Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Assumed Burden on a Note Survives a Contradictory Amendment: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, where lack of consideration is alleged against a promissory note, the burden of proof lies as a rule on the debtor, because a promissory note contains an acknowledgment of debt that does not depend on its cause. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, if the creditor, instead of relying on that presumption in its statement of defence, asserts, contrary to what appears from the text of the note, that it was given for a different underlying relationship (here, against the debt of a company not party to the action) and submits its evidence, it takes the burden of proof upon itself. It cannot later revive the presumption through an amendment wholly contradicting its first defence; this breaches the rule of good faith and the prohibition of contradictory conduct. The Assembly unanimously reversed the decision of resistance with final effect.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that, in a negative declaratory action concerning promissory notes allegedly given as an advance, a defendant who assumed the burden of proof by arguing in its statement of defence that the notes were given against the debt of a company not party to the action cannot later shift that burden back to the claimant by an amendment contradicting its first defence.

Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that, in a negative declaratory action concerning promissory notes allegedly given as an advance, a defendant who assumed the burden of proof in its statement of defence cannot shift that burden back to the claimant by an amendment contradicting its first defence.

The Dispute

The claimant company argued that the promissory notes it had drawn in favour of the defendant company on 10.02.2015 had been given as an advance for a commercial relationship to be established, but that this relationship had never materialised. The notes did not state the reason for their issue. The claimant had paid one note of TRY 50,000 under threat of compulsory enforcement; it sought a declaration that it was not liable under the notes and the recovery of that amount.

In its statement of defence, the defendant argued that two of the notes had not been delivered to it and that the others had been given against the current-account debt of a healthcare company, not party to the action, that was organically linked to the claimant, under a protocol dated 20.12.2013, and it submitted its evidence. By a petition for amendment filed during the proceedings, however, it asserted that the notes had been taken against its receivable directly from the claimant.

The Istanbul Anadolu 2nd Commercial Court of First Instance dismissed the action on the grounds that the advance allegation had not been proved by a written document and that the oath had not been relied on as evidence; the 13th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal, taking the amended defence as its basis, dismissed the appeal on the merits. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed the decision on the ground that the defendant had taken the burden of proof upon itself; the first-instance court, however, resisted, stating that the defence changed by amendment could not be disregarded.

Outcome of the Decision

On 25.06.2025 the Assembly of Civil Chambers accepted the claimant’s appeal and reversed the decision of resistance under art. 371 of the Code of Civil Procedure for the reasons given in the Chamber’s reversal decision; it also expressly stated that it adopted the Chamber’s decision. The decision was given unanimously and with final effect; there is no dissenting opinion. The file was sent to the first-instance court that had given the decision of resistance.

Reasoning

The Assembly first set the starting point: where the note does not state the reason for its issue, the drawer proves lack of consideration; but the burden of proof may shift during the proceedings:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“In the present case, it is undisputed that the reason for issuing the notes was not stated. The claimant asserts that the notes in dispute were given as an advance for a commercial relationship to be established with the defendant in the future but that, as this relationship could not be established, the notes were left without consideration. As matters stand, the burden of proof lies on the debtor claimant who alleges lack of consideration. … However, in the course of the proceedings the burden of proof may of course shift according to the facts and statements put forward by the parties.”

According to the Assembly, a mere denial of the advance allegation by the defendant would not have shifted the burden of proof. What was decisive was that, contrary to what appears from the text of the note, the defendant explained that the note rested on a different underlying relationship and submitted evidence on it:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2024/121, K. 2025/390, 25.06.2025 (the burden of proof passing to the defendant)

“By this defence the defendant, … not relying on the presumption concerning allegations of lack of consideration based on a negotiable instrument … explained the fact put forward concerning the reason for issuing the note within the meaning of procedural law and, by also submitting its evidence on that fact, took the burden of proof upon itself. The defendant now bears the burden of proving this new fact, which forms the basis of its defence.”

The Assembly recalled that, under art. 141 of the Code of Civil Procedure, once the petitions have been exchanged a defence may be changed only with the express consent of the other party or by amendment. Amendment exists to correct procedural errors; but it is limited by the rule of good faith in art. 2 of the Turkish Civil Code and by the duty to tell the truth in art. 29 of the Code of Civil Procedure:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“Although it is in principle possible to change by amendment a fact put forward at the pleadings stage, the subject of amendment is the parties’ procedural errors, and this institution, introduced with the aim of preventing loss of rights, cannot conceivably be used as an instrument for openly committing procedural fraud. Since this conduct, contrary to the rule of good faith and to the parties’ obligation to make truthful statements, is of a nature that violates the prohibition of contradictory conduct, in the present case it is no longer possible to give effect to the amendment or, to put it more plainly, to resolve the dispute between the parties by treating the defendant as if it had never made its first defence.”

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision applies two known rules of Turkish law together. In a negative declaratory action the burden of proof lies as a rule on the defendant claiming the debt; but where the drawer alleges lack of consideration of a promissory note against the payee, the burden passes to the claimant. The Assembly also recalled that, where the note states the cause of the debt as “goods” or “cash”, the burden falls on the party asserting the contrary of that entry. On the other hand, the burden of proof is not fixed for the whole action: a creditor who, instead of relying on the abstract nature of the note, brings its own account of the underlying relationship must prove that account.

The notable element of the decision is the limit on amendment. The Assembly regards changing a defence by amendment as possible in principle; in this case, however, it gave no effect to an amendment that wholly contradicted the first defence and sought to revive the presumption in the defendant’s favour. The claimant had also argued that the amendment was made at the stage when the taking of evidence was ending; the Assembly’s reasoning, however, rests not on the timing of the amendment but on its contradiction with the first defence.

In practice, a creditor that, in answer to an allegation of lack of consideration, explains that the note was given for a different underlying relationship, contrary to what appears from its text, and submits evidence may assume the burden of proof. The debtor, for its part, as a rule proves the advance allegation itself; but whether the creditor has assumed the burden through its own account, and whether a later amendment contradicts it, should be examined separately.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) art. 176 (Scope and number)

“(1) Each party may amend, in part or in whole, the procedural acts it has performed.

(2) In the same action, the parties may resort to amendment only once.”

Statutory Provision — Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) art. 190/1 (Burden of proof)

“(1) Unless there is a special provision in the law, the burden of proof lies on the party who derives a right in its favour from the legal consequence attached to the fact alleged.”

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 2 (Acting in good faith)

“Everyone must act in accordance with the rules of good faith when exercising their rights and performing their obligations.

The legal order does not protect the manifest abuse of a right.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Who bears the burden of proof when lack of consideration is alleged against a promissory note?

Under Turkish law, it lies as a rule with the drawer who alleges lack of consideration, because a promissory note contains an acknowledgment of debt that does not depend on its cause. Where the note states the cause of the debt as “goods” or “cash”, the burden of proof falls on the party asserting the contrary of that entry.

When is the creditor deemed to have assumed the burden of proof?

Merely denying the debtor’s allegation is not enough. If the creditor, contrary to what appears from the text of the note, explains that the note was given for a different underlying relationship and submits its evidence, it must prove this new fact.

Can the defence set out in the statement of defence be changed by amendment?

As a rule, yes; under Turkish law amendment may be made once in the same action (Code of Civil Procedure art. 176). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, however, an amendment wholly contradicting the first defence cannot be a tool for escaping the burden of proof; it breaches the prohibition of contradictory conduct.

What must the debtor prove for a promissory note given as an advance?

Where the note does not state the reason for its issue, as a rule the debtor proves that the note was given as an advance for a relationship to be established and that this relationship was not established.

Can the amount of a promissory note paid under threat of enforcement be recovered?

Under the general principle recited by the Assembly, a debtor who has paid the debt under threat of compulsory enforcement may bring a recovery action against the creditor for the return of the money paid.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Negotiable Instruments Law

All Negotiable Instruments Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Assumed Burden on a Note Survives a Contradictory Amendment: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/promissory-note-burden-of-proof-amendment-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›