Last reviewed:
Breach of the Duty of Disclosure in Turkish Insurance: Can the Insurer Refuse the Claim? (TCC Arts. 1435–1440)
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, the policyholder must disclose to the insurer the material matters he knows or ought to know when the contract is made (Turkish Commercial Code art. 1435). If the breach is discovered before the insured event, the insurer may withdraw from the contract within fifteen days of learning of it or request an additional premium (arts. 1439/1, 1440). After the insured event, as a rule the claim is not refused entirely: negligence leads to a reduction according to its degree where the breach could affect the indemnity or the occurrence of the event; if an intentionally undisclosed matter is connected with the event that occurred, the obligation to pay ceases, and if there is no connection, the claim is paid in proportion to the premiums (art. 1439/2). In life and health insurance, the connection between the undisclosed illness and the death or treatment was determined by medical expert examination in the Court of Cassation decisions reviewed.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, if the policyholder fails to disclose material matters, the insurer may withdraw within fifteen days or request an additional premium before the insured event; after the event, the claim is as a rule not refused entirely but reduced or paid proportionally depending on fault and connection. The article explains pre-existing illness in life and health insurance with Court of Cassation decisions.
What a policyholder in Türkiye must disclose to the insurer when the contract is made and during its term, the consequences of non-disclosure, and the problem of pre-existing illness in life and health insurance under Turkish law: Turkish Commercial Code (Law No. 6102) arts. 1435–1440 and 1444–1446, Court of Cassation decisions and the Insurance Arbitration Commission route.
What Is the Duty of Disclosure in Insurance? (Art. 1435)
The insurer largely sets the risk it assumes and the premium it charges on the basis of the information given by the policyholder. The Turkish Commercial Code therefore places a duty of disclosure on the policyholder when the contract is made. Decisions also call it the duty to give “correct information” or the duty of “notification”.
“The policyholder is obliged to disclose to the insurer all material matters that he knows or ought to know at the time the contract is concluded. Matters not disclosed, or disclosed incompletely or incorrectly, are deemed material if they are of a nature that would have required the contract not to be concluded or to be concluded on different terms. Matters asked by the insurer in writing or orally are deemed material until the contrary is proven.”
Under the article, the scope of the duty depends on two criteria. The first is knowledge: matters the policyholder ought to know are covered as well as those he knows. The second is materiality: an undisclosed matter is material if it would have required the contract not to be made at all or to be made on different terms (for example with a higher premium or an exclusion). Matters the insurer asked about in writing or orally are deemed material until the contrary is proven; so if a question was answered incorrectly, the burden of proving that the matter was immaterial shifts to the policyholder.
A list of questions given by the insurer also sets the limits of the duty:
“If the insurer has given the policyholder a list containing questions to be answered, no responsibility may be imposed on the policyholder for matters outside the questions in the list; unless the policyholder has concealed a material matter in bad faith.”
Where a list was given, the policyholder as a rule cannot be held responsible for matters not asked in it; this protection does not apply if he concealed a material matter in bad faith. Questions outside the list must also be in writing and clear (art. 1436/2). A breach cannot be relied on for a matter the insurer already knew:
“If the true position of a matter or fact that was not disclosed or was incorrectly disclosed is known to the insurer, the insurer cannot withdraw from the contract by claiming that the duty of disclosure was breached. The burden of proof lies with the policyholder.”
Disclosure During the Contract: Aggravation of Risk and Occurrence of the Insured Event
The duty of disclosure does not end when the contract is made. The Code sets separate notification rules for changes that aggravate the risk during the contract and for the occurrence of the insured event.
“If the policyholder, or another person with his permission, carries out acts that increase the likelihood of the insured event or aggravate the existing situation, or if one of the matters expressly accepted as an aggravation of risk when the contract was made occurs, he notifies the insurer immediately; if these acts were carried out without his knowledge, he notifies the insurer within ten days at the latest from the date he learns of the matter.”
“If, during the term of the contract, the insurer learns of the likelihood of the insured event occurring or of the existing situation being aggravated, or of the existence of events that may be accepted in the contract as an aggravation of risk, it may terminate the contract or request an additional premium within one month from that date. If the difference is not accepted within ten days, the contract is deemed terminated.
… If the increase in risk has been caused by a matter related to the insurer’s interest, an event for which the insurer is responsible or the performance of a humanitarian duty, and, in life insurance, by changes in the health of the insured, the first to third paragraphs do not apply.”
The insurer may terminate the contract or request an additional premium within one month of learning of the aggravation; these rights lapse if not exercised in time (arts. 1445/1, 1445/3). Termination is not available if the previous position has been restored (art. 1445/2). The fourth paragraph matters for life insurance: if the risk has increased because of changes in the insured’s health, the first to third paragraphs do not apply. This article’s inference: in life insurance an illness arising after the contract is made is not a ground for termination or an additional premium under these paragraphs; in disputes the real question is whether an illness existing and known when the contract was made was disclosed.
If a breach is found after the insured event, art. 1445/5 sets a regime similar to art. 1439/2, distinguishing negligence and intent. The occurrence of the insured event must also be notified:
“When the policyholder learns that the insured event has occurred, he notifies the insurer without delay.
(2) If the failure to notify, or late notification of, the occurrence of the insured event has caused an increase in the indemnity or sum payable, the indemnity or sum is reduced according to the gravity of the fault.”
Failure to notify, or late notification, does not lead to refusal of the claim but, where it has increased the indemnity payable, to a reduction according to the gravity of the fault; the insurer cannot benefit from this reduction if it had already actually learned of the event (art. 1446/3).
Consequences of Breach: Withdrawal, Additional Premium, Reduction and Refusal
The consequence of a breach of disclosure at the time the contract was made depends on whether the insurer learns of it before or after the insured event.
“If a matter material to the insurer has not been disclosed or has been incorrectly disclosed, the insurer may withdraw from the contract within the period set out in Article 1440 or request an additional premium. If the additional premium requested is not accepted within ten days, the contract is deemed withdrawn from. The fact that a material matter could not be learned through the fault of the policyholder, or was not considered material by the policyholder, does not change the position.
(2) If, after the occurrence of the insured event, the duty of disclosure is found to have been breached through the policyholder’s negligence, and the breach is of a nature that could affect the amount of the indemnity or sum or the occurrence of the insured event, the indemnity is reduced according to the degree of negligence. If the policyholder’s fault amounts to intent and there is a connection between the breach of the duty of disclosure and the insured event that occurred, the insurer’s obligation to pay the indemnity or sum ceases; if there is no connection, the insurer pays the indemnity or sum taking into account the ratio between the premium paid and the premium that should have been paid.”
“Withdrawal must be directed to the policyholder by a declaration.
(2) Withdrawal is notified to the policyholder within fifteen days. This period starts from the date on which the insurer learns that the duty of disclosure has been breached.”
The following picture emerges from these provisions:
- Discovered before the insured event: The insurer may withdraw by a declaration within fifteen days or request an additional premium; if the difference is not accepted within ten days, the contract is deemed withdrawn from. At this stage, the fact that the matter could not be learned through his fault or was not considered material by him does not change the outcome (art. 1439/1).
- After the insured event, with negligence: If the breach could affect the amount of the indemnity or the occurrence of the event, the indemnity is reduced according to the degree of negligence.
- After the insured event, with intent and a connection: The insurer’s obligation to pay ceases.
- After the insured event, with intent but no connection: The claim is paid in the ratio of the premium paid to the premium that should have been paid (known in practice as “proportional” calculation).
Art. 1437 adds that the connection between the undisclosed matter and the insured event is taken into account under the rules in art. 1439. As can be seen, the Code reserves total refusal of the claim for the most serious case, where intent and a connection exist together.
Pre-existing Illness in Life and Health Insurance
Most disputes over the duty of disclosure arise in life insurance taken out with loans and in private health insurance, where the insured did not disclose an illness diagnosed before the policy. Three questions stand out in the Court of Cassation decisions reviewed:
- Did the illness exist when the contract was made, and did the insured know of it? Treatment records, prescriptions and the death certificate are used to answer this.
- Does the non-disclosure amount to intent? The Assembly of Civil Chambers and the 4th Civil Chamber held that intent here covers not only bad-faith concealment but also failing to declare despite knowing. In this article’s assessment, this interpretation makes it easier to treat an insured who knew of the illness as at fault to the degree of intent.
- Is there a connection between the undisclosed illness and the death or treatment? This is a medical question. In the case before it, the Assembly of Civil Chambers required the causal link to be determined by a panel report from the Forensic Medicine Institute. If there is no connection, the claim is not refused entirely even if the illness was knowingly not disclosed; a calculation by premium ratio is made.
In practice, banks’ use of standard application forms at the time of the loan, and forms that are unsigned or not filled in by the insured, are often disputed. In its 2023 decision adopted by majority, the Assembly of Civil Chambers held that the absence of a completed form does not remove the duty of disclosure; the minority view argued that there is no freedom of will in loan-linked life insurance and that the failure to inform the insured of the sanctions should count against the insurer. This article’s inference: where the insurer gave a written list of questions, the policyholder’s responsibility for matters outside the list is limited under art. 1436/1; in the Assembly’s case, the file contained pre-printed forms that bore no signature of the insured and in which only identity details were filled in.
The same questions arise in health insurance, but the insured event is a treatment cost rather than death. The connection is then sought between the undisclosed earlier condition and the new condition for which treatment costs are claimed. In renewed policies, which declaration counts may vary with the documents in the file; in the health insurance decision below, the health declaration completed at the first application was discussed.
Procedure: Competent Court, Insurance Arbitration Commission and Proof
Consumer court: If the policyholder acts for non-commercial and non-professional purposes, the insurance contract falls within the definition of a consumer transaction.
“l) Consumer transaction: any contract and legal transaction, including contracts for work, carriage, brokerage, insurance, agency, banking and similar contracts, concluded in the markets for goods or services between consumers and real or legal persons, including public legal entities, acting for commercial or professional purposes or acting on their behalf or account,”
“Consumer courts have jurisdiction over actions concerning disputes that may arise from consumer transactions and practices directed at consumers.
… Consumer actions may also be brought before the consumer court of the place where the consumer is domiciled.”
In disputes heard by consumer courts, applying to a mediator before filing suit is a condition of action, apart from the exceptions listed in the Law (Law No. 6502 art. 73/A). Jurisdiction is determined by the legislation in force on the date of the action and by whether the policyholder is a consumer; in the Assembly of Civil Chambers case below, filed in 2014, the Chamber had found the commercial court of first instance competent based on the position at that date. Where the policyholder is not a consumer, the competent court must be determined separately under the legislation in force on the date of the action.
Insurance Arbitration Commission: A person in dispute with an institution that is a member of the insurance arbitration system may use arbitration even without a special clause in the contract (Insurance Law No. 5684 art. 30/1). An application must first be made to the insurer:
“In order to apply to the Commission, the person in dispute with the insurance institution must have made the necessary applications to that institution regarding the event giving rise to the dispute and must document that the request was refused in whole or in part. The insurance institution’s failure to reply in writing within fifteen working days from the date of application is also sufficient for an application to the Commission.”
A dispute already brought before a court or a consumer arbitration committee cannot be brought to the Commission (art. 30/14). Whether arbitral awards are final, and whether objection and appeal are available, depend on monetary thresholds written in the Law (art. 30/12); since these amounts may be increased under the authority set out in the Law (art. 30/22), the current amount on the date of application should be checked. The two 4th Civil Chamber decisions below were given on appeal against decisions of objection panels of the Insurance Arbitration Commission.
Proof: The Code makes separate provision for the presumption that matters asked about are material (art. 1435/1) and for the policyholder’s burden of proving that the insurer knew the true position (art. 1438); in the decisions reviewed, matters such as the existence of the illness, knowledge of it and the connection were investigated through expert reports. The Assembly of Civil Chambers decision also quoted art. 1423 of the Code, which governs the insurer’s pre-contractual duty to inform; under the text quoted by the Assembly, the burden of proving that the information was given lies with the insurer.
The Duty of Disclosure in Court Decisions
“the insured, whether upon the insurance company’s question or without any question being asked (and therefore without any form being filled in), is obliged to notify the insurer of all circumstances known to him at the time the contract is concluded that would require the insurer not to conclude the contract or to conclude it on heavier terms, and the fact that the form was not filled in does not remove the insured’s duty to notify the insurer of matters concerning his health. … The expression intentional concealment in the Law refers not to concealment in bad faith but also to failing to declare despite knowing.”
In a life insurance policy taken out for a housing loan and renewed every year, the insured died and the insurer argued that a pre-existing heart disease had been concealed. The first instance court allowed the claim, citing that the information form did not bear the insured’s signature and that the question form was pre-printed, and resisted the Chamber’s reversal. The Assembly reversed the decision of resistance and required a panel report from the Forensic Medicine Institute to establish whether the illness existed at the time of the contract, whether it was concealed and whether there was a direct causal link with the death. The Assembly did not find that the death resulted from the illness; it required this to be investigated. The two 2025 decisions of the 4th Civil Chamber below apply the same criteria of intent, connection and proportional calculation; the current text of arts. 1435–1446 of the Code is the same as the text quoted in the decision.
“Where the insured failed to disclose an illness existing before the policy and this non-disclosure amounts to intent (bearing in mind that intent here refers not to bad-faith non-disclosure but to non-declaration despite knowing), and the undisclosed illness was not the direct cause of death (there being no connection), determining the indemnity according to the ratio between the premium paid and the premium that should have been paid (by proportional calculation) is required by Article 1439/2 of the Turkish Commercial Code.”
The insured had not disclosed, in the declaration form he signed, kidney failure requiring dialysis three times a week; the death resulted from an infection after an operation unrelated to that illness. The dispute panel had largely allowed the claim without a proportional calculation, and the objection panel had dismissed the insurer’s objection. Accepting that the non-disclosure amounted to intent even without a connection, the Chamber required an inquiry into the premium that should have been charged to a candidate with this illness and a proportional calculation of the sum, and reversed the decision. The outcome is specific to the case: the claim was neither refused entirely nor paid in full.
“the expert report obtained after the reversal established that there was no causal link between the previous condition and the condition giving rise to the health expenses in dispute”
A private health insurance policyholder claimed the cost of eye surgery; the insurer argued that a cataract operation years earlier had not been disclosed in the health declaration at the first application. The arbitration panels first refused the claim, and the former 17th Civil Chamber reversed because the decision had been given without an expert report. The report obtained after the reversal found no causal link between the old operation and the new condition; the objection panel allowed the full cost, and the 4th Civil Chamber affirmed. The insurer had also argued for proportional liability; the Chamber dismissed the appeal, referring among other things to the vested rights created by compliance with the reversal, and did not separately discuss the proportional calculation. The decision should therefore not be read as a general rule that full payment is due in health insurance whenever there is no connection.
Practical Points
- Collect the documents: Signed copies of the proposal form, health declaration, question list, information form and policy; who filled in the form and whether it was signed can affect the outcome.
- Read the refusal letter: Whether the insurer withdrew, requested an additional premium or refused payment after the event is governed by different rules. For withdrawal before the event, the fifteen-day period runs from the date the insurer learned of the breach (art. 1440/2).
- Dispute the connection medically: The relationship between the cause of death or treatment and the undisclosed illness is determined by an expert report; if no objection is made to the report, the outcome largely rests on it.
- Separate intent from connection: Without a connection, even knowing non-disclosure as a rule leads to proportional payment rather than total refusal (art. 1439/2).
- Choose the route: The Insurance Arbitration Commission, the consumer court and mandatory mediation can affect one another in the same dispute; a dispute already brought before a court or a consumer arbitration committee cannot be brought to the Commission (art. 30/14).
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an insurer in Türkiye refuse the whole claim if the duty of disclosure was breached?
As a rule, no; under Turkish law the outcome depends on when the breach was discovered and on the degree of fault. If discovered before the insured event, the insurer may withdraw within fifteen days or ask for an additional premium (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 1439/1, 1440). After the event, negligence leads to a reduction according to its degree where the breach could affect the indemnity or the occurrence of the event. The insurer is released entirely only where an intentional breach is connected with the event that occurred; if there is no connection, the claim is paid in the ratio of the premium paid to the premium that should have been paid (art. 1439/2).
Under Turkish law, is a life insurance sum paid if a pre-existing illness was not disclosed?
Under Turkish law, it depends on the connection between the undisclosed illness and the death. Under the Code, where the breach is intentional and the undisclosed matter is connected with the insured event, the obligation to pay ceases; without a connection, the sum is paid proportionally by premium ratio (Turkish Commercial Code art. 1439/2). In the Court of Cassation decisions reviewed, an insured who knew of the illness and did not disclose it was treated as at fault to the degree of intent, and a proportional calculation was required where the illness was unconnected with the death. The connection is a medical question; in the case before it, the Assembly of Civil Chambers required it to be determined by a panel report from the Forensic Medicine Institute.
What is the time limit for an insurer in Türkiye to withdraw from the contract for breach of the duty of disclosure?
Under Turkish law, withdrawal must be notified to the policyholder by a declaration within fifteen days from the date the insurer learned of the breach (Turkish Commercial Code art. 1440). Instead of withdrawing, the insurer may request an additional premium; if it is not accepted within ten days, the contract is deemed withdrawn from (art. 1439/1). An insurer that already knew the true position cannot withdraw; the policyholder bears the burden of proving this (art. 1438). For an aggravation of risk during the contract, the period for termination or additional premium is one month (art. 1445/1).
Under Turkish law, does the duty of disclosure in insurance disappear if no health declaration form was filled in?
In a 2023 decision adopted by majority, the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held under Turkish law that the absence of a completed form does not remove the insured’s duty to disclose health matters. Where the insurer has given a written list of questions, however, the policyholder cannot be held responsible for matters outside the list, unless an important matter was concealed in bad faith (Turkish Commercial Code art. 1436/1). Who filled in the form, how, and whether it was signed are assessed separately in each case.
Can a claim refused for breach of the duty of disclosure be taken to the Insurance Arbitration Commission in Türkiye?
Under Turkish law, yes, if the insurer is a member of the insurance arbitration system; no special clause in the contract is needed (Insurance Law No. 5684 art. 30/1). The claimant must first have applied to the insurer and documented a full or partial refusal; the insurer’s failure to answer in writing within fifteen working days is also sufficient (art. 30/13). A dispute already before a court or a consumer arbitration committee cannot be brought to the Commission (art. 30/14). Objection and appeal against arbitral awards depend on monetary thresholds set in the Law and subject to updating (arts. 30/12, 30/22).
Related Articles
- Motor Own-Damage (Kasko) Insurance Disputes in Turkish Law: Exclusions, Alcohol, Total Loss and Diminished Value, Recourse, Limitation and the Insurance Arbitration Commission
- Workplace Fire and the Insurer’s Liability
- Applying to the Consumer Arbitration Committee
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Insurance attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Insurance Law
- Recourse in Turkish Traffic Insurance: Claims Against Insured and Driver, Exclusive Causation, Limitation
- Claiming from the Guarantee Fund in Türkiye: Uninsured, Hit-and-Run or Stolen Vehicles (Law 5684 Art. 14)
- Knee Pads Not Required, No Contributory Fault Reduction: Turkish Court of Cassation on a Motorcyclist
- Rights in a Property-Damage Traffic Accident
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Breach of the Duty of Disclosure in Turkish Insurance: Can the Insurer Refuse the Claim? (TCC Arts. 1435–1440)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/insurance-duty-of-disclosure-breach-turkiye

























