Last reviewed:
Additional Customs Assessment and Penalty (VEZA) Decisions: Objection and Grounds for Annulment
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, where post-clearance control shows that customs duties were not collected or were under-collected, the customs administration demands the difference by additional assessment and usually imposes an administrative fine; as the two decisions are notified together, in practice they are called a VEZA (tax and penalty) decision. No action can be brought directly against this decision: an administrative objection must first be filed within fifteen days of notification under CL Art. 242, and after the objection is rejected the action for annulment is brought in the tax court within thirty days (Administrative Judicial Procedure Law Art. 7). Settlement may also be requested within fifteen days of notification, and the request suspends the periods for objection and action (CL Art. 244). The principal grounds for annulment are failure to notify the additional assessment within three years of the date on which the customs obligation arose (CL Art. 197/2), defective notification, determination of the customs value contrary to the methods in CL Arts. 23-31 and non-fulfilment of the conditions for the fine. Because a declaration made without reservation binds the obligor, the merits of an assessment based on that declaration cannot, as a rule, be reviewed.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
A comprehensive guide to additional customs assessment and penalty (VEZA) decisions: what additional assessment is and how it arises (post-clearance control; differences in customs value, tariff and origin); the accompanying administrative fines (Customs Law Art. 234 — three times the tax difference, Art. 238 — the customs-cleared value penalty); notification of the assessment, the three-year time bar and finality (CL Art. 197); the administrative objection (CL Art. 242, fifteen days — a precondition of the action); settlement (CL Art. 244, fifteen days, suspending the objection/action periods); the action for annulment and the competent court (tax court, 7th Chamber of the Council of State); the principal grounds for annulling an additional-assessment and penalty decision (time bar, defective notification, incorrect determination of customs value, reservation and the binding nature of the declaration, non-fulfilment of penalty conditions, the objection precondition); time limits; decisions of the 7th Chamber of the Council of State.
A guide to additional customs assessment and penalty (VEZA) decisions; what additional assessment is and how it arises (post-clearance control; differences in customs value/tariff/origin), the accompanying fines (CL Art. 234 — three times the tax difference, Art. 238 — the customs-cleared value penalty), notification, the three-year time bar and finality (CL Art. 197), the administrative objection (CL Art. 242 — fifteen days, a precondition of the action), settlement (CL Art. 244 — fifteen days, suspending the periods), the action for annulment and the competent court (tax court, 7th Chamber of the Council of State), the principal grounds for annulment and the time limits, with decisions of the 7th Chamber of the Council of State.
On importation, customs duties are, as a rule, assessed on the basis of the obligor's declaration and the goods are released. However, if in post-clearance control the customs administration finds that duties were not collected at all or under-collected, it demands the difference by way of additional assessment and usually adds an administrative fine. As these two decisions are notified together, in practice they are called an “additional assessment and penalty decision” or, in short, a VEZA (tax and penalty) decision. This article examines how the additional assessment arises, which fines accompany it, notification and the time bar, the objection and settlement routes, the action for annulment and, most importantly, the principal grounds for annulling an additional-assessment and penalty decision in the light of decisions of the 7th Chamber of the Council of State.
What Is an Additional Customs Assessment and Penalty (VEZA) Decision?
An additional assessment is the customs administration's subsequent calculation and notification of customs duties not collected or under-collected on the original declaration. A penalty decision is the administrative fine provided for in the Customs Law in respect of the act that caused the loss of duty. When notified together, the obligor has three options: to object (CL Art. 242), to request settlement (CL Art. 244), or to let the decision become final. Determining the correct route and the time limits at the outset prevents loss of rights.
The legal basis of additional assessment is Article 197 of the Customs Law, which regulates the assessment and notification of customs duties.
“1. Customs duties are notified to the obligor immediately after assessment. 2. Notification of customs duties found, upon inspections, not to have been collected at all or to have been under-collected, or which could not be notified as set out in paragraph 1, is made within three years of the date on which the customs obligation arose. Provided that the bringing of an action in relation to the event giving rise to the customs obligation suspends the time bar.”
How Does Additional Assessment Arise? (Post-Clearance Control)
Additional assessment mostly arises at the stage of post-clearance control. The principal causes: a customs-value difference (the declared value found to be lower than the value determined under Arts. 23-31 — e.g. declaring below the unit value under a surveillance measure); a tariff/classification difference (declaring the goods under the wrong tariff heading and thus at a lower duty); and an origin difference (withdrawal of preferential-origin/FTA benefit because the origin certificate — e.g. Form A, EUR.1 — turns out to be forged or invalid). In such cases the administration demands the difference by additional assessment and, where the conditions are met, imposes a fine.
Accompanying Fines (CL Arts. 234, 238)
The most frequently applied penalty for acts causing loss of duty is Art. 234: for a difference in tariff elements or in value, a fine of three times the difference between the import duties due and those calculated on the declaration. For breaches of a regime, penalties such as twice the customs-cleared value under Art. 238 come into play.
“Where the declared value of goods subject to import duties on the basis of their value is found to be lower than the value determined under the provisions of Articles 23 to 31, a fine of three times the difference in duty is collected in addition to the import duties on that shortfall.”
“In the event of a breach of the provisions on the inward-processing regime, the processing-under-customs-control regime and the temporary-importation regime, an administrative fine of twice the customs-cleared value of the goods … is imposed.”
Notification, Time Bar and Finality (CL Art. 197)
The additional-assessment and penalty decision is notified to the obligor. What is critical is that notification be made within three years of the date the customs obligation arose (as a rule, the registration of the declaration); this is a time bar. If no objection is raised or no application to the administrative courts is made in time, the decision becomes final on the date the periods expire.
“Customs duties notified under this Article become final on the date the periods expire where no objection is raised within the periods set out in Article 242 or no application is made to the administrative courts in time; where an action is brought, they become collectible on the date the court's decision against the obligor is notified to the customs administration.”
Administrative Objection (CL Art. 242) — Precondition of the Action
An action cannot be brought directly against the additional-assessment and penalty decision; the administrative objection route must first be exhausted. The obligor objects, within fifteen days of notification, by a petition to a higher authority (or, failing one, to the same authority). The objection is decided within thirty days; upon rejection, recourse is had to the administrative court (tax court). Failure to exhaust the objection route leads to dismissal of the action for administrative-remedy jurisdiction / absence of a condition of the action.
“1. Obligors may object, within fifteen days of the date of notification, by a petition to a higher authority (or, failing one, to the same authority), against the customs duties, penalties and administrative decisions notified to them. 2. Objections reaching the administration are decided within thirty days and notified to the person concerned. … 4. Recourse may be had to the administrative courts of the place where the transaction was carried out against decisions rejecting the objection.”
Settlement (CL Art. 244)
The obligor may also request settlement of the additional-assessment and penalty decision. A settlement request is made, for claims not yet objected to or where the objection is not concluded, within fifteen days of notification, and it suspends the objection/action period. If settlement is reached, no action may be brought on the matters settled; if not, the period resumes. Settlement does not apply to acts connected with smuggling offences (Law No. 5607).
“An obligor or the addressee of a penalty may apply for settlement in respect of claims comprised in the additional-assessment and penalty decisions issued by the customs administrations. … The settlement request is made within fifteen days of the date of notification. Where a settlement request is made, the objection or action period is suspended … The taxpayer or the addressee of the penalty may not bring an action, nor complain to any authority, regarding the matters settled and recorded in the minutes.”
Action for Annulment and the Competent Court
Upon rejection of the objection, an action for annulment of the additional-assessment and penalty decision is brought in the tax court. The action must be brought within thirty days of notification of the decision rejecting the objection (Administrative Procedure Law Art. 7). Against the judgments, the appeal (the tax chamber of the regional administrative court) and finally cassation before the 7th Chamber of the Council of State apply. That the Art. 242 objection was duly and timely made is a precondition of the action being heard on the merits.
Grounds for Annulling an Additional-Assessment and Penalty Decision
In practice the grounds most frequently relied on for annulment are:
1) Time bar (three years)
If the additional assessment was not notified within three years of the date the customs obligation arose, it is time-barred and must be annulled (CL Art. 197/2). The date of the obligation is, as a rule, the registration of the declaration; save for the exception of a criminal action having been brought, this period does not extend.
2) Defective or incomplete notification
Notification contrary to the Notification Law, misidentification of the addressee, or failure to state the reasons/basis of the decision are grounds for annulment.
3) Incorrect/irregular determination of customs value
Determining the value without following the sequential methods of Arts. 23-31, on the basis of an insufficient/irregular value inquiry, or where the comparable value does not meet the conditions, vitiates the additional assessment.
4) Reservation and the binding nature of the declaration
A registered declaration is in the nature of an undertaking and binds the obligor. If the obligor did not enter a reservation against matters such as the surveillance value, or did not use the Art. 211 route, the merits of an assessment based on that declaration cannot, as a rule, be reviewed; conversely, a declaration made with a reservation keeps the avenue for seeking one's rights open.
5) Non-fulfilment of the penalty conditions
If the elements underlying the fine have not materialised, the fine is annulled; for example, the Art. 234/1-b fine can be imposed only where there is a shortfall affecting the value of the goods.
6) Procedure regarding the objection precondition
An action brought without exhausting the Art. 242 objection is dismissed on procedural grounds; conversely, where the administration mischaracterises and rejects an objection to a declaration made with a reservation, that rejection may itself be made the subject of an action.
Time Limits
In brief: administrative objection 15 days (from notification), settlement request 15 days (from notification; suspends the objection/action period), action for annulment against the rejection of the objection 30 days (Administrative Procedure Law Art. 7), and a three-year time bar for notification of the additional assessment (CL Art. 197/2). The periods are strict; missing them leads to serious loss of rights.
Decisions of the Council of State
The decisions below concern the exhaustion of the CL Art. 242 objection route before bringing an action against the additional assessment and the function of the reservation, the annulment of an additional assessment made after the three-year time bar had passed, and customs value/surveillance together with the conditions of the Art. 234 fine. Customs-duty disputes are heard in the Council of State by the 7th Chamber. All the decisions were verified in full text from the official case-law database.
Precondition of the action: exhausting the Art. 242 objection and the function of the reservation
“For an action to be brought against customs-duty assessments, recourse must have been had to the administrative-objection route provided for in Article 242 of the Customs Law and that recourse must have been rejected; and for recourse to the objection route to be possible, there must be an additional-assessment transaction made by the administration of its own motion, or an assessment based on a customs declaration made with a reservation. A reservation is characterised, in practice, as an explanation placed on the declaration in order to neutralise the binding nature of the declaration and to reserve the right of recourse to legal remedies, showing that the declaration is not the product of free will.” (unofficial translation)
An additional assessment made after the three-year time bar is annulled
“… whereas the additional-assessment transaction ought to have been notified within the three-year time bar from that date, at the latest by 29/07/2006, the additional assessment was made by the transaction dated 24/02/2011, and as there was no finding that a criminal action had been brought, the additional assessment made after the three-year time bar had passed and the decision rejecting the objection to it were found to be unlawful, and the transaction was annulled.” (unofficial translation)
The binding nature of a declaration made without reservation and the condition of the Art. 234/1-b fine
“In the case at hand, it is clear that this declaration in the nature of an undertaking, which the plaintiff made without manifesting any intention of reservation … by raising the low unit prices in the invoices for the imported goods to the surveillance price, is binding on the plaintiff; … it is not possible to review the lawfulness of the surveillance value declared without reservation. … Article 234(1)(b) of Law No. 4458 regulates the penal sanction to be applied where the value of the goods is under-declared, and since in the case at hand there is no matter affecting the value of the goods, the operative part of the court's judgment dismissing the action with respect to the portion of the administrative fine in the contested act corresponding to the invoice value of the goods must also be reversed.”
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a VEZA decision mean?
In practice the additional assessment (tax) and penalty decision that the customs administration notifies together is called, in short, a “VEZA” (tax and penalty) decision. The under-collected customs duty is demanded by additional assessment, and the related fine is imposed by the penalty decision.
Can I bring an action directly against the additional-assessment and penalty decision?
No. The administrative objection route under CL Art. 242 must first be exhausted within 15 days of notification. Only upon rejection of the objection may an action for annulment be brought in the tax court.
What is the time bar for additional assessment?
The additional assessment must be notified within three years of the date the customs obligation arose (as a rule, the registration of the declaration). An additional assessment notified after that period is time-barred and must be annulled.
What is the relationship between settlement and the action period?
A settlement request is made within 15 days of notification and suspends the objection/action period. If settlement is reached, the matters settled cannot be made the subject of an action; if not, the period resumes.
On what grounds can an additional assessment be annulled?
The principal grounds: the passing of the three-year time bar, defective/incomplete notification, determination of the customs value contrary to the methods of Arts. 23-31, non-fulfilment of the penalty conditions (e.g. Art. 234/1-b), and matters relating to the reservation and the binding nature of the declaration.
In which court are customs disputes heard?
The action for annulment is brought in the tax court; the appeal in the tax chamber of the regional administrative court, and cassation before the 7th Chamber of the Council of State.
Within Customs Law, Çapar Law Office conducts objection, settlement and annulment-action processes against additional-assessment and penalty (VEZA) decisions — including customs-value and time-bar assessments — protecting the obligor's interests.
Related Articles
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- Judicial Review of Disciplinary Penalties
- Unlawfulness and Annulment of Disciplinary Penalties Imposed for Student Cheating
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Customs attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Customs Law
- Unfulfilled Export Commitment under Inward Processing in Türkiye: Duties, Article 238 Customs Fine, Objection
- Foreign-Plated Cars in Türkiye: Exceeding the Time Limit, Temporary Import, Duties, Penalties, Objections
- Tax Cases from Uşak, Afyonkarahisar and Kütahya: Which Court, Time Limits and Appeal in Türkiye
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Additional Customs Assessment and Penalty (VEZA) Decisions: Objection and Grounds for Annulment”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/additional-customs-assessment-penalty-decisions

























