Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 9 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Joint Suit Does Not Spare Director Claim from Mediation: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, claims against the company and claims against the managers are not directed against the same defendant. So where the non-existence, nullity or annulment of general assembly resolutions is sought against the company and compensation based on managers’ liability is sought against the managers, there is no joinder of claims (Code of Civil Procedure art. 110). The court separates the actions and examines the procedural preconditions of each one separately. The separated compensation action is subject to mediation as a precondition to suit under Turkish Commercial Code art. 5/A; if it was filed without applying to a mediator, it is dismissed on procedural grounds. Shareholders who intend to claim compensation from managers must first apply to a mediator for that claim, even if they bring it in the same statement of claim as the action concerning general assembly resolutions.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, where annulment of general assembly resolutions is sought against the company and compensation based on managers' liability against the managers, there is no joinder of claims; the separated compensation action is subject to mandatory mediation under Commercial Code art. 5/A and is dismissed on procedural grounds if filed without applying to a mediator.

A decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation on whether mediation as a precondition to suit applies to a compensation claim against company managers brought in the same statement of claim as the annulment of general assembly resolutions against the company (Turkish Commercial Code art. 5/A, Code of Civil Procedure art. 110).

The Dispute

The claimants are shareholders of a joint-stock company. They sought a declaration that the resolutions adopted at the company’s general assemblies in 2019 were non-existent or null and void, or failing that their annulment; in the same statement of claim they alleged that the defendants, who were managers of the company, had caused loss to the company and asked for the loss to be collected from the defendants and paid to the company. When the claimants’ counsel explained that the action concerning the general assembly resolutions was directed against the company and the compensation claim against the managers, the Istanbul Anatolia 1st Commercial Court of First Instance separated the compensation action and dismissed it on procedural grounds because no application had been made to a mediator. The 14th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on the merits.

By its decision of 10.07.2023, the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed the judgment by majority vote. The first-instance court insisted on its judgment, stating that the two actions were of different types and that there was no actual connection between them; the claimants appealed against the insistence judgment.

Outcome of the Decision

By its decision of 05.11.2025, the Assembly of Civil Chambers upheld the insistence judgment; the decision was given unanimously and is final. The procedural dismissal of the compensation action, for lack of the precondition to suit because it was filed without applying to a mediator, was found correct.

Reasoning

The Chamber had taken the view that mediation is not required where connected claims are brought together.

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision (Chamber’s reversal reasoning as quoted)
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/40, K. 2025/689, 05.11.2025 (from the Chamber’s reversal decision of 10.07.2023)

“… cases that combine connected claims, some subject to an amount and some not, and involve a joinder of claims must be resolved by the court without being subject to mediation.”

The Assembly first set out the condition for a joinder of claims. According to the legislative reasoning of Code of Civil Procedure art. 110, as quoted by the Assembly, “the procedural preconditions are determined separately for each claim.”

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“Within the same type of jurisdiction, the precondition for bringing an action containing several principal claims in the form of a joinder of claims before a court with common jurisdiction is that the claims are brought against the same defendant. In other words, where several principal claims not directed against the same defendant are brought together, the judge, observing that the conditions for a joinder of claims are not met, will order the separation of the actions and will examine specifically whether the procedural preconditions exist for each action.”

The Assembly also stressed that the opposite interpretation would open the way to circumventing the mediation requirement.

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“If the contrary were accepted, … an attempt would be made to circumvent mediation as a precondition to suit by bringing principal claims that are and are not subject to mediation together in the form of a joinder of claims, and this in itself would breach the rule of good faith set out in Article 2 of the Turkish Civil Code.”

Since, in the case at hand, the claims were directed against different persons, the Assembly considered the procedural preconditions of each action separately and found the procedural dismissal of the compensation action correct.

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision sets a limit to the 11th Civil Chamber’s approach that mediation is not required where connected claims are brought together: the joinder of claims on which that approach rests exists only where the claims are directed against the same defendant. Where the claim concerning general assembly resolutions is directed against the company and the compensation claim against the managers, bringing both in the same statement of claim does not release the compensation claim from the mediation requirement.

The Assembly did not separately decide the situation where the claims are directed against the same defendant. In that situation the joinder approach appears to continue: the 11th Civil Chamber upheld, without writing its own reasoning, a regional court of appeal judgment holding that a compensation action brought together with a claim for a declaration and prevention of trademark infringement was not subject to mediation as a precondition to suit, and therefore did not charge the mediation costs to the defendant (11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5725, K. 2026/2704, 07.05.2026). Given the Assembly’s emphasis on the rule of good faith, applying to a mediator in advance for the monetary claim avoids the risk of a procedural dismissal on this ground even in a joinder against the same defendant.

The decision refers to Turkish Commercial Code art. 5/A in the wording of its original version. As stated in another decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the provision was amended by Article 31 of Law No. 7445, which entered into force on 01.09.2023, and its scope now also covers annulment of objection, negative declaratory and restitution actions (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/567, K. 2026/281, 29.04.2026). Compensation actions are covered by both texts; the amendment does not affect the basis of the decision.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Turkish Commercial Code (Law No. 6102) art. 5/A(1) (Mediation as a precondition to suit) (unofficial translation)

“(1) In commercial cases set out in Article 4 of this Law and in other laws, in receivables, compensation, annulment of objection, negative declaratory and restitution actions whose subject is a sum of money, recourse to a mediator before filing the action is a precondition to suit.”

Statutory Provision — Law No. 6325 on Mediation in Civil Disputes art. 18/A (Mediation as a precondition to suit) (unofficial translation)

“(2) … If it is understood that the action was filed without applying to a mediator, the action shall be dismissed on procedural grounds for lack of a precondition to suit without any further step.

… (15) Limitation is suspended and preclusive periods do not run during the period from the application to the mediation office until the date on which the final report is drawn up.”

Statutory Provision — Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) art. 110 (Joinder of claims) (unofficial translation)

“(1) The claimant may bring several principal claims against the same defendant that are independent of one another in the same statement of claim. For this, all the claims brought together must fall within the same type of jurisdiction and there must be a court with jurisdiction common to all the claims.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Is applying to a mediator mandatory before an action to annul a general assembly resolution?

Turkish Commercial Code art. 5/A(1) limits mediation as a precondition to suit to commercial receivables, compensation, annulment of objection, negative declaratory and restitution actions whose subject is a sum of money; annulment of a general assembly resolution is not in that list. In this decision, too, the mediation requirement was applied to the separated compensation action.

What happens if annulment of general assembly resolutions and compensation from the managers are claimed in the same statement of claim?

According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the claims are not directed against the same defendant, so there is no joinder of claims. The court separates the actions and applies the mediation precondition to the compensation action on its own.

Can applying to a mediator after filing the action cure the defect?

If it is found that the action was filed without applying to a mediator, the action is dismissed on procedural grounds without any further step (Law No. 6325 art. 18/A(2)). In this case the first-instance court stated that mediation is not a precondition that can be completed later, and the procedural dismissal was upheld.

Is mediation required if all claims are directed against the same defendant?

The Assembly of Civil Chambers did not decide that situation. After its decision, the 11th Civil Chamber upheld, without writing its own reasoning, a regional court of appeal judgment holding that mediation was not required for trademark infringement and compensation claims brought against the same defendant. Applying to a mediator in advance for the monetary claim avoids the risk of a procedural dismissal on this ground.

Does the mediation process affect limitation periods?

From the application to the mediation office until the final report is drawn up, limitation is suspended and preclusive periods do not run (Law No. 6325 art. 18/A(15)).

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law

All Commercial & Corporate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Joint Suit Does Not Spare Director Claim from Mediation: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-04, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/general-assembly-annulment-director-liability-mediation

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›