Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 10 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

YÖK Paragraph Barring Court-Backed Appointments Annulled: Turkish Council of State on YLSY (Law No. 1416)

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: The Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld annulment of a YÖK paragraph barring even court-ordered appointment of those deemed unsuccessful under Law No. 1416 to teaching staff posts. In that decision of 02.12.2025, the Assembly (Danıştay İdari Dava Daireleri Kurulu) upheld the relevant part of the 8th Chamber’s decision, which annulled that paragraph of a general letter of the Council of Higher Education (Yükseköğretim Kurulu, YÖK); it did so on the Chamber’s reasoning based on the administration’s duty to comply with court decisions. The Assembly also accepted that the scholarship holder whose ties with the university were severed had standing to challenge the whole letter and quashed the dismissal for lack of standing. The decision makes no ruling on the scholarship holder’s appointment or on any compensation debt.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld, on the same reasoning, the annulment of the paragraph of a YÖK general letter stating that those deemed unsuccessful under Law No. 1416 could not be appointed to teaching staff posts even by court decisions, as contrary to the administration’s duty to comply with judicial decisions. The Assembly also accepted that the scholarship holder whose ties with the university were severed had standing to challenge the whole letter, quashed the partial dismissal for lack of standing and sent the file back to the 8th Chamber for that part.

Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld the annulment of a paragraph in a YÖK letter stating that scholarship holders under Law No. 1416 deemed unsuccessful could not be appointed even by court decisions.

The Dispute

In 2011 the claimant was sent abroad under Law No. 1416 for master’s and doctoral studies on behalf of a university, at the expense of the Ministry of National Education. Students sent abroad on this basis are also known in practice as YLSY scholarship holders; the abbreviation does not appear in the decision. The claimant completed the master’s degree, returned to Türkiye while the doctorate was at the thesis stage and asked for a post on the basis of the master’s degree. Following the Ministry’s calculation of the compulsory service (mecburi hizmet), the claimant was appointed as a lecturer (öğretim görevlisi) at the university’s vocational school; YÖK did not approve the transfer of a post that the university requested for this purpose.

YÖK also sent all universities a seven-paragraph general letter entitled “Law No. 1416 - Implementation of Court Decisions”. According to the letter, those who return without completing their studies repay their education costs with interest; those who become liable to pay compensation can be appointed only if they pass the examination stages for teaching staff; and court decisions given in favour of such persons must be implemented by the Ministry as the party to those cases. The fifth paragraph reads: “Those deemed unsuccessful under Law No. 1416 have no possibility of being appointed to the teaching staff posts of higher education institutions, even by court decisions.” (unofficial translation) On the basis of these acts, the university severed the claimant’s ties with the university (ilişik kesme).

The claimant’s action for annulment of the severance, of the refusal of the post transfer and of the general letter was heard at first instance by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State. On 11.10.2024 the Chamber annulled the fifth paragraph and dismissed the action for lack of standing as regards the rest of the letter, on the ground that the claimant had made repayments for the doctorate. While the case was pending, YÖK had found it appropriate for those sent abroad for a master’s degree before 2016 and returning with that degree to perform compulsory service in lecturer posts subject to certain conditions, and the claimant had been appointed to another unit of the university. The Chamber therefore held that there was no need to decide on the other two acts. Both sides appealed.

Outcome of the Decision

The Assembly accepted the claimant’s appeal and rejected the appeals of the defendant administrations. It upheld the parts of the Chamber’s decision concerning annulment and no need to decide; it quashed the dismissal for lack of standing and sent the file back to the 8th Chamber of the Council of State for that part. The decision was given on 02.12.2025, finally; by majority as regards the severance and unanimously as regards the other parts. There is one dissenting opinion: the member stated that the severance had not been withdrawn and had not become moot, and asked for it to be examined on the merits.

Reasoning

On the annulment of the fifth paragraph, the Assembly adopted the Chamber’s reasoning:

Council of State Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers Decision

“The parts of the decision of the Eighth Chamber of the Council of State concerning annulment and finding no need to decide, whose legal grounds and reasoning are set out above, have also been found appropriate by our Assembly on the same reasoning, and the allegations raised by the defendants in their appeal petitions have not been considered such as to require the quashing of those parts of the decision.” (unofficial translation)

According to the Chamber’s reasoning as summarised by the Assembly, the Constitution and Law No. 2577 require the administration to comply with court decisions, not to alter them and not to delay their execution; there can be no fair trial within the meaning of Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights where court decisions are not effectively executed. The Chamber found the paragraph unlawful, also stating that non-execution leads to disciplinary and criminal liability and to compensation against the administration with recourse against the officials.

On standing, the Assembly wrote its own reasoning:

Council of State Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers Decision

“… the general letter on “Law No. 1416 - Implementation of Court Decisions” consists of 7 paragraphs and … is seen to contain interlinked operating rules; it is therefore clear that the whole of the general letter concerns the claimant’s interest, and it is concluded that the repayments made by the claimant, as an undisputed matter, for the doctoral programme that the claimant could not complete do not remove the link of interest. In this situation, considering that the claimant has standing to bring an action for the annulment of the whole of that act, the part of the Chamber’s decision dismissing the action for lack of standing is not legally correct.” (unofficial translation)

Significance and Practical Effect

The test underlying the upheld annulment is the administration’s duty to comply with court decisions. Only the fifth paragraph was annulled; neither the Chamber nor the Assembly ruled that every scholarship holder deemed unsuccessful must be appointed or is released from the compensation debt. The other paragraphs of the letter, concerning compensation, the examination requirement and implementation of decisions by the Ministry, were not examined on the merits; following the quashing, the Chamber will decide on that part anew.

On standing, the Assembly accepted that a person whose ties were severed on the basis of a general letter containing interlinked rules may challenge the whole letter, and that repayments made for the doctorate do not break the link of interest.

In our assessment, the decision may serve as a basis against the non-implementation of a judicial decision given in favour of a scholarship holder on the ground of this general letter; individual appointment claims, however, are assessed separately according to the court decision in each case.

In a keyword search (at the level of result summaries) on Law No. 1416, lecturer appointments and post transfers in Council of State decisions entered in the database after this decision (up to 15.01.2026 for the Assembly and up to 03.03.2026 for the 8th Chamber), no decision changing this test and no decision on the course of the file after the quashing was found.

Relevant Legislation

The current texts of the provisions on which the decision relies are set out below. The sentence added to Article 28/1 of the Administrative Procedure Law by Law No. 7588 after the decision provides that, in certain actions based on grounds such as links with terrorist organisations or a negative security investigation, decisions resulting in reinstatement are executed after they become final; it does not concern this dispute.

Constitutional Provision — Constitution of the Republic of Türkiye (Law No. 2709) art. 138 (fourth paragraph) (unofficial translation)

“The legislative and executive organs and the administration shall comply with court decisions; these organs and the administration shall neither alter court decisions in any respect nor delay their execution.”

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 28/1 (Consequences of decisions) (unofficial translation)

“The administration is obliged to take action or to act without delay in accordance with the requirements of the decisions of the Council of State, the regional administrative courts and the administrative and tax courts on the merits and on stays of execution. This period may in no case exceed thirty days from the notification of the decision to the administration. …”

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 2/1-a (Types of administrative action) (unofficial translation)

“… actions for annulment brought by those whose interests have been infringed, on the ground that administrative acts are unlawful in respect of one of the elements of authority, form, cause, subject or purpose,”

Frequently Asked Questions

May YÖK state in a general letter that scholarship holders deemed unsuccessful cannot be appointed even by court decisions?

Under Turkish law, in this case no: the 8th Chamber of the Council of State annulled that paragraph as contrary to the administration’s duty to comply with court decisions, and the Assembly upheld the annulment on the same reasoning.

Does the decision mean that every scholarship holder who did not complete a doctorate must be appointed?

No. The decision only upheld the annulment of the fifth paragraph; it made no ruling on any individual right to appointment or on the compensation obligation.

May a scholarship holder who has repaid the doctoral costs challenge the whole general letter?

According to the Assembly, in this case yes: the whole letter concerns the claimant’s interest, and repayments made for the uncompleted doctorate do not remove the link of interest.

At what stage is the file now?

The parts concerning annulment and no need to decide were upheld finally. The dismissal for lack of standing was quashed, and the file was sent back to the 8th Chamber of the Council of State for a new decision on the other paragraphs of the general letter.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Higher Education Law

All Higher Education Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “YÖK Paragraph Barring Court-Backed Appointments Annulled: Turkish Council of State on YLSY (Law No. 1416)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/ylsy-scholar-lecturer-appointment-court-rulings-yok-letter

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›