Last reviewed:
How to Challenge a Zoning Fine and a Demolition Order in Türkiye: Zoning Law No. 3194 Arts. 32 and 42
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, where a building is unlicensed or contrary to its permit, the administration seals it and draws up a stop-work report. If, as a rule, the building owner does not bring the building into line with the permit or obtain a permit within one month, the municipal council orders demolition, and a zoning fine is also imposed (Law No. 3194 art. 42). As a rule, an annulment action against these acts is brought in the administrative court within sixty days (Administrative Procedure Law art. 7); in one decision the Council of State’s 6th Chamber ran the period for the stop-work report from the date the report was posted on the building and for the council decision from its proper notification. According to the Constitutional Court and the Council of State’s Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, the fine is imposed not on the registered owner as such but on the person who actually built or commissioned the unlawful structure.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, an action against a stop-work report, a demolition order and a zoning fine for an unlicensed building is, as a rule, brought within the sixty-day period in art. 7 of the Administrative Procedure Law; in the decisions cited, the actions were heard by administrative courts. The article explains the one-month period to obtain a permit, how the fine is calculated, who is liable and the link with art. 184 of the Turkish Criminal Code.
The path under Turkish law against a stop-work report, a demolition order and a zoning fine issued for an unlicensed building or one built contrary to its permit in Türkiye: arts. 32 and 42 of Zoning Law No. 3194, the time limit for an action under art. 7 of the Administrative Procedure Law, the one month allowed to obtain a permit, how the fine is calculated, who is liable for it, and the offence in art. 184 of the Turkish Criminal Code.
What Are the Stop-Work Report, Demolition and the Zoning Fine?
Zoning Law No. 3194 provides two separate sanctions against a building that is unlicensed or contrary to its permit: bringing the building into line with the permit or, failing that, demolition (art. 32), and an administrative fine (art. 42). Both start with the same finding. When the municipality or the governorship learns of the breach, it records the state of construction at that moment, seals the building and stops the works. The document recording this finding is known in practice as the stop-work report (yapı tatil tutanağı; in the Law, yapı tatil zaptı).
Both the demolition order and the fine rest on this finding: the unlawful area, the unlicensed part and the state of construction are written in the report. A wrong or incomplete finding in the report passes into every later act.
The report is posted at the building site and is thereby deemed notified to the building owner. Under sentences added by Law No. 7221 in 2020, information on the breach is reported to the land registry within seven days to be entered in the declarations section of the title register; the entry cannot be removed until the registry is told that the breach has been remedied.
“The stoppage shall be deemed notified to the building owner by posting the stop-work report at the building site.
… Within at most one month from that date, the building owner shall bring the building into line with the permit or obtain a permit and request the municipality or governorship to remove the seal.
… Otherwise, the permit shall be revoked, and the building constructed contrary to the permit or without a permit shall be demolished by the municipality or governorship following a decision of the municipal council or the provincial administrative board, and the cost shall be collected from the building owner.
… The permit of buildings which the administration finds cannot be licensed or whose breaches cannot be remedied shall be revoked without waiting for the one-month period in the third paragraph, and the provisions of the fifth paragraph shall be applied to the unlawful works.”
The One-Month Period to Obtain a Permit and Demolition
The basic design of the Law is that, if the breach can be remedied, the owner is given a chance. Within at most one month from the posting of the report, the owner brings the building into line with the permit or obtains a permit and asks for the seal to be removed. If the administration finds compliance on inspection, it removes the seal and construction continues. Otherwise the permit is revoked and the municipal council (outside municipalities, the provincial administrative board) orders demolition; the cost is collected from the building owner.
The last paragraph, added by Law No. 7153 in 2018, creates an exception: if the administration finds that the building cannot be licensed or the breach cannot be remedied, the permit is revoked without waiting for the one-month period and the demolition provisions apply. In the case decided by the Council of State’s 6th Chamber below, the council had likewise ordered demolition on the ground that the breaches could not be licensed. The dispute then turns on whether the breach truly cannot be remedied, a question the court resolves by site inspection and expert examination.
Under sentences added in 2020, if the administration does not take a demolition decision within two months or does not carry it out within six months, the building may be demolished by the Ministry.
How the Zoning Fine Is Calculated
The fine is imposed by the municipal council, and the Law sets a short period for it: ten working days from the finding of the breach. The fine is applied separately to each person responsible and for each responsibility assumed; the building owner, the contractor and the site supervisor who failed to report the breach within six working days may each be fined.
“The administrative sanctions set out in this article shall be applied separately by the council of the relevant administration to those responsible, for each responsibility assumed, within ten working days from the date on which the acts and situations set out in this article that constitute a breach of zoning legislation are established.
… Administrative fines calculated as follows, not less than one thousand Turkish lira, shall be applied to the owner of buildings constructed without a permit or contrary to the permit, the studies and projects annexed to the permit and zoning legislation, or of buildings that may be built without a permit under article 27 but are built without meeting the conditions set out in that article, to the building contractor and to the site supervisors who do not report the breach to the administration within six working days, according to the ownership status of the building, the characteristics, condition, nature and class of the area where it stands, its effect on settlement and the environment, whether it threatens the safety of life and property, and the size of the breach:”
The calculation has four layers. The first is the base fine: under sub-paragraph (a), for each square metre of the unlawful area, the unit amount written in the Law for the building class and group set by the Ministry is applied (from three lira for class I group A to sixty-three lira for class V group D). These are the amounts in the statutory text; they are increased every year by the revaluation rate, so that year’s updated figure must be used. For breaches that cannot be measured by area (a change to the façade, for example), sub-paragraph (b) uses twenty per cent of the cost determined under the unit price list. Law No. 7579 of 7 May 2026 added a sentence providing that, if the Ministry adds a new group, the highest existing group in that class is used.
The second layer is the aggravating factors: each situation in sub-paragraph (c) is calculated separately on the base fine and added. Examples are 180 per cent for an unlicensed building, 20 per cent for a building in an area with an implementation zoning plan, 20 per cent for a completed building in use, and 30 per cent for a building on a co-owned plot built without the other owners’ consent. As a hypothetical example: if the base fine is 10,000 lira, for an unlicensed building in a planned area that is in use, 18,000 + 2,000 + 2,000 lira are added, for a total of 32,000 lira (excluding sub-paragraph (ç) and repetition).
The third layer is sub-paragraph (ç), added by Law No. 7226 in 2020: an additional fine equal to the unlawful area multiplied by the minimum square-metre value of the land for property tax purposes is added to the fines imposed on the building owner and the contractor. This sub-paragraph has an important exit: if the breach is remedied and the building brought into compliance within one month of notification of the fine, the part arising from sub-paragraph (ç) is not collected. The fourth layer is repetition: if the same act is repeated during construction or, as regards fire safety, during use, for example by breaking the seal and continuing construction, the fine is doubled.
“… 8) If it is unlicensed, 180% of the fine,
… If, within one month of notification to the person concerned of the administrative fine imposed under this paragraph, the breach is remedied and the building is brought into line with the legislation, the fine added under this sub-paragraph shall not be collected.
… Where the acts and situations set out in the paragraphs above are repeated during the construction of the building or, as regards fire safety, during its use, the administrative fines shall be applied doubled.
… Administrative fines collected under the paragraphs above shall be refunded without interest to those convicted for the same act under article 184 of Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 of 26/9/2004.”
When challenging the calculation, each layer is checked separately: the unlawful area, the building class and group, whether each aggravating factor really exists in the case, and the repetition rule. In the decision below, the Council of State’s Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers also stated that the merits would be examined “as regards the base fine and each aggravating factor”.
Who Is Fined? The “Owner of the Building”
The Law imposes the fine on the “owner of the building”. Is the registered owner automatically liable? In 2013 the Constitutional Court, by majority, rejected a request to annul this phrase and read it as follows: the owner of the building is the person who carries out the construction; this may be the registered owner, but also a tenant, a relative of the owner or a usufructuary. The administration cannot impose the fine directly on the registered owner without investigating who built the unlawful structure.
In 2024 the Council of State’s Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers repeated the same test but found no breach of the principle that punishment is personal in the fine imposed on a person named as “building owner” in the permit. The rule therefore works both ways: the administration must investigate who built the structure, but a person shown as building owner in the permit who also took part in the construction by consenting to it could not escape simply by saying “it was not me”.
Remedy, Time Limit and Stay of Execution
The stop-work report, the demolition order and the zoning fine are administrative acts; in all the decisions cited in this article, actions against them were heard in the administrative court as annulment actions. Since the Zoning Law sets no separate time limit, the sixty-day period in art. 7 of the Administrative Procedure Law applies as a rule.
“Where no separate period is set in special laws, the time limit for bringing an action is sixty days before the Council of State and the administrative courts and thirty days before the tax courts.
… a) In administrative disputes, written notification was made,
… These periods start on the day following the date.”
There are two separate starting dates. The stop-work report is deemed notified on the day it is posted on the building; the council decision (demolition and fine) is notified separately under the Notification Law. In the decision below, the Council of State’s 6th Chamber applied these two dates separately and held that, for both acts, the action should have been dismissed as time-barred.
Bringing an action does not by itself stop the act being carried out. For irreversible acts such as demolition, a request for a stay of execution is therefore important. The Law requires two conditions together: damage that is difficult or impossible to remedy, and clear unlawfulness. For acts whose effect would be exhausted by implementation, the court may also stay execution without first hearing the administration, to decide again once the defence is received (art. 27/2).
“Bringing an action before the Council of State or the administrative courts does not stop the execution of the administrative act challenged.
… The Council of State or administrative courts may, giving reasons, order a stay of execution after the defendant administration’s defence has been received or the period for defence has expired, where the conditions that implementation of the administrative act would cause damage that is difficult or impossible to remedy and that the administrative act is clearly unlawful are met together.”
The Criminal Side: Turkish Criminal Code art. 184
An unlicensed building also has a criminal side. Art. 184 of the Turkish Criminal Code punishes a person who builds or has built a building without a permit or contrary to the permit with imprisonment of one to five years. The provision (except its third paragraph) applies only within municipal boundaries or in places under a special zoning regime. Only its link with the administrative process is discussed here.
“(1) A person who builds or has built a building without a building permit or contrary to the permit shall be punished with imprisonment from one to five years.
… (4) Except for the third paragraph, the provisions of this article shall apply only within municipal boundaries or in places subject to a special zoning regime.
… (5) Where the person brings the building that he or she built or had built without a permit or contrary to the permit into line with the zoning plan and the permit, no public prosecution shall be brought under the first and second paragraphs, a public prosecution already brought shall be dropped, and a sentence imposed shall be removed with all its consequences.”
Bringing the building into line with the plan and permit has consequences both in the administrative process (arts. 32 and 42/ç) and in the criminal process (art. 184/5). In addition, a zoning fine already collected is refunded without interest to a person convicted for the same act under art. 184 (Law No. 3194 art. 42). In addition, works done with the administration’s written permission to bring the building into compliance do not constitute the offence of breaking a seal.
Case Law on the Stop-Work Report and the Fine
The decisions below show the time limit, what the report must contain and who is liable for the fine. The Council of State decisions were given as final.
“an action for annulment of the stop-work report, which was notified on 11/02/2020 by being posted at the building site in accordance with the procedure in article 32 of the Zoning Law, had to be brought within sixty days from the day following that date … since it was concluded that the municipal council decision in dispute was properly notified on 15/04/2020, an action had to be brought within sixty days from the day following that date”
In that case, a tenant company received a demolition order and a fine for unlicensed strengthening works, and the first-instance court had annulled the acts, finding the report inadequate. Without going into the merits, the Council of State reversed, stating that the action had not been brought in time for either act. The report had also been signed by the company’s representative on the day it was posted; the details of the Covid-19 suspension and the judicial recess in the calculation are specific to the case.
“Since the stop-work report forms the basis of demolition decisions and administrative fines, it is clear that no demolition or fine may be imposed unless a stop-work report is drawn up in accordance with the procedure set out in the Law and contains concrete, detailed and reasoned findings.”
The report in this decision was drawn up not under Law No. 3194 but under art. 11 of Bosphorus Law No. 2960, which serves the same function. The report stated that a licensed building had been demolished and rebuilt; the owner argued that only strengthening works had been carried out. The Chamber reversed, stating that matters such as whether the findings match the actual situation and whether the works can be licensed must be clarified through site inspection and expert examination. That the same test can apply to art. 32 reports under Law No. 3194 is this article’s inference.
“Under the principle that punishment is personal, the fine to be imposed under article 42 of Zoning Law No. 3194 must be imposed in the name of the person who actually built or had built the unlicensed structure or the structure contrary to the permit, in other words in the name of the building owner. Since the building owner need not always be the same person as the owner of the immovable, where it is understood that the person who built the unlicensed structure is different from the owner of the immovable, the fine must be imposed in the name of the person who built it, not the owner of the immovable.”
Having set out this principle, the Assembly found no breach of it on the facts and quashed the insistence decision so that the merits could be examined as regards the base fine and each aggravating factor: the person named as building owner in the permit and the amendment permit also owned the companies named in the permit and, according to the Assembly, took part in the unlicensed construction by consenting to it. The text of art. 42 quoted in the decision sets the minimum at “five hundred Turkish lira”; in the current text, following the 2020 amendment, it is “one thousand Turkish lira”. There are two separate dissents; one argued that the fine should also have been imposed on the company shown jointly as building owner in the permit.
“the phrase is to be understood as the persons who carry out the construction, whether they are persons owning the building or third parties such as a tenant, a relative of the building owner or a usufructuary. … since the person who carried out the unlawful construction must be identified through the necessary investigation by the administrations and the administrative sanction applied to that person, in this sense the phrase is not contrary to the provision in article 38 of the Constitution”
On an objection by an administrative court, the Constitutional Court examined the phrase “to the owner of the building” in art. 42 and, on this reading, did not find it contrary to arts. 2 and 38 of the Constitution. The decision concerns the 2009 text; the phrase has been retained with the word “owner” after the 2020 amendment. Six members dissented, on the views that the phrase means the registered owner, is unclear or requires no causal link.
Practical Points
- Note the day the report is posted. By law, posting on the building takes the place of notification; both the one-month period to obtain a permit and the sixty-day time limit are linked to this date.
- Track the notification date of the council decision separately. Demolition and the fine may be in a single council decision; it is notified under the Notification Law and its time limit runs from its own notification.
- Compare the report with the permit and the approved plans. If the unlawful parts, measurements and sketch are missing from the report, this is a ground of challenge for both demolition and the fine.
- Assess whether the building can be licensed. If the breach can be remedied, a permit application within the one month also matters for non-collection of the additional fine under sub-paragraph (ç) and for art. 184/5 of the Criminal Code.
- Check who has been fined. If a tenant or someone else built the structure, document this; if you are named as building owner in the permit, bear in mind that this may be held against you.
- Where demolition is a risk, request a stay of execution. Bringing an action does not by itself stop demolition.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the time limit for bringing an action in the administrative court against a zoning fine and a demolition order in Türkiye?
Because the Zoning Law sets no separate period, the sixty-day period in art. 7 of the Administrative Procedure Law applies as a rule under Turkish law; it starts on the day after written notification. In one decision the Council of State’s 6th Chamber ran the period against a council decision containing the demolition and the fine from its proper notification, and the period against the stop-work report from the date the report was posted on the building. Whether notification was proper is examined separately in each file.
Is a separate action needed against the stop-work report (yapı tatil tutanağı) under Turkish zoning law?
The Law provides that the stop-work report is deemed notified to the building owner when it is posted at the building site (Law No. 3194 art. 32/2). In one decision the Council of State’s 6th Chamber ran the time limit against the report from that posting date and held that the part of an action filed later should have been dismissed as time-barred. In this article’s view it is therefore safer to challenge the report within sixty days of its posting, together with the council decision where needed.
Can a zoning fine in Türkiye be imposed on the owner when a tenant built the unlicensed structure?
According to the Constitutional Court and the Council of State’s Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, the “owner of the building” in art. 42 of Law No. 3194 is the person who carried out or commissioned the construction, whether or not they own the land; a tenant falls within this. The administration may not fine the registered owner without investigating who built the unlawful structure. The Assembly found no breach of this principle, however, where the fine was imposed on an owner named as building owner in the permit who took part in the construction by consenting to it.
How is a zoning fine calculated under art. 42 of Zoning Law No. 3194 in Türkiye?
Under Turkish law, the base fine is the unlawful area in square metres multiplied by the unit amount set in the Law for the building’s class and group; these are the amounts in the statutory text and are increased every year by the revaluation rate. Where the breach cannot be measured by area, twenty per cent of the cost under the unit price list is used. Each aggravating factor, such as being unlicensed (180 per cent) or being in an area with an implementation zoning plan (20 per cent), is calculated separately on the base fine and added. An additional fine equal to the unlawful area multiplied by the minimum square-metre value for property tax is also imposed.
Can a criminal case also be brought under art. 184 of the Turkish Criminal Code for an unlicensed building in Türkiye?
Yes. A person who builds or has built a building without a permit or contrary to the permit faces imprisonment of one to five years; as a rule this applies within municipal boundaries or in areas under a special zoning regime. If the building is brought into line with the zoning plan and the permit, no public prosecution is brought and a pending one is dropped. A zoning fine collected is refunded without interest to a person convicted for the same act (Law No. 3194 art. 42).
Related Articles
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- Risky Building Designation under Law No. 6306 in Türkiye: Owners’ Rights, Agreement and Legal Remedies
- Building, Facilities and Mining in Olive Groves in Türkiye: Law No. 3573, Prohibitions and Legal Remedies
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Expropriation attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Expropriation & Zoning Law
- Zoning Readjustment under Art. 18 of Law No. 3194 in Türkiye: Contribution Share, Objection, Annulment Action
- Expropriation Price Determination and Registration in Türkiye
- 1956–1983 Takings Valued at Suit Date by Character at Taking: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly
- Urgent Expropriation Annulment Does Not End Price Suit: Turkish Cassation Assembly, If Expropriation Stands
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “How to Challenge a Zoning Fine and a Demolition Order in Türkiye: Zoning Law No. 3194 Arts. 32 and 42”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/zoning-fine-demolition-order-challenge-law-3194-turkiye

























