Last reviewed:
Case NoteResearch Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate Grounds
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: In its decision of 25.11.2025, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State (Danıştay) stated that, although the administration has discretion in not renewing a research assistant’s (araştırma görevlisi) contract, the reasons must be shown concretely. Grounds of incompatibility and indiscipline not based on concrete findings, and a single 20-minute delay to an examination, did not justify non-renewal. According to the Chamber, academic staff at a foundation university enjoy the same professional security as those at a state university; a new ground raised during the proceedings does not on its own save the act. The decision was given as a final decision and by majority.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held, by majority and as a final decision, that not renewing a research assistant's contract requires concrete and proportionate reasons, that academic staff at foundation universities enjoy the same professional security as those at state universities, and that a new ground raised during the proceedings does not on its own save the act.
Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held unlawful the non-renewal of the contract of a research assistant, against whom no disciplinary investigation had been opened in respect of the alleged incompatibility and indiscipline, on abstract grounds and on the basis of a single delay to an examination.
The Dispute
The claimant was a research assistant who had worked since 2020 under a service contract at the law faculty of a university to which the decision applied the Regulation on Foundation (private, non-profit) Higher Education Institutions. The contract, due to expire on 31.08.2024, was not renewed, in line with a decision of the faculty board, on the ground of the claimant’s “incompatible working, performing assigned tasks incorrectly and undisciplined behaviour”. The concrete incidents in the file were these: on 23.11.2022 the claimant had been 20 minutes late to an examination at which the claimant was the invigilator and had been warned in writing; the faculty member to whom the claimant was attached had stated an unwillingness to work with the claimant, and the claimant had been attached to another faculty member at that request.
The administrative court annulled the act: the documents did not show the grounds concretely and objectively, and no disciplinary investigation had been opened on those matters. The regional administrative court, however, accepted the administration’s appeal and dismissed the action, assessing together the faculty member’s petition, the written warning and the reduction of the faculty’s student quotas from 2021 onwards. The claimant appealed in cassation.
Outcome of the Decision
The Chamber accepted the appeal, quashed the regional administrative court decision and sent the file back to that court for a new decision. The decision was given on 25.11.2025 as a final decision and by majority; one member wrote a dissenting opinion. No new decision given after the quashing could be found.
Reasoning
The Chamber accepted that the administration has discretion in reappointment, but recalled that this discretion is limited by the public interest and the requirements of the service and is subject to judicial review as to its grounds and purpose. It then explained how the reasons must be shown:
“Reasons must be set out concretely in acts not extending the term of office of academic staff working at universities. Otherwise, it is clear that holding lawful an act based solely on statements made by the defendant administrations that do not go beyond abstract allegations would also be contrary to the principle of written proceedings in administrative adjudication.” (unofficial translation)
On the protection of academic staff at a foundation university, it relied on Article 130 of the Constitution, the additional articles of Law No. 2547 on foundation higher education institutions and Article 23 of the Regulation on Foundation Higher Education Institutions:
“… an act terminating the contract of academic staff, or providing that it will not be renewed, without showing a substantial reason would harm the scientific freedom and professional security of academic staff, … no distinction is made between the professional security of academic staff working at foundation higher education institutions and that of academic staff working at state higher education institutions …” (unofficial translation)
It looked for the factual basis of the grounds in the case at hand:
“… no disciplinary investigation was opened against the claimant in this respect, and no concrete findings were made as to which of the claimant’s conduct disrupted the working order. … since it is understood that, during the period of service, the claimant was once 20 minutes late to an examination at which the claimant was the invigilator, was warned in writing about the matter, and the incident did not recur, relying on this matter alone as a ground for not renewing the contract would not be compatible with the principle of proportionality, which explains the relationship between means and end, and would also be contrary to equity.” (unofficial translation)
The Chamber found that the allegation that the claimant had interfered with the new assistant of the claimant’s former supervisor was not borne out by the correspondence in the file, and that the administration had not shown academic insufficiency either. On the student-number ground raised at the appeal stage, it said:
“Furthermore, although at the appeal (istinaf) stage the defendant administration also cited the decrease in the number of students at the faculty as a ground for not renewing the claimant’s contract, it is clear that no reason concerning this matter was stated at the stage when the act in dispute was adopted, and that this ground, raised while the case was pending, would not on its own render the act in dispute lawful.” (unofficial translation)
Significance and Practical Effect
The decision makes the standard applied to contract renewal concrete: the reason must rest on findings supported by documents; where a disciplinary ground is relied on, the conduct that caused the problem must be shown concretely; and a single, non-recurring delay does not on its own justify non-renewal.
The standard works both ways. In its decision of 30.01.2026, the Chamber held lawful the non-extension of the term of office of a lecturer (öğretim görevlisi) at another university (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2024/3833, K. 2026/421, 30.01.2026). There, the action brought against the disciplinary penalty imposed on the claimant for insulting a superior had been dismissed; the claimant had fulfilled only six of the twelve hours of teaching obligation, and a faculty member (doktor öğretim üyesi) had been appointed in the field the claimant taught. However, that decision also relied on facts arising after the act (the appointment of 08.08.2022 and the judicial review of the disciplinary penalty); it too was given by majority.
In the decision examined, the dissenting member argued that, unlike the termination of an ongoing contract, the burden of proof cannot be placed on the administration when an expired contract is not renewed; that otherwise contracts would be renewed indefinitely by court decisions unless an act established by an investigation existed; and that there can be no legitimate expectation in a fixed-term contract. The majority did not adopt this view. In the decisions accessible (up to 03.03.2026 for the 8th Chamber and 15.01.2026 for the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers), no later decision departing from this approach and no unification-of-case-law decision on the issue could be found.
In practice, it is decisive that the reason for non-renewal appears in the act itself, together with its supporting documents.
Relevant Legislation
At foundation higher education institutions, the working principles of academic staff are tied to the provisions for state universities; under the same paragraph of the Regulation, salary and other personnel rights are governed by Labour Law No. 4857.
“… they shall be appointed to research assistant posts for a period of at most three years; their duties end automatically at the end of the term of appointment. … They may be reappointed by the same procedure.” (unofficial translation)
“The working principles of academic and administrative staff to be employed at foundation higher education institutions are subject to the provisions laid down in Law No. 2547 for state universities.” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a research assistant's contract be left unrenewed?
Yes. Under Turkish law, Article 33/a of Law No. 2547 provides that research assistants are appointed for at most three years and that their duties end automatically at the end of the term; reappointment is at the administration’s discretion. According to the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, however, the reason for non-renewal must be shown concretely and must be proportionate.
Does a research assistant at a foundation university enjoy the same protection?
The Chamber stated that no distinction is made between the professional security of academic staff at foundation and state higher education institutions. Article 23 of the Regulation on Foundation Higher Education Institutions also subjects their working principles to the provisions for state universities; salary and other personnel rights are governed by the Labour Law.
Is a written warning or being late to an examination enough for non-renewal?
In this decision, no. The Chamber found that relying on a single 20-minute delay, which was met with a written warning and did not recur, as the sole ground for non-renewal was contrary to the principle of proportionality and to equity. The outcome depends on the concrete circumstances of each case.
Can the administration raise a new ground during the proceedings?
According to the Chamber, a ground that was not stated when the act was adopted and is raised while the case is pending does not on its own render the act lawful. For this reason, the decrease in student numbers added at the appeal stage did not save the act in this case.
Related Articles
- No Age-35 Limit on Research Assistant Reappointment: Turkish Council of State on Article 33 of Law No. 2547
- Disciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment Actions
- Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings at Universities
- Doctoral Withdrawal Ends a 50/d Research Assistant Post: Turkish Council of State Leaves the 33/a Transfer Request Outside the Case
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Higher education law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Higher Education Law
- Actions Against YÖK and University Acts in Türkiye: Which Administrative Court Has Territorial Jurisdiction?
- Research Assistant Requirements, 50/d and 33/a Posts, Term
- Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint Publications
- Art. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Research Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate Grounds”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/research-assistant-contract-non-renewal-concrete-reasons

























