Last reviewed:
The Fraudulent Return Invoice: Does It Extinguish the Debt? (Proof and the Tax-Criminal Dimension)
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, a return invoice not based on a genuine return of goods does not extinguish the debt, and the party claiming that the debt ended by return must prove that the goods were actually redelivered. According to the Court of Cassation, a return invoice does not by itself prove the return, even if it has been entered in the issuer’s own commercial books, and a receivable in an invoice that became final without a timely objection and was entered in the commercial books cannot be eliminated by a return invoice issued later. A genuine return is proven by a signed return delivery note, delivery and receipt documents, transport records and consistent commercial book entries kept in accordance with the law (CCP Art. 222). A return invoice not based on a genuine transaction may be treated as a fake or misleading document for tax purposes, which may lead to the smuggling offence under Tax Procedure Code Art. 359, a tax-loss penalty and a penalised assessment. The commercial court is competent for the receivable dispute.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
The fraudulent (sham) return invoice: a return invoice not based on a genuine return does not extinguish the debt; a return invoice alone does not prove the return; a genuine return must be proven by a signed return delivery note and commercial books (CCP Art. 222); the fake/misleading-document dimension (Tax Procedure Code Art. 359, smuggling offence), tax-loss penalty, the competent commercial court, and Court of Cassation decisions.
The fraudulent (sham) return invoice — a return invoice not based on a genuine return does not extinguish the debt; a return invoice alone does not prove the return; how a genuine return is proven (return delivery note, actual delivery, commercial books — Art. 222); the fake/misleading-document dimension (Tax Procedure Code Art. 359) and the tax-criminal consequences, with Court of Cassation decisions.
A return invoice is a document that wholly or partly reverses an initial sale where the buyer returns goods to the seller. In practice, however, this document is sometimes abused: although there is no genuine return of goods, a fraudulent (sham) return invoice is issued merely to wipe out a debt, reduce a receivable or lower the tax base. This article examines, in the light of verified Court of Cassation decisions, whether a return invoice not based on reality extinguishes the debt, how a genuine return is proven, and the tax-criminal consequences arising from the fake/misleading nature of the document. For the general effect of an invoice see also our article The Legal Effect of an Invoice in Commercial Matters.
What Are a Return Invoice and a Fraudulent Return Invoice?
A genuine return invoice rests on goods actually returned and is supported by the return delivery note/delivery documents evidencing that return. A fraudulent return invoice, by contrast, is a document existing only on paper, issued although there is no real movement of goods (return). A frequent scenario is the attempt to close out the debt in a sales invoice that became final unobjected and was entered in the commercial books, by means of a “return invoice” issued later when there is no genuine return.
Does a Fraudulent Return Invoice Extinguish the Debt?
No. The party claiming that a debt has been extinguished by return must prove the existence of a genuine return (actual re-delivery). The mere issuance of a return invoice does not show that the goods were truly returned; according to the Court of Cassation decisions set out below, a return invoice does not by itself prove the return, even if it has been entered in the issuer's own commercial books, and a court may not accept the return on the basis of the return invoice alone. A party raising a “the goods were returned” defence against a receivable in a finalised, booked invoice must prove that return by a signed return delivery note, a delivery-receipt document or other proper evidence. Otherwise the debt survives.
How Is a Genuine Return Proven?
Proof of a genuine return rests on documents showing the goods were actually re-delivered: the return/dispatch delivery note, delivery documents signed by the authorised person of the buyer or seller, transport records, and commercial-book entries consistent with them. In commercial cases the court may order production of the parties' commercial books; their evidential value depends on whether they were kept in accordance with the law (fully, with approvals, entries corroborating one another).
“(1) In commercial cases the court may, of its own motion or upon a party's request, order the production of the parties' commercial books. (2) For commercial books to be admissible as evidence in commercial cases, they must have been kept fully and properly in accordance with the law, their opening and closing approvals obtained, and the entries must corroborate one another. … (4) Commercial-book records lacking opening or closing approvals and whose entries do not corroborate one another constitute evidence against their owner.”
The Tax-Criminal Dimension: Fake/Misleading Document (Art. 359)
The fraudulent return invoice has not only a private-law (receivable) dimension. A document issued without a genuine transaction may, in tax law, be a fake document; where a transaction exists but the content does not reflect reality, the document may be misleading in content. Issuing or using such documents may constitute an offence requiring imprisonment under Article 359 of the Tax Procedure Code (which governs smuggling offences), and also gives rise to a tax-loss penalty and penalised assessment (retrospective tax and penalty). Where the document is used to deceive a specific person, depending on the facts a discussion of fraud or document forgery under the Criminal Code may also arise. A “let us issue a return invoice to close the debt” solution therefore often turns into a far heavier legal and criminal risk.
Note: the offence types and penalty amounts in Tax Procedure Code Art. 359 have changed over time; the penalty and periods to be applied in a concrete file must be assessed separately, taking the date of the act and the current text as the basis.
Competent Court
Because a receivable/debt dispute based on a return invoice is commercial in nature, the competent court for the private-law side is the commercial court of first instance. The tax-offence dimension concerning the document's falsity is the subject of separate criminal proceedings (criminal court of first instance) and of the tax administration/administrative-judicial process.
Court of Cassation Decisions
A return invoice not recorded in the seller's books does not by itself prove the return, even if entered in the buyer's own books; without proof of the return it cannot be deducted from the debt
“… The invoices in dispute are recorded in the parties' books and there is no dispute as to the purchase of the goods. The dispute arises from the return invoice of 11,357.36 TL submitted to the file by the defendant. Since that return invoice is not recorded in the plaintiff's books, the return must be proven by the defendant with proper evidence. The fact that the return invoice is recorded in the defendant's books is not by itself sufficient to prove the validity of the return. The entries in the commercial books must also be corroborated by supporting documents. Ruling as written, accepting that the goods had been returned without taking this into account, was not found correct.” (unofficial translation)
A receivable in an invoice finalised unobjected and entered in the books cannot be questioned by a later return invoice
“A person who receives an invoice is deemed to have accepted its content if he does not raise an objection to the content of the invoice within eight days from the date of receipt (Turkish Commercial Code art. 21/2). Subsequently issuing a return invoice in respect of the receivable in an invoice that has become final because it was not objected to in time and that has also been entered in the commercial books is not a valid instrument for being released from the debt and rendering the receivable disputed. Issuing a return invoice after the objection period has expired will not have the effect of eliminating the existence of the receivable.”
The buyer asserting a return must prove it; the court may not decide solely on the basis of the return invoice
“… The defendant must prove that it returned the goods covered by the invoice to the seller company. … In that case, the court should have asked the defendant for its evidence to prove the return, collected it and decided according to the result; ruling solely on the basis of the return invoice was not found correct.” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
Does issuing a return invoice automatically erase my debt?
No. The party claiming the debt ended by return must prove that the goods were truly returned (actual delivery). Merely issuing a return invoice is not enough; per the Court of Cassation a return invoice alone does not prove the return, and a court may not accept the return on the basis of the return invoice alone.
How do I prove a genuine return?
By a signed return/dispatch delivery note, delivery-receipt documents, transport records, and properly kept commercial-book entries consistent with them. The Court of Cassation requires the return to be proven by proper evidence; the mere entry of the return invoice in the issuer's own books is not sufficient.
Is there a penalty for issuing a return invoice that is not genuine?
There may be. A document not based on reality may be deemed fake or misleading in content; this may constitute a smuggling offence requiring imprisonment under Tax Procedure Code Art. 359, and gives rise to a tax-loss penalty and penalised assessment.
The other side says it closed its debt with a return invoice; what should I do?
You may assert the invalidity of a return invoice not based on a genuine return; demand from the other side the signed documents showing actual delivery; and request examination of the commercial books and, if necessary, of the document's falsity.
Which court hears this dispute?
Because the receivable/debt side is a commercial case, the commercial court of first instance has jurisdiction. The tax offence concerning the document's falsity is the subject of separate criminal proceedings.
Çapar Law Office advises and litigates on receivable and document disputes arising from fraudulent/sham return invoices within Commercial & Company Law and Criminal Law.
Related Articles
- The Legal Effect of an Invoice in Commercial Matters: The Eight-Day Objection, Commercial Books and the Delivery Note
- The Evidential Nature of Commercial Books (CCP Art. 222): Evidence For and Against the Owner
- Bad (Dishonoured) Cheques and Criminal Liability
- Additional Customs Assessment and Penalty (VEZA) Decisions: Objection and Grounds for Annulment
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Commercial law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Commercial & Corporate Law
- When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye
- Appeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative Court
- Which Court Hears Commercial and Consumer Cases in Türkiye: Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya
- Arbitration Clauses under Turkish Law: Validity, the Arbitration Objection and Lawsuits Filed in Court
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “The Fraudulent Return Invoice: Does It Extinguish the Debt? (Proof and the Tax-Criminal Dimension)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/fraudulent-return-invoice

























