Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 21 min read

Last reviewed:

Unfulfilled Export Commitment under Inward Processing in Türkiye: Duties, Article 238 Customs Fine, Objection

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, in the suspension system of the inward processing regime the duties on imported goods are not collected but secured by collateral; once the goods are exported as processed products within the certificate or permit period, the collateral is returned (Customs Law Art. 108/1). If the export commitment is not fulfilled in time, the commitment is closed with sanctions: the duties on the unexported portion are collected as of the import date under Law No. 6183, and under Customs Law Art. 238 a fine of, as a rule, twice the duty-paid value of the goods is imposed; if the goods have not left customs supervision, the fine is reduced to interest at the late-payment surcharge rate. According to the Council of State, if the collateral is still held by the administration the duties are pursued under Art. 37 of Law No. 6183; if the breach is found after the collateral was returned, the duties are assessed and the fifteen-day objection under Customs Law Art. 242, followed by an action before the administrative courts within thirty days, becomes available (the route of rectification of decision is open in the underlying Assembly decision). The certificate holder may also object to the closure with sanctions before the Ministry of Trade within one month of notification.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law: how duties secured by collateral are collected when the export commitment under an inward processing certificate or permit is not fulfilled in time, the fine under Article 238 of the Customs Law, closing periods and the objection and court route against closure with sanctions, with Council of State decisions.

Under Turkish law: collateral, collection of duties, the fine under Article 238 of the Customs Law, closing periods and the objection and court route when the export commitment under an inward processing authorisation certificate or permit is not fulfilled in time.

The inward processing regime allows an exporter in Türkiye to import raw materials, auxiliary materials or packaging free of duty, or with the duty refunded later, and to export the goods produced from them. The price of this facility is the export commitment recorded in the certificate. If the commitment is not fulfilled in time and in line with the certificate conditions, both duties and an administrative fine arise. Unlike the article Additional Customs Assessment and Penalty (VEZA) Decisions, which covers additional customs assessments and penalties in general, this article deals only with issues specific to inward processing under Turkish law: the collateral, closing periods, closure with sanctions, the fine under Article 238 of the Customs Law and the remedies against them.

What Are the Inward Processing Regime and the Export Commitment?

The statutory basis of the regime is Article 108 of Customs Law No. 4458. The Law provides two systems. Under the suspension system, goods not in free circulation are imported without paying duties, which are secured by collateral; when the goods are exported as processed products, the collateral is returned. Under the drawback system, duties are paid at importation and refunded when the product is exported.

Statutory Provision — Customs Law (Law No. 4458) art. 108/1 (inward processing regime, suspension system, unofficial translation)

“Goods not in free circulation may be temporarily imported under the inward processing regime, without being subject to customs duties and commercial policy measures and with the duties secured by collateral, for the purpose of being re-exported from the Customs Territory of Türkiye after being used in the production of processed products. Where the goods are exported in the form of processed products, the collateral is returned. Benefiting from the inward processing regime in this way is called the suspension system.”

The details are governed by the Inward Processing Regime Communiqué (Export: 2006/12). Under Communiqué Art. 1, the Communiqué was prepared on the basis of the Inward Processing Regime Decision annexed to Council of Ministers Decision No. 2005/8391. Communiqué Art. 3 distinguishes two instruments: the inward processing authorisation certificate issued by the Ministry of Trade and the inward processing permit granted by the customs administration. Which one is used matters, because the authority to which the closing application is made and the route of objection to closure with sanctions differ accordingly. Under Communiqué Art. 8, in the suspension system the duty arising from importation is subject to collateral under Law No. 6183 on the Procedure for the Collection of Public Receivables. This collateral also determines which procedure later applies to the pursuit of the duties.

One further point matters: under Communiqué Art. 7/5, if goods sourced domestically under the certificate are not exported in time, the Article 238 fine does not apply. The fine concerns imported goods.

Certificate Period, Extensions and Closing the Commitment

Under Communiqué Art. 20, the period of the certificate or permit may be set at up to 12 months depending on the sector. The period ends on the last day of the month in which it expires, including extensions.

Extensions. Under Communiqué Arts. 21 and 22, the certificate period is extended by up to three months based on the date of first importation. If the exports made reach at least 25% of the commitment, an extension of half the original period may be granted. These applications are made electronically to the Ministry within three months of the end of the certificate period; an application not made in time is not considered. The same period and consequence apply to justified-reason (Art. 23) and force majeure (Art. 26) applications.

Closing application. Under Communiqué Art. 37, the firm must submit the closing documents to the relevant regional directorate within three months of the end of the certificate period for a certificate, and to the customs administration within three months of the end of the permit period for a permit. No separate written notice of these periods is given to the firm. If the documents are not submitted or are incomplete, under Art. 38/1 the firm is notified to complete them within one month; otherwise the commitment is closed on the existing documents, taking into account the sanctions in Art. 45.

Line code. Under Communiqué Art. 38/3, for an export declaration to count towards the commitment, it must contain the line code including the certificate or permit number.

Short delays. Under Communiqué Art. 45/5, if the operations required by the regime are completed within one month after the certificate or permit period expires, they are treated as within the certificate, but twice the irregularity fine is charged under Customs Law Art. 241/3; if completed within two months, four times under Art. 241/4. Article 238/1 of the Law likewise excludes these cases from the Article 238 fine.

If the Commitment Is Not Fulfilled: Duties and the Article 238 Fine

Article 184 of the Customs Law lists non-fulfilment of an obligation arising from the customs procedure among the cases giving rise to a customs debt on importation.

Statutory Provision — Customs Law (Law No. 4458) art. 184/1-a (incurrence of a customs debt, unofficial translation)

“Apart from the cases set out in Article 183;

a) non-fulfilment of one of the obligations arising from the temporary storage of goods subject to import duties or from the application of the customs procedure under which they have been placed,

… gives rise to a customs debt on importation.”

Communiqué Art. 45/1 sets out the inward processing counterpart of this obligation: the duty not collected on the importation of goods imported under suspension and not exported is collected as of the import date under the Customs Law and Law No. 6183. The same paragraph provides that Article 238 of the Customs Law also applies to goods not exported in time. There are thus two separate burdens: duties and an administrative fine.

Statutory Provision — Customs Law (Law No. 4458) art. 238/1-2 (fines for regime breaches, unofficial translation)

“Except for the cases set out in Article 241(3)(h), (l) and (m), Article 241(4)(g) and (h) and Article 241(5)(b);

a) in the event of breach of the provisions on the inward processing regime, the processing under customs control regime and the temporary admission regime, twice the duty-paid value of the goods,

… c) where the provisions on the inward processing regime and the processing under customs control regime have been breached but it is established that the imported goods covered by the regime, including in their state during processing or as processed products, have not been removed from customs supervision contrary to the legislation, the total of the interest, at the late-payment surcharge rate determined under Law No. 6183, on the customs duties on the imported goods for the period from the registration date of the declaration for the regime until the date of the finding,

… is imposed as an administrative fine.

… Where the goods referred to in subparagraphs (c) and (d) of the first paragraph are not assigned to another customs-approved treatment or use within sixty days of the notification to be made, an additional administrative fine equal to the customs duties is imposed.”

The current structure of the article stems from the 2019 amendment made by Law No. 7190. The standard fine is twice the duty-paid value of the goods (Art. 238/1-a). But where the regime has been breached and it is established that the goods, including in their state during processing or as processed products, have not been removed from customs supervision contrary to the legislation, the fine is reduced to interest at the late-payment surcharge rate on the customs duties from registration of the declaration to the date of the finding (Art. 238/1-c). In that case, if the goods are not assigned to a customs-approved treatment or use within sixty days of notification, a further fine equal to the customs duties is imposed (Art. 238/2). The Council of State upheld a first-instance judgment applying this amendment as a more favourable law to earlier events (see below).

The basis of the fine may also be disputed. The 7th Chamber of the Council of State accepted that, under the provision in force at the time of the events, the Article 238 fine may also be calculated on the resource utilisation support fund levy, which falls within “customs duties”; in the same decision, the regional court's ruling annulling the fine calculated on anti-dumping duty was upheld. The case concerned a payment order sent to a board member as legal representative for the company's tax and penalty debt; in other words, a debt arising from an inward processing breach may be pursued against managers if it cannot be collected from the company.

How Are the Duties Demanded: Article 37 of Law No. 6183 or Assessment?

In inward processing, the duties were in fact assessed at importation; only their collection was deferred against collateral. Which act the administration must take in case of a breach is therefore a separate debate within the Council of State. The Assembly of Tax Law Chambers, adopting the reasoning of the 7th Chamber, drew a twofold distinction:

Council of State Assembly of Tax Law Chambers Decision (reasoning of the 7th Chamber adopted)
Assembly of Tax Law Chambers, E. 2023/295, K. 2024/999, 13.11.2024 (twofold distinction by status of the collateral)

“… a twofold distinction must be made according to whether or not the collateral has been returned to the person concerned. The first of these, i.e. the pursuit where the regime conditions have been breached but the collateral has not yet been returned and is still held by the customs administration, … must be carried out by a transaction under Article 37 of Law No. 6183 on the Procedure for the Collection of Public Receivables and then under Article 56, which governs the pursuit and collection of secured receivables. … the customs duties on the goods must be assessed under that Law and notified to the obligor, so that obligors may have recourse against these notifications to the administrative objection routes in Article 242 of that Law and, upon rejection of their requests, may bring an action within thirty days.” (unofficial translation)

Accordingly, if the collateral is still held by the administration, no new assessment is made; a one-month payment period is notified under Article 37 of Law No. 6183 and, if unpaid, Article 56 is applied as for a secured receivable. If the breach is found after the commitment was closed and the collateral returned, the duties are assessed and notified under the Customs Law; the obligor may lodge an Article 242 objection and, upon its rejection, bring an action within thirty days. Since the route of rectification of decision was left open in the Assembly's decision, the decision may not be final.

At the start of 2026 the 7th Chamber repeated the same distinction and required an inquiry into whether the collateral had been returned:

Council of State Decision
7th Chamber, E. 2025/974, K. 2026/59, 20.01.2026 (whether the collateral was returned must be examined)

“In the present case, upon the finding that part of the raw materials, auxiliary materials and packaging imported under the inward processing authorisation certificate had not been used in the exported products, a transaction was made under Article 37 of Law No. 6183, and although the Court annulled that transaction on the ground that the underlying penalty decision had been withdrawn, no examination was made as to whether there was a breach of the regime, and since there is no information or document in the file as to whether all or part of the collateral given by the claimant was returned, the judgment under appeal must be quashed so that a new judgment can be given by assessing the lawfulness of the contested transaction according to the result of an examination on these points.” (unofficial translation)

One member wrote a dissenting opinion. According to the dissent, because the duty was definitively assessed from the outset, there is no need for a new assessment even if the collateral was returned, and the correct act is in every case Article 37 of Law No. 6183:

Council of State Decision (dissenting opinion)

“For the reason explained, since, because of the breach of the inward processing regime, there is no need for an assessment even after the regime has closed and the collateral has been returned, and since it must be determined, by examining the merits of the contested transaction made under Article 37 of Law No. 6183, whether there was a breach of the regime in the case, I do not agree with the reasoning of our Chamber's decision that a new assessment must be made because the collateral was returned.” (unofficial translation)

Objection and Court Route

Under Turkish law, the remedies for an inward processing breach operate on two levels.

1. Objection to closure with sanctions (Communiqué Arts. 38/12-13). The holder of an inward processing authorisation certificate may object in writing to the Ministry of Trade (Directorate General of Exports) within one month of notification of the closure with sanctions; for inward processing permits, the objection route under Article 242 of the Customs Law applies. All supporting information and documents are submitted with the objection. When an objection is made, the relevant authorities are informed that the steps to apply sanctions are suspended until further notice. If the objection is upheld, the closure is withdrawn and redone.

2. Objection to the customs administration's tax and penalty decisions (Customs Law Art. 242). The tax and penalty decisions notified by the customs administration on the basis of the closure with sanctions are objected to within fifteen days of notification.

Statutory Provision — Customs Law (Law No. 4458) art. 242 (objections, unofficial translation)

“Obligors may object to customs duties, penalties and administrative decisions notified to them, within fifteen days of the date of notification, by a petition submitted to the superior authority or, if there is none, to the same authority.

… Objections reaching the administration are decided within thirty days and notified to the person concerned.

… Recourse may be had to the administrative courts of the place where the act was performed against decisions rejecting the objection.”

According to the Council of State decisions, an action may be brought within thirty days of rejection of the objection. In some of the files examined, the action was brought before the tax court, cassation was examined by the 7th Chamber of the Council of State and, in case of insistence, by the Assembly of Tax Law Chambers.

Settlement, time bar and general grounds for annulment are not specific to inward processing; see the article Additional Customs Assessment and Penalty (VEZA) Decisions for those.

Inward Processing Breaches in Council of State Case Law

The decisions below were obtained in full text from the official case-law database. All are decisions of the 7th Chamber of the Council of State or of the Assembly of Tax Law Chambers and show both favourable and unfavourable outcomes.

A breach requires a concrete finding

In a file where an Article 238 fine was imposed because “tax free” invoices without a line code were not counted towards the commitment, the Assembly, following the 7th Chamber's reasoning, quashed the insistence judgment. The reason was the absence of a concrete administrative finding that the goods were not taken abroad. A formal defect alone was not enough; whether the goods were actually exported was treated as decisive.

Council of State Assembly of Tax Law Chambers Decision (reasoning of the 7th Chamber adopted)

“For goods temporarily imported under the inward processing regime to benefit from the suspension system provided for in the regime, they must have been taken abroad in accordance with the regime conditions and must have actually entered the country of importation. … However, there is no concrete finding made by the defendant administration showing that the regime conditions were breached in the sense that the goods were not taken abroad in relation to the said inward processing authorisation certificate.” (unofficial translation)

More favourable law for goods that did not leave customs supervision

For a fine of twice the duty-paid value imposed on goods exported after the deadline, the tax court applied Article 238/1-c, introduced by the 2019 amendment, as a more favourable law. The fine was found lawful up to the total of interest at the late-payment surcharge rate and unlawful beyond it, and the Council of State upheld the judgment. As the route of rectification of decision was left open, the decision may not be final.

Council of State Decision (reasoning of the first-instance court, upheld)
7th Chamber, E. 2022/3990, K. 2023/3619, 02.10.2023 (Art. 238/1-c as more favourable law)

“… within the framework of the fundamental principle of criminal law that "favourable provisions of law apply retroactively", which undoubtedly also applies to fines in customs disputes, the contested act was partly annulled and the action partly dismissed on the ground that the fine is not unlawful in the part corresponding to the total of the interest, at the late-payment surcharge rate determined under Law No. 6183, on the customs duties on the imported goods for the period from the registration date of the declaration for the regime until the date of the finding, and is unlawful in the part exceeding that amount.” (unofficial translation)

Where the breach is established, duties and fine are upheld

In a file where the regional administrative court found, on the basis of inspection and investigation reports, that part of the imported fabrics had been sold to other firms with an export undertaking and not used in the exported products, the Council of State upheld the duties and the fine of twice the customs and VAT amounts (the Article 238 text in force at the time). The decision shows that where the breach is proven by reports, the outcome may go against the obligor.

Council of State Decision
7th Chamber, E. 2024/482, K. 2024/4526, 07.11.2024 (breach established; duties and fine upheld)

“According to the said legal provisions, for there to be a duty payable and an administrative fine to be imposed in relation to goods imported under the inward processing regime, a finding must be made that the regime conditions have been breached. … Although the Tax Chamber reached the conclusion that it was established that the goods imported under the inward processing authorisation certificate, part of which were sold to other taxpayers with an export undertaking, were not among the fabrics used in production or processing under the export commitment and thus exported, there is no correctness in the part of the judgment annulling the fine calculated under Article 238 of the Customs Law on the resource utilisation support fund levy, which falls within customs duties.” (unofficial translation)

Practical Points

Diarise the periods. For a certificate, the three-month periods for extension, justified-reason, force majeure and closing applications (Communiqué Arts. 21, 23, 26, 37) and the one-month completion period in Art. 38/1 must not be missed.

Check the line code at the time of export. If the declaration does not contain the line code including the certificate number, it does not count towards the commitment (Communiqué Art. 38/3).

Document the link between the imported goods and the product. If it cannot be proven that the imported goods were used in the exported product, duty and fine arise (Communiqué Art. 45/1-g). Communiqué Art. 45/6 allows proof by a sworn financial advisor's report based on stock and accounting records where this condition cannot be established for a technical, scientific or administrative reason.

Identify the type of act received. The closure-with-sanctions letter, the customs administration's tax and penalty decision and the Article 37 payment notice under Law No. 6183 are separate acts, each with its own authority and period. Check whether the fine was calculated under Art. 238/1-a or 1-c: if the goods did not leave customs supervision, the fine may be much lower.

Find out the status of the collateral. The Council of State's distinction turns on whether the collateral was returned.

Risk for legal representatives. A payment order may be sent to managers for an inward processing receivable that cannot be collected from the company. In the Council of State decision, objections concerning the basis of the fine were examined in the payment-order action; according to the dissenting opinion and the administration's appeal argument, however, objections to an act notified to the company and finalised cannot be raised in the payment-order action.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if the export commitment under an inward processing authorisation certificate is not fulfilled in time?

The commitment is closed with sanctions at the closing stage. Under Article 45 of the Inward Processing Regime Communiqué, the duties secured by collateral at importation for the unexported portion are collected as of the import date under the Customs Law and Law No. 6183; in addition, an administrative fine is imposed under Article 238 of the Customs Law.

When must the application to close the commitment be made?

For an inward processing authorisation certificate, at the latest within three months of the end of the certificate period to the relevant regional directorate; for an inward processing permit, within three months of the end of the permit period to the customs administration (Communiqué Art. 37).

Is the Article 238 fine always twice the duty-paid value?

No. The rule is twice the duty-paid value of the goods (Art. 238/1-a). But where the regime has been breached yet the goods are found not to have been removed from customs supervision contrary to the legislation, the fine equals interest calculated on the customs duties at the late-payment surcharge rate (Art. 238/1-c). In that case, if the goods are not assigned to a customs-approved treatment or use within sixty days of notification, a further fine equal to the customs duties is imposed (Art. 238/2).

Where is an objection to closure with sanctions lodged?

The holder of an inward processing authorisation certificate may object in writing to the Ministry of Trade (Directorate General of Exports) within one month of notification of the closure with sanctions. For inward processing permits, the objection route under Article 242 of the Customs Law applies (Communiqué Art. 38/12). The fifteen-day Article 242 objection period against the tax and penalty decisions notified by the customs administration must be observed separately.

Why are the duties sometimes demanded by additional assessment and sometimes by a payment-period notice?

According to the Council of State, the decisive factor is the status of the collateral. If the collateral is still held by the administration, the duties are pursued by setting a due date under Article 37 of Law No. 6183 and from the collateral under Article 56. If the breach is found after the commitment was closed and the collateral returned, the duties are assessed and notified under the Customs Law and the Article 242 objection route opens. There is a dissenting opinion within the Council of State against this distinction.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Customs Law

All Customs Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Unfulfilled Export Commitment under Inward Processing in Türkiye: Duties, Article 238 Customs Fine, Objection”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-13, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/inward-processing-export-commitment-breach-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›