Last reviewed:
Disciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment Actions
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, academics working at universities are subject in disciplinary matters to the special regime of the Higher Education Law (arts. 53 and 53/A-53/E of Law No. 2547). The Civil Servants Law No. 657 does not apply to them. The available penalties are warning, reprimand, deduction from salary or fee, suspension of step progression or multiple fee deductions, removal from the university teaching profession and removal from public service (art. 53/b). No disciplinary penalty may be imposed without granting the right of defence (Constitution art. 129/2), and for acts concerning research and publication ethics such as plagiarism, an examination by the ethics board is mandatory before an investigation is opened. If no investigation is started within one month of learning of the act for the lighter penalties, or within six months for removal penalties, no investigation may be opened, and no penalty may be imposed once two years have passed since the act, or six years for removal from the university teaching profession (art. 53/C). An annulment action against a disciplinary penalty is brought before the administrative court within 60 days of notification and the judgment is open to regional appeal; for acts resulting in removal from a profession or from public service, cassation before the Council of State is also available (APL art. 46). In technical matters such as plagiarism allegations, the Council of State holds that the court must order an expert examination of its own motion and that the expert’s advance cannot be imposed on the claimant.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
A guide to disciplinary penalties on academics in Türkiye and annulment actions: the special regime of Law No. 2547 and its differences from the civil-servant regime; penalty types (art. 53/b); the legality principle shaped by Constitutional Court annulments; investigation procedure, statement-taking and the right of defence (art. 53/A, as amended by Law No. 7592); limitation (art. 53/C); mandatory ethics-board and expert examination in plagiarism cases; the 60-day period, regional appeal and cassation only for removal penalties (APL art. 46) - with verified Council of State (8th Chamber) decisions in the university cases.
A guide to disciplinary penalties imposed on academics (faculty members) in Türkiye and actions for their annulment: the special disciplinary regime of the Higher Education Law No. 2547 and its differences from the civil-servant regime, the types of penalties (art. 53/b), the principle of legality shaped by Constitutional Court annulments, investigation procedure and the right of defence (art. 53/A), limitation periods (art. 53/C), the particularities of plagiarism (research ethics) investigations, the litigation route (60-day period, regional appeal, cassation before the Council of State only for removal penalties — APL art. 46), with verified Council of State (8th Chamber) decisions rendered in cases involving universities.
Update (19.10.2026): The heading and second paragraph of art. 53/A of Law No. 2547 were amended by article 6 of Law No. 7592 (Official Gazette 09.08.2026; in force on publication). The statutory extract, the section on investigation procedure and the related FAQ have been revised accordingly: statement-taking and defence are now separate stages; the invitation to defend must state the act on which the proposal is based and the corresponding penalty; and a person who does not defend within the time limit despite a proper invitation is deemed to have waived the right of defence. The note on the Constitutional Court’s 2022 annulment decision has also been updated. The addition made by Law No. 7592 to art. 53/b-(5)-(b) and the new additional article 47 of Law No. 2547 have been added to the section on plagiarism and ethics investigations.
The Special Disciplinary Regime for Academics
Faculty members at Turkish universities (professors, associate professors, assistant professors, lecturers, research assistants) are subject, in disciplinary matters, not to the Civil Servants Law No. 657 but to the special regime of articles 53 and 53/A-53/E of the Higher Education Law No. 2547. The Council of State stresses that the nature of academic duty differs from that of the civil service; as shown below, this difference renders unlawful the application to academics of institutions peculiar to Law No. 657 — such as deemed resignation for absenteeism. Administrative staff at universities remain subject to art. 125 of Law No. 657.
Special cases in the Law: This principle concerns absenteeism (failing to attend while in post). Failing to take up duty in time at the place of assignment is, however, treated by Law No. 2547 itself as resignation in two cases: a person notified of an assignment under art. 41 or art. 40/b who does not take up duty within the statutory period is deemed to have resigned; and under provisional article 78, a research assistant who has completed training under the Faculty Member Training Programme (ÖYP) and is assigned to another university is deemed to have resigned if they do not take up duty within three months.
“Research assistants who have completed their training under the Faculty Member Training Programme shall, where needed, also be assigned to other universities. Those who do not take up their duties within three months of the assignment shall be deemed to have resigned.”
Types of Disciplinary Penalties (art. 53/b)
“The disciplinary penalties applicable to the teaching staff of State and foundation higher education institutions are warning, reprimand, deduction from salary or wage, suspension of grade advancement or repeated wage deduction, removal from the university teaching profession, and dismissal from public service.”
The penalties range from warning and reprimand to removal from the university teaching profession and dismissal from public service. The acts warranting each penalty are enumerated exhaustively in the statute; no penalty may be imposed by analogy. Removal from the teaching profession, which permanently bars academic titles and university employment, carries the gravest consequences and enjoys special procedural safeguards.
The Principle of Legality and Legislative Evolution
Academic disciplinary law is one of the most striking fields of application of the principle of legality in administrative law. The regime, long governed by regulation, was upended by the Constitutional Court’s 2015 annulment; disciplinary offences and penalties had to be regulated by statute, and article 53 was rewritten by Law No. 6764 (2016). The phrases “in addition to the acts in Law No. 657” were then also annulled by the Constitutional Court, and the current system was established by Law No. 7243 (2020). This evolution, summarised in the Council of State decision quoted below, remains decisive in disputes over which rule (the more favourable provision) applies to earlier acts.
Investigation Procedure and the Right of Defence (art. 53/A)
“b) For acts requiring a disciplinary penalty relating to scientific research and publication ethics, an examination by the scientific research and publication ethics boards is mandatory before an investigation is opened. … l) The investigation shall be completed within two months of the date on which the letter of appointment is notified. If the investigation cannot be completed within this period, the investigator may request additional time, stating reasons; the disciplinary superior decides by assessing the reasons and taking the limitation periods into account. … The principles governing statements and defence in disciplinary investigations are as follows: a) The invitation to give a statement sent by the investigator to the person under investigation shall clearly state what the allegations against that person are and shall notify him or her that the statement will be taken within a period of not less than seven days to be granted, and that, if no oral or written statement is given within that period, action will be taken on the basis of the evidence available in the file. The investigator makes a proposal on the basis of the evidence collected. b) The invitation to present a defence sent to the person under investigation by the authority competent to impose the disciplinary penalty shall state what the act on which the proposal is based consists of and what disciplinary penalty corresponds to that act, and that he or she must present a defence within a period of not less than seven days to be granted. The invitation shall further notify the person under investigation that, if the defence is not presented within the period granted, he or she will be deemed to have waived the right of defence and a decision will be taken on the basis of the available evidence. c) The invitation to present a defence shall notify the person under investigation that he or she may examine the investigation file before exercising the right of defence. Those for whom removal from the university teaching profession or dismissal from public service is sought have the right to examine the investigation file, to have witnesses heard, and to present a defence before the disciplinary board orally or in writing, in person or through counsel.”
The core safeguards: the investigation begins with a written appointment; the investigator’s rank must be equal or superior to that of the person investigated; and the investigation must, as a rule, be completed within two months. Since 09.08.2026, statement-taking and defence have been separate stages. First, the investigator’s invitation to give a statement must set out the allegations clearly and grant at least seven days; if no statement is given, action is taken on the evidence in the file. After the investigator has made a proposal on the basis of the evidence collected, the authority competent to impose the penalty invites the person to defend, stating the act on which the proposal is based and the corresponding penalty, again granting at least seven days and indicating that the investigation file may be examined before the defence. In removal cases the person may also examine the file, call witnesses and defend before the disciplinary board orally or in writing, in person or through counsel.
The new rules follow the Constitutional Court’s decision of 13.10.2022, E.2022/87, K.2022/121. The Court annulled the second sentence of subparagraph (a) of the former second paragraph, under which the investigator granted the period for the defence, subparagraph (b) on the invitation to defend, and subparagraph (c), under which the competent authority could request a further defence if it deemed it necessary. In the Court’s reasoning, a defence could be requested before the file had matured and without notice of the act imputed and the proposed penalty, while a further defence was left to the authority’s discretion; the contested phrases were therefore held contrary to Article 129 of the Constitution, and the rest of those subparagraphs and subparagraph (b) were annulled because they could no longer be applied. The annulment took effect nine months after the decision was published in the Official Gazette (02.02.2023). The heading and the second paragraph were then rewritten by article 6 of Law No. 7592 (adopted 30.07.2026; Official Gazette 09.08.2026, No. 33335), which entered into force on publication. The first sentence of the former subparagraph (a) — no disciplinary penalty without the opportunity to present a defence — had not been annulled, but it no longer appears in the current text because the second paragraph was rewritten in full. The same guarantee remains in Article 129/2 of the Constitution: no disciplinary penalty may be imposed on public servants unless the right of defence has been afforded.
A penalty imposed without any invitation to defend breaches this guarantee, and defects in the invitation — such as failing to state the act on which the proposal is based, the corresponding penalty or a period of at least seven days — may also be a ground for annulment. Conversely, a person who does not defend within the time limit despite a proper invitation is deemed to have waived the right of defence and a decision is taken on the available evidence; in that case the absence of a defence is not in itself a ground for annulment. Breaches of other procedural safeguards, such as an unauthorised investigator or an improperly constituted board, are in themselves a ground for annulment.
Investigations begun before 09.08.2026: Law No. 7592 contains no transitional provision on pending disciplinary investigations. In our view, statement and defence invitations issued after that date should comply with the new rules even where the investigation began earlier, while steps completed before that date fall to be assessed under the rules then in force and the guarantee in Article 129 of the Constitution. Which procedure applies must be examined case by case, according to the dates of each step.
Limitation Periods (art. 53/C)
“Unless a disciplinary investigation is commenced within one month of learning of the act for warning, reprimand, salary deduction and suspension of grade advancement penalties, and within six months for removal from the university teaching profession and dismissal from public service, no disciplinary investigation may be opened. No disciplinary penalty may be imposed where two years have passed since the act, or six years for acts requiring removal from the university teaching profession. Where a scientific work is used in academic appointments and promotions or is republished in whole or in part, the limitation periods start to run anew.”
There are two distinct periods: the period for commencing the investigation (one month from knowledge for minor penalties; six months for removal penalties) and the penalty limitation (two years from the act; six years for removal from the teaching profession). These are examined by the courts of their own motion. The special rule restarting limitation upon the re-use of a scientific work in appointments/promotions or its republication is decisive in plagiarism investigations.
Particularities of Plagiarism and Ethics Investigations
For acts concerning research and publication ethics (chiefly plagiarism), a prior ethics board examination is mandatory (art. 53/A-b). A plagiarism allegation is a technical matter: the Council of State holds that, in the annulment action, the court must of its own motion order an expert examination (APL art. 20) and that the expert fee advance cannot be imposed on the claimant — it must first be requested from the administration and, failing that, covered by the Treasury. In removal-from-profession cases this safeguard alone can lead to reversal, as the case below shows.
Changes made by Law No. 7592: Law No. 7592, in force since 09.08.2026 (Official Gazette 09.08.2026, No. 33335), made two changes in this field. Article 5 of Law No. 7592 extended the act in art. 53/b-(5)-(b) of Law No. 2547, which warrants removal from the university teaching profession: besides using publications and works produced by others, it now also covers making such publications or works on behalf of others, for payment or free of charge and in part or in full, or acting as an intermediary for them. Additional article 47 of Law No. 2547, inserted by article 11 of Law No. 7592, provides that persons who obtain a diploma degree or an academic title through theses, articles, books or projects written or carried out for them by others are removed from the university teaching profession and that the degrees and titles so obtained are withdrawn; it also introduces judicial fines for those who make, produce or broker such works on behalf of others and for those who obtain a degree or title by using them. Whether these provisions can apply to acts committed before 09.08.2026 must be assessed separately.
“Excluding contributions that involve no academic assessment, such as conducting surveys or collecting data, persons who obtain an associate, bachelor’s or postgraduate diploma degree or an academic title through works such as theses, articles or books that they have had written by others, or projects they have had carried out by others, in part or in full, for payment or free of charge, outside their own personal effort and academic accumulation, shall be removed from the university teaching profession, and the academic degrees and titles obtained in this way shall be withdrawn. Persons who, for payment or free of charge, make or produce, in part or in full, the publications or works within the scope of the first paragraph on behalf of others, or act as intermediaries for them, shall be subject to a judicial fine of five thousand to ten thousand days. Where the act is committed by persons who make it their profession, the judicial fine shall not be less than ten thousand days or more than twenty thousand days. Persons who obtain a diploma degree or an academic title by using these publications and works shall be subject to a judicial fine of five thousand to ten thousand days.”
Examples from University Cases
(1) Deemed resignation for absenteeism: a research assistant at a university's faculty of medicine was deemed to have resigned under art. 94 of Law No. 657 for ten days’ absence; the first-instance and regional courts upheld the measure. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State reversed in the academic’s favour: teaching staff are subject to Law No. 2547, and absenteeism may be addressed only through a disciplinary investigation under that Law.
(2) Removal from the profession for plagiarism: an assistant professor at a university was removed from the university teaching profession by the Council of Higher Education’s High Disciplinary Board for plagiarism in a book; the administrative court dismissed the action because the claimant had not paid the expert-fee advance. The 8th Chamber again reversed in the academic’s favour: an expert examination was mandatory under the ex officio investigation principle, and the cost could not be imposed on the claimant.
These cases show that higher-education disciplinary disputes are heard by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, and that procedural safeguards — application of the correct statute, the expert-evidence regime — can alone change the outcome.
The Litigation Route: Time Limit, Appeal and Cassation
An annulment action must be brought before the competent administrative court within 60 days of notification of the penalty (APL art. 7); a regional appeal (istinaf) lies against the judgment. The critical distinction concerns cassation:
“Final decisions of the chambers of the Council of State and decisions of the regional administrative courts in the cases listed below may, notwithstanding contrary provisions in other laws, be appealed in cassation to the Council of State within thirty days of notification: … d) Annulment actions against acts resulting in removal from a particular profession, from public service or from student status.”
Regional-appeal decisions on warning, reprimand, salary deduction and suspension of advancement are therefore, as a rule, final; under art. 46(1) of the Administrative Procedure Law, cassation before the Council of State is available against acts resulting in removal from the profession or from public service (and the other cases listed in art. 46(1)). Under the second paragraph added to art. 46 by Law No. 7589, however, in cases outside the first paragraph, decisions that a regional administrative court renders anew after setting aside the first-instance judgment on appeal may, save for the listed exceptions, be appealed in cassation to the Council of State; this rule applies to decisions of regional administrative courts rendered after 31/7/2026 (Law No. 7589 provisional art. 1(3)). Thus, while a decision dismissing the regional appeal remains final, a regional decision that sets aside the first-instance judgment and rules anew may be open to cassation even for penalties such as warning or reprimand. In minor-penalty cases the weight of judicial review thus lies at first instance and on regional appeal — the defence and evidence must be built fully from the outset. Note also that, upon annulment, the administration may re-issue a penalty within the limits of art. 53/C.
Council of State Decisions
Deemed resignation under Law No. 657 cannot be applied to teaching staff; absenteeism is investigated under Law No. 2547
“It is clear that the duties of teaching staff subject to Laws No. 2547 and 2914 and the public service performed by civil servants subject to Law No. 657 are of different natures. … [T]he situation of the claimant, serving as a research assistant subject to Law No. 2547, should have been established through an investigation under that Law and action taken accordingly; the contested act deeming them to have resigned under article 94 of Law No. 657 was found not to be in conformity with the law.” (translation)
The principle of legality: annulment of the “in addition to the acts in Law No. 657” phrases
“The phrases ‘in addition to the acts in Law No. 657…’ in subparagraphs (1), (2), (3), (4) and (6) of paragraph (b) of article 53 of Law No. 2547, as amended by Law No. 6764, were annulled by the Constitutional Court’s decision of 10.04.2019, E:2017/33, K:2019/20, published in the Official Gazette of 17.07.2019, No. 30834, with effect nine months after publication.” (translation)
In plagiarism cases an expert examination is mandatory; the advance cannot be imposed on the claimant
“Under the ex officio investigation principle enshrined in article 20 of Law No. 2577, since the dispute is technical and cannot be resolved with the general and legal knowledge required by the judicial profession, an expert examination is mandatory … the advance must first be requested from the defendant administration, on condition of ultimately being borne by the unsuccessful party, and, if not paid, covered by the Treasury … the regional court’s dismissal, rendered on incomplete examination without an expert study, is not in conformity with the law and the rules of procedure.” (translation)
Regional-appeal decisions on warnings and reprimands are final; cassation is limited to removal penalties (decision predating Law No. 7589)
“[T]he decision imposing a warning penalty and rejecting the objection to it is not an act resulting in permanent removal from a particular profession or from public service … the decision underlying the cassation application is among the ‘final’ decisions of the Regional Administrative Court not open to cassation under article 46 of the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577.” (translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
Which disciplinary penalties may be imposed on academics?
Under art. 53/b of Law No. 2547: warning, reprimand, salary/wage deduction, suspension of grade advancement or repeated wage deduction, removal from the university teaching profession and dismissal from public service. The acts warranting each penalty are exhaustively enumerated.
May a penalty be imposed without taking a defence?
Not without affording the right of defence (Article 129/2 of the Constitution). Since 09.08.2026, under art. 53/A of Law No. 2547, the competent authority's invitation to defend must state the act on which the proposal is based and the corresponding penalty, grant at least seven days and indicate that the file may be examined before the defence. A person who does not defend within that period despite a proper invitation is deemed to have waived the right of defence; the penalty may then be imposed on the available evidence without a defence. In removal cases the person may also examine the file, call witnesses and defend before the board orally or in writing, in person or through counsel.
What are the limitation periods?
The investigation must be commenced within one month of knowledge for minor penalties and six months for removal penalties; no penalty may be imposed after two years from the act (six years for removal from the teaching profession) (art. 53/C). Re-use or republication of a scientific work restarts the periods.
What safeguards apply in plagiarism investigations?
A prior ethics-board examination is mandatory (art. 53/A-b). In the annulment action the court must order an expert examination of its own motion; the expert fee cannot be imposed on the claimant and is requested from the administration or covered by the Treasury.
Where and within what period is the annulment action brought?
Before the administrative court within 60 days of notification; regional appeal lies against the judgment. Appeal decisions dismissing the regional appeal on warnings and reprimands are final; cassation before the Council of State is available, as a rule, for removal from the profession or public service (APL art. 46(1)). Regional decisions rendered after 31/7/2026 that set aside the first-instance judgment and rule anew may, save for the listed exceptions, be appealed in cassation (APL art. 46(2)).
May an academic be deemed to have resigned for absenteeism?
As a rule, no. In a case the 8th Chamber held that deemed resignation under art. 94 of Law No. 657 cannot be applied to teaching staff; absenteeism may be addressed only through a disciplinary investigation under Law No. 2547. Failing to take up duty in time at the place of assignment is a separate matter: in assignments under art. 41 (and art. 40/b) of Law No. 2547 and provisional art. 78 (ÖYP research assistants), this is treated as resignation.
Academic disciplinary investigations and annulment actions fall within our firm’s Administrative Law practice area; for the general framework of civil-servant discipline see our article on judicial review of disciplinary penalties.
- Judicial Review of Disciplinary Penalties
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- De Facto Expropriation Claims in Türkiye: Compensation, Injunction and Mesne Profits
- Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings: Challenging University Vacancies Drafted for One Candidate under Turkish Law
Related Articles
- Judicial Review of Disciplinary Penalties
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings at Universities
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are published Council of State decisions and are not cases in which the firm acted.
Author: Higher education law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Higher Education Law
- Actions Against YÖK and University Acts in Türkiye: Which Administrative Court Has Territorial Jurisdiction?
- Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint Publications
- Art. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437
- Research Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate Grounds
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Disciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment Actions”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/disciplinary-penalties-academics-annulment-actions

























