Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 21 min read

Last reviewed:

Removal and Protection Orders under Law No. 6284 in Türkiye: Objection and Coercive Detention (Arts. 9, 13)

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, a protection order under Law No. 6284 is issued on the request of the person concerned or on the application of the Ministry, the police or the public prosecutor, and may be issued for at most six months the first time (art. 8). The rule that “no evidence or document is required” is written in the Law only for protective measures; according to the Constitutional Court, no such exception is provided for preventive measures such as removal from the home. An objection may be lodged with the family court within two weeks of pronouncement or service, and the decision on the objection is final (art. 9). A person who breaches the order is, as a rule, subject to coercive detention of three to ten days, and fifteen to thirty days for each repetition, even if the act is also a crime; the total may not exceed six months (art. 13).

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, preventive measures such as removal from the home under Law No. 6284 are issued initially for at most six months and may be extended; an objection lies to the family court within two weeks and the objection decision is final. The article explains the evidentiary threshold, coercive detention for breach, and decisions of the Constitutional Court and the Court of Cassation.

Measures such as removal from the home and no-approach orders issued by the family court in Türkiye under Law No. 6284: who may request them, the evidentiary threshold, duration, objection under art. 9 and coercive detention under art. 13 for breach.

What Is a Protection Order under Law No. 6284?

The decisions commonly called “protection orders” or “removal orders” in Türkiye are based on Law No. 6284 on the Protection of the Family and the Prevention of Violence against Women. A protection order is not a conviction; it is a set of rules of conduct imposed for a limited time: do not come to the home, do not call, do not approach.

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 on the Protection of the Family and the Prevention of Violence against Women art. 1/1 (Purpose, scope and basic principles)

“The purpose of this Law is to regulate the procedures and principles concerning the measures to be taken to protect women, children, family members and victims of unilateral persistent stalking who have suffered violence or are at risk of violence, and to prevent violence against these persons.”

The protected persons are not only women; nor must violence have occurred, as a “risk of violence” is sufficient. The Constitutional Court has also stated that the concept of violence in the Law is broader than the concept of crime, and that the measures are directed at acts capable of causing violence in a broad sense, whether or not they amount to a crime (see decision App. No. 2018/2626 below).

Proceedings for a protection order are not criminal proceedings; according to the Court of Cassation’s 7th Criminal Chamber, the family court gives these decisions at the end of civil proceedings (see the 2024 decision below). A criminal investigation may also run on the same facts.

Protective and Preventive Measures: Which One Is Removal?

The Law distinguishes two kinds of measures; this distinction is the key to the article. Protective measures are directed at the protected person: they set up a new arrangement for that person. Preventive measures are directed at the person who uses violence or is alleged to pose a risk of violence: they restrict that person’s conduct.

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 art. 4/1 (Protective measures to be ordered by the judge)

“With regard to persons protected under this Law, the judge may order one or more of the following protective measures or other similar measures deemed appropriate:

a) Change of workplace.

b) If the person is married, designation of a place of residence separate from the joint residence.”

Removal from the home, by contrast, is a preventive measure. The Law lists it among the measures to be ordered by the judge:

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 art. 5/1 (Preventive measures to be ordered by the judge)

“With regard to persons who use violence, the judge may order one or more of the following preventive measures or other similar measures deemed appropriate:

… b) Immediate removal from the joint residence or from where they are, and allocation of the joint residence to the protected person.

c) Not approaching the protected persons or the residence, school and workplace where these persons are.

… f) Not disturbing the protected person through means of communication or otherwise.”

The article also covers refraining from insults and threats, restricting contact with children, surrender of weapons and measures concerning treatment. The list is not exhaustive: the judge may also order “other similar measures deemed appropriate”.

The judge may also decide on custody, guardianship, maintenance and personal relations (art. 5/3). If the person who uses violence supports or contributes to the family’s livelihood and no maintenance has been awarded under the Turkish Civil Code, the judge may award interim maintenance even if not requested (art. 5/4).

Who May Request the Order and Who Issues It?

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 art. 8/1 (Issuance and service of the order and confidentiality)

“A protection order is issued on the request of the person concerned, or on the application of the Ministry or law enforcement officers or the public prosecutor. Protection orders may be requested from the judge, the local administrative authority or the law enforcement unit that is quickest and easiest to reach.”

No lawsuit is needed; the person seeking protection may apply to the judge, the local administrative authority or the police. “Judge” in the Law means the family court judge; the Court of Cassation’s 7th Criminal Chamber based this on art. 2/1-c of the Law. Where there is no family court, these matters are heard, according to art. 2/2 of Law No. 4787 as quoted in the same decision, by the designated civil court of first instance.

For urgent cases the Law also gives power to the police:

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 art. 5/2

“In cases where delay would be harmful, the measures in subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) and (d) of the first paragraph may also be taken by the relevant law enforcement chiefs. The law enforcement chief submits the file for the judge’s approval at the latest within the first working day following the date of the decision. Measures not approved by the judge within twenty-four hours are lifted automatically.”

A measure such as removal from the home may therefore be taken by a police chief where delay would be harmful; but if the judge does not approve it within twenty-four hours, the measure lapses automatically. The Law also provides that an order may be requested from the local administrative authority (art. 8/1); this article focuses on judicial orders.

Is No Evidence Required? The Text of the Law and the Constitutional Court

The phrase “no evidence is required under 6284” is widely used in practice. The text of the Law is narrower:

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 art. 8/3

“For a protective measure to be ordered, no evidence or document is required as to the use of violence. A preventive measure is ordered without delay. The issuing of this decision may not be delayed in a way that could endanger achieving the purpose of this Law.”

The first sentence of the paragraph speaks of a “protective measure”. What is said of a preventive measure is that it is ordered without delay. The Constitutional Court has drawn this distinction expressly: the no-evidence rule applies to protective measures; for preventive measures such as removal from the home the Law provides no such exception. Referring to the legislative rationale, the Court notes that a preventive measure requires facts showing that the person has been exposed to violence or is at risk of it (see decision App. No. 2018/2626 below).

This does not mean that a preventive measure can only be ordered on full proof. The Law requires the decision not to be delayed, and the Constitutional Court accepts that a more flexible approach to reasoning may be adopted in the first decision. According to this article’s inference, at the objection stage, rejecting the objection without discussing the evidence and arguments of the person against whom the order was made may raise an issue under the right to a reasoned decision.

Duration, Service and Warning

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 art. 8/2

“A protection order may be issued for at most six months the first time. However, where it is understood that violence or the risk of violence will continue, it may be decided, ex officio or upon the request of the protected person or the Ministry or law enforcement officers, to change the duration or form of the measures, to lift them or to continue them as they are.”

Six months is an upper limit; a shorter period may also be set. Besides a six-month order, the decisions below also involve one-month and thirty-day orders. In the case in the Constitutional Court’s 2026 decision, the extension request was rejected because no new event or fact had been reported.

Service of the order and the warning about coercive detention are also regulated in the Law:

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 art. 8/5

“When the protection order is pronounced and served, a warning is given that coercive detention will be applied to the person who uses violence in case of breach of the order.”

The order is pronounced or served on the protected person and on the person who uses violence; a decision rejecting the request is served only on the protected person (art. 8/4). Where necessary, the identity and address information of the protected person is kept confidential in official records (art. 8/6).

Objection to the Order (Art. 9)

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 art. 9 (Objection)

“(1) The persons concerned may object to the family court against decisions given under this Law within two weeks from the date of pronouncement or service.

… (3) The authority hearing the objection gives its decision within one week. Decisions given upon objection are final.”

When an objection is lodged against a judge’s order, the file is sent to the next-numbered family court in the same place (from the last-numbered court to the first), to the civil court of first instance if there is only one family court, or to the nearest civil court of first instance if the family court judge and the civil court judge are the same person (art. 9/2).

In the words of the Law, “the persons concerned” may object; in this article’s assessment, this includes both the person against whom the order was made and a protected person whose request was rejected; indeed, the Law requires a decision rejecting the request to be served on the protected person (art. 8/4), and the objection period runs from service (art. 9/1). The Court of Cassation’s 2nd Civil Chamber has stated, on the basis of this provision, that a decision rejecting the objection cannot be appealed. The ordinary remedies end here; if there is an alleged rights violation, an individual application to the Constitutional Court may come into play.

Breach and Coercive Detention (Art. 13)

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6284 art. 13 (Breach of protection orders)

“(1) A person who uses violence and against whom a protection order has been issued under this Law shall, if he acts contrary to the requirements of the order, be subject by judicial decision to coercive detention of three to ten days, depending on the nature of the breached measure and the gravity of the breach, even if the act constitutes a crime.

(2) For each repetition of a breach of the requirements of the order, the duration of coercive detention is fifteen to thirty days, depending on the nature of the breached measure and the gravity of the breach. However, the total duration of coercive detention may not exceed six months.”

Coercive detention decisions are enforced by the chief public prosecutor’s office (art. 13/3). The duration is graduated: 3–10 days for the first breach, 15–30 days for each repetition; the total may not exceed six months.

The words “even if the act constitutes a crime” matter: if the breach is also a crime such as threats, insult or bodily harm, coercive detention does not prevent a separate criminal investigation for that crime. The Constitutional Court did not find this structure unconstitutional.

Whether coercive detention can be imposed for conduct before the order was pronounced or served has been debated. The Law requires a warning about coercive detention on pronouncement and service (art. 8/5). In the 2024 case below, the Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office at the Court of Cassation argued, relying on art. 38/3 of the Implementing Regulation, that coercive detention cannot be applied for an incident before service. The Chamber did not examine the merits of that view and rejected the request on another ground. The Regulation provision quoted by the Prosecutor’s Office requires that the order containing the warning has been pronounced or served; the Chamber did not resolve the question.

Orders, Objections and Coercive Detention in Court Decisions

The nature of coercive detention. A civil court of first instance asked for the annulment of the whole of art. 13, arguing that punishing a person who breaches the order both with coercive detention and under criminal laws amounts to double punishment for the same act. The Constitutional Court rejected the referral concerning paragraphs (2) and (3) for lack of jurisdiction, as they were not applicable in the case before the referring court, and rejected the challenge to paragraph (1) on the merits, by majority:

Constitutional Court Decision (norm review)
Constitutional Court, E. 2013/119, K. 2013/141, 28.11.2013 (rejection of the referral against art. 13/1)

“The coercive detention in the impugned rule is not a penalty applied in return for a crime. By its legal nature, coercive detention is a disciplinary detention that compels compliance with the obligation to obey the protection order and is provided for in case of breach of that obligation. … If the person’s conduct contrary to the protection order also constitutes a crime, since this results in the violation of different legal interests protected by the legal order, there can be no question of double punishment.”

Three members dissented, arguing that where a single act both breaches the order and constitutes a crime, providing for two separate custodial sanctions violates the prohibition of being punished more than once for the same act (non bis in idem). The Court’s decision, however, is that the rule is constitutional, and the rule remains in force today with the same text.

Facts for preventive measures and reasoning on objection. A family court, on a police request, issued a six-month order against a spouse in divorce proceedings; the criminal investigation into the same incident ended with a decision of non-prosecution for lack of evidence. The objection authority rejected the objection without discussing the person’s arguments and evidence. The Constitutional Court found violations of both the presumption of innocence and the right to a reasoned decision:

Constitutional Court Decision (individual application)
Constitutional Court, App. No. 2018/2626, 14.10.2020 (First Section; violation; §§ 43, 48)

“… paragraph (3) of article 8 states that no evidence or document as to the existence of violence will be required for the protective measures specified in article 4 of the Law that may be ordered by the judge. On the other hand, no such exception has been provided for the preventive measures regulated in article 5 of the Law, which are predominantly of a nature restricting the fundamental rights and freedoms of the person against whom the order is made … it is seen that the objection authority did not explain, even at a minimum level, why the objection to the unreasoned protection order was rejected.”

The violation of the presumption of innocence rests on the fact that, in that case, the order proceedings began following a criminal investigation and the decisions used the label “person who uses violence” about the applicant in a template manner. The outcome is specific to the case; not every protection order violates the presumption of innocence.

A more recent decision: flexible reasoning and the criminal link. In a 2026 decision, a person raised the same two complaints about a one-month order issued because of social media posts and the rejection of the objection; the Constitutional Court declared the application inadmissible:

Constitutional Court Decision (individual application)
Constitutional Court, App. No. 2024/26138, 06.05.2026 (First Section; inadmissibility; §§ 14, 19)

“… since the reasons given in the court’s decision and in the decision on the objection to the protection order were found to be relevant and sufficient, it was assessed that there was manifestly no violation of the right to a reasoned decision. … Since the expressions used in a decision given in a dispute concerning civil rights and obligations cannot be examined under the presumption of innocence – as there is no connected criminal case/investigation – …”

The two decisions do not supersede but complement each other. On reasoning, the yardstick is the nature and duration of the measure and the particularities of the case. In the 2026 decision, the Court found a one-month preventive measure ordered with brief reasoning referring to the facts sufficient. The presumption of innocence comes into play only where there is a link between the order proceedings and a criminal investigation or prosecution.

Finality of the objection decision. The Court of Cassation’s 2nd Civil Chamber did not examine an appeal against a decision rejecting an objection to an order under Law No. 6284:

Court of Cassation Decision

“The decision appealed concerns the rejection of an objection to decisions given under Law No. 6284. It is therefore not among the decisions that can be appealed.”

Objection to a coercive detention decision. In a file brought before it by way of appeal in the interest of the law, the same Chamber stated that a coercive detention decision given by a family court is also subject to objection under art. 9 and that finalisation should take place after the objection stage. The decision also relies on the rule in article 4 of the Law on the Enforcement of Sentences and Security Measures that “convictions cannot be enforced unless final”:

Court of Cassation Decision (appeal in the interest of the law)
2nd Civil Chamber, E. 2014/17763, K. 2015/3728, 05.03.2015 (reversal without effect on the outcome)

“… that the coercive detention decision is subject to objection and that the finalisation procedure must be carried out after this stage; therefore, it was not correct to reject the objection as written instead of accepting it on this point.”

The Implementing Regulation also expressly provides that coercive detention decisions may be objected to before the family court within two weeks of pronouncement or service (art. 34/1); the point that they cannot be enforced before becoming final rests only on this decision. The decision dates from 2015 and was given by way of appeal in the interest of the law; the search carried out for this article found no more recent Court of Cassation decision addressing the same question. Practice may vary from court to court.

The appeal in the interest of the law route. In its 2024 decision, the Court of Cassation’s 7th Criminal Chamber rejected an appeal in the interest of the law under art. 309 of the Code of Criminal Procedure against coercive detention decisions given by a family court:

Court of Cassation Decision
7th Criminal Chamber, E. 2022/3528, K. 2024/1779, 19.02.2024 (appeal in the interest of the law rejected)

“it was considered that decisions given by the family court, which is a civil court, at the end of civil proceedings cannot be reversed in the interest of the law under article 309 of Law No. 5271, whose field of application is criminal procedure.”

In this article’s assessment, the outcome shows that the main route of review against coercive detention is the objection under art. 9.

Practical Points

  • Count the time limit from service. The time limit for objection is two weeks and runs from the date of pronouncement or service (art. 9/1). The decision of the objection authority is final; there is no appeal.
  • Make the objection concrete. According to the Constitutional Court’s decisions, the objection authority is expected to address the essential arguments and evidence. Showing concrete evidence against the facts (message records, witnesses, the outcome of the investigation) in the objection therefore also sharpens the authority’s duty to give reasons.
  • Comply while the order lasts. Art. 9 contains no provision that an objection suspends enforcement of the measure; the Constitutional Court also notes that protection orders are enforceable as soon as they are issued. The order must be complied with until it is lifted or expires. A coercive detention decision is different: according to the Court of Cassation’s 2nd Civil Chamber, it does not become final, and is not enforced, before the objection stage is completed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is evidence required for a removal order under Law No. 6284 in Türkiye?

The rule that “no evidence or document is required” (art. 8/3) is written in the Law for protective measures. Removal from the home is a preventive measure (art. 5/1-b). According to the Constitutional Court of Türkiye, that exception is not provided for preventive measures; referring to the legislative rationale, the Court noted that a preventive measure requires facts showing exposure to violence or a risk of it. Even so, a preventive measure is ordered without delay, and a more flexible approach to reasoning may be accepted in the first decision.

What is the maximum duration of a protection or removal order under Law No. 6284 in Türkiye?

Under Turkish law, a protection order may be issued for at most six months the first time (art. 8/2). If violence or the risk of violence is found likely to continue, the judge may, ex officio or on the request of the protected person, the Ministry or the police, change the duration or form of the measure, lift it or continue it unchanged. Six months is an upper limit; a shorter period may also be set.

How and within what time limit can a removal order under Law No. 6284 be challenged in Türkiye?

Under Turkish law, an objection is lodged with the family court within two weeks of the date of pronouncement or service (art. 9/1). The file is sent to the next-numbered family court in the same place, to the civil court of first instance if there is only one family court, or to the nearest civil court of first instance if both courts have the same judge. The objection authority decides within one week and its decision is final (art. 9/3); according to the Court of Cassation’s 2nd Civil Chamber, a decision rejecting the objection cannot be appealed.

How long is the coercive detention for breaching a protection order under Law No. 6284 in Türkiye?

Under Turkish law, a person who breaches the order is subject by judicial decision to coercive detention of three to ten days for the first breach, depending on the nature of the breached measure and the gravity of the breach (art. 13/1). For each repetition the period is fifteen to thirty days; the total may not exceed six months (art. 13/2). The decisions are enforced by the chief public prosecutor’s office.

Does coercive detention for breaching an order under Law No. 6284 prevent a criminal case for the same act in Türkiye?

As a rule, no. The Law provides for coercive detention “even if the act constitutes a crime” (art. 13/1). The Constitutional Court of Türkiye held that coercive detention is not a penalty for a crime but a disciplinary detention, and that where the breach is also a crime there is no double punishment because different legal interests are violated; three members dissented.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Family & Divorce Law

All Family & Divorce Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Removal and Protection Orders under Law No. 6284 in Türkiye: Objection and Coercive Detention (Arts. 9, 13)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/law-6284-removal-order-objection-coercive-detention

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›