Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Practice Area

Higher Education Law

Higher education law attorney Bayram Can Çapar: disciplinary investigations of students and academic staff; acts of the Council of Higher Education and universities.

This page explains Turkish law. It is an English version of the Turkish page; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In higher education, students and academic staff may face disciplinary investigations, examination and credit-transfer decisions and various administrative measures. Reviewing these acts in terms of procedure and substance is of great importance.

The office represents clients in disciplinary proceedings concerning students and academic staff, objections to acts of the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) and universities, and equivalence and credit-transfer disputes.

Key Legislation

The statutes are linked to the official Turkish Legislation Information System (mevzuat.gov.tr); the texts there are in Turkish.

Competent Courts and Authorities

Our office is in Denizli. Below are the courts and authorities seised in disputes in this field in Denizli and in the other provinces where we follow cases; each entry links to its official source.

Denizli

Aegean: İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya

İzmir

Aydın

Muğla

Manisa

Uşak

Afyonkarahisar

Kütahya

İstanbul and Ankara

İstanbul

Ankara

Articles in This Area (21)

Associate professorship (doçentlik)

Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint PublicationsHigher Education LawAssoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint PublicationsUnder Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State finally held, by majority, that an associate professor appointment was unlawful where it relied on the reports of a jury including a professor with several joint articles and papers with the appointee, and was made as if there were a single candidate although an expert had found that both candidates met the minimum conditions.Residence Rule Upheld for Assoc. Prof. Language Exams Abroad: Turkish Council of State on the 2022 GuideHigher Education LawResidence Rule Upheld for Assoc. Prof. Language Exams Abroad: Turkish Council of State on the 2022 GuideUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State found the provision of the 2022 March Term Associate Professorship Application Guide requiring associate professor candidates who sit a foreign language exam abroad to document at least six months’ residence in the exam country up to and including the exam date, not contrary to the public interest and the requirements of the service, and also held lawful the cancellation of the application of a candidate who did not submit a residence certificate. The decision was given at first instance and unanimously; since an appeal is open, it may not be final.Excluding Associate Degree Courses Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on 2023 Associate Professor CriteriaHigher Education LawExcluding Associate Degree Courses Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on 2023 Associate Professor CriteriaUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State annulled the omission of associate degree courses from the 2023 associate professorship application requirements and upheld the other contested rules. The decision is subject to appeal in cassation.Associate Professorship in Türkiye: Application Requirements and Annulment Action Against a Negative ResultHigher Education LawAssociate Professorship in Türkiye: Application Requirements and Annulment Action Against a Negative ResultUnder Turkish law, an application for associate professorship requires a doctorate, at least 55 points in a central foreign language examination and original publications set for each field; the Interuniversity Board's jury assesses the file through detailed and reasoned reports. An annulment action against a negative result is brought against the Presidency of the Interuniversity Board within sixty days before the administrative courts of Ankara; Higher Education Law No. 2547 art. 24, the Associate Professorship Regulation and Council of State decisions.

Appointment of faculty members and vacancy announcements

Appointing a Markedly Lower Scorer Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Assistant Professor RankingsHigher Education LawAppointing a Markedly Lower Scorer Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Assistant Professor RankingsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, holding unlawful the appointment of a candidate with a markedly lower score to an assistant professor post by departing from the objective ranking in the expert report, quashed the regional administrative court’s dismissal finally and by majority; as the top-ranked candidate had not sued, the Chamber held that the administration must annul the appointment and re-advertise the post.Split Experts in Professor Case Need New Panel: Turkish Council of State on Conflicting Expert ReportsHigher Education LawSplit Experts in Professor Case Need New Panel: Turkish Council of State on Conflicting Expert ReportsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State stated that, in a professor appointment where both candidates met the advertised requirements, the administration must compare them on objective and verifiable criteria of merit and scientific competence. As the expert panel was divided on which candidate was superior, it held that the dispute must be resolved with the report of a new panel of different persons and quashed the regional administrative court’s dismissal finally and unanimously.Annulling Faculty Appointments in Türkiye: Appointment and Promotion Criteria, Non-Appointment, Non-RenewalHigher Education LawAnnulling Faculty Appointments in Türkiye: Appointment and Promotion Criteria, Non-Appointment, Non-RenewalUnder Turkish law, annulment actions against non-appointment to assistant professor, associate professor and professor posts and against non-reappointment: criteria under Law No. 2547 and the Regulation, YÖK-approved institutional criteria, limits of discretion, time limits and Council of State decisions.Annulling Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings in Türkiye: University Vacancies Drafted for One CandidateHigher Education LawAnnulling Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings in Türkiye: University Vacancies Drafted for One CandidateAnnulment actions against academic job postings tailored to one candidate: Constitution, Law No. 2547, regulations, time limits, standing, Council of State rulings.

Terms of office; research assistant and lecturer posts

Research Assistant Requirements, 50/d and 33/a Posts, TermHigher Education LawResearch Assistant Requirements, 50/d and 33/a Posts, TermUnder Turkish law, applying for a research assistant post requires at least 70 in ALES, at least 50 points in a central foreign language examination, not having reached the age of 35 on 1 January of the year of the entrance examination and, at state universities, postgraduate studentship; candidates go through a pre-assessment and a written entrance examination. Appointments are made under Article 50/d of Law No. 2547 using the procedure in Article 33; a 50/d post depends on postgraduate education, while a 33/a appointment lasts at most three years; the Central Examination Regulation and Council of State decisions.Research Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate GroundsHigher Education LawResearch Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate GroundsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held, by majority and as a final decision, that not renewing a research assistant's contract requires concrete and proportionate reasons, that academic staff at foundation universities enjoy the same professional security as those at state universities, and that a new ground raised during the proceedings does not on its own save the act.YÖK Paragraph Barring Court-Backed Appointments Annulled: Turkish Council of State on YLSY (Law No. 1416)Higher Education LawYÖK Paragraph Barring Court-Backed Appointments Annulled: Turkish Council of State on YLSY (Law No. 1416)Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld, on the same reasoning, the annulment of the paragraph of a YÖK general letter stating that those deemed unsuccessful under Law No. 1416 could not be appointed to teaching staff posts even by court decisions, as contrary to the administration’s duty to comply with judicial decisions. The Assembly also accepted that the scholarship holder whose ties with the university were severed had standing to challenge the whole letter, quashed the partial dismissal for lack of standing and sent the file back to the 8th Chamber for that part.Rector Holds Power Not to Extend Assistant Professor Terms: Turkish Council of State on Vice-Rector DecisionHigher Education LawRector Holds Power Not to Extend Assistant Professor Terms: Turkish Council of State on Vice-Rector DecisionUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, in a final and unanimous decision quashing a regional administrative court judgment that had rejected the appeal, held that an act not extending an assistant professor's term, signed by a vice-rector, was unlawful for lack of authority because Article 23 of Law No. 2547 gives that power to the rector and contains no express provision for its delegation; as the merits were not examined, lost financial rights could not be granted directly at this stage.Doctoral Withdrawal Ends a 50/d Research Assistant Post: Turkish Council of State; 33/a Request Is SeparateHigher Education LawDoctoral Withdrawal Ends a 50/d Research Assistant Post: Turkish Council of State; 33/a Request Is SeparateUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held that a post under Article 50/d of Law No. 2547 is support limited to the duration of postgraduate education and that ties with the post must be severed when that education ends for any reason, finding lawful the severance of a research assistant who had the doctoral registration deleted at their own request; it left the 33/a request made around the same time outside the case. The Chamber quashed, finally and by majority, the regional administrative court decision rejecting the appeal, and the file was sent back to that court for a new decision.No Regulatory Gap for Staff Already Over the Norm Cadre: Turkish Council of State on University StaffHigher Education LawNo Regulatory Gap for Staff Already Over the Norm Cadre: Turkish Council of State on University StaffUnder Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld the 8th Chamber’s decision rejecting the claim of incomplete regulation, because provisional Article 1 of the norm cadre regulation provides that teaching staff in excess of the norm cadre when it entered into force, and those appointed to posts advertised before then, continue to serve in their posts. The Chamber had also found lawful planning up to twice the minimum cadre and the maximum ratio for the same title; the ratio provision was amended both before and after the decision.Lecturer Term Non-Extension Held Lawful on Combined Grounds: Turkish Council of State on Three FactsHigher Education LawLecturer Term Non-Extension Held Lawful on Combined Grounds: Turkish Council of State on Three FactsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held lawful the non-extension of a lecturer’s term of office, assessing together that the precondition in Article 31 of Law No. 2547 had ceased to exist with the later appointment of an assistant professor to the field taught, that the action against a disciplinary penalty had been dismissed and that only 6 hours of the 12-hour teaching load had been fulfilled. The Chamber quashed, finally and by majority, the regional administrative court decision rejecting the appeal, and the file was sent back to that court.No Age-35 Limit on Research Assistant Reappointment: Turkish Council of State on Article 33 of Law No. 2547Higher Education LawNo Age-35 Limit on Research Assistant Reappointment: Turkish Council of State on Article 33 of Law No. 2547Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State unanimously and finally held that the age-35 condition in Article 33 of Law No. 2547 applies only to the first application for a research assistant post, not to the reappointment of a research assistant who met it on taking up the post.

Discipline: academics and students

Art. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437Higher Education LawArt. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State did not regard the Constitutional Court’s annulment of Article 54 of Law No. 2547 as sufficient on its own to annul a student disciplinary penalty imposed under the former Regulation, and required a review on the merits, under the provision re-enacted by Law No. 7437 before the annulment took effect, of the proof of the act, whether it warrants the penalty and the more favourable provision. The Assembly quashed, finally and by majority, the regional administrative court’s decision of insistence that had annulled the penalty solely because of the annulment decision, and the file was sent back to that court for a new decision.Missing Rules on Deleting Student Penalties Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Disciplinary RecordsHigher Education LawMissing Rules on Deleting Student Penalties Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Disciplinary RecordsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, ruling at first instance and by majority, held that the absence of a clear rule on keeping higher education students’ disciplinary penalties on record and deleting them after certain conditions and a certain period breaches legal security, legal certainty and proportionality, and annulled the implied refusal of the application asking the Council of Higher Education to regulate the matter and the dean’s act based on it.Disciplinary Penalties for Student Cheating: Unlawfulness and Annulment under Turkish LawHigher Education LawDisciplinary Penalties for Student Cheating: Unlawfulness and Annulment under Turkish LawUnlawfulness and annulment of disciplinary penalties imposed for a student cheating in an exam: the disciplinary treatment of cheating (Higher Education Law No. 2547, art. 54 — reprimand for attempted cheating, one-semester suspension for cheating or enabling cheating, two-semester suspension for cheating by threat; the provision that replaced the Student Discipline Regulation repealed in 2023), the right of defence and investigation procedure (art. 54/5-6), proof of cheating by concrete evidence and expert report, proportionality and the problem of a separate penalty per course, the criminal-disciplinary relationship (art. 54/6-ğ), objection, the annulment action, the sixty-day time limit (Administrative Procedure Code art. 7) and the appeal route (art. 46, including the amendment by Law No. 7589), with decisions from files upheld by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State.Disciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment ActionsHigher Education LawDisciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment ActionsA guide to disciplinary penalties on academics in Türkiye and annulment actions: the special regime of Law No. 2547 and its differences from the civil-servant regime; penalty types (art. 53/b); the legality principle shaped by Constitutional Court annulments; investigation procedure, statement-taking and the right of defence (art. 53/A, as amended by Law No. 7592); limitation (art. 53/C); mandatory ethics-board and expert examination in plagiarism cases; the 60-day period, regional appeal and cassation only for removal penalties (APL art. 46) - with verified Council of State (8th Chamber) decisions in the university cases.

Key Decisions

Leading decisions of the Turkish high courts in this area. Headings, citations and quotations are given in the original Turkish; the linked articles explain them in English.

Devamsızlık eden akademisyen müstafi sayılamaz; 2547'ye göre soruşturulur

“2547 sayılı Kanun kapsamında disiplin cezası uygulanması gereken uyuşmazlığın, daha farklı sonuçları olan idari bir tasarrufa konu edilmesi hukuka uygun olmayacaktır.…davacı hakkında durumun ilgili Kanun uyarınca yapılacak bir soruşturma ile tespit edilerek, bunun sonucuna göre işlem tesis edilmesi gerekmekte iken, görevinden çekilmiş sayılması yönünde 657 sayılı Kanun'un 94. maddesi uyarınca tesis edilen dava konusu işlemde hukuka uyarlık bulunmadığı sonucuna varılmıştır.”

Explanation in English →

İntihal davasında bilirkişi incelemesi zorunludur; avans davacıya yüklenemez

“re'sen araştırma ilkesi gereği, hakim tarafından maddi gerçeğin ortaya çıkarılmasını teminen, dava konusu uyuşmazlığın teknik bir konu olması ve hâkimlik mesleğinin gerektirdiği genel ve hukuki bilgiyle çözümlenmesinin mümkün olmaması nedeniyle bilirkişi incelemesi yaptırılmasını zorunlu kıldığından…avansın yargılama sonucu haksız çıkan taraftan alınmak şartıyla, öncelikle davalı idareden istenilmesi, davalı idarece yatırılmaması halinde Hazineden karşılanarak bilirkişi incelemesi yaptırılması gerekirken”

Explanation in English →

Kadro ilanındaki ek koşul kişiyi mi tarif ediyor, alana katkı mı sağlıyor?

“bu takdir hakkı, serbestçe ve keyfi şekilde kullanılanabilecek bir durumu ifade etmeyip, kamu yararı ve hizmet gerekleri açısından hukuka uygun olarak temellendirilmiş olgularla desteklenmelidir.…hükme esas alınacak bilirkişi raporunda dava konusu ek koşulun kişiyi tarif eder, keyfi, subjektif nitelikte mi yoksa ilgi bilim alanında ihtisaslaşmaya katkı sağlayan akademik bir değer mi taşıdığı hususunun incelenmesi”

Explanation in English →

Araştırma görevlisini yeniden atamada takdir, hizmet gereğiyle sınırlıdır

“idarenin öğretim yardımcısı statüsünde olan ve 2547 sayılı Kanun'un 33/a maddesi uyarınca ataması yapılan araştırma görevlilerinin görev sürelerini uzatıp uzatmama konusunda takdir yetkisine sahip olduğu; ancak takdir yetkisine dayanan her idari işlemde olduğu gibi bu takdir yetkisini kamu yararı ve hizmet gereklerini göz önünde bulundurarak kullanması gerektiği açıktır.…öğrenci alımı yapılamayan bölümde akademik personel istihdamının kamu yararı ve hizmet gerekleri ile bağdaşmayacağı açık”

Explanation in English →

Araştırma görevlisinde 35 yaş şartı yeniden atamada aranmaz

“araştırma görevliliği kadrolarına ilk başvuru halinde aranacak, araştırma görevliliği giriş sınavına ilişkin bir şart olup önceden araştırma görevlisi olarak görev yapan kişilere uygulanması mümkün değildir.…Yeniden atama durumunda otuz beş yaşını doldurmamış olma şartı aranmadığından, olayda idarenin bağlı yetkisi de söz konusu değildir.”

Explanation in English →

Ölçütü belirlenmemiş yağmacı dergi yasağıyla doçentlik başvurusu iptal edilemez

“Kişilerin, haklarını kullanırken hangi kısıtlamalara tabi olacağını önceden bilmesi ve bu kısıtlamaların da somut, objektif ve öngörülebilir nitelikte ve netlikte olması gerekmektedir.…jüri üyelerince yapılacak doçentlik değerlendirmesinde hangi ölçüt ve kriterlerin esas alınacağının objektif, net ve anlaşılır şekilde ortaya konulmadığı ve öngörülebilir olmadığı anlaşıldığından, Yükseköğretim Genel Kurulunun 07/03/2019 tarih ve 2019.3.88 sayılı kararının hukuki güvenlik ve belirlilik ilkelerine aykırı olduğu sonucuna varılmıştır.”

Explanation in English →

Recent Case Notes

Frequently Asked Questions

I received a student disciplinary penalty. What can I do?

It is examined whether the investigation was conducted in accordance with the procedure; the penalty can be reviewed through an administrative objection and an action for annulment brought in time.

Where can a university's decision be challenged?

Depending on the nature of the act, an administrative objection and the administrative courts are available. As the periods are short, the date of notification matters.

Can I challenge a refusal of equivalence or credit transfer?

Yes, an administrative action is available against unlawful refusals.

Scope of Our Services

At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

  • Student disciplinary investigations and objections to penalties
  • Disciplinary and appointment disputes of academic staff
  • Administrative actions against acts of the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) and universities
  • Credit-transfer, equivalence and enrolment disputes
  • Objections to examination and assessment decisions
Would you like to discuss this matter?

Send your request and we will get back to you shortly.

Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk · Phone: +90 258 241 55 54 · Email: info@capar.av.tr

Contact / Request a Meeting →

Other Practice Areas

Latest Articles

All articles ›