Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 22 min read

Last reviewed:

Principal Employer and Subcontractor in Türkiye: Sham Arrangements, Joint Liability (Labour Law Arts. 2, 112)

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, a principal employer–subcontractor relationship is formed when an ancillary job is given to a subcontractor. It is also formed when a part of the main work that is required by operational and business needs and requires expertise for technological reasons is given to a subcontractor. The principal employer is jointly liable with the subcontractor towards the subcontractor’s employees for obligations relating to that workplace (Labour Law No. 4857 art. 2). If the relationship is sham (simulated) or does not meet the statutory conditions, the subcontractor’s employees are deemed to be the principal employer’s employees from the outset; according to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, sham arrangements are examined separately for each tender period. In public bodies, the severance pay of a subcontractor’s employee working within the scope of art. 62/1-e of Law No. 4734 is, where the conditions are met, as a rule paid by the public body (art. 112); the Court of Cassation’s 9th Civil Chamber has held that this rule does not remove the subcontractor’s liability.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, a subcontracting relationship may be set up for ancillary jobs or for a part of the main work required by operational and business needs and requiring technological expertise; if it is a sham, the employee is deemed the principal employer's employee from the outset, and in a valid relationship the principal employer is jointly liable with the subcontractor. The article explains the conditions, the sham-arrangement criteria, the separate examination of each tender period and the payment of severance pay in the public sector, with Court of Cassation decisions.

Under Turkish law: the statutory conditions of a subcontracting (principal employer–subcontractor) relationship, the subcontractor’s employees being treated as the principal employer’s employees where the arrangement is sham, joint liability for employee receivables and payment of severance pay in public procurement work, in light of Articles 2, 3 and 112 of Labour Law No. 4857 in Türkiye and the Subcontracting Regulation.

What Is a Principal Employer–Subcontractor Relationship?

What is commonly called “subcontracting” (taşeron) is the principal employer–subcontractor relationship of the Turkish Labour Law: the principal employer gives part of the work at its workplace to a subcontractor, and the subcontractor employs its workers for that job only at that workplace. In the decisions below, hospital cleaning and the loading and transport of coal at a mine were carried out under this structure.

Two consequences matter for the employee: in a valid relationship, the principal employer is jointly liable with the subcontractor; if the relationship is unlawful or sham, the employee is deemed the principal employer’s employee from the outset.

Statutory Provision — Labour Law (Law No. 4857) art. 2 (Definitions — paragraphs on the principal employer–subcontractor relationship)

“The relationship established between an employer who takes on work from another employer in ancillary jobs relating to the production of goods or services carried out at the latter’s workplace, or in jobs within a part of the main work requiring expertise for operational, business and technological reasons, and who employs the workers assigned to that work only in the work taken on at that workplace, and the employer from whom the work is taken, is called the principal employer-subcontractor relationship. In this relationship, the principal employer is jointly liable with the subcontractor towards the subcontractor’s workers, in relation to that workplace, for obligations arising from this Law, from the employment contract or from the collective labour agreement to which the subcontractor is a party.

The rights of the principal employer’s workers cannot be restricted by their being hired by the subcontractor and kept in employment, nor can a subcontracting relationship be established with a person previously employed at that workplace. Otherwise, and in general, the principal employer-subcontractor relationship is deemed to be based on a sham transaction and the subcontractor’s workers are treated as the principal employer’s workers from the outset. Except for jobs requiring expertise for operational, business and technological reasons, the main work cannot be divided and given to subcontractors.”

As the fourth paragraph is repealed, decisions refer to these provisions as paragraphs 6–7 or 7–8 of art. 2; this article refers to their content instead.

Conditions for a Valid Subcontracting Relationship

The following conditions follow from the statutory text and from the Assembly of Civil Chambers decisions cited below:

  • Two separate employers: there must be two employers that are legally and economically independent and each have their own work organisation.
  • Work relating to the production of goods or services: the work given to the subcontractor must relate to production at the principal employer’s workplace.
  • An ancillary job or a part of the main work requiring expertise: ancillary jobs may be given without restriction if there is no sham. A part of the main work may be given only if the criteria of operational and business necessity and of requiring expertise for technological reasons are met together.
  • The subcontractor’s employees are employed only in the work taken from the principal employer.
  • No prohibited situation: the subcontractor must not be someone previously employed at that workplace, and the principal employer’s employees must not be moved to the subcontractor with their rights restricted.

The Law does not define “main work” and “ancillary job”. These definitions are in the Subcontracting Regulation issued under the Labour Law. The Regulation defines main work as “the work forming the essence of the production of goods or services”. The definition of an ancillary job is in the box below. The same article of the Regulation also lists the forms a sham arrangement may take. These are provisions of a regulation, not of the statute; courts use these criteria in their assessment.

Regulatory Provision — Subcontracting Regulation art. 3 (Definitions — sham arrangement and ancillary job)

“g) Sham arrangement (muvazaa):

1) the giving to a subcontractor of jobs not requiring expertise within a part of the main work relating to the production of goods or services carried out at the workplace,

2) a subcontracting relationship established with a person previously employed at that workplace,

3) the principal employer’s workers being hired by the subcontractor and kept in employment with their rights restricted,

4) transactions aimed at concealing the real intentions of the parties, such as avoiding public obligations or restricting or eliminating the workers’ rights arising from the employment contract, the collective labour agreement or labour legislation,

means a contract containing [these],

ğ) Ancillary job: a job which relates to the production of goods or services carried out at the workplace but is not directly part of the production organisation, is not a necessary element of production, but continues as long as the main work continues and is dependent on the main work,”

The subcontractor must notify its workplace to the regional directorate with the written subcontracting agreement and the necessary documents (art. 3). Since a labour inspector may find a sham arrangement even after registration (art. 3), registration does not by itself prove that the relationship is valid.

Sham Arrangements and Their Effect: Treating the Employee as the Principal Employer’s Employee

A sham arrangement (muvazaa) is where the parties create an appearance that does not reflect their real intention in order to deceive third parties. In subcontracting, this means that on paper there are two employers but in reality the work and the employee remain within the principal employer’s organisation. According to the reasoning of the Assembly of Civil Chambers, both where the statutory prohibitions and restrictions are breached and, in general, where there is a sham arrangement, the employees are deemed to be the principal employer’s employees from the outset. The dissenting opinion in the Assembly’s 2022 decision also states that the absence of statutory conditions and a sham arrangement are different concepts but have the same consequences.

Art. 12 of the Regulation requires certain criteria to be considered when examining a sham arrangement. In its 2025 decision, the Assembly of Civil Chambers also listed these criteria for judicial review.

Regulatory Provision — Subcontracting Regulation art. 12/2 (Examination of sham arrangements)

“(2) In examining a sham arrangement, in particular;

… ç) whether the subcontractor has sufficient equipment and experience suited to the work,

d) whether the qualifications of the workers it will employ are suited to the work to be done,

e) whether any worker of the principal employer, other than those assigned on the principal employer’s behalf for coordination and supervision, works in the work given to the subcontractor,

… shall be taken into account.”

In connection with these criteria, the following facts may stand out in case files: the employee carrying out the work on instructions from the principal employer’s managers, the subcontractor lacking its own equipment and experienced staff suited to the work, and the same work being done side by side with the principal employer’s employees. This list is this article’s own inference; these facts are not rules that produce a result on their own, but indications the judge assesses together with the whole file.

As a result of a sham arrangement, the employee may claim to benefit from the collective labour agreement and from the pay scheme applied to the principal employer’s comparable employees. According to the Chamber’s reversal reasoning quoted in the Assembly of Civil Chambers’ 2025 decision, the differences owed to an employee who is not a union member and does not pay a solidarity contribution are calculated on the basis of the pay of a non-unionised comparable employee doing the same work; the Assembly did not examine this part separately, as it regarded it as a reversal “on the alternative assumption”.

Joint Liability for Employee Receivables

In a valid relationship, the principal employer is jointly liable with the subcontractor towards the subcontractor’s employee, “in relation to that workplace”, for obligations arising from the Law, from the employment contract or from the collective labour agreement to which the subcontractor is a party. In decisions of the Court of Cassation’s 9th Civil Chamber, this liability is applied as joint and several liability. Severance pay, notice pay, overtime, annual leave and wage receivables are assessed within this scope; for the calculation of these receivables, see the articles on severance pay, notice pay and overtime pay.

The words “in relation to that workplace” limit the principal employer’s liability to the period during which the employee worked at its workplace. In the 2026 decision cited below, the first-instance and regional appellate courts calculated the principal employer’s liability according to that period; the Chamber did not discuss this approach, and reversed on the ground that the period during which the employee worked at the principal employer’s shipyard had been determined incorrectly. That this limit follows from these words of the statute is this article’s own inference.

Where there is a sham arrangement, the employee is treated as the principal employer’s employee from the outset (art. 2); that the receivables are therefore directed at the principal employer is this article’s own inference. In a valid relationship, the principal employer’s possibility of recourse against the subcontractor is mentioned in the reversal reasoning quoted in the 2024 decision below; that the internal allocation between the two employers does not affect the employee’s receivable is also this article’s own inference.

Severance Pay in Public Procurement Work (art. 112)

In 2014, Law No. 6552 added to art. 112 of Law No. 4857 special payment rules for employees employed by subcontractors within the scope of art. 62/1-e of Public Procurement Law No. 4734. That subparagraph defines “service procurement based on the employment of personnel”; its current text, amended by Decree-Law No. 696 and Law No. 7079, prohibits the listed public administrations from making such procurements.

Statutory Provision — Labour Law (Law No. 4857) art. 112/2 (second paragraph added by Law No. 6552)

“The severance pay of workers employed by subcontractors within the scope of subparagraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 62 of Public Procurement Law No. 4734 dated 4/1/2002;

a) For those who have worked without interruption at workplaces belonging to the same public institution or body, regardless of whether their subcontractors have changed, the service periods on which severance pay is based for the periods so worked shall be determined on the basis of the total working periods spent at workplaces belonging to the same public institution or body. For those among them whose employment contracts with their last subcontractor ended in a manner requiring the payment of severance pay under Article 14 of Labour Law No. 1475, the severance pay shall be paid by the relevant public institution or body,

… by being deposited into the worker’s bank account.”

Subparagraph (b) of the article provides that, for those who worked for the same subcontractor at different public bodies, payment is made by the last body; the third paragraph governs payment, on written request, of the portion relating to public-sector service where the contract ends at a non-public workplace.

This rule determines who makes the payment; it does not release the subcontractor from liability. The Court of Cassation’s 9th Civil Chamber reversed, for this reason, a judgment holding only the Ministry liable for severance pay (see the decision box below). Another added paragraph of the same article appears in the text as annulled by a decision of the Constitutional Court; the second paragraph discussed in this article is outside that annulment.

In addition, under a paragraph added to art. 2 in 2006, persons employed in the public sector through a contractor under service procurement contracts are not entitled, “on the basis of having worked in this way”, to appointment to permanent posts or to the financial rights granted to permanent staff. In the decisions cited, sham arrangements were examined in actions against public bodies; the effect of this paragraph was not discussed separately.

Procedure: Objection to the Inspector’s Report, Mediation and Proof

Administrative finding and objection. The documents of a registered subcontractor workplace may be examined by labour inspectors. If a sham arrangement is found, the reasoned report is served on the employers, who may object to the labour court within thirty working days.

Statutory Provision — Labour Law (Law No. 4857) art. 3/2 (Notification of the workplace)

“Where a sham transaction is found as a result of the examination, the reasoned inspector’s report on this finding shall be served on the employers. The employers may object to this report before the competent labour court within thirty working days of the date of service. … If no objection is made to the report within thirty working days, or if the court upholds the finding of a sham transaction, the registration shall be cancelled and the subcontractor’s workers shall be deemed the principal employer’s workers from the outset.”

Mediation. An employee who will claim receivables on the basis of a sham arrangement or of joint liability must first apply to a mediator; in actions for employee receivables and compensation based on the law or on an individual or collective employment contract, mediation is a precondition for bringing the action. The limitation period is suspended from the application until the final report (Law No. 7036 art. 3/17). If both the principal employer and the subcontractor are to be held jointly liable, it is advisable to direct the application against both; this is a suggestion, not an express rule of the Law.

Statutory Provision — Labour Courts Law (Law No. 7036) art. 3/1 (Mediation as a precondition for an action)

“(1) In actions brought for employee or employer receivables and compensation based on the law or on an individual or collective employment contract, and for reinstatement, having applied to a mediator is a precondition for bringing the action.”

Proof. A sham arrangement is subject to the general rules of proof; contracts, specifications, site inspection, expert reports, witnesses and social security (SGK) records are assessed together. The burden of proving the fact of work and the length of service lies on the employee; the link between the employer shown in the SGK records and the actual work is examined separately.

Subcontracting in Court Decisions

Each tender period is examined separately. The Assembly of Civil Chambers held it wrong to accept a sham arrangement on the basis of final sham-arrangement judgments given for other employees at the same workplace without examining the tender periods during which the claimant worked, and unanimously reversed the judgment of resistance.

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“It should first be noted that a finding that the principal employer-subcontractor relationship established for a given tender period is invalid or based on a sham arrangement will have no effect for the previous and subsequent tender periods. Each tender contract must be assessed within its own period and conditions. … For this reason, final court judgments that the contracts made by the defendant were unlawful or sham are binding only for the tender periods found to be sham and are not sufficient to accept that the previous and subsequent tender periods were sham.”

The Assembly required that, for each period, the nature of the work, whether technological expertise was required and whether the principal employer’s employees worked in the same job be investigated, with an expert report obtained if necessary.

A judgment for an earlier period does not bind a later period. The Assembly of Civil Chambers’ 2022 decision accepted by majority that a final sham-arrangement judgment for the same employee’s earlier period does not automatically apply to a later tender period; the dissenting opinion argued that the later contracts should also be deemed sham. The Chamber’s reversal decision adopted by the Assembly also deals with employment outside the tendered work:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision (Chamber’s reversal reasoning adopted by the Assembly)
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2021/811, K. 2022/1592, 24.11.2022 (9th Civil Chamber’s reversal reasoning quoted in the decision)

“Employing the worker outside the work left to the subcontractor does not make the contracts concluded sham; where this is established, it must be concluded that the elements of the principal employer-subcontractor relationship are not present only for that worker. In that case, invalidity or a sham arrangement cannot be said to exist for the other workers.”

According to the reversal reasoning, if it is established that the employee was employed in work outside the tender, the receivables must be calculated under the defendant’s collective labour agreement, also taking into account that the claimant is a union member. That the outcome for the employee is similar even though the characterisation is “missing elements” rather than “sham” is this article’s own assessment.

Employment outside the scope of the tender. In a 2023 decision, the Court of Cassation’s 9th Civil Chamber noted that the sham nature of the same service procurement contracts had become final in other employees’ cases and found that the receivables claimed related to the period for which the sham arrangement had become final; it also added to its reasoning that the employee had been employed outside the scope of the work undertaken. The Chamber characterised this situation as a sham arrangement, while the 2022 reversal reasoning adopted by the Assembly describes the same situation as missing elements.

Court of Cassation Decision

“Although there is no restriction on giving an ancillary job to a subcontractor, it is mandatory that the part of the main work requires technological expertise. … Moreover, since it is understood that in the present case the claimant was employed as a mechanical maintenance and repair worker in a job outside the scope of the work undertaken under the service procurement contract accepted as sham, it must be accepted that the principal employer-subcontractor relationship is sham in this case as well.”

Severance pay in the public sector and the subcontractor’s liability. In the case of an employee who worked as a cleaner for changing subcontractors at a hospital attached to a Ministry, the first-instance court had held only the Ministry liable because of art. 112. The Chamber reversed that judgment; the judgment given in compliance with the reversal was upheld in 2024. The quotation is from the earlier reversal reasoning quoted in the decision upholding the judgment.

Court of Cassation Decision (Chamber’s reversal reasoning quoted in the decision)
9th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/18451, K. 2024/2412, 15.02.2024 (quoting the Chamber’s reversal decision E. 2016/21951, K. 2020/514)

“that the rule introduced in subparagraph (a) of the second paragraph added to Article 112 does not remove the liability of the subcontractor, who is the employee’s real employer; that it was therefore wrong for the Court … to hold only the Ministry liable in a way that removes the subcontractor’s liability for the claimant’s severance pay and, in particular, the principal employer’s possibility of recourse; that the defendants, between whom there is a principal employer-subcontractor relationship, are jointly and severally liable for the claimant’s severance pay”

Proof of the service period and the workplace. In the case of an employee who claimed to have worked at a shipyard as a subcontractor’s employee, the SGK record for some periods appeared under other workplace registration numbers. The regional appellate court had limited the principal employer’s liability to the period it accepted, on the basis of SGK records, as spent at the principal employer’s shipyard. The Chamber reversed, stating that when witness statements and records are assessed together, it must be accepted that the whole period was spent at the principal employer’s shipyard.

Court of Cassation Decision

“In labour law, the burden of proving the fact of work and the period of service lies on the worker who asserts it. The fact of work may be proved by any kind of evidence. … In particular, the employers appearing in the SGK records for the alleged working period must be investigated, and it must be investigated whether work was actually performed between the employers appearing on record and the worker, and how the record came about.”

This is a reversal decision; the case will be decided again, and the outcome in each case depends on the records and on the periods during which the witnesses worked.

Practical Points

  • Collect documents period by period. Since sham arrangements are examined separately for each tender period, judgments given for other tender periods are not enough; the contracts and specifications for each period worked should be obtained for the file.
  • Do not treat the SGK record as sufficient on its own. Where the employee actually worked should be proved by witnesses and documents.
  • Do not skip mediation. The final report must be attached to the statement of claim.
  • Check membership for collective agreement claims. Even where a sham arrangement is accepted, benefiting from the collective labour agreement may depend on separate conditions such as union membership or a solidarity contribution.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is a principal employer–subcontractor relationship considered a sham under Turkish law?

As a rule, the relationship is treated as sham if a part of the main work not requiring expertise has been given to the subcontractor, if the relationship has been set up with someone previously employed at that workplace, or if the principal employer’s employees have been moved to the subcontractor with their rights restricted (Labour Law No. 4857 art. 2; Subcontracting Regulation art. 3). The Subcontracting Regulation also requires consideration of the subcontractor’s equipment and experience and of whether the principal employer’s employees work in the same job. The decision is based on all the facts in the file.

What follows under Turkish law if a sham arrangement is found for a subcontractor’s employee?

The subcontractor’s employee is deemed the principal employer’s employee from the outset (Labour Law No. 4857 art. 2). The employee may then claim the differences arising from the pay scheme of the principal employer’s comparable employees and, where the conditions are met, from the collective labour agreement. Benefiting from the collective labour agreement may depend on separate conditions such as union membership or a solidarity contribution.

Is the principal employer liable under Turkish law for the severance pay and other receivables of a subcontractor’s employee?

Yes, in a valid subcontracting relationship the principal employer is jointly liable with the subcontractor, in relation to that workplace, for obligations arising from the Law, the employment contract and the collective labour agreement to which the subcontractor is a party (Labour Law No. 4857 art. 2). The Court of Cassation’s 9th Civil Chamber applies this as joint and several liability. That the statutory words “in relation to that workplace” limit the liability to the period the employee worked at the principal employer’s workplace is this article’s own inference.

Who pays the severance pay of a subcontractor’s employee working at a public body in Türkiye under art. 112 of Law No. 4857?

The severance pay of an employee who worked without interruption at the same public body as a subcontractor’s employee within the scope of art. 62/1-e of Law No. 4734, and whose last employment contract ended in a way requiring severance pay, is as a rule paid by the relevant public body into the employee’s bank account (art. 112/2-a). The Court of Cassation’s 9th Civil Chamber has held that this rule does not remove the subcontractor’s liability and that the principal employer and the subcontractor are jointly liable.

In a subcontracting relationship under Turkish law, does a sham-arrangement judgment for one tender period also apply to later tender periods?

No, according to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, final sham-arrangement judgments are binding only for the tender periods found to be sham. The contracts and the work actually done must be examined separately for previous and subsequent tender periods. The Assembly repeated this principle unanimously in its 2025 decision.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Labor & Social Security Law

All Labor & Social Security Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Principal Employer and Subcontractor in Türkiye: Sham Arrangements, Joint Liability (Labour Law Arts. 2, 112)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/principal-employer-subcontractor-sham-liability-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›