Last reviewed:
Judicial Review of Disciplinary Penalties
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, disciplinary penalties are administrative acts and may therefore be challenged for unlawfulness in an annulment action before the administrative court; unless a special law provides otherwise, the filing period is sixty days from the day following notification (Administrative Procedure Law (İYUK) Art. 7). Warnings, reprimands and deductions from salary may be objected to before the disciplinary board, and suspension of step advancement before the high disciplinary board, within seven days; this route is optional, and an action may be brought without objecting first (Law No. 657, Art. 135). The court reviews the penalty as to competence, form, grounds, subject and purpose, but cannot review its expediency. In the case law of the Council of State, a penalty imposed without a properly taken defence, a penalty whose underlying act is not established beyond all doubt by conclusive and sufficient evidence, and a penalty disproportionate to the act have been found unlawful. Filing an action does not by itself suspend the penalty; where the conditions are met, a stay of execution must be requested separately (İYUK Art. 27).
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
The legal framework and judicial review of disciplinary penalties imposed on civil servants and public officials (warning, reprimand, deduction from salary, suspension of step advancement, dismissal from the civil service): the categories of penalty (Law No. 657, Art. 125), the right of defence (Art. 130), limitation (Art. 127) and objection (Art. 135); the investigation procedure, the standard of proof, the principle of proportionality, the relationship with criminal proceedings, the competent administrative court, the filing period and the stay of execution, with decisions of the 12th and 2nd Chambers and the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State.
The legal framework and administrative-court review of disciplinary penalties imposed on civil servants and other public officials (warning, reprimand, deduction from salary, suspension of step advancement, dismissal from the civil service); the disciplinary investigation and the right of defence (Law No. 657, Art. 130), the categories of penalty and the corresponding acts (Art. 125), limitation periods (Art. 127), objection and the judicial route (Art. 135), the standard of proof, the principle of proportionality, the relationship with criminal proceedings, the competent court, the filing period and the stay of execution, together with decisions of the 12th and 2nd Chambers and the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State (Danıştay).
A disciplinary penalty is an administrative sanction imposed by the administration on a public official for acts and conduct contrary to the legislation, the working order and the requirements of the service, in order to protect the institution's internal order. Since disciplinary penalties are administrative acts, they may be challenged in an annulment action before the administrative judiciary on the ground that they are unlawful. This article addresses, for civil servants, the categories of disciplinary penalty, the investigation procedure and the right of defence, limitation, the objection mechanism, the scope of judicial review (proof, proportionality), the competent court and the settled criteria of the Council of State.
What Is a Disciplinary Penalty? Fundamentals of Civil-Service Disciplinary Law
The disciplinary liability of civil servants is largely regulated in Law No. 657 on Civil Servants and in the Civil Servants Disciplinary Regulation issued thereunder. Disciplinary law is subject to its own principles and rules, distinct from criminal law; yet the fundamental principles guaranteed by the Constitution (the right of defence, the rule of law, proportionality) apply here too. Article 129 of the Constitution expressly provides that no disciplinary penalty may be imposed on civil servants and other public officials without granting the right of defence. For a disciplinary penalty to be lawful, the act giving rise to it must be proven, a duly conducted disciplinary investigation must be carried out, the right of defence must be granted, the penalty must be imposed by the competent superior or board within the limitation periods, and there must be a proportionate balance between the act and the penalty.
Categories of Disciplinary Penalty and the Corresponding Acts
Law No. 657 provides for five categories of disciplinary penalty, increasing in severity: warning, reprimand, deduction from salary, suspension of step advancement and dismissal from the civil service. The acts and situations corresponding to each category are listed one by one in the Law. A penalty one degree lighter may be applied for officials with a positive service record, while in case of repetition a penalty one degree heavier is applied.
“The disciplinary penalties to be imposed on civil servants and the acts and situations requiring each disciplinary penalty are as follows: A - Warning: a written notice to the official that they must be more careful in their duties and conduct. … B - Reprimand: a written notice to the official that they have been at fault in their duties and conduct. … C - Deduction from salary: a deduction of between 1/30 and 1/8 from the official's gross salary. … D - Suspension of step advancement: the suspension, for 1 to 3 years according to the gravity of the act, of the official's advancement in the step they occupy. … E - Dismissal from the civil service: dismissal from office so as never again to be appointed to the civil service. …”
The authorities competent to impose the penalty are also set out in the Law: warning, reprimand and deduction from salary are imposed by the disciplinary superiors; suspension of step advancement after a decision of the disciplinary board, by the appointing authority; and dismissal from the civil service by decision of the high disciplinary board.
“Warning, reprimand and deduction-from-salary penalties are imposed by the disciplinary superiors; the suspension-of-step-advancement penalty is imposed, after a decision of the disciplinary board of the institution to which the official is attached, by the appointing authorities — in cases based on decisions of the provincial disciplinary boards, by the governors. The dismissal-from-the-civil-service penalty is imposed, upon the superiors' request to that effect, by decision of the high disciplinary board of the institution to which the official is attached. …”
The Disciplinary Investigation and the Right of Defence (Procedure)
A disciplinary penalty is, as a rule, imposed at the end of a duly conducted disciplinary investigation. In the investigation evidence is collected, witnesses are heard and the alleged act is concretely identified. The most critical stage of this process is the right of defence: no penalty may be imposed without notifying the official of the allegations, the evidence on which they rest and the legal characterisation of the act. A period of at least seven days must be granted for the defence.
“No disciplinary penalty may be imposed on a civil servant without taking their defence. An official who does not submit their defence within the period — not less than 7 days — given by the investigator or the competent disciplinary board, or on the date specified, is deemed to have waived the right of defence.”
The Civil Servants Disciplinary Regulation of 30 April 2021 sets out in detail how the defence is to be requested: the defence is requested by stating the allegations against the official, the evidence on which they rest, the legal characterisation of the alleged act, and which of the acts listed in Article 125 of Law No. 657 it falls under, indicating the relevant sub-paragraph. If new information and documents enter the file after the defence has been taken, an additional defence must be granted, indicating what they are.
Limitation: Time-limits to Open an Investigation and to Impose a Penalty
Disciplinary law contains two separate limitation periods. The first is the limitation to open an investigation: if an investigation is not begun within one month for warning, reprimand, deduction from salary and suspension of step advancement, and within six months for dismissal, calculated from the date the act is learned of, the power to impose a penalty lapses. The second is the limitation to impose a penalty: if no penalty is imposed within at most two years from the date the act was committed, the power lapses (current arrangement following the amendment of 23 January 2026).
“In respect of those who commit the acts and situations listed in Article 125 of this Law, calculated from the date on which the commission of these acts and situations is learned of; a) for warning, reprimand, deduction from salary and suspension of step advancement, if a disciplinary investigation is not begun within one month, b) for dismissal from the civil service, if disciplinary proceedings are not begun within six months, the power to impose a disciplinary penalty becomes time-barred. If no disciplinary penalty is imposed within at most two years from the date on which the acts and situations requiring a disciplinary penalty were committed, the power to impose a penalty becomes time-barred. Where a disciplinary penalty is annulled by a judicial decision, a disciplinary penalty may be imposed anew, taking into account the reasoning of the decision, within the remaining disciplinary limitation period counted from the date on which the decision reaches the administration; where the limitation period has expired or less than six months of it remain, within six months at the latest.”
Objection and the Judicial Route
An administrative objection may first be made against a disciplinary penalty; this route is optional. An objection may be made within seven days against warning, reprimand and deduction-from-salary penalties to the disciplinary board, and against the suspension-of-step-advancement penalty to the high disciplinary board. Penalties not objected to become final. In any event the judicial route is open against disciplinary penalties; the official may bring an annulment action directly, without objecting.
“An objection may be made against warning, reprimand and deduction-from-salary penalties imposed by the disciplinary superiors to the disciplinary board, and against the suspension-of-step-advancement penalty to the high disciplinary board. The period for objection is seven days from the date the decision is served on the person concerned. Disciplinary penalties not objected to within the period become final. The objection authorities are obliged to give their decision within thirty days of the objection petition and the decision and its annexes reaching them. If the objection is accepted, the disciplinary superiors may, on review of the decision, mitigate or entirely lift the penalty imposed. Recourse to the administrative judiciary is available against disciplinary penalties.”
When an annulment action is brought, the court reviews the disciplinary penalty as an administrative act for lawfulness in terms of its elements of competence, form, cause, subject-matter and purpose. The administrative judiciary may not conduct an expediency review; but it filters the administration's discretionary power through proportionality and lawfulness.
“Annulment actions, brought by those whose interests are violated, for the annulment of administrative acts on the ground that they are unlawful in terms of one of competence, form, cause, subject-matter and purpose, … Administrative judicial power is limited to the review of the lawfulness of administrative acts and actions. Administrative courts may not conduct an expediency review, …”
The Scope of Judicial Review: Proof, Proportionality and Evidence
According to the settled case-law of the Council of State, three axes stand out when the lawfulness of a disciplinary penalty is reviewed. The first is proof: the commission of the alleged act must be established concretely, with certain and sufficient evidence, beyond all doubt; otherwise a penalty resting on an unproven act is annulled. The second is proportionality: there must be a fair balance between the act and the penalty; the administration must observe the sub-principles of proportionality — suitability, necessity and commensurability. The third is the relationship with criminal proceedings: disciplinary law and criminal procedure are separate disciplines; the criminal court's finding as to the proof of the same act is to be respected. As to evidence, all the evidence — technical examinations and witness statements alike — is assessed once the file is complete; where necessary, the court exercises its power of ex officio investigation.
Competent Court, Time-limit and Stay of Execution
An action seeking the annulment of a disciplinary penalty is, as a rule, heard before the administrative court. Where no separate period is provided in a special law, the period for bringing the action is sixty days from the day following the written notification (service) (Administrative Procedure Law, Art. 7). If the objection route has been used or an application to the superior authority has been made, Article 11 must be taken into account as regards the period. Bringing the action does not by itself stay the application of the penalty; therefore, if the conditions — the occurrence of harm that is difficult or impossible to remedy and the manifest unlawfulness of the act — are met together, a stay of execution must be requested (Art. 27). As the period is a forfeiture period, it is important to obtain legal advice immediately after service.
Council of State Decisions
The judicial review of civil-service disciplinary penalties is conducted in the administrative judiciary essentially by the relevant chambers of the Council of State (historically the 12th and 5th Chambers, and in the current structure the 2nd and 5th Chambers) and, on points of principle, by the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers. The decisions below were verified in full text from the official case-law database.
No disciplinary penalty may be imposed without taking the defence in due form
“… The importance of the right of defence is also emphasised in Article 129 of our Constitution, [which provides] that no disciplinary penalty may be imposed on civil servants and other public officials without granting the right of defence. … When the defence of the public official under investigation is taken for the purpose of imposing a disciplinary penalty, the act constituting the disciplinary offence must be clearly identified, and which disciplinary rules that act infringes must be set out. … since the act established as a result of a defence not taken in due form is unlawful, … the act in question was found not to be sound.” (unofficial translation)
Proof: if the act is not established beyond all doubt with certain and sufficient evidence, the penalty is annulled (upheld determination)
“… since it cannot be said that the claimant's commission of the said act was established concretely, with certain and sufficient evidence, beyond all doubt, there is no lawfulness in the disciplinary penalty imposed on account of an unproven act …” (Chamber: “The reviewed decision is in accordance with procedure and law … it is UPHELD …”)
Proportionality: a fair balance must be observed between the act and the penalty (upheld determination)
“… that the administrations, in determining and assessing a disciplinary penalty for public officials, must observe the delicate balance between offence and penalty; that the organs competent to impose a disciplinary penalty, while bound by the legislation, must also take into account suitability, necessity and commensurability — the sub-principles of proportionality, which is among the universal norms of law; and that, accordingly, a penalty proportionate to the act established for the claimant should have been applied, … there is no lawfulness in the act in question …” (unofficial translation)
Criminal proceedings and disciplinary law are separate; the criminal court's finding on the proof of the act is to be respected
“Criminal-procedure law and disciplinary law are disciplines subject to different rules and principles. … Where the acts that are the subject of the disciplinary offence and of the criminal trial are the same, in disputes concerning the disciplinary investigation the finding reached by the criminal court as to the proof of the act must be respected, and expressions questioning it must not be used in the decisions …” (unofficial translation)
Frequently Asked Questions
What disciplinary penalties are there?
Article 125 of Law No. 657 provides for five penalties increasing in severity: warning, reprimand, deduction from salary, suspension of step advancement and dismissal from the civil service. The corresponding acts and situations are listed one by one; the same kind of penalty may also be imposed for acts of similar gravity.
A disciplinary penalty was imposed without taking my defence; what can I do?
No disciplinary penalty may be imposed without taking the defence (Art. 130), a guarantee protected by Article 129 of the Constitution. If the defence was not taken at all, or not taken in due form (by notifying the allegations, the evidence and the characterisation of the act), this is in itself a ground for annulment. An action may be brought before the administrative court to annul the penalty.
Should I object first, or bring an action directly?
The objection route is optional. You may object within seven days against warning, reprimand and deduction-from-salary penalties to the disciplinary board, and against the suspension-of-step-advancement penalty to the high disciplinary board. You may also bring an annulment action before the administrative judiciary directly, without objecting; in any event the judicial route is open (Art. 135).
Within what period does a disciplinary penalty become time-barred?
There are two periods: the period to open an investigation (one month for warning/reprimand/deduction from salary/suspension of step advancement, six months for dismissal) and the period to impose a penalty (at most two years from the date the act was committed). If these periods are exceeded, the power to impose a penalty lapses (Art. 127).
I was acquitted in the criminal case; is my disciplinary penalty automatically lifted?
No, it is not lifted automatically. Disciplinary law and criminal procedure are separate disciplines; the official's not being convicted under criminal law does not by itself prevent a disciplinary penalty. However, the criminal court's finding as to the proof of the same act (whether or not it occurred) must be respected in the administrative judiciary.
In which court and within what period is the action brought?
The action to annul a disciplinary penalty is, as a rule, heard before the administrative court. The period to bring the action is sixty days from the day following service (Administrative Procedure Law, Art. 7). Bringing the action does not by itself stay the application of the penalty; if the conditions are met, a stay of execution must be requested separately (Art. 27).
Within Administrative Law, Çapar Law Office handles objections against disciplinary penalties imposed on civil servants and public officials and annulment actions before the administrative judiciary, reviewing the lawfulness of the act in terms of the right of defence, proof, proportionality and limitation.
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- Disciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment Actions: In Light of Pamukkale University Cases
- Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings: Challenging University Vacancies Drafted for One Candidate under Turkish Law
- Türkiye’s “Full-Time Law” for Physicians: The Chronological Development of the Restrictions on Private Practice by Physicians and Faculty Members from 1928 to 2026 and the Current Position
Related Articles
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- Disciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment Actions
- Annulment of Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings at Universities
- Türkiye’s “Full-Time Law” for Physicians: The Chronological Development of the Restrictions on Private Practice by Physicians and Faculty Members from 1928 to 2026 and the Current Position
- Union Standing Cannot Be Judged on Members’ Interest Alone: Turkish Constitutional Court on a Trade Union’s Annulment Action
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Administrative law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Administrative Law
- Appeals in Afyonkarahisar Cases in Türkiye: Konya Regional Court of Appeal and Regional Administrative Court
- Unlawful Processing of Personal Data in Türkiye: Application, KVKK Complaint, Damages, Criminal Code Art. 136
- Tax Cases from Uşak, Afyonkarahisar and Kütahya: Which Court, Time Limits and Appeal in Türkiye
- Building, Facilities and Mining in Olive Groves in Türkiye: Law No. 3573, Prohibitions and Legal Remedies
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Judicial Review of Disciplinary Penalties”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/judicial-review-disciplinary-penalties

























