Administrative Law
Denizli administrative law attorney Bayram Can Çapar: actions for annulment and full remedy actions, administrative acts, disciplinary penalties and public procurement.
This page explains Turkish law. It is an English version of the Turkish page; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Acts of the administration directly affect people's rights in many areas, such as appointments, penalties, licences and tenders. An action for annulment brought in time against an unlawful administrative act is the most effective means of protection.
The office provides advice and litigation services in disputes concerning disciplinary penalties, administrative fines, losses caused by administrative acts and actions, and public procurement.
Key Legislation
- Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) (2577 sayılı İdari Yargılama Usulü Kanunu)Provisions most cited in the articles: Art. 2, Art. 7, Art. 13, Art. 11
- Constitution of the Republic of Türkiye (No. 2709) (2709 sayılı Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Anayasası)Provisions most cited in the articles: Art. 125, Art. 36, Art. 70, Art. 138
- Expropriation Law (Law No. 2942) (2942 sayılı Kamulaştırma Kanunu)Provisions most cited in the articles: Art. 10, Art. 11, Provisional Art. 6, Art. 14
- Higher Education Law (Law No. 2547) (2547 sayılı Yükseköğretim Kanunu)Provisions most cited in the articles: Art. 24, Art. 23, Art. 33, Art. 54
- Civil Servants Law (Law No. 657) (657 sayılı Devlet Memurları Kanunu)Provisions most cited in the articles: Art. 125, Art. 126, Art. 127, Art. 130
The statutes are linked to the official Turkish Legislation Information System (mevzuat.gov.tr); the texts there are in Turkish.
Competent Courts and Authorities
Our office is in Denizli. Below are the courts and authorities seised in disputes in this field in Denizli and in the other provinces where we follow cases; each entry links to its official source.
Denizli
- Administrative court Denizli İdare Mahkemeleri
- Regional administrative court İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
Aegean: İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya
İzmir
- Administrative court İzmir İdare Mahkemeleri
- Regional administrative court İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
Aydın
- Administrative court Aydın İdare Mahkemeleri
- Regional administrative court İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
Muğla
- Administrative court Muğla İdare Mahkemeleri
- Regional administrative court İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
Manisa
- Administrative court Manisa İdare Mahkemeleri
- Regional administrative court İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
Uşak
- Administrative court Uşak İdare Mahkemesi
- Regional administrative court İzmir Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
Afyonkarahisar
- Administrative court Afyonkarahisar İdare Mahkemesi
- Regional administrative court Konya Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
Kütahya
- Administrative court Kütahya İdare Mahkemesi
- Regional administrative court Bursa Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
İstanbul and Ankara
İstanbul
- Administrative court İstanbul İdare Mahkemeleri
- Regional administrative court İstanbul Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
Ankara
- Administrative court Ankara İdare Mahkemeleri
- Regional administrative court Ankara Bölge İdare Mahkemesi
Articles in This Area (66)
Actions for annulment, administrative applications and objections to administrative sanctions
Administrative LawAppeals in Afyonkarahisar Cases in Türkiye: Konya Regional Court of Appeal and Regional Administrative CourtUnder Turkish law, appeals against civil and criminal decisions in Afyonkarahisar go to the Konya Regional Court of Appeal, and appeals against administrative and tax decisions go to the Konya Regional Administrative Court. This article explains the official basis of this mapping, where the petition is lodged, the time limits and the relevant case law.
Administrative LawUnlawful Processing of Personal Data in Türkiye: Application, KVKK Complaint, Damages, Criminal Code Art. 136Under Turkish law, a person whose personal data has been processed unlawfully first applies to the data controller and, if this fails, may complain to the Personal Data Protection Board within the 30/60-day limits. The article explains administrative fines and actions against them, compensation under general provisions and the offences in Turkish Criminal Code arts. 135–136, with Court of Cassation and Council of State decisions.
Administrative LawTax Cases from Uşak, Afyonkarahisar and Kütahya: Which Court, Time Limits and Appeal in TürkiyeThere is no tax court in Uşak, Afyonkarahisar or Kütahya; tax cases are heard by the Manisa, Konya and Eskişehir Tax Courts respectively. This article explains, under Turkish law and with official sources and Council of State decisions, the venue rule (Law No. 2577 art. 37), the thirty- and fifteen-day time limits, where the petition may be lodged, what happens when a case is filed in the wrong court, and the appellate court.
Administrative LawBuilding, Facilities and Mining in Olive Groves in Türkiye: Law No. 3573, Prohibitions and Legal RemediesUnder Turkish law, Law No. 3573 art. 20 prohibits facilities that leave chemical waste or emit dust and smoke within olive grove areas and within 3 kilometres of them; olive grove areas may not be reduced and uprooting trees requires permission. The article explains the source of the definition of an olive grove area, the annulled regulation provisions, provisional article 45 of the Mining Law and the remedies against EIA, mining and expropriation acts in Türkiye, with Council of State decisions.
Administrative Lawİzmir Regional Administrative Court: Jurisdiction (İzmir, Aydın, Denizli, Manisa, Muğla, Uşak) and AppealsThe İzmir Regional Administrative Court hears appeals against decisions of the administrative and tax courts in İzmir, Aydın, Denizli, Manisa, Muğla and Uşak. This article explains, under Turkish law and with official sources, the courts province by province, the thirty-day time limit, where to lodge the petition, final decisions, the expedited procedure and cassation after Law No. 7589.
Administrative LawForeign-Currency Military Service, Deferment Abroad in Türkiye: Conditions, Cancellation, Multiple NationalsUnder Turkish law, deferment abroad (art. 38) and military service by foreign-currency payment (art. 39) under the Military Recruitment Law No. 7179 for male Turkish citizens living abroad: the three-year condition, multiple nationals, the payment formula, cancellation, refunds and the route to court, with Council of State decisions.
Administrative LawThe Blue Card and Dual Citizenship in Türkiye: Rights of Former Turkish Citizens Who Renounced with PermissionUnder Turkish law, the rights in Türkiye of persons who renounced Turkish citizenship with permission and of their descendants under art. 28 of Law No. 5901: the Blue Card, the exceptions (elections, military service, duty-free vehicle import, cadre-based civil service) and persons deprived of citizenship, with Council of State and Court of Cassation decisions.
Administrative LawUnion Standing Not Judged on Members' Interest Alone: Turkish Constitutional Court on Union Annulment ActionUnder Turkish law, the Constitutional Court unanimously held that administrative court decisions dismissing a trade union's annulment action for lack of standing, on the basis of the members' common interest alone and without discussing the act's effect on the union's own legal personality, violated the right of access to a court, and ordered a retrial.
Administrative LawChallenging a Refusal of Veteran or Martyr Status in Türkiye: Disability, Laws No. 3713 and 2330, Time LimitsChallenging refusals of service-disability, martyr or veteran status in Türkiye: Laws No. 3713, 2330, 5510 and 5434, the 2026 amendments by Law No. 7594, administrative versus labour courts, time limits and case law.
Administrative LawThe Annulment Action in Administrative JurisdictionA comprehensive guide to the annulment action in administrative jurisdiction: the definition of the action and the elements of an administrative act (competence, form, cause, subject-matter, purpose) under Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577, Art. 2; violation of interest and subjective standing; the final-and-enforceable (executory) act requirement; the filing period (Art. 7) and application to the superior authority (Art. 11); the stay of execution (Art. 27); the competent court; the principle of ex officio investigation; and the effects of an annulment decision, with decisions of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers and the 2nd and 6th Chambers of the Council of State.
Commercial & Corporate LawAppeals from Kütahya in Türkiye: Bursa Regional Court of Appeal and Bursa Regional Administrative CourtUnder Turkish law, appeals against civil and criminal judgments given in Kütahya go to the Bursa Regional Court of Appeal, and appeals in administrative and tax cases go to the Bursa Regional Administrative Court. This article sets out the official basis of these links, where the petition is lodged and the time limits.
Real Estate LawProperty Inside the Shore Edge Line in Türkiye: Title Cancellation, Compensation and Legal RemediesUnder Turkish law, the title to land lying on the seaward side of the shore edge line may be cancelled in an action brought by the Treasury, and the owner may claim the loss from the Treasury under art. 1007 of the Turkish Civil Code. The article explains how the line is determined, the objection and the annulment action, title cancellation, compensation claims brought before the title is cancelled, how compensation is calculated, the ten-year limitation period and the competent court, with decisions of the Constitutional Court, the Court of Cassation and the Council of State.
Mining & Energy LawMining Licence Cancellation in Türkiye: Forfeited Security and Fines (Law No. 3213 Arts. 10, 13, 17, 24)Under Turkish law, an action against an administrative fine imposed under the Mining Law must be brought before the administrative court within thirty days of notification, and the action does not stop collection; for the cancellation of a licence, on this article’s own inference, the general sixty-day limit applies as a rule. The article explains the grounds for cancellation and fines, forfeiture of the security deposit and the competent court with Council of State and Constitutional Court decisions.
Competition LawPrice-Fixing, Information Exchange and Concerted Practices in Türkiye (Law No. 4054 Art. 4): Fines, LeniencyUnder Turkish law, joint price-setting, exchange of competitively sensitive information and concerted practices between competitors are prohibited by Article 4 of Law No. 4054, and the Competition Board may impose fines of up to ten percent of annual gross revenue. This guide explains the presumption of concerted practice, how fines are calculated, and leniency, settlement and commitments, with Competition Board and Council of State decisions.
Competition LawChallenging Competition Board Decisions in Türkiye: Administrative Fines, Competent Court and Time LimitsUnder Turkish law, an action against an administrative sanction decision of the Competition Board is brought before the competent administrative court; the time limit is sixty days from notification of the reasoned decision, and filing the action does not suspend collection of the fine. The article covers the investigation procedure under Law No. 4054, rights of defence, on-site inspections, fine rates, settlement, stay of execution and appeals, with Constitutional Court and Council of State decisions.
Real Estate LawShort-Term Tourist Rentals in Türkiye: The Permit, Flat Owners' Unanimous Decision and Administrative FinesUnder Turkish law, letting a dwelling for one hundred days or less requires a permit under Law No. 7464, and in a building with more than one independent unit a unanimous decision of all flat owners is required as a rule. The article explains the application, the exceptions to unanimity, the twenty-five per cent cap, the ban on subletting, administrative fines, remedies and the neighbours' rights under condominium law, with decisions of the Constitutional Court, the Council of State and the Court of Cassation.
Citizenship & Foreigners LawAcquiring Turkish Citizenship after Birth: Routes, Conditions and Challenging a RefusalUnder Turkish law, citizenship may be acquired after birth through the general route (five years of uninterrupted residence), marriage (at least three years), the exceptional route, re-acquisition and adoption; meeting the conditions does not give an absolute right. The article explains the conditions in Law No. 5901, the application procedure in Türkiye, the sixty-day time limit, the competent court and how the Council of State and the Constitutional Court review refusals.
Commercial & Corporate LawAppeals in İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye: Regional Courts of Appeal and Regional Administrative CourtsUnder Turkish law, this guide explains which regional court of appeal and which regional administrative court hear appeals against civil, criminal, administrative and tax court decisions in İstanbul and Ankara, the official basis of their jurisdiction, and where and when the appeal is lodged. It also shows how the jurisdiction of the Ankara administrative courts over central government acts affects the appellate court.
Real Estate LawRisky Building Designation under Law No. 6306 in Türkiye: Owners' Rights, Agreement and Legal RemediesUnder Turkish law, owners may object to a risky building designation before a technical board within fifteen days, and the time limit for an action against administrative acts taken under Law No. 6306 is thirty days from notification. The article explains designation and notification, eviction and demolition, the absolute majority decision, the sale of the land share of an owner who does not join the decision, tenants' rights and the division between civil and administrative jurisdiction, with decisions of the Council of State and the Court of Cassation.
Higher Education LawActions Against YÖK and University Acts in Türkiye: Which Administrative Court Has Territorial Jurisdiction?Under Turkish law, which administrative court has jurisdiction over actions against acts of YÖK, the Inter-University Board and universities: Administrative Procedure Law arts. 32 and 33 for students, academics and staff, first-instance cases before the Council of State, actions filed in the wrong court, time limits and the appellate court, with Council of State decisions.
Inheritance LawTurkish Inheritance and Transfer Tax for Heirs Abroad: Filing, Additional Periods, Instalments, Tax ClearanceUnder Turkish law, inheritance and transfer tax for heirs living abroad: the four-, six- and eight-month filing periods under art. 9 of Law No. 7338, the additional periods under art. 342 of the Tax Procedure Law, instalments, land register transfer and the tax clearance certificate under art. 19, with Council of State decisions.
Real Estate LawYear-Round Beach Occupation: Ecrimisil Due for Whole YearUnder Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State held that where an area under the sovereignty and disposal of the State is occupied as a beach, the business is open all year and the occupation continues throughout the year, ecrimisil is calculated for the whole year and not only for the summer season. The Assembly also held that a unit value fixed by a court decision for a comparable property for a different period cannot be taken directly as the basis of the calculation.
Criminal LawChallenging a Traffic Fine and Drink-Driving in Türkiye: 15-Day Period, Judgeship of Peace, LicenceChallenging a traffic administrative fine under the Misdemeanours Law (Law No. 5326 art. 27): the fifteen-day period from service or pronouncement, electronic notification, force majeure, petition to the criminal judgeship of peace, applying to the wrong authority (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 264), examination of the application, finality and the two-week objection (arts. 28-29), the payment period and the 25% reduction (Highway Traffic Law art. 115, Law No. 5326 art. 17); blood-alcohol limits and licence-withdrawal periods for drink-driving (Highway Traffic Law art. 48), refusing a breath test, conditions for return of the licence and the offence of endangering traffic safety above 1.00 per mille (Penal Code art. 179/3); without fine amounts, with verified decisions of the Court of Cassation.Disciplinary penalties: civil servants, academics and students
Administrative LawJudicial Review of Disciplinary PenaltiesThe legal framework and judicial review of disciplinary penalties imposed on civil servants and public officials (warning, reprimand, deduction from salary, suspension of step advancement, dismissal from the civil service): the categories of penalty (Law No. 657, Art. 125), the right of defence (Art. 130), limitation (Art. 127) and objection (Art. 135); the investigation procedure, the standard of proof, the principle of proportionality, the relationship with criminal proceedings, the competent administrative court, the filing period and the stay of execution, with decisions of the 12th and 2nd Chambers and the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State.
Higher Education LawArt. 54 Annulment Alone Does Not Lift Student Penalties: Turkish Council of State, Review Under Law No. 7437Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State did not regard the Constitutional Court’s annulment of Article 54 of Law No. 2547 as sufficient on its own to annul a student disciplinary penalty imposed under the former Regulation, and required a review on the merits, under the provision re-enacted by Law No. 7437 before the annulment took effect, of the proof of the act, whether it warrants the penalty and the more favourable provision. The Assembly quashed, finally and by majority, the regional administrative court’s decision of insistence that had annulled the penalty solely because of the annulment decision, and the file was sent back to that court for a new decision.
Higher Education LawMissing Rules on Deleting Student Penalties Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Disciplinary RecordsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, ruling at first instance and by majority, held that the absence of a clear rule on keeping higher education students’ disciplinary penalties on record and deleting them after certain conditions and a certain period breaches legal security, legal certainty and proportionality, and annulled the implied refusal of the application asking the Council of Higher Education to regulate the matter and the dean’s act based on it.
Higher Education LawDisciplinary Penalties for Student Cheating: Unlawfulness and Annulment under Turkish LawUnlawfulness and annulment of disciplinary penalties imposed for a student cheating in an exam: the disciplinary treatment of cheating (Higher Education Law No. 2547, art. 54 — reprimand for attempted cheating, one-semester suspension for cheating or enabling cheating, two-semester suspension for cheating by threat; the provision that replaced the Student Discipline Regulation repealed in 2023), the right of defence and investigation procedure (art. 54/5-6), proof of cheating by concrete evidence and expert report, proportionality and the problem of a separate penalty per course, the criminal-disciplinary relationship (art. 54/6-ğ), objection, the annulment action, the sixty-day time limit (Administrative Procedure Code art. 7) and the appeal route (art. 46, including the amendment by Law No. 7589), with decisions from files upheld by the 8th Chamber of the Council of State.
Higher Education LawDisciplinary Penalties on Academics and Annulment ActionsA guide to disciplinary penalties on academics in Türkiye and annulment actions: the special regime of Law No. 2547 and its differences from the civil-servant regime; penalty types (art. 53/b); the legality principle shaped by Constitutional Court annulments; investigation procedure, statement-taking and the right of defence (art. 53/A, as amended by Law No. 7592); limitation (art. 53/C); mandatory ethics-board and expert examination in plagiarism cases; the 60-day period, regional appeal and cassation only for removal penalties (APL art. 46) - with verified Council of State (8th Chamber) decisions in the university cases.Full remedy actions and service fault
Administrative LawDamages for Delayed Healthcare in Turkish Prisons: Jurisdiction, Time Limits, Service Fault and InterestUnder Turkish law, harm caused by delayed examination, treatment or hospital referral in a penal institution is claimed through a full-remedy action against the administration: the ordinary and administrative court divide, the one-year application and sixty-day action time limits, service fault, heads of damage, non-pecuniary damages and interest.
Health LawMedical Error in Turkish Public Hospitals: Full-Remedy Action, Prior Administrative Application, Time LimitsUnder Turkish law, an action for harm caused by medical treatment in a state or university hospital is as a rule brought against the administration, not the physician, as a full-remedy action before the administrative courts, as a rule after a prior application to the administration within one year and in any event five years. The article explains the proper defendant, the time limits in Law No. 2577 art. 13, the competent administrative court, expert reports, non-pecuniary damages and recourse against the physician, with Council of State, Court of Cassation and Constitutional Court decisions.
Health LawMalpractice Time Limit Runs from End of Treatment: Turkish Council of State on Five-Year Full-Remedy PeriodUnder Turkish law, the 10th Chamber of the Council of State held unanimously, in a full-remedy action brought for a child whose treatment was continuing and where it was alleged that the necessary interventions had not been made in time before and during birth, that the period in Administrative Procedure Law art. 13 starts when treatment ends and the final health report is given, and quashed the decision that had calculated the five-year period from the date of birth.
Commercial & Corporate LawTera, Pusula and Liquidated Fund Investors in Türkiye: Legal Roadmap on Liquidation, Claims, Full RemedyA guide for investors harmed in the Tera, Pusula and liquidated fund cases: CMB decisions, compensation, criminal complaints, bankruptcy claims, full-remedy actions.Expropriation and de facto expropriation
Real Estate LawExpropriation and Easements in Geothermal Resource Areas in Türkiye: The Landowner's RightsUnder Turkish law, a geothermal licence holder gains access to land by agreement, easement, expropriation or urgent expropriation, and only an easement may be requested under an exploration licence. The owner's rights to compensation, easement compensation, the remaining part and court actions under Laws No. 5686 and 2942, with Council of State and Court of Cassation decisions.
Real Estate LawMining Revenue and Tax Do Not Justify Urgent ExpropriationUnder Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State annulled, in respect of the immovable in dispute, an urgent expropriation decision taken for a gold mine, holding that revenue, State royalty and tax data do not show an extraordinary state of urgency and that the project's EIA positive decision had been annulled by an administrative court. The decision is final and was given by majority.
Real Estate LawExpropriation Price Determination and Registration in TürkiyeUnder Turkish law, the stages of the action for determination of the expropriation price and registration under art. 10 of Law No. 2942: summons and time-limits, the settlement hearing, site inspection and the expert panel, the criteria of art. 11, the deposit period, registration, fees and interest after the Constitutional Court’s annulment, with decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.
Real Estate Law1956–1983 Takings Valued at Suit Date by Character at Taking: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil AssemblyUnder Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that compensation for land taken without expropriation between 09.10.1956 and 04.11.1983 is determined under provisional art. 6 of Law No. 2942 on the basis of the land’s characteristics at the date of taking and its value at the date of the action. In a case where the land had been valued as a building plot by comparable sales on the basis of its zoning status at the date of the action without its character at the date of taking being determined, the Assembly reversed the decision of resistance by majority.
Real Estate LawUrgent Expropriation Annulment Does Not End Price Suit: Turkish Cassation Assembly, If Expropriation StandsUnder Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, the Council of State’s annulment of an urgent expropriation decision only taints the taking of possession under the urgent procedure; as long as the public-interest and expropriation decisions have not been annulled, the action for determination of the price and registration under art. 10 of Law No. 2942 is heard on the merits. The decision was given by majority.
Real Estate LawExpropriation Price Checked Against Final Same-Scheme Awards: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil AssemblyUnder Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that, although the main principle for the expropriation price is real value, the price must be reviewed for consistency with the prices awarded and finalised for the other properties in the same expropriation area, and there should be no excessive differences in value between properties in similar locations. The Assembly unanimously reversed the decision of resistance of the regional court of appeal, which had departed from the experts’ price without a supplementary report and calculated the price itself using a five-year average yield and a 25% objective value increase.
Real Estate LawTurkish Court of Cassation 5th Civil Chamber: Most Reviewed Case Types and Current Leading DecisionsThe 5th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation is the specialised chamber for expropriation disputes. Based on a scan of the official case-law database, this article explains the case types most frequently reviewed by the Chamber (determination of expropriation compensation and registration, de facto expropriation, easement compensation, mesne profits, urgent expropriation); how compensation is assessed under Articles 10, 11 and 25 of Law No. 2942; the effect of the 26.06.2025 division-of-labour decision; and the Chamber's current leading decisions, together with case-duration observations read from the decisions.
Real Estate LawDe Facto Expropriation Claims in Türkiye: Compensation, Injunction and Mesne ProfitsA guide to de facto expropriation (kamulastirmasiz el atma) claims under Turkish law: the physical vs regulatory taking distinction and competent jurisdiction; the owner's alternative remedies (injunction and demolition, compensation, mesne profits); valuation as at the date of action and interest; the mandatory settlement procedure for 1956-1983 takings (Provisional art. 6); absence of prescription; fees and costs - with verified decisions of the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers and 5th Civil Chamber.
Real Estate LawExpropriation and the Owner's RightsA comprehensive guide to expropriation and the owner's rights: the constitutional basis and the real-value principle; the purchase-by-agreement procedure (Law No. 2942, Art. 8); the court determination of the price and the registration action (Art. 10); the valuation criteria (Art. 11 — comparable sales for building plots, net income/capitalisation for land, unit prices and depreciation for structures, objective value increase); the owner's right of action (Art. 14 — annulment and correction); the passing of ownership (Art. 25); de facto expropriation (Provisional Art. 6 — reconciliation as a condition of the action); urgent expropriation (Art. 27); the competent court; and decisions of the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation.Associate professorship and appointment of faculty members
Higher Education LawAssoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint PublicationsUnder Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State finally held, by majority, that an associate professor appointment was unlawful where it relied on the reports of a jury including a professor with several joint articles and papers with the appointee, and was made as if there were a single candidate although an expert had found that both candidates met the minimum conditions.
Higher Education LawResidence Rule Upheld for Assoc. Prof. Language Exams Abroad: Turkish Council of State on the 2022 GuideUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State found the provision of the 2022 March Term Associate Professorship Application Guide requiring associate professor candidates who sit a foreign language exam abroad to document at least six months’ residence in the exam country up to and including the exam date, not contrary to the public interest and the requirements of the service, and also held lawful the cancellation of the application of a candidate who did not submit a residence certificate. The decision was given at first instance and unanimously; since an appeal is open, it may not be final.
Higher Education LawAppointing a Markedly Lower Scorer Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on Assistant Professor RankingsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, holding unlawful the appointment of a candidate with a markedly lower score to an assistant professor post by departing from the objective ranking in the expert report, quashed the regional administrative court’s dismissal finally and by majority; as the top-ranked candidate had not sued, the Chamber held that the administration must annul the appointment and re-advertise the post.
Higher Education LawSplit Experts in Professor Case Need New Panel: Turkish Council of State on Conflicting Expert ReportsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State stated that, in a professor appointment where both candidates met the advertised requirements, the administration must compare them on objective and verifiable criteria of merit and scientific competence. As the expert panel was divided on which candidate was superior, it held that the dispute must be resolved with the report of a new panel of different persons and quashed the regional administrative court’s dismissal finally and unanimously.
Higher Education LawAnnulling Faculty Appointments in Türkiye: Appointment and Promotion Criteria, Non-Appointment, Non-RenewalUnder Turkish law, annulment actions against non-appointment to assistant professor, associate professor and professor posts and against non-reappointment: criteria under Law No. 2547 and the Regulation, YÖK-approved institutional criteria, limits of discretion, time limits and Council of State decisions.
Higher Education LawExcluding Associate Degree Courses Is Unlawful: Turkish Council of State on 2023 Associate Professor CriteriaUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State annulled the omission of associate degree courses from the 2023 associate professorship application requirements and upheld the other contested rules. The decision is subject to appeal in cassation.
Higher Education LawAssociate Professorship in Türkiye: Application Requirements and Annulment Action Against a Negative ResultUnder Turkish law, an application for associate professorship requires a doctorate, at least 55 points in a central foreign language examination and original publications set for each field; the Interuniversity Board's jury assesses the file through detailed and reasoned reports. An annulment action against a negative result is brought against the Presidency of the Interuniversity Board within sixty days before the administrative courts of Ankara; Higher Education Law No. 2547 art. 24, the Associate Professorship Regulation and Council of State decisions.
Higher Education LawAnnulling Tailor-Made Academic Job Postings in Türkiye: University Vacancies Drafted for One CandidateAnnulment actions against academic job postings tailored to one candidate: Constitution, Law No. 2547, regulations, time limits, standing, Council of State rulings.Academic posts and terms of office
Higher Education LawResearch Assistant Requirements, 50/d and 33/a Posts, TermUnder Turkish law, applying for a research assistant post requires at least 70 in ALES, at least 50 points in a central foreign language examination, not having reached the age of 35 on 1 January of the year of the entrance examination and, at state universities, postgraduate studentship; candidates go through a pre-assessment and a written entrance examination. Appointments are made under Article 50/d of Law No. 2547 using the procedure in Article 33; a 50/d post depends on postgraduate education, while a 33/a appointment lasts at most three years; the Central Examination Regulation and Council of State decisions.
Higher Education LawResearch Assistant Non-Renewal Needs Concrete Reasons: Turkish Council of State Requires Proportionate GroundsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held, by majority and as a final decision, that not renewing a research assistant's contract requires concrete and proportionate reasons, that academic staff at foundation universities enjoy the same professional security as those at state universities, and that a new ground raised during the proceedings does not on its own save the act.
Higher Education LawYÖK Paragraph Barring Court-Backed Appointments Annulled: Turkish Council of State on YLSY (Law No. 1416)Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld, on the same reasoning, the annulment of the paragraph of a YÖK general letter stating that those deemed unsuccessful under Law No. 1416 could not be appointed to teaching staff posts even by court decisions, as contrary to the administration’s duty to comply with judicial decisions. The Assembly also accepted that the scholarship holder whose ties with the university were severed had standing to challenge the whole letter, quashed the partial dismissal for lack of standing and sent the file back to the 8th Chamber for that part.
Higher Education LawRector Holds Power Not to Extend Assistant Professor Terms: Turkish Council of State on Vice-Rector DecisionUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State, in a final and unanimous decision quashing a regional administrative court judgment that had rejected the appeal, held that an act not extending an assistant professor's term, signed by a vice-rector, was unlawful for lack of authority because Article 23 of Law No. 2547 gives that power to the rector and contains no express provision for its delegation; as the merits were not examined, lost financial rights could not be granted directly at this stage.
Higher Education LawDoctoral Withdrawal Ends a 50/d Research Assistant Post: Turkish Council of State; 33/a Request Is SeparateUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held that a post under Article 50/d of Law No. 2547 is support limited to the duration of postgraduate education and that ties with the post must be severed when that education ends for any reason, finding lawful the severance of a research assistant who had the doctoral registration deleted at their own request; it left the 33/a request made around the same time outside the case. The Chamber quashed, finally and by majority, the regional administrative court decision rejecting the appeal, and the file was sent back to that court for a new decision.
Higher Education LawNo Regulatory Gap for Staff Already Over the Norm Cadre: Turkish Council of State on University StaffUnder Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State upheld the 8th Chamber’s decision rejecting the claim of incomplete regulation, because provisional Article 1 of the norm cadre regulation provides that teaching staff in excess of the norm cadre when it entered into force, and those appointed to posts advertised before then, continue to serve in their posts. The Chamber had also found lawful planning up to twice the minimum cadre and the maximum ratio for the same title; the ratio provision was amended both before and after the decision.
Higher Education LawLecturer Term Non-Extension Held Lawful on Combined Grounds: Turkish Council of State on Three FactsUnder Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State held lawful the non-extension of a lecturer’s term of office, assessing together that the precondition in Article 31 of Law No. 2547 had ceased to exist with the later appointment of an assistant professor to the field taught, that the action against a disciplinary penalty had been dismissed and that only 6 hours of the 12-hour teaching load had been fulfilled. The Chamber quashed, finally and by majority, the regional administrative court decision rejecting the appeal, and the file was sent back to that court.
Higher Education LawNo Age-35 Limit on Research Assistant Reappointment: Turkish Council of State on Article 33 of Law No. 2547Under Turkish law, the 8th Chamber of the Council of State unanimously and finally held that the age-35 condition in Article 33 of Law No. 2547 applies only to the first application for a research assistant post, not to the reappointment of a research assistant who met it on taking up the post.Zoning, building and urban transformation decisions
Urban Regeneration & Construction LawReserve Building Area Designation Annulment (Law No. 6306): Time Limit and Stay of Execution in TürkiyeUnder Turkish law, a reserve building area is an area designated by the Ministry for use in implementations under Law No. 6306; an action may be brought before the administrative courts within thirty days of notification against acts taken under the Law. The article explains the definition amended by Law No. 7471, the suspension of zoning procedures, the majority decision, stay of execution and decisions of the Council of State and the Constitutional Court on urgent expropriation.
Expropriation & Zoning LawHow to Challenge a Zoning Fine and a Demolition Order in Türkiye: Zoning Law No. 3194 Arts. 32 and 42Under Turkish law, an action against a stop-work report, a demolition order and a zoning fine for an unlicensed building is, as a rule, brought within the sixty-day period in art. 7 of the Administrative Procedure Law; in the decisions cited, the actions were heard by administrative courts. The article explains the one-month period to obtain a permit, how the fine is calculated, who is liable and the link with art. 184 of the Turkish Criminal Code.
Expropriation & Zoning LawZoning Readjustment under Art. 18 of Law No. 3194 in Türkiye: Contribution Share, Objection, Annulment ActionUnder article 18 of the Zoning Law (Law No. 3194), a municipality in Türkiye may merge and re-parcel land and plots without the owners’ consent and may deduct up to forty-five per cent of the pre-readjustment area as the readjustment contribution share. The article explains the scope and limits of that share, the allocation of parcels, posting and objection, the time limit for an annulment action and reversal after annulment, with decisions of the Council of State.Tax and public receivables disputes
Tax LawTax Loss Penalty and Settlement in Türkiye: How a Settlement Request Affects the Time to Sue (VUK, İYUK)Under Turkish law, the tax loss penalty is as a rule one times the tax; post-assessment settlement is requested within thirty days of service of the tax notice and, if no settlement is reached, the time limit for an action against the penalty is extended where necessary to fifteen days from service of the record. The article explains the art. 376 reduction, pre-assessment settlement, penalties excluded from settlement and the change made by Law No. 7524.
Tax LawCompany Tax Debt in Türkiye: Shareholder and Legal Representative Liability (Law 6183 Art. 35), Payment OrdersUnder Turkish law, the shareholder's proportional liability and the legal representative's duty-based liability for a limited company's unpaid tax debt, the order of enforcement, the relevant period and the 15-day time limit to challenge a payment order, with Constitutional Court and Council of State decisions.Foreign nationals: deportation, residence and work permits
Citizenship & Foreigners LawChallenging a Deportation Order and a Residence Permit Refusal in Türkiye: Law No. 6458 Arts. 53, 57 and 25Under Turkish law, an action against a deportation order must be brought before the administrative court within seven days of notification; the court's decision is final and, unless the foreigner consents, the foreigner is not deported until the proceedings end. The article explains the challenge to administrative detention before the criminal judge of peace, the entry ban, actions against residence permit refusals, and decisions of the Constitutional Court and the Council of State.
Citizenship & Foreigners LawWork Permits for Foreign Nationals in Türkiye: Challenging a Refusal and Fines (Law No. 6735 Arts. 21, 23)Under Turkish law, an objection against a work permit refusal may be filed with the Ministry within thirty days of notification, and the administrative courts may be seized if the objection is rejected; foreigners working without a permit and the employers who employ them face administrative fines, and the foreigner is reported for deportation. The article explains the application, refusal, objection and penalty provisions of the International Labour Force Law No. 6735 with decisions of the Council of State and the Court of Cassation.Recent Case Notes
- Court of Cassation: An SGK Fine Not Challenged in Time Cannot Be Disputed in a Payment-Order Action
- Mining Revenue and Tax Do Not Justify Urgent Expropriation
- Year-Round Beach Occupation: Ecrimisil Due for Whole Year
- Union Standing Not Judged on Members' Interest Alone: Turkish Constitutional Court on Union Annulment Action
- Assoc. Prof. Appointment Unlawful Over Co-Author Juror: Turkish Council of State on Joint Publications
Frequently Asked Questions
How is a disciplinary penalty challenged?
A disciplinary penalty may first be challenged by an administrative objection and then, in time, by an action for annulment before the administrative courts. The periods are short; the date of notification is decisive.
What is the time limit for bringing an action for annulment?
As a rule, an action for annulment against an administrative act is brought within sixty days of notification. Missing the period has consequences that are difficult to remedy.
I suffered a loss because of an administrative act. Can I claim compensation?
Losses caused by an unlawful administrative act or action may be claimed through a full remedy action.
Scope of Our Services
At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
- Actions for the annulment of administrative acts
- Objections to and annulment of disciplinary penalties (civil servants and other public officials)
- Full remedy (compensation) actions
- Objections to administrative fines
- Public procurement and complaint procedures
Send your request and we will get back to you shortly.
Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk · Phone: +90 258 241 55 54 · Email: info@capar.av.tr
Contact / Request a Meeting →
