Last reviewed:
Case NoteArt. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: In its decision of 17.09.2025, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State (Danıştay İdari Dava Daireleri Kurulu) did not regard the Constitutional Court’s annulment of subparagraph (a) of Article 54 of Law No. 2547 as sufficient on its own to annul a student disciplinary penalty imposed under the former Regulation. According to the Assembly, annulment decisions do not have retroactive effect; their effect is determined by taking their reasoning into account. The Assembly accepted that the penalty had been left without a legal basis; however, since Article 54 was re-enacted by Law No. 7437 before the annulment took effect, it required the dispute to be resolved on the merits under that regulation, as to the proof of the act, whether it warrants the penalty and the more favourable provision. The regional administrative court’s decision of insistence, which had annulled the penalty solely because of the annulment decision, was quashed finally and by majority; the file was sent back to the regional administrative court for a new decision.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State did not regard the Constitutional Court’s annulment of Article 54 of Law No. 2547 as sufficient on its own to annul a student disciplinary penalty imposed under the former Regulation, and required a review on the merits, under the provision re-enacted by Law No. 7437 before the annulment took effect, of the proof of the act, whether it warrants the penalty and the more favourable provision. The Assembly quashed, finally and by majority, the regional administrative court’s decision of insistence that had annulled the penalty solely because of the annulment decision, and the file was sent back to that court for a new decision.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State did not regard the Constitutional Court’s annulment of Article 54 as sufficient on its own to annul a student disciplinary penalty based on the former Regulation.
The Dispute
While a law faculty student, the claimant was sentenced to imprisonment for membership of an armed terrorist organisation. Once the judgment became final, the university imposed on the claimant the penalty of expulsion from the higher education institution under Article 9/1-a of the Higher Education Institutions Student Discipline Regulation. The administrative court dismissed the action.
By the decision Constitutional Court, E. 2022/54, K. 2022/99, 08.09.2022, subparagraph (a) of Article 54 of Law No. 2547 and the wording in Article 65 that left students’ disciplinary matters to a regulation had been annulled, and it had been decided that the annulment would take effect nine months after the decision’s publication in the Official Gazette on 20.09.2022. Before that period expired, Article 54 was rewritten by Law No. 7437, which entered into force on 09.02.2023; the Regulation was repealed by a regulation published in the Official Gazette of 11.03.2023.
The regional administrative court annulled the act, stating that the Constitutional Court decision had to be taken into account immediately and that a penalty whose statutory basis later disappears must be lifted. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State quashed that decision on 05.03.2024: according to the Chamber, the deferral of the annulment also binds the executive and the judiciary, and acts established before the annulment took effect are reviewed under the provision kept in force. The regional administrative court insisted on its first decision; the university appealed the decision of insistence.
Outcome of the Decision
The Assembly accepted the appeal, quashed the decision of insistence and sent the file back to the regional administrative court for a new decision. The decision was given on 17.09.2025, finally and by majority. There is one dissenting opinion in the decision; as it is written in the plural, it appears that more than one member joined it, but the number cannot be determined from the text. Both the dissent and the Investigating Judge favoured upholding the decision of insistence.
Reasoning
Recalling that under Article 153 of the Constitution annulment decisions do not have retroactive effect, the Assembly explained what this principle means in administrative law:
“The significance of this principle for administrative law lies in the point that acts established before the annulment decision of the Constitutional Court do not directly become unlawful and that acts established within this scope are not left without a basis in terms of the "principle of legality".” (unofficial translation)
According to the Assembly, the annulment decision is also taken into account, together with its reasoning, in cases in an identical position:
“… it will also have to be taken into account in the judicial review of administrative acts established during the period when the underlying statutory provision was in force before the Constitutional Court’s annulment decision; when the Constitutional Court decision is applied, the effect on the administrative act of the forward-looking legal situation created by the removal of the underlying statutory provision from the date on which the Constitutional Court decision enters into force -having regard to the principle that Constitutional Court decisions do not have retroactive effect- will be determined by taking into account the reasoning of the decision.” (unofficial translation)
In the case at hand, the Assembly accepted that the penalty had been left without a legal basis because of the annulment. However, before the annulment took effect, Law No. 7437 had regulated student disciplinary penalties and the acts warranting them by listing them in the Law. The Assembly concluded as follows:
“In view of this situation, with respect to a disciplinary penalty left without a legal basis, if a new statutory regulation is made by the legislature after the Constitutional Court annuls a statutory article, the dispute must be resolved according to that regulation. The contrary approach would result in the acts committed going unpunished. … In that case, it has been concluded that the Regional Administrative Court must enter into the merits and assess whether the act alleged to have been committed by the claimant is proven, whether it warrants a disciplinary penalty and whether there is a more favourable provision, and then give a new decision according to the conclusion it reaches.” (unofficial translation)
Significance and Practical Effect
Three approaches appeared in the same file: the regional administrative court held that the penalty had to be lifted because of the annulment decision, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State that the act would be reviewed under the provision kept in force, and the Assembly, while accepting that the penalty had been left without a basis, that the dispute would be resolved under the law enacted after the annulment.
The limits of the decision are clear. The act in this case was organisation membership, as established by a final court judgment; current Article 54/1-d-1 likewise links this act to the penalty of expulsion. The claimant’s objections on limitation, the right of defence and not being punished twice for the same act were not discussed in the Assembly’s decision.
How the more favourable provision is compared is covered in the guide “Disciplinary Penalties for Student Cheating: Unlawfulness and Annulment under Turkish Law”, and the deletion of penalties from records in the note “Lack of Rules on Deleting Student Penalties Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on University Disciplinary Records”.
A search of Council of State decisions given after the date of the decision in the official case-law database (for the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, those accessible up to 15.01.2026; for the 8th Chamber, up to 03.03.2026), limited to summaries, found no decision changing this standard.
Relevant Legislation
“Laws, Presidential decrees or the Rules of Procedure of the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye, or provisions thereof, shall cease to have effect on the date on which the annulment decisions are published in the Official Gazette. Where necessary, the Constitutional Court may also decide on the date on which the annulment decision shall enter into force. That date shall not be more than one year from the date of publication of the decision in the Official Gazette.
…Annulment decisions shall not have retroactive effect.”
“d) Expulsion from the higher education institution: written notification to the student that he or she has been expelled from studentship, not to be admitted again to the higher education institution from which he or she was expelled. The acts requiring the penalty of expulsion from the higher education institution are as follows:
1) Provided that it has become final by a court decision, establishing an organisation for the purpose of committing crimes, managing such an organisation or being a member of an organisation established for that purpose,”
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Constitutional Court’s annulment of Article 54 automatically lift a student disciplinary penalty?
Under Turkish law, according to the decision of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State of 17.09.2025, it does not do so automatically. The Assembly accepted that the annulment left the penalty without a legal basis; however, since Article 54 was re-enacted by Law No. 7437 before the annulment took effect, it quashed the decision of insistence that had annulled the penalty solely on the basis of the annulment decision. The case will be examined on the merits under that regulation.
What will the court examine in a penalty imposed under the former Regulation?
According to the Assembly, if a new statutory regulation has been made after the annulment, the dispute is resolved according to that regulation. In this file, the regional administrative court will examine whether the act is proven, whether it warrants a disciplinary penalty and whether there is a more favourable provision.
Does the decision apply to every student disciplinary penalty?
The decision concerns an expulsion penalty imposed under the former Regulation and based on a final conviction for membership of an organisation. The Assembly’s standard rests on a new statutory regulation having been made after the annulment; in this file, the fate of the penalty will be decided by the regional administrative court’s review on the merits.
Is the Assembly’s decision final, and where did the file go?
The Assembly’s decision is final and was given by majority. The file was sent back to the regional administrative court for a new decision; the new decision given after the quashing could not be located.
Related Articles
- Unlawfulness and Annulment of Disciplinary Penalties Imposed for Student Cheating
- Lack of Rules on Deleting Student Penalties Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on University Disciplinary Records
- Disciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment Actions
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Higher education law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Higher Education Law
- Actions Against YÖK and University Acts in Türkiye: Which Administrative Court Has Territorial Jurisdiction?
- Research Assistant Requirements, 50/d and 33/a Posts, Term
- Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint Publications
- Research Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate Grounds
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Art. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/constitutional-court-annulment-student-discipline-penalty

























