Last reviewed:
Case NoteContributory Fault Need Not Cut Non-Pecuniary Damages: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, the injured party’s own fault in the incident (contributory fault) does not automatically require a reduction of non-pecuniary damages. In its decision of 30.04.2025, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay Hukuk Genel Kurulu) stated that the claimant’s fault is one of the factors the judge takes into account in assessing non-pecuniary damages. If the judge, having also taken that fault into account, finds the amount claimed appropriate and shows this in the reasoning, awarding the full claim does not breach the principle of being bound by the relief sought. In pecuniary damages, by contrast, the claimant’s 20% fault had been reflected as a reduction in the calculation. The decision of resistance was upheld by majority and with final effect.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held by majority that a claimant’s own fault in a tort causing serious injury does not automatically require a reduction of non-pecuniary damages, and that the judge, having taken that fault into account, may award the full amount claimed.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation upheld a decision of resistance awarding the full amount of non-pecuniary damages claimed by a claimant who was seriously injured by an electric current and found 20% at fault.
The Dispute
While painting the exterior of a building, the claimant touched a high-voltage line passing close by and was seriously injured. The claimant sought TRY 100,000 in non-pecuniary damages and pecuniary damages from the defendant electricity distribution company and the defendant municipality.
On the basis of expert reports, the first-instance court found the claimant 20%, the defendant company 15%, the defendant municipality 15% and a company not party to the case 50% at fault for the accident, and established that the claimant had suffered a 53% disability. It dismissed the action against the municipality on the ground that the administrative courts had jurisdiction; accepting that the defendant company was jointly and severally liable for the entire loss, it awarded pecuniary damages and the full TRY 100,000 in non-pecuniary damages claimed. The regional court of appeal dismissed the appeals on the merits.
By its decision of 23.03.2023, the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that allowing the non-pecuniary claim in full, while the pecuniary damages had been reduced because of the claimant’s fault, breached the rule of being bound by the relief sought, and reversed the judgment on the ground that some reduction, not a mathematical one, should have been made. The first-instance court resisted, stating that the finding that the claimant was at fault did not change the relief sought as regards non-pecuniary damages and that the judge could determine the amount in accordance with equity; the defendant company appealed the decision of resistance.
Outcome of the Decision
The Assembly of Civil Chambers first examined, as a preliminary issue, whether the decision of resistance on TRY 100,000 in non-pecuniary damages could be appealed in view of the amount. Noting that the Code contains no express rule on the finality threshold where a first-instance decision given after reversal is appealed, the majority relied on Code of Civil Procedure art. 341/2, which opens the route of appeal (istinaf) against non-pecuniary damages decisions regardless of the amount, and held that the decision was not final. The single dissenting opinion at the end of the decision concerns only this preliminary issue; in the dissent’s view, the appeal threshold should have been determined under Code of Civil Procedure art. 362/1-a and the decision should have been regarded as final in view of the amount.
On the merits, the Assembly upheld the decision of resistance. The views in favour of reversal and of upholding on different reasoning were not adopted by the majority. The decision was given on 30.04.2025 by majority and with final effect.
Reasoning
Starting from the nature of non-pecuniary damages, the Assembly set out the framework of the judge’s discretion as follows:
“This non-pecuniary redress, by which the party seeks satisfaction, is by its nature not a fixed, objective value measurable in money. It is for this reason that the judge, while on the one hand taking into account together the facts reflected in the file, the manner in which the incident occurred, the gravity of the harm suffered, the material and moral intensity and permanence of the pain endured, the socio-economic circumstances of the parties and similar matters, and on the other hand bearing in mind the aim of ensuring that the compensation rests on a balance of equity in such a way that it does not result in punishment for one party and enrichment for the other, may freely determine the amount of compensation that can be accepted as just and sufficient, and, of course, cannot exceed the claimant’s claim as an upper limit.”
Restating the approach it had expressed in an earlier decision, it assessed the effect of the claimant presenting themselves as free of fault in the petition and later being found at fault as follows:
“…it is clear that the statements in the statement of claim of a claimant who cannot have a definite idea of the degree of fault, to the effect that the harm occurred as a result of the other party’s fault and that the claimant was not at fault, contain a general and abstract account, and that, for this reason, a finding during the proceedings that a claimant who made the claim stating that they were not at fault was in fact at fault is not, given the nature of non-pecuniary damages explained above, of a kind that changes the relief sought, but may influence the judge’s discretion.”
In the present case, it found the first-instance court’s assessment to be correct:
“In the present case, the Court, too, in determining the amount of non-pecuniary damages in line with these principles, took into account the fault not only of the defendant but also of the claimant, and nevertheless concluded that the amount of compensation claimed was reasonable and acceptable; since the manner in which the power of discretion was exercised was reflected in the reasoning in a reviewable way, it cannot be said that allowing the non-pecuniary damages in full exceeded the claim forming the subject of the action or breached the principle of being bound by the relief sought.”
Significance and Practical Effect
The decision answers, at the level of the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the question “are non-pecuniary damages reduced where there is contributory fault?” In pecuniary damages, the injured party’s fault may be reflected as a proportional reduction of the calculated compensation. Non-pecuniary damages, however, are not an objective value measurable in money, so the claimant’s fault is a matter for the judge’s discretion rather than for a proportional reduction. Code of Obligations art. 52 likewise provides that the judge “may reduce” the compensation in such a case; the Assembly did not separately refer to this article. Whether failing to wear protective equipment counts as contributory fault is discussed in our article on a motorcyclist not wearing knee pads.
In practice, the reasoning is decisive. The Assembly’s conclusion rests on its finding that the first-instance court also took the claimant’s fault into account and reflected its discretion in its reasoning in a reviewable way; it is therefore important that the claimant’s fault is discussed in the reasoning. The judge cannot award more than the amount claimed (Code of Civil Procedure art. 26).
Note: within the Assembly, the view was also expressed that if the statement of claim had expressly asserted that the claimant bore no fault at all, a reduction of non-pecuniary damages would necessarily have been required; this view was not adopted by the majority. The decision concerns not a traffic accident but a tort arising from a power line; however, Code of Obligations art. 56, on which it relies, is the general provision for non-pecuniary damages claims based on impairment of bodily integrity. In a later decision concerning a claimant at contributory fault, the Assembly found the reduction made in pecuniary damages too high and the non-pecuniary damages awarded too low (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/281, K. 2025/766, 03.12.2025).
In death and bodily injury, the victim’s contributory fault does not bar non-pecuniary damages unless it breaks the causal link entirely, but is weighed in fixing the amount: the 1966 decision unifying case law (as quoted by the Assembly of Civil Chambers)
“that, for liability for non-pecuniary damages under Article 47 of the C.O., neither his own fault nor that of his employee is required..., and that the proportion in which the deceased or the person suffering bodily harm contributed, or his contributory fault, must be assessed within the special circumstances” — “Accordingly, only where the injured party’s contributory fault or contribution is such as to break the causal link entirely can this be accepted as being of such weight and intensity as to make an award of non-pecuniary damages unjust and unwarranted.” (unofficial translation)
Because the text of the decision unifying case law could not be accessed in the Court of Cassation’s decision database, the first part of the quotation is the passage that the Assembly of Civil Chambers quoted from it in its 2010 decision; the second part is the Assembly’s own reasoning. Both decisions date from the period of the former Code of Obligations No. 818, art. 47; the present counterpart is Turkish Code of Obligations art. 56. The children of two pedestrians killed by a car while crossing the road claimed non-pecuniary damages; according to the report in the criminal file the deceased bore primary fault and the driver secondary fault. The first-instance court dismissed the claim, holding that the driver’s secondary fault did not create a sufficient causal link with the harm, and insisted on that judgment against the reversal of the 4th Civil Chamber. The Assembly of Civil Chambers held that fault of the tortfeasor is not a requirement for non-pecuniary damages in cases of death and bodily injury and that the victim’s fault is relevant only to fixing the amount, and reversed the insistence judgment unanimously. The 2025 Assembly decision discussed in this article likewise treats the injured party’s fault as affecting the judge’s assessment rather than the relief sought.
Relevant Legislation
“The judge may, where a person’s bodily integrity is impaired, taking into account the particular circumstances of the case, order that an appropriate sum of money be paid to the injured party as non-pecuniary damages.”
“If the injured party consented to the act causing the damage, or contributed to the occurrence or increase of the damage, or aggravated the position of the person liable to pay compensation, the judge may reduce the compensation or eliminate it altogether.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Are non-pecuniary damages reduced where there is contributory fault?
Under Turkish law, not automatically. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the injured party’s fault is one of the factors the judge takes into account in assessing non-pecuniary damages; having taken that fault into account, the judge may still find the amount claimed appropriate.
Does the fault reduction applied to pecuniary damages also apply to non-pecuniary damages?
According to the Assembly, it need not be carried over as a percentage. In this case the claimant’s 20% fault was taken as the basis in calculating pecuniary damages, whereas the full amount of non-pecuniary damages claimed was awarded, and the Assembly upheld that outcome.
What happens if a claimant who said they were not at fault is later found at fault?
According to the Assembly, the assertion of no fault by a claimant who cannot know the degrees of fault in advance is general and abstract; a later finding that the claimant was at fault does not change the relief sought, but it may influence the judge’s discretion.
Can the judge award more non-pecuniary damages than claimed?
No. Under Code of Civil Procedure art. 26, the judge is bound by the relief sought; the Assembly also referred to the claimant’s claim as the upper limit for non-pecuniary damages.
Is this decision final?
Yes. The decision of resistance was upheld by majority and with final effect. The dissenting opinion concerns not the merits but the preliminary issue of whether the decision could be appealed in view of the amount.
Related Articles
- Damages in Fatal Traffic Accidents: Loss of Support and Calculation Principles
- Rights in a Property-Damage Traffic Accident
- Recourse in Traffic Insurance: The Insurer’s Claim Against the Insured and the Driver, Exclusive Causation and Limitation
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Traffic accident compensation attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Traffic Accident Compensation Law
- Claiming from the Guarantee Fund in Türkiye: Uninsured, Hit-and-Run or Stolen Vehicles (Law 5684 Art. 14)
- Vehicle Diminished-Value Compensation: How to Claim It After a Traffic Accident under Turkish Law
- From PMF 1931 to TRH 2010: The Life Table in Bodily Injury and Loss-of-Support Damages under Turkish Law
- Motor Own-Damage (Kasko) Insurance Disputes in Türkiye: Exclusions, Alcohol, Total Loss, Recourse, Limitation
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Contributory Fault Need Not Cut Non-Pecuniary Damages: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-19, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/contributory-fault-non-pecuniary-damages-reduction

























