Last reviewed:
Challenging Competition Board Decisions in Türkiye: Administrative Fines, Competent Court and Time Limits
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, an action against an administrative sanction decision of the Competition Board is brought before the competent administrative court (Law No. 4054 art. 55/1). The Law does not name the court; since the seat of the Authority is in Ankara (art. 20), the general rule in art. 32 of the Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) points, on this article’s reading, to the Ankara administrative courts. The time limit is sixty days (Law No. 2577 art. 7) and starts from notification of the reasoned decision (art. 54). Bringing the action does not suspend the pursuit and collection of the fine (art. 55/2); a stay of execution must be requested separately. Except for judgments that are final because the amount in dispute is below the statutory threshold, the judgment may be appealed and then, as a rule, appealed on points of law to the Council of State. In a file closed by settlement, the fine and the matters in the settlement text cannot be challenged in court (art. 43).
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, an action against an administrative sanction decision of the Competition Board is brought before the competent administrative court; the time limit is sixty days from notification of the reasoned decision, and filing the action does not suspend collection of the fine. The article covers the investigation procedure under Law No. 4054, rights of defence, on-site inspections, fine rates, settlement, stay of execution and appeals, with Constitutional Court and Council of State decisions.
For an undertaking in Türkiye facing an administrative fine or another administrative sanction decision of the Competition Board under Turkish law: the investigation procedure and rights of defence, on-site inspections, fine rates, settlement, the competent court, the time limit, stay of execution, and appeals.
What Is a Competition Board Decision? The Framework of Law No. 4054
Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition is applied by the Competition Authority; the seat of the Authority is in Ankara (art. 20). The Competition Board decides whether to open an investigation, whether there is an infringement, and on the fine. The prohibitions referred to in article 16 of the Law are found in three articles, namely articles 4, 6 and 7 (art. 16/3). Article 4 prohibits agreements, concerted practices and decisions of associations of undertakings which have as their object or effect, or are likely to have the effect of, preventing, distorting or restricting competition; price fixing, the partitioning of markets and control of the quantity of supply are listed as examples. Unfair competition under the Turkish Commercial Code is a separate subject; see Unfair Competition Actions.
Investigation Procedure and Rights of Defence
The Board may, of its own motion or upon application, open an investigation directly or first order a preliminary inquiry; the rapporteur reports within thirty days, and the Board decides within ten days of delivery of the report (arts. 40 and 41). The investigation is completed within six months at the latest; an additional period of up to six months may be granted once (art. 43/1). The Board notifies the parties of the investigation decision within fifteen days and sends them sufficient information on the type and nature of the allegations (art. 43/2, as amended by Law No. 7511 in 2024).
The investigation report is notified to the parties. The written defence is submitted within thirty days of notification; on justified grounds the period may be extended once, by no more than the same length. A defence not submitted in time is disregarded (art. 45; second paragraph as amended by Law No. 7511). An oral hearing is held if the parties request it or the Board so decides of its own motion (art. 46). The final decision is given on the same day after the hearing or within fifteen days together with its reasons; where no hearing is held, within thirty days after the end of the investigation stage (art. 48).
Until they request an oral hearing, the parties may ask for a copy of all documents drawn up about them within the Authority and, if possible, of all evidence obtained (art. 44/2).
“The Board may not base its decisions on matters about which it has not informed the parties and given them the right of defence.”
As summarised in the Constitutional Court’s individual application decision cited below, the 13th Chamber of the Council of State in that case regarded the periods in articles 40, 41 and 43 as regulatory in nature and treated non-compliance with them as a procedural defect that did not affect the merits; that assessment relates to that case.
On-Site Inspections and the Sanction for Obstruction
The Board may carry out on-site inspections at undertakings where it deems necessary. Authority staff may examine the books and all data and documents kept in physical and electronic media and in information systems, take copies, and ask for explanations (art. 15/1; sub-paragraph (a) as amended by Law No. 7246 in 2020). The staff carry an authorisation document showing the subject matter and purpose of the inspection (art. 15/2).
“Those concerned are obliged to provide copies of the information, documents, books and other instruments requested. Where an on-site inspection is obstructed or is likely to be obstructed, the on-site inspection is carried out by decision of a criminal judge of peace.”
Obstructing or hindering an inspection is subject to two separate sanctions: an administrative fine of five per thousand of annual gross revenue (art. 16/1-d) and a fine of five per ten thousand for each day from the day after the act occurred (art. 17). The fact that the inspection is carried out by court decision does not prevent these fines (art. 16/2).
Administrative Fines, Settlement, Commitments and Active Cooperation
For procedural infringements the rate is fixed: in cases such as giving false or misleading information in applications, carrying out a merger or acquisition subject to authorisation without it, and failing to provide requested information or documents, the fine is one per thousand of annual gross revenue; for obstruction of an on-site inspection it is five per thousand (art. 16/1). According to the text of the Law, this fine cannot be less than ten thousand Turkish liras; that is the amount in the statutory text. The lower limit is increased by communiqué; the current amount could not be verified for this article.
“Those who engage in conduct prohibited in articles 4, 6 and 7 of this Law shall be given an administrative fine of up to ten per cent of the annual gross revenue of the undertaking, association of undertakings or members of such associations to be fined, as generated at the end of the financial year preceding the final decision or, if that cannot be calculated, at the end of the financial year closest to the date of the final decision, and as determined by the Board.”
Managers and employees found to have had a decisive influence in the infringement are fined up to five per cent of the fine imposed on the undertaking (art. 16/4). The Board takes into account the repetition and duration of the infringement, market power, compliance with commitments, assistance with the examination and the gravity of the harm (art. 16/5). The calculation method is determined by a regulation issued by the Board (art. 16/7); these details are provisions of the regulation, not of the Law.
Active cooperation. Those who actively cooperate with the Authority to reveal an infringement of the Law may be spared the fine or granted a reduction; the conditions of this route are set by regulation (art. 16/6-7).
Commitments. During a preliminary inquiry or investigation, commitments may be offered to eliminate competition concerns under article 4 or 6; the Board may make the commitments binding and decide not to open an investigation or to close it. Commitments are not accepted for clear and serious infringements such as price fixing between competitors, sharing of territories or customers, or restriction of supply (art. 43/3).
Settlement. After an investigation has begun, the Board may settle, until the investigation report is notified, with an undertaking that accepts the existence and scope of the infringement (art. 43/5; added by Law No. 7246 in 2020).
“As a result of the settlement procedure, a reduction of up to twenty-five per cent may be applied to the administrative fine.
… Where the process ends in settlement, the administrative fine and the matters set out in the settlement text cannot be made the subject of an action by the parties to the settlement.”
The settlement reduction does not prevent the payment reduction under art. 17/6 of the Misdemeanours Law (Law No. 5326) (art. 43/7). The other procedures and principles of settlement are set by regulation (art. 43/9); the provisions of that regulation have not been examined separately in this article.
Competent Court and Time Limit for Bringing an Action
“An action may be brought before the competent administrative court against administrative sanction decisions. Every action brought against Board decisions is deemed a priority matter.
Applying to the courts against Board decisions does not suspend the implementation of the decisions or the pursuit and collection of administrative fines.”
The first paragraph took this form in 2012 through Law No. 6352. In the case underlying the Constitutional Court’s individual application decision below, registered with the 13th Chamber of the Council of State in 2011, the action was heard at first instance by the Council of State and the appeal on points of law was examined by its Plenary Session of Administrative Law Chambers. Under the current art. 55/1, the action is brought before the competent administrative court.
The article names no province. Under art. 32/1 of Law No. 2577, where the special law does not indicate the competent court, the competent court is the administrative court of the place where the administrative authority that made the act in dispute is located. Since the seat of the Authority is in Ankara (art. 20), the competent courts are the Ankara administrative courts; this is the conclusion this article draws from the two provisions. One of the courts that referred the question decided by the Constitutional Court in 2025 was the Ankara 11th Administrative Court.
Where the special law indicates no separate period, the time limit for bringing an action before the administrative courts is sixty days and starts on the day after the date of written notification (Law No. 2577 art. 7/1-2). Article 55 of Law No. 4054 sets no separate period; the general period therefore applies.
“In Competition Board decisions, time limits start from the date on which the reasoned decision is notified to the parties.”
Actions are not confined to fines: in a decision cited below, the Council of State examined on the merits an action against a Board decision partly refusing a request for access to the file. Board decisions are not among the acts listed in art. 20/A of Law No. 2577; the thirty-day time limit and the appeal structure of the expedited procedure, which excludes the regional administrative court stage, do not apply to these actions.
Stay of Execution and Collection of the Fine
Bringing an action does not of itself suspend execution of the act (Law No. 2577 art. 27/1); Law No. 4054 says so separately for the pursuit and collection of administrative fines (art. 55/2). Where the conditions of irreparable or hardly reparable harm arising from implementation of the act and manifest unlawfulness of the act are met together, the court may order a stay of execution, stating its reasons, after receiving the administration’s defence or after the period for defence has expired (Law No. 2577 art. 27/2). The order is made against security; depending on the circumstances, security may be dispensed with (art. 27/6).
As regards payment, the Misdemeanours Law applies: if the administrative fine is paid within the payment period, a reduction of twenty-five per cent is applied and payment does not affect the right to seek judicial review; where the relevant law does not regulate a payment period, the period is one month from notification (Law No. 5326 art. 17/6). The same article provides that final decisions on administrative fines that must be recorded as revenue of the general budget are sent to the collection offices for collection under Law No. 6183 (art. 17/4). The stage at which a Board fine is reported to the collection office has not been verified for this article.
Appeal and Appeal on Points of Law
An appeal against the administrative court’s judgment may be lodged, within thirty days of its notification, with the regional administrative court in whose judicial district the court is located; however, in annulment actions whose subject matter does not exceed thirty-one thousand Turkish liras, the administrative court’s judgment is final (Law No. 2577 art. 45/1; second sentence as amended by Law No. 7524 in 2024). That is the amount in the statutory text; it is updated every year. The regional administrative court’s judgment may be appealed on points of law to the Council of State within thirty days of notification if it falls under the following sub-paragraph (art. 46/1).
“Actions brought against decisions taken by regulatory and supervisory boards concerning the market or sector for which they are responsible.”
This sub-paragraph appears to be the basis for appeals on points of law in actions against Competition Board decisions; this is the assessment of this article. In actions against administrative acts whose subject matter exceeds nine hundred and twenty thousand Turkish liras, the regional administrative court’s judgment is also open to appeal on points of law under sub-paragraph (b) (Law No. 2577 art. 46/1-b; the amount in the statutory text, updated every year). All the Council of State 13th Chamber decisions cited below were given on appeals on points of law against regional administrative court judgments. For the appellate court of the courts in Ankara, see Appeals in İstanbul and Ankara under Turkish Law: Jurisdiction of the Regional Courts of Appeal and Regional Administrative Courts.
Competition Board Fines in the Case-Law
On-site inspections and inviolability of domicile
The Plenary of the Constitutional Court held that the right to inviolability of domicile had been violated by an on-site inspection carried out in 2009 without a judge’s decision, in which e-mails were taken from the computers of company staff.
“the special safeguard laid down in the second sentence of the first paragraph of Article 21 of the Constitution covers every situation in which public officials wish to enter persons’ domiciles without their consent, and a provision that confines the judge’s decision to the existence of obstruction or of a likelihood of obstruction is contrary to that safeguard.”
The Court stated that the violation stemmed from the fact that the on-site inspection power in the Law was not regulated in line with the safeguards in Article 21 of the Constitution, and notified the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye. In the same decision it found no violation of the right to property as regards the fine and did not order a retrial. As the applicant had made no complaint to that effect, the use at trial of the evidence obtained in the inspection was not separately examined. After this decision, the 13th Chamber of the Council of State and the Ankara 11th Administrative Court referred two rules of article 15 to the Constitutional Court for annulment.
“it is understood that the rule granting the Board the power to carry out on-site inspections where it deems necessary falls within the said margin of discretion, which is a consequence of the positive obligation imposed on the State by Article 167 of the Constitution. … The rule was not found to be related to Articles 13 and 21 of the Constitution.”
The Court rejected the challenge to the phrase “where it deems necessary”; as regards the sentence on the decision of the criminal judge of peace, it rejected the application for lack of competence of the referring courts, on the ground that the rule could not be applied in the cases before them. Five members dissented; the decision was published in the Official Gazette of 17.02.2026. Today article 15 is in force; the finding of a violation in the individual application and the rejection in the constitutionality review stand side by side.
Proof in obstruction fines
“an act must be established by setting out, with concrete information and documents, the conduct requiring an administrative sanction; a penalty cannot, by contrast, be imposed on the basis of suspicion, without the conduct requiring the sanction being established in all its elements”
From a statement in the inspection record that a computer had been controlled remotely, the Competition Board had concluded that documents were concealed. The Chamber annulled the fine on the ground that the act had not been proved with concrete information and documents; the Plenary Session upheld that judgment, which had been given in compliance with its own earlier reversal.
“Following this review, only those parts containing data belonging to the undertaking may be examined on a device that is personal property and has been found to contain data belonging to the undertaking.”
In this case, WhatsApp group messages on an officer’s personal telephone had been deleted after the inspection began. The Chamber found the annulment of the fine correct in its result, because it had not been concretely shown that the device and the group contained data belonging to the undertaking; it also described the obstruction fine as a procedural sanction attached to an abstract danger. There are cases that went the other way: in Council of State, 13th Chamber, E. 2022/81, K. 2025/1708, 24.04.2025, postponing the inspection to the next day on the ground that the officers were out of town was treated as obstruction; the regional administrative court’s judgment, which reasoned that a one-day delay was enough for evidence to be removed, was upheld with a correction as to counsel’s fees.
Rights of defence and access to the file
“it is clear that refusing a request for access to the file on the ground that the content of a document which is internal correspondence of the Authority but contains exculpatory or inculpatory material had already been obtained by the person requesting access is incompatible with the second paragraph of Article 44 of Law No. 4054 and the provisions of Communiqué No. 2010/3.”
Access to two information notes on the settlement process of another undertaking in the investigation had been refused on the ground that their content had already been communicated to the claimant. The Chamber stated that the legislation contains no such ground for refusal, reversed the regional administrative court’s judgment and remitted the file for a fresh decision. Communiqué No. 2010/3 is referred to in this article only as reported in the decision.
Standard of proof for substantive infringements and more favourable rules
“in general, taking the type of infringement and the particular features of the case together, the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt is applied, and “proof of what happened to a near certainty” is not required.”
The administrative court had annulled a fine imposed for abuse of dominant position through excessive pricing, on the premise that each item of evidence had to be beyond doubt and conclusive. The Chamber did not accept that reasoning and stated that the evidence is to be assessed as a whole; but, finding the inquiry insufficient as regards barriers to entry, profit margin, comparison and consumer welfare, it upheld the annulment in its result. The Plenary Session decision above, by contrast, concerns a procedural fine.
In Council of State, 13th Chamber, E. 2025/454, K. 2025/3550, 18.11.2025, the Chamber accepted that the new fines regulation published in the Official Gazette of 27.12.2024 contains provisions that may be more favourable than the previous one and that the Board must compare the two regulations and set the fine rate again, and it reversed the judgment dismissing the action (by majority as to reasoning). The provisions of the regulation are referred to only as reported in the decision.
Private-Law Damages
Part Five of the Law governs the private-law consequences of restrictions of competition. Anyone who prevents, distorts or restricts competition by conduct contrary to the Law, or abuses a dominant position, must compensate all harm suffered by those injured; where more than one person caused the harm, they are jointly and severally liable (art. 57). Those injured may claim the difference between the price they paid and the price they would have paid had competition not been restricted (art. 58/1).
“Where the harm arises from an agreement or decision of the parties or from cases of their gross negligence, the judge may, upon the request of those injured, award damages amounting to three times the material harm suffered or the profits that those who caused the harm obtained or are likely to obtain.”
The provision says “may award”; treble damages depend on the injured party’s request and the judge’s discretion.
Points to Note in Practice
- The sixty-day time limit is calculated from notification of the reasoned decision.
- Bringing an action does not suspend collection. In a request for a stay of execution, hardly reparable harm and manifest unlawfulness are shown together and with concrete data.
- The reduction for payment within the payment period does not affect the right to sue; settlement, by contrast, closes the judicial route as regards the fine and the settlement text.
- If the thirty-day period for the defence against the investigation report is missed, the defence is disregarded; an extension may be requested once.
- The lower limit of ten thousand Turkish liras is the amount in the statutory text; the current amount should be checked in the communiqué in force.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which court hears an action against a Competition Board decision in Türkiye?
Under Turkish law, an action against an administrative sanction decision of the Competition Board is brought before the competent administrative court (Law No. 4054 art. 55/1). The Law does not name the court. Under art. 32 of the Administrative Procedure Law, the competent court is the administrative court of the place where the authority that took the act is located; since the seat of the Competition Authority is in Ankara (art. 20), this rule points to the Ankara administrative courts. This conclusion rests on reading the two provisions together.
What is the time limit for bringing an action against a Competition Board decision under Turkish law?
Since art. 55 of Law No. 4054, which governs judicial review, sets no separate period, the general sixty-day time limit for administrative courts applies (Administrative Procedure Law art. 7). In Competition Board decisions, time limits start from the date on which the reasoned decision is notified to the parties (Law No. 4054 art. 54); the period runs from the day after notification. The thirty-day period of the expedited procedure does not apply to these actions, because Board decisions are not on the list in art. 20/A of the Administrative Procedure Law.
Does bringing an action against a Competition Board fine suspend collection of the fine in Türkiye?
No. Under Turkish law, applying to the courts against Board decisions does not suspend the implementation of the decisions or the pursuit and collection of administrative fines (Law No. 4054 art. 55/2). To suspend collection, a stay of execution must be requested from the court; the court may grant it where irreparable or hardly reparable harm and manifest unlawfulness exist together, and as a rule requires security (Administrative Procedure Law art. 27).
Can an undertaking that settles with the Competition Board still challenge the fine in court under Turkish law?
As a rule, no. Under Turkish law, a reduction of up to twenty-five per cent may be applied to the administrative fine as a result of the settlement procedure; if the process ends in settlement, the administrative fine and the matters set out in the settlement text cannot be challenged in court by the settling parties (Law No. 4054 art. 43). Settlement is possible, until the investigation report is notified, with an undertaking that accepts the existence and scope of the infringement. The other procedures and principles of settlement are set by a regulation issued by the Board.
Does the Competition Board need a judge’s decision for an on-site inspection in Türkiye?
Under art. 15 of Law No. 4054, the Board may carry out on-site inspections where it deems necessary; a decision of a criminal judge of peace is required only where the inspection is obstructed or likely to be obstructed. In 2023 the Constitutional Court held, in an individual application, that an on-site inspection carried out without a judge’s decision violated the right to inviolability of domicile. In 2025, however, the Court rejected by majority the request to annul the phrase “where it deems necessary” in the same article. The article is in force.
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- Appeals in İstanbul and Ankara under Turkish Law: Jurisdiction of the Regional Courts of Appeal and Regional Administrative Courts
- Unfair Competition Actions: Acts of Unfair Competition, Claims, Competent Court and Limitation (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 54-62)
Related Articles
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- Appeals in İstanbul and Ankara under Turkish Law: Jurisdiction of the Regional Courts of Appeal and Regional Administrative Courts
- Unfair Competition Actions: Acts of Unfair Competition, Claims, Competent Court and Limitation (Turkish Commercial Code arts. 54-62)
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Competition law attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Competition Law
- Resale Price, Exclusivity and Non-Compete in Dealership Agreements in Türkiye: Five-Year Limit (Law No. 4054)
- When a Former Employee Sets Up a Competing Business: Poaching, Trade Secrets, Unfair Competition in Türkiye
- Unfair Competition by Confusion in Türkiye: Trade Names, Packaging and Domain Names (TCC Arts. 55/1-a-4, 52)
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Challenging Competition Board Decisions in Türkiye: Administrative Fines, Competent Court and Time Limits”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/competition-board-fines-judicial-review-turkiye

























