Last reviewed:
Legal Effect of an Invoice in Turkish Commercial Matters: Eight-Day Objection, Commercial Books, Delivery Note
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, a person who receives an invoice in a commercial matter and does not object to its content within eight days of receipt is deemed to have accepted that content (TCC Art. 21/2). This acceptance is limited to the ordinary entries relating to performance of the contract, such as the type of goods sold or the quantity, type and price of the work done; an entry for a late-payment charge that has no basis in the contract or in commercial custom is not deemed accepted merely because no objection was made. According to the Court of Cassation, failing to object makes the content of the invoice final, but the existence of the contractual relationship must still be proved by written evidence. If the invoice has been entered in the other party’s commercial books, Code of Civil Procedure Art. 222 applies and the recorded invoice also proves the contractual relationship; actual delivery of the goods is usually proved by a signed delivery note.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
The legal effect of an invoice in commercial matters: the consequence of not objecting within eight days (the acceptance presumption in TCC Art. 21/2), whether an invoice alone proves the contractual relationship, the comparison with proof by commercial books (Code of Civil Procedure Art. 222), proof of delivery via the delivery note, a warning on fake/fraudulent invoices and subsequent return invoices, the competent commercial court, and Court of Cassation decisions.
The legal effect of an invoice in commercial matters — the consequence of not objecting to an invoice within eight days (the acceptance presumption in TCC Art. 21/2), whether an invoice alone proves the contractual relationship, the comparison with proof by commercial books (Art. 222), proof of delivery via the delivery note, a warning on fake/fraudulent invoices and subsequent return invoices, the competent court, and Court of Cassation decisions.
In commercial life an invoice is both an accounting/tax document and an important piece of evidence in proving a receivable. Yet the legal effect of an invoice operates more subtly than many assume: although failing to object to an invoice in time produces certain consequences, an invoice does not always, on its own, prove that a contractual relationship exists between the parties. This article examines the effect of an invoice around the eight-day objection presumption, the comparison with proof by commercial books, proof of delivery via the delivery note, and the risk of fake/fraudulent invoices, in the light of verified Court of Cassation decisions.
What Is an Invoice and When Is It Issued?
An invoice is a commercial document issued to show the amount the customer owes in return for goods sold or work performed. The Turkish Commercial Code provides that a merchant who sells goods or performs work within its commercial enterprise must give an invoice upon the other party's request. As a matter of tax legislation, an invoice must be issued within a certain period from the delivery of the goods or the performance of the service.
“(1) The other party may request, from a merchant who within its commercial enterprise has sold goods, produced, performed work or provided a benefit, that an invoice be given and, if the price has been paid, that this too be shown on the invoice. (2) A person receiving an invoice who does not object to its content within eight days of receipt is deemed to have accepted that content. (3) A person who receives a letter confirming the content of declarations made under contracts concluded by telephone, telegraph, any communication or information device or other technical means, or orally, and who does not object within eight days of receipt, is deemed to have accepted that the confirmation letter conforms to the contract or declarations.”
The Eight-Day Objection and Acceptance Presumption (Art. 21/2)
A person who receives an invoice and does not object to its content within eight days of receipt is deemed to have accepted that content. The acceptance here concerns the invoice's ordinary content, that is, entries relating to the performance of the contract (for example, the type of goods sold or the quantity, kind and price of the work done). Thus such entries in an invoice not objected to in time create a presumption against the recipient. Entries that were not agreed in the contract but were added to the invoice afterwards and make the other party's position more onerous are not deemed accepted merely because no objection was raised. However, the eight-day presumption is not a magic rule that proves everything; in particular, whether a genuine contractual relationship exists between the parties is a separate matter.
Under Turkish law, the Court of Cassation's Assembly of Civil Chambers for the Unification of Judgments held that, where the parties have no written agreement or commercial custom on a late-payment charge (vade farkı), failing to object within eight days to such an entry written on the invoice only makes the invoice content final; it does not mean that the late-payment charge has been accepted. The decision was given under Art. 23/2 of the former Turkish Commercial Code; the same rule now appears in Art. 21/2 of TCC No. 6102.
“In conclusion, since the invoice relates to the performance stage of the contract, the invoice content deemed accepted under Art. 23/2 of the TCC through failure to object in time can relate only to matters such as the type of goods sold or the quantity, kind and price of the work done, which are ordinarily included in an invoice in connection with the performance stage of the contract. Failure to object to an entry stating that a late-payment charge will be applied in case of delay does not mean that an entry which, although included in the invoice, concerns a matter not regulated in the contract between the parties has also been accepted.”
Does an Invoice Alone Prove the Contractual Relationship?
According to the settled approach of the Court of Cassation, failing to object to an invoice in time finalises its content; but the existence of the contractual relationship must be proven separately by written or conclusive evidence. There is an important exception: if the invoice has been entered in the other party's commercial books, the issue is no longer merely the evidential value of the invoice but that of the commercial books (Art. 222). In that case the invoice entered in the books also proves the existence of the contractual relationship, and the party claiming not to have received goods/services must prove this by written/conclusive evidence.
The Comparison with Proof by Commercial Books (Art. 222)
Being evidence as an invoice and being evidence as commercial books are different things. Commercial books can be evidence in favour of their owner only when kept in accordance with the law (fully, with opening/closing approvals, entries corroborating one another); books kept improperly are evidence against their owner. The favourable and unfavourable entries cannot be separated.
“(1) In commercial cases the court may, of its own motion or upon a party's request, order the production of the parties' commercial books. (2) For commercial books to be admissible as evidence in commercial cases, they must have been kept fully and properly in accordance with the law, their opening and closing approvals must have been obtained, and their entries must corroborate one another. (3) For the entries in commercial books kept in accordance with the conditions set out in the second paragraph to be admissible as evidence in favour of their owner and successors, the entries in the other party's commercial books kept under the same conditions must not be contrary to them, or the other party must fail to produce its commercial books, or the contrary of the entries must not have been proven by deed or other conclusive evidence. Where the other party's commercial books kept in accordance with the conditions set out in the second paragraph contain no entry on the matter concerned, the commercial books cannot be used as evidence in favour of their owner. The entries in favour of and against the owner in books kept in accordance with these conditions cannot be separated from one another. (4) Commercial-book entries lacking opening or closing approvals and whose entries do not corroborate one another constitute evidence against their owner.”
The Delivery Note and Proof of Delivery
Although an invoice is a document concerning the amount of the receivable, it does not always, on its own, show that the goods were actually delivered. The dispatch/delivery note, and especially a delivery note signed by the buyer's authorised person, is important in proving delivery. In practice, in disputes over invoice-based receivables courts evaluate the signed delivery note, the delivery-receipt record, transport documents and commercial-book entries together. Keeping the delivery note signed is therefore strong evidence against a later defence that “the goods were not received”.
Fake/Fraudulent Invoices and Subsequent Return Invoices: a Warning
The evidential force of an invoice means something only where the invoice rests on a genuine transaction. Invoices not based on a real flow of goods/services (fake), or whose content does not reflect reality (misleading in content), produce serious consequences in both tax law and criminal law. A scenario frequently seen in practice is the attempt to wipe out the debt in an invoice that became final by not being objected to and was entered in the books, by means of a “return invoice” issued afterwards although there is no genuine return. Such fraudulent return invoices are a separate and serious matter in terms of proof and criminal liability; for details see our article Fraudulent Return Invoice.
Competent Court
Under Turkish law, the fact that the invoice is regulated in the Turkish Commercial Code does not by itself make a dispute over a receivable based on it an absolute commercial case. Where the dispute concerns the commercial enterprises of both parties, it is a commercial case (Turkish Commercial Code Art. 4(1)) and the competent court is the commercial court of first instance (where there is none, the civil court of first instance acting as such). The Court of Cassation has held that a dispute over the collection of invoices issued by a claimant who is not a merchant is not a commercial case and must be resolved by the general courts (Court of Cassation, 20th Civil Chamber, 2016/6760 E., 2016/8201 K., 03.10.2016). Where the dispute arises from an objection to an enforcement proceeding, the path of an action for annulment of the objection is taken; the examination of the parties' commercial books is often decisive.
Court of Cassation Decisions
Failure to object to an invoice finalises its content; an invoice entered in the books also proves the contractual relationship
“Being evidence as an invoice and being evidence as commercial books are different from one another. Under Art. 21/2 of TCC No. 6102, where no objection is made to an invoice its content becomes final, yet the contractual relationship must be proven by written evidence. If the invoice has been entered in the commercial books, one must look not to this provision on the invoice as evidence but to Article 222 on commercial books as evidence. … an invoice entered in the commercial books also proves the existence of the contractual relationship. A person who, after receiving the invoice, neither objects nor returns it within the period and enters it in their commercial books is deemed to have accepted that the invoice was issued under a valid contractual relationship for goods or services received.” (unofficial translation)
An invoice that became final unobjected and was entered in the books cannot be undone by a later return invoice
“A person who receives an invoice and does not raise any objection to its content within eight days of receipt is deemed to have accepted that content (TCC 21/2). Subsequently issuing a return invoice in respect of the receivable under an invoice that has become final through the absence of a timely objection and has also been entered in the commercial books is not a valid means of escaping the debt or of rendering the receivable disputed. Issuing a return invoice after the objection period has expired will not have the effect of extinguishing the receivable.”
If the sales invoice is recorded in the buyer's commercial books, receipt of the goods is accepted; the book entry operates against its owner
“… In a sale relationship, delivery of the goods must be proven by the plaintiff. The defendant argued in its defence that it had issued a return invoice; on examination, it was established that the sales invoice was recorded in the defendant's books. In that case it must be accepted that the goods were received by the defendant. The court erred in allocating the burden of proof, and ruling as written was not correct …” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
If I do not object to an invoice within eight days, do I become liable?
If you do not object within eight days, you are deemed to accept the invoice's ordinary content, that is, entries relating to performance such as the type, quantity and price of the goods. A late-payment charge entry with no basis in your contract or in commercial custom, however, is not deemed accepted merely because you did not object (Court of Cassation, Unification of Judgments, 2003/1 K.). Moreover, not objecting does not, on its own, prove that a contract truly exists between the parties; the other side must separately prove the contractual relationship.
Does an invoice alone prove the receivable?
As a rule, no. According to the Court of Cassation, not objecting finalises the content, but the contractual relationship must be proven by written/conclusive evidence. If the invoice was entered in the other party's commercial books, the booked invoice also proves the contractual relationship.
I entered the invoice in my books without objecting; can I later say I received no goods?
In that case the burden of proof shifts to you. If you did not object/return the invoice in time and entered it in your books, you must prove by written or conclusive evidence that you received no goods/services or owe no debt.
Why is the delivery note important?
The invoice shows the amount; actual delivery is usually proven by a signed dispatch/delivery note. A signed delivery note is strong evidence against a later “goods not received” defence.
Will my commercial book be evidence in my favour?
Only if it was kept in accordance with the law (fully, with opening/closing approvals, entries corroborating one another) and is not contrary to the other party's properly kept book. A book kept improperly is evidence against you.
Which court has jurisdiction in an invoice dispute?
Where the dispute concerns the commercial enterprises of both parties, it is a commercial case and the commercial court of first instance has jurisdiction (Turkish Commercial Code Art. 4(1)); the fact that the invoice is regulated in the Turkish Commercial Code does not by itself make the case commercial. Expert examination of the parties' commercial books is often decisive.
Çapar Law Office pursues actions for annulment of objection and debt claims based on invoices/commercial receivables within Commercial & Company Law.
- The Fraudulent Return Invoice: Does It Extinguish the Debt? (Proof and the Tax-Criminal Dimension)
- The Evidential Nature of Commercial Books (CCP Art. 222): Evidence For and Against the Owner
- Unfair Competition Actions: Acts of Unfair Competition, Claims, Competent Court and Limitation (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 54-62)
- Transfer of a Commercial Enterprise: The Principle of Integrity, Registration and Liability for Debts (Turkish Commercial Code art. 11, Code of Obligations art. 202)
Related Articles
- The Fraudulent Return Invoice: Does It Extinguish the Debt? (Proof and the Tax-Criminal Dimension)
- The Evidential Nature of Commercial Books (CCP Art. 222): Evidence For and Against the Owner
- Validity Requirements of a Promissory Note (Bono) under Turkish Law: Mandatory Elements, Missing Elements and Limitation Periods
- Unfair Competition Actions: Acts of Unfair Competition, Claims, Competent Court and Limitation (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 54-62)
- Transfer of a Commercial Enterprise: The Principle of Integrity, Registration and Liability for Debts (Turkish Commercial Code art. 11, Code of Obligations art. 202)
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Commercial law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law
- When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye
- Appeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative Court
- Which Court Hears Commercial and Consumer Cases in Türkiye: Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya
- Arbitration Clauses under Turkish Law: Validity, the Arbitration Objection and Lawsuits Filed in Court
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Legal Effect of an Invoice in Turkish Commercial Matters: Eight-Day Objection, Commercial Books, Delivery Note”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/legal-effect-invoice-commercial-matters

























