Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 24 min read

Last reviewed:

SGK Recourse Against Employers for Work Accidents in Türkiye: Conditions, Fault, Amount and Limitation Period

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, if a work accident results from the employer’s intent or from breach of the legislation on insured persons’ health protection and occupational safety, the SGK claims recourse from the employer. It claims the payments it has made to the insured person or the beneficiaries and the initial capitalised value of the income awarded, as at the date the income started (Law No. 5510 art. 21/1). The amount is limited to what the insured person or the beneficiaries could claim from the employer; according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, as a rule the lower of the initial capitalised value and the real damage is taken and the degree of fault is applied. If the insured person was not notified to the Institution in time, the grounds of liability in art. 21/1 are not required (art. 23). The action is heard by the labour court and is subject to a ten-year limitation period, which runs from the Institution’s approval date for income and from the date of the expense or payment for expenses and payments (art. 93/3).

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, where a work accident results from the employer’s intent or from a breach of occupational safety legislation, the SGK claims from the employer the payments it has made and the initial capitalised value of the income awarded, limited to what the insured person could claim from the employer (Law No. 5510 art. 21). The article explains the conditions, unavoidability, insured persons not notified in time (art. 23), the inner and outer ceilings, the effect of fault reports, the ten-year limitation period and the competent court, with decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers and the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation.

The recourse action brought by the Social Security Institution (SGK) against the employer after a work accident under Turkish law: the conditions in Articles 21 and 23 of Law No. 5510, the effect of fault and unavoidability, the two ceilings on the amount, the ten-year limitation period, the competent court and the employer’s defences.

What Is the SGK’s Recourse Action against the Employer?

In Türkiye the SGK pays for the treatment of an insured person who has a work accident; it pays a temporary incapacity allowance, awards a permanent incapacity income if there is a lasting loss and, in the event of death, awards a survivors’ income to the beneficiaries. The recourse action is the second stage: the Institution claims back what it has spent from whoever caused the accident. The action the worker brings for his or her own loss is a separate one; we explained it in the article on work-accident compensation.

The basis of the right of recourse is Article 21 of Law No. 5510.

Statutory Provision — Social Insurance and General Health Insurance Law (Law No. 5510) art. 21/1 (Liability of the employer and third parties in respect of work accidents, occupational diseases and illness)

“If a work accident or occupational disease has occurred as a result of the employer’s intent or of an act of the employer contrary to the legislation on the protection of insured persons’ health and on occupational safety, the total of the payments made or to be made in the future by the Institution to the insured person or the beneficiaries under this Law and the initial capitalised value, at the date on which it started, of the income awarded shall be collected by the Institution from the employer, limited to the amounts that the insured person or the beneficiaries could claim from the employer. The principle of unavoidability shall be taken into account in determining the employer’s liability.”

There is a separate provision for treatment costs: if the work accident resulted from the employer’s intent or from an act contrary to occupational health and safety legislation, the health service costs incurred by the Institution are recovered from the employer; here too the principle of unavoidability is taken into account (art. 76/4).

The date of the accident determines which statute applies. In a reversal decision concerning an accident in 2005, the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation drew the line as follows:

Court of Cassation Decision
10th Civil Chamber, E. 2019/4890, K. 2019/8423, 12.11.2019 (the Chamber’s grounds for reversal)

“Article 26 of Law No. 506 must be applied to accidents and events that occurred before 01.10.2008, and Article 21 of Law No. 5510 to accidents and events that occurred from that date onwards.”

This article deals with accidents on or after 1 October 2008; for older accidents the calculation rules are different.

Conditions: Intent, Breach of Legislation and Unavoidability

Under the first paragraph of Article 21, recourse against the employer requires one of two situations: the employer’s intent, or an act contrary to the legislation on the protection of insured persons’ health and on occupational safety. The accident must also be the result of that act, in other words there must be a causal link. The 10th Civil Chamber has stated that for the employer to be held liable under this article its fault must be proven, and that force majeure and the gross fault of the injured person or of a third party may break the causal link (the decision of 26.06.2018 below).

The same decision defines the principle of unavoidability in the last sentence of the paragraph as follows:

Court of Cassation Decision
10th Civil Chamber, E. 2016/21, K. 2018/6118, 26.06.2018 (the Chamber’s grounds for reversal; recourse action concerning an occupational disease)

“The principle of unavoidability referred to in the text of the article denotes, in the legal and technical sense, situations and consequences that cannot technically be prevented; in other words, that are impossible to prevent even where the employer has taken the measures prescribed by the legislation.”

In that case the fault reports had found the employer one hundred per cent at fault. The Chamber found that the reports had been drawn up without assessing unavoidability, reversed the judgment and required a new report that also took into account workplace conditions and the insured person’s physical predisposition. The decision concerns an occupational disease; the Chamber also noted that the position in occupational diseases differs from that in work accidents.

The article also governs situations other than the first paragraph:

Statutory Provision — Social Insurance and General Health Insurance Law (Law No. 5510) art. 21/4 (Liability of third parties)

“If the work accident, occupational disease or illness has occurred through the fault of a third party, the payments made or to be made in the future to the insured person and the beneficiaries and half of the initial capitalised value, at the date on which it started, of the income awarded shall be recovered from the third parties who caused the damage and, if they are at fault, from those who employ them.”

Under the second paragraph, if the employer does not report the accident to the Institution in time, the temporary incapacity allowance payable for the period until the date of notification is collected from the employer. That period is three working days after the accident; if the accident happened in a place outside the employer’s control, it runs from the date the employer learned of it (art. 13/2). The third paragraph provides that the temporary incapacity allowance paid on account of the illness of an insured person who was employed without a required health report, or contrary to the report, is recovered from the employer. Under the last paragraph, in fatal accidents the Institution has no recourse against beneficiaries who were at fault in the accident or against the beneficiaries of an insured person who died in a work accident and was at fault; according to the text, this rule concerns recourse against beneficiaries.

Insured Person Not Notified in Time (art. 23)

If the worker had an accident while being employed without an employment entry declaration having been filed, a separate and stricter rule applies.

Statutory Provision — Social Insurance and General Health Insurance Law (Law No. 5510) art. 23/1-2 (Liability arising from insured status not notified in time)

“If the commencement of employment of an insured person is not notified to the Institution within the prescribed period by means of the insured employment entry declaration, the income and allowances of those concerned arising from work accidents, occupational diseases, illness and maternity occurring before the date on which the declaration is subsequently filed or on which the Institution establishes that the insured person was employed shall be paid by the Institution.

In the cases referred to in the paragraph above, the amount of all expenses incurred and to be incurred by the Institution and, if income is awarded, the initial capitalised value of that income at the date on which it started shall additionally be collected from the employer, without the grounds of liability set out in the first paragraph of Article 21 being required.”

The 10th Civil Chamber applies this provision as follows:

Court of Cassation Decision

“under Article 23 the employer’s liability rests on the principle of strict liability. Again, in view of the clear wording of the article, there is no obligation to carry out a real-damage ceiling calculation. … the Institution’s loss must be determined by applying to the initial capitalised value, established without regard to the parties’ degrees of fault, an equitable reduction under Articles 43-44 of the Code of Obligations of not less than 50% of the insured person’s fault.”

What the decision says is this: if the declaration was not filed within the statutory period and the accident happened after that period, the employer is liable for the benefits provided by the Institution even if it was not at fault in the accident; a real-damage ceiling calculation is not mandatory; only an equitable reduction is made on account of the insured person’s fault. In that case the Chamber reversed the judgment because the employer’s liability under art. 21/2 and art. 23 had not been examined and the overlap of the income with an old-age pension (art. 54) had not been taken into account. This is the Chamber decision on art. 23 whose full text was read for this article; the Assembly of Civil Chambers’ decision of 15.06.2022 also restates the article with the same content. The decision cites “Articles 43-44 of the Code of Obligations” as the basis of the equitable reduction, although the accident in that case occurred on 17.10.2012, after the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 entered into force on 01.07.2012. The decisions read for this article do not state which provision of the Turkish Code of Obligations the reduction rests on today.

The Amount: Two Ceilings and the Degree of Fault

The main item of the recourse claim is the initial capitalised value of the income awarded. According to the statutory definition quoted by the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the capitalised value is the amount of the expenses calculated by taking into account age, the probability of termination and the discount rate to be set by the Institution. Payments such as the temporary incapacity allowance and treatment costs are added to it.

The first paragraph of Article 21 limits this total to the amount that the insured person or the beneficiaries could claim from the employer. The Assembly of Civil Chambers names these two limits as follows:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/135, K. 2026/338, 20.05.2026 (the Assembly’s reasoning; on this issue the decision to persist was reversed unanimously)

“In the calculation of compensation, the expenditure consisting of the payments made and to be made by law to the insured person or the beneficiaries on account of the work accident and the initial capitalised values of the income awarded to them constitutes the highest amount of compensation that the Institution may claim, that is, the inner/lower ceiling of the compensation, while the amount that the insured person or the beneficiaries could claim from the employer constitutes the outer/upper ceiling of the compensation. … The court will calculate both the inner ceiling and the outer ceiling and award recourse compensation on the basis of whichever amount is lower.”

The outer ceiling is the real pecuniary damage that would be calculated in an action brought by the worker or the beneficiaries against the employer. We explained how that calculation is made in the articles on the actuarial calculation of work-accident compensation and on damages in fatal work accidents. The Assembly of Civil Chambers has also stated the difference between the employer and a third party clearly:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2019/111, K. 2022/948, 15.06.2022 (the Assembly’s reasoning; the decision to persist was reversed unanimously)

“in recourse actions the bases of liability of the employer and of the third party differ: when liability for the recourse claim is determined under Article 21 of Law No. 5510, as a rule, for the employer, the initial capitalised value of the income at the date on which it started must be compared, under paragraph 1, with the real (pecuniary) damage to be duly calculated in the proceedings and the lower amount taken as the basis; for the third party, under paragraph 4, half of the initial capitalised value of the income must be adopted without regard to the real damage; and the degrees of fault must be applied to these amounts.”

In this article’s simplified example: if the initial capitalised value is TRY 1,000,000, the duly calculated real damage is TRY 800,000 and the employer’s fault is 70 per cent, the lower figure of TRY 800,000 is taken and the degree of fault is applied; the recourse claim in respect of the income is TRY 560,000. For a third party at fault in the same accident, the real damage is not considered; that party’s own degree of fault is applied to half of the initial capitalised value. The 10th Civil Chamber has stated that where the employer and a third party are sued together there is joint and several liability between them and that the amount for which each is jointly and severally liable is calculated separately within these limits (the decision of 03.04.2024 below).

Increases in the income. The Law refers to the initial capitalised value at the date on which the income started. Among the decisions read, the one that expressly says increases in the income should not be claimed concerns an accident of 12.12.2005 and Article 26 of Law No. 506 (the decision of 12.11.2019 above); no decision whose full text was read for this article says so for the period of Law No. 5510. In its decision of 20.05.2026 the Assembly of Civil Chambers stated that when the degree of permanent incapacity changes the Institution recalculates the capitalised value, that each increase or change in the income is a separate fact, and that the Institution may determine its claim according to the new situation or make an additional claim.

Determining Fault and the Effect of Other Proceedings

The report in the compensation action. The Assembly of Civil Chambers answered the question whether the fault finding in the action brought by the worker or the beneficiaries binds the recourse action as follows:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/135, K. 2026/338, 20.05.2026 (the Assembly’s reasoning; by majority on this issue)

“the fault reports obtained and the degrees of fault determined in that action cannot be accepted as conclusive evidence in recourse actions to which the Institution is a party, because the subject matter and the parties of the two actions are not the same; it is clear, however, that they will constitute strong evidence.”

In that case the regional court of appeal had set the expert reports aside and itself determined that no fault could be attributed to the worker. The Assembly held, by majority, that determining to whom fault belongs and in what proportion requires special and technical knowledge and cannot be resolved by the judge’s legal knowledge; it required the compensation file to be obtained and the contradiction between the reports to be resolved by a report, containing an assessment under occupational safety legislation, from a panel of experts in the field.

Criminal proceedings. According to the Assembly’s decision of 15.06.2022, the civil judge is not bound by the criminal judge’s assessment of fault or by an acquittal (the provision the Assembly relies on is Article 74 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098); however, a final criminal judgment establishing the material facts binds the civil judge. The Assembly also explained that a decision to defer the announcement of the verdict does not have the nature of a judgment. In that case the decision to persist was reversed because the report had not assessed whether the company’s officer had a personal fault that had to be separated from the company’s fault.

Procedure: Competent Court, Mediation and Limitation

Competent court. The recourse action is heard by the labour court.

Statutory Provision — Social Insurance and General Health Insurance Law (Law No. 5510) art. 101 (Forum for disputes)

“Unless otherwise provided in this Law, disputes arising from the application of the provisions of this Law shall be heard by the labour courts.”

The Labour Courts Law No. 7036 likewise assigns to the labour courts disputes arising from labour and social security legislation to which the SGK is a party, other than objections to administrative fines and disputes under provisional Article 4 of Law No. 5510 (art. 5/1-b).

Venue and mediation. In the labour courts the court with venue is the court of the defendant’s domicile on the date the action is filed and the court of the place where the work or transaction was performed; if there is more than one defendant, the court of the domicile of any of them also has venue (Law No. 7036 art. 6/1-2). In actions for pecuniary and non-pecuniary compensation arising from a work accident or occupational disease and in the related declaratory, objection and recourse actions, applying to a mediator is not a condition for bringing the action (art. 3/3).

Limitation. The period and its starting point are expressly stated in the Law:

Statutory Provision — Social Insurance and General Health Insurance Law (Law No. 5510) art. 93/3 (Assignment, transfer, attachment and limitation of the Institution’s claims; current text)

“Actions for compensation and recourse to be brought by the Institution on the basis of this Law are subject to a ten-year limitation period. The limitation period starts, for the income and pensions that are the subject of recourse, from the date of the Institution’s approval, and for expenses and payments, from the date of the expense or payment.”

The period does not run from the date of the accident but from different dates depending on the item: the Institution’s approval date for the income, and the date of payment or expense for items such as the temporary incapacity allowance and treatment costs. The conclusion this article draws from the text is that some items arising from the same accident may be time-barred while others are not. For the general rules, see limitation periods and preclusive periods.

The Employer’s Defences in Court of Cassation Decisions

The limitation defence and when it is raised. The 10th Civil Chamber did not accept the dismissal of the action on limitation grounds in respect of a defendant who raised the objection not during the proceedings but for the first time in the appeal petition:

Court of Cassation Decision
10th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/2925, K. 2024/3692, 03.04.2024 (the Chamber’s grounds for reversal)

“given that the defendant … raised the limitation objection not during the proceedings but in the appeal petition, the action should have been upheld as regards the defendant …; the decision dismissing it on limitation grounds, on the contrary assumption, is a ground for reversal.”

In another decision the same Chamber stated that where the Institution’s first recourse action, brought as a partial action, was dismissed as time-barred and became final, the res judicata effect covers only the amount claimed in that action, and that in the second action brought for the balance the limitation defence must be assessed in the light of art. 93/3 (10th Civil Chamber, E. 2021/9247, K. 2022/2997, 03.03.2022). That outcome is specific to the circumstances of that case.

Defences that are not accepted. The Assembly of Civil Chambers interprets the employer’s duty to take occupational health and safety measures broadly; it requires the measures made necessary by scientific and technological developments to be taken even if they are not prescribed by the legislation:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“As regards these measures, an employer cannot escape liability by pleading inexperience because the workplace was newly opened, lack of knowledge of scientific and technical developments, the weakness of its financial position, or the fact that these occupational safety measures are not taken in similar workplaces.”

Defences that may be raised. The main defences this article compiles from the statutory text and the decisions read are: that the accident was not the result of an act contrary to the legislation, or was unavoidable; that the fault of the insured person or of a third party reduces the employer’s own share of fault; that the amount claimed exceeds the real damage (the outer ceiling); that the initial capitalised value table is based on incorrect data; and that the claim is time-barred item by item. As regards an insured person not notified in time, according to the 10th Civil Chamber’s decision above a defence of absence of fault does not succeed; there the dispute concerns whether the notification was made in time and the rate of the equitable reduction.

Points to Note in Practice

  • SGK income is also taken into account in the worker’s action. We explained in the article on the actuarial calculation how the part of the SGK income that is subject to recourse is deducted from the worker’s pecuniary compensation; the calculations in the two actions should rest on the same data.
  • The capitalised value table should be checked. In its 2026 decision the Assembly of Civil Chambers did not accept a calculation based on a table containing incorrect data as to the date of entry into income, the approval date and the article applied.
  • Principal employer and subcontractor. We dealt with liability in the principal employer–subcontractor relationship in the article on work accidents in mines and marble quarries.

Frequently Asked Questions

Under what conditions can the SGK bring a recourse action against the employer after a work accident in Türkiye?

Under Turkish law, the SGK may have recourse against the employer if the work accident occurred as a result of the employer’s intent or of an act contrary to the legislation on the protection of insured persons’ health and on occupational safety (Law No. 5510 art. 21/1). The principle of unavoidability is taken into account in determining the employer’s liability. The 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation has defined this principle as situations and consequences that are impossible to prevent even where the measures prescribed by the legislation have been taken (in a recourse action concerning an occupational disease). If the insured person was not notified to the Institution in time, these grounds of liability are not required (art. 23).

What is the limit on the amount the SGK can claim from the employer in a recourse action under Turkish law?

Under Turkish law, the employer is asked for the payments made and to be made by the Institution and the initial capitalised value of the income awarded, as at the date the income started; this total is limited to the amount the insured person or the beneficiaries could claim from the employer (Law No. 5510 art. 21/1). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, the court calculates both the Institution’s expenditure (inner ceiling) and the real damage (outer ceiling), takes the lower and, as a rule, applies the degree of fault. Against a third party at fault, recourse is based on half of the initial capitalised value (art. 21/4).

What is the limitation period for an SGK recourse action arising from a work accident in Türkiye, and when does it start?

Under Turkish law, actions for compensation and recourse brought by the Institution on the basis of Law No. 5510 are subject to a ten-year limitation period (art. 93/3). The period starts from the Institution’s approval date for the income and pensions that are the subject of recourse, and from the date of the expense or payment for expenses and payments; it does not start from the date of the accident. In a 2024 decision the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation treated as a ground for reversal the dismissal of an action on the basis of a limitation objection raised not during the proceedings but for the first time in the appeal petition.

Does the fault report in the worker’s compensation action bind the SGK’s recourse action under Turkish law?

Under Turkish law it does not bind as conclusive evidence, but it is strong evidence. In its decision of 20.05.2026 (by majority on this issue) the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation stated that, because the subject matter and the parties of the two actions are not the same, the fault report in the compensation action cannot be regarded as conclusive evidence in the recourse action, but will constitute strong evidence. If the reports contradict each other, the compensation file is obtained and the contradiction is resolved by a new expert panel report. According to the same decision, to whom fault belongs and in what proportion requires special and technical knowledge; the court cannot determine it of its own motion by setting the expert reports aside.

If a worker whose employment entry declaration was not filed in time has a work accident in Türkiye, is the employer liable to the SGK even without fault?

Yes, under Turkish law the employer is liable if the insured employment entry declaration was not filed in time. Under Law No. 5510 art. 23, in that case the expenses incurred and to be incurred by the Institution and the initial capitalised value of the income awarded are collected from the employer without the grounds of liability in art. 21/1 being required. In a 2021 decision the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation treated this as strict liability and stated that a real-damage ceiling calculation is not mandatory and that the Institution’s loss is determined by making an equitable reduction of not less than fifty per cent of the insured person’s fault.

Which court hears the SGK’s recourse action against the employer in Türkiye, and is mediation mandatory?

Under Turkish law the action is heard by the labour court. Disputes arising from the application of Law No. 5510 are resolved by the labour courts unless the Law provides otherwise (art. 101); Law No. 7036 also assigns to the labour court, apart from the listed exceptions, disputes arising from labour and social security legislation to which the SGK is a party (art. 5/1-b). The court with venue is the court of the defendant’s domicile or of the place where the work or transaction was performed (art. 6). In recourse actions arising from a work accident, applying to a mediator is not a condition for bringing the action (art. 3/3).

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Work Accident Compensation Law

All Work Accident Compensation Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “SGK Recourse Against Employers for Work Accidents in Türkiye: Conditions, Fault, Amount and Limitation Period”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/sgk-recourse-action-employer-work-accident

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›