Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 22 min read

Last reviewed:

Annulling Faculty Appointments in Türkiye: Appointment and Promotion Criteria, Non-Appointment, Non-Renewal

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, appointments to faculty posts are made by the rector after the jury reports and the opinion of the executive board have been obtained. Non-appointment to a post, or the non-reappointment of an assistant professor, is an administrative act; it may be challenged by an annulment action before the administrative court within sixty days from the day following written notification. The administration may choose among candidates who meet the requirements, but the 8th Chamber of the Council of State requires that choice to rest on objective criteria and on reasons that can be reviewed: in quashing decisions of 2025 the unexplained non-appointment of a candidate with a clearly higher score was held unlawful, while in a 2023 decision the Chamber maintained its quashing of an annulment judgment that, despite an even larger score gap, had relied on the score alone without regard to the candidates’ other academic activities. Reappointment is governed by the university’s criteria approved by the Council of Higher Education (YÖK); where a new requirement demanding a certain score or number of publications within a set period is introduced during the term of office, that period is calculated from the date the requirement entered into force. An annulment judgment does not by itself appoint the claimant.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, annulment actions against non-appointment to assistant professor, associate professor and professor posts and against non-reappointment: criteria under Law No. 2547 and the Regulation, YÖK-approved institutional criteria, limits of discretion, time limits and Council of State decisions.

Annulment actions under Turkish law against non-appointment to assistant professor (doktor öğretim üyesi), associate professor and professor posts and against non-reappointment of assistant professors: Law No. 2547 arts. 23, 24 and 26, the Regulation on Promotion and Appointment to Faculty Membership, universities’ appointment criteria and decisions of the Council of State.

What Is an Annulment Action Against a Faculty Appointment?

Under Turkish law, faculty members are professors, associate professors and assistant professors. A candidate’s non-appointment, the appointment of another candidate in his or her place, or the non-reappointment of an assistant professor whose term has expired are administrative acts that directly affect the person concerned. The remedy is the annulment action, in which the act is reviewed as to competence, form, grounds, subject matter and purpose (Law No. 2577 art. 2/1-a).

Three types of dispute stand out in practice:

  • Non-appointment to a post: another candidate is appointed instead of an applicant who meets the requirements. The appointed candidate may join the proceedings as an intervener on the side of the defendant administration.
  • Non-reappointment: the term of an assistant professor is not extended and his or her link with the post is severed.
  • The criterion itself: regulatory acts such as the university’s appointment and promotion criteria or YÖK’s regulation.

Where the requirement in the job posting describes a particular candidate (a tailor-made posting), this is a separate type of dispute; review at the posting stage, standing, the competent court and appeal routes are explained in detail in Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings: Challenging University Vacancies Drafted for One Candidate under Turkish Law. For the general elements of the annulment action: The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction.

Appointment and Promotion Criteria

The criteria have three layers. The Law sets the minimum: for assistant professor, a doctorate or an equivalent title listed in the Law; for an associate professor post, the title of associate professor (doçent) awarded by the Interuniversity Board; for professor, at least five years of work in the relevant field and original publications after obtaining the title of associate professor. The Regulation governs the general conditions and the procedure. The university’s own criteria are the additional conditions permitted by the Law: they must be set with YÖK’s approval, exclusively for the purpose of raising scientific quality, taking account of differences between disciplines, and must be objective and verifiable.

Statutory Provision — Higher Education Law (Law No. 2547) art. 23/a (Assistant professor) (unofficial translation)

“a) Vacant assistant professor posts at higher education institutions shall be announced by the rectorate. For such announced posts, the dean in faculties and the director in other units shall designate three professors or associate professors, one being the head of that unit and one being from outside that higher education institution, and shall request from them a written opinion on each of the candidates. The dean or the director concerned shall submit his or her proposals to the rector after obtaining the opinion of the executive board. The appointment shall be made by the rector for a period of at most four years. At the end of each appointment period the post shall terminate automatically. Those whose term has expired may be reappointed.”

Statutory Provision — Higher Education Law (Law No. 2547) art. 24/d-e (Associate professorship and appointment) (unofficial translation)

“d) Higher education institutions may, for appointment to an associate professor post, in addition to holding the title of associate professor, set additional conditions of an objective and verifiable nature, with the approval of the Council of Higher Education, exclusively for the purpose of raising scientific quality and taking into account the differences between scientific or artistic disciplines. Where the additional conditions set by higher education institutions include an oral examination, that examination shall be conducted by juries formed by the Interuniversity Board.

e) Holders of the title of associate professor shall apply to associate professor posts announced by higher education institutions. To examine the situation of the candidates applying for an associate professor post, the rector shall designate three professors, one being the head of the unit concerned where there is one, and at least one being from outside that university. These professors shall each write a separate report for each candidate and, where there is more than one candidate to be appointed to the post, state their preferences. The rector shall make the appointment upon the decision of the executive board of the university or institute of high technology taken in the light of these reports.”

For professorships, too, universities may set additional conditions with YÖK’s approval on the same criteria (Law No. 2547 art. 26). The Regulation treats approved additional conditions as a general requirement for all faculty posts:

Regulatory Provision — Regulation on Promotion and Appointment to Faculty Membership art. 3/1 (General conditions) (unofficial translation)

“(1) To be appointed to assistant professor, associate professor and professor posts under this Regulation, it is necessary;

a) to meet the general conditions in Article 48 of Civil Servants Law No. 657,

b) where there are additional conditions relating to promotion and appointment to faculty membership determined by higher education institutions under Articles 23, 24 and 26 of Law No. 2547 and approved by the Council of Higher Education, to satisfy those conditions.”

The Regulation also prohibits the inclusion of the candidate’s thesis title as an application requirement and special conditions that describe only a particular candidate (art. 3/3; added in 2021). The Regulation itself has been reviewed by the courts: in an action brought by a trade union, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held lawful the rule requiring the head of department to sit on the assistant professor jury, the appointment of assistant professors for at least one and at most four years, and the possibility for universities to require an oral examination as an additional condition for associate professor posts, and dismissed the action (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2018/4765, K. 2022/4283, 21.06.2022). The decision was upheld unanimously by the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers (Council of State, Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2022/3506, K. 2023/1278, 07.06.2023).

The Appointment Procedure: Jury, Executive Board and Rector

  • Assistant professor: the dean or director designates, within fifteen days of the application deadline, three professors or associate professors holding associate professor posts in the relevant field, at least one from another university; if the head of department is a professor or an associate professor in such a post, he or she must be on the jury. Jury members give their written opinions within one month (Regulation art. 6/2-3).
  • Associate professor: the rector designates three professors, at least one from another university; they report their preferences and opinions on each candidate separately. The rector decides on the appointment after also obtaining the reasoned opinion of the university executive board (Regulation art. 11).
  • Professor: the jury consists of five professors chosen by the university executive board, at least three of them from other universities (Law No. 2547 art. 26/b).
Regulatory Provision — Regulation on Promotion and Appointment to Faculty Membership art. 6/4 (Application and appointment procedure) (unofficial translation)

“(4) After the written opinions have been received, the dean or the director concerned shall obtain, at the first meeting of the executive board, a separate opinion on each candidate. Where more than one candidate applies for a vacant post, the executive board shall state its preference with reasons. The dean or the director concerned shall submit his or her views and proposals to the rector. The rector shall decide whether or not the appointment is to be made and shall carry out the necessary steps.”

Limits of Discretion in Non-Appointment

According to the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, the administration may choose the most suitable candidate for the post among those whose appointment was viewed favourably in the jury assessment; however, this discretion must be exercised within the limits of the legislation, in line with the aims of Law No. 2547, on the basis of objective criteria and in a way that allows judicial review (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2025/174, K. 2025/7810, 21.10.2025). The following criteria emerge from the decisions:

  • Clear score advantage and reasons: for two associate professor posts, the claimant’s score was 553.50 and those of the appointees 353.5 and 350.09; the external jury member and the court expert had both recommended the claimant. The Chamber quashed the decision dismissing the action, finding that the administration had not shown sufficient reasons for preferring the lower-scoring candidates, but first required the publication ethics allegation raised at the cassation stage to be investigated and, if necessary, a new expert examination to be carried out.
  • The score alone is not decisive: in another associate professor case the administrative court had annulled the act on the basis of the clear gap between the claimant’s 815.78 points and the appointee’s 313.09. The Chamber quashed that judgment in 2022 and explained its reasoning in 2023 when rejecting the request for rectification: according to the expert, the candidates’ publication performance did not differ greatly, while the appointee had thesis supervision, projects and teaching in the field of the post, which the claimant lacked (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2022/7130, K. 2023/1428, 23.03.2023). What matters is not the score difference alone but whether the other academic activities and the reasons for the choice are shown on file.
  • Departing from the objective ranking: appointing to an assistant professor post a candidate with a markedly lower score, outside the merit ranking made by the expert, was held unlawful (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2025/4163, K. 2025/9593, 08.12.2025). The decision was taken by majority; the dissenting opinion considered that no candidate was clearly superior and that the regional administrative court’s judgment should be upheld.

After being quashed, the score-advantage and objective-ranking cases were sent back to the regional administrative court for a new decision; the final outcome cannot be seen from these decisions. The Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, in an associate professor case that the Chamber had quashed on the ground of score advantage, based its own quashing decision of 11.12.2025, taken by majority, not on the score but on a jury member’s joint publications with the appointee and on the act having been made as if there were a single candidate; it stated that where the candidates’ work is very close or equal, the administration’s discretion becomes important. One dissenting opinion defended the score reasoning (Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Several Joint Publications with the Appointee).

Non-Reappointment of Assistant Professors

Unlike assistant professors, the Law provides no term for appointment to associate professor and professor posts (arts. 24, 26). The Regulation makes reappointment subject to the favourable opinion of the executive board and the rector’s decision:

Regulatory Provision — Regulation on Promotion and Appointment to Faculty Membership art. 7/1-2 (Appointment) (unofficial translation)

“(1) Assistant professors shall be appointed by the rector for a period of at least one and at most four years, on the proposal of the dean concerned in faculties and of the director in other units, after the opinion of the executive board concerned has been obtained.

(2) At the end of each appointment period the post shall terminate automatically. Those whose term has expired may be reappointed by the rector upon the favourable opinion of the executive board concerned.”

According to the Council of State, universities may also set objective and verifiable additional conditions for reappointment with YÖK’s approval (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2022/5652, K. 2024/1681, 21.03.2024). Three situations can be distinguished in the decisions:

  • A criterion known at the time of appointment: the non-reappointment of an assistant professor who, at the end of the term, did not meet a foreign language requirement (a minimum of 65 points) adopted by the senate before the first appointment but entering into force only after it was held lawful, and the contrary judgment of the regional administrative court was quashed (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2023/5314, K. 2024/4982, 02.10.2024).
  • A criterion introduced during the term: requiring “60 points in the last four years” under a rule that entered into force about one year before the end of the term was held contrary to the principles of legal certainty and foreseeability; the Chamber stated that the term had to be extended and that a new assessment under the directive would be made at the end of the new term (E. 2022/5652, K. 2024/1681).
  • Reasons other than the criteria: the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, under the pre-2018 text of Article 23, held lawful the non-extension of the term of an assistant professor (under the old title yardımcı doçent) whose disciplinary penalties had been annulled by the courts, on the ground that the administration had exercised its discretion in line with the requirements of the service. In the same case the 8th Chamber had found the act unlawful; the Assembly’s decision was taken by majority, with two dissenting opinions, one in favour of quashing and the other in favour of upholding on different grounds (Council of State, Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2021/511, K. 2021/1469, 15.09.2021). As it rests on the pre-2018 text of Article 23, the decision should be read together with current decisions.

Procedure: Time Limit, Court and Effect of Annulment

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 7/1 and 7/4 (Time limit for bringing an action) (unofficial translation)

“The time limit for bringing an action is sixty days before the Council of State and the administrative courts and thirty days before the tax courts, unless a different period is laid down in special laws.

… For regulatory acts that must be published, the time limit runs from the day following the date of publication. However, upon the application of such acts, those concerned may bring an action against the regulatory act, against the act of application, or against both. The fact that the regulatory act has not been annulled does not prevent the annulment of an act based on it.”

Time limit. In administrative disputes the period runs from the day following written notification (art. 7/2-a). The effect of announcing results only on the website and of an application to the superior authority is discussed in the article on tailor-made postings. The university’s criterion may be challenged together with the individual act applying it, even if the period from its publication has expired (art. 7/4).

Court. In the appointment cases reviewed, the actions were brought before the administrative court; appellate decisions were reviewed by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State and the judgment of persistence by the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, while in the 2023 rectification case the Council of State had reviewed the administrative court’s judgment directly on appeal. The action against the Regulation was heard at first instance by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State. Territorial jurisdiction, stay of execution, implementation of the annulment judgment and the cassation regime after 2026 are explained in the article on tailor-made postings.

Financial rights. In two of the non-reappointment cases reviewed, compensation of the financial rights lost as a result of the act (in one case also personnel rights), with statutory interest, was claimed together with annulment.

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 2/2 (Limits of administrative jurisdiction) (unofficial translation)

“Administrative jurisdiction is limited to reviewing the lawfulness of administrative actions and acts. Administrative courts may not review expediency, and may not render judgments that restrict the performance of the executive function in accordance with the forms and principles laid down in laws and Presidential Decrees, that have the nature of an administrative action or act, or that remove the discretion of the administration.”

Effect of annulment. An annulment judgment does not by itself appoint the claimant to the post; the administration carries out a new assessment in line with the reasons of the judgment.

Council of State Decisions

Unexplained non-appointment of a candidate with a clearly higher score was held unlawful

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2025/174, K. 2025/7810, 21.10.2025 (the Chamber’s reasoning for quashing; unanimous)

“… although the candidates appointed to the post, from among the candidates meeting all the requirements for the associate professor post in dispute, have a relatively lower academic score, it is considered that the defendant administration has not put forward the necessary and sufficient reasons for preferring their appointment to the said post and for their being more suitable for the post in scientific and academic terms.”

Appointing a markedly lower-scoring candidate outside the objective ranking was held unlawful (by majority)

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2025/4163, K. 2025/9593, 08.12.2025 (the Chamber’s reasoning for quashing; by majority, one dissenting opinion)

“In this situation, the act of the defendant administration appointing a candidate with a markedly lower score, departing from the objective ranking, is not lawful. However, given that the first-ranked candidate did not challenge the act, it is clear that the defendant administration will cancel the appointment, announce the post again, assess the applicants objectively and make the appointment to the post.”

A higher score alone is not enough; all academic activities are assessed

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2022/7130, K. 2023/1428, 23.03.2023 (rejection of the request for rectification; the Chamber’s reasoning, unanimous)

“Our Chamber decided to quash the Administrative Court’s judgment on the ground that the judgment under appeal, annulling the administrative act in dispute solely because the claimant’s score was higher, was not legally correct. … it is clear that in appointments to the post, a decision is to be made by examining all scientific activities of the candidates as a whole.”

For a reappointment requirement introduced during the term, the period runs from its entry into force

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2022/5652, K. 2024/1681, 21.03.2024 (the Chamber’s reasoning for quashing; unanimous)

“However, where the additional conditions introduced for faculty members to be reappointed to the same post after their terms have expired impose an obligation such as producing a certain number of academic works within a certain period, the periods envisaged must be calculated from the date on which the additional condition entered into force. Otherwise, a clear breach of the principles of legal certainty and foreseeability results. … Nevertheless, it is clear that at the end of the claimant’s renewed contract, his or her situation will be reassessed under the university’s Academic Assessment Directive.”

Non-reappointment of an assistant professor who does not meet a requirement known at appointment is lawful

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2023/5314, K. 2024/4982, 02.10.2024 (the Chamber’s reasoning for quashing; the regional administrative court’s annulment was quashed, unanimous)

“… it is understood that the rule on the foreign language requirement was among the additional conditions on the date of the claimant’s first appointment and its entry-into-force date had been set as 31/12/2019, that the claimant was therefore in a position to know from the date of appointment that this requirement would be sought from him or her for reappointment in 2022, when the term expired, and that in this context it cannot be accepted that the foreign language requirement was unforeseeable for the claimant.”

Discretion in extending the term of office (by majority)

Council of State Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers Decision
Council of State, Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2021/511, K. 2021/1469, 15.09.2021 (the Assembly’s reasoning; pre-2018 text of Article 23, judgment of persistence upheld on this ground, two dissenting opinions)

“Nevertheless, even though the claimant’s conduct has not been proven as acts that could be subject to a disciplinary penalty, under Article 23 of Law No. 2547 there is no obstacle to the administration exercising its discretion, in line with the requirements of the public service, as regards extending the term of a person whose post terminates automatically at the end of the appointment period.”

Practical Points

  • Date of the criterion: the institutional criterion in force on the date of application or on expiry of the term, YÖK’s approval and the entry-into-force provision should be placed on file; for a requirement introduced during the term, the remaining period should be calculated separately.
  • Documents: the jury reports, the executive board’s decision and the points tables should be requested, and whether the preference was reasoned should be checked.
  • Acts challenged: the appointment of the other candidate should be challenged together with the non-appointment. The part of a first-instance judgment that is not appealed becomes final; in the two-post associate professor case, the dismissal concerning one of the appointees became final for this reason (E. 2025/174, K. 2025/7810).
  • Composition of the jury: compliance of the jury with the Regulation’s rules on the external member, the head of department and the field should be checked. A jury member’s joint publications with a candidate are discussed in a separate article: Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Several Joint Publications with the Appointee.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the time limit for challenging a faculty appointment?

Unless a special law provides otherwise, the time limit before the administrative courts is sixty days and runs from the day following written notification (Law No. 2577 art. 7).

My score is higher than the appointee’s; is my non-appointment unlawful?

Not on that basis alone. In quashing decisions of 2025, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State found the act unlawful where, despite a clear score advantage, no academic reason was shown for preferring the lower-scoring candidate. In a 2023 decision, however, it explained its quashing of an annulment judgment based on an even larger score difference by stating that activities such as thesis supervision, projects and teaching must also be assessed as a whole. The Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers did not base its quashing on score advantage in a similar case.

If the court annuls the act, will I be appointed?

Not automatically. Administrative courts may not render judgments that remove the discretion of the administration (Law No. 2577 art. 2/2). The administration carries out a new assessment in line with the reasons of the judgment; in one case the Council of State stated that, since the first-ranked candidate had not challenged the act, the administration would cancel the appointment and announce the post again.

What can an assistant professor do if the term is not extended?

An annulment action may be brought against the non-reappointment. The Council of State has held lawful the non-reappointment of a faculty member who did not meet an institutional requirement known at the time of first appointment, while for a new publication or points requirement introduced during the term it has accepted that the period must be calculated from the requirement’s entry into force.

Can the university’s appointment criteria be challenged separately?

Yes. The criteria are regulatory acts; they may be challenged directly within the time limit from their publication or together with the individual act applying them (Law No. 2577 art. 7/4). Under the Law, additional conditions must be approved by YÖK, aimed exclusively at raising scientific quality, and objective and verifiable.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Higher Education Law

All Higher Education Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Annulling Faculty Appointments in Türkiye: Appointment and Promotion Criteria, Non-Appointment, Non-Renewal”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/faculty-appointment-annulment-action-turkish-universities

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›