Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 15 min read

Last reviewed:

De Facto Expropriation Claims in Türkiye: Compensation, Injunction and Mesne Profits

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, de facto expropriation occurs where the administration, without a lawful expropriation and without paying compensation, physically seizes privately owned land by building a road, building, park or power line on it, or designates the land for public services in the zoning plan and leaves it unexpropriated for a long time, restricting the owner’s power of disposal. In a physical taking, the registered owner or their heir may choose between an action to stop the interference and for demolition and accepting the situation and claiming the land’s value; in either case mesne profits (ecrimisil) may also be claimed for the period of wrongful use. Physical-taking claims are heard by the civil court of first instance where the land is located; in a compensation action the land’s value at the date of the action is decisive and statutory interest, as a rule, runs from that date. For a legal (regulatory) taking arising from zoning-plan restrictions, the compensation action is brought before the administrative courts. For takings between 09.10.1956 and 04.11.1983, the settlement procedure must first be completed as a precondition of the action, and if no settlement is reached an action to determine compensation may be brought within three months of the record of non-settlement (Expropriation Law No. 2942, Provisional art. 6).

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

A guide to de facto expropriation (kamulastirmasiz el atma) claims under Turkish law: the physical vs regulatory taking distinction and competent jurisdiction; the owner's alternative remedies (injunction and demolition, compensation, mesne profits); valuation as at the date of action and interest; the mandatory settlement procedure for 1956-1983 takings (Provisional art. 6); absence of prescription; fees and costs - with verified decisions of the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers and 5th Civil Chamber.

A guide to de facto expropriation (kamulaştırmasız el atma) claims under Turkish law: definition and elements, the distinction between physical (de facto) and legal (regulatory) taking, the owner’s alternative remedies (action to stop the interference and demolition, recovery of the land’s value, mesne profits/ecrimisil), valuation (land classification, comparable-sales method, statutory interest from the date of action), the mandatory settlement procedure for 1956–1983 takings (Expropriation Law No. 2942, Provisional art. 6), the competent jurisdiction (civil vs administrative courts), time limits, fees and costs, with verified decisions of the Turkish Court of Cassation (Assembly of Civil Chambers and 5th Civil Chamber).

What Is De Facto Expropriation?

Where the administration needs privately owned land for a public service, it may acquire it only through a formal expropriation complying with the guarantees of article 46 of the Constitution and against payment of its value. De facto expropriation (kamulaştırmasız el atma) occurs where the administration, without a lawful expropriation and without paying compensation, seizes the land physically or legally — by building a road, school, park or power transmission line on it, dedicating it to a public service, or otherwise interfering with the owner’s right of use. This is an unlawful interference with the core of the right of property (Constitution art. 35; Civil Code art. 683), and the owner is granted robust judicial remedies.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 683 (Content of ownership) (unofficial translation)

“The owner of a thing has the authority, within the limits of the legal order, to use, enjoy and dispose of it as they see fit. The owner may bring a replevin action against anyone who wrongfully withholds the thing, and may also sue for the prevention of any wrongful interference.”

The doctrine rests on the Court of Cassation’s Unification of Case-Law Decision of 16 May 1956 (No. 1/6), maintained today in Assembly of Civil Chambers case law; in 2010, Provisional article 6 added by Law No. 5999 brought the concept — for a limited period of takings — into the statute itself.

Physical Taking vs Regulatory (Legal) Taking

Practice distinguishes two types of taking, and the distinction determines both the nature of the claim and the competent jurisdiction:

Physical (de facto) taking is the administration’s actual seizure of the land: routing a road through it, erecting buildings or installations, laying out a park, running power transmission lines and pylons, or laying canals and pipelines. Possession passes to the administration and the owner can no longer use the property.

Regulatory (legal) taking arises where the land is not physically touched, but is designated in the zoning (implementation) plan for public services — school, road, park, public institution — and remains unexpropriated for years, so that the owner’s power of disposal is paralysed. The legislature addressed this in 2016 through Supplementary article 1, which imposes a five-year deadline:

Statutory Provision — Expropriation Law (Law No. 2942) Supplementary art. 1/1 (Zoning restrictions; five years) (unofficial translation)

“In respect of immovables whose disposal is legally restricted in a manner touching the core of the right of property by being allocated to public services and official institutions in implementation zoning plans, zoning programmes or zoning implementations shall be carried out within five years from the entry into force of the implementation zoning plans, and, within budgetary means, such immovables shall be expropriated by the relevant administrations, or in any event a zoning plan amendment removing the restriction preventing the exercise of the right of ownership shall be made or procured.”

If, within the five-year period, the land is neither expropriated nor freed of the restriction, the owner’s claim to compensation arises; but for this (regulatory) type of taking the action is brought before the administrative courts, as explained below. Several provisions of the article have been annulled by the Constitutional Court; the current text must always be checked in the specific case.

The Owner’s Alternative Remedies

An owner whose land is physically seized enjoys alternative remedies under settled case law: (1) An action to stop the interference and for demolition (men’i müdahale ve kal): refusing to accept the fait accompli, the owner may demand that the interference end and the installations be removed. (2) A compensation action: accepting the situation, the owner may demand payment of the land’s value, whereupon ownership passes to the administration (registration or striking from the land registry). (3) Mesne profits (ecrimisil): in either case, compensation for the administration’s wrongful use may be claimed.

The threshold condition is that the claimant be the registered owner or their heir; claims based on adverse possession first require establishment of ownership. In partial takings (e.g. power transmission lines), compensation is assessed as the diminution in value of the whole parcel caused by the easement — see our article on expropriation and the owner’s rights.

The Compensation Action and Valuation

The land is valued as at the date the action is filed, applying by analogy the valuation criteria of the Expropriation Law: for land classified as building plot (arsa), comparison with arm’s-length comparable sales preceding the valuation date; for agricultural land (arazi), the net-income method. Classification (location within a settlement, access to municipal services, etc.) is determined through expert panels and site inspection.

As a rule, statutory interest runs from the date of action; alongside the award, the court orders the land (or the seized part) to be registered in the administration’s name or, for roads and similar non-registrable areas, struck from the registry. In partial takings, the loss of value of the remainder is added to the award.

Mesne Profits (Ecrimisil)

For the period of wrongful use, the owner may claim ecrimisil — compensation for wrongful occupation, at least equal to rental value. In practice it is calculated retrospectively for five years; the administration’s prescription defence is heard for any longer period. It may be sought together with the compensation action or separately.

Mandatory Settlement for 1956–1983 Takings (Provisional art. 6)

For takings between 9 October 1956 and 4 November 1983, the legislature created a special liquidation regime: the claimant must first apply to the administration and exhaust the settlement (uzlaşma) procedure, which is a procedural prerequisite; failing settlement, a valuation action may be brought within three months of the disagreement report.

Statutory Provision — Expropriation Law Provisional art. 6/1 and 6 (Settlement prerequisite; valuation action) (unofficial translation)

“Claims arising from the right of ownership by reason of the de facto seizure of immovables or resources, in whole or in part or through the creation of easements, without the owner’s consent, which were in fact allocated to public services or dedicated to a need in the public interest with installations built upon them between 9/10/1956 and 4/11/1983 although expropriation proceedings were not completed or no expropriation was ever carried out, and, where compensation is claimed, the assessment of compensation and other procedures, shall be conducted under this article. In proceedings under this article, prior recourse to the settlement procedure is a procedural prerequisite.

… If no settlement is reached between the administration and the owner, a valuation action may be brought by the owner or the administration within three months from the date the disagreement report is drawn up.”

The Court of Cassation holds that this prerequisite applies only to 1956–1983 takings; where the taking occurred after 4 November 1983, the merits are examined without any settlement requirement — which makes accurate determination of the taking date critical. In Provisional art. 6 cases, court fees and attorney fees are fixed (maktu); outside that period, the proportional fee regime must be assessed before filing.

Competent Court and Venue

For physical takings, the action is brought before the civil courts — the civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk mahkemesi) at the place where the land is situated, under the simplified procedure:

Statutory Provision — Expropriation Law art. 37 (Competent court and venue) (unofficial translation)

“Those disputes arising from this Law that fall to be resolved by the civil judiciary shall be heard by the civil courts of first instance at the place where the immovable is situated, under the simplified trial procedure.”

For regulatory takings (compensation arising from zoning restrictions), under the distinction adopted by the Constitutional Court and the Court of Cassation, the action is a full-remedy action before the administrative courts: possession remains with the owner and only the power of disposal is restricted by legislation. In mixed situations (part physically seized, part merely plan-restricted), each part is assessed separately. See our Administrative Law practice page.

Time Limits and Prescription

Article 38 of the Expropriation Law, which subjected these claims to a 20-year forfeiture period, was annulled by the Constitutional Court (the annulment was published on 4 November 2003) and never replaced. Under settled practice, therefore, ownership-based actions to stop the interference and compensation actions are subject to no prescription or forfeiture period; they may be brought as long as the taking continues. By contrast, ecrimisil is limited to the five preceding years; for 1956–1983 takings, the three-month valuation-action period after the disagreement report applies, and administrative-court time limits must be observed for regulatory takings. Time limits must always be verified for the specific case.

Fees and Costs

Under article 29 as amended by Law No. 7584 of 11 June 2026, site-inspection and expert fees, the land registry fees arising in the enforcement of final judgments ordering registration in de facto expropriation and compensation cases, and other costs required by the Law are borne by the administration:

Statutory Provision — Expropriation Law art. 29 (as amended by Law No. 7584 of 11.06.2026) (Costs borne by the administration) (unofficial translation)

“The travel allowances of the court panel under article 10, the fees of the court-appointed experts under article 15 and of the neighbourhood headman heard at the site inspection as assessed by the court, together with land registry fees, the land registry fees arising in the enforcement of final court judgments ordering registration in de facto expropriation and compensation cases or in the implementation of the settlement report drawn up between the owner and the administration by reason of de facto expropriation, and the other costs required by this Law, shall be paid by the administration.”

The special rule making fees and attorney fees fixed in Provisional art. 6 (1956–1983) cases is reserved; outside that period, the fee regime should be assessed against current case law before filing.

Court of Cassation Decisions

Definition, alternative remedies (the 1956 Unification of Case-Law Decision) and the registered-owner requirement

Court of Cassation Decision

“Where the administration, without establishing a transaction conforming to the Constitution and the laws, seizes a person’s immovable, builds an installation or building upon it, or dedicates it to a service and thereby interferes in any way with the owner’s right to use their immovable as they see fit, it is deemed to have seized the immovable without expropriation. The owner suing the administration is granted alternative remedies. The Unification of Case-Law Decision of 16.05.1956, No. 1/6, which resolves every issue in this field, ruled that a person whose immovable is seized without a duly issued expropriation decision and without payment may bring an action against the public legal entity to stop the interference, or may instead demand payment of its value. … Whichever action is brought, the first condition is to be the registered owner of the place or their heir.” (translation)

Regulatory taking (zoning restriction) — jurisdiction of the administrative courts

Court of Cassation Decision

“For a de facto expropriation to exist, possession of the immovable must pass to the administration and the immovable must in fact be dedicated to a public service; in zoning restrictions, possession remains with the owner and only the owner’s power of disposal is subjected to certain restrictions arising from the relevant legislation; accordingly, compensation actions arising from zoning restrictions may be brought before the administrative courts. … As the action must be heard by the administrative judiciary” (translation)

Valuation in physical takings: comparable sales for building plots, interest from the date of action, ecrimisil (recent affirmance)

Court of Cassation Decision

“[T]he immovable lies in a road area in the 1/1000-scale implementation zoning plan; the site inspection, observation and expert examination established that the defendant administration physically seized the immovable … the expert panel classified the immovable as a building plot and valued it by comparable-sales comparison as required by Expropriation Law No. 2942, in which method no error was found … no error was found in running statutory interest on the award from the date of action, in holding the defendant liable for costs and attorney fees, or in the calculation and amount of ecrimisil by the comparable-sales method.” (translation)

Scope of the settlement prerequisite: only takings between 1956 and 1983

Court of Cassation Decision

“By this regulation, the settlement procedure is a procedural prerequisite in actions filed after 11.06.2013, the entry into force of the Law, concerning immovables seized without expropriation between 09.10.1956 and 04.11.1983. Therefore, the date of the actual seizure must be conclusively established through investigation, and if it is found that the seizure occurred after 04.11.1983, the merits must be examined.” (translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

What is de facto expropriation?

The administration’s seizure of privately owned land without a lawful expropriation and without compensation — physically (roads, buildings, parks, power lines) or legally, by designating the land for public services in the zoning plan and leaving it unexpropriated for years.

What is the difference between physical and regulatory taking, and which court hears each?

In a physical taking the administration actually seizes the land; the action is brought before the civil court of first instance where the land is situated. In a regulatory taking the land is merely restricted by the zoning plan; the compensation action is brought before the administrative courts.

Which actions can I bring against the administration?

You have alternative remedies: an action to stop the interference and demolish the installations, or, accepting the situation, an action for payment of the land’s value. In both cases, mesne profits (ecrimisil) may be claimed for the period of wrongful use.

How is compensation calculated and when does interest start?

The land is valued as at the date of action — by comparable sales for building plots and by the net-income method for agricultural land. Statutory interest generally runs from the date of action, and the land is registered in the administration’s name or struck from the registry.

Is there a time limit for de facto expropriation actions?

After the annulment of article 38, ownership-based actions to stop the interference and for compensation are subject to no prescription or forfeiture period while the taking continues. Ecrimisil is limited to the preceding five years; the three-month period applies to 1956–1983 takings after the disagreement report, and administrative time limits apply to regulatory takings.

Must I attempt settlement with the administration before suing?

Only for takings between 09.10.1956 and 04.11.1983 is the settlement procedure a procedural prerequisite (Provisional art. 6). For takings after 04.11.1983, no settlement requirement applies and the action may be brought directly.

Actions to stop de facto expropriation, compensation and ecrimisil claims fall within our firm’s Real Estate and Construction Law and Administrative Law practice areas; for the expropriation process as a whole, see our article on Expropriation and the Owner’s Rights.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Real Estate Law

All Real Estate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “De Facto Expropriation Claims in Türkiye: Compensation, Injunction and Mesne Profits”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/de-facto-expropriation-claims

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›