Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 9 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Knee Pads Not Required, No Contributory Fault Reduction: Turkish Court of Cassation on a Motorcyclist

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, the fact that a motorcycle driver did not wear knee pads did not, even though the driver was injured in the knee, provide a basis for reducing the driver’s compensation for contributory fault. In its decision of 06.11.2024, the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay 4. Hukuk Dairesi) stated that the Regulation lists a protective helmet and protective goggles for motorcycle drivers but does not regulate knee pads as mandatory protective equipment, and treated the 20% reduction as a ground for reversal. In a 2022 reversal decision, by contrast, the Chamber had required a 20% reduction for a driver injured in the knee. The decision of 06.11.2024 was unanimous; no decision given after the reversal could be found, and the dispute may not be final.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that, because the Highway Traffic Regulation does not regulate knee pads as mandatory protective equipment for motorcycle drivers, a 20% reduction for contributory fault made from the compensation of a driver injured in the knee on the ground that the driver did not use knee pads was a ground for reversal.

Under Turkish law, the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that a 20% reduction for contributory fault, made from a motorcycle driver’s compensation on the ground that the driver did not use knee pads, was erroneous because the Regulation does not make knee pads mandatory.

The Dispute

The claimant was injured while driving a motorcycle in a two-party traffic accident on 29.07.2020 and suffered permanent incapacity. The claimant sought permanent and temporary incapacity compensation and carer expenses from the defendant insurance company, the compulsory motor third-party liability insurer of the vehicle involved in the accident, and increased the claim to TRY 58,147.45.

The Dispute Arbitration Panel partly allowed the application, awarding a total of TRY 58,147.45 in compensation and rejecting the claim for carer expenses. On both parties’ objections, the Objection Arbitration Panel, accepting that the claimant had been injured in the knee and had not used knee pads as protective equipment, made a 20% reduction for contributory fault (the injured party’s own fault); the compensation fell to TRY 46,517.95. The claimant appealed on the grounds of the conflict between the disability reports, the reduction for contributory fault and the attorney’s fee.

Outcome of the Decision

On 06.11.2024 the 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation rejected the claimant’s objections concerning the disability report and the attorney’s fee; it accepted the claimant’s objection to the reduction for contributory fault and reversed the decision of the Objection Arbitration Panel. The decision was unanimous; there was no dissenting opinion.

At the time of writing, no decision given after the reversal could be found; the dispute may not be final.

Reasoning

The Chamber first recalled the test for a reduction for contributory fault under Code of Obligations art. 52:

Court of Cassation Decision
4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/10813, K. 2024/10557, 06.11.2024 (the test for a reduction for contributory fault)

“A reduction for contributory fault requires that, according to the particular features of each case, the manner in which the incident occurred and the effect on the outcome of the injured party’s faulty conduct in increasing the loss be assessed and an appropriate reduction be made; and it is accepted and settled both in legal scholarship and in the case law of the Court of Cassation that, where contributory fault of the injured party is established, an appropriate reduction is made from the compensation under Article 52 of Law No. 6098.”

Then, after referring to Highway Traffic Law art. 78, which leaves it to regulation to determine in which types of vehicles, and from what date, protective equipment is to be used, it quoted the provision of the Regulation in force at the date of the accident:

Court of Cassation Decision
4th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/10813, K. 2024/10557, 06.11.2024 (the provision of the Regulation in force at the date of the accident)

“Article 150 of the Highway Traffic Regulation contains the provision "Certain drivers and passengers are obliged to use protective equipment while vehicles are being driven. … a) Except for three-wheeled goods motorcycles, on electric bicycles, motorised bicycles and motorcycles, a protective helmet and protective goggles for drivers, and a protective helmet for passengers,"”

It assessed the present case as follows:

Court of Cassation Decision

“In the present case, although a 20% reduction for contributory fault was made on the ground that the claimant, who was injured in the knee area, did not use knee pads as protective equipment at the time of the accident, since knee pads are not regulated as mandatory protective equipment for motorcycle drivers in the relevant article of the KTY [Highway Traffic Regulation], making a reduction in this way was erroneous and required reversal.”

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision separates two steps of contributory fault. The Objection Arbitration Panel had made the reduction by linking the knee injury to the failure to use knee pads. The Chamber did not discuss that link. It tied the reduction to the effect on the outcome of the injured party’s “faulty conduct” and, for a motorcycle driver, found the standard of fault regarding protective equipment in the mandatory equipment listed in the Regulation.

Code of Obligations art. 52/1 makes a reduction depend on the injured party having contributed to the occurrence or increase of the loss; so the failure to use mandatory equipment does not automatically lead to a reduction either.

Note: Highway Traffic Regulation art. 150 was amended after the decision by a regulation published in the Official Gazette of 4.11.2025. The current text also lists protective gloves for motorcycle drivers and passengers carried. Knee pads do not appear in the current text either. For the date on which the glove obligation took effect, the amending regulation should be consulted.

The Chamber’s decisions on this point have not always gone the same way. According to the account given in 4th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/220, K. 2024/3312, 15.04.2024, in a reversal decision given in that case on 07.03.2022 the Chamber, dealing with a motorcycle driver for whom the accident report left the use of protective equipment unclear, inferred from the injury being to the knee that knee pads had not been worn and, citing its own “established practice”, treated the failure to make a 20% reduction for contributory fault as a ground for reversal. The 2024 decision did not re-examine the knee-pad issue; noting that the reversal had been complied with, it upheld the decision, correcting it only as regards the attorney’s fee. After the decision of 06.11.2024, by contrast, in 4th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/14775, K. 2026/5722, 12.05.2026 a 20% reduction made from the compensation of a claimant driver injured in the knee was likewise treated as a ground for reversal because the Regulation does not regulate knee pads as mandatory protective equipment; the search found no decision of the Chamber after 06.11.2024 departing from this line. For this reason, where a knee-pad defence is raised, the dates of the decisions relied on and the particular features of the case should be considered together.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 52/1 (Reduction)

“If the injured party consented to the act causing the loss, or contributed to the occurrence or increase of the loss, or aggravated the position of the party liable to compensate, the judge may reduce the compensation or set it aside entirely.”

Regulatory Provision — Highway Traffic Regulation art. 150 (Obligation of drivers and passengers to use protective equipment; current text) (unofficial translation)

“Certain drivers and passengers are obliged to use protective equipment while vehicles are being driven.

… Of the protective equipment shown for drivers and passengers in table (1) annexed to this Regulation, whose quantities and qualities are specified there, and in the other regulations issued under the Highway Traffic Law;

a) … Except for three-wheeled goods motorcycles and those whose driver and passengers are protected by a frame or bodywork, on bicycles, electric bicycles, motorised bicycles, motorcycles … the wearing and fastening of a protective helmet and protective goggles by drivers (protective goggles are not required where the protective helmet has protective goggles, nor for cyclists), and of a protective helmet by passengers,

b) … Except for three-wheeled goods motorcycles and those whose driver and passengers are protected by a frame or bodywork, the wearing of protective gloves by motorcycle drivers and, where carried, by passengers, …”

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a motorcyclist’s compensation reduced if they did not wear knee pads?

Under Turkish law, the reduction was not upheld in this decision. The 4th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation found the 20% reduction for contributory fault, based on the failure to use knee pads, erroneous because the Highway Traffic Regulation does not regulate knee pads as mandatory protective equipment for motorcycle drivers. In a 2022 reversal decision, however, the Chamber had required a 20% reduction in this situation; the date of the decision relied on should be borne in mind.

What protective equipment is mandatory for a motorcycle driver?

The text of the Regulation in force at the time of the accident, as quoted by the Chamber, listed a protective helmet and protective goggles for the driver and a protective helmet for passengers. The current text, following the amendment of 4.11.2025, also lists protective gloves for motorcycle drivers and passengers carried; knee pads do not appear in the current text either.

Is it not enough that the injury was to the knee?

It was not considered enough in this decision. The Objection Arbitration Panel had relied on the injury being to the knee; the Chamber, however, found the reduction erroneous because knee pads are not regulated as mandatory protective equipment in the Regulation.

Is not wearing a helmet always a ground for reduction?

This decision made no ruling on helmets. Code of Obligations art. 52/1 makes a reduction depend on the injured party having contributed to the occurrence or increase of the loss; so even where mandatory equipment was not used, the effect of the omission on the actual injury is assessed separately.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Traffic Accident Compensation Law

All Traffic Accident Compensation Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Knee Pads Not Required, No Contributory Fault Reduction: Turkish Court of Cassation on a Motorcyclist”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/motorcycle-knee-pads-contributory-fault-reduction

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›