Last reviewed:
Case NoteCourt of Cassation: An SGK Fine Not Challenged in Time Cannot Be Disputed in a Payment-Order Action
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, an objection to an administrative fine imposed by the Social Security Institution (SGK) under Article 102 of Law No. 5510 is made to the Institution within fifteen days of notification; if it is rejected, an action is brought before the administrative court within thirty days of notification of the rejection. In its decision of 15.12.2022, the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers (Yargıtay Hukuk Genel Kurulu) held that a fine which had become final because no administrative court action was brought after the Institution’s rejection cannot be reopened in an action to annul the payment order. In such an action the debtor may only argue that the debt has been paid or is time-barred. The decision was unanimous and final.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, in its decision of 15.12.2022 the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that an SGK administrative fine is challenged by objecting to the Institution within fifteen days and, if rejected, suing in the administrative court within thirty days; once the fine becomes final because that route was not used, an action against the payment order can raise only payment and limitation.
Under Turkish law, an SGK administrative fine is challenged through the Institution and the administrative court; if that route is not used in time the fine becomes final, and in an action before the labour court against the payment order only payment and limitation may be raised.
The Dispute
The Institution imposed administrative fines under Article 102 on an employer company for failing to submit the documents of a worker found to be employed uninsured and for failing to produce records. The fines were notified on 23.01.2014; the company objected to the Institution on 06.02.2014, the objection commission rejected the objection on 12.02.2014 and the rejection was notified on 20.02.2014. The company did not bring an action before the administrative court. When the Institution sent a payment order, the company sued in time to annul it, arguing that the fines had no legal basis.
The first-instance court found one of the fines unlawful and annulled the payment order. The (abolished) 21st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed twice; the court persisted, including after a procedural reversal.
Outcome of the Decision
The Assembly of Civil Chambers reversed the decision to persist as regards the main action concerning the administrative fines: since the fines had become final, the action should have been dismissed. As regards the joined action, concerning whether the payment-order action had been filed in time, it found the decision to persist correct and sent the file to the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation for examination on the merits. The decision was given unanimously and as final on 15.12.2022.
Reasoning
The Assembly first explained the two-stage objection route set up by Article 102 and when the fine becomes final:
“Under this provision, an objection must first be made to the commission within the Institution against an administrative fine imposed by the Institution and, if the objection is rejected, an action must be brought before the administrative court within the statutory period; the administrative fine becomes final if no objection is made to the commission, if no action is brought before the administrative court, or if the administrative court dismisses the action.” (unofficial translation)
It also addressed the case where a payment order is sent while the objection procedure is pending:
“If a payment order has been sent although the objection procedure has not been completed, and an action has been brought objecting to the payment order and seeking its annulment, the court must await the outcome of the procedure under Article 102 of Law No. 5510 and, to that end, treat the outcome of the action brought before the administrative court as a preliminary question.” (unofficial translation)
It drew the limit of the payment-order action for a final fine as follows:
“When a final administrative fine is enforced under Law No. 6183, the debtor may raise only the defences of payment and limitation. Since the existence of the administrative fine has become final at the administrative stage or by an administrative court decision, it will not be possible to object to the substance of the claim by asserting that “there is no such debt”.” (unofficial translation)
In the case, the thirty-day period for suing had been missed, so the fine had become final; the company had no objection of payment or limitation either.
Significance and Practical Effect
Two routes, two courts. The route against the fine itself is the objection to the Institution and the administrative court (Art. 102). The route against the payment order is the objection under Article 58 of Law No. 6183; under Article 88 of Law No. 5510 the labour court of the place where the Institution’s creditor unit is located has jurisdiction over these disputes. An objection to the payment order does not replace a missed objection to the fine.
Time limits. 15 days from notification of the fine to object to the Institution, 30 days from notification of the rejection to go to the administrative court; the objection to a payment order is 15 days under the current text. In the file at hand the payment-order period was seven days; the decision also notes that Law No. 7061 raised it to fifteen days from 01.01.2018.
Currency. For this article, decisions of the 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation from 2023–2026 were searched; no decision departing from this one was found. The objection and action periods of Article 102 cited above are the same in the current text.
Relevant Legislation
… Administrative fines accrue upon notification to the person concerned. They are paid to the Institution or into the Institution’s relevant accounts within fifteen days of notification, or an objection may be made to the Institution within the same period. An objection stays enforcement. Those whose objection is rejected by the Institution may apply to the competent administrative court within thirty days of notification of the decision. If no application is made within that period, the administrative fine becomes final.
If administrative fines are paid in advance within fifteen days of notification, before an objection to the Institution or recourse to the courts, three quarters of the fine is collected. Advance payment does not affect the right to challenge the administrative fine in court.
… Applying to the court does not stop the enforcement and collection of the administrative fine.
… Administrative fines are subject to a ten-year limitation period. The limitation period starts from the date on which the act was committed.
A person served with a payment order may object, within 15 days of service, before the tax objection commission dealing with the objections of the collecting office, on the grounds that there is no such debt, that it has been partly paid or that it is time-barred.
Frequently Asked Questions
Under Turkish law, what is the time limit for objecting to an SGK administrative fine?
An objection to an SGK administrative fine may be made to the Institution within fifteen days of notification; the objection stays enforcement. If the objection is rejected, an action may be brought before the competent administrative court within thirty days of notification of the rejection; if that period is missed the fine becomes final (Law No. 5510, Art. 102).
Which court hears a challenge to an SGK administrative fine in Türkiye?
An action against an SGK administrative fine is brought before the administrative court after the Institution rejects the objection (Law No. 5510, Art. 102). For disputes arising from collection of the Institution’s claims under Law No. 6183, that is, objections to a payment order, the labour court of the place where the Institution’s creditor unit is located has jurisdiction (Art. 88).
How can a payment order for a final SGK administrative fine be challenged?
An objection to the payment order is made within 15 days of service (Law No. 6183, Art. 58). According to the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, for a final administrative fine the debtor may raise only payment and limitation; the unlawfulness of the fine or the claim that “there is no debt” cannot be raised in that action.
Is there a discount if an SGK administrative fine is paid early?
Yes. If the fine is paid in advance within fifteen days of notification, before any objection to the Institution or recourse to the courts, three quarters of it is collected. Advance payment does not affect the right to go to court (Law No. 5510, Art. 102).
What happens if the SGK sends a payment order while the objection to the fine is still pending?
According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, if a payment order is sent before the objection procedure under Article 102 is completed and an action is brought against the payment order, the court must await the outcome of that procedure and treat the administrative court action as a preliminary question.
Related Articles
- Company Tax Debt in Türkiye: Shareholder and Legal Representative Liability (Law 6183 Art. 35), Payment Orders
- Action for Determination of Insured Service: Conditions, Time Limit and Proof
- Work Permits for Foreign Nationals in Türkiye: Challenging a Refusal and Fines (Law No. 6735 Arts. 21, 23)
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Labor cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Labor & Social Security Law
- Invalidity Pension in Türkiye: Conditions, 60% Loss of Working Capacity and Challenging the SGK Decision
- Court of Cassation: Survivors’ Pension Reached by Crediting Days Is Stopped; Recovery Limited as SGK Error
- Is a Heart Attack at Work a Work Accident in Türkiye? Law No. 5510 Art. 13 and Court of Cassation Decisions
- Principal Employer and Subcontractor in Türkiye: Sham Arrangements, Joint Liability (Labour Law Arts. 2, 112)
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Court of Cassation: An SGK Fine Not Challenged in Time Cannot Be Disputed in a Payment-Order Action”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-19, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/sgk-administrative-fine-objection-payment-order-turkiye

























