.12.2022 the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that an SGK administrative fine is challenged by objecting to the Institution within fifteen… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sgk-idari-para-cezasi-kesinlesirse-odeme-emri-davasinda-tartisilamaz - Q: Under Turkish law, what is the time limit for objecting to an SGK administrative fine? A: An objection to an SGK administrative fine may be made to the Institution within fifteen days of notification; the objection stays enforcement. If the objection is rejected, an action may be brought before the competent administrative court within thirty days of notification of the rejection; if that period is missed the fine becomes final (Law No. 5510, Art. 102). - Q: Which court hears a challenge to an SGK administrative fine in Türkiye? A: An action against an SGK administrative fine is brought before the administrative court after the Institution rejects the objection (Law No. 5510, Art. 102). For disputes arising from collection of the Institution’s claims under Law No. 6183, that is, objections to a payment order, the labour court of the place where the Institution’s creditor unit is located has jurisdiction (Art. 88). - Q: How can a payment order for a final SGK administrative fine be challenged? A: An objection to the payment order is made within 15 days of service (Law No. 6183, Art. 58). According to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, for a final administrative fine the debtor may raise only payment and limitation; the unlawfulness of the fine or the claim that “there is no debt” cannot be raised in that action. - Q: Is there a discount if an SGK administrative fine is paid early? A: Yes. If the fine is paid in advance within fifteen days of notification, before any objection to the Institution or recourse to the courts, three quarters of it is collected. Advance payment does not affect the right to go to court (Law No. 5510, Art. 102). - Q: What happens if the SGK sends a payment order while the objection to the fine is still pending? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, if a payment order is sent before the objection procedure under Article 102 is completed and an action is brought against the payment order, the court must await the outcome of that procedure and treat the administrative court action as a preliminary question. - [Court of Cassation: Survivors’ Pension Reached by Crediting Days Is Stopped; Recovery Limited as SGK Error](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/survivors-pension-900-days-overpayment-sgk-error-turkiye): Under Turkish law, in its decision of 18.06.2026 the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that credited periods do not count towards the 5-year and 900-day route for a survivors’… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/olum-ayligi-900-gun-borclanma-kurum-hatasi-yersiz-odeme - Q: Under Turkish law, can the 900 days required for a survivors’ pension be completed by crediting military service? A: No. In its decision of 18.06.2026, the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that the phrase “excluding all kinds of credited periods” in Article 32/2-a of Law No. 5510 applies to both the 5-year insurance period and the 900-day premium condition. Credited days may, however, count towards the 1800-day premium condition. - Q: Can the Social Security Institution (SGK) stop a survivors’ pension it granted by its own error? A: Yes. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, if the statutory conditions for the survivors’ pension were never met, the Institution is right to stop the pension; the fact that it had been paid for years did not change that result. The beneficiaries’ request to have the pension reinstated must be rejected. - Q: Can survivors’ pensions paid by the SGK’s own error be reclaimed in Türkiye? A: They can, but only to the extent of Article 96/1-b of Law No. 5510. Payments made within at most five years back from the detection of the erroneous act are recovered; no interest runs if the debt is paid within twenty-four months of notification, and statutory interest applies from the end of that period to payments made later. - Q: Is the Assembly of Civil Chambers’ survivors’ pension decision No. 2026/386 final? A: Yes. The decision was given unanimously and as final on 18.06.2026; the decision to persist was reversed and the file was sent to the Regional Court of Appeal, which will decide again in line with the reversal adopted by the Assembly. - [Determining Farmer Bağ-Kur Insurance in Türkiye: Farmers’ Service and Insured Status (Laws No. 2926 and 5510)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/determination-agricultural-bag-kur-service-insurance): Retroactive determination of compulsory agricultural Bağ-Kur insurance under Laws No. 2926 and 5510; registration, premium withholding from product prices, commencement, competent court, proof, and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-16; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tarim-bag-kur-ciftci-hizmet-sigortalilik-tespiti - Q: Is agricultural Bağ-Kur insurance optional? A: No. Once the agricultural-activity condition is met, insurance is compulsory and cannot be waived (Art. 5 of Law 2926; Art. 92 of Law 5510). - Q: I never registered — do my past years still count? A: Even without registration, if premiums were withheld from your product sales, the Court of Cassation starts insurance from the month after the withholding. But the period before any withholding or voluntary payment cannot be determined. - Q: I only have chamber registration; is that enough? A: Not by itself. Actual agricultural activity (production, sale, withholding) must be shown with concrete evidence alongside the registration. - Q: I interrupted my farming; is my insurance terminated? A: Interruptions exceeding an acceptable period (about two years) may end insurance; restarting requires registration, voluntary payment, or withholding. - Q: My father died; can I have his agricultural insurance determined? A: Yes. On the insured's death, the beneficiaries (spouse, child, parents) may sue to determine the deceased's agricultural insurance to obtain a survivor's pension. - Q: Which court is competent? A: The labour court (Art. 101 of Law 5510); where none exists, the civil court of first instance acts in that capacity. - [Fictitious Insurance and Cancellation of Insured Status](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/fictitious-insurance-cancellation-insured-status): Legal consequences of fictitious/collusive insurance and fake-workplace notifications; the actual-work requirement, the SGK's audit and cancellation powers, pension suspension and recovery of undue… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-16; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sahte-sigortalilik-ve-sigortaliligin-iptali - Q: My insurance was paid although I did not actually work; is it valid? A: No. The essential condition of insurance is genuine (actual) work. A notification without work is not protected and may be cancelled by the Institution. - Q: An SGK inspector drew up a report; can I challenge it? A: Yes. Audit officers' reports are valid until the contrary is proven; you may prove otherwise by any evidence before the labour court. - Q: My employer admits I worked; is that enough on its own? A: No. According to the Court of Cassation, the employer's admission or denial of the work is not decisive on its own; the court investigates ex officio. - Q: What happens to my pension if my insurance is cancelled? A: The pension based on cancelled periods is suspended; pensions paid after cancellation and health expenses obtained may be reclaimed as undue payments. - Q: I was shown as collusively insured with a relative; what is my risk? A: Notifications among relatives not based on genuine work are deemed collusive; cancellation, undue-payment recovery and, depending on the case, criminal liability may arise. - Q: My insurance was cancelled although I genuinely worked; what can I do? A: You may sue in the labour court to annul the Institution's transaction and to determine the service, proving your actual work with payroll witnesses and records. - [Invalidity Pension in Türkiye: Conditions, 60% Loss of Working Capacity and Challenging the SGK Decision](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/invalidity-pension-conditions-sgk-objection-turkiye): Under Turkish law, an invalidity pension requires the Institution’s Health Board to find a loss of at least 60% of working capacity, at least ten years of insurance and 1800 premium days, and a… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/malulluk-ayligi-sartlari-ve-sgk-kararina-itiraz - Q: What are the conditions for an invalidity pension under Turkish law? A: Under Article 26 of Law No. 5510, the insured must be considered an invalid under Article 25, must have been insured for at least ten years with a total of 1800 premium days reported, and must make a written request to the Institution after leaving work, or closing or transferring the business, because of the invalidity. For those needing another person’s constant care, the ten-year insurance period is not required; 1800 days suffice. - Q: What percentage of working capacity must be lost to be considered an invalid in Türkiye? A: For employees (4/1-a) and the self-employed (4/1-b), at least 60% of working capacity, or of earning capacity in the profession as a result of a work accident or occupational disease, must be lost. This is determined by the Institution’s Health Board (Law No. 5510, Art. 25). - Q: Is an invalidity pension granted for an illness that existed before starting work? A: If the insured had already lost 60% of working capacity before first starting work, no invalidity pension is granted for that illness (Art. 25/2). According to the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, however, if the illness had not reached that degree at the start of insurance but progressed during insurance to a degree requiring invalidity, a pension may be granted. In 2025, however, the Assembly of Civil Chambers held that the claim of an insured whose illness already existed before the start of insurance had to be rejected under Art. 25/2. - Q: How can an SGK health board decision on invalidity be challenged in Türkiye? A: On an objection to the decision of the Institution’s Health Board, the Social Insurance Supreme Health Board decides. According to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, that Board’s decisions bind the Institution but not the insured. An application to the Institution is mandatory before suing (Law No. 7036, Art. 4); in the decisions cited, the cases were heard by labour courts and the courts obtained reports from the Forensic Medicine Institute. - Q: From what date does an invalidity pension start under Turkish law? A: It starts from the beginning of the month following the date of the written request if the report on which invalidity is based predates the request, or following the report date if the report is later (Law No. 5510, Art. 27). In a file where the 1800-day condition was met later, the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that the pension should start from the beginning of the month following the date that condition was met. - Q: What happens if a person receiving an invalidity pension in Türkiye starts working again? A: Under Article 27 of Law No. 5510, the pension of a person who starts working under this Law or under a foreign country’s legislation while receiving an invalidity pension is stopped at the start of the payment period following the start of work. If the person leaves work and makes a new written request, the pension is recalculated and granted again, provided that a control examination shows the invalidity continues. - [Is a Heart Attack at Work a Work Accident in Türkiye? Law No. 5510 Art. 13 and Court of Cassation Decisions](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/heart-attack-at-work-work-accident-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a heart attack suffered by an insured while at the workplace is, as a rule, treated as a work accident under Article 13 of Law No. 5510 in decisions of the Court of Cassation’s… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/isyerinde-kalp-krizi-is-kazasi-sayilir-mi - Q: Under Turkish law, is a heart attack at the workplace a work accident? A: In decisions of the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, a heart attack suffered while the insured is at the workplace is, as a rule, treated as a work accident under Article 13/1-a of Law No. 5510. The law makes no distinction between heart attacks and other events. In a 2025 decision, however, the Chamber required a report from a cardiology expert to establish medically whether a heart attack had occurred. - Q: Is a heart attack in an employer-provided shuttle a work accident in Türkiye? A: In a 2023 decision, the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld a judgment treating the death of an insured from a heart attack while travelling to work in a vehicle provided by the employer as a work accident under Article 13/1-e and granting a survivors’ income. Under the upheld reasoning, the SGK circular excluding heart attacks in this situation is contrary to the law. - Q: Is a heart attack suffered by a driver sent abroad on duty always a work accident under Turkish law? A: Not always. In a 2025 decision, the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation did not treat as a work accident the death of a driver who parked his truck in the customs area, went of his own accord to a friend’s house and died there of a heart attack. The decision was by majority; the dissent argued that the event occurred under the employer’s indirect control and should be treated as a work accident. - Q: Must one apply to the SGK before suing to have a heart attack recognised as a work accident? A: Yes. Under Article 4 of Labour Courts Law No. 7036, in disputes arising from social security legislation, except for determining insurance periods under an employment contract, an application to the Institution is mandatory before suing. If the Institution does not respond within sixty days, the request is deemed rejected. - Q: If a heart attack is recognised as a work accident in Türkiye, is the employer automatically at fault? A: No. Recognising the event as a work accident and the employer’s fault are separate questions. The dissenting opinions in the 10th Civil Chamber’s 2025 decisions also state that the link between the work and the event affects the employer’s fault and the amount of compensation, not whether the event is a work accident. - [Notice Pay: Conditions, Notice Periods and Calculation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/notice-pay): Notice pay: compensation payable under Labour Code art. 17 on the improper (notice-less) termination of an indefinite-term contract; seniority-based notice periods of 2-4-6-8 weeks, the two-sided… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ihbar-tazminati - Q: What is notice pay and who pays it? A: Notice pay is the compensation the party who terminates an indefinite-term contract without just cause and without giving notice pays to the other side. It is two-sided: if the employer terminates improperly it pays the employee, and if the employee does, he pays the employer. - Q: How long are the notice periods? A: They are graduated by seniority: 2 weeks for less than 6 months, 4 weeks for 6 months–1.5 years, 6 weeks for 1.5–3 years, and 8 weeks for more than 3 years. These are minimums and may be increased by contract. - Q: Can a resigning employee claim notice pay? A: No. An employee who leaves without just cause and without giving notice is deemed to have resigned; he does not acquire a right to severance or notice pay and may even owe notice pay to the employer. An employee who proves the resignation letter was taken by pressure or threat may, however, acquire a right to compensation. - Q: How is notice pay calculated? A: By multiplying the notice period corresponding to seniority (2/4/6/8 weeks) by the dressed gross wage. The dressed wage includes, besides the base wage, regular benefits such as transport, meals and bonuses. - Q: What happens if job-search leave is not granted? A: Within the notice period the employee must be given at least two hours of job-search leave per day. If it is not given or given short, the wage for that period is paid; if the employer makes the employee work during the leave, it pays that time’s wage with a 100% surcharge. The leave arises only for days actually worked within the notice period. - Q: What is the limitation period for notice pay? A: Five years (Labour Code add. art. 3). This applies to employment contracts that ended after 25 October 2017; for contracts that ended earlier, the ten-year period may apply under the transitional provisions. - [Overtime Pay: Conditions, Calculation and Proof](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/overtime-pay): Overtime pay under Turkish law: the 50% surcharge for work over 45 hours per week (Labour Code art. 41), extended-hours work (25%), written consent and the annual 270-hour ceiling, averaging (art.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/fazla-calisma-alacagi - Q: How is overtime pay calculated? A: For each hour exceeding forty-five hours per week, the normal hourly wage increased by 50% (1.5x) is paid. If the weekly time is set below 45 hours by contract, work exceeding the agreed time up to 45 hours is “extended-hours work” at a 25% surcharge. - Q: How do I prove I worked overtime? A: First by written documents such as entry/exit records, time-clock/fingerprint data and internal correspondence; failing that, by witness testimony. If a signed payroll shows an overtime accrual and no reservation was entered, any excess must be proven by written document. - Q: Does “overtime included in salary” extinguish the claim? A: No. Such a clause is valid at most for 270 hours per year and only if the wage is adequate for it. If the wage is set at the minimum wage the clause is invalid; and overtime exceeding 270 hours is always paid separately. - Q: Why is a reduction applied to overtime claims? A: Where overtime is calculated on witness testimony, continuous identical work every day is contrary to the ordinary course of life (leave, illness, excuse), so a presumption-based reasonable reduction applies. Where the calculation rests on written documents, no reduction is made, and it may not destroy the essence of the right. - Q: Can I claim overtime as a manager? A: A manager who sets their own hours and works at the highest level cannot, as a rule, claim overtime. But if there is a higher manager/employer from whom you take instructions and you must observe fixed hours, you may be entitled to overtime pay. - Q: What is the limitation period for overtime claims? A: Five years (Labour Code art. 32). It runs from the date each month’s claim falls due; applying to a mediator is a condition of the action before filing. - [Principal Employer and Subcontractor in Türkiye: Sham Arrangements, Joint Liability (Labour Law Arts. 2, 112)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/principal-employer-subcontractor-sham-liability-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a subcontracting relationship may be set up for ancillary jobs or for a part of the main work required by operational and business needs and requiring technological expertise; if… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/asil-isveren-alt-isveren-iliskisi-muvazaa-ve-birlikte-sorumluluk - Q: When is a principal employer–subcontractor relationship considered a sham under Turkish law? A: As a rule, the relationship is treated as sham if a part of the main work not requiring expertise has been given to the subcontractor, if the relationship has been set up with someone previously employed at that workplace, or if the principal employer’s employees have been moved to the subcontractor with their rights restricted (Labour Law No. 4857 art. 2; Subcontracting Regulation art. 3). The Subcontracting Regulation also requires consideration of the subcontractor’s equipment and experience and of whether the principal employer’s employees work in the same job. The decision is based on all the facts in the file. - Q: What follows under Turkish law if a sham arrangement is found for a subcontractor’s employee? A: The subcontractor’s employee is deemed the principal employer’s employee from the outset (Labour Law No. 4857 art. 2). The employee may then claim the differences arising from the pay scheme of the principal employer’s comparable employees and, where the conditions are met, from the collective labour agreement. Benefiting from the collective labour agreement may depend on separate conditions such as union membership or a solidarity contribution. - Q: Is the principal employer liable under Turkish law for the severance pay and other receivables of a subcontractor’s employee? A: Yes, in a valid subcontracting relationship the principal employer is jointly liable with the subcontractor, in relation to that workplace, for obligations arising from the Law, the employment contract and the collective labour agreement to which the subcontractor is a party (Labour Law No. 4857 art. 2). The Court of Cassation’s 9th Civil Chamber applies this as joint and several liability. That the statutory words “in relation to that workplace” limit the liability to the period the employee worked at the principal employer’s workplace is this article’s own inference. - Q: Who pays the severance pay of a subcontractor’s employee working at a public body in Türkiye under art. 112 of Law No. 4857? A: The severance pay of an employee who worked without interruption at the same public body as a subcontractor’s employee within the scope of art. 62/1-e of Law No. 4734, and whose last employment contract ended in a way requiring severance pay, is as a rule paid by the relevant public body into the employee’s bank account (art. 112/2-a). The Court of Cassation’s 9th Civil Chamber has held that this rule does not remove the subcontractor’s liability and that the principal employer and the subcontractor are jointly liable. - Q: In a subcontracting relationship under Turkish law, does a sham-arrangement judgment for one tender period also apply to later tender periods? A: No, according to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, final sham-arrangement judgments are binding only for the tender periods found to be sham. The contracts and the work actually done must be examined separately for previous and subsequent tender periods. The Assembly repeated this principle unanimously in its 2025 decision. - [Reinstatement Action under Turkish Labour Law: Conditions, Valid Reason, Mediation, Time Limits, Compensation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/reinstatement-action-labour-law): The legal regime of the reinstatement action (action to establish the invalidity of a dismissal) available to an employee within the scope of job security whose contract has been terminated without a… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ise-iade-davasi - Q: Who may bring a reinstatement action? A: The action is available to an employee within the scope of job security: the workplace must employ thirty or more employees, the employee must have at least six months' seniority, and the contract must be of indefinite term. Employer's representatives who manage the entire undertaking or workplace and have authority to hire and dismiss do not benefit from this security. - Q: Is applying to a mediator compulsory before bringing the action? A: Yes. Mediation is a condition of action. Application to a mediator must be made within one month of service of the notice of dismissal; if no agreement is reached, the action must be brought before the labour court within two weeks of the final minutes. An action brought without applying to a mediator is dismissed on procedural grounds. - Q: Are a valid reason and a just cause the same? A: No. A just cause (Art. 25) is a serious fact that makes the relationship intolerable and permits immediate termination. A valid reason is a less grave one that justifies terminating the contract by notice. A fact may constitute a valid reason even if it does not reach the level of a just cause. - Q: How much is the compensation for non-reinstatement? A: It is between four and eight months' wages. In the Court of Cassation's practice, by seniority, 4 months' wages apply for 6 months–5 years, 5 for 5–15 years and 6 for more than 15 years; depending on the reason for dismissal it may rise to eight months. The only case permitting the upper limit to be exceeded is a union-related dismissal. - Q: I won the case; am I reinstated automatically? A: No. You must apply to the employer to start work within ten working days of service of the finalised decision. If you do not apply, the dismissal is deemed valid. If, despite your application, the employer does not reinstate within one month, you become entitled to compensation for non-reinstatement and idle-period wages. - Q: Is the dismissal invalid if the employer dismissed me without obtaining my defence? A: In dismissals based on conduct or productivity, obtaining a defence is compulsory; a dismissal made without it is invalid solely for that reason. The period allowed for the defence must also be reasonable. In dismissals based on operational requirements, however, obtaining a defence is not required. - [Retirement Through Crediting of Periods Spent Abroad](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/retirement-through-crediting-periods-spent-abroad): Periods spent abroad working or as a homemaker can be credited under Law No. 3201 and counted toward retirement in Türkiye; scope, amount and three-month payment, status, and the final-return… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-16; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yurt-disi-borclanmasi-ile-emeklilik - Q: Can I credit periods spent abroad as a homemaker? A: Yes. Law No. 3201 includes periods spent abroad as a homemaker within crediting. - Q: Is final return required for crediting? A: Not for crediting itself; but final return is required to obtain a pension based on the credited periods. - Q: How is the amount calculated and when is it paid? A: It is 45% of the chosen daily earning. The accrued debt must be paid within three months of notification; otherwise a fresh application is needed. - Q: Under which status is crediting assessed? A: The Court of Cassation fixes status by the last insurance status at the request date (4/1-a or 4/1-b), which affects pension conditions. - Q: What if I work abroad again after the pension is granted? A: Pensions of those granted under this Law who work abroad again or receive a residence-based benefit may be suspended. - Q: If I give up crediting, is my payment refunded? A: Those who give up crediting or cannot meet the pension conditions are refunded their payments without interest. - [Retirement for Homemakers: Voluntary Insurance](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/retirement-homemakers): Homemakers not working under an employment contract can earn pension rights by paying voluntary-insurance premiums; conditions, 4/1-b status, age and premium-day requirements, in light of Law No.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-16; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ev-hanimlarinin-emekliligi-istege-bagli-sigorta - Q: Can a homemaker who never worked retire? A: Yes. By paying voluntary-insurance premiums she joins the long-term branches and, once the statutory age and premium-day conditions are met, becomes entitled to an old-age pension. - Q: Under which status is voluntary insurance counted? A: As a rule, 4/1-b (formerly Bağ-Kur) insurance. This matters for the conditions of the pension to be granted. - Q: How many premium days are needed to retire? A: The required age and premium days vary in stages by the start date of insurance. Missing days may be completed by continuing to pay after the application. - Q: What if I pay premiums irregularly? A: Validity depends on regular payment. Non-payment may end the insurance, and an irregularly granted pension may be cancelled and reclaimed. - Q: What happens to my voluntary insurance if I start working? A: If work requiring compulsory insurance begins, the overlapping voluntary premiums are cancelled and refunded; compulsory insurance prevails. - Q: Can I use periods spent abroad as a homemaker? A: Yes; these may be separately assessed through crediting of periods spent abroad under Law No. 3201. - [Severance Pay on Resignation: Just-Cause Termination](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/severance-pay-resignation): The difference between resignation and the worker's just-cause immediate termination (Labour Law Art. 24); whether a resigning worker can claim severance; non-payment of wages and overtime… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/istifada-kidem-tazminati-hakli-nedenle-fesih - Q: I submitted a resignation letter; can I still claim severance? A: It is the real reason for leaving, not the letter's heading, that is decisive. If you left because your wages or overtime were unpaid, or your working conditions were substantially changed against you, that is a just-cause termination and entitles you to severance. - Q: I left because my wages were unpaid; is that a just-cause termination? A: Yes. Non-payment of the wage in accordance with law or contract is a just-cause ground under Art. 24/II-e and gives rise to severance. Non-payment of overtime, weekly rest, and national/general holiday pay produces the same result. - Q: I terminated with just cause; can I also claim notice pay? A: No. Notice pay is paid only by the party who terminates, to the other party. Because you terminated, you cannot claim notice pay even with just cause; you may claim severance and your other receivables. - Q: The employer made me sign a resignation letter promising compensation, then did not pay; what can I do? A: A resignation obtained by a promise of compensation or by pressure does not reflect a genuine resignation intent; in that case the termination is deemed the employer's. Proving the claim with witnesses and other evidence is important. - Q: Within what time must I exercise a just-cause termination? A: For conduct contrary to morality and good faith, you must terminate within six working days of learning the ground and, in any event, within one year of the event. However, in continuing violations such as non-payment of wages the six-working-day period does not run while the violation continues. - Q: What is the limitation period for a severance claim? A: Five years from the date the employment contract ends (Law No. 4857, Additional Art. 3). Applying to a mediator before suit is mandatory. - [Severance Pay: Conditions and Calculation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/severance-pay): Severance pay's basis (Law 1475, Art. 14), conditions, qualifying termination grounds, the one-year requirement, calculation over the 30-day all-inclusive wage, the ceiling, merging of intermittent… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-16; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kidem-tazminati-sartlar-ve-hesap - Q: Can I get severance pay if I resign? A: As a rule, no. But severance is earned in cases such as just-cause termination (Art. 24), military service, retirement, or a woman worker's termination within one year of marriage. - Q: How many years of service are needed? A: At least one year of service is required. Pro-rata payment is also made for periods exceeding one year. - Q: Which wage is used in the calculation? A: The last all-inclusive wage; continuing benefits such as bonuses, regular premiums, transport, meals, fuel, clothing and private health insurance are included. The minimum-living allowance and overtime are not. - Q: What is the severance ceiling? A: The severance payable per year cannot exceed the maximum retirement bonus payable to the highest civil servant for one year (the ceiling); the ceiling concerns public order. - Q: I worked intermittently at the same workplace; are the periods merged? A: Yes. Intermittent service at the same employer's workplaces is merged; but a period already settled by severance payment is not counted again. - Q: What is the limitation period for severance pay? A: Five years from the date the employment contract ends (Law No. 4857, Additional Art. 3). - [Workplace Mobbing and Compensation: Psychological Harassment under Turkish Labour Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/workplace-mobbing-compensation): Workplace mobbing (psychological harassment) and compensation: the definition and elements (targeting, spread over time, systematic/continuous, intent to intimidate), the employer's duty of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/mobbing-ve-tazminat - Q: Is a one-off negative act mobbing? A: As a rule, no. Mobbing requires conduct that targets a specific employee, is spread over a period, and is systematically repeated. A one-off rude or unfair act, however serious, is not mobbing on its own. - Q: How do I prove mobbing? A: Witness statements, e-mail and message correspondence, minutes, health/psychiatric reports, camera footage and complaint applications may serve as evidence. Conclusive evidence is not required; once strong facts raising a suspicion of mobbing are shown, the burden of proving otherwise shifts to the employer. But abstract, non-concrete statements do not suffice. - Q: What compensation can I claim for mobbing? A: Moral compensation for the violation of personality rights (TBK art. 58) and, where applicable, compensation for pecuniary damage. In addition, if you terminate your contract treating the mobbing as just cause, you may become entitled to severance pay where the conditions are met. - Q: Can I get severance pay if I resign due to mobbing? A: Mobbing is a just-cause ground for termination under Labour Code art. 24/II. If mobbing is proven, the termination is deemed justified and you may be entitled to severance pay where the conditions are met. If it cannot be proven, the termination is not deemed justified and the claim may be rejected; hence gathering evidence before terminating is important. - Q: Is the employer liable for mobbing by another employee? A: Yes. The employer is obliged to protect the employee’s personality and prevent psychological harassment (TBK art. 417). If it fails to prevent harassment by a superior, subordinate or other employees, to investigate complaints effectively and to take measures, it is liable for the resulting damage. - Q: In which court is a mobbing case filed? A: In the labour court. Applying to a mediator before filing is a condition of the action; if no agreement is reached, the action is filed with the final minutes. ### Enforcement & Bankruptcy Law - [Action for Annulment of Dispositions under Turkish Law: Conditions, Time Limits, 2025 Amendment (EBL 277-284)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-annulment-dispositions): A comprehensive guide to the action for annulment of dispositions: the purpose and relative nature of the action (EBL art. 277); gratuitous dispositions and transactions deemed donations as rewritten… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tasarrufun-iptali-davasi - Q: What is an action for annulment of dispositions? A: It renders dispositions such as transfers made by the debtor to hide assets ineffective only against the claimant creditor. It does not recover ownership; it gives the creditor the power of attachment and sale over that asset. - Q: Is a certificate of insolvency required to bring the action? A: Yes; a provisional or definitive certificate is a condition of the action. An attachment record showing no attachable assets has the same nature (EBL art. 105). The defect can be cured even on appeal. - Q: Which dispositions are subject to annulment? A: Gratuitous dispositions and transactions deemed donations within one year before the certificate of insolvency or bankruptcy, certain pledges and unusual payments in the same period, and transactions made with intent to harm that the other party knew or should have known of. - Q: Against whom do I bring the action? A: Jointly against the debtor and the third party who acquired the asset (EBL art. 282). Bad-faith subsequent acquirers may be joined; if bad faith is not proven, the action becomes a money claim. - Q: What is the time limit for the action? A: The action must be brought within five years of the annullable disposition (EBL art. 284). Separately, the one-year look-back periods for the relevant ground and the requirement that proceedings be brought within five years of the transaction must be met. - Q: Can a partner’s assets be pursued for a company debt? A: As a rule, no. If company assets were moved to a partner or group company, annulment of dispositions, simulation or, exceptionally, piercing the veil may apply. For public receivables, partners and legal representatives may be directly liable under Law No. 6183 art. 35 and repeated art. 35. - [Action for Annulment of Objection under Turkish Law: Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Art. 67](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-annulment-objection): A comprehensive guide to the action for annulment of objection: what the action is and when it is brought upon an objection to unsecured (ilamsız) enforcement proceedings (EBL Arts. 66-67); the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/itirazin-iptali-davasi - Q: What is an action for annulment of objection? A: It is the action the creditor brings in the general court to resume enforcement proceedings stayed by the debtor's objection. If the court allows it, it annuls the objection and orders the continuation of the proceedings. - Q: Within what time must the action be brought? A: Within one year of service of the debtor's objection on the creditor. This is a time bar examined by the court of its own motion. If the objection has not been served on the creditor, the period does not begin. - Q: In which court is the action brought? A: Not in the enforcement court but in the general court competent by the nature of the claim (civil, commercial, consumer or labour court). As to venue, as a rule the court of the defendant debtor's domicile is competent. - Q: When can enforcement-denial compensation be sought? A: Where the debtor's objection is unjustified and the claim pursued is liquid (definite/ascertainable), on the other party's request compensation of at least 20% of the adjudicated sum is awarded. If the claim can be determined only through a trial, it is not liquid and no compensation is awarded. - Q: What is the difference between annulment of objection and removal of objection? A: Removal of objection is a narrow/formal route by which a creditor holding the qualified documents of Arts. 68/68-a applies to the enforcement court within six months. Annulment of objection is an action brought in the general court within one year, in which the claim is examined on the merits. Where the conditions are met, the creditor may choose one of these routes. - Q: What happens if I miss the one-year period? A: You cannot seek annulment on the same proceedings; but your right to bring a separate debt action under general provisions is reserved (Art. 67/5). - [Bank Debits During a Turkish Concordat Moratorium: Set-Off, Netting and Account Blocks (EBL Art. 294)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/bank-debit-company-account-during-concordat): In a Turkish concordat, a bank cannot set off against its loan any money reaching the company account after the temporary moratorium is announced; set-off against an earlier balance requires a due… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/konkordatoda-bankanin-hesaptan-kesinti-yapmasi - Q: Can a bank apply money reaching the account of a company in concordat to its loan? A: Not money reaching the account after the announcement of the temporary moratorium; in a concordat set-off is subject to arts. 200–201 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, applied by reference to the announcement date (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 294/4). Set-off against money held in the account before the announcement is possible if the bank’s loan claim is also due (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 139/1). - Q: Can a bank block a company’s account during a concordat moratorium? A: During the moratorium no enforcement proceedings may be taken against the debtor and interim injunctions and precautionary attachment orders are not executed (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 294/1). Concordat courts may order, as a protective measure, the lifting of blocks on funds reaching the account after the moratorium; in a decision upheld by the 11th Civil Chamber, the objection of a bank that withheld a deposit through a block based on a contractual pledge was found unjustified (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/3323, K. 2024/5376). - Q: Is interest payable to the bank during the concordat process? A: Unless the project provides otherwise, no interest runs on an unsecured bank claim from the date of the temporary moratorium (Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/2336, K. 2024/2845). The 6th Civil Chamber also treats a claim secured only by a mortgage over a third party’s real property as an unsecured claim (Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/426, K. 2023/488). - Q: Can the bank apply the proceeds of customer cheques collected during the moratorium to the loan? A: According to the 2025 decision of the 6th Civil Chamber it can, if the cheques were transferred by assignment endorsement and the loan claim arose and fell due before the temporary moratorium. If the company proves that the cheques were given as security by a disguised pledge endorsement, the collected proceeds must be returned to the commissioner (Court of Cassation, 6th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/1755, K. 2025/2890). - Q: How is money debited by the bank in breach of concordat measures recovered? A: Return is first requested through the commissioner and the concordat court. If the bank does not pay, enforcement proceedings without judgment are started and, if the bank objects, an action for annulment of objection is filed after mediation (Turkish Commercial Code art. 5/A). The court’s written order to the bank is not a sufficient document for removal of objection (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/3470, K. 2024/9880). - [Compensation in Title Deed Cases Enforceable Before Finality: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/compensation-in-title-deed-case-enforceable-before-finality): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held by majority that where, in an action for cancellation of title and registration or, alternatively, compensation, the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tapu-iptali-davasinda-hukmedilen-tazminat-kesinlesmeden-icraya-konulabilir - Q: Can a judgment given in an action for cancellation of title and registration be enforced before it becomes final? A: Under Turkish law, a judgment requiring a change in the register, such as cancellation of title and registration, may not be enforced until it has become final (Code of Civil Procedure arts. 350/2 and 367/2). If, in the same action, the title claim is dismissed and compensation is awarded, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation the compensation award may be put into enforcement without waiting for finality. - Q: Does the outcome change if the action was brought with alternative claims? A: No. According to the Assembly, what matters for enforcement based on a judgment is not the type of action but the nature of the judgment. The enforcement officer looks at the operative part and does not review the type of action. - Q: What if positive damages are the primary claim and cancellation of title the alternative claim? A: In its decision of 11.03.2026 the 12th Civil Chamber required finality for such a judgment as well. That decision predates the Assembly’s decision; under the Assembly’s criterion, which looks at the operative part, whether the claim was primary or alternative does not appear decisive for a judgment awarding a money claim. - Q: How did the debtor challenge enforcement based on a judgment that was not final? A: In this case the debtor filed a complaint with the enforcement court seeking the annulment of the enforcement proceedings. Since the judgment did not need to become final, the complaint was dismissed. Code of Civil Procedure arts. 350/1 and 367/1 provide that an appeal (istinaf or cassation) does not stay enforcement, but reserve the provision of Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 36 on the stay of enforcement. - [Custodianship in Turkish Enforcement Law: Safekeeping, Liability and Liquidation (EBL Art. 88, TCK Art. 289)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/custodianship-enforcement-law): A guide to custodianship in Turkish enforcement law: what a custodian is and its legal nature; safekeeping of attached movables (EBL art. 88); the debtor, the creditor, a third party or a licensed… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/icra-hukukunda-yedieminlik - Q: My attached goods were left with me as custodian; may I use them? A: No. Even an owner-custodian may not sell, pledge, lease or relocate the goods; any disposal outside the purpose of safekeeping may be an offence under Law No. 5237 art. 289. For an owner-custodian the penalty is halved. - Q: What happens if I do not bring the goods to the sale venue on the sale date? A: According to the Criminal General Assembly, the custodian has no obligation to take the goods to the sale venue; this alone is not abuse of the duty of safekeeping. However, failing to return the goods when the enforcement office requests them where they are kept may be an offence and may trigger civil liability under EBL art. 358. - Q: Who pays the custodian fee? A: Safekeeping costs and advances are first collected from the creditor (EBL art. 95) and are, as a rule, charged to the debtor as enforcement costs (EBL art. 15). But if the attachment lapses because the sale was not requested in time, the creditor who caused this is liable for all costs including safekeeping (EBL art. 110). Licensed depot fees follow the Ministry tariff. - Q: The attachment has lapsed but my vehicle is still in a custodian car park; what should I do? A: The debtor may collect the vehicle by paying the custodian fee under the tariff; otherwise ex officio liquidation under EBL art. 88/A begins. The debtor is given ten days from service of notice. The goods may ultimately be sold, pass to the custodian, be transferred as scrap to MKE A.Ş., or be transferred free of charge to the Red Crescent. - Q: Whom do I sue if goods are lost in a custodian depot? A: An action for damages lies under the general rules against the custodian and the licensed depot operator; the enforcement office may also recover the value, of its own motion, from a custodian who cannot prove perishing or loss (EBL art. 358). If enforcement officers were at fault, the action is brought against the State, not the officer (EBL art. 5). - Q: How can I challenge enforcement office acts concerning the custodian? A: By a complaint to the enforcement court within seven days of learning of the act (EBL art. 16); where a right is not performed or is left pending without reason, a complaint may be made at any time. A compensation order under EBL art. 358 may also be challenged by complaint within the same seven days. - [Exceeding a Maximum-Amount Mortgage: Are Interest, BSMV, Costs Included? (Turkish Civil Code Arts. 851, 875)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/exceeding-limit-maximum-amount-mortgage): In a maximum-amount (limit) mortgage under Turkish law, principal, interest, BSMV, enforcement costs and attorney’s fees together cannot exceed the limit; the excess can be annulled by a complaint… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ust-sinir-ipoteginde-limit-asimi - Q: Can the bank claim interest above the limit of a maximum-amount mortgage? A: Not in proceedings for realisation of the mortgage. The total claim, including interest, BSMV, enforcement costs and attorney’s fees, cannot exceed the limit; if the claim exceeds the limit, no interest may be claimed from the date of the proceedings either (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2022/75, K. 2023/1011). The claim above the limit may be pursued against the borrower by general attachment (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/3362, K. 2024/476). - Q: Within how many days must a complaint be filed against an enforcement order exceeding the mortgage limit? A: A limit complaint is not subject to a time limit; the first-instance court’s dismissal of the complaint as time-barred was reversed by the Court of Cassation (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/8074, K. 2025/1043). If the complaint is upheld, the proceedings are annulled only as to the part exceeding the limit (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/5159, K. 2024/9879). - Q: If the bank has two mortgages on the same immovable, are the limits added together? A: Yes. The limits of mortgages established for the same claim are added together; the 12th Civil Chamber accepted first- and second-degree mortgages of TRY 6,000,000 each and a TRY 2,500,000 mortgage on another immovable as a total limit of TRY 14,500,000 (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/8000, K. 2025/2895). A mortgagor, however, is liable only up to the limits of its own mortgages (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/4750, K. 2024/1808). - Q: I both stood surety for the loan and gave a mortgage; am I liable above the limit? A: In proceedings for realisation of the mortgage, liability is limited to the limit, and being a surety does not change this (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/615, K. 2024/4920). The bank may, however, separately pursue the claim outside the limit by general attachment in your capacity as surety (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/1307, K. 2025/2865). - Q: Does a limit complaint stop the sale of the mortgaged immovable? A: Not in itself; even if the complaint is upheld, the proceedings continue for the claim up to the limit (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/1392, K. 2026/1335). In a collective mortgage, however, the other immovables must not be sold once the limit has been covered (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/8564, K. 2024/786). - [Fees in Allowed Negative Declaratory Actions Await Finality: Turkish Court of Cassation; No Complaint Deadline](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/negative-declaratory-attorney-fees-enforcement-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, a negative declaratory judgment is a whole; the litigation costs and attorney's fee awarded when the action… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/menfi-tespit-vekalet-ucreti-kesinlesmeden-icraya-konulamaz - Q: Can the attorney’s fee awarded in a negative declaratory action be enforced before the judgment becomes final? A: Under Turkish law, where the action has been allowed, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, no. The litigation costs and attorney’s fee are ancillary to the judgment; they cannot be the subject of enforcement based on the judgment until the judgment on the merits becomes final. A judgment dismissing the action was not examined in this decision. - Q: What is the time limit for a complaint against enforcement started before finality? A: According to the Assembly, the complaint concerns public order and is not bound by the seven-day time limit in art. 16 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law. - Q: What happens if the complaint is upheld? A: According to the Assembly, the enforcement court annuls the enforcement proceedings. - Q: Which judgments cannot be enforced before they become final? A: As a rule, an appeal (istinaf or cassation) does not stop enforcement (Code of Civil Procedure arts. 350/1 and 367/1). Decisions concerning the law of persons, family law and rights in rem over immovable property (arts. 350/2 and 367/2) and negative declaratory judgments (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 72) are among the exceptions; special laws contain further exceptions. - Q: Was the decision unanimous? A: No, it was given by majority; the view that the claim, being a monetary claim, did not concern public order did not obtain a majority. - [How to Obtain a Stay of Enforcement Pending Appeal in Türkiye: Step-by-Step Procedure, Security, Time Limits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/stay-of-enforcement-pending-appeal-turkiye): Under Turkish law, appealing a judgment does not by itself stop its enforcement; the debtor must provide security, obtain time from the enforcement office and bring a decision on stay of enforcement… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tehir-i-icra-icranin-geri-birakilmasi-nasil-alinir - Q: Does appealing a judgment stop enforcement in Türkiye, or is a stay of enforcement needed? A: No, under Turkish law lodging an appeal to the regional court of appeal or to the Court of Cassation does not by itself stop enforcement of the judgment (CCP arts. 350/1 and 367/1). A debtor who wants enforcement stopped must, under EBL art. 36, provide security, obtain time from the enforcement office and bring a decision on stay of enforcement from the enforcement court within that time. Judgments on the law of persons, family law and rights in rem over immovable property cannot be enforced before becoming final in any case. - Q: Which court decides on a stay of enforcement pending appeal under Turkish law? A: Under Turkish law, the decision on stay of enforcement is given by the enforcement court of the place where the proceedings are conducted. The phrase “from the regional court of appeal or the Court of Cassation” in EBL art. 36/1 was, as reported by the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, replaced in this way by Law No. 7343, adopted on 24.11.2021. Since the amendment, the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation finds no legal interest in requesting a stay from it. The enforcement court’s decision cannot be appealed to the regional court of appeal (EBL art. 363/1). - Q: How much and what kind of security is required for a stay of enforcement in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, security for a stay of enforcement must be to the value of the money or goods awarded (EBL art. 36/1). The law lists deposit of the money with an official authority, a pledge of movables or mortgage over immovables, shares or bonds and a reliable bank suretyship to be accepted by the enforcement court; attachment of the debtor’s assets covering the debt is also sufficient. The amount should be confirmed against the enforcement office’s file calculation. The State or a person receiving legal aid is not required to provide security. - Q: What happens if the time granted for a stay of enforcement expires in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, the period is not fixed in days; the enforcement officer grants “a reasonable period”, which may be extended only in case of necessity (EBL art. 36/1). The law does not state expressly what happens when the period expires; since the warning in the enforcement order (EBL art. 32) states that compulsory enforcement will follow unless a decision is brought, the proceedings can be expected to continue if no decision on stay of enforcement is brought within the period. It is prudent to request any extension before the period expires. - Q: What happens to the security for a stay of enforcement in Türkiye if the judgment is reversed? A: Under Turkish law, if the judgment is set aside by the regional court of appeal or reversed by the Court of Cassation, enforcement steps stop where they are (EBL art. 40). If the regional court of appeal finds the appeal justified, it decides whether the security is returned; if the Court of Cassation reverses, the court examining the merits after reversal decides with final effect, upon the debtor’s application and according to the nature of the reversal (EBL art. 36/5). If the judgment is upheld, the money held as security is paid to the creditor. - [Improper Account Closure Notice in Turkish Mortgage Enforcement: Are Proceedings Annulled? (EBL Art. 150/ı)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/improperly-served-account-closure-notice-mortgage): A Turkish bank may use judgment-track mortgage enforcement only after serving an account closure notice via a notary; defective service leads to annulment. The article covers the conditions of art.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03; updated: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ipotekli-ilamli-takip-hesap-kat-ihtari - Q: Can a bank bring judgment-type mortgage enforcement without serving an account closure notice? A: Not on a maximum-amount mortgage. Judgment-type enforcement requires the account statement or payment notice to be served on the borrower through a notary, or to be deemed served under art. 68/b (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 150/ı). The Court of Cassation treats this as a condition of the proceedings and requires the proceedings to be annulled if the notice was not duly served (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/9381, K. 2026/2739). - Q: Within how many days must a complaint of defective service of the account closure notice be filed? A: The 12th Civil Chamber examines this complaint without time limit under art. 16/2 (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/1743, K. 2024/7285); the former practice requiring a seven-day period has been abandoned. A complaint without time limit, too, can only be made until the proceedings are concluded (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/1685, K. 2024/6923). - Q: Within how many days must I object to the account closure notice, and what if I do not? A: The borrower objects through a notary within eight days from service of the notice or from the date it is deemed served under art. 68/b (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 150/ı). Without a timely objection, the amount of debt stated in the notice becomes final for the purposes of enforcement law (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2022/75, K. 2023/1011). - Q: My address changed and the bank sent the notice to my old address; is the service valid? A: If the new address was not notified to the bank through a notary, the date on which the account statement reaches the old address is deemed the date of service (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 68/b/1). The 12th Civil Chamber has held that the condition of the proceedings is fulfilled in that situation (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/9760, K. 2026/3608). - Q: If the mortgagor has died, must the bank serve a new account closure notice on the heirs? A: Not where the proceedings were started against the mortgagor, the notice was served on the mortgagor and the proceedings became final (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/8662, K. 2023/1610; by majority). If the death occurred before the proceedings started, the proceedings cannot continue on the basis of a notice served after they were started (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/711, K. 2022/7295). - [Negative-Declaratory and Recovery Actions: Declaring Non-Liability and Recovering Money Paid](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/negative-declaratory-recovery-actions): Negative-declaratory and recovery actions (EBC art. 72): declaring non-liability, actions before and after enforcement, an interim injunction staying enforcement against 15% security, the condition… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/menfi-tespit-ve-istirdat-davasi - Q: Does a negative-declaratory action stay the enforcement? A: Not automatically. In an action brought before enforcement the court may, against security of at least 15% of the claim, issue an injunction staying the proceedings. In an action brought after enforcement, the proceedings cannot be stayed by injunction; the debtor may only, against 15% security, request that the money not be released to the creditor. - Q: What is the difference between a negative-declaratory and a recovery action? A: In a negative-declaratory action no payment has yet been made and non-liability is sought. In a recovery action payment has been made under threat of compulsory enforcement and the aim is restitution. If a debtor who brought a negative-declaratory action obtained no injunction and then paid, the action continues as a recovery action. - Q: Is there a time limit for a recovery action? A: Yes. A person compelled to pay a sum he did not owe must bring the recovery action within one year of the date of payment (EBC art. 72/7). This period is for payments connected to enforcement (under threat of compulsory enforcement); the return of overpayments outside enforcement is subject to the unjust-enrichment provisions. - Q: Who bears the burden of proof? A: It depends on the nature of the claims. If the debt is embodied in an instrument and it is alleged to be without consideration or given as security, the party making that allegation must, in principle, prove it by written evidence (CCP art. 200). Without a beginning of written evidence, proof by witnesses may not be possible. - Q: In which court are these actions brought? A: As to territory, before the court of the place of the enforcement office or of the defendant’s domicile. As to subject matter, depending on the nature of the dispute, the civil, commercial, consumer or labour court. - Q: Can I claim damages if the proceedings were unjust? A: Yes. If the action succeeds for the debtor and the proceedings are found to be unjust and in bad faith, the debtor’s damage is collected from the creditor; this compensation may not be less than 20% of the claim pursued. - [Objecting to a Payment Order and Salary Attachment: Time Limits, Late Objection, Protected Wages (Turkish Law)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/objecting-payment-order-salary-attachment-enforcement): Objecting to a payment order under the Turkish Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (EBL art. 62): the seven-day period, objection to the enforcement office by petition or orally, objections to the debt… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/odeme-emrine-itiraz-ve-maas-haczi - Q: How many days do I have to object to a payment order? A: In general attachment proceedings without judgment, seven days from service of the payment order, and the objection is made to the enforcement office (EBL art. 62). In proceedings based on a negotiable instrument (promissory note, cheque, bill of exchange), objections to the debt and to the signature must be made within five days by petition to the enforcement court (EBL art. 168). - Q: Can I object before the payment order is served on me? A: Yes. The 12th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation treats as valid an objection lodged with the enforcement office by a debtor who learned of the proceedings by other means before the payment order was served; as long as the creditor intends to pursue the proceedings, the absence of service does not prevent an objection. - Q: I missed the objection period. What can I do? A: If the period was missed because of an obstacle for which you were not at fault, you may file a late objection with the enforcement court within three days from the removal of the obstacle, with evidence of your excuse (EBL art. 65). If the payment order was served irregularly, you may ask the enforcement court, by way of complaint, to correct the date of service. Even if the proceedings have become final, a negative declaratory and recovery action should be considered separately. - Q: How much of my salary can be attached? A: The amount necessary for your and your family’s subsistence is first deducted and the remainder is attached; however, the amount attached may not be less than one quarter of the salary. Where there are several attachments they are ranked, and no deduction is made for a later one until the earlier one has been completed (EBL art. 83). Under Court of Cassation practice, current maintenance is deducted in first rank. - Q: Can my state pension be attached? A: Income, pensions and allowances paid by the Social Security Institution may not be attached except for the Institution’s own claims and maintenance debts; attachment requests falling within this prohibition are rejected by the enforcement officer unless the debtor consents (Law No. 5510 art. 93). Agreements made in advance that a salary may be attached are invalid (EBL art. 83/a). - Q: My home has been attached. How do I argue that it is a home appropriate to my circumstances? A: You must file a complaint of non-attachability with the enforcement court within seven days of learning of the attachment (EBL art. 16, EBL art. 82). If the home is worth more than is appropriate to your circumstances, it is sold and a portion of the proceeds sufficient for your needs is left to you; the protection does not apply if the debt arises directly from the price of the home. - [Physical Attachment When No Custodian Is Available: No Licensed Warehouse or Refusal (EBL Art. 88)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/physical-attachment-no-custodian-available): How does physical attachment proceed in Turkish enforcement law when there is no licensed custodian warehouse, the warehouse staff do not come or they refuse the goods? Based on EBL arts. 79/a… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yediemin-bulunmadiginda-fiili-haciz - Q: Can attachment not be carried out if there is no custodian warehouse? A: It can. A movable is attached once it is recorded in the report; safekeeping is a separate stage. Without a warehouse, the goods may be left temporarily with the debtor or a third party with the creditor’s consent, or delivered to the body assigned to provide warehouse services in the area. At the sale stage, however, the goods must be taken into safekeeping or made ready for delivery to the buyer (EBL art. 88/2). - Q: Can the officer leave the attached goods with the debtor without the creditor’s consent? A: By law, goods in the debtor’s hands may be left temporarily with the debtor only with the creditor’s consent (EBL art. 88/2). If they are left without consent, the act may be challenged within seven days of learning of it. However, if the safekeeping cost has not been paid in advance, safekeeping is not carried out and the creditor bears the consequence. - Q: What should be done if the licensed warehouse does not take the goods? A: The licence holder must accept goods ordered into safekeeping. The situation should be recorded and the office asked to write to the operator and set a new date. If the request is not acted upon, a complaint may be filed at any time; if it is expressly rejected, within seven days (EBL art. 16). Warehouses are supervised by the chief public prosecutor and the Ministry. - Q: Who pays the safekeeping and warehouse fees? A: The creditor pays the safekeeping advance in advance, calculated on at least six months’ storage cost. These are enforcement costs ultimately collected from the debtor (EBL art. 59). The warehouse fee is calculated under the tariff in force when safekeeping ends. - Q: The attachment has lapsed but my car is still in the car park; what happens? A: Goods left with a custodian after the attachment has lapsed are liquidated ex officio (EBL art. 88/a). The debtor is notified that he may collect the vehicle within ten days on paying the custodian fee; otherwise the stages of pledgee, electronic sale, transfer to the custodian, transfer as scrap to Makine ve Kimya Endüstrisi AŞ and finally free transfer to the Turkish Red Crescent follow. - Q: Can I appeal an enforcement court decision rejecting my request for safekeeping? A: No. Enforcement court decisions on custodian fees, replacement of custodians and the manner of safekeeping of attached movables are not appealable to the regional court (EBL art. 363/1). The complaint should therefore be complete at the first attempt, documenting payment of the cost and the warehouse or custodian proposed. - [Pledge-First Rule in Turkish Enforcement Law: Can a Mortgagee Bank Go Straight to Attachment? (EBL Art. 45)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pledge-first-rule): A bank holding a mortgage must first enforce by realising it; attachment brought directly against the debtor breaches Turkish Enforcement Law art. 45/1. The article explains the public-order nature… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/once-rehne-muracaat-ilkesi - Q: Can a bank holding a mortgage attach the company’s accounts or vehicles? A: As a rule, no. For a mortgage-secured loan claim the bank must first enforce against the borrower by realisation of the mortgage (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 45/1). Attachment is available for the part of the claim not covered by the pledge or exceeding the mortgage limits (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/3362, K. 2024/476); a bank holding a promissory note or cheque may choose bills-of-exchange enforcement instead (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 167/1). - Q: Within how many days must a complaint against proceedings breaching the pledge-first rule be filed? A: The Court of Cassation treats this complaint as a matter of public order and does not subject it to a time limit (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/1109, K. 2023/7900). However, a debtor who neither objects to the proceedings nor files a complaint cannot benefit from the rule’s protection (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2024/300, K. 2025/571). The existence and scope of any mortgage should therefore be examined as soon as the payment order is served. - Q: If the mortgage does not cover the debt, how does the bank pursue the balance? A: If the finalised valuation does not cover the claim, the bank may obtain a provisional pledge shortfall certificate and request attachment of the debtor’s other assets (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 150/f). If the sale price is insufficient, a pledge shortfall certificate is issued; if attachment is requested within one year, no new enforcement order or payment order needs to be served (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 152). - Q: Can a bank bring both promissory-note enforcement and mortgage enforcement for the same loan? A: Not at the same time. Under the unification decision of 20.01.2023, E. 2021/2, K. 2023/1, as cited by the Assembly of Civil Chambers, two sets of proceedings cannot be brought simultaneously for the same claim even with a “without double recovery” reservation; the creditor chooses one route, and mortgage proceedings started while bills-of-exchange enforcement is pending are annulled as duplicate (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2022/1039, K. 2023/856). - Q: I am a surety for the loan and also gave a mortgage; can the bank pursue me directly by attachment? A: It depends on the mortgage deed. If the mortgage secures only the company’s debts, the bank may pursue you as a surety by general attachment under the conditions of art. 586 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/7479, K. 2021/7971). If the mortgage also covers debts arising from your suretyship, the mortgage must be realised first; attachment is available for the part not covered by the mortgage (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/4387, K. 2025/6585). - [Precautionary Attachment](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/precautionary-attachment): An analysis of the requirements for precautionary attachment, the procedure for applying to court and for security, the ten-day period for enforcing the order, the seven-day and one-month periods… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ihtiyati-haciz - Q: What is precautionary attachment, and under what conditions may it be sought? A: Precautionary attachment is a provisional measure by which, on the creditor's application, the court places an advance attachment over the debtor's property and rights to secure collection of a monetary claim that is due and not secured by a pledge. For a claim not yet due, it may be sought only where the debtor has no fixed domicile or is attempting to abscond or conceal assets in order to escape its obligations. - Q: Is providing security mandatory to obtain a precautionary attachment order? A: As a rule, yes; under Article 259 EBC the creditor must provide security to cover any damages that may arise should the attachment prove unwarranted. However, no security is required where the claim is founded on a judgment; where it is founded on a document having the effect of a judgment, the court decides, in its discretion, whether security is needed. - Q: Within what period must a precautionary attachment order be enforced after it is obtained? A: Under Article 261 EBC, the creditor must, within ten days of the date the order was rendered, request its enforcement from the enforcement office within the judicial district of the court that rendered it. If this period lapses, the precautionary attachment order falls away automatically. - Q: Is there a time limit for bringing an action or commencing enforcement proceedings after precautionary attachment has been carried out? A: Yes. Under Article 264 EBC, a creditor who obtained precautionary attachment before bringing an action or commencing enforcement proceedings must, within seven days of the attachment being carried out (or, if carried out in the debtor's absence, of service of the attachment record), file a request to commence enforcement proceedings or bring an action; failing this, the precautionary attachment becomes void. - Q: How may a debtor object to a precautionary attachment order made against them? A: Under Article 265 EBC, a debtor against whom precautionary attachment was ordered without being heard may object, within seven days — from the carrying out of the attachment where the debtor was present, or otherwise from service of the attachment record — to the grounds on which the attachment rests, to the court's jurisdiction, and to the security, before the court that rendered the order. Third parties whose interests are affected may likewise object within seven days of learning of it. - Q: Can the decision rendered upon an objection to precautionary attachment be further appealed? A: Yes; under Article 265 EBC, an appeal (istinaf) lies against the decision rendered on objection. The regional court of appeal examines such an appeal as a priority, and its decision is final; the appeal does not suspend enforcement of the precautionary attachment order. - [Removal of Objection under Turkish Law: Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law Arts. 68, 68/a and 69](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/removal-objection): A comprehensive guide to removal of objection: definitive removal of objection (EBL Art. 68) and its underlying documents (a deed containing an acknowledgment of debt with an admitted or notarised… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/itirazin-kaldirilmasi - Q: What is removal of objection? A: It is the creditor's request to the enforcement court, on the basis of a qualified document in hand, to remove the objection so that unsecured proceedings stayed by the objection may continue. The enforcement court does not try the merits; it decides by a formal examination. - Q: What is the difference between definitive and provisional removal? A: Definitive removal (Art. 68) rests on a qualified document such as an acknowledgment of debt with an admitted/notarised signature or an official document. Provisional removal (Art. 68/a) applies where the debtor denies the signature on a private deed, following a signature examination, and gives the debtor the possibility of bringing an action for release from debt. - Q: Which documents may support removal of objection? A: Deeds containing an acknowledgment of debt with an admitted or notarised signature, and receipts/documents duly issued by official departments and competent authorities. The document must contain an unconditional acknowledgment of debt; synallagmatic contracts conditional in performance are, as a rule, insufficient. - Q: What is the time limit for removal of objection? A: Six months from service of the debtor's objection on the creditor. This is a time bar examined by the court of its own motion. If no application is made within the period, fresh unsecured proceedings may not be brought for the same claim. - Q: Does the enforcement court examine whether the claim actually exists? A: No. The enforcement court conducts a narrow, formal examination and decides only on the documents. Disputes requiring a trial — the existence of the claim, performance of the contract — fall within the general court's jurisdiction. - Q: What can I do after provisional removal of objection? A: The debtor may bring an action for release from debt within seven days of the pronouncement or service of the provisional-removal decision. For this action to be heard, 15% of the claim at issue must be deposited by the first hearing (or security of equal value provided). - [Return of Leased Assets in a Turkish Concordat: Can It Be Postponed? (EBL Arts. 307 and 294/7)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/return-leased-assets-postponed-concordat): In a Turkish concordat, return of a leased asset can be postponed only in the confirmation decision, at the debtor’s request, for up to one year, if all five conditions of Enforcement Law art. 307/3… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03; updated: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/konkordatoda-finansal-kiralama-malinin-iadesi - Q: Can leased machinery be taken back from a company in concordat? A: If rent has not been paid and the contract has been terminated by a proper notice, the lessor can bring an action for return; the concordat moratorium alone does not prevent this (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/3472, K. 2025/1972). However, if the concordat court has issued a measure preventing the return of the machinery, a contrary delivery injunction may not be granted in the action for return (Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, 44th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/745, K. 2025/976). - Q: For how long can the return of a leased asset be postponed in a concordat? A: For at most one year from the confirmation decision. The postponement is ordered in the confirmation decision at the debtor’s request and depends on all five conditions of art. 307/3 (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/3). If the debtor voluntarily transfers the asset, goes bankrupt or dies, the postponement automatically becomes void (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/5). - Q: Is postponement possible if more than three months of lease rent is unpaid? A: No. The Law lists as a condition of postponement that the unpaid rent must not exceed three months’ rent (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 307/3-c). This condition applies together with the other four; the absence of any one prevents postponement. - Q: Can a leasing company terminate the contract because the company applied for a concordat? A: No. The contract may not be terminated on the ground that the debtor applied for a concordat, and obligations under contracts continuing during the moratorium are performed reciprocally (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 296/1). If rent is not paid, however, the notice and termination route of Law No. 6361 applies (Law No. 6361, art. 31/1). - [Service on Persons Living Abroad under Turkish Law: Consular Service, Public Notice, Unnoticed Judgments](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/service-of-process-abroad-turkish-courts-enforcement): Under Turkish law, service on persons living abroad: the consular route and the thirty-day period under arts. 25 and 25/a of the Notification Law, why service by public notice without researching the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yurt-disindaki-kisiye-tebligat-ve-habersiz-kesinlesen-kararlar - Q: I live abroad and a judgment was given against me without my knowledge; what can I do? A: If service was defective, the judgment is not final. You can lodge an appeal stating your date of knowledge; with defective service, the date of knowledge declared by the addressee counts as the date of service (Notification Law art. 32). - Q: What happens if I do not collect a service letter from the consulate? A: If the notice reached you under the laws of that country and you do not apply to the consulate within thirty days, service is deemed effected at the end of the thirtieth day (art. 25/a). Time limits run from that date. - Q: Is service at my old address in Türkiye valid? A: If it is known that you live abroad, or the address registration system shows a foreign address, service at an old address in Türkiye by posting on the door is defective according to Court of Cassation decisions. - Q: What is the time limit against enforcement proceedings started without my knowledge? A: A complaint against defective service is filed with the enforcement court within seven days of learning of the act (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 16). The time limit to object to the payment order runs from the corrected date of service. - Q: Can I sue my spouse or debtor who lives abroad in Türkiye? A: Yes; service is made through the competent authority of that country or, if the other party is a Turkish citizen, through the consulate. The foreign address should be stated in the statement of claim from the outset; if it is unknown, the address is researched first and public notice is the last resort. - [Third-Party Mortgagor Liability for Company Loans: Acceleration Notice, Limit, Subrogation (TMK 887, 884)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/third-party-mortgagor-liability): A third party who mortgages real property for a company loan is liable only with the property and up to the mortgage limit, and must also receive notice. The article covers annulment of enforcement… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-03; updated: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ipotek-veren-ucuncu-kisinin-sorumlulugu - Q: I mortgaged my home for the company’s loan; can the bank attach my salary or my other assets? A: Not if you only gave a mortgage. A third-party mortgagor is not personally liable for the debt but is liable with the property (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/466, K. 2026/289); no pledge shortfall certificate can be issued against you for the claim remaining after the property is sold (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/6305, K. 2021/11636). If you also signed the loan agreement as a joint and several surety, you are personally liable in that capacity (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 586/1). - Q: Can the bank put my mortgaged property up for sale without sending me a notice? A: No. The demand for payment must be made to the mortgagor as well as to the debtor (Turkish Civil Code art. 887); service of the account closure notice on the mortgagor replaces that demand (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 150/ı). Judgment-based enforcement started without notice is annulled in respect of the mortgagor, and the complaint is not subject to a time limit (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/116, K. 2026/5017). - Q: If I pay the company’s debt, from whom can I recover the money? A: When a mortgagor who is not personally liable pays the debt, the claim passes to them (Turkish Civil Code art. 884) and they may recover the amount from the borrower (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2021/427, K. 2022/1610). You may claim against the sureties only if there is an agreement between you or the pledge was given later by a third party (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 596/4). - Q: Can a mortgagor object to the account closure notice? A: The objection through a notary under art. 150/ı is for the party using the credit; a mortgagor who is not personally liable cannot object in that way but may raise discharge, extension or limitation (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/8932, K. 2023/2393; affirmed). A surety who also gave a mortgage for the suretyship debt may object to the notice in time (Court of Cassation, 12th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/3924, K. 2024/1291). - Q: Can I have the mortgage removed before the loan is closed? A: A mortgage does not lapse by itself while the secured claim exists; the owner may request its cancellation once the claim ends (Turkish Civil Code art. 883/1). An owner who is not personally liable may pay the debt on the terms applicable to the debtor and request removal of the mortgage (Turkish Civil Code art. 884). Ending the security under a mortgage given for existing and future debts is discussed in the article on the action for release of a mortgage. - [Third-Party Ownership Claims in Turkish Enforcement: EBL Arts. 96-99, Burden of Proof, Seven-Day Period](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/third-party-ownership-claims-enforcement-proceedings): Third-party ownership claims over attached property, first in plain language with everyday examples (a son's motorcycle at the family home, a spouse's jewellery, a leased machine, another company at… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/icra-takibinde-istihkak-davasi - Q: Enforcement officers attached my goods at my business or home for someone else’s debt. What should I do? A: Assert the ownership claim at the attachment itself, recorded in the report, and ensure it is made by an authorised person. Accept custody so that the goods are not removed. Have the lease, tax certificate and the serial numbers of the goods recorded. Then bring the ownership action within seven days of the pronouncement or service of the enforcement court’s decision on continuation or stay. - Q: The television attached at my home belongs to my daughter. Should I bring an ownership action? A: Often there is no need. The personal belongings of the debtor and family members living under the same roof and household goods used in common are exempt, except money and valuables (EBL art. 82/1-3). If such an item is attached, a complaint should be made to the enforcement court, as a rule within seven days of learning of it (EBL art. 16). The ownership claim is for attachable property belonging to someone else. - Q: I hold the invoice for the attached goods. Is that enough? A: Usually not. Where the presumption favours the creditor, you must rebut it with evidence that is convincing and free of all doubt: the invoice entered in duly kept commercial books, serial numbers matching the attachment report, financial capacity at the time of purchase, and an explanation of why the goods were where they were. - Q: Does bringing the action stop the sale? A: Not automatically. If the goods were attached in the debtor’s hands, you must obtain a stay from the enforcement court and provide security (EBL art. 97/3). If the goods were attached in your sole possession (EBL art. 99), the property may not be sold until an action brought in time by the creditor is concluded. - Q: If I lose, will I pay damages? A: Only if a stay was ordered and the proceedings were in fact stayed. In that case, damages of not less than 20% of the delayed recovery are awarded (EBL art. 97/13), calculated on the lesser of the debt claimed and the value of the attached property. If you win and the objector’s bad faith is established, damages of not less than 15% of the value of the property are awarded against him (EBL art. 97/15). - Q: I missed the seven-day period. What happens? A: Under EBL art. 96/3 you forfeit the right to raise the ownership claim in the same proceedings. The period is preclusive and examined by the court of its own motion at every stage. The date of awareness is construed broadly — filing a power of attorney in the enforcement file may suffice. ### Negotiable Instruments Law - [Assumed Burden on a Note Survives a Contradictory Amendment: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/promissory-note-burden-of-proof-amendment-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that, in a negative declaratory action concerning promissory notes allegedly given as an advance, a… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/bono-bedelsizlik-davasinda-ispat-yukunu-ustlenen-davali-islahla-kurtulamaz - Q: Who bears the burden of proof when lack of consideration is alleged against a promissory note? A: Under Turkish law, it lies as a rule with the drawer who alleges lack of consideration, because a promissory note contains an acknowledgment of debt that does not depend on its cause. Where the note states the cause of the debt as “goods” or “cash”, the burden of proof falls on the party asserting the contrary of that entry. - Q: When is the creditor deemed to have assumed the burden of proof? A: Merely denying the debtor’s allegation is not enough. If the creditor, contrary to what appears from the text of the note, explains that the note was given for a different underlying relationship and submits its evidence, it must prove this new fact. - Q: Can the defence set out in the statement of defence be changed by amendment? A: As a rule, yes; under Turkish law amendment may be made once in the same action (Code of Civil Procedure art. 176). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, however, an amendment wholly contradicting the first defence cannot be a tool for escaping the burden of proof; it breaches the prohibition of contradictory conduct. - Q: What must the debtor prove for a promissory note given as an advance? A: Where the note does not state the reason for its issue, as a rule the debtor proves that the note was given as an advance for a relationship to be established and that this relationship was not established. - Q: Can the amount of a promissory note paid under threat of enforcement be recovered? A: Under the general principle recited by the Assembly, a debtor who has paid the debt under threat of compulsory enforcement may bring a recovery action against the creditor for the return of the money paid. - [Bad (Dishonoured) Cheques and Criminal Liability](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/bad-cheques-criminal-liability): A comprehensive guide to bad cheques and criminal liability: the offence (causing a “dishonoured” notation, Cheque Law No. 5941, Art. 5); the elements (presentation within the legal presentation… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-26; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/karsiliksiz-cek-ve-cezai-sorumluluk - Q: Is there imprisonment for a bad cheque? A: The direct sanction is a judicial fine. However, if the fine is not paid, it is converted directly into imprisonment without a public-service order (Art. 5/11). The perception of “just a fine, no prison” is therefore misleading. - Q: How much is the penalty for a bad cheque? A: A judicial fine of up to 1,500 days is imposed for each cheque; but the fine cannot be less than the unpaid amount of the cheque. In practice the fine is usually equal to the unpaid amount. A ban on issuing cheques and opening cheque accounts is also ordered. - Q: What is the complaint period? A: By the Cheque Law’s reference, EBL Art. 347 applies: the complaint right lapses three months after the act is learned of and, in any event, one year after it is committed. The period is a forfeiture period; if missed, the lapse of the complaint right is ordered. - Q: If I pay the cheque amount, does the penalty fall away? A: Yes. Under effective remorse, if you pay the unpaid amount in full together with commercial default interest running from the legal presentation date, the case is dismissed during the trial; if the conviction has become final, the verdict is set aside with all its consequences. Withdrawal of the complaint has the same effect. Payment must be full and with interest. - Q: Who is criminally liable in a company cheque? A: If the cheque-account holder is a legal person (company), the liable person is the member of the management organ charged with financial affairs or, absent such a designation, the natural persons forming the management organ. The Court of Cassation holds that liability and the cheque ban apply to the person authorised to represent the company at the date of presentation/offence. - Q: Do HAGB or conciliation apply to a bad-cheque offence? A: No. For this offence the provisions on advance payment, conciliation and deferment of the announcement of the verdict (HAGB) do not apply (Art. 5/10). It is therefore important to set the defence strategy correctly from the outset and to assess the possibility of effective remorse. - [Cheque Presentment Periods in Türkiye: 10-Day, 1-Month and 3-Month Rules, Post-Dated Cheques and Recourse](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/cheque-presentment-periods-legal-effect-cheque): A cheque is payable at sight; it must be presented to the bank within ten days if payable where it was issued, within one month if payable elsewhere, and, if issued in another country, within one… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/cekin-ibraz-sureleri-ve-hukmu - Q: How long is the presentment period for a cheque? A: A cheque payable where it was issued must be presented within ten days, and one payable elsewhere within one month. For a cheque issued in a country other than the country of payment, the period is one month on the same continent and three months on different continents; all periods start on the day after the date of issue written on the cheque (TCC art. 796). - Q: What happens if a post-dated cheque is presented early? A: Until 31/12/2028, presenting a cheque before the date written on it is invalid (Law No. 5941, provisional art. 3/5). No legal proceedings may be brought on a cheque presented early and not paid; for proceedings, the cheque must be presented within the presentment period calculated from the date on it and subjected to the “no funds” procedure (Law No. 5941 art. 3/8). - Q: Can a cheque be collected after the presentment period? A: If not countermanded, the bank may still pay it after the period (TCC art. 799). If it is not paid, the holder loses recourse against the drawer, endorsers and avalists; against the drawer, an unjust-enrichment claim remains to the extent of the drawer’s enrichment at the holder’s expense (TCC art. 818/1-m, art. 732). - Q: When does the limitation period for a cheque expire? A: The holder’s rights of recourse against the drawer, endorsers and other parties are time-barred three years after the end of the presentment period. For a party who paid the cheque to claim against the others, the three years run from payment or from the date an action was brought against that party (TCC art. 814). - Q: What should be done about a dishonoured cheque? A: The cheque must be presented to the bank in time and its non-payment certified by the bank’s dated declaration on the cheque (the “no funds” procedure), a protest, or a clearing house’s dated declaration (TCC art. 808). Enforcement proceedings specific to negotiable instruments may then be initiated against the drawer, endorsers and avalists (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 167); criminal proceedings are a separate route that depends on the holder’s complaint. - [Cheques Not Presented in Time and Unjust Enrichment: Lost Recourse, Art. 732 Claim, Time Limits in Türkiye](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/cheque-not-presented-in-time-unjust-enrichment): If a cheque is not presented in time or its dishonour is not duly certified, the holder loses recourse against all parties including the drawer, and bill enforcement is annulled by the enforcement… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ibraz-suresi-gecen-cekte-haklar-ve-sebepsiz-zenginlesme - Q: Can enforcement proceedings be brought on a cheque not presented to the bank in time? A: Not through bill-enforcement proceedings; such proceedings are annulled by the enforcement court upon the debtor’s complaint within five days or upon another timely complaint or objection (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 168, Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 170/a). The creditor may instead resort to ordinary enforcement or an action based on unjust enrichment or the underlying relationship. - Q: Can money be claimed from the drawer of a cheque whose presentment period has expired? A: Not under the law of negotiable instruments; the holder loses recourse against the drawer as well. However, the drawer remains liable to the extent that it has been enriched at the holder’s expense, and the holder may bring an unjust enrichment action for that reason (Commercial Code art. 818/1-m, Commercial Code art. 732). If there is a direct underlying relationship with the drawer, a claim based on that relationship may also be brought. - Q: Who bears the burden of proof in an action under Commercial Code art. 732? A: The drawer, who claims that it has not been unjustly enriched (Commercial Code art. 732). The drawer must prove with documents that it paid the cheque’s value in another way or that the cheque was given without consideration; the Court of Cassation reverses decisions that place the burden on the holder. - Q: Within what time must the unjust enrichment action be brought? A: Within one year from the day following the date on which the cheque became time-barred (Commercial Code art. 732). Since rights of recourse under a cheque become time-barred three years after the end of the presentment period, the one-year period starts after those three years expire (Commercial Code art. 814). - Q: Which court hears this action, and is mediation mandatory? A: An action under Commercial Code art. 732 is a commercial case and is heard by the commercial court of first instance (Commercial Code art. 5). In actions for receivables, annulment of objection, negative declaration and restitution whose subject is a sum of money, applying to a mediator before bringing the action is a precondition (Commercial Code art. 5/A). - Q: Can I claim against the endorser who gave me the cheque? A: Not under the law of negotiable instruments, and no unjust enrichment claim may be asserted against an endorser whose obligation has lapsed (Commercial Code art. 732). If you have an underlying relationship with the endorser, such as a sale, service or loan, you may bring a claim under the general rules based on that relationship. - [Negative Declaratory Action on Negotiable Instruments in Türkiye: Promissory Notes, Cheques, Bills of Exchange](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/negative-declaratory-action-negotiable-instruments): A comprehensive guide to the negative declaratory action on negotiable instruments (promissory note, cheque, bill of exchange): what the action is and when it is brought (EBL Art. 72); the conditions… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-26; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kambiyo-senetlerinde-menfi-tespit - Q: What is a negative declaratory action on a negotiable instrument, and when is it brought? A: It is the action by which the debtor asks the court to establish that it is not indebted under a cheque/promissory note/bill of exchange. Under Art. 72 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law it may be brought before enforcement, during enforcement, or after the proceedings have become final. - Q: Does bringing the action stay the enforcement? A: Not automatically. If the action was filed before enforcement, an injunction staying it may be granted against security of at least 15% of the claim. If filed after enforcement, it cannot be stayed; the debtor may only request, against at least 15% security, that the money in the enforcement office not be paid to the creditor. - Q: Who proves want of consideration in a promissory note? A: As a rule, the party alleging it — the debtor. If the instrument states value received “in goods” or “in cash” and one party asserts the contrary (talil), the burden shifts to the party asserting the contrary of that statement. - Q: Can I prove want of consideration by witness? A: As a rule, no. Want of consideration, that the note was given as security, or that it was completed contrary to the agreement must, under the rule of proof by deed, be proven by written evidence; a witness alone is insufficient. Payment receipts, reconciliations and correspondence are critical. - Q: I signed the instrument under fraud or duress; what can I do? A: An allegation of fraud or duress (defect of will) may be raised in the action, but it must be proven by concrete, definite and sufficient evidence. Forgery of the instrument, or that the signature is not yours, is an absolute defence assertable against everyone. - Q: Can I sue after paying the debt? Is there bad-faith compensation? A: Yes. If you were compelled to pay without an injunction, the action converts into a recovery action; you may also bring a recovery action within one year of payment. If the enforcement is found to be unjust and in bad faith, the creditor is ordered to pay bad-faith compensation of at least 20% of the claim. - [Presentment and Enforcement of Post-Dated Cheques in Türkiye: Early Presentment Ban until 31/12/2028](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/presentment-enforcement-requirements-post-dated-cheques): Until 31/12/2028 a post-dated cheque cannot be presented to the bank before its written date; early presentment is invalid, and enforcing an unpaid cheque requires presenting it again within the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ileri-tarihli-cekte-ibraz-ve-takip-sartlari - Q: Can a post-dated cheque be handed to the bank before its written date? A: Even if handed over, it has no legal effect. Until 31/12/2028, presentment of a cheque to the bank for payment before the issue date written on it is invalid (Law No. 5941, provisional art. 3/5). Since presentment through clearing is equivalent to presentment for payment, the same result applies to a cheque sent to clearing. - Q: Can enforcement proceedings be brought on a cheque presented early and dishonoured? A: No. No legal action may be brought on a cheque presented before its written date and not paid. Enforcement requires the cheque to be presented again within the statutory presentment period calculated from its written date and certified as dishonoured (Law No. 5941 art. 3/8). Otherwise the bill enforcement is annulled by the enforcement court upon the debtor’s timely complaint or objection. - Q: From which date does the presentment period of a post-dated cheque start? A: It starts not on the day the cheque was actually delivered but on the day after the issue date written on it (Commercial Code art. 796). It is ten days for a cheque payable at the same place and one month for a cheque payable elsewhere; the starting day is not counted (Commercial Code art. 817). - Q: What happens if the last day of the presentment period falls on a Sunday or a public holiday? A: The period is extended to include the first business day that follows; intervening holidays are counted in the period (Commercial Code art. 816). Since presentment can only be made on a business day, a cheque dated on a Sunday cannot be presented on that day. - Q: What is the presentment period of a cheque issued abroad and payable in Türkiye? A: It is one month if the places of issue and payment are on the same continent and three months if they are on different continents; a cheque issued in a European country and payable in a country with a Mediterranean coast is deemed issued on the same continent (Commercial Code art. 796). The effects of a later date and the presentment period are determined by the law of the country of payment, i.e. Turkish law (Commercial Code art. 822). - Q: Why is the QR code important when accepting a post-dated cheque? A: A QR query reveals the number and amount of the drawer’s cheques not yet presented to banks and its dishonoured cheques in the last five years (Commercial Code art. 780). Registration of the cheque in the system by the payee also ensures that changes of company representatives after registration do not remove the liability of the account-holding company (Law No. 5941 art. 3/10). - [Promissory Note (Bono) Validity under Turkish Law: Mandatory Elements, Missing Elements and Limitation Periods](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/validity-requirements-promissory-note): A detailed examination of the mandatory elements of a promissory note (bono) under art. 776 of the Turkish Commercial Code, the consequences of missing elements under art. 777, the bill-of-exchange… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/bono-senedin-gecerlilik-sartlari - Q: What elements must an instrument contain to be treated as a promissory note? A: Under art. 776 of the TCC, the instrument must contain the words 'bono' or 'emre yazılı senet,' an unconditional promise to pay a specific sum, the maturity, the place of payment, the payee's name, the date and place of issue, and the maker's signature. Even if the maturity or place elements are missing, the presumptions of art. 777 apply; however, the absence of the note clause, the promise to pay, or the signature deprives the instrument of its character as a promissory note. - Q: Is a note invalid if it does not state a maturity date? A: No. Under art. 777/2 of the TCC, a note without a stated maturity is treated as payable at sight; it must be presented within one year of its date of issue, but failure to present it in time does not relieve the maker of liability until the limitation period has expired. - Q: Does a note given as security lose its character as a negotiable instrument? A: No. According to the settled case law of the Court of Cassation, the fact that a note was given as security does not remove its character as a negotiable instrument as long as it contains the mandatory elements of art. 776 of the TCC; objections based on the underlying security relationship can only be proven by documents relating to that relationship (written evidence). - Q: What happens if a note lacks the maker's signature? A: Under art. 776/1-g of the TCC, the maker's signature is a mandatory element; an instrument without a signature does not have the character of a promissory note, and enforcement by the special attachment procedure for negotiable instruments cannot be based on it. - Q: What is the limitation period for claims arising from a promissory note? A: Art. 749 of the TCC, applied to promissory notes by reference through art. 778/h, provides that claims against the maker become time-barred after three years from the maturity date, claims of the holder against an endorser after one year, and an endorser's recourse claims against other endorsers or the maker after six months. - Q: Is a note invalid if it does not state the date or place of issue? A: A note that does not state the place of issue is deemed to have been issued at the place indicated next to the maker's name (art. 777/4), and this omission does not invalidate it. By contrast, the complete absence of a date of issue, according to Court of Cassation case law, deprives the instrument entirely of its character as a promissory note under art. 776/1-f of the TCC. ### Insurance Law - [Breach of the Duty of Disclosure in Turkish Insurance: Can the Insurer Refuse the Claim? (TCC Arts. 1435–1440)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/insurance-duty-of-disclosure-breach-turkiye): Under Turkish law, if the policyholder fails to disclose material matters, the insurer may withdraw within fifteen days or request an additional premium before the insured event; after the event, the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sigortada-beyan-yukumlulugunun-ihlali-ve-tazminatin-reddi-ttk-1435 - Q: Can an insurer in Türkiye refuse the whole claim if the duty of disclosure was breached? A: As a rule, no; under Turkish law the outcome depends on when the breach was discovered and on the degree of fault. If discovered before the insured event, the insurer may withdraw within fifteen days or ask for an additional premium (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 1439/1, 1440). After the event, negligence leads to a reduction according to its degree where the breach could affect the indemnity or the occurrence of the event. The insurer is released entirely only where an intentional breach is connected with the event that occurred; if there is no connection, the claim is paid in the ratio of the premium paid to the premium that should have been paid (art. 1439/2). - Q: Under Turkish law, is a life insurance sum paid if a pre-existing illness was not disclosed? A: Under Turkish law, it depends on the connection between the undisclosed illness and the death. Under the Code, where the breach is intentional and the undisclosed matter is connected with the insured event, the obligation to pay ceases; without a connection, the sum is paid proportionally by premium ratio (Turkish Commercial Code art. 1439/2). In the Court of Cassation decisions reviewed, an insured who knew of the illness and did not disclose it was treated as at fault to the degree of intent, and a proportional calculation was required where the illness was unconnected with the death. The connection is a medical question; in the case before it, the Assembly of Civil Chambers required it to be determined by a panel report from the Forensic Medicine Institute. - Q: What is the time limit for an insurer in Türkiye to withdraw from the contract for breach of the duty of disclosure? A: Under Turkish law, withdrawal must be notified to the policyholder by a declaration within fifteen days from the date the insurer learned of the breach (Turkish Commercial Code art. 1440). Instead of withdrawing, the insurer may request an additional premium; if it is not accepted within ten days, the contract is deemed withdrawn from (art. 1439/1). An insurer that already knew the true position cannot withdraw; the policyholder bears the burden of proving this (art. 1438). For an aggravation of risk during the contract, the period for termination or additional premium is one month (art. 1445/1). - Q: Under Turkish law, does the duty of disclosure in insurance disappear if no health declaration form was filled in? A: In a 2023 decision adopted by majority, the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held under Turkish law that the absence of a completed form does not remove the insured’s duty to disclose health matters. Where the insurer has given a written list of questions, however, the policyholder cannot be held responsible for matters outside the list, unless an important matter was concealed in bad faith (Turkish Commercial Code art. 1436/1). Who filled in the form, how, and whether it was signed are assessed separately in each case. - Q: Can a claim refused for breach of the duty of disclosure be taken to the Insurance Arbitration Commission in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, yes, if the insurer is a member of the insurance arbitration system; no special clause in the contract is needed (Insurance Law No. 5684 art. 30/1). The claimant must first have applied to the insurer and documented a full or partial refusal; the insurer’s failure to answer in writing within fifteen working days is also sufficient (art. 30/13). A dispute already before a court or a consumer arbitration committee cannot be brought to the Commission (art. 30/14). Objection and appeal against arbitral awards depend on monetary thresholds set in the Law and subject to updating (arts. 30/12, 30/22). - [Motor Own-Damage (Kasko) Insurance Disputes in Türkiye: Exclusions, Alcohol, Total Loss, Recourse, Limitation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/motor-own-damage-insurance-disputes): Motor own-damage (kasko) insurance disputes under Turkish law: the scope of cover and the insurer’s burden of proving exclusions (Commercial Code art. 1409), allegations of intent and bad faith… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kasko-sigorta-uyusmazligi - Q: What losses does kasko insurance cover? A: Cover is determined by the policy and the General Conditions of Kasko Insurance. Under article A/1 of the General Conditions as set out in Court of Cassation decisions, property damage to the vehicle caused by accidents such as impact, collision, overturning, falling or rolling, by malicious acts of third parties, and by fire, theft or attempted theft is covered. The insurer must prove that a loss falls outside the cover (Commercial Code art. 1409). - Q: Does kasko pay if the driver was under the influence of alcohol? A: Alcohol alone is not enough. According to the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, for the loss to be excluded the accident must have occurred exclusively as a result of the alcohol, and the insurer must prove this; no exclusivity report is required for a driver who is wholly at fault and has 1.00 promille or more of alcohol. In a case where the other driver was primarily at fault, the loss was held to be covered. - Q: When must the kasko insurer pay the indemnity? A: The indemnity falls due once the documents have been delivered and the investigations completed, and in any event forty-five days after the notification of the loss; if the investigations are not completed within three months, the insurer pays an advance of at least fifty per cent. Once the indemnity is due, the insurer is in default without the need for a notice (Commercial Code art. 1427). - Q: Does kasko cover the diminished value of my vehicle? A: This depends on the policy conditions. The Court of Cassation held, in a file where the special conditions of the policy expressly excluded all diminished value, that the insurer was not liable for it. Diminished value may separately be claimed from the operator and the compulsory traffic insurer of the vehicle that caused the accident. - Q: Where should a kasko dispute be taken? A: A written application must first be made to the insurer. If the request is rejected or not answered within fifteen working days, an application may be made to the Insurance Arbitration Commission (Insurance Law art. 30). The courts are also available: the consumer court has jurisdiction if the insured is a consumer, and otherwise the commercial court of first instance; the rules on mediation before suing and, for consumer disputes below the set threshold, on the consumer arbitration committee must be observed. - Q: What is the limitation period for a kasko indemnity? A: Claims arising from the insurance contract are time-barred two years from the date on which the claim fell due, and claims for the indemnity are in any event time-barred six years from the date on which the risk occurred (Commercial Code art. 1420). The Court of Cassation holds that the extended criminal limitation period does not apply to kasko claims. - [Recourse in Turkish Traffic Insurance: Claims Against Insured and Driver, Exclusive Causation, Limitation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/recourse-traffic-insurance): Recourse in Turkish compulsory motor third-party liability (traffic) insurance: the paying insurer’s claim against the policyholder under Highway Traffic Law art. 95, matters outside cover (art. 92)… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/trafik-sigortasinda-rucu - Q: When can a traffic insurer claim back from its insured the compensation it paid? A: The insurer cannot raise against the injured party circumstances arising from the contract that remove or reduce the compensation, and it pays; after payment it may claim against the policyholder to the extent that it could have obtained the removal or reduction of the compensation (Highway Traffic Law art. 95). The recourse grounds are listed in clause B.4 of the General Conditions (General Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1713, K. 2021/1042); in a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, the lower courts applied the version of the General Conditions in force on the policy date (4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/5871, K. 2024/10214). An intoxicated or unlicensed driver and unlicensed passenger carriage are among these grounds. - Q: If the driver was intoxicated, can the insurer always claim recourse? A: No. According to the General Assembly of Civil Chambers, recourse requires that the accident occurred solely (exclusively) under the influence of alcohol, without any other contributing factor; the burden of proof is on the insurer and the blood-alcohol level alone does not decide the outcome. A report from an expert panel including a neurologist and a traffic expert was required for this determination (General Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2013/626, K. 2014/146). - Q: In recourse for an unlicensed driver, must it also be proven that the accident resulted from the lack of a licence? A: In the decisions examined here, unlike the alcohol ground, the Court of Cassation did not require exclusivity for unlicensed driving. The General Assembly of Civil Chambers recognised the insurer’s right of recourse for an accident caused with a vehicle driven by a certificate holder who had not obtained a driving licence (General Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/1713, K. 2021/1042). The recoverable amount is, however, limited to the driver’s fault ratio and the injured party’s actual loss (4th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/26622, K. 2024/2700). - Q: Is leaving the scene of the accident a recourse ground in itself? A: The former 17th Civil Chamber held that, for an insured who later gave a statement to the police admitting fault, merely not being present at the scene does not give the insurer a right of recourse (former 17th Civil Chamber, E. 2016/5264, K. 2019/1876). The General Conditions that entered into force on 01.06.2015 listed leaving the scene other than in cases of necessity, and breaching the duty to have documents such as the accident report and the alcohol report drawn up, as a separate recourse ground; in a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, the lower courts held that this provision could not be applied to a 2006 policy (4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/5871, K. 2024/10214). - Q: Which court hears a recourse action? A: Where the insured qualifies as a consumer under Law No. 6502, the Court of Cassation found it correct that the insurer’s recourse action was heard by a consumer court (4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/5871, K. 2024/10214). If the insured is not a consumer, jurisdiction is determined under the general rules. For a claim against a driver who is not a party to the policy, the Court of Cassation based the driver’s liability on tort and did not treat the relationship as commercial (4th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/10883, K. 2025/15619). - Q: What is the limitation period for a recourse action? A: Under Highway Traffic Law art. 109/4, the rights of recourse of persons liable to pay compensation in motor vehicle accidents against one another are time-barred two years from the day on which they fully performed their own obligations and learned of the person against whom recourse is to be had. In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation, it was accepted that, in an insurer’s recourse action against its insured, the period starts with payment to the injured party, and the request to apply the extended criminal limitation period did not affect the outcome (4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/12393, K. 2025/8608). - [Workplace Fire and the Insurer's Liability](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/workplace-fire-insurers-liability): Fire-insurance indemnity after a fire at a workplace: the conditions of the insurer's liability and the scope of cover (Fire Insurance General Conditions); the burden of proving an exclusion lies… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-21; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/isyeri-yangini-ve-sigortacinin-sorumlulugu - Q: The insurer refuses to pay, saying the loss is “excluded”; what can I do? A: The burden of proving an exclusion lies with the insurer (TCC Art. 1409/2). A risk not stated as excluded in the policy is, as a rule, within the cover. If the insurer cannot prove the exclusion, it must pay; if the refusal is unjustified, you may sue or go to Insurance Arbitration. - Q: I notified the insurer of the fire late; do I lose my indemnity entirely? A: No. Late or deficient notice is a ground for a proportionate reduction according to the degree of fault, and only if it increased the indemnity payable; it does not wholly extinguish the indemnity. If the insurer had already actually learned of the fire, it cannot benefit from this reduction (TCC Art. 1446). - Q: The insurer claims I started the fire; who must prove it? A: The insured's intent is an exclusion that removes the cover, and the burden of proving it lies with the insurer; unless intent is proven, the insurer must pay. Fault (negligence) falling short of intent does not, unless otherwise agreed, remove the cover (TCC Art. 1429). Nor can direct fault be imputed to the insured where the cause is one to which no fault can be attributed, such as electrical/short-circuit. - Q: I had declared a low stock value; will I receive full indemnity? A: If the sum insured is below the real value, there is under-insurance and, absent a contrary agreement, the insurer pays the loss in proportion of the sum insured to the insured value. It is therefore important to set the sum insured in line with the real value. - Q: My workplace closed because of the fire; can I claim turnover/profit loss? A: If business-interruption (loss-of-profit) cover was added to the policy, where the activity stops beyond the period stated in the policy, this indemnity is also paid, subject to the policy's conditions and limits. - Q: By when must I file the indemnity action? A: Claims arising from the insurance contract are subject to a two-year limitation; claims for the insurance indemnity are in any event subject to a six-year limitation from the date the risk (the fire) materialised (TCC Art. 1420). ### Inheritance Law - [Annulment of a Will in Türkiye: Requirements, Formal Rules and Court of Cassation 7th Civil Chamber Precedents](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-annulment-will): An action for annulment of a will seeks to set aside a testamentary disposition that reflects the decedent's final wishes where it is tainted by incapacity, a defect of intent, illegality or… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/vasiyetnamenin-iptali - Q: On what grounds may a will be annulled? A: Article 557 lists four exhaustive grounds: testamentary incapacity; a defect of intent from mistake, fraud, duress or undue influence; unlawful or immoral content or burdens; and non-compliance with the statutory form. - Q: Who may bring an action to annul a will? A: Any heir with a legal interest in the annulment (a reserved share is not required) or any legatee. The defendant is the person or persons who benefited under the will. - Q: Within what time must the action be brought? A: One year from when the claimant learns of the will, the ground for annulment and his own entitlement; in any event ten years (good-faith defendant) or twenty years (bad-faith defendant) from the will's opening or the succession's opening. Invalidity may still be raised at any time as a defence. - Q: Which court and Court of Cassation chamber hear the case? A: The civil court of first instance at the decedent's last domicile. Since the Grand General Assembly's decision of 26 June 2025 (No. 2025/1), jurisdiction lies with the 7th Civil Chamber; files combined with a title-annulment/simulated-transaction claim may still reach the 1st Civil Chamber. - Q: What makes a holographic will valid? A: It must state the year, month and day, and be written and signed entirely in the decedent's own hand. Disputes over authorship are resolved by a Forensic Medicine Institute examination. - Q: What is the difference between annulment and abatement? A: Annulment sets aside a defective will in whole or part and may be sought by any interested heir. Abatement reduces only the portion of a valid disposition that exceeds the reserved share, and may be sought only by heirs entitled to that share. - [Certificate of Inheritance and Disclaimer in Türkiye: Notary or Court, Three-Month Period, Estate Debts](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/certificate-of-inheritance-and-disclaimer): How a certificate of inheritance is obtained from a notary or a civil court of peace, the cases in which a notary cannot issue it and the action for its annulment (Civil Code art. 598, Notaries Law… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/mirascilik-belgesi-ve-mirasin-reddi - Q: Where is a certificate of inheritance obtained? A: Statutory heirs may obtain it from a notary or from the civil court of peace (Civil Code art. 598). However, if issuing the certificate requires adjudication, if the civil registry records are insufficient or if the certificate is requested by foreigners, a notary cannot issue it and the application is made to the civil court of peace (art. 71/B of Law No. 1512). For heirs appointed by will and legatees, the certificate is issued by the civil court of peace. - Q: What can be done if the certificate of inheritance is wrong? A: The invalidity of a certificate of inheritance may be asserted at any time (Civil Code art. 598). According to the Court of Cassation, the certificate does not constitute res judicata in the substantive sense, but in an annulment action conditions such as legal interest and res judicata are observed and everyone shown as an heir in the certificate must be a party. Persons whose interests are infringed may object to a certificate issued by a notary before the civil court of peace. - Q: How long do I have to disclaim an inheritance? A: An inheritance may be disclaimed within three months. For statutory heirs the period starts, as a rule, on the date on which the death became known or, if it is proven that the heir learned later that he or she was an heir, from that date; for heirs appointed by will it starts on the date of official notification of the disposition (Civil Code art. 606). The period is peremptory; where there are important reasons, the judge of the civil court of peace may extend it (Civil Code art. 615). - Q: How is an inheritance disclaimed? A: The disclaimer is made by an oral or written declaration to the civil court of peace and must be unconditional (Civil Code art. 609). This actual disclaimer is not directed against the creditors. Once the declaration reaches the court, it cannot be withdrawn unilaterally. - Q: Can I still avoid the debts if the three months have passed? A: If it can be proven that the estate was insolvent at the date of death, a deemed disclaimer may be sought (Civil Code art. 605/2). According to the Court of Cassation, this claim is not subject to a time limit and is raised in an action against the creditors; however, an heir who has intermeddled with the estate, concealed estate assets or appropriated them cannot disclaim (Civil Code art. 610). - Q: If I disclaim the inheritance, do my children become heirs? A: If one heir disclaims, his or her share passes to those entitled as if he or she had not been alive when the succession opened (Civil Code art. 611); a share disclaimed by one of the deceased’s children therefore passes, as a rule, to that child’s descendants (Civil Code art. 495), and their period for disclaimer runs from the date on which they learned that the earlier heirs had disclaimed. If all the descendants disclaim, their shares pass to the surviving spouse (Civil Code art. 613). If all of the nearest statutory heirs disclaim, the estate is liquidated by the civil court of peace under the bankruptcy rules and, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, does not pass to the heirs of the next class (Civil Code art. 612). - [Decedent's Simulated Transactions (Muris Muvazaasi): Title Annulment in Turkish Court of Cassation Case-Law](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/decedents-simulated-transactions): Muris muvazaasi (concealing assets from heirs) occurs where a decedent transfers real property that is in truth a gift, disguising it as a sale or a care-until-death contract. This article explains… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-02; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/muris-muvazaasi-mirastan-mal-kacirma - Q: Who may bring a muris muvazaasi action? A: Every heir whose inheritance right is infringed, whether or not entitled to a reserved share. The right of action arises upon the decedent's death; no action lies during the decedent's lifetime. - Q: Is the action subject to a limitation period? A: No. It may be brought at any time; transactions dating from 1957 and 1970 were litigated in the reviewed decisions. An alternative abatement (tenkis) claim, however, is subject to statutory periods. - Q: Which transactions fall within the action? A: The decedent's transfer of registered land disguised as a sale or care-until-death contract. Cooperative share transfers and cases where the decedent paid the price but title was registered directly in another's name fall outside; there, abatement may be available. - Q: By what criteria is simulation established? A: Local customs, the ordinary course of events, whether the decedent had a just and reasonable ground to sell, the transferee's means, the gap between price and true value, and the personal relationship between the parties — provable by any evidence, including witnesses. - Q: Is a transfer made in return for care simulated? A: The price need not be money; services or labour suffice. Where the transfer was made out of gratitude in return for care rather than to defraud heirs, the action is dismissed. However, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, a child’s ordinary care for a parent is a moral duty; care counts as consideration only where special attention beyond ordinary care was needed. - Q: How long does the case take? A: In the reviewed decisions, files passing through the current three-tier system were completed in roughly 2.5–4 years, while older files involving reversals stretched to about 9 years from the transaction to the final decision. - [Foreign Heirs and Property in Türkiye: Inheritance Certificate, Land Registry Transfer, Acquisition Limits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/inheritance-of-property-in-turkiye-by-foreign-heirs): Under Turkish law, how a foreign heir inherits real estate in Türkiye: Turkish law under art. 20 of Law No. 5718, the certificate of inheritance from the civil court of peace, the country and area… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-14. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yabanci-uyruklu-mirasci-tapu-intikali-ve-edinim-sinirlamalari - Q: Can a foreign heir inherit real estate in Türkiye under Turkish law? A: Yes, if the conditions of art. 35 of the Land Registry Law are met. Under the current text, the heir must be a national of a country designated by the President, and the limits of ten per cent of the district’s area and thirty hectares per person must not be exceeded. According to the text of the article, immovable property inherited outside these restrictions is, if not liquidated by its owner within the period granted, liquidated and converted into money, and the proceeds are paid to the person entitled. - Q: Can a foreign heir obtain a certificate of inheritance from a notary in Türkiye? A: No. Under art. 71/B of the Notaries Law, a notary may not issue a certificate of inheritance where it is requested by foreigners. The application is made to the civil court of peace; according to the Court of Cassation, naming the Treasury as a party in such proceedings is not compulsory. - Q: Can a certificate of inheritance issued abroad be used for a land registry transfer in Türkiye? A: Not on its own. Under art. 37 of the Land Registry Law, transfers for foreigners are based on certificates of inheritance issued by Turkish courts, or issued by foreign authorities and confirmed by a Turkish court as conforming to Turkish law. The Court of Cassation also considers a certificate from a Turkish court mandatory for immovables. - Q: Does a foreign heir lose the inheritance share in real estate in Türkiye if the acquisition conditions are not met? A: No. Under the last paragraph of art. 35 of the Land Registry Law, immovable property inherited outside the restrictions is, if not liquidated by its owner within a period of no more than one year to be granted, liquidated and converted into money, and the proceeds are paid to the person entitled. The reasoning of a regional court of appeal upheld by the 7th Civil Chamber in a 2023 decision also provides, for a death under the pre-2012 text, that the certificate should state the foreign heirs’ entitlement to the liquidation proceeds. - Q: Does a foreign heir who inherits real estate in Türkiye pay inheritance and transfer tax under Turkish law? A: The transfer by inheritance of real estate in Türkiye is subject to the tax (Law No. 7338, art. 1); the heir’s nationality does not change this. Whether any tax is actually payable, and how much, is determined under the other provisions of the Law. The exception in the Law concerns a foreigner without a domicile in Türkiye who acquires a Turkish citizen’s property located outside Türkiye. - [How the Turkish Inheritance Law System Works: Heirs, Spouse’s Share, Reserved Shares, Wills, Division](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/inheritance-law-system): Under Turkish inheritance law the succession opens on death and the estate passes to the heirs as a whole by operation of law; absent a will, the descendants, the parents’ order and the grandparents’… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/turk-miras-hukuku-sistemi - Q: How is an inheritance divided? A: If there is no will, the estate goes, in the order of the parentelic system, first to the descendants, then to the parents and their descendants, then to the grandparents and their descendants; the surviving spouse takes a separate share alongside every order (Civil Code arts. 495-499). Until division the heirs own the estate jointly, and each heir may ask the civil court of peace for division (Civil Code art. 642). - Q: How much does a spouse inherit? A: The surviving spouse takes one quarter of the estate alongside the descendants, one half alongside the parents’ order, three quarters alongside the grandparents and their children, and the whole estate if none of these exist (Civil Code art. 499). - Q: Do siblings inherit? A: Yes, in the second order: if there are no descendants and a parent died before the deceased, the siblings take that parent’s share (Civil Code art. 496); if there is a spouse, this order receives one half of the estate. Since siblings have no reserved share, they can be excluded entirely by will (Civil Code arts. 505-506). - Q: What is the reserved share and who has one? A: The reserved share is the part of the statutory share guaranteed by law to descendants, parents and the surviving spouse: one half of the statutory share for descendants, one quarter for each parent, and for the spouse the whole statutory share alongside descendants or the parents’ order and three quarters in other cases (Civil Code art. 506). - Q: Can an heir be completely excluded from the inheritance by will? A: An heir with a reserved share cannot, as a rule, be excluded; an heir whose reserved share is infringed may sue for abatement (Civil Code art. 560). Complete exclusion is possible only by disinheritance based on a statutory ground stated in the disposition (Civil Code arts. 510-512). - [Lifelong Care Contracts in Türkiye (TCO Arts. 611–618): Form, Duty of Care, Termination, Simulation, Abatement](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/lifelong-care-contract-turkiye-form-simulation-abatement): Under Turkish law, a lifelong care contract is invalid unless it is made in the form of a contract of inheritance, before an official and two witnesses. The article explains the duty of care, the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/olunceye-kadar-bakma-sozlesmesi-sekil-muvazaa-ve-tenkis - Q: Is a lifelong care contract valid in Türkiye if it is not made before a notary with two witnesses? A: As a rule, no. Under art. 612 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, a lifelong care contract is invalid unless it is made in the form of a contract of inheritance, even if it does not appoint an heir; art. 545 of the Turkish Civil Code describes that form as the form of an official will and requires the parties to sign before the official and two witnesses. The only exception is a contract made by a state-recognised care institution in compliance with the conditions set by the competent authorities; written form is then sufficient. - Q: How is a lifelong care contract terminated under Turkish law if the caregiver does not provide care? A: If a breach of the duty of care makes the continuation of the contract unbearable, either party may terminate it without notice; the party at fault returns what it received and pays appropriate compensation (Code of Obligations art. 617). Instead of termination, the judge may end their life in a common household and award the care recipient a life annuity. The 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation treats the right to terminate for failure to provide care as a right the care recipient must exercise during his or her lifetime. - Q: Can heirs in Türkiye challenge a lifelong care contract after the care recipient's death by claiming that no care was provided? A: According to the cited decision of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, in an action for cancellation of title and registration brought by the caregiver against the heirs, the heirs' defence that the duty of care was not performed is not heard, because the right of termination must be exercised by the care recipient during his or her lifetime. This does not prevent heirs from relying on other grounds such as simulation or a defect of form. - Q: How do heirs in Türkiye prove that a lifelong care contract was a simulated transaction by the deceased? A: The burden of proof lies on the heir alleging simulation; since heirs are third parties to the contract, they may rely on any evidence, including witnesses. The Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation requires an examination of whether the deceased had a justified and reasonable ground for the contract, his or her relations with the caregiver and the other heirs, age, health and the proportion of the transferred property to the whole estate. If the intention to deprive heirs is not proven, the Unification Decision of 01.04.1974 does not apply. - Q: Can heirs in Türkiye bring an abatement action for real estate transferred under a lifelong care contract? A: Art. 615/3 of the Turkish Code of Obligations expressly reserves the heirs' right to bring an abatement action against a lifelong care contract. In practice heirs usually ask first for cancellation of title on the ground of the deceased's simulated transaction and, failing that, for abatement. A principle of the Court of Cassation on how far abatement applies to this contract for consideration has not been verified in this article; the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld, with general reasoning, a regional court of appeal decision holding that the contract is not subject to abatement because it is for consideration. The view that the value exceeding the care provided may be subject to abatement is this article's own inference. - [Turkish Abatement (Tenkis) Actions: Reserved Shares, Calculation, Cassation 7th Civil Chamber Precedents](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/abatement-actions): An abatement (tenkis) action is a formative action that reduces, to the disposable limit, only the portion of a decedent's testamentary or lifetime gift that infringes the reserved shares of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tenkis-davasi - Q: What is an abatement action and who may bring it? A: It reduces, to the extent of the infringement of the reserved share, testamentary or lifetime gifts exceeding the disposable portion. Only heirs whose reserved share is infringed — descendants, parents, and the surviving spouse — may sue. - Q: What are the reserved-share ratios? A: One-half of the statutory share for descendants; one-quarter for each parent; for the surviving spouse, the whole statutory share when inheriting with other classes, otherwise three-quarters. - Q: Which gifts are subject to abatement? A: Every testamentary gift exceeding the disposable portion. Lifetime gifts only where they fall within Article 565 — for instance a disguised gift plainly made to nullify the reserved-share rules. - Q: How does abatement differ from a muris muvazaasi action? A: The 1974 Unification Decision applies only to the decedent's transfer of his own registered land. Where the decedent paid the price but title was registered directly in a relative's name, that is a disguised gift, to which only abatement — not the Unification Decision — may apply, if its conditions are met. - Q: Within what time must an abatement action be brought? A: One year from learning that the reserved share was infringed; in any event ten years from the will's opening or, for other dispositions, from succession's opening. A plea of abatement may still be raised at any time as a defence. - Q: How is the abatement calculation performed? A: The net estate (assets less debts and expenses) is first determined, then increased by the lifetime gifts subject to abatement to yield the notional estate. Abatement proceeds first from testamentary dispositions, then, if needed, from lifetime gifts from the most recent backward; for an indivisible asset the beneficiary exercises an election. - [Turkish Inheritance and Transfer Tax for Heirs Abroad: Filing, Additional Periods, Instalments, Tax Clearance](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/turkish-inheritance-tax-heirs-living-abroad): Under Turkish law, inheritance and transfer tax for heirs living abroad: the four-, six- and eight-month filing periods under art. 9 of Law No. 7338, the additional periods under art. 342 of the Tax… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yurt-disindaki-mirascinin-veraset-ve-intikal-vergisi - Q: I live abroad and my father died in Türkiye; what is my filing period? A: If the death occurred in Türkiye and you are in a foreign country, the period is six months from the date of death (Law No. 7338, art. 9/1-a). For heirs in Türkiye it is four months. - Q: How do the periods work if the death occurred abroad? A: Six months for heirs in Türkiye, four months for heirs in the same country as the deceased, and eight months for heirs in another foreign country (art. 9/1-b). - Q: I missed the filing period; will a penalty be imposed immediately? A: No. The administration waits fifteen days after the period ends, then grants a further fifteen-day period by notification. If the return is filed within these periods, no tax loss is deemed to have occurred. The Council of State holds that a penalty assessment made without the second period is unlawful (Tax Procedure Law art. 342). - Q: Can the property be registered in our names before the tax is paid? A: Yes; registration in the heirs’ names is made without waiting for the assessment. However, if the immovable is to be sold or a right in rem is to be created over it, the tax attributable to it must be paid in full or security provided (art. 19). - Q: Is the tax paid in one go? A: No. The tax is paid over three years from assessment, in six equal instalments in May and November each year (art. 19). ### Health Law - [Lack of Informed Consent in Cosmetic Surgery in Türkiye: Surgeon's Liability, Proof, Limitation (TBK Art. 147)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/informed-consent-cosmetic-surgery-liability-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a patient must be informed of the risks, complications and alternatives before a medical intervention; the Court of Cassation's 3rd Civil Chamber places the burden of proving this… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/aydinlatilmis-onam-eksikligi-ve-estetik-ameliyatta-hekimin-sorumlulugu - Q: Under Turkish law, who must prove that the patient was properly informed when informed consent is disputed? A: In its decision of 09.03.2026, the Court of Cassation’s 3rd Civil Chamber, relying on Law No. 1219 art. 70 and article 26 of the Rules of Medical Professional Ethics, stated that the burden of proof for informed consent lies with the doctor or the hospital, and quashed a dismissal given without allowing the defendant doctors to prove it. The patient, as a rule, must still prove the breach of contract, the damage and the causal link; the Assembly of Civil Chambers stressed that the presumption of fault concerns fault only. - Q: Under Turkish law, is a consent form signed by the patient sufficient on its own for informed consent? A: As a rule, no. Under art. 26 of the Patient Rights Regulation, the consent form must contain the information listed in art. 15 (such as complications, alternatives and the consequences of refusal), and that information must also be conveyed to the patient orally. Whether the form contains this information and whether it was actually explained is assessed in each case; the existence of a signed form does not by itself end the dispute over disclosure (this is the article’s own inference). - Q: Is cosmetic surgery treated as a contract for work or as a contract of mandate in Turkish Court of Cassation decisions? A: Surgery performed for an aesthetic purpose (to achieve a better appearance) was classified as a contract for work in the decisions of the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers of 02.11.2022 and of the 6th Civil Chamber of 25.06.2025; the contractor (physician or hospital) was held bound to achieve the agreed result, and disclosure and management of complications were also treated as the contractor’s responsibility. Where the operation is for treatment (for example nose surgery for a breathing problem), the relationship was treated as a mandate both in a regional court decision and in the reasoning of the 3rd Civil Chamber upholding it. - Q: What is the limitation period for a damages claim arising from cosmetic surgery in Türkiye? A: Claims arising from a contract for work are, as a rule, subject to a five-year limitation period; however, the case where the contractor fails to perform its obligations at all or properly through gross fault is excluded from that five-year period (TBK art. 147). Unless the law provides otherwise, the general period is ten years (TBK art. 146). If the claim is based on defective performance, the two-year periods in TBK art. 478 and Law No. 6502 art. 16 may also apply. Tort-based claims are subject to two- and ten-year periods (TBK art. 72). Which period applies depends on the nature of the relationship and the defendant; limitation is considered only if the defendant raises it. - Q: Under Turkish law, can a lack of informed consent be raised for the first time on appeal in a damages action? A: It is not safe to do so. In its decision of 21.05.2026, the Court of Cassation’s 3rd Civil Chamber treated a lack of consent raised later, without having been pleaded in the statement of claim, as an extension of the claim and dismissed the appeal ground. Although the Assembly of Civil Chambers, in a 2021 decision concerning a different procedural situation, required disclosure to be taken into account, the safest course is to plead the lack of consent expressly in the statement of claim. - [Malpractice Time Limit Runs from End of Treatment: Turkish Council of State on Five-Year Full-Remedy Period](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/public-hospital-malpractice-claim-five-year-time-limit): Under Turkish law, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State held unanimously, in a full-remedy action brought for a child whose treatment was continuing and where it was alleged that the necessary… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tibbi-hata-tam-yargi-davasinda-bes-yillik-sure-kesin-rapor - Q: When does the time limit start in a full-remedy action for medical error at a public hospital? A: Under Turkish law, according to the 10th Chamber of the Council of State, for bodily harm the period in Administrative Procedure Law art. 13 starts on the date on which the treatment process is completed and the final health report is given to the person concerned. - Q: Is the five-year period always calculated from the date of the event? A: Not in this decision. The Chamber stated that calculating the one-year and five-year periods without taking into account the date on which the administrative action was completed and the damage fully emerged would be incompatible with the freedom to seek legal remedies. - Q: Does a disability report valid for two years start the time limit? A: In this decision, the Chamber treated the report, which was valid for two years and not of a permanent nature, as an indication that treatment was continuing, and quashed the decision based on the ground that the action had been brought after the five-year period. In another case the outcome depends on the nature of the report and the course of treatment. - Q: Can an action be brought directly, or must an application first be made to the administration? A: For damage caused by administrative actions, Administrative Procedure Law art. 13 requires a prior application to the administration. If the request is rejected or not answered within thirty days, the action is brought within the sixty-day time limit in art. 7. - Q: Does this decision mean that the plaintiffs will receive compensation? A: No. The decision was quashed only on the time-limit point; the administrative court had found that there was no service fault; the merits of the claim will be examined by the regional administrative court in the appeal review. - [Medical Error in Turkish Public Hospitals: Full-Remedy Action, Prior Administrative Application, Time Limits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/medical-error-public-hospital-full-remedy-action-turkiye): Under Turkish law, an action for harm caused by medical treatment in a state or university hospital is as a rule brought against the administration, not the physician, as a full-remedy action before… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kamu-hastanesinde-tibbi-hata-tam-yargi-davasi-ve-sureler - Q: Under Turkish law, is an action for medical error in a state hospital brought against the doctor or the administration? A: As a rule, against the administration. Under Constitution art. 129/5 and Law No. 657 art. 13, an action for damages arising from a fault committed by a public official while performing the duty is brought against the administration running the service, as a full-remedy action before the administrative courts. In its decision of 25.01.2022 (given with rectification of the decision still available; it may not be final), the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that in a claim of faulty treatment connected with the duty the proper defendant is the administration, not the physician. According to the same decision this protection does not cover personal fault clearly separable from the duty; in that case the action is heard against the physician before the civil courts. - Q: What is the time limit for a full-remedy action for medical error in a public hospital in Türkiye? A: An application to the administration comes first: within one year of learning of the act and in any event within five years of the act (Law No. 2577 art. 13). If the administration refuses, the time limit for the action runs from the day following notification of the refusal; if it does not reply within thirty days, from the date on which that period expires. Unless a special law sets a separate period, the time limit is sixty days before the administrative court (Law No. 2577 art. 7). - Q: Which court hears a medical error action against a public hospital in Türkiye? A: The administrative court. Under Law No. 2577 art. 36/b, if the harm arose from an action of the administration, the competent court is the administrative court of the place where the service was provided or the action was carried out; as a rule this is where the hospital is located (the conclusion this article draws from the text of the provision). If the action is mistakenly brought before the civil courts and dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, an action may be brought before the administrative court within thirty days from the day after that decision becomes final (art. 9), and the prior application to the administration is not required (art. 13/2). - Q: Is a medical error action against a public hospital in Türkiye dismissed if the Forensic Medicine Institute report finds no fault? A: Not always. In its decision of 14.01.2026 the Council of State 10th Chamber quashed a dismissal based on a report that answered the parties’ allegations without sufficient reasons and required a new report from the Higher Board of Forensic Medicine. In its decision of 06.11.2025 the Council of State Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers likewise concluded, by majority, that the required medical care had not been shown although the reports stated that no certain causal link could be established. These decisions are specific to their facts; quashing does not mean the action will be upheld. - Q: Under Turkish law, can the administration recover from the physician the compensation it paid for a medical error? A: It can, but the decision is taken by the Professional Liability Board. Under additional art. 18 of Law No. 3359, the Board decides within one year whether recourse is to be had and in what amount, having regard to whether the person concerned abused his or her office by acting contrary to the requirements of the duty and to the degree of fault. For those working in state universities the final decision is taken by the university within six months. - [The Physician's Liability in Medical Malpractice](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/physicians-liability-medical-malpractice): The physician's civil liability in medical malpractice: the nature of the patient–physician relationship (mandate for a private/independent physician — TCO Art. 502; a public-law relationship in a… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-26; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tibbi-malpraktiste-hekimin-sorumlulugu - Q: My treatment ended badly; is every adverse outcome malpractice? A: No. Adverse outcomes that may arise despite compliance with the rules and requirements of medicine are complications and, as a rule, do not give rise to liability. Liability requires faulty conduct of the physician contrary to the duty of care, a loss, and a causal link between them. Even where there is a complication, the physician's duty to inform beforehand and to manage the process correctly continues. - Q: I signed a consent form before the operation; can I still sue? A: Yes, you can. Mere “consent” is not enough; the risks, complications and alternatives of the intervention must have been explained to you in a way you can understand. General/standard forms are not valid informed consent if they do not concretely set out the risks specific to the intervention. The burden of proving that disclosure was duly made lies with the physician. - Q: I was harmed in a public hospital; whom and where do I sue? A: In public hospitals there is no contract between patient and physician; the relationship is public-law. The action is therefore brought not against the physician but against the administration, as a full-remedy action before the administrative judiciary. The administrative application and action time-limits also matter; obtain advice early so as not to miss the deadline. - Q: Which court is competent for a private hospital or an aesthetic procedure? A: Actions against a private hospital/independent physician mostly fall within the jurisdiction of the consumer court. As aesthetic procedures are treated as a works contract, where the result is not achieved the defect provisions of the works contract (price reduction, remedy, damages) apply. - Q: If the physician has compulsory insurance, can I recover from the insurer? A: Compulsory Financial Liability Insurance for Medical Malpractice (Law No. 1219, Additional Art. 12) is mandatory for physicians. Where the conditions are met, the loss may be covered from this insurance within the policy limits; disputes in which the insurer is a party are heard, owing to their commercial nature, in a separate judicial branch. - Q: How is the existence of fault determined? A: Whether the medical practice complied with the rules and whether there was fault is, as a rule, determined by expert examination (panels from the Forensic Medicine Institution and/or relevant specialist departments of universities). Medical records, discharge summaries, images and consent documents are therefore very important as evidence. - [Türkiye’s “Full-Time Law” for Physicians: Private Practice Restrictions from 1928 to 2026 and Today](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/full-time-law-physicians): The chronological development of Türkiye’s Full-Time Law for physicians: Laws No. 224 and 2162, Law No. 2368, the Full-Time Law No. 5947, the Constitutional Court’s annulment decisions of 2010, 2012… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-25; updated: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tam-gun-yasasi-kronolojik-gelisim-ve-guncel-durum - Q: May a specialist with a permanent post at a state hospital open a private clinic after hours? A: No. Law No. 657 art. 28 prohibits civil servants from opening clinics and working in private workplaces. Public physicians without managerial duties may act as occupational physicians only with permission and for up to thirty hours a month. - Q: May a physician faculty member at a state university work in a private hospital? A: As a rule, no. Professors and associate professors may be employed out of hours under an institutional contract of up to one year concluded by the university and within quotas (Law No. 2547 art. 36/7). A personal clinic or individual contract is not covered. - Q: What is the position of faculty members who had a clinic before 2014? A: Faculty members who were lawfully running a clinic or working in a private institution on 18.01.2014 may continue, because the transitional provision was annulled. According to the Council of State, this protection does not extend to those without a clinic on that date or who became faculty members later. - Q: In how many places may a physician working in a private hospital work at the same time? A: Since Law No. 7557, in no more than two health institutions, within Ministry workforce planning and within one sub-paragraph each (Law No. 1219 art. 12/3); private-sector work is insured employment. - Q: May a clinic physician operate on a patient in a private hospital? A: Yes, if the patient pays and nothing is claimed from the SGK. The Private Hospitals Regulation requires a contract with the hospital, a quota of one third of the specialty’s posts and an exception for physicians over 60; case-based permits may be granted where needed. - Q: What is the sanction for working in breach of the ban? A: Suspension of step advancement for civil-servant physicians (Law No. 657 art. 125), and suspension of step advancement or a multiple salary deduction for academic staff (Law No. 2547 art. 53). A faculty member breaching an institutional contract may not be so employed for one year, or five years on repetition. ### Family & Divorce Law - [Action for Denial of Paternity in Turkish Law: Presumption, the Mother’s Right, Time Limits, DNA Testing](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/action-denial-paternity): Action for denial of paternity under the Turkish Civil Code (arts. 282-291): the right of action granted to the husband, the mother and the child by Law No. 7531, the presumption of paternity and the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/soybaginin-reddi-davasi - Q: Who can bring an action for denial of paternity? A: Under art. 286 of the Civil Code, as amended by Law No. 7531, the husband, the mother or the child; the action is directed at the other persons entitled to bring it. If the husband dies, is declared absent or permanently loses the capacity to discern before his time limit expires, the person claiming to be the father and the husband’s descendants, mother or father may also sue (art. 291). - Q: Within what time must the action be brought? A: The husband must sue within one year of learning of the birth and that he is not the father or that the mother had relations with another man at the time of conception; the mother within one year from the birth; the child within one year from reaching majority. If the delay rests on a justified reason, the period starts when that reason ceases (art. 289). The Court of Cassation treats this period as a peremptory time limit observed by the judge ex officio. - Q: Does my suspicion that the child is not mine start the time limit? A: No. According to the Court of Cassation, suspicion is not sufficient for learning; where learning occurs through an out-of-court paternity test, the period starts at that moment. The one-year period should therefore not be missed once a private DNA result is known. - Q: What happens if the other party does not attend the DNA test? A: Under art. 284/2 of the Civil Code the judge may draw an adverse inference against a defendant who refuses the examination, while art. 292 of the Code of Civil Procedure provides that the examination is carried out by force if blood or tissue is refused without a justified reason. The Assembly of Civil Chambers held that a report must be obtained by applying coercive measures, including arrest and compulsory appearance where necessary, against a defendant who avoids testing. - Q: Is a DNA report from a private laboratory sufficient for the case? A: A private report may be important in fixing the moment of learning, but the Court of Cassation holds that judgment cannot rest solely on a report submitted by the claimant and that a report must be obtained from the Forensic Medicine Institute by referring the persons concerned at the same time. - Q: If the defendant accepts the claim, will the court simply grant it? A: No. Because descent concerns public order, acceptance does not by itself produce effect; the judge investigates the facts ex officio and orders a genetic examination (Civil Code art. 284; Code of Civil Procedure art. 308/2). A claimant’s waiver, by contrast, led to dismissal of the action in a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation. - [Breaking Off an Engagement: Material and Non-Pecuniary Damages and the Return of Gifts](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/breaking-off-engagement): Breaking off an engagement under Turkish law: material and non-pecuniary damages and the return of gifts under Civil Code arts. 118-123 — formation of the engagement, no action to compel marriage… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/nisanin-bozulmasi-tazminat-ve-hediyelerin-iadesi - Q: Must gold and jewellery given at the engagement be returned when it is broken off? A: As a rule, yes. Gold, jewellery and ornaments other than the engagement ring (wedding band) are gifts beyond the customary and may be reclaimed by those who gave them when the engagement ends for a reason other than marriage (TCC art. 122); fault is not required in this action. The engagement ring and items that wear out through wearing and use cannot be reclaimed. - Q: Does the party who breaks off the engagement always pay compensation? A: No. Material and non-pecuniary damages depend on fault: the party at fault — who breaks off the engagement without just cause or causes it to end for a reason attributable to them — is liable (TCC arts. 120-121). A party who breaks off the engagement for just cause may claim compensation from the other party who caused the break-up. Fault and loss must be proven. - Q: Can non-pecuniary damages be claimed for a broken engagement? A: Only if personal rights were infringed as a result of the breaking off of the engagement (TCC art. 121). According to the Court of Cassation, the natural distress caused by a broken engagement is not sufficient. Non-pecuniary damages have been accepted where the person’s standing in society was harmed, for example after the invitations had been distributed or when only a very short time remained before the wedding. - Q: Can engagement and wedding preparation expenses be recovered? A: If the engagement was broken off through the other party’s fault, appropriate compensation may be claimed for expenses incurred with a view to marriage in accordance with good faith and for material sacrifices made (TCC art. 120). Wasted expenses and actual loss must be proven; the price of items that remain with the claimant and can be used by them cannot be claimed in addition. Parents may also claim their own expenses under the same conditions. - Q: What is the limitation period for claims arising from a broken engagement? A: Rights of action arising from the termination of the engagement become time-barred one year after the termination (TCC art. 123). Limitation is a defence that must be raised by the defendant; the court must establish the date on which the engagement was broken off and decide on the defence as a preliminary issue. - Q: Which court hears disputes over a broken engagement? A: Claims for damages and for the return of gifts arising from a broken engagement are family-law cases heard by the family court (Law No. 4787 art. 4); where no family court has been established, they are heard by the civil court of first instance designated under the Law. The court of general venue is the court of the defendant’s domicile on the date the action is filed (Code of Civil Procedure art. 6). - [Collecting Maintenance from Debtors Abroad in Türkiye: Enforcing Foreign Orders, New York, Hague Conventions](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/collecting-maintenance-from-debtor-abroad-turkiye): Under Turkish law, collecting maintenance when creditor and debtor live in different countries: enforcement and execution in Türkiye of a foreign maintenance order under MÖHUK arts. 50 and 54, why… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yurt-disindaki-borcludan-nafaka-tahsili - Q: My former spouse lives abroad and does not pay maintenance; what can I do? A: If the maintenance order was given abroad and the debtor has property or income in Türkiye, you can have the order enforced in Türkiye and start enforcement proceedings (MÖHUK art. 50). If the debtor has income only abroad, collection follows that country’s procedure and international conventions. - Q: Can I start enforcement in Türkiye directly on a German maintenance order? A: No. An enforcement judgment must first be obtained from a Turkish court. The Court of Cassation has stated that the 1956 New York Convention does not make a foreign maintenance order directly enforceable in Türkiye. - Q: Which court hears the enforcement action? A: In practice the family court; venue lies at the debtor’s domicile in Türkiye, failing that the place of residence, failing that Ankara, Istanbul or Izmir (MÖHUK art. 51). - Q: My child has come of age; can he or she seek enforcement of past maintenance? A: Yes. The Court of Cassation has accepted that children who have come of age have a legal interest in enforcing maintenance awarded for their benefit. - Q: The debtor says part has been paid; will enforcement be refused? A: No. The Court of Cassation affirmed an enforcement judgment, stating that payments made can be assessed during execution; the amount paid is deducted at the execution stage. - [Contested Divorce and Grounds in Turkish Law: Adultery, Degrading Treatment, Desertion, Breakdown, Separation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/contested-divorce-grounds): Contested divorce under Turkish law: the special grounds (adultery, attempt on life and degrading treatment, criminal offence and dishonourable life, abandonment, mental illness — Civil Code arts.… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/cekismeli-bosanma-ve-bosanma-sebepleri - Q: How long does a contested divorce take? A: The law sets no fixed duration. It depends on the pleadings stage (two weeks for the reply, two weeks each for the reply to the reply and the rejoinder: Code of Civil Procedure art. 127, Code of Civil Procedure art. 136), the preliminary examination, the collection of witness and other evidence and the appeal stages. The periods for appeal and for appeal on points of law are two weeks each from service (Code of Civil Procedure art. 345, Code of Civil Procedure art. 361). - Q: When must a divorce action for adultery be brought? A: Within six months of learning of it and in any event within five years of the act (Civil Code art. 161). According to the Court of Cassation, in a continuing relationship the six-month period starts when the last act ends. A spouse who has forgiven has no right of action; if the period has expired and breakdown was claimed in the alternative, the claim is assessed under breakdown of the union (Civil Code art. 166/1). - Q: Can messages on my spouse’s phone be used as evidence? A: Evidence must be obtained lawfully; unlawfully obtained evidence may not be taken into account in proving a fact (Code of Civil Procedure art. 189/2). The Court of Cassation treated messages obtained by forcibly taking the phone and breaking its password as unlawful and held that the court must consider this of its own motion even if the other party does not object. - Q: Can a spouse at fault sue for divorce? A: Yes. According to the Court of Cassation, one need not be entirely without fault or less at fault to seek divorce; however, for divorce to be granted, at least some fault on the part of the defendant must be proven. If the claimant’s fault is heavier, the defendant may object; if the objection is an abuse of right and no interest worthy of protection remains in continuing the marriage, divorce may still be granted (Civil Code art. 166/2). - Q: How many years of separation are needed for divorce on the ground of de facto separation? A: Under Civil Code art. 166/4 as amended by Law No. 7532, if common life has not been re-established within one year of the finality of a decision dismissing an earlier divorce action, divorce is granted at the request of either spouse. Without an earlier dismissal, merely living apart does not trigger this provision. - Q: Can compensation and maintenance be awarded where the spouses are equally at fault? A: According to the Court of Cassation, no material or non-pecuniary compensation may be awarded to a spouse equally at fault (Civil Code art. 174). Poverty maintenance, however, may be claimed if the claimant’s fault is not heavier and he or she would fall into poverty because of the divorce (Civil Code art. 175). - [Custody and Contact (Personal Relationship) in Türkiye: Child's Best Interests, Custody Change, Contact Orders](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/custody-personal-relationship): Custody and the child’s personal relationship (contact) under Turkish law: to whom custody belongs (TMK arts. 336, 337), the paramount criterion of the child’s best interests (UNCRC art. 3)… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/velayet-ve-kisisel-iliski - Q: Is custody always awarded to the mother in divorce? A: No. The decisive factor is the child’s best interests. Because young children are presumed to need maternal care, custody is often awarded to the mother; but this presumption applies only where it does not conflict with the child’s best interests. If the expert report and the evidence show that the child’s interest lies with the father, custody may be awarded to him. - Q: At what age is a child’s opinion sought? A: The law sets no fixed age; the criterion is that the child be of an ‘age of discernment’. A discerning child must be heard in person by the judge on custody and contact. In practice this generally arises from around the age of eight. - Q: What happens if the custodial parent refuses to allow contact? A: Persistent, unjustified obstruction of contact is a ground for changing custody, provided this is not contrary to the child’s interest; the court warns the parties of this in its decision. Enforcement of a contact order is carried out through the judicial support and victim services directorates. - Q: Can custody be changed? A: Yes. A custody decision is not res judicata. If new and serious facts — a parent’s remarriage, relocation or death, or misuse of the custodial function — endanger the child’s welfare, an action to change custody may be brought. - Q: Is joint custody possible in Türkiye? A: Within marriage custody is already exercised jointly. In divorce the rule is to award custody to one spouse; however, the Court of Cassation also permits joint custody where the parents are willing to cooperate and it serves the child’s best interests. Each case is assessed on its own facts. - Q: Can a contact order be changed later? A: Yes. Contact orders do not create res judicata; in the child’s interest they may be re-regulated, extended or removed according to changing circumstances. - [Division of Property in Divorce: The Participation in Acquired Property Regime](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/division-property-divorce): How property is divided in divorce, acquired vs personal property, the participation claim and value-increase share, and which date's value governs — in light of the Turkish Civil Code and Court of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-08; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/bosanmada-edinilmis-mallara-katilma-rejimi - Q: Can I get a share of the home registered in my spouse's name? A: If the home is acquired property obtained during the marriage, you may claim half the surplus value even if it is not registered to you; if you prove a contribution to its acquisition, you may also claim a value-increase share. - Q: Must I prove I contributed to the home for the participation claim? A: No. The participation claim arises by law; no proof of contribution is needed. Proof of contribution matters only for an additional value-increase share. - Q: Do inheritance or wedding gold fall into the division? A: Assets from inheritance or gift, and personal-use items, are personal property and as a rule are excluded; their income, however, is acquired property. - Q: Which date governs the asset's value? A: In the Court of Cassation's practice, the asset's value at the date closest to the judgment (current/market value) governs, so value increases are reflected in the division. - Q: Do I lose my right if my spouse sold the home before divorce? A: No. Transfers aimed at reducing the participation claim are included in liquidation as if the asset still existed (added value). - Q: What is the limitation period? A: In the Court of Cassation's practice, ten years, starting as a rule when the divorce judgment becomes final. - [Divorce in Türkiye for Turkish Citizens Abroad: Competent Court, Applicable Law and Attending the Hearing](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/divorce-in-turkiye-for-turkish-citizens-living-abroad): Under Turkish law, divorce proceedings in Türkiye for Turkish citizens living abroad: the competent court under MÖHUK art. 41, the applicable law under MÖHUK art. 14, the judge's duty to hear the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yurt-disinda-yasayanlarin-turkiyede-bosanmasi - Q: I live abroad; can I bring divorce proceedings in Türkiye? A: Yes. If the action has not been or cannot be brought in your country of residence, it can be brought before the court with territorial jurisdiction in Türkiye or, failing that, at your place of residence, your last domicile, or in Ankara, Istanbul or Izmir (MÖHUK art. 41). - Q: Is attending the hearing mandatory in an uncontested divorce? A: Yes. Turkish Civil Code art. 166/3 requires the judge to hear the parties in person and be satisfied that they expressed their will freely. Both spouses therefore need to be present at the hearing. - Q: We live in Germany; which law will the Turkish court apply? A: If both spouses are Turkish citizens, Turkish law applies. If they have different nationalities, the law of their common habitual residence (for example German law) applies, failing which Turkish law (MÖHUK art. 14). Interim measures are always governed by Turkish law. - Q: Can I conduct a contested divorce without travelling to Türkiye? A: Yes; there is no personal hearing requirement in a contested case. A lawyer can conduct the case under a power of attorney drawn up at a consulate or before a foreign notary and duly certified; witnesses abroad can be heard through letters rogatory. - Q: Will a divorce obtained in Türkiye be valid in my country of residence? A: The judgment is entered in the Turkish civil register; whether it takes effect in your country of residence depends on that country’s recognition rules. You may need to apply separately to the competent authority there. - [Foreign Divorce Validity in Türkiye: Administrative Registration at the Consulate and the Recognition Action](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/foreign-divorce-recognition-turkiye-civil-registry): Under Turkish law, a Turkish citizen who divorced abroad can correct the Turkish civil register in two ways: administrative registration at a consulate or civil registry office under art. 27/A of Law… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yurt-disinda-alinan-bosanma-kararinin-turkiyede-taninmasi - Q: Is my foreign divorce automatically valid in Türkiye? A: No. For the decision to be entered in the Turkish civil register, either administrative registration at a consulate or civil registry office (Law No. 5490, art. 27/A) or recognition by a court (MÖHUK art. 58) is required. Until then you continue to appear as married in Turkish records. - Q: What happens if my former spouse will not join the application? A: Administrative registration requires two Turkish-citizen spouses to apply together (or through attorneys). If your former spouse will not join, is not a foreign national and has not died, you need to bring a recognition action, in which the statement of claim is served on your former spouse together with the hearing date. - Q: Do I have to travel to Türkiye for the recognition action? A: No. A lawyer can conduct the case on the basis of a power of attorney drawn up at a consulate or before a notary in your country of residence and duly certified. If you have no domicile in Türkiye, the action is brought at the other party’s domicile in Türkiye or, failing that, in Ankara, Istanbul or Izmir. - Q: I divorced years ago; can I still seek recognition? A: Yes. Turkish law sets no time limit for recognition. The Court of Cassation accepted the recognition of a divorce that became final in 1991, even though the spouses later lived together. - Q: Which documents are needed? A: The original of the divorce decision certified by that country’s authorities or a copy certified by the court that gave it, a certified document showing that the decision is final, and certified Turkish translations of both. If documents are missing, the court gives time to complete them. - [Increasing and Decreasing Maintenance: Conditions, PPI-Rate Increase and Removal of Alimony](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/increasing-decreasing-maintenance): Increasing and decreasing maintenance under Turkish law: the legal basis (TMK art. 176/4 — financial change or equity), the PPI-rate increase and balance principle absent an extraordinary change… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/nafakanin-artirilmasi-ve-azaltilmasi - Q: How many years must I wait to increase maintenance? A: There is no waiting period. An increase action may be brought at any time; each is assessed on the parties’ circumstances as at the filing date. In practice most awards already provide for an automatic annual PPI-rate increase. - Q: Does maintenance increase automatically each year? A: If the original decision ordered an annual increase at the TurkStat PPI rate, it applies automatically and no further action is needed. Absent such a clause, an increase action must be brought. - Q: I lost my job — can I reduce the maintenance? A: If you prove an extraordinary and lasting fall in your income, you may seek a decrease on the ground of changed financial circumstances. The court reassesses the creditor’s needs against your means and sets an equitable amount. - Q: My ex-spouse lives with someone — can I remove the poverty maintenance? A: The creditor living as if married without marrying is a ground for removal. But the Court of Cassation requires concrete, convincing proof that a common life just like marriage has been established; occasional meetings or friendship alone are not enough. - Q: Can child support be increased as the child grows? A: Yes. As the child’s age and needs (especially education costs) grow, an increase in child support may be sought. The judge weighs the child’s needs against the parents’ means. - Q: Can I take a maintenance decision to cassation? A: Not always. If the annual increase/decrease brought to cassation is below the finality threshold set in the HMK, the appellate decision is final and cassation is closed. Amounts above the threshold may be taken to cassation. - [Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Court Judgments](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/recognition-enforcement-foreign-court-judgments): A foreign judgment (e.g. a divorce) has no automatic effect in Türkiye; enforcement requires tenfiz, and conclusive-evidence effect requires recognition. Conditions, reciprocity and the révision bar… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-16; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yabanci-mahkeme-kararlarinin-taninmasi-ve-tenfizi - Q: I divorced abroad; must I sue again in Türkiye? A: No. To make a foreign divorce effective and register it, a recognition action is, as a rule, sufficient; a fresh divorce action is not needed. If the statutory conditions are met and the parties apply together (or, where one has died or is a foreign national, the Turkish-citizen party alone), the decision can also be registered by a Turkish mission abroad or a civil registry office without a court action (Population Services Act art. 27/A). - Q: What is the difference between recognition and enforcement? A: Recognition gives the judgment conclusive-evidence/res judicata effect (e.g. registering a divorce). Enforcement allows it to be executed in Türkiye (e.g. collecting maintenance or damages). - Q: Is reciprocity always required? A: No. Reciprocity is required only for enforcement, not for recognition (Art. 58). - Q: Does the court examine whether the foreign judgment is just? A: No. The enforcement judge cannot review the merits/substantive correctness; only the enforcement conditions are checked. - Q: Which documents are needed? A: The certified original of the foreign judgment, the finality annotation, a sworn translation and, within applicable treaties, an apostille. - Q: Which court hears the action? A: As a rule the civil court of first instance; for family-law judgments such as divorce, the family court. - [Removal and Protection Orders under Law No. 6284 in Türkiye: Objection and Coercive Detention (Arts. 9, 13)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/law-6284-removal-order-objection-coercive-detention): Under Turkish law, preventive measures such as removal from the home under Law No. 6284 are issued initially for at most six months and may be extended; an objection lies to the family court within… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/6284-sayili-kanun-koruma-ve-uzaklastirma-karari-itiraz-ve-zorlama-hapsi - Q: Is evidence required for a removal order under Law No. 6284 in Türkiye? A: The rule that “no evidence or document is required” (art. 8/3) is written in the Law for protective measures. Removal from the home is a preventive measure (art. 5/1-b). According to the Constitutional Court of Türkiye, that exception is not provided for preventive measures; referring to the legislative rationale, the Court noted that a preventive measure requires facts showing exposure to violence or a risk of it. Even so, a preventive measure is ordered without delay, and a more flexible approach to reasoning may be accepted in the first decision. - Q: What is the maximum duration of a protection or removal order under Law No. 6284 in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, a protection order may be issued for at most six months the first time (art. 8/2). If violence or the risk of violence is found likely to continue, the judge may, ex officio or on the request of the protected person, the Ministry or the police, change the duration or form of the measure, lift it or continue it unchanged. Six months is an upper limit; a shorter period may also be set. - Q: How and within what time limit can a removal order under Law No. 6284 be challenged in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, an objection is lodged with the family court within two weeks of the date of pronouncement or service (art. 9/1). The file is sent to the next-numbered family court in the same place, to the civil court of first instance if there is only one family court, or to the nearest civil court of first instance if both courts have the same judge. The objection authority decides within one week and its decision is final (art. 9/3); according to the Court of Cassation’s 2nd Civil Chamber, a decision rejecting the objection cannot be appealed. - Q: How long is the coercive detention for breaching a protection order under Law No. 6284 in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, a person who breaches the order is subject by judicial decision to coercive detention of three to ten days for the first breach, depending on the nature of the breached measure and the gravity of the breach (art. 13/1). For each repetition the period is fifteen to thirty days; the total may not exceed six months (art. 13/2). The decisions are enforced by the chief public prosecutor’s office. - Q: Does coercive detention for breaching an order under Law No. 6284 prevent a criminal case for the same act in Türkiye? A: As a rule, no. The Law provides for coercive detention “even if the act constitutes a crime” (art. 13/1). The Constitutional Court of Türkiye held that coercive detention is not a penalty for a crime but a disciplinary detention, and that where the breach is also a crime there is no double punishment because different legal interests are violated; three members dissented. - [Return of a Child under the Hague Convention in Türkiye: Application, One-Year Period, Grounds for Refusal](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/hague-child-abduction-return-of-child-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the return action under the 1980 Hague Convention and Law No. 5717 where a child is brought to Türkiye, or taken from Türkiye, without the other parent's consent: the Central… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/lahey-sozlesmesi-cocuk-kacirma-ve-cocugun-iadesi - Q: My spouse took our child to Türkiye and will not return; what can I do? A: You can file a return application under the Hague Convention with the central authority of your country or with the Central Authority in Türkiye. In Türkiye the action is brought by the chief public prosecutor’s office and heard urgently under the simple procedure (Law No. 5717, arts. 4 and 9). - Q: If a year has passed, can return no longer be requested? A: It can; but for applications made within one year, prompt return is the rule. After one year the Convention allows an additional ground for refusal, so applying without delay matters. - Q: I obtained custody in Türkiye; can a return order still be made? A: Yes. A custody order given after the return application is not a ground for refusing return (Law No. 5717, art. 13). The Court of Cassation has held that temporary custody obtained in Türkiye is of no significance under the Convention. - Q: When is return refused? A: On the grounds listed in the Convention, most often a grave risk that return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm, or the objection of a child of sufficient age and maturity. The risk must be shown by concrete evidence; young age alone is not enough. - Q: Does the return case stop during the judicial recess? A: No. These cases are heard during the judicial recess and time limits are not extended because of it. The period for appealing a regional court of appeal’s decision is two weeks from service. - [Types of Alimony in Divorce: Interim, Poverty and Child Support](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/types-alimony-divorce): Types of alimony in divorce: interim maintenance during the case (Art. 169), poverty alimony after divorce (Art. 175) and child support (Art. 182); the conditions and mode of payment of poverty… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-07-17; updated: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/bosanmada-nafaka-turleri - Q: How many types of alimony are there in divorce? A: Three main types: interim maintenance paid during the case, poverty alimony paid after divorce to a spouse who falls into poverty, and child support for the child. These differ from the other financial consequence of divorce — pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages. - Q: Must one be faultless to receive poverty alimony? A: No. It is enough that the requesting spouse’s fault is not greater than the other’s. The paying spouse need not be at fault; even a faultless spouse may pay poverty alimony in proportion to their means. - Q: Is poverty alimony paid for life? A: The current text of the law provides that poverty alimony may be claimed for an indefinite period; however, by its decision of 04.06.2026 (2025/156 E., 2026/131 K.) the Constitutional Court annulled the words “for an indefinite period”, and the annulment takes effect on 30.06.2027. Until then the current rule applies; what happens to new and existing alimony after 30.06.2027 depends on how the legislature regulates the matter. Even indefinite alimony does not mean absolute lifelong payment: it ceases automatically on the creditor’s remarriage or death; it may be terminated by court decision on grounds such as living as if married, the end of poverty or a dishonourable life, and reduced if circumstances change. - Q: When does interim maintenance begin and end? A: The judge may order it of their own motion when the case is filed, and it continues throughout the proceedings. The amount paid until the divorce becomes final is, by nature, interim maintenance; poverty alimony takes effect only after the judgment is final. - Q: Does child support end when the child turns 18? A: As a rule, child support ends when the child comes of age. If the adult child’s education continues, they may claim assistance maintenance through an action they bring themselves. - Q: Is there a time limit to bring a maintenance action after divorce? A: Rights of action arising from the finalisation of the divorce are subject to a one-year limitation period. If poverty alimony was not claimed with the divorce case, it must be sought in a separate action within one year of finalisation. Child support, however, is not bound by this period; the parent with custody may claim it at any time. - [Uncontested Divorce in Turkish Law: Requirements, Protocol, Procedure, Competent Court, Withdrawing Consent](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/uncontested-divorce): Uncontested divorce under the Turkish Civil Code (art. 166/3): a marriage of at least one year, a joint application or acceptance of the action, the judge hearing the spouses in person and approval… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/anlasmali-bosanma-sartlari-ve-sureci - Q: How long does an uncontested divorce take? A: The law sets no fixed duration. The length depends on the scheduling of the hearing, the spouses being heard in person, the service of the reasoned judgment and the appeal periods. The appeal period is two weeks from service of the judgment on each party (Code of Civil Procedure art. 345); the parties cannot waive the right of appeal before the judgment is served on them (Code of Civil Procedure art. 349/1). Judgments concerning family law cannot be enforced until they become final (Code of Civil Procedure art. 350/2). - Q: Is an uncontested divorce possible without a lawyer? A: Yes. Anyone with capacity to sue may bring and pursue an action personally or through an attorney (Code of Civil Procedure art. 71/1). Even when represented by a lawyer, however, the spouses must be heard in person by the judge at the hearing; the Court of Cassation does not consider the attorneys’ statement that an agreement exists to be sufficient. Since the protocol is enforced as an annex to the judgment after finality, its clauses should be drafted clearly and completely. - Q: Is an uncontested divorce possible before the marriage has lasted one year? A: No. The marriage must have lasted at least one year and, according to the Court of Cassation, the period must be completed on the date of filing; completion of the year after filing is not enough. In an action filed before one year has passed, the claimant is asked whether he or she will continue as a contested divorce (Civil Code art. 166/1-2) and, if so, the evidence is collected. - Q: Can a spouse withdraw from the uncontested divorce or the protocol? A: Yes, until the judgment becomes final. According to the Court of Cassation, no provision prevents the spouses from withdrawing their will regarding the divorce and the protocol before finality; the action is then heard as a contested divorce. After finality, the protocol is deemed an annex to the judgment and cannot be departed from. - Q: Which court hears an uncontested divorce? A: The family court (Law No. 4787 art. 4); where there is no family court, the designated civil court of first instance. Venue lies with the court of the domicile of either spouse or of the place where they lived together during the last six months before the action (Civil Code art. 168). - Q: Can division of property and compensation be regulated in the protocol? A: Yes. In a decision upheld by the Court of Cassation it was accepted that the protocol may regulate matters such as the division of jewellery and household goods, the liquidation of the matrimonial property regime, the transfer of immovables, the payment of money and the transfer of shares, and that upon finality these obligations become an inseparable part of the divorce. Material and non-pecuniary compensation (Civil Code art. 174) are also among the financial consequences of divorce. - [Unpaid Maintenance in Türkiye: What Happens? Enforcement, Salary Attachment, Coercive Detention, Limitation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/unpaid-maintenance-enforcement-detention-turkiye): Under Turkish law, if court-ordered maintenance is not paid the creditor may collect it through enforcement proceedings and, where the debtor fails to pay current maintenance claimed in those… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-13. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/nafaka-odenmezse-ne-olur-icra-takibi-ve-tazyik-hapsi - Q: Can you go to prison for not paying maintenance? A: Under Turkish law, if a debtor fails to pay the current monthly maintenance claimed in enforcement proceedings based on a maintenance decision, the enforcement court may, on the creditor’s complaint, order coercive detention of up to three months (EBL art. 344). This is not a penalty but a means of compelling payment: a debtor who pays after detention begins is released, and if payment of the debt is established the penalty lapses. - Q: How is interim maintenance enforced? A: According to the 12th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, an interim decision ordering interim maintenance during divorce proceedings is neither a judgment nor a document having the character of a judgment; it cannot be enforced as a judgment but may be enforced by way of general attachment without judgment. Interim maintenance ends when the divorce decision becomes final; no maintenance can be claimed under it for the period after finality. - Q: Can coercive detention be sought for accrued (arrears) maintenance? A: The Assembly of Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation, in a file where only past-period maintenance was claimed and the enforcement order for that request was not served on the debtor, treated the claim as an ordinary claim and held that the elements of the art. 344 offence were not formed. Under the Assembly’s conditions, coercive detention requires at least one month of current maintenance accrued between service of the enforcement order and the complaint. Arrears are collected by attachment. - Q: How much of a salary can be attached for maintenance? A: The amount attached may not be less than one quarter of the salary (EBL art. 83); for workers’ wages and social security pensions the law reserves the rights of maintenance creditors. For retirement pensions, the 12th Civil Chamber accepted that current monthly maintenance is deducted in full each month and arrears at not less than one quarter of the remainder. - Q: When does a maintenance claim become time-barred? A: Where a debt has been established by a court decision, the new period that begins when limitation is interrupted is ten years (TCO art. 156/2). The 12th Civil Chamber applies this period in maintenance enforcement; since maintenance accrues over time, it holds that monthly instalments accrued more than ten years before the date of enforcement are time-barred, while those of the last ten years may be claimed. Enforcement proceedings based on a judgment also become time-barred if no step is taken for ten years (EBL art. 39). - Q: Can a coercive detention decision be challenged? A: Yes. An objection may be lodged within two weeks of notification of the enforcement court’s decision on coercive detention; the authority designated by law examines it and its decision is final (EBL art. 353). A coercive detention decision is not enforced once two years have passed from its finality (EBL art. 354). - [Wedding Jewellery (Ziynet) Claims on Divorce in Turkish Law: Who Owns the Gold, Proof, Return, Limitation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/wedding-jewellery-claims-divorce): Wedding jewellery (ziynet) claims on divorce under Turkish law: who owns the gold given at the wedding (agreement, local custom and the new principled criteria of the Court of Cassation’s 2nd Civil… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/bosanmada-ziynet-esyasi-alacagi - Q: Who keeps the gold given at the wedding after a divorce? A: Under the 2nd Civil Chamber’s new principled view, the court first looks at any agreement between the parties and, absent an agreement, at a local custom that has been alleged and proven. Failing both, everything of economic value attached to the man and to the woman belongs, as a rule, to each of them; an item specific to women or to men is deemed given to that sex. Items placed in the jewellery chest or bag that suit both sexes are treated as jointly owned. - Q: How can I prove that my spouse took my gold? A: As a rule, you bear the burden of proving that the jewellery existed and that your spouse took it. Wedding photographs and footage, witness statements and expert examination are assessed together, but statements of witnesses who only repeat what they heard from you are not considered sufficient. Relying on the oath in your statement of claim matters if the other evidence proves insufficient. - Q: Can I claim back gold that was sold to buy a house or a car? A: Yes. According to the Court of Cassation, unless it is alleged and proven that the jewellery was given on the understanding that it would not be claimed back, the person who took it must return it, and what it was spent on does not affect the return. If the husband argues that it was given to him on condition that it would not be returned, he must prove this; an abstract witness statement unsupported by other evidence has not been considered sufficient. - Q: Can a jewellery claim be brought together with the divorce action? A: Yes; in practice it is usually raised together with the divorce action or as a counterclaim and heard by the family court. However, because the jewellery claim is not an ancillary of the divorce, a proportional fee must be paid on the value of the jewellery claimed; if the fee is short, the court must give a proper time limit. - Q: Can a jewellery claim be brought years after the divorce? A: According to the Court of Cassation, if the jewellery is found to exist, the dispute is based on ownership and limitation does not arise; if it no longer exists, the ten-year limitation period applies, and limitation does not run between spouses while the marriage continues (Code of Obligations art. 146 and art. 153). How the period is calculated in a particular case must be assessed separately. - Q: On what date is the value of the gold calculated? A: This depends on the relief sought. The Court of Cassation states that where return in kind is ordered and proves impossible, the current value of the jewellery can be taken into account at the enforcement stage; under Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 24, if the value is not stated in the judgment or is disputed, the enforcement officer assesses it at the market value on the date of attachment. The court cannot award the value on the date of the action if it was not claimed. ### Consumer Law - [A Defective Zero-km Vehicle (Consumer Rights)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/defective-zero-km-vehicle): The consumer's rights when a zero-km vehicle turns out defective: the definition of defective goods (Law 6502, Art. 8), hidden defects and the six-month presumption of proof (Art. 10), the four… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-17; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sifir-km-aracin-ayipli-cikmasi-tuketici - Q: Can I have my defective zero-km vehicle replaced with a new one? A: Yes. Where a defect exists you choose one of four elective rights; one of them is replacement of the vehicle with a defect-free equivalent (same make/model, zero-km). Especially for important defects originating in manufacture and not remediable by repair, the Court of Cassation finds replacement equitable. - Q: Who must prove the vehicle is not defective? A: For defects emerging within six months of delivery, the burden of proving the vehicle is defect-free lies with the seller (Art. 10). This is a strong presumption in the consumer's favour. - Q: The service repaired it repeatedly but the fault recurs; what can I do? A: Even if you used the repair right, if the vehicle malfunctions again within the warranty, the maximum repair time is exceeded, or repair is impossible, you may move to the other elective rights (replacement or rescission); the seller cannot reject this (Art. 56/3). - Q: Can I direct my demand only to the dealer, or also to the producer/importer? A: Free repair and replacement may be used against the producer or importer too; seller, producer and importer are jointly and severally liable (Art. 11/2). - Q: Which court should I apply to? A: A zero-km vehicle is a consumer transaction; since the price far exceeds the consumer arbitration committee's monetary threshold, the competent court is the consumer court (or the civil court of first instance acting as such). Applying to a mediator before suing is a precondition to suit. - Q: I bought the vehicle years ago; has the period expired? A: As a rule, liability for defective goods is two years from delivery. But where the defect was concealed by gross fault or fraud, the limitation provisions do not apply (Art. 12/3). - [Applying to the Consumer Arbitration Committee](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/applying-consumer-arbitration-committee): An analysis of when application to the consumer arbitration committee is mandatory, the applicable monetary threshold, the application procedure, the binding effect of its decisions, the prohibition… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tuketici-hakem-heyetine-basvuru - Q: When is application to the consumer arbitration committee mandatory? A: Without prejudice to the parties’ rights under the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, application to the consumer arbitration committee is mandatory for disputes valued below the monetary threshold set by the Law and increased every year by the revaluation rate (Law No. 6502 art. 68/1 and 68/4); the Court of Cassation treated this requirement as a condition of action to be examined by the consumer court of its own motion (Court of Cassation 13th Civil Chamber, E. 2016/9334, K. 2016/14097). No application can be made to the committee for disputes above the threshold; in such disputes, applying to a mediator before filing suit in the consumer court is, as a rule, a condition of action (Law No. 6502 art. 73/A). The current year’s amount should be confirmed from official sources before applying. - Q: Where, and within what time limit, must an objection to the committee’s decision be filed? A: The parties may object, within two weeks of service of the decision, before the consumer court of the place where the consumer arbitration committee or the consumer’s domicile is located (Law No. 6502 art. 70/3). The Court of Cassation has accepted that venue in an objection action is not exclusive (Court of Cassation 5th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/5656, K. 2024/9689). - Q: Does filing an objection automatically suspend enforcement of the decision? A: No. An objection does not suspend enforcement of the consumer arbitration committee’s decision; however, upon request, the judge may suspend enforcement by way of an interim measure (Law No. 6502 art. 70/3). - Q: Can a consumer arbitration committee decision be enforced directly? A: Yes. Consumer arbitration committee decisions are enforced in accordance with the provisions of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law on the enforcement of judgments (Law No. 6502 art. 70/2); an objection to the decision does not automatically suspend enforcement either (Law No. 6502 art. 70/3). - Q: Can the consumer court’s decision on an objection be challenged further? A: No. The decision of the consumer court on an objection is final (Law No. 6502 art. 70/5). The Court of Cassation likewise held that no appeal lies against such a decision (Court of Cassation 13th Civil Chamber, E. 2017/154, K. 2017/521). - Q: What happens if an action is filed directly, without applying to the committee? A: Where a dispute falls within the threshold that makes application mandatory and an action is filed without applying to the committee, according to the Court of Cassation the action must be dismissed on procedural grounds for want of a condition of action, without examining the merits (Court of Cassation 13th Civil Chamber, E. 2016/9334, K. 2016/14097). The provisions on mediation as a condition of action do not apply to disputes within the committee’s remit (Law No. 6502 art. 73/A/1). - [Early Repayment of a Consumer Loan in Türkiye: Interest and Cost Reductions, Compensation Cap, Restructuring](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/early-repayment-consumer-loan): Early repayment of consumer loans under the Turkish Consumer Protection Law (arts. 27 and 37): the lender’s duty to reduce interest and other cost elements when all or part of a loan is repaid early… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tuketici-kredisinde-erken-odeme - Q: If I repay my personal loan early, must the bank reduce the interest? A: Yes. The consumer may pay instalments not yet due or the whole debt early, and the lender must make the necessary reduction in all interest and other cost elements in proportion to the amount repaid early (Consumer Protection Law art. 27). The reduction is calculated on the basis of the payment date, which may not be changed to the consumer’s detriment (Consumer Credit Agreements Regulation art. 15/2). - Q: Can an early closure fee be charged on a personal or vehicle loan? A: The Law provides for early repayment compensation only for housing loans (Consumer Protection Law art. 37/2); Consumer Protection Law art. 27, which governs general consumer loans, provides for no such compensation and regulates only the duty to reduce the cost. Under the repealed Law No. 4077, the Court of Cassation also stressed that there was no provision allowing an early repayment commission on consumer loans. - Q: How much early repayment compensation can the bank charge when I pay off my housing loan? A: It may be charged only on fixed-rate loans and only if the agreement provides for it. It may not exceed one per cent of the amount repaid early for loans with a remaining term of up to thirty-six months, and two per cent for longer remaining terms; it may not be charged on variable-rate loans (Consumer Protection Law art. 37/2). Under the Regulation, it also may not exceed the total reduction granted to the consumer. - Q: Do I pay early repayment compensation if I restructure my loan with the same bank? A: In a decision concerning the period of the repealed Law No. 4077, the Assembly of Civil Chambers held that refinancing agreed with the same bank is not early repayment and that no early repayment fee may therefore be claimed; the bank may claim certain costs only if the consumer is informed, gives express written approval and the bank proves that the costs reflect reality. Paying off the loan with a loan from another bank, by contrast, is early repayment. - Q: What happens if I pay off the loan within 14 days of taking it out? A: There is a fourteen-day right of withdrawal from a consumer credit agreement. If the whole credit debt is repaid early within that period, the withdrawal rules apply without any separate notice; the consumer pays the principal and the contractual interest for the period of use, and nothing may be claimed beyond the costs paid to public bodies or third parties (Consumer Protection Law art. 24). - Q: How can I recover an amount the bank overcharged? A: For disputes below the statutory monetary threshold, application to a consumer arbitration committee is mandatory; for disputes above the threshold an action may be brought in the consumer court after applying to a mediator (Consumer Protection Law art. 68 and Consumer Protection Law art. 73/A). As the threshold is updated every year, the amount applicable on the date of application should be checked. - [Liability for Defects in the Sale of a Second-Hand Vehicle](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/liability-defects-sale-second-hand-vehicle): The buyer's rights when a second-hand vehicle turns out to have a hidden defect (accident/salvage/Tramer record, odometer fraud, engine-transmission fault): the seller is liable even if unaware of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-06-21; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/ikinci-el-arac-satisinda-ayiptan-sorumluluk - Q: The contract says “I saw it, approved it, took it as-is”; do I lose my rights? A: No. According to the General Assembly of Civil Chambers, such a statement removes the seller's liability only for patent defects; for hidden defects (e.g. a heavy-damage/salvage record) the seller's liability continues, and the seller need not have given a separate warranty. - Q: I later learned of an accident/salvage record or that the odometer was rolled back; what can I do? A: These are typical hidden defects and usually show the seller's gross fault (indeed fraud). A grossly-at-fault seller cannot escape liability by claiming late notice (TCO Art. 225) and cannot rely on the two-year limitation (TCO Art. 231). You may seek rescission, a price reduction, or loss-of-value damages. - Q: Must I investigate hidden defects before buying? A: No. The Court of Cassation holds that the buyer has no duty to investigate hidden defects; nor are you obliged to examine the traffic/insurance records one by one. You only need to notify the seller within the shortest time consistent with good faith once the defect appears. - Q: I bought from a dealer; where do I sue? A: A purchase from a dealer/commercial seller is a consumer transaction; the competent court is the consumer court (or the civil court of first instance acting as such). For low-value disputes you must first apply to the consumer arbitration committee; before suing in the consumer court, applying to a mediator is a precondition to suit. In sales between individuals, the action is heard in the civil court of first instance. - Q: I bought the vehicle a year ago; has the period expired? A: As a rule the warranty period is two years from transfer (at least one year for a second-hand purchase from a commercial seller). But if the seller was grossly at fault or concealed the defect by fraud, limitation does not run, so a limitation defence will not bar you. - Q: I had the vehicle inspected before the sale; can I still sue? A: Faults clearly appearing in the expert report count as a “known defect” for which the seller is not liable (TCO Art. 222). By contrast, your rights continue for hidden defects not detected in the inspection that emerge later. - [Right of Withdrawal in Turkish Distance Contracts: Fourteen Days, Exceptions, Refunds, Marketplace Liability](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/right-withdrawal-distance-contracts): The right of withdrawal in distance contracts under the Turkish Consumer Protection Law (art. 48) and the Distance Contracts Regulation: when the fourteen-day period starts for goods and services… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-10. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/mesafeli-sozlesmede-cayma-hakki - Q: Within how many days can I return a product bought online? A: In distance contracts the consumer may withdraw within fourteen days without giving reasons and without paying a penalty. For goods the period starts on the day of delivery, for services on the day the contract is concluded (Distance Contracts Regulation art. 9). After sending the withdrawal notice you must send the goods back within fourteen days, unless the seller has offered to collect them (Distance Contracts Regulation art. 13/1). - Q: When must the seller refund the money I paid? A: The seller must refund all payments received, including delivery costs, in a single payment and in a manner appropriate to your means of payment, within fourteen days of the date on which the goods are handed to the carrier specified for returns in the pre-contractual information; if you use a different carrier, the period starts when the goods reach the seller (Distance Contracts Regulation art. 12). - Q: Who pays for return shipping? A: If you send the goods back with the carrier specified by the seller for returns, you cannot be held liable for the return costs; if the seller did not specify any carrier for returns in the pre-contractual information, no return costs can be claimed from you either (Distance Contracts Regulation art. 12/5). The current wording of this rule applies from 1/1/2026. - Q: Can I return a product whose box I have opened or which I have tried out? A: Opening the packaging does not remove the right of withdrawal for every product; the cases in which the right cannot be exercised once the packaging is opened are listed in the Regulation (for example goods unsuitable for return for health and hygiene reasons, and books, digital content and computer consumables on a tangible medium). You are not liable for changes resulting from trying the product out to a normal extent; for use beyond normal use, however, you may be held liable for the seller’s loss. The Court of Cassation held that for a mobile phone used for six days this must be determined by an expert report. - Q: What happens if the seller did not inform me about the right of withdrawal? A: The seller bears the burden of proving that the information was given. If you were not properly informed, you are not bound by the fourteen-day period; however, the right ends in any event one year after the withdrawal period expires (Consumer Protection Law art. 48/4). The Court of Cassation has accepted that a consumer not informed of the right of withdrawal may withdraw by bringing an action within that one-year period. - Q: Can I claim the refund from the platform for a product bought on a marketplace? A: If the platform collected the price on the seller’s behalf and the price has not been transferred to the seller after delivery, the platform is jointly and severally liable with the seller for the refund obligation relating to the right of withdrawal. The remedies for defects are outside this joint liability (Consumer Protection Law art. 48/6). - [Tourist Damages and the Liability of Tourism Businesses: Package Tours, Hotel Theft, Pool Accidents in Türkiye](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/tourist-damages-liability-tourism-businesses): Liability of package tour organisers, intermediaries (travel agencies) and hotels for damage suffered by tourists in Türkiye: price reduction, withdrawal and compensation, including for wasted… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/turist-zararlari-ve-turizm-isletmelerinin-sorumlulugu - Q: Can compensation be obtained if the holiday is not as expected? A: Yes. The tourist may claim a price reduction, withdraw in the event of a serious failure, claim compensation for the damage and appropriate compensation for wasted holiday time (Consumer Protection Law art. 51/7-8). The Court of Cassation treated the failure to provide the environment necessary for a holiday as an attack on personality rights and reversed the dismissal of a claim for non-pecuniary damages. - Q: Is the hotel liable for belongings stolen at the hotel? A: Yes. Even without fault the hotel is liable up to three times the daily room rate, and without that cap where it or its staff are at fault (Code of Obligations art. 576). The damage must be reported to the hotel as soon as it becomes known (Code of Obligations art. 578). - Q: Who is liable for a pool accident? A: Where safety measures are lacking, the hotel may be held liable under contract and tort rules, including for its staff’s fault (Code of Obligations art. 66); the injured person’s own fault may reduce compensation (Code of Obligations art. 52). In a judgment upheld by the Court of Cassation, a hotel that kept no lifeguard was found 40% at fault. - Q: In a package tour, is the travel agency or the hotel liable? A: Towards the tourist, the organiser is liable, including for failures caused by the hotel; the Regulation also holds the intermediary (travel agency) liable, and where the organiser has no representative in Türkiye the intermediary is liable as if it were the organiser (Consumer Protection Law art. 51; Package Tour Contracts Regulation art. 13). The hotel may in addition be held directly liable for guests’ belongings (Code of Obligations art. 576) and for its own culpable acts (Code of Obligations art. 49). - Q: Which time limits matter for complaints? A: A deficiency must be reported immediately during the holiday (Package Tour Contracts Regulation art. 12/1), and damage to belongings at a hotel as soon as it becomes known (Code of Obligations art. 578). Liability for a defective service is as a rule time-barred two years after performance of the service (Consumer Protection Law art. 16), and a tort claim two years after knowledge and in any event ten years after the act (Code of Obligations art. 72). ### Contract Law - [Adaptation of Contracts in Türkiye: Excessive Difficulty (TBK Art. 138), Leases, Currency Debts, Works](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/adaptation-contracts): Adaptation of contracts for excessive difficulty of performance under Turkish law: the conditions of Code of Obligations art. 138 (unforeseeability, a cause not attributable to the debtor, an… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sozlesmenin-uyarlanmasi-asiri-ifa-guclugu - Q: Under what conditions can adaptation of a contract be requested? A: Under Code of Obligations art. 138, an extraordinary situation that was not foreseen and could not have been expected to be foreseen when the contract was concluded must arise for a reason not attributable to the debtor, must change the circumstances to the debtor’s detriment to such an extent that demanding performance would be contrary to good faith, and the debtor must not yet have performed or must have performed under reservation of its rights. All conditions are required together. - Q: Is an increase in the exchange rate sufficient for adaptation of a contract? A: On its own it is generally not considered sufficient. The Court of Cassation has treated exchange-rate changes as foreseeable in a foreign-currency-indexed housing loan and in a commercial lease in euro (Court of Cassation Civil General Assembly, E. 2014/1614, K. 2014/900; Court of Cassation 3rd Civil Chamber, E. 2024/1255, K. 2025/813). Where a long period, a fundamental change in the parties’ circumstances and the debtor’s lack of foreign-currency income coincide, however, adaptation may be accepted (Court of Cassation Civil General Assembly, E. 2023/582, K. 2025/24). - Q: The rent has fallen behind; can an action for adaptation be brought instead of an action for determination of rent? A: In residential and roofed commercial leases, inflation, rent inflation and changes in comparable rents are the subject of the action for determination of rent under Code of Obligations art. 344 and are not separately grounds for adaptation under Code of Obligations art. 138. If the conditions of Code of Obligations art. 138 are met, the contractual rent increase rate may be the subject of an action for adaptation (Court of Cassation 3rd Civil Chamber, E. 2026/1213, K. 2026/1751). - Q: I paid the rent without any reservation; can I still request adaptation? A: Since rent is performed periodically, payment without reservation of rights does not bar an action for adaptation (Court of Cassation 3rd Civil Chamber, E. 2018/7863, K. 2019/534), although the other conditions must also be met. For obligations performed in a single act, adaptation after performance can, as a rule, be requested only if rights were reserved. - Q: Which court hears an adaptation action, and is mediation mandatory? A: The civil court of peace has jurisdiction over actions arising from a lease relationship (Code of Civil Procedure art. 4/1-a) and, for other contracts, unless otherwise provided, the civil court of first instance (Code of Civil Procedure art. 2/1); besides the court of the defendant’s domicile, the court of the place of performance also has venue (Code of Civil Procedure art. 10). In lease disputes, applying to a mediator before filing suit is a precondition to suit (Law No. 6325 art. 18/B). - Q: Can a contractor ask for an increase of a lump-sum price in a works contract? A: As a rule, no (Code of Obligations art. 480/1). However, if circumstances that could not be foreseen at the outset, or that could have been foreseen but were not taken into account by the parties, prevent the work from being produced for that price or make it extremely difficult, the contractor may ask the court for adaptation or, where this is not possible, withdraw (Code of Obligations art. 480/2). - [Agency (Mandate) Contract and Revocation of Authority](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/agency-contract-revocation-authority): An analysis of the agency (vekalet/mandate) contract under Turkish law — its definition, the parties' obligations, unilateral termination (revocation and withdrawal) and the specific consequences of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/vekalet-sozlesmesi-ve-azil - Q: When may an agent be justifiably revoked? A: Conduct that undermines the relationship of trust — such as failing to pursue the matter diligently, departing from instructions, or breaching the duty of loyalty — may amount to justified cause for revocation. The Court of Cassation has, on the facts of a particular case, treated an attorney's demand for a fee before the matter concluded as conduct undermining trust and therefore justifying revocation. The burden of proving justified cause lies with the party relying on it. - Q: If revocation is unjustified, is the attorney entitled to the full fee? A: Under Article 174/2 of the Attorneys Act, in the case of unjustified revocation the attorney is entitled to the entire fee for the undertaken matter, regardless of the stage it had reached. Conversely, in the case of justified revocation the attorney may claim a fee only for matters concluded and become final as of the date of revocation; no fee is due for matters still pending at that date. - Q: May an agent always resign, and is there a cost to doing so? A: Under Article 512 TCO, both the principal and the agent may terminate the agency unilaterally at any time, reflecting the personal, trust-based nature of the relationship. However, a party who terminates at an inopportune time is obliged to compensate the other party for the resulting (negative) loss. - Q: Does the death of the principal or agent automatically end the agency? A: Under Article 513 TCO, unless otherwise apparent from the contract or the nature of the affair, the death, loss of capacity, or bankruptcy of either party automatically terminates the agency. However, if termination would endanger the principal's interests, the agent (or the agent's heir) must continue performing the agency until the matter can be taken over. - Q: When does the agent's duty to account become time-barred? A: According to the Court of Cassation, limitation does not run on the agent's duty to account and return what was obtained for as long as the agency relationship continues; the claim falls due once the agent renders account or the relationship ends. Claims arising from an agency contract are generally subject to a five-year limitation period under Article 147/5 TCO. - Q: What does a substitution clause in a power of attorney given to an attorney mean? A: Under Article 171 of the Attorneys Act, where the power of attorney authorises substitution, the attorney may pursue the matter jointly with, or hand it over entirely to, another attorney; even so, the original attorney's liability toward the client continues, jointly and severally with the substitute attorney. - [Limitation vs Preclusive Periods in Turkish Law: General and Five-Year Periods, Suspension and Interruption](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/limitation-periods-preclusive-periods): The differences between limitation and preclusive periods in Turkish law (defence and objection, consideration by the judge of its own motion, suspension and interruption), the ten-year general and… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-10-19; updated: 2026-11-08. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/zamanasimi-ve-hak-dusurucu-sureler - Q: What is the basic difference between limitation and a preclusive period? A: Limitation does not extinguish the claim; it gives the debtor a defence preventing the claim from being enforced by action or enforcement proceedings, and it cannot be taken into account by the judge unless raised (Code of Obligations art. 161). A preclusive period extinguishes the right itself, is taken into account by the judge of its own motion and, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, is not subject to suspension or interruption. - Q: Can a person who paid a time-barred debt claim the money back? A: No. Enrichment resulting from the performance of a time-barred debt cannot be reclaimed (Code of Obligations art. 78/2). Limitation does not extinguish the debt; it removes the possibility of collecting the claim through legal channels. - Q: In which cases is limitation interrupted, and what happens then? A: Limitation is interrupted if the debtor acknowledges the debt (in particular by paying interest, making part performance, giving a pledge or providing a surety) or if the creditor applies to a court or an arbitrator by way of action or defence, initiates enforcement proceedings or lodges a claim in bankruptcy (Code of Obligations art. 154). On interruption a new period begins to run; if the debt has been acknowledged in a written instrument or established by a court or arbitral decision, the new period is always ten years (Code of Obligations art. 156). - Q: When does limitation start in tort, and when does the criminal limitation period apply? A: A claim for compensation becomes time-barred two years after the injured party learned of the damage and of the person liable and in any event ten years after the act was committed; if the compensation arises from an act requiring punishment for which the criminal laws provide a longer limitation period, that period applies (Code of Obligations art. 72). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, whether the act requires punishment is, as a rule, determined by the civil judge. - Q: Can the limitation period be extended or shortened by contract? A: The periods laid down in the limitation section of the Turkish Code of Obligations cannot be changed by contract (Code of Obligations art. 148), and limitation cannot be waived in advance (Code of Obligations art. 160). The Assembly of Civil Chambers likewise considers it impossible for the parties to change or abolish preclusive periods by contract. - [Seller at Gross Fault Loses 2-Year Defect Limitation: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/seller-gross-fault-two-year-limitation-defective-goods): Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that a seller whose devices, bought in a commercial sale, kept breaking down was at gross fault within the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-07. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/agir-kusurlu-satici-ayipli-malda-iki-yillik-zamanasimindan-yararlanamaz - Q: How long does a buyer have to sue over defective goods? A: Under Code of Obligations art. 231/1, every action arising from a defect in the thing sold is time-barred two years after the thing sold is transferred to the buyer, even if the defect comes to light later. If the seller has undertaken a longer period, that period applies. - Q: Does the two-year period apply if the seller is at gross fault? A: No. Under art. 231/2, a seller at gross fault in transferring the thing sold in a defective state cannot benefit from the two-year period. In this decision the Assembly of Civil Chambers did not treat as time-barred an action filed more than two years after the devices were delivered or replaced. - Q: What does gross fault mean? A: According to the Assembly, gross fault consists of intent and gross negligence; fraud may also be included. The Assembly stated that grossly faulty conduct aimed at preventing the buyer from notifying the defect may also fall within the exception in Code of Obligations art. 225/1. - Q: Does the buyer lose its rights if the defect was not notified in time? A: As a rule, the buyer must notify the defect in time (Code of Obligations art. 223; in commercial sales, Commercial Code art. 23/1-c). A seller at gross fault, however, cannot escape liability by asserting that the defect was not notified in time (Code of Obligations art. 225/1). - Q: Which right did the buyer use in this case? A: Among the elective rights in Code of Obligations art. 227, the buyer chose to withdraw from the contract and claimed the price it had paid, against return of the devices; the Assembly accepted that it had this right. ### Citizenship & Foreigners Law - [Acquiring Turkish Citizenship after Birth: Routes, Conditions and Challenging a Refusal](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/acquiring-turkish-citizenship-routes-conditions-refusal): Under Turkish law, citizenship may be acquired after birth through the general route (five years of uninterrupted residence), marriage (at least three years), the exceptional route, re-acquisition… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/turk-vatandasliginin-sonradan-kazanilmasi-ve-ret-kararina-karsi-dava - Q: How many years of residence are required to apply for Turkish citizenship under Turkish law? A: Under Turkish law, the general route requires five years of uninterrupted residence in Türkiye counted back from the date of application (Law No. 5901 art. 11/1-b). Within that period the applicant may be abroad for a total not exceeding twelve months (art. 15). For an application through marriage the test is not a period of residence but a marriage that has lasted at least three years (art. 16). Meeting the conditions does not by itself give a right to citizenship (art. 10/1). - Q: When and on what conditions can a foreigner married to a Turkish citizen apply for Turkish citizenship through marriage? A: Under Turkish law, marriage does not directly confer citizenship. A foreigner who has been married to a Turkish citizen for at least three years and whose marriage continues may apply; the applicant must live in family unity, must not engage in any activity incompatible with the marital union and must not be in a situation that constitutes an obstacle in terms of national security and public order (Law No. 5901 art. 16/1). Even where the conditions are met, the administration has discretion (art. 10/1). - Q: Is the amount required for Turkish citizenship by investment written in the Turkish Citizenship Law? A: No. Under Turkish law, the Law only provides for the exceptional route and the decision of the President (Law No. 5901 art. 12/1-b); the amounts are in article 20 of the Regulation on the Implementation of the Turkish Citizenship Law. According to the text of the Regulation as retrieved on 14 November 2026, the purchase of, or a notarised promise-of-sale contract for, immovable property requires at least 400,000 US dollars and a three-year annotation in the land registry, and the other listed investment options require at least 500,000 US dollars or the creation of employment for at least 50 people. These are provisions of a regulation and have been amended by Presidential decisions in the past; the current text should be checked before applying. - Q: If an application for Turkish citizenship is refused, in which court and within how many days can an action be brought in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, an annulment action against the Ministry’s refusal may be brought before the administrative court within sixty days from the day after written notification (Administrative Procedure Law art. 7). As there is no special rule, the court with territorial jurisdiction is the administrative court of the place where the authority that issued the act is located (art. 32). Where the contested act is a decision of the President, the Council of State is the court of first instance (Law No. 2575 art. 24/1-a). The administrative court’s decision may be appealed to the regional administrative court within thirty days of notification (art. 45). - Q: If a court annuls the refusal of a Turkish citizenship application, does the applicant automatically become a Turkish citizen? A: No. Under Turkish law, administrative courts may not review expediency and may not give decisions that remove the administration’s discretion (Administrative Procedure Law art. 2/2). In its decision of 15.10.2025, which may not yet be final, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State stated that annulling the refusal does not result in the applicant being directly granted citizenship, and that the administration may make a fresh assessment in respect of the other matters required by the legislation and issue a new act that may be favourable or unfavourable. - Q: Can Turkish citizenship acquired after birth be cancelled later under Turkish law? A: Yes. Under Turkish law, if the decision granting citizenship resulted from a false statement by the person concerned or from the concealment of important matters forming the basis for the acquisition, it is cancelled by the authority that gave the decision (Law No. 5901 art. 31). Where the cancellation is made by a decision of the President, the action is heard at first instance by the Council of State. - [Challenging a Deportation Order and a Residence Permit Refusal in Türkiye: Law No. 6458 Arts. 53, 57 and 25](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/deportation-order-residence-permit-refusal-turkiye): Under Turkish law, an action against a deportation order must be brought before the administrative court within seven days of notification; the court's decision is final and, unless the foreigner… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sinir-disi-etme-karari-ve-ikamet-izni-reddine-karsi-dava-6458 - Q: What is the time limit for challenging a deportation order in Türkiye under Law No. 6458? A: Under Turkish law, an action against a deportation order must be brought before the administrative court within seven days of notification of the order (Law No. 6458 art. 53/3). This is much shorter than the general sixty-day limit for administrative actions and, as a special provision, applies first. The claimant also notifies the authority that issued the order. Subject to the foreigner’s consent, the foreigner is not deported during the time limit or, if an action is brought, until the proceedings end. - Q: Is the administrative court’s decision on a deportation order in Türkiye final, or can it be appealed? A: Under Law No. 6458 art. 53/3, the administrative court’s decision in an action against a deportation order in Türkiye is final; no regional appeal or appeal on points of law lies. In decision 2024/116, given on the text before Law No. 7533, the Constitutional Court found this rule not contrary to the Constitution; the rule is retained in the current text. After a final decision, alleged violations of fundamental rights may, where its conditions are met, be raised by an individual application to the Constitutional Court; those conditions must be examined separately. - Q: Where and how can administrative detention at a removal centre in Türkiye be challenged? A: Under Turkish law, administrative detention is challenged before the criminal judge of peace, not the administrative court (Law No. 6458 art. 57/6). The foreigner, a legal representative or a lawyer may apply; the application does not suspend the detention. The judge decides within five days and the decision is final. A fresh application may be made on the ground that the conditions of detention have ceased or changed. - Q: What is the time limit for an action against the refusal, cancellation or non-renewal of a residence permit in Türkiye? A: Law No. 6458 sets no separate time limit for an action against the refusal, cancellation or non-renewal of a residence permit in Türkiye. In this article’s view, the general sixty-day limit in the Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 7 therefore applies as a rule, starting on the day after written notification. A foreigner whose extension application is refused and who does not leave within ten days may be made subject to a deportation order (art. 54/1-j), so that ten-day period must also be watched. - Q: How long does an entry ban on a foreigner deported from Türkiye last, and can it be lifted? A: Under Law No. 6458 art. 9, the entry into Türkiye of a foreigner deported from Türkiye is banned by the Directorate General or the governorates. The Law also provides that in certain cases no entry ban decision need be taken (art. 9/4 and 9/5). An entry ban lasts at most five years; where there is a serious threat to public order or public security it may be extended by at most ten more years. The Directorate General may lift the ban or, with the ban remaining in place, allow entry for a specified period. - [Work Permits for Foreign Nationals in Türkiye: Challenging a Refusal and Fines (Law No. 6735 Arts. 21, 23)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/work-permit-refusal-objection-unpermitted-employment-fine): Under Turkish law, an objection against a work permit refusal may be filed with the Ministry within thirty days of notification, and the administrative courts may be seized if the objection is… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/yabancilarin-calisma-izni-reddi-ve-kacak-yabanci-calistirma-para-cezasi-6735 - Q: What is the time limit for objecting to a work permit refusal in Türkiye? A: Under art. 21 of Law No. 6735, an objection may be filed with the Ministry within thirty days of notification against the Ministry’s decisions under that Law. If the objection is rejected, the administrative courts may be seized. Since the Law sets no separate time limit for the action, this article infers that, as a rule, the sixty-day period in art. 7 of the Administrative Procedure Law applies; the date on which the rejection of the objection is notified should be taken into account. - Q: On what grounds is a work permit application refused under Turkish law? A: Art. 9 of Law No. 6735 lists the grounds; they include inconsistency with international labour force policy, false or misleading documents, insufficient justification for employment, professions reserved for Turkish citizens, objections on grounds of public order, public security or public health, and applications made out of time or left incomplete. The sub-paragraph applied should be identified in the refusal decision. - Q: How much is the administrative fine for an employer who employs a foreigner without a work permit in Türkiye? A: Under art. 23(5) of Law No. 6735, an employer or employer’s representative who employs a foreigner without a work permit is fined six thousand Turkish lira for each foreigner. This is the amount in the statutory text; under art. 17(7) of the Misdemeanours Law it is increased every year by the revaluation rate. In one decision of the Court of Cassation’s 7th Criminal Chamber, 8,821 TL per foreigner was applied for 2019. A repeated offence doubles the fine. - Q: What sanctions apply to a foreigner who works in Türkiye without a work permit? A: According to the statutory text, a foreigner working for an employer without a permit is fined two thousand four hundred Turkish lira, and an independent worker four thousand eight hundred; these amounts are updated every year. In addition, a foreigner found working without a permit is reported to the Ministry of Interior for deportation under art. 23(8) of Law No. 6735. The Law regulates the report at this stage; a deportation decision is a separate assessment (this article’s view). - Q: Where and within what time limit can a fine for employing a foreigner without a permit be challenged in Türkiye? A: Under art. 27 of the Misdemeanours Law, an application against an administrative fine may be made to the criminal court of peace within fifteen days at the latest of notification or announcement; if the period is missed, the decision becomes final. In the Court of Cassation decisions discussed, applications against fines under Law No. 6735 were examined by criminal judgeships of peace. If a decision within the jurisdiction of the administrative courts was given in the same act, art. 27(8) sends the fine to the administrative courts together with that act. ### Tax Law - [Company Tax Debt in Türkiye: Shareholder and Legal Representative Liability (Law 6183 Art. 35), Payment Orders](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/company-tax-debt-shareholder-legal-representative-liability): Under Turkish law, the shareholder's proportional liability and the legal representative's duty-based liability for a limited company's unpaid tax debt, the order of enforcement, the relevant period… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/sirket-vergi-borcundan-ortak-ve-kanuni-temsilcinin-sorumlulugu-odeme-emri - Q: Up to what amount is a shareholder liable for a limited company’s tax debt in Türkiye? A: A limited company shareholder is liable, in proportion to its capital share, for tax debts that cannot be collected from the company or are understood to be uncollectable (Law No. 6183 art. 35). In a 2025 decision, the Council of State Assembly of Tax Law Chambers characterised this liability as secondary and strict. The transferor and transferee of a share are jointly and severally liable for debts relating to the period before the transfer. - Q: Under Turkish law, is a company’s tax debt first claimed from the company or from the shareholder or legal representative? A: It is first claimed from the company. The Constitutional Court has stated that the legal representative’s liability is secondary and that the public receivable must first be sought to be collected from the legal person. Decisions given or upheld by the Council of State Assembly of Tax Law Chambers have required due service of a payment order on the company followed by an adequate asset search. - Q: Can a limited company shareholder who is not a manager be held liable for the company’s tax debt in Türkiye? A: Yes, as a rule. Law No. 6183 art. 35 does not tie the shareholder’s liability to the capacity of manager; the Council of State Assembly of Tax Law Chambers has stated that no condition other than being a shareholder is required. The liability is limited to debts of the shareholding period that cannot be collected from the company, in proportion to the capital share. - Q: Under Turkish law, is a limited company shareholder who transferred its shares liable for a tax penalty imposed after the transfer? A: It depends on the circumstances. The Council of State Assembly of Tax Law Chambers has accepted that liability for the taxes of the shareholding period continues after the transfer. In one decision, however, it held by majority that a former shareholder cannot be held liable for a tax loss penalty imposed for a breach of voluntary disclosure committed after the shareholding ended. - Q: What is the time limit for an action against a tax payment order issued to a shareholder or legal representative in Türkiye? A: The time limit is 15 days from service of the payment order (Law No. 6183 art. 58). Because the statutory term “objection commission” means the tax court and “objection” means filing an action, the action is filed with the tax court (Law No. 2576 art. 13). If only part of the debt is challenged, that part and its amount must be clearly indicated. - [Tax Loss Penalty and Settlement in Türkiye: How a Settlement Request Affects the Time to Sue (VUK, İYUK)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/tax-loss-penalty-settlement-tax-court-deadline-turkiye): Under Turkish law, the tax loss penalty is as a rule one times the tax; post-assessment settlement is requested within thirty days of service of the tax notice and, if no settlement is reached, the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/vergi-ziyai-cezasi-uzlasma-ve-vergi-davasi-acma-suresi - Q: What is the rate of the tax loss penalty under Turkish law? A: Under Turkish law, the tax loss penalty is, as a rule, equal to one times the tax lost (Tax Procedure Law art. 344). If the loss arises from the smuggling acts in art. 359, the penalty is three times the tax, and one times for those who participate in those acts. For returns filed after the deadline, but before a tax audit begins and before referral to an assessment commission, the penalty is applied at fifty per cent. Since 2 August 2024, the penalty is increased by fifty per cent where loss is caused by activity carried on without registering as a taxpayer. - Q: By when must post-assessment settlement of a tax loss penalty be requested in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, post-assessment settlement must be requested within thirty days of the date of service of the tax notice (Tax Procedure Law additional art. 1). If no settlement is reached or it cannot be secured, settlement cannot be requested again for the same penalty. If no agreement was reached in pre-assessment settlement, post-assessment settlement cannot be requested after the penalty is imposed (additional art. 11). Some penalties, such as those imposed for tax loss through smuggling acts, cannot be settled at all. - Q: How does a settlement request affect the time limit for filing a tax action in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, an action against a penalty for which settlement was requested may be filed only if no settlement is reached (Tax Procedure Law additional art. 7). If, when the record stating that no settlement was reached is served, the thirty-day period has expired or less than fifteen days remain, the period is extended to fifteen days from service of the record. If more than fifteen days remain, the original period continues. As the current text states this rule for actions against the penalty, filing the action against the principal tax within thirty days is the cautious course; this is this article’s inference. - Q: Can an action be brought against a settled tax loss penalty under Turkish law? A: No. Under Turkish law, settlement records are final; the taxpayer may not bring an action or complain to any authority about matters settled and recorded in a record (Tax Procedure Law additional art. 6). The same rule applies to an agreement reached in pre-assessment settlement (additional art. 11). In a 2025 decision, the Council of State’s 9th Chamber upheld, as to the outcome, the dismissal of a case seeking to reclaim settled and paid tax and penalty through a correction and complaint application, on the ground that no action may be brought about a settled matter. - Q: Can the art. 376 reduction and settlement be used together for the same tax loss penalty under Turkish law? A: No. Under Turkish law, no other reduction applies to settled penalties, and the settlement provisions do not apply to penalties for which the art. 376 reduction has been used (Tax Procedure Law additional art. 9). A taxpayer who has requested settlement may withdraw it until signing the record and ask for art. 376 to be applied. The art. 376 reduction requires applying within thirty days of service of the tax notice and paying the tax and the remaining half of the penalty on the due date; filing an action cancels the reduction. ### Expropriation & Zoning Law - [How to Challenge a Zoning Fine and a Demolition Order in Türkiye: Zoning Law No. 3194 Arts. 32 and 42](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/zoning-fine-demolition-order-challenge-law-3194-turkiye): Under Turkish law, an action against a stop-work report, a demolition order and a zoning fine for an unlicensed building is, as a rule, brought within the sixty-day period in art. 7 of the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/imar-para-cezasi-ve-yikim-kararina-karsi-dava-3194-m-32-42 - Q: What is the time limit for bringing an action in the administrative court against a zoning fine and a demolition order in Türkiye? A: Because the Zoning Law sets no separate period, the sixty-day period in art. 7 of the Administrative Procedure Law applies as a rule under Turkish law; it starts on the day after written notification. In one decision the Council of State’s 6th Chamber ran the period against a council decision containing the demolition and the fine from its proper notification, and the period against the stop-work report from the date the report was posted on the building. Whether notification was proper is examined separately in each file. - Q: Is a separate action needed against the stop-work report (yapı tatil tutanağı) under Turkish zoning law? A: The Law provides that the stop-work report is deemed notified to the building owner when it is posted at the building site (Law No. 3194 art. 32/2). In one decision the Council of State’s 6th Chamber ran the time limit against the report from that posting date and held that the part of an action filed later should have been dismissed as time-barred. In this article’s view it is therefore safer to challenge the report within sixty days of its posting, together with the council decision where needed. - Q: Can a zoning fine in Türkiye be imposed on the owner when a tenant built the unlicensed structure? A: According to the Constitutional Court and the Council of State’s Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, the “owner of the building” in art. 42 of Law No. 3194 is the person who carried out or commissioned the construction, whether or not they own the land; a tenant falls within this. The administration may not fine the registered owner without investigating who built the unlawful structure. The Assembly found no breach of this principle, however, where the fine was imposed on an owner named as building owner in the permit who took part in the construction by consenting to it. - Q: How is a zoning fine calculated under art. 42 of Zoning Law No. 3194 in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, the base fine is the unlawful area in square metres multiplied by the unit amount set in the Law for the building’s class and group; these are the amounts in the statutory text and are increased every year by the revaluation rate. Where the breach cannot be measured by area, twenty per cent of the cost under the unit price list is used. Each aggravating factor, such as being unlicensed (180 per cent) or being in an area with an implementation zoning plan (20 per cent), is calculated separately on the base fine and added. An additional fine equal to the unlawful area multiplied by the minimum square-metre value for property tax is also imposed. - Q: Can a criminal case also be brought under art. 184 of the Turkish Criminal Code for an unlicensed building in Türkiye? A: Yes. A person who builds or has built a building without a permit or contrary to the permit faces imprisonment of one to five years; as a rule this applies within municipal boundaries or in areas under a special zoning regime. If the building is brought into line with the zoning plan and the permit, no public prosecution is brought and a pending one is dropped. A zoning fine collected is refunded without interest to a person convicted for the same act (Law No. 3194 art. 42). - [Zoning Readjustment under Art. 18 of Law No. 3194 in Türkiye: Contribution Share, Objection, Annulment Action](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/zoning-readjustment-article-18-law-3194-turkiye): Under article 18 of the Zoning Law (Law No. 3194), a municipality in Türkiye may merge and re-parcel land and plots without the owners’ consent and may deduct up to forty-five per cent of the… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/imar-uygulamasi-18-madde-duzenleme-ortaklik-payi-ve-parselasyona-itiraz - Q: Under Turkish law, how much land can be deducted as the readjustment contribution share (DOP) in a zoning readjustment under article 18 of the Zoning Law? A: Under article 18(2) of the Zoning Law (Law No. 3194), the readjustment contribution share may not exceed forty-five per cent of the pre-readjustment area of the land and plots included in the readjustment. As a rule, the share is taken from a parcel only once; where a plan decision increases building conditions and population, the rate of the first readjustment may be topped up to 45% provided that the parcel’s value does not fall. If public service areas exceed that limit, the excess is transferred to the public by the methods in article 13 of the Law, for example by expropriation. - Q: How is an objection made during the posting period against a parcellation plan (article 18 readjustment) in Türkiye? A: Article 19 of the Zoning Law states that a parcellation plan is posted at the relevant administration for one month and becomes final at the end of that period; the objection procedure is set out in the Regulation on Land and Plot Readjustment. Under article 26 of the Regulation, amended on 11/9/2025, the posting period is thirty days, owners are notified via e-Government and objections may also be filed through the PARSİD system. The administration assesses the objection; if it is rejected, the plan becomes final by a reasoned administrative decision. - Q: Under Turkish law, when must an action for annulment be brought against a zoning readjustment (parcellation act)? A: The time limit for an action before an administrative court in Türkiye is sixty days unless a special law provides otherwise (Administrative Procedure Law art. 7). In a 2017 posting, the Council of State’s 6th Chamber held that where an objection is made during the posting period and the administration does not reply within the sixty-day period then in force, the action must be brought within the second sixty-day period following the last day of the posting, and that a later rejection letter does not start a new period. Since 14/7/2021 the reply period under article 11 has been thirty days; the effect of the 2025 amendment to the Regulation was not addressed in the decisions reviewed. The period should therefore be counted from the earliest possible starting point; this is the article’s own inference. - Q: In a zoning readjustment in Türkiye, must the new parcel be allocated where the old parcel was located? A: As a rule, yes. Under article 18 of the Zoning Law, parcels are allocated first from where the property was located and, if that is not possible, from the nearest equivalent area. The Council of State’s Plenary Session of Administrative Law Chambers found it contrary to the legislation to allocate a share in another block where no legal, physical or technical necessity prevented allocation at the original location. Where, for example, the parcel falls on a public service area or is too small to form a building parcel on its own, allocation elsewhere or as a shared parcel is possible. - Q: Under Turkish law, if a court annuls a zoning readjustment, is the land returned to the original parcels? A: Under article 37 of the Regulation on Land and Plot Readjustment, if the parcellation plan or its approval is annulled, as a rule a reversal is carried out and the original (root) parcels are restored; where the annulment concerns only a specific parcel, a correction may be made for the parcels concerned. The Council of State’s 6th Chamber stated that reversal must be applied where there is a general ground of annulment. If returning to the root parcels is legally or physically impossible, article 18 of the Law provides for a new readjustment on the registered zoning parcels, failing which allocation of a suitable site or payment of the market value. ### Competition Law - [Challenging Competition Board Decisions in Türkiye: Administrative Fines, Competent Court and Time Limits](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/competition-board-fines-judicial-review-turkiye): Under Turkish law, an action against an administrative sanction decision of the Competition Board is brought before the competent administrative court; the time limit is sixty days from notification… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/rekabet-kurulu-kararlarina-karsi-dava-ve-idari-para-cezasi - Q: Which court hears an action against a Competition Board decision in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, an action against an administrative sanction decision of the Competition Board is brought before the competent administrative court (Law No. 4054 art. 55/1). The Law does not name the court. Under art. 32 of the Administrative Procedure Law, the competent court is the administrative court of the place where the authority that took the act is located; since the seat of the Competition Authority is in Ankara (art. 20), this rule points to the Ankara administrative courts. This conclusion rests on reading the two provisions together. - Q: What is the time limit for bringing an action against a Competition Board decision under Turkish law? A: Since art. 55 of Law No. 4054, which governs judicial review, sets no separate period, the general sixty-day time limit for administrative courts applies (Administrative Procedure Law art. 7). In Competition Board decisions, time limits start from the date on which the reasoned decision is notified to the parties (Law No. 4054 art. 54); the period runs from the day after notification. The thirty-day period of the expedited procedure does not apply to these actions, because Board decisions are not on the list in art. 20/A of the Administrative Procedure Law. - Q: Does bringing an action against a Competition Board fine suspend collection of the fine in Türkiye? A: No. Under Turkish law, applying to the courts against Board decisions does not suspend the implementation of the decisions or the pursuit and collection of administrative fines (Law No. 4054 art. 55/2). To suspend collection, a stay of execution must be requested from the court; the court may grant it where irreparable or hardly reparable harm and manifest unlawfulness exist together, and as a rule requires security (Administrative Procedure Law art. 27). - Q: Can an undertaking that settles with the Competition Board still challenge the fine in court under Turkish law? A: As a rule, no. Under Turkish law, a reduction of up to twenty-five per cent may be applied to the administrative fine as a result of the settlement procedure; if the process ends in settlement, the administrative fine and the matters set out in the settlement text cannot be challenged in court by the settling parties (Law No. 4054 art. 43). Settlement is possible, until the investigation report is notified, with an undertaking that accepts the existence and scope of the infringement. The other procedures and principles of settlement are set by a regulation issued by the Board. - Q: Does the Competition Board need a judge’s decision for an on-site inspection in Türkiye? A: Under art. 15 of Law No. 4054, the Board may carry out on-site inspections where it deems necessary; a decision of a criminal judge of peace is required only where the inspection is obstructed or likely to be obstructed. In 2023 the Constitutional Court held, in an individual application, that an on-site inspection carried out without a judge’s decision violated the right to inviolability of domicile. In 2025, however, the Court rejected by majority the request to annul the phrase “where it deems necessary” in the same article. The article is in force. - [Competition Damages in Türkiye: Treble Damages, Proof, Board Decisions, Limitation (Law No. 4054 Arts. 56-59)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/competition-law-damages-action-treble-damages-turkiye): Under Turkish law, buyers and competitors harmed by an anti-competitive agreement or an abuse of dominance may claim damages under arts. 56–59 of Law No. 4054: invalidity, calculation of loss, treble… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/rekabet-ihlalinden-dogan-tazminat-davasi-uc-kat-tazminat - Q: Are treble damages always awarded in a competition law damages action under Turkish law? A: No. Under art. 58(2) of Law No. 4054, the damage must result from an agreement or decision of the parties or from their gross negligence, and the injured party must request it; the judge “may” award treble damages, so the court has discretion. In a 2023 decision the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation rejected an objection on this point because the reasons for the treble award had been stated in the judgment. In this article’s assessment, a treble award without reasons may be challenged on appeal. - Q: Must a Competition Board decision be final before a competition damages action is filed in Türkiye? A: In a 2016 decision the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that finality of the Competition Board decision is not a precondition for the action and required the outcome of the Board proceedings and the objection to be treated as a preliminary question. However, where the regional court of appeal stated that the underlying Board decision had been found unlawful by the administrative courts, appellate judgments dismissing the action were upheld; an appellate judgment requiring a Board finding where no Board decision existed was also upheld. The Board proceedings and any annulment action should therefore be followed closely. - Q: What is the limitation period for a competition law damages action under Turkish law? A: Arts. 56–59 of Law No. 4054 contain no separate period; the general rule is the two-year and ten-year periods in art. 72 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, but if the act requires a penalty subject to a longer limitation period under criminal laws, that period applies. In a 2022 decision the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that the eight-year period in the Misdemeanours Law applies to an abuse of dominance that entails a proportional administrative fine. When the period starts is assessed separately in each case. - Q: Can a competitor that did not complain to the Competition Board claim damages for a competition law infringement in Türkiye? A: Yes, according to a 2023 decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation. The Chamber stated that the legislator did not make an application to the Competition Authority a precondition for damages and that, since the Board decision finding an abuse of dominance had become final, everyone injured may claim compensation. On that ground it reversed the dismissal of the claim of a competitor company that was not listed as a complainant in the Board decision. - Q: Which court hears a competition damages action against a bank for cartel interest in Türkiye? A: In a 2017 decision the 19th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that the court may not decline jurisdiction without first obtaining the parties’ contract and determining whether it is a consumer contract; if it is, the consumer court decides the merits. However, in the cartel interest cases reviewed, appellate judgments dismissing the claims were upheld in 2024 and 2026 because the regional court of appeal stated that the underlying Board decision had been found unlawful by the administrative courts. - [Price-Fixing, Information Exchange and Concerted Practices in Türkiye (Law No. 4054 Art. 4): Fines, Leniency](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/price-fixing-information-exchange-concerted-practice-turkiye): Under Turkish law, joint price-setting, exchange of competitively sensitive information and concerted practices between competitors are prohibited by Article 4 of Law No. 4054, and the Competition… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/rakipler-arasi-fiyat-anlasmasi-bilgi-degisimi-uyumlu-eylem-4054 - Q: Is sharing price information with competitors in itself an infringement of Article 4 of Law No. 4054 under Turkish law? A: Not every exchange of information is an infringement; according to the Turkish Competition Board, information exchange may also generate efficiencies, but an exchange that reduces competitors’ uncertainty about future conduct is sufficient to show coordination. Sharing future prices, price increases, campaigns or costs with a competitor, however, may amount to a concerted practice; the Competition Board may classify information exchanges aimed at price-fixing, or facilitating the functioning of a cartel, directly as a cartel. Where the information flow is one-sided, proof of common intent may be required; in one decision reviewed, no infringement was found because this could not be proven. - Q: What is the presumption of concerted practice in Law No. 4054 in Türkiye, and how can an undertaking rebut it? A: Where an agreement cannot be proven, similarity of price changes or operational regions to those in markets where competition is restricted is a presumption of concerted practice (art. 4/3). An undertaking is relieved of liability if it proves, based on economic and rational facts, that it did not engage in a concerted practice (art. 4/4); cost, exchange-rate and demand data may be used for this purpose. In a 2025 Council of State decision, price parallelism alone, without evidence of communication or contact, was not accepted as sufficient proof. - Q: How large an administrative fine can the Turkish Competition Board impose for a price-fixing agreement between competitors? A: Under art. 16/3, the Board may impose an administrative fine of up to ten percent of annual gross revenue at the end of the financial year preceding the final decision (or, if that cannot be calculated, the financial year closest to the decision); this is an upper limit. The actual rate is calculated under the Board’s fining regulation, taking into account the starting rate, duration and aggravating and mitigating factors. Managers and employees with a decisive influence on the infringement may additionally be fined up to five percent of the undertaking’s fine. - Q: Can a price-fixing investigation in Türkiye be closed by offering commitments to the Competition Authority? A: No. Article 43/3 expressly provides that commitments are not accepted for clear and serious infringements such as price-fixing, territory or customer allocation or restriction of supply between competitors. Commitments may be used for certain other issues under Articles 4 and 6; in such cases the Board may make the commitments binding and decide not to open an investigation or to end an investigation already opened. - Q: What is the difference between settlement and leniency (active cooperation) in a Turkish competition investigation? A: In leniency (the statutory term is active cooperation), an undertaking or its manager actively helps uncover a cartel; under art. 16/6, no fine or a reduced fine may be imposed depending on the nature, effectiveness and timing of the cooperation. Settlement takes place after the investigation has started and until the investigation report is notified, with the existence and scope of the infringement admitted; the fine may be reduced by up to twenty-five percent, but the fine and the matters in the settlement text cannot be challenged in court by the settling party (art. 43). - [Resale Price, Exclusivity and Non-Compete in Dealership Agreements in Türkiye: Five-Year Limit (Law No. 4054)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/dealership-resale-price-exclusivity-non-compete-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a fixed or minimum resale price removes a dealership agreement from the block exemption, and a non-compete obligation exceeding five years cannot benefit from it. The article… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/bayilik-sozlesmesinde-yeniden-satis-fiyati-munhasirlik-rekabet-etmeme - Q: Can a supplier set the dealer’s resale price in a dealership agreement in Türkiye? A: As a rule, no. Under Communiqué No. 2002/2, preventing the dealer from freely setting its own sale price removes the whole agreement from the block exemption. The supplier may set a maximum sale price or recommend a price, but that price must not turn into a fixed or minimum price through pressure or incentives. The Competition Board has treated practices such as a floor price list and cancelling discounts as resale price maintenance. - Q: What is the maximum duration of a non-compete clause in a dealership agreement under Turkish law? A: To benefit from the block exemption, a non-compete obligation imposed on the dealer must not exceed five years; an indefinite obligation, or one tacitly renewable beyond five years, falls outside the exemption. If the premises belong to the supplier, or the supplier has obtained a right of use over them from third parties unconnected with the dealer, the term may be linked to the period of use of the premises. A post-term non-compete is at most one year under the conditions in the Communiqué. - Q: Is a usufruct agreement exceeding five years valid in a fuel dealership in Türkiye? A: According to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, the part exceeding five years cannot benefit from the block exemption, as the dealership and the related usufruct and lease agreements form a single vertical agreement. Agreements made before 18.09.2005 exceeding five years benefit from the exemption until 18.09.2010 at the latest, and those made afterwards for at most five years from the date they were made. The outcome is assessed according to the contractual structure of each case. - Q: Can money paid under a dealership agreement contrary to competition law be claimed back under Turkish law? A: Under Article 56 of Law No. 4054, an agreement contrary to Article 4 is invalid and restitution of obligations already performed is subject to the rules of unjust enrichment. The Assembly of Civil Chambers has accepted that, where long-term usufruct and lease agreements made before 18.09.2005 became invalid as of 18.09.2010, benefits conferred are unwound under the rules of unjust enrichment. However, a restitution action brought while the agreement and the usufruct right were still in force was dismissed on the merits; where investment costs are claimed, proof that the investment added value to the property has also been required. - Q: Does granting territorial exclusivity in a dealership agreement infringe competition law in Türkiye? A: Not in itself. Communiqué No. 2002/2 allows restrictions on active sales into an exclusive territory or to an exclusive customer group reserved by the supplier to itself or allocated to another dealer. By contrast, prohibiting the dealer from selling to customers who approach it (passive sales) is not covered by this exception and may remove the exemption. The supplier’s market share must also not exceed 30%. ### Trademark Law - [Copyright Infringement in Türkiye: Triple Fee, Damages, Complaint, Time Limits (Law No. 5846 Arts. 66–71, 75)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/copyright-infringement-turkiye-triple-fee-damages): Under Turkish law, a person whose copyright is infringed may seek removal and prevention of the infringement without proof of fault, up to three times the contractual fee or market value for economic… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/telif-hakki-ihlali-fsek-tazminat-uc-kat-bedel-ve-ceza-sikayeti - Q: Must the infringer be at fault for a right holder to claim the triple fee for copyright infringement in Türkiye? A: No. In a 2020 decision, the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that the fee under art. 68 of Law No. 5846 can be claimed without fault and that this claim differs from tort damages. By contrast, if material damages are claimed under art. 70/2, the infringer’s fault is required. - Q: Can a judge in Türkiye award less than three times when the triple fee under FSEK art. 68 is claimed? A: This is disputed under Turkish law. The Constitutional Court stated that three times is an upper limit and that the judge has discretion within that limit; in two decisions of the Court of Cassation’s 11th Civil Chamber that were read, however, regional court reasoning stating that three times must be awarded where claimed was upheld by majority; in the decisions read, the Chamber majority takes this view. - Q: What is the time limit for filing a criminal complaint for copyright infringement under Turkish law? A: The offences in art. 71 of Law No. 5846 depend on a complaint, and the complaint period is six months under art. 73 of the Turkish Criminal Code; it runs from the day the act and the offender become known. Under art. 75 of Law No. 5846, documents and evidence proving ownership of the rights must also be submitted to the Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office within this period; otherwise a decision of non-prosecution is given. - Q: Which court hears a copyright infringement action in Türkiye? A: The competent courts in cases arising from Law No. 5846 are the intellectual and industrial property civil and criminal courts referred to in art. 156/1 of the Industrial Property Code. Where these courts have not been established, the civil and criminal courts of first instance designated by the Council of Judges and Prosecutors hear the cases. The author may also bring an action for removal or prevention at his or her place of residence (Law No. 5846 art. 66). - Q: What happens under Turkish law if unauthorised use continues after the triple fee under FSEK art. 68 has been obtained? A: According to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, the art. 68 fee forms a notional contract only for the uses in dispute that occurred before the action was filed. Uses that continue after the filing of the action or are likely to be repeated do not become lawful; an action for prevention (Law No. 5846 art. 69) and new claims are available for them. Infringements of moral rights are not covered either. - [Design Protection in Türkiye: Registered and Unregistered Designs, Novelty, Infringement (IPC Arts. 55-81)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/design-protection-registered-unregistered-designs-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a design is protected as a registered design if registered and as an unregistered design if first made available to the public in Türkiye; in both cases it must be new and have… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/tasarim-hakkinin-korunmasi-tescilli-ve-tescilsiz-tasarim-smk - Q: How long is an unregistered design protected under the Industrial Property Code in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, an unregistered design is protected for three years from the date on which it was first made available to the public (Law No. 6769 art. 69/2). To benefit from this protection, the design must be new, have individual character and have been made available to the public for the first time in Türkiye (arts. 55/4, 56). A registered design is protected for five years from the filing date, renewable in five-year periods up to a total of twenty-five years (art. 69/1). - Q: Is a design first exhibited abroad protected as an unregistered design in Türkiye? A: As a rule, no. IPC art. 55/4 ties unregistered design protection to the design being made available to the public for the first time in Türkiye; in decision K. 2025/7420 the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation also stated that protection begins when a design not disclosed anywhere in the world is first disclosed in Türkiye. Registration is assessed separately: a disclosure by the designer within the twelve months before filing does not affect novelty or individual character (art. 57/2). - Q: Does selling a design before filing an application invalidate a design registration under Turkish law? A: A sale counts as making the design available to the public (IPC art. 57/1). If the disclosure by the designer or a person with the designer’s consent falls within the twelve months before filing, it does not affect novelty (art. 57/2). If that period has passed, the design may lack novelty and be declared invalid (art. 77/1-a). In the regional court reasoning upheld by Court of Cassation decision K. 2026/5010, a lace pattern sold about twenty-six months before registration was held to lack novelty for this reason, and the first-instance court’s invalidity ruling was found correct. - Q: What must the claimant prove in an unregistered design infringement action in Türkiye? A: The claimant must show when and where the design was first made available to the public and that the other party copied it; absolute novelty is also examined by the court of its own motion, while individual character is assessed on the evidence the parties submit. An unregistered design is protected only against copying of an identical design or one that does not produce a different overall impression; an independent design by a designer who could not reasonably have known the protected design is not a copy (IPC art. 59/2). In the reasoning upheld by decision K. 2026/5010, the claim failed because the time and place of first disclosure were not shown. - Q: Can unfair competition rules be relied on alongside the Industrial Property Code in a design infringement case in Türkiye? A: In decision K. 2026/928, given by majority, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that for an unregistered design protected under the IPC, the unfair competition provisions of the Turkish Commercial Code cannot also be applied to the same facts and that cumulative protection no longer applies; one judge dissented. Unregistered designs made available before the IPC entered into force on 10.01.2017 are, according to the Chamber’s decision K. 2025/7420, assessed under TCC art. 55/1-a-4. - [Trademark Invalidity and Revocation in Türkiye: Grounds, Time Limits, Authority, Non-Use (IPC Arts. 25-26)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/trademark-invalidity-and-revocation-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a trademark invalidity action rests on an obstacle that existed at registration and is heard by a court, while revocation for grounds arising later, such as non-use, becoming a… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/markanin-hukumsuzlugu-ve-iptali-smk-25-26 - Q: What is the difference between a trademark invalidity action and trademark revocation under Turkish law? A: Invalidity rests on an obstacle that existed at registration; a court decides, and the decision takes effect from the filing date of the trademark (Industrial Property Code arts. 25 and 27/1). Revocation rests on grounds arising after registration, such as non-use or the trademark becoming a common name; the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office decides on request and, as a rule, the decision takes effect from the date of the request (arts. 26 and 27/2). - Q: Is revocation of a trademark for non-use in Türkiye requested from the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office or from a court? A: Under art. 26/1 of the Industrial Property Code, revocation is decided by the Office on request. That article entered into force seven years after the Code was published; revocation actions pending before the courts on that date are concluded by the courts (art. 192/1-a, provisional art. 4). The request is filed on a signed form, with the fee, separately for each trademark (Implementing Regulation art. 30/A). The Ankara Civil Court of Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights is the competent court with jurisdiction over actions against the Office’s decisions (art. 156/2). - Q: How is the five-year period for non-use revocation of a trademark calculated under Turkish law, and who proves use? A: A trademark is revoked if, without a justified reason, it has not been put to genuine use in Türkiye within five years of registration, or if use has been interrupted for five consecutive years (art. 9/1). Genuine use between the expiry of the five years and the request prevents revocation; use in the last three months made in anticipation of the request does not count (art. 26/4). The Implementing Regulation asks the proprietor for evidence (art. 30/A-10); in decisions upheld by the Court of Cassation the burden of proof was likewise placed on the proprietor. - Q: Is there a time limit for bringing a trademark invalidity action in Türkiye? A: The text of art. 25 of the Industrial Property Code sets no general time limit for an invalidity action. However, an earlier proprietor who, while knowing or having to know that a later trademark was in use, has remained silent for five consecutive years cannot rely on its trademark as a ground of invalidity, unless the later registration was in bad faith (art. 25/6). In one decision the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation treated these five years as a forfeiture period. - Q: Which court hears a trademark invalidity action in Türkiye, and against whom is it brought? A: The competent court is the civil court of intellectual and industrial property rights; where none has been established, the designated civil court of first instance hears the case (art. 156/1). The action is brought against the person recorded in the register as proprietor on the date of the action, or that person’s legal successor; the Office is not named as a party (art. 25/3). In actions brought by third parties against a right holder, the court of the defendant’s domicile has, as a rule, territorial jurisdiction (art. 156/5). ### Urban Regeneration & Construction Law - [Contractor Delay in Flat-for-Land Construction in Türkiye: Delay Damages, Termination, Title (TCO Art. 125)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/flat-for-land-contract-delay-termination-turkiye): Under Turkish law, when the contractor delays delivery the landowner may await performance and claim delay compensation at least equal to the market rent under art. 125 of the Code of Obligations, or… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15; updated: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/kat-karsiligi-insaat-sozlesmesinde-gecikme-fesih-ve-arsa-sahibinin-haklari - Q: What compensation can a landowner claim under Turkish law if the contractor delays delivery under a flat-for-land construction contract? A: Under Turkish law, the landowner may, as a rule, await performance and claim compensation for the delay (Turkish Code of Obligations art. 125/1). According to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, this requires the contractor's default, the landowner's loss and the contractor's fault. Even if the contract sets no amount, compensation may be claimed at least at the level of the monthly local market rent; if the contract sets a rent compensation, that clause applies. If a penalty for late delivery was also agreed, the creditor may claim it together with performance unless he expressly waived it or accepted performance without reservation (art. 179/2). - Q: Until what date is delay compensation calculated under a flat-for-land construction contract in Türkiye? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, delay compensation may as a rule be claimed from the agreed delivery date until the unit is delivered complete and fit for use, or until the landowner starts actually using it. If delivery is tied to the occupancy permit and there was no earlier actual delivery, it is calculated until the permit date. If the contractor proves actual delivery, letting or sale before the permit, it is calculated until that date. - Q: Can a landowner terminate a flat-for-land construction contract in Türkiye by unilateral notice? A: According to decisions of the Court of Cassation's 6th Civil Chamber, no: because the contract includes a promise to transfer land shares, it ends only by agreement of the parties or, where there is just cause, by a court judgment of termination. The landowner's notice of termination to the contractor still matters; the Chamber used the date of that notice when calculating the contractual penalty in a forward-looking termination. - Q: What is the difference between retroactive and forward-looking termination of a flat-for-land construction contract under Turkish law? A: In retroactive termination the parties return to their position before the contract: the landowner reclaims shares transferred as an advance, and the contractor may claim the value of lawful work. In forward-looking termination the contractor receives units or shares in proportion to the work done, and the landowner may also claim delay compensation and the penalty attached to performance. The Court of Cassation's 6th Civil Chamber holds that retroactive termination cannot be ordered once construction reaches 90 percent or more; the landowner may also seek forward-looking termination at a lower level. - Q: Is a flat-for-land construction contract in Türkiye invalid if it was not drawn up by a notary in official form? A: As a rule, yes. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, because the contract includes a promise to transfer land shares, drawing it up by a notary in official form is a condition of validity (Turkish Civil Code art. 706). However, if the parties have performed their obligations fully or to a significant extent, or the land share has been transferred to the contractor, the lack of form cannot be invoked. Whether this exception applies depends on the facts of each case. - [Reserve Building Area Designation Annulment (Law No. 6306): Time Limit and Stay of Execution in Türkiye](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/reserve-building-area-annulment-law-6306-turkiye): Under Turkish law, a reserve building area is an area designated by the Ministry for use in implementations under Law No. 6306; an action may be brought before the administrative courts within thirty… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/rezerv-yapi-alani-ilani-ve-iptal-davasi-6306 - Q: What is the time limit for an action against a reserve building area designation in Türkiye? A: Under Turkish law, an action may be brought in the administrative courts within thirty days of notification against administrative acts taken under Law No. 6306 (art. 6/9). In a decision given by majority, which may not be final, on an urgent expropriation decision taken by Presidential decision, the Council of State’s 6th Chamber applied the general sixty-day limit because the special time limit under art. 20/A of the Administrative Procedure Law had not been stated in the act; it did not address the thirty-day limit in art. 6/9. When the period starts depends in each case on notification, publication or the date of knowledge. - Q: Can a stay of execution be requested in an action against a reserve building area designation in Türkiye? A: Yes. The original text of Law No. 6306 barred a stay of execution in actions brought under it; the Constitutional Court annulled that sentence by its 2014 decision E.2012/87, K.2014/41. Today, as a rule, a stay may be ordered under art. 27 of the Administrative Procedure Law where the act is clearly unlawful and its implementation would cause irreparable or impossible-to-remedy harm, both conditions being met together. - Q: What did Law No. 7471 change in the definition of a reserve building area under Law No. 6306? A: Law No. 7471 of 7/11/2023 removed the words “as a new settlement area” from the definition. Under Turkish law as now worded, a reserve building area is an area designated by the Ministry, at the request of TOKİ or the Administration or of its own motion, for use in implementations carried out under the Law (art. 2/1-c). In a decision recording this amendment, the Council of State’s 6th Chamber found lawful the designation of an empty parcel declared at the co-owners’ request. - Q: For how long can zoning and building procedures be suspended on property designated a reserve building area in Türkiye? A: Under art. 4/1 of Law No. 6306, the Presidency or, where it carries out the implementation, TOKİ or the Administration may temporarily suspend zoning and building procedures in reserve building areas for two years; where the implementation requires, this may be extended by one more year. The original text had no time limit; the Constitutional Court annulled the open-ended zoning ban as contrary to the right to property, and the provision was later re-enacted with these periods. - Q: Can urgent expropriation be carried out in a reserve building area under Turkish law? A: According to the 6th Chamber reasoning upheld by the Council of State’s Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers, declarations concerning a reserve building area have the character of a settlement project, and urgency exists provided the other expropriation requirements are met. The decision was given by majority; the dissent argued that whether the designation rests on concrete, technical and scientific data must also be reviewed. The outcome may differ in each case depending on the reasons for the act and the documents in the file. ### Mediation & Arbitration - [Mediation Completed Before the File Reaches the Competent Court Meets the Precondition: Court of Cassation](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/mediation-after-lack-of-jurisdiction-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, where an employment action was filed in a court lacking jurisdiction and mediation was concluded after the decision of lack of… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/gorevsiz-mahkemede-acilan-davada-sonradan-arabulucuya-basvuru - Q: What happens in Türkiye if an employment action is filed without applying to a mediator? A: Under Turkish law, if it is found that the action was filed without applying to a mediator, it is dismissed on procedural grounds for lack of a precondition without any further step (Law No. 7036 art. 3(2); Law No. 6325 art. 18/A(2)). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, no time is given to the claimant to apply to a mediator in that case. - Q: Does applying to a mediator after a decision of lack of jurisdiction satisfy the mediation precondition in Türkiye? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers decision of 21.01.2026, where an action was filed in a court without subject-matter jurisdiction and the mediation was concluded before the file was registered on the docket of the competent labour court, the precondition is deemed satisfied and the competent court proceeds to the merits. - Q: Is an employment action dismissed immediately in Türkiye if the final mediation report is not attached? A: No. If a mediator was applied to but the final report was not attached, the court gives a one-week final time limit; if the report is not submitted within that time, the action is dismissed on procedural grounds without the statement of claim being served on the other side. The Assembly of Civil Chambers characterises this as a precondition that can be completed. - Q: Is an employer's damages claim against an employee also subject to mandatory mediation in Türkiye? A: Yes. Law No. 7036 art. 3(1) makes mediation a precondition for employee or employer receivables and compensation. According to the statutory reasoning quoted by the Assembly of Civil Chambers, claims in tort or unjust enrichment arising from the employment relationship are also covered; damages actions arising from work accidents and occupational diseases are excluded by art. 3(3). - Q: Does mandatory mediation in Türkiye affect limitation and preclusive periods? A: From the application to the mediation office until the final report is drawn up, limitation is suspended and preclusive periods do not run (Law No. 7036 art. 3(17)). - [Unpaid Mediation Settlement Can Open the Way to Suing for the Whole Claim: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/unpaid-mediation-settlement-action-turkiye): Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, where a mediation settlement is conditional on full payment and allows all claims to be sued for in case of non-payment, the whole… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-19. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/arabuluculuk-anlasma-belgesi-odenmezse-dava-acilabilir-mi - Q: What can an employee do in Türkiye if the amount agreed in mediation is not paid? A: Under Turkish law a settlement document signed together by the parties, their lawyers and the mediator is treated as a document equivalent to a judgment without an enforceability annotation (Law No. 6325 art. 18(4)); enforcement proceedings can be started for the unpaid part. If the settlement provides that all claims may be sued for in case of non-payment, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers an action may also be filed for the entire claim after deducting what was paid. - Q: Can an action be filed in Türkiye for matters agreed in a mediation settlement? A: As a rule, no; Law No. 6325 art. 18(5) prohibits actions on matters agreed. In Assembly of Civil Chambers decision K. 2025/329, however, the settlement was made conditional on full and complete payment and an instalment was not paid, so it was held that the dispute had not been resolved permanently by the settlement. - Q: Is the action dismissed in Türkiye if the debtor pays the last instalment after the action is filed? A: According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, every action is decided on the factual and legal grounds existing on the date it was filed. Payment of the last instalment after filing did not change the fact that payments were not made fully and on time, and could not justify a procedural dismissal. - Q: On what grounds can the invalidity of a mediation settlement document be raised under Turkish law? A: According to the 9th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, since the settlement document is not res judicata in the substantive sense, absolute nullity, excessive advantage, mistake, fraud, duress and forgery may be raised. If there was no real dispute before mediation, the document is not a settlement within the meaning of art. 18(5). Whether invalidity must be pursued in a separate annulment action or examined as a preliminary issue in the claim itself is disputed within the Chamber. ### Mining & Energy Law - [Mining Licence Cancellation in Türkiye: Forfeited Security and Fines (Law No. 3213 Arts. 10, 13, 17, 24)](https://capar.av.tr/en/article/mining-licence-cancellation-administrative-fine-turkiye): Under Turkish law, an action against an administrative fine imposed under the Mining Law must be brought before the administrative court within thirty days of notification, and the action does not… Jurisdiction: Türkiye (Turkish law). Published: 2026-11-15. Turkish original: https://capar.av.tr/makale/maden-ruhsatinin-iptali-teminat-irat-kaydi-ve-idari-para-cezalarina-karsi-dava - Q: What is the time limit under Turkish law for suing against an administrative fine imposed under the Mining Law? A: Under Mining Law No. 3213 art. 13, an action against these fines may be brought before the administrative court within thirty days of notification. This special limit replaces the general sixty-day limit in Law No. 2577 art. 7. The day on which electronic notification is deemed made and extensions such as the judicial recess must be calculated separately; the 8th Chamber of the Council of State made this calculation in detail in one decision. - Q: Does suing against a Mining Law administrative fine in Türkiye stop collection of the fine? A: No. Law No. 3213 art. 13 expressly states that recourse to judicial remedies against administrative fines does not stop enforcement and collection. The fine is payable within one month of notification. Bringing an action alone is not enough to stop collection; a separate decision of the court is needed. This article does not examine the conditions for a stay of execution. - Q: Within what time limit and before which court is a mining licence cancellation challenged in Türkiye? A: Cancellation of a licence is an administrative act and is challenged by an action for annulment before the administrative court. Since no time limit specific to licence cancellation was found in the Mining Law articles examined for this article, the general sixty-day limit in Law No. 2577 art. 7 applies as a rule; this is the article’s own inference. If the act also contains an administrative fine, it is safer to rely on the thirty-day limit. The competent court is, as a rule, the administrative court where the authority that made the act is located (Law No. 2577 art. 32). - Q: Under Turkish law, is a mining licence cancelled immediately if the licence fee is not paid by the end of January? A: As a rule, no. Under the current text of Law No. 3213 art. 13, the portion unpaid at the end of January may be paid by the last day of June of that year, increased at the late-payment surcharge rate; if this is not done, the licence is cancelled without separate notice. In its decision of 27.02.2025, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State upheld a judgment finding a cancellation made before the end of June unlawful. - Q: When is a mining licence security deposit recorded as revenue under Turkish law today? A: Law No. 6592 (2015) abolished the security deposit and fee practice and introduced the licence fee; the current art. 13 also provides for a rehabilitation fee. Today Law No. 3213 art. 17 provides for the security deposit to be recorded as revenue for exploration licences where activity reports are not submitted, minimum activities are not carried out or the investment is not realised. For past security deposits that could not be recorded as revenue, provisional art. 21 provides for an administrative fine equal to that security deposit revenue. - Q: Is a fine imposed under the Turkish Mining Law if the permits required for the operating permit are not obtained in time? A: Under Law No. 3213 art. 24, if permits such as the environmental impact assessment decision, the ownership permit and the workplace opening and operating licence are not submitted within three years of the operating licence entering into force, an administrative fine is imposed each year. In its decision of 16.01.2025 the Constitutional Court did not find the rule unconstitutional, but stated that the fine cannot be applied where no fault can be attributed to the licence holder for the delay. Last updated: 2026-11-19