Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 19 min read

Last reviewed:

Disciplinary Penalties for Student Cheating: Unlawfulness and Annulment under Turkish Law

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, the disciplinary treatment of cheating in higher education is governed by art. 54 of Higher Education Law No. 2547, as amended by Law No. 7437: attempted cheating is punished by a reprimand, cheating or enabling cheating by a one-semester suspension, and cheating by threat or sitting an exam for another person by a two-semester suspension. A penalty may be imposed only after a properly conducted investigation; the student must be informed in writing of the alleged offence at least seven days before the defence date, and the investigation must be conducted so as to allow the student to defend themselves properly (art. 54/5). The act of cheating must be proven by concrete, legally admissible evidence leaving no room for doubt; in one case where an expert report showed that the answer sheet was the student’s own work, the suspension was found unlawful. An objection may be lodged with the university executive board within fifteen days, but it is not compulsory; the annulment action is brought before the administrative court, as a rule within sixty days of notification (Administrative Procedure Code art. 7). A cheating penalty imposed without respecting the right of defence and the investigation procedure, or without establishing that the act occurred, is annulled by the administrative courts.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Unlawfulness and annulment of disciplinary penalties imposed for a student cheating in an exam: the disciplinary treatment of cheating (Higher Education Law No. 2547, art. 54 — reprimand for attempted cheating, one-semester suspension for cheating or enabling cheating, two-semester suspension for cheating by threat; the provision that replaced the Student Discipline Regulation repealed in 2023), the right of defence and investigation procedure (art. 54/5-6), proof of cheating by concrete evidence and expert report, proportionality and the problem of a separate penalty per course, the criminal-disciplinary relationship (art. 54/6-ğ), objection, the annulment action, the sixty-day time limit (Administrative Procedure Code art. 7) and the appeal route (art. 46, including the amendment by Law No. 7589), with decisions from files upheld by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State.

A guide to the unlawfulness and annulment of disciplinary penalties imposed for a student cheating in an examination; the disciplinary treatment of cheating in higher education (Higher Education Law No. 2547, art. 54/1 — attempted cheating: reprimand; cheating or enabling cheating: one-semester suspension; cheating by threat or sitting an exam for another person: two-semester suspension), procedure and the right of defence in disciplinary investigations (art. 54/5), the requirement that the act (cheating) be proven by concrete and convincing evidence, proportionality and the problem of a separate penalty for each course, the independence of criminal proceedings and disciplinary investigation (art. 54/6-ğ), objection, the competent administrative court for an annulment action, the sixty-day time limit (Administrative Procedure Code art. 7) and the appeal route (Administrative Procedure Code art. 46), with decisions from files upheld by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State.

Update (19.10.2026): Student disciplinary offences and penalties are now governed by Article 54 of Higher Education Law No. 2547, as amended by Law No. 7437 of 2/2/2023; the Higher Education Institutions Student Discipline Regulation previously applied was repealed by a regulation published in the Official Gazette of 11.03.2023. This article has been updated accordingly and to reflect the change to cassation under the Administrative Procedure Code made by Law No. 7589.

Cheating and the Disciplinary Penalty

The disciplinary offences and penalties of higher-education students are governed by Article 54 of Higher Education Law No. 2547, as amended by Law No. 7437 of 2/2/2023; the Higher Education Institutions Student Discipline Regulation, which previously governed the matter, was repealed by a regulation published in Official Gazette No. 32129 of 11.03.2023. Under the Law, attempting to cheat in examinations is punished by a reprimand, cheating or enabling cheating by one-semester suspension from the institution, and cheating by threat, preventing the removal of cheating students from the examination hall, having another person sit the exam or sitting the exam for another person by two-semester suspension. A suspended student cannot exercise student rights during the suspension. Because the penalty can have serious consequences (especially for students whose maximum period of study has expired), both whether the act was actually committed and the lawfulness of the investigation procedure are scrutinised closely; the absence of either leads to annulment of the penalty before the administrative courts.

Relevant Provision — Higher Education Law No. 2547, Art. 54/1 (provisions on cheating) (unofficial translation)

“(1) Disciplinary penalties and the disciplinary offences requiring them: a) Reprimand: written notification to the student that they are reprimanded for faulty conduct relating to studentship. The acts requiring a reprimand are: … 5) attempting to cheat in examinations, … c) One-semester suspension from the higher-education institution: written notification to the student that they are suspended from the institution for one semester and cannot exercise student rights during this period. The acts requiring one-semester suspension are: … 5) cheating or enabling cheating in examinations, … ç) Two-semester suspension from the higher-education institution: … The acts requiring two-semester suspension are: … 4) cheating by threat in examinations, preventing the removal of cheating students from the examination hall, having another person sit the examination in one’s place or sitting the examination in another person’s place, …”

Procedure and the Right of Defence

A disciplinary penalty may be imposed only after a properly conducted investigation. The Law regulates the right of defence in detail: the student must be informed in writing of what the imputed offence consists of at least seven days before the date of the defence (notification may also be made through the student information system, e-mail or text message); the defence may be oral or written; a student who fails to respond to the summons without excuse is deemed to have waived the right of defence; and the investigation must be conducted so as to allow the student to defend themselves properly (Law No. 2547, art. 54/5). Court decisions likewise stress that the request-for-defence letter must state the imputed acts and the envisaged penalty together with the legal provision, that it must be duly served, and that the decision must be taken by the competent disciplinary authority or board after the defence is obtained; imposing a penalty without following this procedure — for example, relying solely on a record or report — requires annulment. One- or two-semester suspensions are imposed by the competent disciplinary board (art. 54/7-c). The content of the investigation report is also laid down in the Law.

Relevant Provision — Higher Education Law No. 2547, Art. 54/5 (right of defence) (unofficial translation)

“(5) Right of defence: a) The student against whom a disciplinary investigation is opened shall be notified in writing, at least seven days before the date of the defence, of what the imputed offence consists of; notification may also be made through the student information system or by e-mail or text message. This letter asks the student to be present at the stated day, time and place to make their defence. … c) The summons sent to the student shall state that, if the student fails to respond without excuse or does not notify the excuse in time, they will be deemed to have waived the right of defence and the necessary decision will be taken on the basis of the existing evidence. … d) The investigation shall be conducted in a manner allowing the student to defend themselves properly.”

Relevant Provision — Higher Education Law No. 2547, Art. 54/6-g (investigation report) (unofficial translation)

“g) When the investigation is concluded, a report is drawn up. The report summarises the investigation authorisation, the start date of the investigation, the identity of the person investigated, the offences imputed, the stages of the investigation, the evidence and the defence obtained. Whether the imputed offence is established is discussed and, if it is found established, the disciplinary penalty corresponding to the act is proposed. Originals or copies of the documents relating to the investigation are attached to the report on a schedule. The investigation report, together with the file, is submitted to the authority that opened the investigation.”

Proof of the Act of Cheating

In disciplinary law too, the imputed act must be established beyond doubt by concrete and legally acceptable evidence. In a cheating allegation it must be clearly determined which student, in which exam, cheated and how. The investigator may hear witnesses, conduct an inspection and consult experts; the investigation report must discuss whether the imputed offence is established, and a penalty may be proposed only if it is (Law No. 2547, art. 54/6-b and art. 54/6-g). In online exams, technical claims such as “the answer sheet is not the student’s own work” often require expert examination; if the act is not found established, the suspension becomes unlawful. Similar answers to those of other students, unless supported by further concrete evidence, may not by themselves suffice to prove cheating conclusively.

Proportionality and a Separate Penalty per Course

Disciplinary penalties must be proportionate to the act. To that end the Law allows disciplinary authorities and boards to impose a penalty one degree lower, taking into account the gravity of the act, whether the student has previously received a disciplinary penalty, whether they show remorse, and their past conduct, work and achievements at the institution (Law No. 2547, art. 54/9-d). In case of recurrence, a penalty one degree heavier applies; however, recurrence concerns acts committed after notification of the previous penalty and within the disciplinary limitation period, and expulsion from the institution may not be imposed on the ground of recurrence (art. 54/2). In practice, particularly in make-up exams taken by students whose maximum period has expired, imposing a separate “one-semester suspension” for each of several courses can, through consecutive application, keep the student out of the institution for many years. In one such file examined by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, the reporting judge, noting that a separate penalty had been imposed for each of sixteen courses in the second make-up exams and that the acts would result in the student’s enrolment being terminated, considered that the administration’s appeal on points of law should be admitted; the Chamber did not adopt this view and upheld the regional administrative court’s decision rejecting the appeal (2024/5452 E., 2024/7600 K., 25.12.2024). The grave consequence of consecutive penalties should therefore be argued in detail, as to proof and proportionality, before the first-instance and appellate courts.

Criminal Proceedings and Discipline

Disciplinary investigation and criminal proceedings are independent. The commencement of criminal prosecution against the student for the same event does not delay the disciplinary investigation; the initiation of criminal prosecution, or the student’s conviction or acquittal, does not bar a disciplinary penalty (Law No. 2547, art. 54/6-ğ). Nonetheless, the proof of the underlying act and the lawfulness of the procedure are examined separately in administrative judicial review.

Relevant Provision — Higher Education Law No. 2547, Art. 54/6-ğ (unofficial translation)

“ğ) The fact that criminal prosecution has begun against the student for the same event does not delay the disciplinary investigation. The initiation of criminal prosecution against the student, or the student’s conviction or acquittal, does not bar the imposition of a disciplinary penalty.”

Penalties Imposed under the Former Regulation and the More Favourable Provision

Under Turkish law, where a cheating penalty was imposed under the former Regulation and the case is still pending, the applicable provision must be determined separately. The Constitutional Court annulled paragraph (a) of the former Article 54 of Law No. 2547 and the wording of Article 65 that left student discipline to regulations, because the Law did not show which act required which penalty; it deferred the entry into force of the annulment for nine months from the decision’s publication in the Official Gazette (20.09.2022) (Constitutional Court, E. 2022/54, K. 2022/99, 08.09.2022). Before that period expired, Article 54 was rewritten by Law No. 7437, in force since 09.02.2023; that Law contains no transitional provision for penalties imposed during the Regulation period.

According to the Council of State’s Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, where new legislation is enacted after the annulment, the dispute is resolved under that legislation; under the principle that the more favourable norm applies, however, if the Regulation provision in force on the date of the act differs from the later provision of the Law, the one more favourable to the student applies. In a case where the former Regulation punished drug dealing by expulsion only if committed in higher-education institutions, the Assembly found the former provision more favourable and, since there was no evidence that the act took place within the institution, held the expulsion unlawful.

Council of State Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers Decision

“Where, after the Constitutional Court has annulled a provision of a Law, the legislature enacts new legislation, the dispute must be resolved under that legislation. … In this sense, it must be accepted that, in the judicial review of a disciplinary sanction in the nature of an administrative act, the rule that the norm more favourable as to offence and penalty applies is valid in principle. Accordingly, if the legislation in force on the date the act was committed differs from legislation that entered into force later, the provision more favourable to the persons to be disciplined must be taken into account. It is also clear, however, that an annulment ordered in order to apply the more favourable provision will not prevent the imposition of another disciplinary penalty corresponding to the claimant’s act.”

In later decisions the Assembly reversed regional administrative court decisions that had annulled the penalty solely because of the Constitutional Court’s decision, and required an examination on the merits of whether the act is proven, whether it warrants a disciplinary penalty and whether there is a more favourable provision (E. 2024/2841, K. 2025/1683, 17.09.2025). These decisions are final and were given by majority; a dissenting opinion appearing in both, relying on the Constitutional Court’s judgment in Kemal Alican Yeğen and Others (App. No. 2018/10488, 29.03.2023), argued that a penalty imposed under a Regulation whose statutory basis had been annulled is unlawful. The decisions cited concern expulsion, not cheating; on the Assembly’s approach, for a cheating penalty imposed during the Regulation period too, the Regulation provision in force on the date of the act is compared with the current Article 54 and the one more favourable to the student applies.

Council of State Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers Decision (dissenting opinion)
Council of State, Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2024/2841, K. 2025/1683, 17.09.2025 (dissenting opinion; the Assembly’s majority did not adopt this view)

“In conclusion, in Kemal Alican Yeğen and Others, a violation as regards lawfulness was found on the ground that the statutory provision permitting the disciplinary penalties at issue to be regulated by regulation had been annulled by a Constitutional Court decision. In this context, on an assessment of the present case, given that the statutory provision underlying the Regulation that governed the penalty imposed on the claimant was annulled by a Constitutional Court decision and that disciplinary offences and penalties must be laid down by law, the disciplinary penalty at issue, imposed under Regulation provisions that were left without a legal basis and that breach the principle that legislative power cannot be delegated, is not lawful.”

Annulment Action: Jurisdiction, Time Limit and Appeal

An objection against a disciplinary penalty may be lodged with the university executive board within fifteen days (Law No. 2547, art. 54/10-ç); the objection is not mandatory, and recourse may be had directly to the administrative courts without using it (art. 54/10-e). Since a suspension for cheating is an administrative act, it is challenged by an annulment action before the administrative court. As a rule the action must be brought within sixty days of the act’s notification to the student (Administrative Procedure Code art. 7). The administrative court’s decision is subject to appeal (istinaf) before the regional administrative court. Actions concerning a one-semester suspension are not among the actions open to cassation under Article 46(1) of the Administrative Procedure Code; that paragraph opens cassation for acts resulting in removal from student status, i.e. expulsion from the institution (art. 46/1-d). The regional administrative court’s decision dismissing the appeal is therefore final. Under the second paragraph added to Article 46 by Law No. 7589 of 16/7/2026, however, in actions outside the first paragraph, decisions given anew by the regional administrative court after quashing the first-instance decision may, save for the exceptions listed in that paragraph, be appealed on points of law before the Council of State; this rule applies to decisions given by regional administrative courts after 31/7/2026 (Law No. 7589, provisional art. 1/3). Requesting a stay of execution together with the action is important to suspend the penalty.

Court Decisions

In the files below the 8th Chamber of the Council of State did not examine the merits; it upheld the regional administrative courts’ decisions rejecting the appeal on points of law on the ground that the appellate decision was final. The reasoning quoted therefore belongs to the final regional administrative court and first-instance decisions. The decisions concern exams held in 2021, i.e. the period when the Regulation was in force; the rules applied in them on the cheating penalty, the defence and the investigation report now appear, largely unchanged, in Article 54 of Law No. 2547.

A cheating penalty imposed without respecting the right of defence and the investigation procedure is annulled

Council of State (final regional-court appellate reasoning)

“… in the disciplinary investigation, after all evidence for and against the person is collected and it is set out beyond doubt, by concrete and legally acceptable evidence, which act was committed, where, when and how, the student must be asked to make a defence; the request-for-defence letter must state the imputed acts and the disciplinary penalty envisaged together with the legislation and its article, and must be duly served; and the penalty must be imposed by the competent authority or board after the defence is obtained — whereas imposing a ‘one-semester suspension’ on the basis of a report drawn up without following this procedure was found not to comply with procedure and law.”

If cheating is not proven by concrete evidence (expert report), the penalty is unlawful

Council of State (first-instance reasoning, final on regional appeal)

“… evaluating the expert report and the other information and documents in the file together, the examination answer sheet was the student’s own work, and therefore, since the student did not commit the act of cheating, there was no lawfulness in the act invalidating the exam and imposing a one-semester suspension.”

In a file where a separate penalty was reportedly imposed for each of several courses in the second make-up exams (2024/5452 E., 2024/7600 K., 25.12.2024), the 8th Chamber likewise upheld the regional administrative court’s decision rejecting the administration’s appeal on points of law, after the first-instance annulment — given on the ground that the student had not committed the act of cheating — had become final on appeal.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the disciplinary penalty for cheating in an exam?

Under Article 54 of Higher Education Law No. 2547, cheating or enabling cheating in exams requires one-semester suspension from the institution. Attempting to cheat is punished by a reprimand, while cheating by threat, preventing the removal of cheating students from the exam hall, having another person sit the exam or sitting it for another person requires two-semester suspension. These rules were contained in the Higher Education Institutions Student Discipline Regulation until 2023; the Regulation was repealed on 11.03.2023.

Is a penalty imposed without taking my defence valid?

No. The student must be informed in writing, at least seven days before the defence date, of what the imputed offence consists of, and the investigation must allow the student to defend themselves properly (Law No. 2547, art. 54/5). A penalty imposed without duly requesting the defence is annulled before the administrative courts for breach of the right of defence. However, a student who fails to respond to the summons without a valid excuse is deemed to have waived the right of defence.

How must cheating be proven?

The allegation must be established by concrete, legally acceptable and doubt-free evidence. The investigator may hear witnesses, conduct an inspection and consult experts (Law No. 2547, art. 54/6-b). Especially in online exams, technical claims such as the authorship of the answer sheet may require expert examination; if the act is not found established, the penalty is annulled.

How and within what time can I challenge a suspension?

An objection may be lodged with the university executive board within fifteen days; it is not mandatory, and an annulment action may be brought directly (Law No. 2547, art. 54/10). The annulment action is brought before the administrative court, as a rule within sixty days of notification (Administrative Procedure Code, art. 7). To suspend the penalty, a stay of execution should be requested together with the action.

Is cassation available against a suspension?

Since actions concerning a one-semester suspension are not listed in Article 46(1) of the Administrative Procedure Code, the regional administrative court’s decision dismissing the appeal is final; the 8th Chamber of the Council of State upheld the rejection of the appeal on points of law even in a file where it was argued that consecutive penalties would end enrolment. Cassation is, however, available against expulsion from the institution (Administrative Procedure Code, art. 46/1-d). For decisions given after 31.07.2026, if the regional administrative court quashes the first-instance decision and decides anew, that decision may also be appealed on points of law, save for the statutory exceptions (Administrative Procedure Code, art. 46/2).

If I am acquitted in the criminal case, is the disciplinary penalty lifted?

Disciplinary and criminal processes are independent; the initiation of criminal prosecution, or the student’s conviction or acquittal, does not bar a disciplinary penalty (Law No. 2547, art. 54/6-ğ). Acquittal therefore does not by itself remove the disciplinary penalty, but the penalty is separately reviewed by the administrative courts as to the proof of the act and the lawfulness of the procedure.

Within Administrative Law, Çapar Law Office advises and litigates in actions to annul student and civil-servant disciplinary penalties; for the general framework of judicial review of disciplinary penalties see our article Judicial Review of Disciplinary Penalties.

Related Articles

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory and regulatory texts are taken from the Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database; the cited decisions are not files to which the office was a party.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Higher Education Law

All Higher Education Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Disciplinary Penalties for Student Cheating: Unlawfulness and Annulment under Turkish Law”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-08, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/unlawfulness-annulment-disciplinary-penalties-imposed

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›