Last reviewed:
Case NoteExpropriation Price Checked Against Final Same-Scheme Awards: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, the main principle for the expropriation price is the real value of the property. However, the price assigned must be reviewed, taking the property’s particular characteristics into account as well, for consistency with the prices awarded and finalised for the other properties in the same expropriation area, and there should be no excessive differences in value between properties in similar locations. For agricultural land the value is found by net income (art. 11(1)(f)); an objective value increase is applied by explaining the effect of each criterion. In this case the regional court of appeal had departed, without obtaining a supplementary report, from the expert calculation that matched the finalised prices, and had calculated the price itself; the Assembly reversed the decision of resistance unanimously and finally, and the file went back to the regional court of appeal.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation held that, although the main principle for the expropriation price is real value, the price must be reviewed for consistency with the prices awarded and finalised for the other properties in the same expropriation area, and there should be no excessive differences in value between properties in similar locations. The Assembly unanimously reversed the decision of resistance of the regional court of appeal, which had departed from the experts’ price without a supplementary report and calculated the price itself using a five-year average yield and a 25% objective value increase.
A decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Turkish Court of Cassation on reviewing an expropriation price for consistency with the prices awarded and finalised for similar properties in the same expropriation, and on the regional court of appeal departing from the experts’ price (Expropriation Law (Law No. 2942) art. 11).
The Dispute
The claimant administration sought determination of the expropriation price of a property qualifying as agricultural land and its registration in the name of an organised industrial zone (Law No. 2942, art. 10); the defendants argued that the price was too low. In the proceedings held after the regional court of appeal had set aside the first-instance court’s first decision, the first-instance court relied on the part of the supplementary expert report that found 87.16 TL/m² using 2019 Agricultural Cost System (TAMSİS) data and a 20% objective value increase.
This time the regional court of appeal made the calculation itself: using the five-year average yield of the rotation crops and a 25% objective value increase, it found 97.15 TL/m². The 5th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed, noting that in five files within the same expropriation that had passed its review, 87.16 TL/m² had been adopted using 2019 TAMSİS data, and holding that the decision had been given in a manner not open to review, without a supplementary report on the reasons for departing and by applying a 25% increase on abstract grounds. The regional court of appeal resisted (direnme), stating that forest land in the same village had been valued at 78.26 and 79.37 TL/m² for 2016 and 2017 in compensation actions, that valuing the agricultural land at 87.16 TL/m² would be inequitable, that there were unusual changes in yields, and that the 25% rate had been approved by the Chamber in files from the previous year.
Outcome of the Decision
By its decision of 11.03.2026, the Assembly of Civil Chambers allowed the claimant administration’s grounds of appeal and reversed the decision of resistance under art. 371 of the Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) for the reasons stated in the Special Chamber’s reversal decision; in view of the ground for reversal, it did not examine the defendants’ grounds of appeal. The file was sent to the regional court of appeal under art. 373(2) of the HMK. The decision was given unanimously and is final.
Reasoning
The Assembly stated that the value of agricultural land is found by net income under art. 11(1)(f), and that yields, costs and wholesale prices should be determined on the basis of official data applying equally in the same locality and based on statistical information, with the effect of each value-increasing criterion, such as ease of transport, also explained (art. 11(1)(ı)). For some properties outside the case within the same expropriation, 87.16 TL/m² had likewise been determined and those decisions had become final upon being upheld by the Special Chamber. The Assembly set out the standard as follows:
“Having regard to the letter and spirit of the Expropriation Law, although the main principle is to determine the real value of the property, there is no doubt that, in addition, in files relating to the same expropriation in the same region, judicial review should also be carried out with a view to uniformity of practice alongside the statutory elements explained above, and that it should be reviewed whether the value assigned to the property in the expert reports, the price assessed for the property, taking its particular characteristics into account as well, is consistent with the prices awarded and finalised for the other properties in the expropriation area. Accordingly, within the same expropriation, there should be uniformity between the prices determined for properties in similar locations, and there should be no excessive differences in value.” (translation)
And applied it to the case:
“That being so, in the light of the explanations above, whereas the Regional Court of Appeal should have obtained a supplementary report on the reasons for departing from the expropriation price determined by the expert panel on the basis of TAMSİS data, evaluated, for uniformity of practice, the files within the same expropriation that had passed the Special Chamber’s review, and determined the expropriation price of the property on condition of explaining the effect of each criterion as regards the objective value increase rate, giving a decision, as written, by making its own calculation in a manner not open to review was not found correct.” (translation)
Significance and Practical Effect
While keeping the real-value principle, the decision adds a review for uniformity of practice: the prices finalised for properties in similar locations within the same expropriation become, taking particular characteristics into account, the yardstick against which the price in a new file is reviewed. On the objective value increase, the Assembly prescribed no particular rate; rejecting the reasoning of resistance based on the 25% rate in previous-year files, it required the effect of each criterion to be explained; it did not separately discuss the forest-land comparison.
Two later decisions of the Assembly show the limits of the standard. In the decision of 08.04.2026 (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/750, K. 2026/229, 08.04.2026) the regional court of appeal had a supplementary report prepared using the yield, price and cost figures applied in files within the same expropriation; stating that the data tables contradicted each other and that it was not clearly shown which data had been relied on, the Assembly found the report insufficient and required a new supplementary report based on the official data for the valuation year. In the decision of 29.04.2026 on de facto expropriation of building plots (Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/806, K. 2026/276, 29.04.2026), the Assembly reversed the decision of resistance, noting among other things that the prices for nearby parcels which the regional court of appeal had treated as consistent had become final at the appeal stage without review by the Special Chamber, and that the prices reviewed by the Chamber, indexed to the date of the action, led to lower values. In our assessment, finalised prices do not replace official data and the comparable-sales analysis; the reasons both for departing from them and for following them should be shown in an expert report open to review.
A search, through search results and summaries, of Court of Cassation decisions published in the official case-law database from the date of the decision to the date of this article found no decision departing from this standard of the Assembly; the decisions of 08.04.2026 and 29.04.2026 were read in full. In the database, decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers appear up to 01.10.2026 and those of the 5th Civil Chamber up to 10.09.2026.
Relevant Legislation
“The expert panel to be formed under article 15 shall go, together with the court, to the place where the immovable property or source to be expropriated is located and, after hearing the interested persons present, shall, taking as the basis the immovable property’s or source’s;
… f) For land, the net income that the immovable property or source would yield, according to its … location and conditions, if used as it stands.
… ı) … other objective criteria that will be effective in determining the price, on condition that the effect of each criterion is explained, …”
The “(…)” mark showing an annulled phrase in item f), the amendment and annulment marks in item ı) and the footnote references in the official text have been replaced by ….
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the final price awarded for neighbouring properties in the same expropriation taken into account in my case?
Yes, as a yardstick for review. According to the Assembly, the main principle is real value; however, the price must be reviewed, taking particular characteristics into account as well, for consistency with the prices finalised in the same expropriation area, and there should be no excessive differences in value between properties in similar locations. The Assembly required the files that had passed the Special Chamber’s review to be evaluated.
At what rate is an objective value increase applied?
The decision sets no fixed rate. Features such as ease of transport and proximity to residential areas may increase the price, but the effect of each criterion must be explained. In this case the 25% rate applied on abstract grounds was not considered sufficient.
May the regional court of appeal depart from the experts’ price and calculate the price itself?
In this case the Assembly did not find it correct to give a decision by making its own calculation, in a manner not open to review, without obtaining a supplementary report on the reasons for departing from the expert panel’s price based on TAMSİS data.
Is the decision final, and what happened to the case?
The decision was given unanimously and is final. The decision of resistance was reversed; the file was sent to the regional court of appeal that gave the decision.
- Expropriation and the Owner's Rights
- Cases Heard by the Court of Cassation 5th Civil Chamber: Most Reviewed Case Types and Current Leading Decisions under Turkish Law
- Urgent Expropriation Annulment Does Not End Price Suit: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, While the Expropriation Stands
Related Articles
- Expropriation and the Owner's Rights
- Which Cases Does the 5th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation Hear? The Most Frequently Reviewed Case Types and Current Leading Decisions
- Urgent Expropriation Annulment Does Not End Price Suit: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, While the Expropriation Stands
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Title deed cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Real Estate Law
- Turnkey Home Purchases in Türkiye: Off-Plan Sale Contracts, Late Delivery, Withdrawal and Title
- Revoking a Gift of Real Estate in Türkiye: Conditional Gifts, Grounds and the One-Year Period (TCO 295–297)
- Promise to Sell Real Estate in Türkiye: Registration Action, Termination, Limitation and Informal Sales
- Property Inside the Shore Edge Line in Türkiye: Title Cancellation, Compensation and Legal Remedies
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Expropriation Price Checked Against Final Same-Scheme Awards: Turkish Court of Cassation Civil Assembly”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/expropriation-price-consistency-similar-plots-turkiye

























