Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 9 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Appointing a Markedly Lower Scorer Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Assistant Professor Rankings

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: In its decision of 08.12.2025, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State (Danıştay) held unlawful an assistant professor (doktor öğretim üyesi) appointment of a candidate with a markedly lower score. The appointment had been made by departing from the objective ranking in the expert report, and the Chamber quashed, finally and by majority, the regional administrative court’s dismissal based on the absence of clear superiority among the candidates. According to the Chamber, as the top-ranked candidate did not sue, the administration must annul the appointment, re-advertise the post and assess the candidates objectively. The decision does not result in the claimant being appointed automatically.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, holding unlawful the appointment of a candidate with a markedly lower score to an assistant professor post by departing from the objective ranking in the expert report, quashed the regional administrative court’s dismissal finally and by majority; as the top-ranked candidate had not sued, the Chamber held that the administration must annul the appointment and re-advertise the post.

Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held unlawful, as exceeding the limits of discretion, the appointment to an assistant professor post of a candidate with a markedly lower score, made by departing from the expert’s objective score ranking.

The Dispute

A university advertised one assistant professor post in the urbanisation and environmental problems section of its public administration department. The advertisement contained a post-specific condition of “having work in the fields of urbanisation and public economics”. Five candidates applied and the administration appointed one of them; the claimant sought annulment of the act rejecting their application. A separate annulment action brought by the claimant against the advertisement and its special condition had been dismissed and that decision had become final.

In the expert examination ordered by the administrative court, the candidates were ranked on merit with scores of 222.7, 210.5, 162, 122 and 105, and the top-ranked candidate, who did not sue, was reported to be the most suitable option for the post. The claimant ranked third and the appointee ranked below the claimant. The experts could not find in the file the scientific justification for the “public economics” part of the special condition. The administrative court annulled the act.

The regional administrative court did not accept the experts’ exclusion of public economics work from the assessment; it stated that, if that work were counted, the appointee would move ahead of the claimant and that no candidate was clearly superior to the others, and dismissed the action. The claimant appealed, arguing that the appointee was an engineering faculty graduate and that the advertisement had been tailored to a particular person.

Outcome of the Decision

The 8th Chamber of the Council of State accepted the appeal, quashed the regional administrative court’s decision and sent the file back to that court for a new decision. The decision was given on 08.12.2025, finally and by majority. The single dissenting opinion argues for upholding on the ground that no candidate was clearly superior. The Chamber’s reasoning does not address the allegation of a tailor-made advertisement.

Reasoning

The Chamber first set out the limits of the administration’s discretion:

Council of State Decision

“Judicial review of discretion is limited to whether it complies with the law, the principle of equality and the public interest. … in the dispute, the discretion must be determined first within the limits set by the relevant legislation, in line with the aims envisaged by Law No. 2547 and on the basis of objective criteria, and thus in a manner allowing judicial review of whether it has been exercised lawfully.” (unofficial translation)

The Chamber noted that there was also a score difference between the claimant and the candidate recommended by the expert, and concluded as follows:

Council of State Decision

“In the dispute, in the comparison made on the basis of the academic scores obtained by the candidates through their academic and scientific work, it is understood that, although the claimant’s score is above the score of the person appointed to the post, it is lower than that of the candidate who, according to the expert report set out above, should be appointed to the post …. In that case, the defendant administration’s act appointing a candidate with a markedly lower score by departing from the objective ranking is not lawful.” (unofficial translation)

The Chamber also set out the consequence of the top-ranked candidate not having challenged the act:

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2024/5427, K. 2025/9592, 08.12.2025 (the Chamber’s reasoning on the act expected from the administration)

“Nevertheless, considering that the first-ranked candidate did not challenge the act, it is clear that the defendant administration will annul the appointment, re-advertise the post, assess the applicant candidates objectively and make the appointment to the post.” (unofficial translation)

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision does not require the appointment of the highest-scoring candidate; the test is a departure from the objective ranking combined with a markedly lower score of the appointee. In this case, although the top-ranked candidate had not sued, the action of the claimant, who ranked above the appointee, was enough to establish the unlawfulness of the act. A different dispute concerning the appointment of scholarship holders who completed postgraduate studies abroad is described in our article on the annulled YÖK paragraph barring court-ordered appointment of YLSY scholarship holders.

On the same day, the Chamber quashed on the same reasoning the decision in the case of another candidate who had applied under the same advertisement (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2025/4163, K. 2025/9593, 08.12.2025). Three days later, in an associate professor post case, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers stated that where the candidates’ scientific work is very close or equal, the administration’s discretion becomes important; however, it based the quashing not on the score difference but on the composition of the jury and on the act having been established as if there were a single candidate (Council of State, Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2025/9, K. 2025/3131, 11.12.2025).

Note: In an associate professor post decision of 31.12.2025, although the claimant’s score was about four times that of the appointee, the Chamber concluded that this advantage did not stem from publications in the advertised field and did not find the claimant’s non-appointment unlawful (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2025/4363, K. 2025/10658, 31.12.2025; by majority; one of the two dissenting opinions concerns the reasoning only). In both decisions the Chamber relied on the expert report: in the 31.12.2025 decision the expert found the appointee suitable, while in the decision discussed here the expert recommended the top-ranked candidate. The Chamber did not separately discuss the regional administrative court’s view that the appointee moved ahead once “public economics” work was counted.

In the decisions accessible after this decision (up to 03.03.2026 for the 8th Chamber and 15.01.2026 for the Assembly), no decision changing this test and no unification-of-case-law decision was found; in its decision of 30.01.2026, the Chamber also held that an annulment judgment given without comparing the academic scores of the claimant and the appointee in the expert report was based on incomplete examination (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2024/3974, K. 2026/420, 30.01.2026). In practice, it is important that the board sets out its preference with scientific reasons.

Relevant Legislation

Article 23 of Law No. 2547 and Article 6/1–4 of the Regulation, as set out in the decision, remain in force with the same text today.

Statutory Provision — Higher Education Law (Law No. 2547) art. 23/c (Assistant professor)

“c) Higher education institutions may, with the approval of the Council of Higher Education, set additional conditions of an objective and verifiable nature for appointment to assistant professor posts, aimed exclusively at enhancing scientific quality and taking into account the differences between scientific disciplines.” (unofficial translation)

Regulatory Provision — Regulation on Promotion and Appointment to Faculty Membership art. 6/4 (Application and appointment process)

“(4) After the written opinions have been obtained, the dean or the relevant director obtains, at the first meeting of the board of directors, its opinion on the candidate or candidates separately. Where more than one candidate applies for one vacant post, the board of directors states its preference with reasons. The dean or the relevant director submits his or her views and proposals to the rector. The rector decides whether the appointment will be made and carries out the necessary procedures.” (unofficial translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

Must the candidate with the highest score be appointed to an assistant professor post?

Under Turkish law, the decision does not lay down such a general rule. The Chamber held unlawful the appointment of a candidate with a markedly lower score made by departing from the objective ranking. According to the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, where the candidates’ scientific work is very close or equal, the administration’s discretion becomes important.

What happens if the top-ranked candidate does not sue?

In this case, according to the Chamber, the administration annuls the appointment, re-advertises the post and makes an appointment after assessing the applicants objectively.

Is the claimant appointed directly to the post?

Not in this decision. The claimant was not first in the expert’s ranking; the outcome is not the claimant’s appointment but a new advertisement and a fresh assessment of the candidates.

Is a higher score decisive in every case?

No. In a decision of 31.12.2025, the Chamber did not find unlawful the non-appointment of a higher-scoring candidate in a file where it was established that the score advantage did not stem from publications in the advertised field.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Higher Education Law

All Higher Education Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Appointing a Markedly Lower Scorer Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Assistant Professor Rankings”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/assistant-professor-appointment-objective-score-ranking

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›