Last reviewed:
Turkish Court of Cassation 5th Civil Chamber: Most Reviewed Case Types and Current Leading Decisions
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, the 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation is the specialised chamber for expropriation disputes. The bulk of its docket consists of actions for the determination of expropriation compensation and registration in the administration’s name under Article 10 of the Expropriation Law No. 2942, followed by compensation and mesne-profit claims arising from de facto expropriation, easement compensation disputes and urgent expropriation matters. Compensation is assessed by a panel of experts under the criteria of Article 11 of Law No. 2942: the income method based on net income for land and comparison with comparable sales for building plots, without taking into account any increase in value caused by the project requiring the expropriation. The registration ruling is final; appeals on fact and on points of law concern only the compensation.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
The 5th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation is the specialised chamber for expropriation disputes. Based on a scan of the official case-law database, this article explains the case types most frequently reviewed by the Chamber (determination of expropriation compensation and registration, de facto expropriation, easement compensation, mesne profits, urgent expropriation); how compensation is assessed under Articles 10, 11 and 25 of Law No. 2942; the effect of the 26.06.2025 division-of-labour decision; and the Chamber's current leading decisions, together with case-duration observations read from the decisions.
The jurisdiction of the 5th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation; the most frequently reviewed case types according to a scan of the official case-law database (determination of expropriation compensation and registration, de facto expropriation, easement compensation, mesne profits, urgent expropriation); how the Article 10 action works, the valuation criteria of Article 11, transfer of ownership under Article 25; the interest question after the Constitutional Court's annulment; current leading decisions and case-duration observations.
The Chamber's Jurisdiction
The 5th Civil Chamber has for decades been the specialised chamber for expropriation law. The backbone of its docket is the action for the determination of expropriation compensation and registration in the administration's name under Article 10 of the Expropriation Law No. 2942, followed by compensation and mesne-profit claims arising from de facto expropriation, disputes over easement compensation, and urgent expropriation matters (Art. 27).
Following the division-of-labour decision of the Grand General Assembly of the Court of Cassation dated 26.06.2025 and numbered 2025/1, the Chamber's scope has narrowed further around expropriation: in the recent decisions we reviewed, files concerning prevention of interference based on ownership, dissolution of co-ownership and refund of easement-deregistration fees are transferred to the 7th Civil Chamber. The type of the real-property dispute therefore directly determines which chamber will review the file.
Most Frequently Reviewed Case Types: A Database Scan
No official statistics are published on the composition of the Chamber's caseload. The table below shows the results of our full-text keyword scan of 5th Civil Chamber decisions in the official database; categories may overlap and the figures show only the number of decisions containing the phrase:
| Search phrase (case type) | Decisions | Share of scanned 5th Chamber decisions |
|---|---|---|
| “expropriation” (general) | 216,301 | ≈ 63% |
| “determination of expropriation compensation” + “registration” (Art. 10 action) | 117,066 | ≈ 34% |
| “easement” + “expropriation” | 27,773 | ≈ 8% |
| “de facto expropriation” | 19,237 | ≈ 5.6% |
| “mesne profits (ecrimisil)” | 14,095 | ≈ 4.1% |
| “urgent expropriation” | 3,746 | ≈ 1.1% |
The scanned pool comprises roughly 344,500 decisions of the Chamber. By far the largest item is the Article 10 compensation-and-registration action, followed by de facto expropriation, easement compensation and mesne profits. A sample review of the Chamber's April 2026 decisions likewise showed that nearly all merits decisions arise from Article 10 actions. This is a database scan, not official statistics, but it realistically reflects the Chamber's docket profile.
The Action for Determination of Compensation and Registration (Art. 10)
Where no agreement is reached through the purchase procedure, the administration sues before the civil court of the place where the property is situated:
“Where expropriation cannot be effected by the purchase procedure, the administration shall apply to the civil court of first instance of the place where the immovable is located, attaching the information and documents gathered under Article 7 and the valuation made under Article 8, and shall request that the expropriation compensation of the immovable be determined and that the property be registered in the administration's name against payment of that compensation in cash or, where expropriation was made under the second paragraph of Article 3, in instalments.”
The judge first invites the parties to agree on the amount; failing agreement, a survey is held, the expert panel formed under Article 15 values the property under the Article 11 criteria, and the judge determines a just and equitable compensation:
“Where the parties fail to agree on the amount, a new expert panel may be appointed by the judge to conclude within fifteen days, and the judge shall determine a just and equitable expropriation compensation drawing on the parties' and the experts' reports and statements. The compensation so determined by the court is the expropriation compensation of the immovable, the source or the easement. … The registration judgment is final; the parties' rights of appeal on the amount are reserved.”
Registration cannot be ordered before the administration deposits the compensation in the bank account designated by the court; the Chamber also approves ordering payment to the owner without awaiting finality (5th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/16861, K. 2026/5508). Failure to deposit the compensation within the time allowed results in dismissal.
Valuation Criteria (Art. 11)
The heart of the compensation action is Article 11. The property's character (agricultural land / building plot / structure) dictates the valuation method:
“f) For agricultural land, the net income the property or source would yield if used as it stands, according to its location and conditions. g) For building plots, the sale value according to comparable sales without special purpose preceding the date of expropriation. … In determining the value of the immovable, increases in value caused by the development or service undertaking necessitating the expropriation, and profit based on intended future uses, shall not be taken into account. In the creation of an easement by way of expropriation, the diminution in value that the immovable or the source will suffer by reason of the expropriation shall be stated with reasons. That diminution in value is the expropriation compensation.”
In practice this means the income method for agricultural land (crop pattern, yields, prices and costs capitalised into value, with an objective value increment where warranted), comparable-sales analysis for building plots, and official unit costs less depreciation for structures. The Chamber's current decisions require yield and price data to match the District Directorate of Agriculture figures for the valuation year, uniformity with files from the same region, and easement value-loss ratios set with regard to the property as a whole (5th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/15349, K. 2026/5521).
De Facto Expropriation and Mesne Profits
Where the administration physically seizes property without a lawful expropriation (for instance by building a road), the owner may claim the value of the property together with retrospective mesne profits (ecrimisil). The Chamber affirms valuation of building plots by comparable sales, statutory interest from the date of the action, and deregistration of the property as road (5th Civil Chamber, E. 2024/11195, K. 2025/9092). For the requirements of this action see our detailed analysis: De Facto Expropriation.
The Interest Question After the Constitutional Court's Annulment
Under Turkish law, the ninth paragraph of Article 10, which provided for statutory interest running four months after the filing of the action, was annulled by the Constitutional Court's decision of 05.04.2023, E. 2022/83, K. 2023/69 (Official Gazette 01.08.2023). Which interest applies in actions filed before the annulment and not yet final long remained disputed. For a time the majority of the 5th Civil Chamber, relying on Article 153/5 of the Constitution ("Annulment decisions shall not have retroactive effect.") and the principle that every case is decided according to the legal situation at the date it was filed, applied statutory interest starting four months after the filing date to the differential compensation in such actions; the dissent maintained that annulment decisions must apply to pending cases that have not become final (5th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/15349, K. 2026/5521, 01.04.2026, by majority).
In its decision of 08.04.2026 the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers resolved the question, on the interest point by majority, in the direction of the dissent: an annulment decision given through concrete norm review also applies to pending cases that have not become res judicata, and, in place of the annulled provision, the last paragraph of Article 46 of the Constitution applies, so that interest at the highest rate applied to public receivables runs on the differential compensation from the filing date until the date of judgment, without the need for a request by the defendant.
“In the light of these explanations, it is clear that annulment decisions of the Constitutional Court given through concrete review must be applied to pending files that have not become res judicata. … Accordingly, the regional court of appeal’s resistance decision, reasoning that, assessing the matter in line with the annulment decision of the Constitutional Court and applying, in place of the annulled statutory provision, the last paragraph of article 46 of the Constitution as the higher norm, the highest interest rate applied to public receivables must be applied for the period from the date of the action to the date of judgment without the need for a request by the defendant, is correct.”
According to the view put forward during the Assembly’s deliberations and not adopted by the majority, the Constitutional Court’s annulment applies, but since the defendant had not requested any interest other than statutory interest, the principle that the court is bound by the parties’ requests (Code of Civil Procedure art. 26/1) required statutory interest from the filing date until the date of judgment:
“… although the view was put forward that, since the defendant had no request that could be assessed under the “principle of being bound by the request” regulated in article 26/1 of Law No. 6100 concerning the application of an interest other than statutory interest, statutory interest should be applied to the differential expropriation price for the period from the date of the action to the date of judgment …, this view was not adopted by the Majority of the Assembly.”
The 5th Civil Chamber changed its line after this decision. In an action filed in 2021, it upheld, as corrected, a first-instance judgment that had applied statutory interest from four months after filing, so that the highest rate runs from the filing date until the date of judgment:
“Whereas the highest interest rate provided for public receivables should have been applied to the expropriation price from the date of the action to the date of judgment pursuant to the last paragraph of article 46 of the Constitution, ruling as written requires reversal.”
The Chamber made the same correction in September 2026: in an action filed on 13.12.2022, it removed the statutory interest that the regional court of appeal had run from four months after filing and awarded interest at the highest rate applied to public receivables from the filing date until the dates of judgment; in that file the owner’s appeal had asked for interest at the rate of the Producer Price Index (5th Civil Chamber, E. 2026/3049, K. 2026/12316, 07.09.2026). The line is new; for the owner, the careful framing of the interest claim and of appellate petitions remains important.
Transfer of Ownership and Finality of Registration (Art. 25)
“As regards the exercise of rights and the performance of obligations, the expropriation process begins, for the owner, with the notification made by the court under Article 10. Ownership passes to the administration upon the registration judgment rendered by the court. As of the date of the registration judgment, the owner's rights of use — such as erecting new buildings, planting, or making substantial alterations to existing structures — cease.”
Because the registration judgment is final, appellate review runs solely on the amount. The practical significance of the 5th Chamber's case law is that it directly determines the compensation, interest and costs the owner will receive. For the expropriation process as a whole, see: Expropriation and the Owner's Rights.
Court of Cassation Precedents
All decisions below were verified against their full texts in the official database; quotations are verbatim translations, omissions marked with …
Income method for agricultural land and uniformity
“It is correct that the disputed property, being agricultural land, was valued on the basis of the income method under item (f) of the first paragraph of Article 11 of Law No. 2942.”
The decision also reviewed the consistency of yield and price data with the District Directorate of Agriculture figures, uniformity with files from the same region, and the easement value-loss ratio. Its interest ruling (statutory interest from four months after filing; the dissent took the opposite view) predates the Assembly of Civil Chambers’ decision of 08.04.2026; for the current position see The Interest Question.
Comparable sales for building plots; payment without awaiting finality
“It is correct that the disputed property, being a building plot, was valued by comparable-sales analysis under item (g) of the first paragraph of Article 11 of Law No. 2942, and that the compensation so determined was ordered to be blocked and paid to the defendant without awaiting the finality of the judgment.”
The affirmed reasoning also included the denial of an attorney fee in favour of the expropriating administration on grounds of equity and the true-value principle; the case had earlier been dismissed for failure to deposit the compensation and went through two rounds of regional-court reversal.
De facto expropriation: comparable sales, mesne profits, statutory interest and deregistration
“It is correct that the disputed properties, being building plots, were valued by comparable-sales analysis and that their value was ordered to be recovered from the defendant administration in accordance with the report obtained.”
The affirmed judgment awarded the value of land physically seized for road construction with statutory interest from the date of the action, together with mesne profits, and ordered deregistration as road; the mesne-profits appeal was rejected as below the monetary threshold.
Current division of labour: transfer of out-of-scope files to the 7th Civil Chamber
“… the nature of the dispute and the scope of the appeal concern the refund of the easement-deregistration fee paid under protest for the deletion of the easement annotation … Since, under the decision of the Grand General Assembly of the Court of Cassation on the division of labour among chambers dated 26.06.2025 and numbered 1, the review of the file falls to the 7th Civil Chamber …”
In the same period the Chamber transferred claims for prevention of interference based on ownership and for dissolution of co-ownership to the 7th Civil Chamber on the same ground.
How Long Do These Cases Take?
The observations below are not official statistics; they are confined to dates read directly from the reviewed decisions:
| Decision | Course of proceedings as read from the text | Duration observed |
|---|---|---|
| E. 2025/15349, K. 2026/5521 | Filed 06.12.2021 → first instance K. 2023/473 → regional appeal (new judgment) 09.09.2025 → Court of Cassation 01.04.2026 | All three instances ≈ 4 years 4 months |
| E. 2025/16861, K. 2026/5508 | Filed 20.05.2022 → dismissal (deposit failure) → regional reversal → judgment → second regional reversal → judgment → affirmance 01.04.2026 | ≈ 3 years 10 months with two reversal rounds |
| E. 2024/11195, K. 2025/9092 | Regional appeal E. 2023/1980 → K. 2024/1182; cassation affirmance 18.06.2025 | Appeal + cassation stages ≈ 2 years |
The trend in this sample: compensation files can take about 4–4.5 years across three instances owing to surveys, expert panels, supplementary reports and appellate remedies, and each regional-court reversal adds another round. For the owner, this underlines the importance of getting comparables and yield data right at the survey stage.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which cases does the 5th Civil Chamber hear?
Determination of expropriation compensation and registration (Art. 10), de facto expropriation compensation and mesne profits, easement compensation and urgent expropriation; ownership-based interference and co-ownership dissolution files are now transferred to the 7th Civil Chamber.
How is expropriation compensation assessed?
By an expert panel under the Article 11 criteria: income method for agricultural land, comparable sales for building plots, official unit costs less depreciation for structures; value increases caused by the expropriating undertaking are excluded.
Can the registration judgment be appealed?
No — it is final; appeal and cassation lie only against the amount of compensation.
What interest applies to the compensation?
The Constitutional Court annulled the interest provision in the ninth paragraph of Article 10 (E. 2022/83, K. 2023/69; Official Gazette 01.08.2023). In its decision of 08.04.2026 the Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers held by majority that the annulment also applies to cases not yet final and that interest at the highest rate applied to public receivables runs on the differential compensation from the filing date until the date of judgment under the last paragraph of Article 46 of the Constitution, without the need for a request; the 5th Civil Chamber has since ruled in the same direction. The line is new: in September 2026 the Chamber upheld, without giving reasons, a regional court of appeal judgment applying statutory interest from four months after filing.
How long does an expropriation case take?
In the reviewed decisions, about 4–4.5 years across three instances; regional-court reversals extend the process.
The administration seized my land without expropriation — what can I do?
You may claim the value of the property and mesne profits; see our de facto expropriation analysis for details.
Our related practice areas: Real Estate Law and Administrative Law. Related articles: Expropriation and the Owner's Rights, De Facto Expropriation.
Related Articles
- Expropriation and the Owner's Rights
- De Facto Expropriation Claims in Türkiye: Compensation, Injunction and Mesne Profits
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- Expropriation Price Checked Against Final Same-Scheme Awards: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers on Price Consistency
- 1956–1983 Takings Valued at Suit Date by Character at Taking: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers on De Facto Expropriation
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are published Court of Cassation decisions and do not relate to files in which this firm acted; the case-type distribution and duration observations are a sample derived solely from that database scan and those decision texts, and are not official statistics.
Author: Title deed cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Real Estate Law
- Turnkey Home Purchases in Türkiye: Off-Plan Sale Contracts, Late Delivery, Withdrawal and Title
- Revoking a Gift of Real Estate in Türkiye: Conditional Gifts, Grounds and the One-Year Period (TCO 295–297)
- Promise to Sell Real Estate in Türkiye: Registration Action, Termination, Limitation and Informal Sales
- Property Inside the Shore Edge Line in Türkiye: Title Cancellation, Compensation and Legal Remedies
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Turkish Court of Cassation 5th Civil Chamber: Most Reviewed Case Types and Current Leading Decisions”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/court-of-cassation-5th-civil-chamber

























