Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 9 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Court of Cassation: Survivors’ Pension Reached by Crediting Days Is Stopped; Recovery Limited as SGK Error

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, credited days do not count towards the “5 years of insurance and 900 days” route in Article 32/2-a of Law No. 5510 for a survivors’ pension; the 900 days must be completed excluding credited periods. In its decision of 18.06.2026, the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers (Yargıtay Hukuk Genel Kurulu) found lawful the stopping, nine years later, of a survivors’ pension that had been granted after the deceased’s 890 days were raised to 1430 days by crediting military service. In the same decision it held that, since the pension had been granted through the Institution’s erroneous act and the beneficiaries had no intent or fault, the undue payments would be reclaimed under Article 96/1-b, that is, limited to payments made within at most five years back from detection and interest-free for the first twenty-four months. The decision was unanimous and final.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, in its decision of 18.06.2026 the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that credited periods do not count towards the 5-year and 900-day route for a survivors’ pension, so stopping a pension granted through credited military service was correct; but since the beneficiaries were not at fault, the pensions paid are to be reclaimed under Article 96/1-b of Law No. 5510, limited to five years and interest-free for the first twenty-four months.

Under Turkish law, a survivors’ pension granted after reaching 900 days through credited military service is stopped; if the beneficiary is not at fault, the pensions paid are reclaimed only to the extent of Article 96/1-b.

The Dispute

The insured, who worked under an employment contract (Art. 4/1-a), had 890 premium days when he died on 01.02.2009. On 07.04.2009 his spouse paid for 540 days of credited military service, and a survivors’ pension was granted to the beneficiaries on the basis of 1430 days. Finding that the 900-day condition excluding credited periods had not been met, the Institution stopped the pensions by an act dated 25.09.2018, sent debt notices and then sued for recovery. The beneficiaries asked for the act to be annulled and the pensions reinstated.

The first-instance court accepted that the pension conditions were not met, but annulled the recovery act, stating that recovery nine years later because of a 10-day shortfall would be an excessive burden. The Regional Court of Appeal also ordered the pensions to be reinstated. The 10th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed; the Regional Court of Appeal persisted on grounds of proportionality and good administration.

Outcome of the Decision

The Assembly of Civil Chambers allowed the Institution’s appeal, reversed the decision to persist and sent the file back to the Regional Court of Appeal. According to the Assembly, the request to reinstate the survivors’ pension must be rejected, and the pensions paid must be recovered under Article 96/1-b. The decision was given unanimously and as final on 18.06.2026.

Reasoning

The Assembly stated that the phrase is not a bar on moving the insurance start date back, but refers to the period to be completed without crediting. Citing the Constitutional Court’s decision of 22.10.2015, E. 2015/10, K. 2015/93, which rejected the application for annulment of this phrase, it concluded:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/640, K. 2026/386, 18.06.2026 (the Assembly’s reasoning — both conditions together)

“In conclusion, the phrase “excluding all kinds of credited periods” in Article 32 of Law No. 5510 is not contrary to the principle of equality, and it must be applied to both conditions listed in that Law among the conditions for benefiting from survivors’ insurance: having been insured “for at least 5 years” and having “900 days of invalidity, old-age and survivors’ insurance premiums reported”.” (unofficial translation)

The Assembly recalled that it had adopted the same principle in four decisions given in 2017–2019. On recovery, it stressed that Article 96 sets up two separate regimes:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/640, K. 2026/386, 18.06.2026 (the Assembly’s reasoning — the two regimes of Art. 96)

“Accordingly, the consequence of excess or undue payments made for reasons arising from the Institution’s erroneous act has been made lighter than the rules governing excess or undue payments made as a result of the intentional or negligent conduct of the persons concerned.” (unofficial translation)

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/640, K. 2026/386, 18.06.2026 (the Assembly’s application to the case)

“… since the conditions for a survivors’ pension were not met in the present case, the Institution’s act of stopping the pension is correct; however, as this did not arise from the intentional or negligent conduct of the beneficiaries, the decision on the undue pension payments must be made by applying Article 96/1-b of Law No. 5510.” (unofficial translation)

Significance and Practical Effect

Entitlement and recovery are assessed separately. The decision separates two questions. If the statutory conditions for the pension are absent, an Institution error does not create a right to a pension; the pension is stopped. The Institution’s error only narrows the scope of recovery: if the beneficiary acted without intent or fault, at most five years of payments are claimed, and no interest runs if the debt is paid within twenty-four months of notification.

Calculation. On this article’s reading, if the pension was paid from 2009 and the error was detected in 2018, the amount that can be reclaimed is limited to payments made in the five years before detection; older payments cannot be claimed.

Approach of the lower courts. The lower courts had relied on the right to property and proportionality; the Institution, for its part, argued that the binding effect of Constitutional Court individual-application decisions was debatable. The Assembly did not enter into that debate; it provided protection through the limits of Article 96/1-b. In a similar file, in decision 10th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/12484, K. 2026/3905, 06.04.2026, the beneficiaries’ request for the pension to continue was also rejected, and the court annulled the objection to the Institution’s enforcement proceedings for the undue-payment debt and awarded compensation for denial of enforcement.

Note. The position is different if 1800 days are reached through crediting: the crediting bar applies only to the 5-year and 900-day route. In a survivors’ pension application, both routes should therefore be calculated separately first; if there are periods where service was under-reported, an action for determination of insured service should also be considered.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Social Insurance and General Health Insurance Law (Law No. 5510) art. 32/2 (Rights provided by survivors’ insurance and conditions of entitlement) (unofficial translation)

A survivors’ pension shall be granted to the beneficiaries of an insured person who died while;

a) having at least 1800 days of invalidity, old-age and survivors’ insurance premiums reported, or, for those insured under subparagraph (a) of the first paragraph of Article 4, having been insured for at least 5 years excluding all kinds of credited periods and having a total of 900 days of invalidity, old-age and survivors’ insurance premiums reported,

… upon their written request.

Statutory Provision — Social Insurance and General Health Insurance Law (Law No. 5510) art. 96 (Recovery of undue payments) (unofficial translation)

All payments of any kind under this Law made by the Institution to employers, insured persons, voluntarily insured persons, recipients of income or pensions and their beneficiaries, general health insurance holders and their dependants, which are found to have been made in excess or unduly, shall,

a) if they arose from intentional or negligent conduct, for payments made within at most ten years back from the date on which the erroneous act was detected, from the dates of those payments,

b) if they arose from the Institution’s erroneous acts, for the total of payments made within at most five years back from the date on which the erroneous act was detected, without interest for payments made within twenty-four months of notification to the person concerned, and for payments made after the twenty-four-month period, from the end of that period,

… be set off, together with statutory interest, against any receivables of the persons concerned from the Institution, or, if there are none, recovered under the general provisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Under Turkish law, can the 900 days required for a survivors’ pension be completed by crediting military service?

No. In its decision of 18.06.2026, the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held that the phrase “excluding all kinds of credited periods” in Article 32/2-a of Law No. 5510 applies to both the 5-year insurance period and the 900-day premium condition. Credited days may, however, count towards the 1800-day premium condition.

Can the Social Security Institution (SGK) stop a survivors’ pension it granted by its own error?

Yes. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, if the statutory conditions for the survivors’ pension were never met, the Institution is right to stop the pension; the fact that it had been paid for years did not change that result. The beneficiaries’ request to have the pension reinstated must be rejected.

Can survivors’ pensions paid by the SGK’s own error be reclaimed in Türkiye?

They can, but only to the extent of Article 96/1-b of Law No. 5510. Payments made within at most five years back from the detection of the erroneous act are recovered; no interest runs if the debt is paid within twenty-four months of notification, and statutory interest applies from the end of that period to payments made later.

Is the Assembly of Civil Chambers’ survivors’ pension decision No. 2026/386 final?

Yes. The decision was given unanimously and as final on 18.06.2026; the decision to persist was reversed and the file was sent to the Regional Court of Appeal, which will decide again in line with the reversal adopted by the Assembly.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Labor & Social Security Law

All Labor & Social Security Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Court of Cassation: Survivors’ Pension Reached by Crediting Days Is Stopped; Recovery Limited as SGK Error”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-19, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/survivors-pension-900-days-overpayment-sgk-error-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›