Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Fictitious Insurance and Cancellation of Insured Status

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, the essential condition for insured status is genuine (actual) work based on an employment contract; notifications made without actual work and insurance created through fake workplaces are not legally protected (Law No. 5510, Art. 4/1-a). If the Social Security Institution’s audit officers establish that the notifications are not based on genuine work, the Institution cancels the insured status; the records drawn up by those officers are valid until proven otherwise (Law No. 5510, Art. 59). Where a pension has been granted on the basis of the cancelled periods, it is stopped and payments made after the cancellation are reclaimed as undue payments; whether health expenses can be recovered is determined by first investigating whether the work was actual and by taking into account Provisional Article 45 of Law No. 5510. The Institution’s decision can be challenged before the labour court by an action for annulment of the decision and for determination of service (Law No. 5510, Art. 101). Because these cases concern public order, the judge gathers evidence ex officio, and the employer’s acceptance or denial of the work has no effect on its own.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Legal consequences of fictitious/collusive insurance and fake-workplace notifications; the actual-work requirement, the SGK's audit and cancellation powers, pension suspension and recovery of undue payments, competent court, ex officio investigation, and Court of Cassation case-law.

The legal nature of insured notifications not based on genuine work (collusive/fictitious insurance) and registrations through fake workplaces; the actual-work requirement as the foundation of insurance, the Social Security Institution's audit and cancellation powers, the consequences of cancellation (pension suspension, recovery of undue payments), the competent court, proof, ex officio investigation, and Court of Cassation case-law.

The right to social security is the reward for genuine labour. For this reason the legal order does not protect notifications made without actual work — to gain premium days or an insurance start date — nor insurance created through fake workplaces. This article addresses the consequences of fictitious (collusive) insurance, the Institution's cancellation power, and the “actual-work” test applied by the courts.

What Is Fictitious (Collusive) Insurance?

Fictitious insurance is showing a person as insured although no genuine employment relationship exists. It is usually done to retire earlier, complete missing premium days, access general health insurance or obtain crediting rights; sometimes through collusive notifications among relatives, sometimes through “fake workplace” records with no real activity. Under Law No. 5510, a valid employment contract and actual work are, as a rule, required for insurance to arise.

Relevant provision — Law No. 5510, Art. 4/1-a (unofficial translation)

For the purposes of the short- and long-term insurance branches; (a) those employed by one or more employers under an employment contract … are deemed insured.

Foundation of Insurance: the Actual-Work Requirement

According to the settled view of the Court of Cassation, the essential condition for being insured under this Law is genuine (actual) work based on an employment contract. Insured status is acquired only when the work rests on an employment contract, is performed within the employer's work organisation, and the person is not within the exceptions. A worker's failure to notify himself is not evidence against him; conversely, a notification made without actual work is also not protected.

Relevant provision — Law No. 5510, Art. 8 (unofficial translation)

Insured persons notify the Institution that they have started work within at most one month of starting. However, an insured person's failure to notify himself does not constitute evidence against him.

When Does the Institution Cancel Insurance?

The Institution's audit officers (inspectors) conduct on-site audits, examine workplace records and draw up reports. If the notifications are found not to rest on genuine work, the Institution cancels the insurance. The reports drawn up by audit officers are valid until the contrary is proven.

Relevant provision — Law No. 5510, Art. 59 (unofficial translation)

Events giving rise to an Institution claim, and the related transactions, detected by the Institution's audit officers in the course of their duties may be based on any evidence except oath. The reports they draw up are valid until the contrary is proven.

Relevant provision — Law No. 5510, Art. 86 (unofficial translation)

Where, from on-site determinations by the Institution's audit officers …, a person is found to have worked without reliance on records or documents but whose service or earnings were not reported, only the part relating to a period of at most one year back from the date of determination is taken into account.

Consequences: Pension Suspension and Undue Payment

Cancellation is not limited to deleting premium days. If a pension was granted based on the cancelled periods, the pension is suspended and payments made after cancellation are reclaimed as undue payments. Health expenses obtained on the basis of fictitious insurance are likewise pursued for recovery by the Institution; however, whether the Institution is entitled to collect them is determined after first investigating whether the work was actual and having regard to provisional Article 45 of Law No. 5510. In serious cases the conduct may also lead to a separate criminal investigation (forgery of official documents or aggravated fraud causing loss to the Institution).

Parties and Procedure

Against the Institution's cancellation, the insured, beneficiary or employer may sue to annul the transaction and to have the genuine work determined. Conversely, the Institution pursues the undue pension or health expense through enforcement; if the enforcement is opposed, an action to annul the objection arises. As these disputes concern public order, the parties' statements and admissions are not decisive.

Competent Court

The competent court for determination of insurance, annulment of the Institution's transaction and undue-payment disputes is the labour court (Art. 101 of Law 5510); where none exists, the civil court of first instance acts in that capacity. As to the criminal aspect, the criminal courts have separate jurisdiction.

Proof and Ex Officio Investigation

Work may be proved by any evidence; but in these cases the judge is not confined to the parties' evidence and conducts ex officio investigation. Period payrolls, wage records, inspector reports, SGK and tax records are obtained; impartial payroll witnesses from the same and neighbouring workplaces are identified through the police and heard; and whether the number of reported workers is consistent with the workplace's capacity and nature is checked. The employer's admission or denial of the work is not decisive on its own.

Court of Cassation Decisions

Service-determination actions concern public order; the judge gathers evidence ex officio and the burden of proof cannot be placed on one party

Court of Cassation

“… actions for the determination of insured service fall outside the scope of the principle of party presentation; the principle of ex officio investigation applies. Since it is the settled case law of the Court of Cassation that actions concerning the insurance commencement date and the determination of service concern public order and must therefore be conducted with particular sensitivity and care, in service determination actions, which concern public order, the judge must collect the evidence ex officio, showing particular sensitivity, and decide according to the outcome. In these actions, to which the principle of ex officio investigation applies, the burden of proof cannot be placed on one party.” (unofficial translation)

The employer's admission or denial of the work has no legal effect on its own

Court of Cassation

“Moreover, in these actions it must be borne in mind that the employer's admission or denial of the work does not produce a legal result on its own.” (unofficial translation)

Without actual work the pension is cancelled; genuine work must be established by concrete and convincing evidence

Court of Cassation

“The action concerns the payment, from the date on which it was discontinued, of the old-age pension cancelled on the ground that there was no actual employment, and a declaration that the plaintiff is not indebted to the Institution. … by conducting all necessary inquiries and establishing with full clarity whether the fact of actual employment occurred, the disputed matter must be resolved in a manner leaving no room for any doubt or hesitation, and, after all the evidence has been assessed and weighed together, a decision must be rendered according to the result reached.”

Where a fake workplace is alleged, actual work is investigated first; if the work was not actual, the Institution's right to recover health expenses is examined in light of provisional Article 45

Court of Cassation

“… it must first be investigated whether the employment was actual and, if the employment was not actual, a decision must be rendered according to the result after examining whether the plaintiff Institution has a right of recovery in respect of health expenses, having regard to the content of the decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation dated 12.03.2019, numbered 2015/10-2743 E., 2019/275 K., and to provisional Article 45 of Law No. 5510.” (unofficial translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

My insurance was paid although I did not actually work; is it valid?

No. The essential condition of insurance is genuine (actual) work. A notification without work is not protected and may be cancelled by the Institution.

An SGK inspector drew up a report; can I challenge it?

Yes. Audit officers' reports are valid until the contrary is proven; you may prove otherwise by any evidence before the labour court.

My employer admits I worked; is that enough on its own?

No. According to the Court of Cassation, the employer's admission or denial of the work is not decisive on its own; the court investigates ex officio.

What happens to my pension if my insurance is cancelled?

The pension based on cancelled periods is suspended; pensions paid after cancellation and health expenses obtained may be reclaimed as undue payments.

I was shown as collusively insured with a relative; what is my risk?

Notifications among relatives not based on genuine work are deemed collusive; cancellation, undue-payment recovery and, depending on the case, criminal liability may arise.

My insurance was cancelled although I genuinely worked; what can I do?

You may sue in the labour court to annul the Institution's transaction and to determine the service, proving your actual work with payroll witnesses and records.

Çapar Law Office handles determination of insurance, objections to the Institution's cancellation transactions and undue-payment disputes within Labour & Social Security Law.

Related Articles

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Labor & Social Security Law

All Labor & Social Security Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Fictitious Insurance and Cancellation of Insured Status”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/fictitious-insurance-cancellation-insured-status

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›