Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 9 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Unpaid Mediation Settlement Can Open the Way to Suing for the Whole Claim: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Law No. 6325 art. 18(5), no action may be filed on matters agreed in mediation. In its decision of 21.05.2025, however, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held by majority that where the settlement document is conditional on “full and complete payment” of the agreed amount and provides that the employee may sue for all claims in case of non-payment, the entire claim may be sued for, after deducting what was paid, once the last instalment is not paid. Payment made after the action was filed does not change this. The decision was given despite a dissenting view questioning the validity of such a clause in a settlement document.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, where a mediation settlement is conditional on full payment and allows all claims to be sued for in case of non-payment, the whole claim may be sued for after deducting what was paid once an instalment is unpaid; the bar in Law No. 6325 art. 18(5) does not prevent this.

Under Turkish law: an Assembly of Civil Chambers decision on whether, despite a settlement document, an action may be filed for the whole claim when employment receivables agreed in voluntary mediation to be paid in instalments are not paid on time (Law No. 6325 art. 18(5)).

The Dispute

The claimant employee worked for a subcontractor at the principal employers' workplaces and terminated the employment contract for just cause. No agreement was reached in mandatory mediation; afterwards the employee and the subcontractor signed a settlement document dated 18.02.2021 before a mediator in voluntary mediation. Under the document the company was to pay, at a discount, a net total of TRY 45,970.12 in four instalments for severance pay, wages, annual leave, overtime, weekly rest and public holiday claims. Article 3 of the document provided that, if the instalments were not paid on time, the employee could claim all receivables without being limited to the settlement amount.

When the last instalment was not paid on time, the employee sued for all employment receivables. The first-instance court dismissed the action on procedural grounds under art. 18(5), and the regional court of appeal rejected the appeal on the merits. The 9th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed, and the first-instance court resisted.

Outcome

The Assembly of Civil Chambers reversed the decision of resistance. The decision was given on 21.05.2025 by majority and is final. According to the Assembly, the procedural dismissal of the action under art. 18(5) was wrong.

Reasoning

The Assembly first determined the legal nature of the settlement document, characterising it as a contract under the law of obligations subject to the general provisions. It then examined the content of the document to see whether the dispute had ended permanently:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2024/499, K. 2025/329, 21.05.2025 (the Assembly's reasoning; the dispute did not end)

“In fact, it does not appear possible to say here that the dispute between the parties was resolved permanently and ended by the settlement document signed as a result of the mediation.” (unofficial translation)

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“the claimant's bringing the whole receivable to court after deducting the amounts paid is consistent with the settlement document.” (unofficial translation)

The decision of resistance had also relied on the fact that the balance was paid after the action was filed. The Assembly rejected this ground as well:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“On the other hand, as a principle, every action is decided according to the factual and legal grounds existing on the date it was filed.” (unofficial translation)

During the deliberations it was argued that a settlement document cannot be made conditional, that article 3 was therefore invalid and that the rest of the document would survive under Code of Obligations art. 27(2); this view was not adopted by the majority of the Assembly.

Significance and Practical Impact

The decision shows that the prohibition on suing in art. 18(5) is not absolute and that the settlement document is to be interpreted according to its own terms. Where the document expressly states that all claims may be pursued in case of non-payment, the debtor's default gives the employee two options: enforcement proceedings on the basis of the document for the unpaid instalments, or an action for the whole claim after deducting what was paid. Without such a clause, since the document is equivalent to a judgment, enforcement for the unpaid part comes to the fore.

The validity of the settlement document is a separate issue. The 9th Civil Chamber accepts that documents drawn up merely to record payment, without a real dispute between the parties before mediation, are not settlement documents within the meaning of art. 18(5) (9th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/10147, K. 2024/13332, 10.10.2024). However, there is a difference of opinion within the Chamber on how invalidity is to be raised: the dissent in that decision argues that no action may be filed on agreed matters until the settlement has been annulled in a separate action and the judgment has become final. The dissent in a later decision states that invalidity may be examined as a preliminary issue in the claim or reinstatement action and that there is therefore no legal interest in a separate annulment action (9th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/4126, K. 2025/5830, 03.07.2025). Since this point has consequences for the type of action and the available appeals, it should be assessed carefully case by case.

Constitutional Court: a settlement document is not res judicata in the substantive sense; the rules on the enforceability annotation (art. 18(2)-(3), original text) were held constitutional

Constitutional Court Decision (constitutional review)

“The text of the agreement drawn up as a result of the parties’ settlement at the end of the mediation process is not res judicata in the substantive sense. The court’s granting an enforceability annotation to the agreement does not turn that agreement into a judgment/res judicata/court judgment, but merely into a document having the nature of a judgment. … Likewise, defects of consent such as mistake, fraud and duress may be raised by the parties in the process of granting the enforceability annotation.” (unofficial translation)

In an action for annulment brought by members of parliament against numerous provisions of Law No. 6325, the Court examined the merits and dismissed all requests for annulment. As regards Article 18(2) and (3), which governed the annotation of enforceability on the settlement document, treated the annotated agreement as a document having the nature of a judgment and limited the examination to whether the agreement was suitable for mediation and for compulsory enforcement, the request for annulment was dismissed unanimously. The Court stated that the annotation is a non-contentious matter, that the judge examines public order matters of its own motion, that documents having the nature of a judgment are subject to the same regime as judgments only as regards enforceability, and that issues arising from the annotated agreement not being res judicata may be raised under the general rules. The decision was published in the Official Gazette of 25.01.2014, No. 28893. The text reviewed is the original 2012 text of Article 18; the article was later amended, and today’s rule on a settlement document also signed by the lawyers is Article 18(4) quoted above. The decision does not resolve the debate on which action should examine objections to the validity of the document.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Law on Mediation in Civil Disputes (Law No. 6325) art. 18(4)-(5) (Agreement of the parties) (unofficial translation)

Except where the law requires an enforceability annotation, a settlement document signed together by the parties, their lawyers and the mediator, and for commercial disputes by the lawyers and the mediator, is deemed a document equivalent to a judgment without an enforceability annotation.

… If an agreement is reached at the end of the mediation, the parties may not bring an action on the matters agreed.

Frequently Asked Questions

What can an employee do in Türkiye if the amount agreed in mediation is not paid?

Under Turkish law a settlement document signed together by the parties, their lawyers and the mediator is treated as a document equivalent to a judgment without an enforceability annotation (Law No. 6325 art. 18(4)); enforcement proceedings can be started for the unpaid part. If the settlement provides that all claims may be sued for in case of non-payment, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers an action may also be filed for the entire claim after deducting what was paid.

Can an action be filed in Türkiye for matters agreed in a mediation settlement?

As a rule, no; Law No. 6325 art. 18(5) prohibits actions on matters agreed. In Assembly of Civil Chambers decision K. 2025/329, however, the settlement was made conditional on full and complete payment and an instalment was not paid, so it was held that the dispute had not been resolved permanently by the settlement.

Is the action dismissed in Türkiye if the debtor pays the last instalment after the action is filed?

According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, every action is decided on the factual and legal grounds existing on the date it was filed. Payment of the last instalment after filing did not change the fact that payments were not made fully and on time, and could not justify a procedural dismissal.

On what grounds can the invalidity of a mediation settlement document be raised under Turkish law?

According to the 9th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, since the settlement document is not res judicata in the substantive sense, absolute nullity, excessive advantage, mistake, fraud, duress and forgery may be raised. If there was no real dispute before mediation, the document is not a settlement within the meaning of art. 18(5). Whether invalidity must be pursued in a separate annulment action or examined as a preliminary issue in the claim itself is disputed within the Chamber.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Mediation & Arbitration

All Mediation & Arbitration articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Unpaid Mediation Settlement Can Open the Way to Suing for the Whole Claim: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-19, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/unpaid-mediation-settlement-action-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›