Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 14 min read

Last reviewed:

Board Deadlock in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Remedies, Quorum, Void Resolutions, Court-Appointed Trustee

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Unless the articles of association provide a stricter rule, the board meets with a majority of its total membership and decides by a majority of the members present; if the votes are tied again at the second meeting, the proposal is deemed rejected (TCC art. 390). If the board is continuously unable to meet, a quorum cannot be formed or there is no board, a single shareholder may call the general assembly with court permission; the general assembly may remove members on the basis of an agenda item or just cause (TCC art. 410/2, TCC art. 364). A trustee is appointed only if the company has been left without its necessary organs and its management cannot be secured in another way (Civil Code art. 427/4); according to the Court of Cassation, a board whose term has expired can still call the general assembly, so the company is not organless for that reason (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2012/13135, K. 2014/3515).

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

In a Turkish joint-stock company the board, unless the articles of association provide a stricter rule, meets with a majority of its total membership and decides by a majority of the members present; if the votes are tied again at the second meeting, the proposal is deemed rejected. If the board is continuously unable to meet, cannot form a meeting quorum or does not exist, a single shareholder may call the general assembly with court permission, and the general assembly may remove members where there is a relevant agenda item or just cause and elect new ones. A court-appointed trustee is a last resort: it may be appointed only if the company has been left without its necessary organs and its management cannot be secured in another way.

When the board of directors of a Turkish joint-stock company cannot take decisions: meeting and decision quorum, tied votes, calling a board meeting, resolutions by circulation, void resolutions, removal of members, convening the general assembly with court permission and the court-appointed trustee; Turkish Commercial Code arts. 390-393 and 410-412, Civil Code art. 427 and Court of Cassation decisions.

If the board is split evenly between two shareholder groups, if a member stops attending or if the chair does not call meetings, the board cannot take decisions and the company’s business comes to a halt.

What Quorum Does the Board Need to Meet and Decide?

Unless the articles of association set a stricter quorum, the board meets with a majority of its total membership and decides by a majority of the members present; members may not attend through a proxy. If the votes are tied, the matter is deferred to the next meeting, and if there is a tie again there, the proposal is deemed rejected; since the Code gives the chair no casting vote, this is where deadlock arises on an evenly split board (TCC art. 390).

Statutory Provision — Turkish Commercial Code (Law No. 6102) art. 390 (Board meetings: resolutions) (unofficial translation)

“(1) Unless the articles of association contain a provision to the contrary imposing a stricter requirement, the board of directors meets with the majority of its total number of members and takes its decisions by the majority of the members present at the meeting. … (3) If the votes are equal, the matter is deferred to the next meeting. If there is again a tie at the second meeting, the proposal in question is deemed rejected. (4) Provided that none of the members has requested a meeting, board decisions may also be taken by obtaining the written approval of at least the majority of the total number of members to a proposal on a specific matter made by one of the members and drafted in the form of a resolution. Making the same proposal to all board members is a condition of validity of a decision taken in this way. … (5) The validity of decisions depends on their being written and signed.”

What If the Chair Does Not Call a Meeting?

Any member may ask the chair in writing to call a meeting. Under the sentences added in 2024 by Law No. 7511, if a majority of the members so request in writing, the chair must call the board so that it meets within thirty days at the latest from receipt of the request; if the chair fails to do so, or the chair or vice-chair cannot be reached, the requesting members may call the meeting directly. The quorums in TCC art. 390/1 still apply at that meeting, and the articles of association may lay down a different calling procedure (TCC art. 392/7).

Can the Board Decide Without a Meeting?

Yes. If no member has requested a meeting, a decision may be taken by obtaining the written approval of a majority of the total membership to a proposal drafted as a resolution by one member; making the proposal to all members is a condition of validity, and the approval sheets must be pasted into the resolution book or turned into a signed resolution entered in the book (TCC art. 390/4). The Court of Cassation held that a decision taken by two members of a three-member board at a meeting held without a call, without following this procedure, was non-existent (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/6232, K. 2023/653).

Which Board Resolutions Are Void?

In particular, resolutions that breach the principle of equal treatment, the basic structure of the company or the principle of capital maintenance, that violate shareholders’ inalienable rights, or that encroach on the non-transferable powers of other organs are void, and a declaration to that effect may be sought from the court (TCC art. 391). The Court of Cassation treated failure to follow the circulation procedure as contrary to the basic structure and subject to nullity (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/6232, K. 2023/653). A member may not take part in deliberations on matters where his or her own, or certain relatives’, personal interests outside the company conflict with the company’s interests (TCC art. 393).

What If a Seat Falls Vacant or a Member Is Removed?

If a seat falls vacant, the board provisionally elects a person meeting the statutory requirements and submits the appointment to the next general assembly for approval; membership ends automatically upon bankruptcy, restriction of capacity or loss of the required qualifications (TCC art. 363). According to the Court of Cassation, members whose term has expired remain in office for extraordinary and urgent matters until a new management is elected (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2012/13135, K. 2014/3515). Members may be removed at any time by a general assembly resolution where there is a relevant agenda item or just cause (TCC art. 364); the Court of Cassation, stating that the power of removal lies with the general assembly, upheld a judgment dismissing a request, made without alleging any missing organ, to strip the directors of their power of representation and confer it on a trustee (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2014/4548, K. 2015/2472).

How Is the General Assembly Convened If the Board Cannot Meet?

The organ that can break the deadlock is the general assembly. A board whose term has expired may still call it; if the board is continuously unable to meet, a meeting quorum cannot be formed or there is no board, a single shareholder may make the call with court permission.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Commercial Code (Law No. 6102) art. 410 (Organs authorised and responsible for calling) (unofficial translation)

“(1) The general assembly may be called to a meeting by the board of directors even if its term of office has expired. Liquidators may also call the general assembly to a meeting for matters relating to their duties. (2) Where the board of directors is continuously unable to meet, where it is impossible to form a meeting quorum, or where there is no board, a single shareholder may call the general assembly to a meeting with the permission of the court. The court’s decision is final.”

Shareholders holding at least one tenth of the capital (one twentieth in publicly held companies) may request a call through a notary (TCC art. 411); if the request is rejected or not answered positively within seven business days, the commercial court at the company’s seat may appoint a trustee to make the call (TCC art. 412). The Court of Cassation stated that such decisions are final and cannot be reviewed on appeal (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/5248, K. 2024/6934). See also minority shareholder rights in joint-stock companies.

Can a Trustee Be Appointed to the Company?

A trustee is a subsidiary remedy: it is appointed where a legal person has been left without its necessary organs and its management cannot be secured in another way.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 427 (Management trusteeship) (unofficial translation)

“The guardianship authority takes the necessary measures for property whose management belongs to no one and, in particular, appoints a management trustee in the following cases: … 4. Where a legal person has been left without its necessary organs and its management cannot be secured in another way, …”

If for a long time a legally required organ is missing or the general assembly cannot meet, the court, on the application of a shareholder, a creditor or the Ministry, grants a period to remedy the situation, orders dissolution if it is not remedied, and once proceedings are brought may take the necessary measures at a party’s request (TCC art. 530). In a judgment upheld by the Court of Cassation, a trustee was held to require a missing organ or the general assembly having been unable to meet for many years (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2014/4548, K. 2015/2472). In another company left without a board, a trustee panel appointed as an interim measure called the general assembly and a new board was elected; the appellate decision stating that an appointment can be “limited to a specific task” was reversed by the Court of Cassation because the first-instance decision was final (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/5248, K. 2024/6934).

How Does a Limited Company Differ?

Managers decide by majority and in the event of a tie the chair has the casting vote, unless the articles provide otherwise (TCC art. 624/3). The provision on void board resolutions also applies to limited companies (TCC art. 644/1-c), and the joint-stock company rules on calling meetings and minority rights apply by analogy (TCC art. 617/3). Where there is just cause, any partner may ask the court to remove or restrict a manager’s management and representation powers (TCC art. 630/2). See also extraordinary general assembly in limited companies.

What Should Be Done, Step by Step?

  1. The quorum and calling provisions of the articles of association are reviewed.
  2. The chair is asked in writing to call a meeting; if a majority has made the request, the thirty-day period is monitored.
  3. For a decision without a meeting, the proposal is sent to all members.
  4. A call of the general assembly is requested; if this fails, the court is applied to.
  5. At the general assembly, members are removed and new ones elected.
  6. As a last resort, the court is applied to on the ground of a missing organ, or dissolution for just cause is sought (TCC art. 531).

What If the Wrong Procedure Is Followed?

A decision that is not written and signed is invalid (TCC art. 390/5); breach of the conflict-of-interest rule gives rise to liability for damages (TCC art. 393/2). Resolutions of a general assembly convened, without a court decision, by persons not authorised to call it may be held non-existent; a limited company judgment upheld by the Court of Cassation is to that effect (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/634, K. 2023/4147). See also liability of board members.

Case Study: What If the Votes Split 2–2?

Hypothetical: On a four-member board two shareholder groups each have two members; a proposal tied 2–2 at two meetings is deemed rejected. When one group’s members stop attending, the meeting quorum of at least three members cannot be reached, and the remaining two, not being a majority, cannot trigger the mandatory thirty-day call either. If the board is continuously unable to meet, one of the shareholders may call the general assembly with court permission (TCC art. 410/2), and the general assembly may elect a new board. If the shares are also split evenly, an action for dissolution for just cause may come into consideration.

Court of Cassation Decisions

For a decision without a meeting, the proposal must be made to all members

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/6232, K. 2023/653, 07.02.2023 (the Chamber’s reasoning for reversal; joint-stock company; rendered before the 2024 amendment on calling meetings)

“it has been regulated in a mandatory manner that making the same proposal to all board members is a condition of validity of a decision taken in this way. … Board resolutions that do not conform to the basic structure of the joint-stock company are subject to the sanction of nullity under subparagraph (b) of the first paragraph of Article 391 of the same Law.” (translation)

A board whose term has expired can call the general assembly

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2012/13135, K. 2014/3515, 25.02.2014 (the Chamber’s reasoning for reversal; joint-stock company)

“Therefore, it cannot be said that the company automatically becomes organless upon the expiry of the board members’ term of office. … it is clear that a board whose term of office has expired may call the general assembly to a meeting.” (translation)

A trustee requires a missing organ; removal is a power of the general assembly

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2014/4548, K. 2015/2472, 24.02.2015 (first part: reasoning of the court of first instance; second part: the Chamber’s reasoning for affirmance)

“that the appointment of a trustee in joint-stock companies is regulated in Article 530 of the TCC, and that the absence of one of the company organs or the general assembly having been unable to meet for many years is required … since, under Article 364 of the TCC, the power to remove the board of directors is among the absolute powers of the general assembly” (translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

With how many members does the board meet and decide?

Unless the articles provide a stricter rule, it meets with a majority of its total membership and decides by a majority of the members present (TCC art. 390/1).

What happens if the board’s votes are tied?

The matter is deferred to the next meeting; if there is a tie again, the proposal is deemed rejected (TCC art. 390/3). In a limited company, by contrast, the chair has the casting vote (TCC art. 624/3).

Can the board take a decision without a meeting?

If no member requests a meeting, a written proposal made to all members may be adopted with the written approval of a majority of the total membership (TCC art. 390/4).

What can a shareholder do if the board cannot meet at all?

If the board is continuously unable to meet, a quorum cannot be formed or there is no board, a single shareholder may call the general assembly with court permission; the court’s decision is final (TCC art. 410/2).

What is required for a trustee to be appointed to a joint-stock company?

The company must have been left without its necessary organs and its management must be impossible to secure in another way (Civil Code art. 427/4). According to the Court of Cassation, a board whose term has expired can still call the general assembly, so the company is not automatically organless (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2012/13135, K. 2014/3515).

Board and general assembly disputes fall within our Commercial and Company Law practice area.

The way out depends on the articles of association, the distribution of shares, the duration of the deadlock and the resolutions already adopted, so the specific documents need to be assessed separately.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Board Deadlock in Turkish Joint-Stock Companies: Remedies, Quorum, Void Resolutions, Court-Appointed Trustee”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-10-19, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/board-deadlock-joint-stock-company

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›