Last reviewed:
The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, an annulment action is brought, under Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, Art. 2, by those whose interests are violated, for the annulment of administrative acts that are unlawful in terms of one of competence, form, cause, subject-matter or purpose. Only a final and enforceable (executory) act may be challenged, so preparatory acts and opinions cannot be challenged on their own, and the claimant must have a personal, legitimate and current interest in the act. Unless a special law provides otherwise, the filing period is sixty days before the administrative courts and the Council of State and thirty days before the tax courts, running as a rule from the day after written notification, and an application to the superior authority stops this period (Art. 11). Filing the action does not in itself stop the act from being implemented; a stay of execution may be ordered where implementation would cause damage that is difficult or impossible to remedy and the act is clearly unlawful, the two conditions being met together (Art. 27). An annulment decision removes the act with effect from the date it was made, and the administration must comply with it without delay.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
A comprehensive guide to the annulment action in administrative jurisdiction: the definition of the action and the elements of an administrative act (competence, form, cause, subject-matter, purpose) under Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, Art. 2; violation of interest and subjective standing; the final-and-enforceable (executory) act requirement; the filing period (Art. 7) and application to the superior authority (Art. 11); the stay of execution (Art. 27); the competent court; the principle of ex officio investigation; and the effects of an annulment decision, with decisions of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers and the 2nd and 6th Chambers of the Council of State.
A comprehensive guide to the annulment action in administrative jurisdiction; the definition of the annulment action and the elements of an administrative act — competence, form, cause, subject-matter and purpose (Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, Art. 2); violation of interest and subjective standing; the requirement of a final and enforceable (executory) act and the distinction from a preparatory act; the filing period (Art. 7) and application to the superior authority (Art. 11); the stay of execution (Art. 27); the competent court; the principle of ex officio investigation; and the effects of an annulment decision, with decisions of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers and the 2nd and 6th Chambers of the Council of State.
The annulment action is the most fundamental type of action in administrative jurisdiction and one of the most important means of ensuring that the administration acts lawfully. Where an administrative act is unlawful in terms of one of the elements of competence, form, cause, subject-matter or purpose, persons whose interests are violated may seek its annulment before the administrative judiciary. This article addresses the definition of the annulment action, the elements of an administrative act, which acts may be challenged, the standing requirement, the filing period and application to the superior authority, the stay of execution, the competent court and the settled criteria of the Council of State.
What Is an Annulment Action?
The annulment action is defined in Article 2 of Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577. Accordingly, an annulment action is one brought, by those whose interests are violated, for the annulment of administrative acts on the ground that they are unlawful in terms of one of competence, form, cause, subject-matter and purpose. Differently from the annulment action, an action brought by those whose personal rights are directly harmed by administrative actions and acts is a full-remedy (compensation) action. Administrative judicial power is limited to the review of lawfulness; courts may not conduct an expediency review and may not decide in the administration's place.
“The types of administrative action are as follows: (a) annulment actions, brought by those whose interests are violated, for the annulment of administrative acts on the ground that they are unlawful in terms of one of competence, form, cause, subject-matter and purpose; (b) full-remedy actions brought by those whose personal rights are directly impaired by administrative actions and acts; (c) … actions concerning disputes arising between the parties from any administrative contracts made for the performance of one of the public services. … Administrative judicial power is limited to the review of the lawfulness of administrative acts and actions. Administrative courts may not conduct an expediency review, …”
The Elements of an Administrative Act and Grounds of Annulment
An administrative act consists of five elements, and unlawfulness in any of them is a ground of annulment:
Competence
The authority issuing the act must be competent to issue it in terms of person, place, time and subject-matter. An act issued by an incompetent authority is unlawful; the rules of competence are matters of public order and are reviewed by the court ex officio.
Form
The act must be issued in accordance with the procedural and formal rules provided by law (for example, obtaining the required opinion, writing, reasoning). Substantial defects of form require annulment.
Cause
The factual or legal event, provided in the legislation, that leads the administration to act. The complete absence of the cause, its untruth, or an erroneous legal characterisation vitiates the act. Even if no cause is stated, once an action is brought the administration must state before the court the cause underlying the act.
Subject-matter
The legal result produced by the act. The subject-matter being contrary to law or to higher legal norms is a ground of annulment.
Purpose
The ultimate aim of an administrative act is always the public interest. An act issued for a purpose other than the public interest (for example personal animosity or a political motive) constitutes a defect of purpose and requires annulment as a misuse of power.
Even in fields where the administration has discretionary power, that power may not be exercised arbitrarily; it must be grounded in the public interest and the requirements of the service, on concrete and lawful facts.
Which Acts May Be Challenged? (Final and Enforceable Act)
Not every administrative letter or statement may be the subject of an annulment action. To bring an action there must be a final and enforceable (executory) administrative act. A final and enforceable act is the definitive act that the administration issues by its unilateral will, using public power, that has completed all the required administrative process and that produces a change in the legal order without the need for the approval of another authority (affecting the legal position of the person concerned). Preparatory acts, opinions and preliminary acts made within the administrative decision-making process may not be challenged on their own; they are reviewed together with the final act.
Who May Be a Claimant? Violation of Interest and Subjective Standing
To bring an annulment action there must be a certain relationship of interest between the act in question and the person bringing the action. This is called subjective standing, and the Law requires it through the expression “those whose interests are violated”. In the case-law this interest is required to be personal, legitimate and current. As the standing requirement concerns the maintenance of the rule of law, it is interpreted so as not to prevent the review of administrative acts; on matters closely concerning the public interest — such as the protection of the environment, historical and cultural values, and zoning — civil-society organisations such as associations, trade unions and professional bodies may also bring actions within the framework of their founding purposes.
The Filing Period and Application to the Superior Authority
The annulment action is subject to strict time-limits. Where no separate period is provided in their special laws, the period to bring the action is sixty days before the Council of State and the administrative courts, and thirty days before the tax courts. This period, as a rule, begins from the day following the written notification (service) of the act.
“The period to bring an action is, where no separate period is provided in their special laws, sixty days before the Council of State and the administrative courts and thirty days before the tax courts. These periods begin from the day following: (a) in administrative disputes, the date the written notification was made; … In regulatory acts requiring publication, the period begins from the day following the date of publication. …”
Within the filing period, an application may be made to the superior authority (or, if there is none, to the authority that issued the act) for the act to be withdrawn, revoked, amended or for a new act to be made. This application suspends the running filing period; if the administration does not reply within thirty days, the request is deemed rejected and the period continues from where it left off.
“Before bringing an administrative action, the persons concerned may, within the period for bringing an action, request from the superior authority — or, if there is none, from the authority that issued the act — the withdrawal, revocation or amendment of the administrative act or the making of a new act. This application suspends the period for bringing an action that has begun to run. If no reply is given within thirty days, the request is deemed rejected. Where the request is rejected or deemed rejected, the period for bringing an action begins to run again, and the time elapsed up to the date of application is also taken into account.”
Competent Court and Venue
In annulment actions the court of first instance is, as a rule, the administrative court; in certain disputes the Council of State has first-instance jurisdiction. The court with venue is determined according to the venue rules in the Administrative Procedure Law (as a rule the place where the administration that issued the act is located; for certain acts concerning public officials, the place where the official serves). The rules of jurisdiction and venue are matters of public order and are observed by the court ex officio; an action brought before a court lacking jurisdiction or venue is sent to the relevant court on that ground.
Stay of Execution
Bringing an administrative action does not by itself stay the execution of the act in question. If the application of the act produces harm that is difficult or impossible to remedy and the act is manifestly unlawful — provided these two conditions occur together — the court may, stating reasons, decide on a stay of execution. The decision is, as a rule, given after the administration's defence has been taken.
“Bringing an action before the Council of State or the administrative courts does not stay the execution of the administrative act under challenge. The Council of State or the administrative courts may, where the conditions — the occurrence of harm that is difficult or impossible to remedy upon application of the administrative act and the manifest unlawfulness of the administrative act — occur together, decide on a stay of execution, stating reasons, after the defendant administration's defence has been taken or the defence period has elapsed. … In stay-of-execution decisions it is obligatory to state the grounds on which the administrative act is manifestly unlawful and what harm that is difficult or impossible to remedy would arise upon application of the act. …”
Evidence, Ex Officio Investigation and the Effects of an Annulment Decision
In administrative proceedings the principles of writing and ex officio investigation are essential (Administrative Procedure Law, Art. 20). The court is obliged to carry out every examination relating to the case of its own motion; where necessary, it requests from the administration the information and documents underlying the act. This power is at the same time a safeguard for the claimant, since the real reasoning and cause of the administrative act are often in the administration's hands. When an annulment decision is given, the act in question is removed with all its effects from the date it was issued (retroactively) and produces results as if it had never been made. Under Article 138 of the Constitution and the provisions of the Administrative Procedure Law on the implementation of decisions, the administration must implement the requirements of the annulment decision without delay.
Council of State Decisions
The decisions below concern the basic institutions of the annulment action (definition and standing, the cause element and ex officio investigation, the challengeable act, and the period) and were verified in full text from the official case-law database.
The definition of the annulment action and the subjective-standing (violation of interest) requirement
“In Article 2 of Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, annulment actions are defined as actions brought, by those whose interests are violated, for the annulment of administrative acts on the ground that they are unlawful in terms of one of competence, form, cause, subject-matter and purpose, … [the legislature] requires violation of interest as the condition of subjective standing for annulment actions, … in the field of administrative law, acts issued by a unilateral declaration of will, of a final and necessarily enforceable nature, can be made the subject of an annulment action only by those who have a personal, legitimate and current relationship of interest with these administrative acts …” (unofficial translation)
The cause element of an administrative act and the judge's power of ex officio investigation
“In sub-paragraph (a) of the first paragraph of Article 2 of Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, it is provided that in annulment actions the review of lawfulness is conducted on the competence, form, cause, subject-matter and purpose elements of administrative acts, … the cause element is defined as the legal or factual event requiring the making of the act, … even where the cause underlying the administrative act is not expressly stated in the laws, the administration is obliged, where an action is brought, to state it before the court, … on the basis of the power conferred by Article 20 of Law No. 2577 the courts must … request from the administration that the cause underlying the act be shown, or investigate this cause of their own motion …” (unofficial translation)
The subject of an annulment action: a final and enforceable (executory) act; a preparatory act may not be challenged (upheld determination)
“… for the persons concerned to be able to bring an annulment action there must be a final and enforceable act capable of being the subject of an administrative action, … for an administrative act to be regarded as final and enforceable, the act must have completed all the required administrative process and be able to produce a change in the legal order — that is, to affect the legal position of the governed — without being subject to the approval and permission of any other administrative authority; among the acts performed within the administrative decision-making process, only the final act may be the subject of an annulment action, and the preparatory and similar acts that administrations make … may not be challenged …” (unofficial translation)
The filing period is a matter of public order, is a forfeiture period and is observed at every stage
“The action period concerns public order and has the nature of a forfeiture period. Indeed, in Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 the question of whether the action was brought within time is counted among the matters of preliminary examination; it is provided that, where it is established that the action was not brought within time, the action will be rejected on the ground of expiry of the period without entering into the merits (Articles 14/3-e and 15/1-b). It has also been emphasised that whether the action was brought within time must be taken into account at every stage of the proceedings (Article 14/6).” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between an annulment action and a full-remedy action?
An annulment action seeks the annulment of an administrative act on the ground of unlawfulness in terms of competence, form, cause, subject-matter or purpose, and is brought by those whose interests are violated. A full-remedy action is a claim for compensation (or for the fulfilment of a right) by those whose personal rights are directly harmed by an administrative action or act. Where the conditions are met, the two actions may also be brought together.
Who may bring an annulment action?
Anyone who has a personal, legitimate and current relationship of interest with the act in question may bring it (subjective standing). On matters closely concerning the public interest — such as the environment, zoning, and the protection of historical and cultural values — associations, trade unions and professional bodies may also bring actions within the framework of their founding purposes.
Can an action be brought against any administrative letter?
No. Only final and enforceable (executory) administrative acts may be challenged. The administration's opinions, preparatory acts or preliminary-act letters may not be challenged on their own; they are reviewed only together with the final act.
What is the filing period?
Where there is no separate period in their special laws, it is sixty days before the administrative courts and the Council of State and thirty days before the tax courts. The period, as a rule, begins from the day following service of the act. Under Article 11, an application to the superior authority suspends the period; in case of rejection or implied rejection it continues from where it left off.
Does bringing an action stay the application of the act?
No, bringing an action does not stay the act by itself. If the application of the act will cause harm that is difficult or impossible to remedy and the act is manifestly unlawful (the two conditions together), a stay of execution must be requested from the court (Art. 27).
What happens if an annulment decision is given?
An annulment decision removes the act from the moment it was issued (retroactively); the act is deemed never to have been made. Under Article 138 of the Constitution and the Administrative Procedure Law, the administration must implement the requirements of the annulment decision without delay.
Within Administrative Law, Çapar Law Office conducts annulment actions and full-remedy actions against administrative acts, handling every stage of administrative disputes, including applications to the superior authority, stays of execution and the management of time-limits.
Related Articles
- Judicial Review of Disciplinary Penalties
- Disciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment Actions
- De Facto Expropriation Claims in Türkiye: Compensation, Injunction and Mesne Profits
- Additional Customs Assessment and Penalty (VEZA) Decisions: Objection and Grounds for Annulment
- Union Standing Cannot Be Judged on Members’ Interest Alone: Turkish Constitutional Court on a Trade Union’s Annulment Action
- YÖK Paragraph Barring Court-Backed Appointments Annulled: Turkish Council of State on Lecturer Posts for YLSY (Law No. 1416) Scholarship Holders
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Administrative law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Administrative Law
- Appeals in Afyonkarahisar Cases in Türkiye: Konya Regional Court of Appeal and Regional Administrative Court
- Unlawful Processing of Personal Data in Türkiye: Application, KVKK Complaint, Damages, Criminal Code Art. 136
- Tax Cases from Uşak, Afyonkarahisar and Kütahya: Which Court, Time Limits and Appeal in Türkiye
- Building, Facilities and Mining in Olive Groves in Türkiye: Law No. 3573, Prohibitions and Legal Remedies
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/annulment-action-administrative-jurisdiction

























