Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 9 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Excluding Associate Degree Courses Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on 2023 Associate Professor Criteria

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: By majority, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State (Danıştay) annulled as an incomplete regulation the omission of associate degree (two-year, ön lisans) courses. The omission concerned the “9. Education-Teaching” section of the Associate Professorship (doçentlik) Application Requirements adopted by the General Assembly of the Council of Higher Education (YÖK) by decision no. 2023.10.183 of 15.06.2023 (including the updates of 17.08.2023). The reason was that no explanation had been given for allowing permanent teaching staff to meet the requirement regardless of the level of the courses they taught, while requiring candidates without a permanent post to meet it only through undergraduate and graduate courses. The claims against the teaching duration (at least 2 points), scientific meeting, book and entry-into-force rules were dismissed. The decision is a first-instance decision of the Council of State; it was given subject to appeal in cassation and may not be final.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State annulled the omission of associate degree courses from the 2023 associate professorship application requirements and upheld the other contested rules. The decision is subject to appeal in cassation.

Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State annulled the exclusion of associate degree (ön lisans) courses from the 2023 Associate Professorship Application Requirements, while upholding the rules on teaching duration, scientific meetings, books and entry into force.

The Dispute

A trade union brought the action against the Presidency of the Council of Higher Education and the Presidency of the Inter-University Board (ÜAK). The union challenged nine points of the 2023 requirements: the requirement of an academic representative at scientific meetings, the editor and chapter rules for books, the scoring of only one work per scientific meeting, the compulsory “at least 2 points” in the education-teaching section, the omission of associate degree courses, and the absence of a rule postponing entry into force until at least four semesters later.

The case was heard by the Council of State at first instance. The reporting judge proposed dismissal; the Council of State prosecutor proposed annulment of the “at least 2 points” phrase and of the omission of associate degree courses. According to another decision of the Chamber, a stay of execution had been ordered in this case regarding the omission of associate degree courses, and the objection to it was rejected by the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2023/6035, K. 2025/3376, 09.04.2025).

Outcome of the Decision

On 24.02.2026 the Chamber partly annulled the requirements and partly dismissed the action:

  • Annulment (by majority, one member dissenting): the incomplete regulation resulting from the absence of the phrase “having taught associate degree courses” in the “9. Education-Teaching” section.
  • Dismissal (by majority, the President of the Chamber and one member dissenting): the requirement that the organising committee of a scientific meeting include an academic representative officially appointed for that purpose.
  • Dismissal (unanimous): the editorship and book rules, the scoring of at most one work presented at the same scientific meeting, the compulsory minimum of 2 points in the education-teaching section, and the claim that no separate transitional rule had been made for entry into force.

The decision was given subject to appeal in cassation to the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers within 30 days following notification. At the time of writing, no cassation decision in this case could be found; the decision may not be final.

Reasoning

The Chamber accepted that the defendant authorities undoubtedly have the power to set the application requirements, and directed its review to whether that discretion was exercised in line with the public interest and the requirements of the service. Until the March 2023 period, having taught associate degree courses for one semester was considered sufficient. The foreign-language certificate and residence aspects of the requirements are examined in our article on language exams taken abroad and the residence requirement.

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2023/6088, K. 2026/1003, 24.02.2026 (the Chamber’s reasoning for annulment regarding associate degree courses)

“It is clear that, under the regulation, persons who have served on the permanent staff of higher education institutions for 2 years meet the requirement in the contested regulation regardless of whether they taught associate degree, undergraduate or graduate courses, whereas persons not serving on the permanent staff of higher education institutions are obliged to meet the requirement of teaching for 4 semesters/2 years only by teaching undergraduate or graduate courses, and that the reasons for such a distinction have not been shown by the defendant administrations. Furthermore, the defendant administrations have not been able to justify with concrete information and documents on the basis of which service requirements and public interest they ended the long-standing practice of treating the teaching of associate degree courses as sufficient for associate professorship applications. In that case, since the part of the contested regulation left incomplete by the absence of the phrase ‘having taught associate degree courses’ is not consistent with the public interest and the requirements of the service, it is necessary to annul it as regards that part of the action.” (unofficial translation)

The teaching requirement itself, however, was upheld. The Chamber found lawful the obligation to teach undergraduate or graduate courses for four semesters in semester-based programmes or two years in year-based programmes; the Council of State prosecutor had proposed annulment of this part as well.

Council of State Decision
Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2023/6088, K. 2026/1003, 24.02.2026 (the Chamber’s reasoning for dismissal regarding the teaching requirement)

“For this reason, having concluded that the regulation was made with the aim of ensuring that candidates have a minimum accumulation of academic experience, of increasing scientific standards and quality in academic output, and of bringing qualified and experienced staff into service, no breach of the public interest and the requirements of the service was found in this part of the contested regulation.” (unofficial translation)

The Chamber found the academic representative requirement lawful as aimed at protecting scientific standards and academic values. The President of the Chamber and one member, dissenting, argued that the requirement should be annulled because candidates’ works are already reviewed for scientific adequacy by the jury formed by the Inter-University Board. The entry-into-force claim was also dismissed: since the Associate Professorship Regulation applies criteria updates from the second application period after their adoption, the Chamber regarded this period as required by the principles of legal certainty and foreseeability.

Significance and Practical Effect

The decision continues the Chamber’s line on the same issue. In the action brought against the update decision of 17.08.2023, the omission of associate degree courses was annulled unanimously and the claim against the teaching requirement was dismissed by majority (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2023/6035, K. 2025/3376, 09.04.2025). In another case, the same omission was annulled by majority, the Chamber held that there was no need to rule on the teaching duration claim as it had become devoid of subject matter, and the claims against the other headings were dismissed (Council of State, 8th Chamber, E. 2024/2998, K. 2025/8797, 19.11.2025). These decisions were also given subject to appeal in cassation, and no cassation decision of the Plenary Session concerning them could be found.

In practice, what was struck down is not the teaching requirement but the exclusion of associate degree courses from it. For papers presented at scientific meetings, documenting the officially appointed academic representative on the organising committee matters. Because criteria changes apply from the second application period, the requirements a candidate is subject to depend on the application period. How the decision will be reflected in practice depends on the outcome of the cassation appeal and on any new regulation by the authorities. As the Associate Professorship Application Requirements are not published in the Official Legislation Information System, their content is described here as reported in the decision; the current requirements should be checked separately before applying.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Higher Education Law (Law No. 2547) art. 24 (Associate professorship and appointment) (unofficial translation)

“(3) To have produced original scientific publications and works of sufficient number and quality, to be determined by the Council of Higher Education upon the opinion of the Inter-University Board, taking into account the characteristics of each scientific or artistic discipline. …

ç) The principles and procedures concerning candidates’ publications and works in associate professorship applications shall be laid down in a regulation to be issued by the Council of Higher Education.” (unofficial translation)

Regulatory Provision — Associate Professorship Regulation art. 3/1 (Scientific/artistic fields and criteria for associate professorship) (unofficial translation)

“(1) The associate professorship assessment shall be carried out by examining the candidate’s academic publications and works in the scientific/artistic fields determined by the Council of Higher Education upon the opinion of the Inter-University Board. Updates to scientific/artistic fields shall apply in the following period, while updates to associate professorship criteria shall apply in the second associate professorship application period after the date of their adoption.” (unofficial translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

Do associate degree courses count for an associate professorship application?

The 2023 requirements did not include associate degree courses. The 8th Chamber of the Council of State annulled this omission; however, the decision was given subject to appeal in cassation and may not be final.

Has the teaching requirement for associate professorship been abolished?

No. The claim against the requirement to teach undergraduate or graduate courses for four semesters or two years (at least 2 points) was dismissed unanimously. Those who have served on the permanent teaching staff for at least two years after their doctorate are deemed to meet the requirement.

On what condition is a work presented at a scientific meeting scored?

The requirement that the organising committee include an officially appointed academic representative was found lawful. The rule that at most one work presented at the same meeting is scored was also upheld.

Is this decision final?

The decision was given by the Council of State acting as a first-instance court and is subject to appeal in cassation to the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers. No cassation decision could be found; the decision may not be final.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Higher Education Law

All Higher Education Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Excluding Associate Degree Courses Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on 2023 Associate Professor Criteria”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/associate-professor-application-associate-degree-courses

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›