Last reviewed:
Case NoteSplit Experts in Professor Case Need New Panel: Turkish Council of State on Conflicting Expert Reports
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: In its decision of 02.02.2026, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State (Danıştay) stated that, in a professor (profesör) appointment where both candidates met the advertised requirements, the administration could not rely only on the formal requirements and had to compare the candidates on objective and verifiable criteria in terms of merit and scientific competence. As the expert panel was divided on which candidate was superior, it considered necessary a comparative examination of quality by a new panel of different persons and quashed, finally and unanimously, the regional administrative court’s decision dismissing the action on grounds of discretion. The decision does not result in the claimant’s appointment; the file went back to the regional administrative court for a new decision.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State stated that, in a professor appointment where both candidates met the advertised requirements, the administration must compare them on objective and verifiable criteria of merit and scientific competence. As the expert panel was divided on which candidate was superior, it held that the dispute must be resolved with the report of a new panel of different persons and quashed the regional administrative court’s dismissal finally and unanimously.
Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State considered a report by a new expert panel necessary in a professor appointment where both candidates met the requirements, because the panel was divided on which candidate was superior.
The Dispute
A university advertised a professor post in its public administration section, with an additional condition of holding the associate professor (doçent) title in a particular field and having work on particular subjects. Of the two applicants, the other candidate was appointed; the claimant sought annulment of the acts concerning their non-appointment and the appointment of another person to the post.
In the expert examination ordered by the administrative court, the panel unanimously reported that both candidates met the conditions, that the claimant’s works were greater in number and that the jury members’ preference rested on subjective views. The additional report obtained at the stay-of-execution stage at the request of the regional administrative court was adopted by majority: the majority maintained its earlier view, while the dissenting member found the appointee’s work superior and criticised the technical depth of the other members. The administrative court annulled the act.
The regional administrative court dismissed the action, stating that both candidates met the requirements and that the university had exercised its discretion in view of its academic needs and priorities. The claimant appealed.
Outcome of the Decision
The 8th Chamber of the Council of State accepted the appeal, quashed the regional administrative court’s decision and sent the file back to that court for a new decision. The decision was given on 02.02.2026, finally and unanimously.
Reasoning
The Chamber first set out the limits of discretion:
“… it is one of the settled principles of administrative law that the discretion held by administrations is not absolute and unlimited but is limited by the public interest and the requirements of the service. … In this context, when making its choice, the administration must not merely look at whether the formal requirements have been met but must carry out an assessment between the candidates based on objective and verifiable criteria in terms of merit and scientific competence.” (unofficial translation)
The Chamber assessed the divergence of opinion within the expert panel against that standard:
“In the concrete case, although the expert reports state that both candidates meet the requirements of the advertisement, it is understood that there is doubt as to which of the candidates is superior in terms of quality, whether this superiority constitutes a clear and marked difference, or whether it remains within a limit that can be assessed within the scope of the administration’s discretion. … This divergence of opinion among the members of the expert panel as to the scientific assessment criteria and the result raises doubt as to the adequacy and soundness of the expert report on which the judgment was based. For judicial review to be carried out soundly, there must be a clear and reasoned expert assessment free of contradiction on technical matters.” (unofficial translation)
It consequently considered an examination by a new panel necessary:
“Accordingly, in order to remove the contradictions between the existing expert reports, it is considered necessary for the resolution of the dispute that a new expert panel be formed of different persons who are experts in their field, that the candidates’ scientific works and studies be examined in detail in terms of quality, also taking into account the requirements of the advertisement, that a comparative assessment be made within the framework of objective criteria and, where necessary, that a scoring method based on concrete criteria be applied.” (unofficial translation)
Significance and Practical Effect
Two separate questions stand out in the decision. The first is the administration’s choice: the fact that both candidates meet the minimum requirements does not by itself make the choice lawful. The second is proof: since the comparison requires technical knowledge, the court turns to experts; in this case, according to the Chamber, the panel’s division on which candidate was superior made the adequacy of the report relied on doubtful.
The Chamber did not lay down a general rule that the candidate with the higher score or more works must be appointed; the point on which the Chamber had doubts is whether any superiority constitutes a clear and marked difference or remains within the limits of discretion. Although the decision does not refer to it, in our assessment this distinction can be read together with a general statement in an associate professor post decision of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers adopted by majority on both the outcome and the reasoning: according to the Assembly, where the candidates’ scientific work is very close or equal, the administration’s discretion becomes important (Council of State, Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2025/9, K. 2025/3131, 11.12.2025). In that case the Assembly based its quashing not on this statement but on doubt about the minimum requirements and on the impartiality of a jury member.
In practice, it is important to look not only at the conclusion of the report but also at contradictions between reports and at the minority view.
In a keyword search (at the level of result summaries) of decisions entered in the case-law database after this decision, up to 03.03.2026 for the 8th Chamber, no decision changing this test was found; as the latest decision of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers in the database is dated 15.01.2026, later decisions of the Assembly could not be searched.
Relevant Legislation
Article 26 of Law No. 2547, as set out in the decision, is the same as the current text. In the decision’s rendering, Article 31 of the Administrative Procedure Law states that the selection of experts is also made ex officio; in the current text this sentence mentions only third-party notice, while the selection of experts from lists is governed by a sentence added by Law No. 6754.
“… These professors each write a separate report for each candidate and, if there is more than one candidate to be appointed to the post, state their preferences. The rector makes the appointment upon the decision that the board of directors of the university or high technology institute takes in view of these reports.”
“In matters for which there is no provision in this Law; … experts, on-site inspection, preservation of evidence, … the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure apply. … Experts are selected from the lists prepared by the regional expert witness boards, and the Expert Witness Law and the relevant provisions of Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 dated 12/1/2011 apply to experts.”
“(1) The judge freely assesses the vote and opinion of the expert together with the other evidence.”
Frequently Asked Questions
If both candidates meet the requirements, may the administration appoint whichever candidate it wishes to a professor post?
Under Turkish law, according to the Chamber in this decision, no: the administration may make a choice in the exercise of its discretion, but it cannot rely only on the formal requirements and must compare the candidates on objective and verifiable criteria in terms of merit and scientific competence.
What happens if the expert panel is divided on which candidate is superior?
In this case, the Chamber stated that the divergence of opinion raised doubt as to the adequacy and soundness of the report on which the judgment was based, and considered an examination by a new expert panel of different persons necessary.
What should the new expert panel examine?
According to the Chamber, the panel should examine the candidates’ works and studies in terms of quality, taking the requirements of the advertisement into account, compare them on objective criteria and, where necessary, apply scoring based on concrete criteria.
Does this decision mean that the claimant is appointed to the professor post?
No. The Chamber did not decide which candidate is superior; the file went back to the regional administrative court. If that court complies with the quashing decision, it decides on the basis of the new expert report; if it insists on its earlier decision, the insistence decision is reviewed on appeal by the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers.
- Annulment Action Against Faculty Appointments: Appointment and Promotion Criteria, Non-Appointment and Non-Reappointment in Turkish Law
- Appointing a Markedly Lower Scorer Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Departing from the Objective Score Ranking for an Assistant Professor Post
- Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Several Joint Publications with the Appointee
Related Articles
- Annulment Action Against Faculty Appointments under Turkish Law: Appointment and Promotion Criteria, Non-Appointment and Non-Reappointment
- Appointing a Markedly Lower Scorer Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Departing from the Objective Score Ranking for an Assistant Professor Post
- Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Several Joint Publications with the Appointee
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Higher education law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Higher Education Law
- Actions Against YÖK and University Acts in Türkiye: Which Administrative Court Has Territorial Jurisdiction?
- Research Assistant Requirements, 50/d and 33/a Posts, Term
- Art. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437
- Research Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate Grounds
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Split Experts in Professor Case Need New Panel: Turkish Council of State on Conflicting Expert Reports”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/professor-appointment-conflicting-expert-reports-new-panel

























