Last reviewed:
Case NoteAssoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint Publications
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: In its decision of 11.12.2025, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State (Danıştay İdari Dava Daireleri Kurulu) accepted that the presence on the jury of a professor who had several joint articles and joint conference papers with the candidate appointed to an associate professor (doçent) post may create a negative impression as to objectivity. An appointment based on that jury’s reports, made as if there were only one suitable candidate in a file where the court-appointed expert had found that both candidates met the minimum conditions, was held unlawful. The Assembly quashed the regional administrative court’s decision of insistence, finally and by majority. A new scientific assessment between the two candidates must be made; this does not mean that the claimant is automatically appointed.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State finally held, by majority, that an associate professor appointment was unlawful where it relied on the reports of a jury including a professor with several joint articles and papers with the appointee, and was made as if there were a single candidate although an expert had found that both candidates met the minimum conditions.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State held unlawful an appointment to an associate professor post based on the reports of a jury that included a professor with joint publications with the appointee.
The Dispute
A single associate professor post advertised at a faculty of medicine was applied for by the claimant, a physician working at a city hospital, and by a candidate who later joined the case on the side of the defendant administration (the intervener). Two of the three jury members reported that the claimant had not obtained the compulsory score for scientific meetings required by the university’s minimum conditions; the third reported that the claimant was not suitable for appointment. All jury members gave an opinion in favour of the intervener, who was appointed to the post.
In the expert examination ordered by the administrative court, it was found that both candidates met the application conditions, with the claimant’s score at 2,916.50 and the intervener’s at 1,387.65; the court annulled the act. The regional administrative court dismissed the action, stating that the score is not the only criterion and that discretion had been exercised in line with the requirements of the service. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State quashed that decision on 05.07.2024 on the ground of the claimant’s higher score; the regional administrative court insisted on its first decision, and the decision of insistence was appealed.
Outcome of the Decision
The Assembly quashed the decision of insistence and sent the file back to the regional administrative court for a new decision. The decision was given on 11.12.2025, finally and by majority on both the merits and the reasoning. There are two dissenting opinions: one disagreed only with the reasoning, stating that the quashing should have been based on the Chamber’s higher-score reasoning; the other called for the decision of insistence to be upheld. The intervener’s appeal concerning attorney’s fees was not assessed at this stage. No decision on the subsequent course of the file could be found.
Reasoning
After stating that the jury’s assessments are an essential element in appointments to associate professor posts, the Assembly found that the act was not a choice made between two candidates:
“… it is seen that the intervener, being the only candidate considered to meet the conditions, was appointed. However, … considering that it was assessed that both candidates possess the minimum requirements and meet the application conditions, this matter must first be clarified in a manner leaving no room for doubt, and the act must be established accordingly.” (unofficial translation)
The core principle of the decision concerns the impartiality of the jury:
“On the other hand, the purpose of forming a jury is the impartial and objective assessment of the scientific competence of candidates in relation to their appointment to a particular post, and it is not considered possible for a jury member who personally appears as a co-author in some of the works submitted for the jury’s examination to create a conviction among all candidates that the assessment he or she makes of those works will be objective.” (unofficial translation)
In the case at hand, one of the jury members and the intervener had several joint articles and joint poster presentations at international congresses:
“… it has been concluded that the assessments made by that jury member may always give rise to dispute and may create negative impressions as to objectivity. Accordingly, while the jury should have been determined by removing ... from the jury membership so as to eliminate the matters set out above, the act in dispute, established by taking into account reports prepared by jury members selected without observing this point, is not lawful in this respect either.” (unofficial translation)
The Assembly also specified the act expected from the administration:
“… since it has been concluded that a new appointment act aimed exclusively at enhancing scientific quality must be established between the two candidates, by assessing their academic work, experience, qualifications, etc., the act in dispute has not been found lawful.” (unofficial translation)
Significance and Practical Effect
The decision was given at the level of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, which reviews decisions of insistence, and is final. The Assembly based the quashing not on the higher score relied on by the Chamber but on two points: the jury included a member with joint works with the appointee, and the act was established as if there were a single candidate despite the expert’s finding.
The 8th Chamber of the Council of State subsequently ruled in the same direction: it did not regard as impartial, objective and reviewable the assessment of a jury member who had joint academic activities and publications with the candidate appointed to an assistant professor (doktor öğretim üyesi) post, and unanimously quashed on the merits the regional administrative court decision dismissing the action (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2024/4559, K. 2026/909, 18.02.2026). In the decisions accessible (up to 15.01.2026 for the Assembly and 03.03.2026 for the 8th Chamber), no contrary Council of State decision or unification-of-case-law decision after the Assembly’s decision could be found.
In practice, when determining the jury, the rector should take care not to appoint professors who have joint works with the candidates. In this decision the joint work consisted of several articles and papers; whether a single, older joint work would lead to the same result was not addressed.
Relevant Legislation
Article 24/e of Law No. 2547 and the first four paragraphs of Article 11 of the Regulation, as set out in the decision, remain in force with the same text today.
“e) Holders of the title of associate professor apply for associate professor posts advertised by higher education institutions. In order to examine the situation of candidates applying for an associate professor post, three professors are determined by the rector, one of whom shall be the head of the relevant unit, if any, and at least one of whom shall be from outside that university. These professors each write a separate report for each candidate and, if there is more than one candidate for the post, state their preferences. The rector makes the appointment upon the decision of the university or high technology institute board of directors, taking these reports into account.” (unofficial translation)
“(4) The rector gives the decision on the appointment on the basis of the results of the file examination, after also obtaining the reasoned opinion of the university or high technology institute board of directors.” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a professor with joint publications with the appointee sit on the jury for an associate professor post?
Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly’s decision, the presence of such a member on the jury may create a negative impression as to objectivity. The jury should be determined without that member; otherwise an appointment based on that jury’s reports may be held unlawful.
If the jury is flawed, is the claimant appointed directly to the post?
No. The Assembly required a new appointment act aimed at scientific quality to be established between the two candidates.
If the jury says that one candidate does not meet the minimum conditions, can the administration appoint the other?
In this case the appointment was made on the basis of the jury reports as if there were a single candidate. Since the expert examination ordered by the court showed that both candidates met the conditions, the Assembly required this matter first to be clarified in a manner leaving no room for doubt and the act to be established accordingly.
Must the candidate with the higher score be appointed?
The Assembly did not base the quashing on the higher score; it stated that where the candidates’ scientific work is very close or equal, the administration’s discretion becomes important. One member wrote a dissenting opinion stating that the quashing should have been based on the higher score.
- Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings: Challenging University Vacancies Drafted for One Candidate under Turkish Law
- Associate Professorship in Türkiye: Application Requirements and the Annulment Action Against a Negative Result
- Excluding Associate Degree Courses Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on the 2023 Associate Professorship Application Requirements
Related Articles
- Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings at Universities
- Associate Professorship in Türkiye: Application Requirements and the Annulment Action Against a Negative Result
- Excluding Associate Degree Courses Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on the 2023 Associate Professorship Application Requirements
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Higher education law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Higher Education Law
- Actions Against YÖK and University Acts in Türkiye: Which Administrative Court Has Territorial Jurisdiction?
- Research Assistant Requirements, 50/d and 33/a Posts, Term
- Art. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437
- Research Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate Grounds
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint Publications”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/associate-professor-appointment-jury-joint-publications

























