Last reviewed:
Case NoteNo Regulatory Gap for Staff Already Over the Norm Cadre: Turkish Council of State on University Staff
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: In its decision of 20.01.2025, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State (Danıştay İdari Dava Daireleri Kurulu) upheld the decision of the 8th Chamber of the Council of State dismissing an action brought against the regulation on teaching staff norm cadres (norm kadro) in state higher education institutions. According to the upheld reasoning, there is no incomplete regulation: provisional Article 1 provides that those in excess of the norm cadre on 02.11.2018, when the Regulation entered into force, and those appointed to posts advertised before that date continue to serve in the posts they hold. The Chamber also found lawful planning up to twice the minimum cadre and the maximum ratio for the same title. The decision did not address surpluses arising later; the ratio provision was amended both before and after the decision.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld the 8th Chamber’s decision rejecting the claim of incomplete regulation, because provisional Article 1 of the norm cadre regulation provides that teaching staff in excess of the norm cadre when it entered into force, and those appointed to posts advertised before then, continue to serve in their posts. The Chamber had also found lawful planning up to twice the minimum cadre and the maximum ratio for the same title; the ratio provision was amended both before and after the decision.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld a Chamber decision rejecting, on the basis of the Regulation’s transitional provision, the claim of incomplete regulation as regards teaching staff in excess of the norm cadre.
The Dispute
A trade union sought the annulment of the purpose and legal basis articles of the Regulation published on 02.11.2018, of paragraphs 2, 4, 6 and 7 of Article 4 on norm cadre planning, of paragraph 4 of Article 5 on the same-title ratio, and of the incomplete regulation consisting in the failure to regulate how teaching staff in excess of the norm cadre (norm kadro fazlası) are to be identified and what treatment they are to receive. It also asked that the Constitutional Court be applied to in respect of the underlying provision, paragraph 4 of Article 11 of Presidential Decree No. 2 on General Cadres and Procedure.
The 8th Chamber of the Council of State, hearing the case at first instance, dismissed it on 17.11.2022. On appeal, the union argued that changes concerning the work and personal rights of faculty members must be made by statute and that provisional Article 1 does not regulate how teaching staff in excess of the norm cadre are to be identified.
Outcome of the Decision
The Assembly did not consider the allegation of unconstitutionality serious, rejected the appeal and upheld the Chamber’s decision. The decision was given on 20.01.2025, finally and by majority. There is one dissenting opinion: the member stated that norm cadres affect the personal rights of teaching staff and must, under Article 130 of the Constitution, be regulated exclusively by statute, and voted for quashing. The Investigating Judge (Tetkik Hâkimi) was also of the view that the matter should be referred to the Constitutional Court.
Reasoning
The Assembly did not write reasoning of its own; it upheld the Chamber’s decision with a general upholding sentence:
“… having found the allegation of unconstitutionality not serious, the matter was considered: … The decision examined on appeal is in accordance with procedure and law, and the allegations raised in the appeal petition have not been considered such as to require the quashing of the decision.” (unofficial translation)
The substantive reasoning is in the Chamber’s decision. The quotation below is taken not from the Chamber’s decision itself but from the summary of it in the Assembly’s decision:
“… it was concluded that there was no incomplete regulation, since provisional Article 1 of the Regulation, headed ‘Transitional provisions’, provides that teaching staff in excess of the norm cadre in a department, main discipline/main art discipline or vocational school programme on the date the regulation entered into force will continue to serve in the posts they hold, … and that, as regards teaching staff posts advertised before the date the Regulation entered into force, … those appointed will continue to serve in the posts they hold even if they create a surplus over the norm cadre” (unofficial translation)
According to the summary, the Chamber stated that the use of teaching staff posts was regulated on the basis of the power conferred on the Presidency of the Council of Higher Education by paragraph 4 of Article 11 of Presidential Decree No. 2, and that the challenged paragraphs of Article 4 were made with regard to the requirements of the service and the public interest. It also found the same-title ratio lawful, considering it aimed at preventing a single post title from dominating units and at removing the accumulation in professor posts at developed universities.
Significance and Practical Effect
The test in the upheld reasoning is provisional Article 1. The provision protects two groups: teaching staff who, on 02.11.2018, were in excess of the norm cadre in a department, main discipline/main art discipline or vocational school programme, and those appointed to posts advertised before that date. The position of those who became surplus to the norm cadre after the Regulation entered into force was not addressed in the decision. Under Article 6 of the Regulation, however, its provisions do not apply to appointments amounting to an extension of the term of office of those employed in posts within its scope; this provision was not discussed in the decision.
The Chamber also set out the amendments of 03.03.2022 made after the action was brought: norm cadres beyond the minimum cadre are now planned by the rector after obtaining the relevant boards’ opinion, and the same-title ratio rose from 2/3 to 3/4. The exceptions to the ratio changed again on 15.01.2023, after the Chamber’s decision, and on 21.05.2025, after the Assembly’s decision: the exception for “assistant professor posts” (doktor öğretim üyesi kadroları) in the 2022 text set out in the decision now reads “faculty member posts” (öğretim üyesi kadroları) in the current text, with a marker of a repealed phrase. The decision’s assessment of the ratio does not cover these later amendments. Provisional Article 1 and the rule on planning up to twice the minimum, by contrast, have not changed.
In our assessment, in practice the first question is whether the person falls within provisional Article 1: were they in excess of the norm cadre on 02.11.2018, or were they appointed to a post advertised before that date?
In a keyword search for “norm kadro” and “norm kadro fazlası” (at the level of result summaries) in Council of State decisions entered in the database after this decision (up to 15.01.2026 for the Assembly and up to 03.03.2026 for the 8th Chamber), no decision departing from this decision of the Assembly was found. Nor did a keyword search of the Constitutional Court’s norm review decisions given after this decision (those entered up to 08.09.2026, at the level of subject summaries) show any decision concerning the underlying Presidential Decree provision.
Relevant Legislation
The texts below are the current version of the Regulation.
“(1) Teaching staff in excess of the norm cadre in a department, main discipline/main art discipline or vocational school programme on the date this Regulation enters into force shall continue to serve in the posts they hold. Vacant and reserved teaching staff posts shall be transferred to the rectorate.
(2) Appointment procedures for teaching staff posts advertised before the date this Regulation enters into force shall be completed under the legislation in force without taking the provisions of this Regulation into account. Those appointed to these posts shall continue to serve in the posts they hold even if they create a surplus over the norm cadre.”
“(4) … In all appointments exceeding the minimum teaching staff cadre number, at most 3/4 of the posts, including the minimum cadres, may be used for the same title. If the figure resulting from this calculation is fractional, it is rounded down. This requirement does not apply to … faculty member posts in units for which the Council of Higher Education has decided that faculty members are difficult to recruit, or in … research universities, in units that assign faculty members for at least two semesters under the Council of Higher Education Academic Mobility Project and in vocational schools.”
Amendment markers in the official text are omitted and shown as ….
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens to teaching staff who were in excess of the norm cadre when the Regulation entered into force?
Under Turkish law, provisional Article 1 provides that they continue to serve in the posts they hold; those appointed to posts advertised before the Regulation also remain in their posts even if they create a surplus over the norm cadre. The Council of State did not accept the claim of incomplete regulation because of this provision.
Does the decision also cover those who later became surplus to the norm cadre?
No. The upheld reasoning rests on provisional Article 1; surpluses arising after the Regulation entered into force were not addressed in the decision.
What is the maximum ratio for the same title today?
Under the current text, in appointments exceeding the minimum cadre number at most 3/4 of the posts may be used for the same title; the requirement does not apply in certain units, research universities and vocational schools. The 2023 and 2025 amendments were not assessed in the decision.
What became of the allegation that the underlying Presidential Decree provision is unconstitutional?
The Assembly did not consider the allegation serious and did not refer the matter to the Constitutional Court. One member argued in a dissenting opinion that norm cadres must be regulated by statute.
- Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings: Challenging University Vacancies Drafted for One Candidate under Turkish Law
- Rector Holds Power Not to Extend Assistant Professor Terms: Turkish Council of State Finds a Vice-Rector's Non-Extension Unlawful
- No Age-35 Limit on Research Assistant Reappointment: Turkish Council of State on Article 33 of Law No. 2547
Related Articles
- Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings at Universities
- Rector Holds Power Not to Extend Assistant Professor Terms: Turkish Council of State Finds a Vice-Rector's Non-Extension Unlawful
- No Age-35 Limit on Research Assistant Reappointment: Turkish Council of State on Article 33 of Law No. 2547
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Higher education law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Higher Education Law
- Actions Against YÖK and University Acts in Türkiye: Which Administrative Court Has Territorial Jurisdiction?
- Research Assistant Requirements, 50/d and 33/a Posts, Term
- Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint Publications
- Art. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “No Regulatory Gap for Staff Already Over the Norm Cadre: Turkish Council of State on University Staff”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/norm-cadre-surplus-teaching-staff-keep-posts

























