Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Seller at Gross Fault Loses 2-Year Defect Limitation: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, actions arising from a defect in the thing sold are, as a rule, time-barred two years after the thing sold is transferred to the buyer; a seller at gross fault in transferring the thing sold in a defective state cannot, however, benefit from this period (Code of Obligations art. 231). In its decision of 20.12.2022, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation treated the seller as being at gross fault within the meaning of Code of Obligations art. 225/1 in a case where devices bought in a commercial sale kept breaking down and the seller’s service carried out repairs and replaced devices. It did not treat as time-barred an action filed more than two years after the devices, or their replacements, were delivered, and it accepted that the buyer could withdraw from the contract and recover the price paid. The decision was unanimous; the file was sent to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation for the appeal objections on the merits and the amount.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation unanimously held that a seller whose devices, bought in a commercial sale, kept breaking down was at gross fault within the meaning of Code of Obligations art. 225/1, that the two-year limitation period in Code of Obligations art. 231 had not expired, and that the buyer could withdraw from the contract and recover the price.

In an action over machines that kept breaking down, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation held that the seller was at gross fault within the meaning of art. 225(1), that the two-year limitation period in Code of Obligations art. 231 had not expired, and sent the objections on the merits back to the Chamber.

The Dispute

The claimant company bought an IPL hair-removal device, a slimming device and a face and body care device. One defendant company issued the invoice and the other delivered the devices. Two devices were delivered on 18.02.2011 and the slimming device in June 2012. Because of failures, one device was replaced with a new one on 20.01.2012 and the IPL device on 21.11.2012. According to the expert report, the devices broke down repeatedly from 2012 until mid-2014, and service forms were drawn up.

After a service report dated 11.10.2014 stating that the problem originated in the devices, the claimant withdrew from the contract by a formal notice, declaring that it was ready to return the devices. In the action it filed on 12.05.2015, the claimant sought the price it had paid, against return of the devices, and TRY 10,000 in pecuniary damages; it argued that the seller’s side had kept stalling it and that relying on the limitation defence was contrary to good faith.

The commercial court of first instance found that the defects were latent and had been notified in time, ordered reimbursement of the price and rejected the claim for pecuniary damages. The regional court of appeal dismissed the action against the second defendant, which was found to be only an authorised service, for lack of standing, and partly accepted the action against the seller company. The former 19th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (since abolished) reversed that judgment, stating that art. 231/1 of the Code of Obligations applied to the commercial sale and that the two-year period had expired when counted from the second delivery dates of the machines. Partly repeating its earlier reasoning and stating that the buyer’s right of defence arising from a defect notified within two years does not lapse upon the expiry of that period, the regional court of appeal resisted.

Outcome of the Decision

On 20.12.2022 the Assembly of Civil Chambers found the resistance justified. Because the appeal objections on the merits and on the amount awarded had not been examined by the Chamber, it sent the file to the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation for those objections to be examined. The decision was unanimous and final.

Reasoning

The Assembly first set out the scope of gross fault:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“The notion of gross fault consists of intent and gross negligence. By interpreting the concept of gross fault, fraud may also be included within this scope. It is sufficient that the fraud or, from a broader perspective, the fault is aimed at preventing the buyer from giving notice. … Art. 225/1 of the Code of Obligations can also be applied to commercial sale contracts within the scope of art. 23 of the Turkish Commercial Code.”

In the present case it derived gross fault from the facts in the file:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“According to the contents of the file, since the failure of the devices sold between the parties recurred continuously in a manner that the claimant could not be expected to accept, the defendant seller’s authorised service carried out fault detection, repairs and parts replacements and even replacement of the machines, the failures were of a kind that would emerge as the devices operated, the defendant was at gross fault within the meaning of art. 225/1 of the Code of Obligations, and the defendant seller at gross fault cannot escape liability, even in part, by asserting that the defect in the thing sold was not notified to it in time, it has been concluded that the action must be accepted as filed within the limitation period and that the claimant company has the right, among the elective rights regulated in art. 227 of the Code of Obligations, to terminate the contract and claim reimbursement of the price it paid.”

It stated its conclusion as follows:

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“That being so, the decision to resist, rendered by the regional court of appeal on the basis that in the present case the defendant seller was at gross fault under art. 225 of the Code of Obligations and that therefore the two-year limitation period set out in art. 231 of the Code of Obligations had not expired, is correct.”

Significance and Practical Impact

The decision shows that the two-year limitation period is not a defence that works in every case for a seller of defective goods. The Assembly stated that gross fault consists of intent and gross negligence and that fraud may also be included; with regard to Code of Obligations art. 225/1, which governs the defence that the defect was not notified in time, it added that grossly faulty conduct aimed at preventing the buyer from giving notice may also fall within that exception. It accepted that, by reference from Turkish Commercial Code art. 23, Code of Obligations art. 225/1 can also be applied to commercial sales.

The Assembly reached its finding of gross fault from the records in the file: the expert report, the service forms, the repairs, parts replacements and device replacements carried out by the seller’s service, and the e-mail correspondence. It also found that the seller had acknowledged that the devices were defective and provided continuous service.

Note: art. 231/2 requires the seller to have been at gross fault in transferring the thing sold in a defective state. The Assembly, however, established gross fault within the meaning of art. 225/1 and concluded that the two-year period had not expired; it did not separately discuss the element in art. 231/2 or which period runs in case of gross fault. Gross fault is an exception: in a later decision, where gross fault in transferring the thing sold had not been proved, the Assembly accepted that the two-year period had expired (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2024/135, K. 2024/185, 17.04.2024).

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 231 (Limitation)

“Unless the seller has undertaken liability for a longer period, all actions concerning liability arising from a defect in the thing sold are time-barred two years after the transfer of the thing sold to the buyer, even if the defect comes to light later. The buyer’s right of defence arising from a defect that it notified within two years of the transfer of the thing sold to it does not lapse upon the expiry of this period.

If the seller was at gross fault in transferring the thing sold in a defective state, it cannot benefit from the two-year limitation period.”

Statutory Provision — Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 225 (Consequences of the seller’s gross fault)

“A seller at gross fault cannot escape liability, even in part, by asserting that the defect in the thing sold was not notified to it in time.

The same rule applies to defects that persons who sell as a profession ought to know.”

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a buyer have to sue over defective goods?

Under Code of Obligations art. 231/1, every action arising from a defect in the thing sold is time-barred two years after the thing sold is transferred to the buyer, even if the defect comes to light later. If the seller has undertaken a longer period, that period applies.

Does the two-year period apply if the seller is at gross fault?

No. Under art. 231/2, a seller at gross fault in transferring the thing sold in a defective state cannot benefit from the two-year period. In this decision the Assembly of Civil Chambers did not treat as time-barred an action filed more than two years after the devices were delivered or replaced.

What does gross fault mean?

According to the Assembly, gross fault consists of intent and gross negligence; fraud may also be included. The Assembly stated that grossly faulty conduct aimed at preventing the buyer from notifying the defect may also fall within the exception in Code of Obligations art. 225/1.

Does the buyer lose its rights if the defect was not notified in time?

As a rule, the buyer must notify the defect in time (Code of Obligations art. 223; in commercial sales, Commercial Code art. 23/1-c). A seller at gross fault, however, cannot escape liability by asserting that the defect was not notified in time (Code of Obligations art. 225/1).

Which right did the buyer use in this case?

Among the elective rights in Code of Obligations art. 227, the buyer chose to withdraw from the contract and claimed the price it had paid, against return of the devices; the Assembly accepted that it had this right.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Contract Law

All Contract Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Seller at Gross Fault Loses 2-Year Defect Limitation: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/seller-gross-fault-two-year-limitation-defective-goods

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›