Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 21 min read

Last reviewed:

Competition Damages in Türkiye: Treble Damages, Proof, Board Decisions, Limitation (Law No. 4054 Arts. 56-59)

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Anyone who prevents, distorts or restricts competition through an act, decision, contract or agreement contrary to Law No. 4054, or abuses a dominant position, must compensate all damage suffered by those harmed; where several persons caused the damage, they are jointly and severally liable (art. 57). If the damage results from an agreement or decision of the parties or from their gross negligence, the judge may, at the request of the injured party, award compensation of three times the loss suffered or of the profits gained or likely to be gained (art. 58(2)); this is a discretionary power. In one decision the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that finality of the Competition Board decision is not a precondition for the action and required its outcome to be treated as a preliminary question; where the regional court of appeal stated that the underlying Board decision had been found unlawful by the administrative courts, appellate judgments dismissing the action were upheld. For an infringement entailing a proportional administrative fine, the Chamber applied the eight-year limitation period in the Misdemeanours Law.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, buyers and competitors harmed by an anti-competitive agreement or an abuse of dominance may claim damages under arts. 56–59 of Law No. 4054: invalidity, calculation of loss, treble damages, the presumption in art. 59, the Competition Board decision as a preliminary question, the eight-year limitation period applied by the Court of Cassation and the competent court, with Court of Cassation decisions and an example Competition Board decision.

Under Turkish law, the damages action that a buyer or a competitor harmed by an anti-competitive agreement, a concerted practice or an abuse of dominance may bring under arts. 56–59 of Law No. 4054: invalidity, calculation of loss, treble damages, the presumption of proof, the effect of the Competition Board decision, limitation and the competent court.

What Is a Competition Law Damages Action?

Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition prohibits agreements and concerted practices restricting competition (art. 4) and the abuse of a dominant position (art. 6). The Competition Board responds to infringements with administrative fines. Arts. 56–59 of the Law govern the private law consequences of an infringement; the damages action is based on these provisions.

This action differs from the unfair competition action under arts. 54 et seq. of the Turkish Commercial Code, which targets individual acts contrary to good faith. The Court of Cassation treats this action as tort liability.

Invalidity of Anti-Competitive Agreements (art. 56)

Agreements and decisions of associations of undertakings contrary to art. 4 are invalid. Performance arising from the agreement cannot be demanded; restitution of performance already rendered is subject to the Code of Obligations provisions named in the article. The provision is tied to infringements of art. 4; it contains no separate invalidity rule for abuse of dominance.

Statutory Provision — Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition art. 56 (Legal Nature of Agreements and Decisions Contrary to this Law)

Any agreement and decision of an association of undertakings contrary to article 4 of this Law is invalid. Performance of obligations arising from these agreements and decisions cannot be demanded. Where obligations already performed are claimed back on the ground of invalidity, the parties’ restitution obligation is subject to articles 63 and 64 of the Code of Obligations.

Article 65 of the Code of Obligations shall not apply to disputes arising from this Law.

Conditions of Liability and Claimants (arts. 57–58)

Art. 57 is the basic rule of liability: anyone who prevents, distorts or restricts competition through an act, decision, contract or agreement contrary to the Law, or abuses a dominant position, must compensate “all damage” suffered by those harmed. If the damage results from the conduct of several persons, liability is joint and several; an action for the whole loss may be brought against any member of a cartel (as a consequence of joint and several liability).

Statutory Provision — Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition art. 57 (Right to Compensation)

Anyone who prevents, distorts or restricts competition by an act, decision, contract or agreement contrary to this Law, or abuses its dominant position in a particular market for goods or services, is obliged to compensate all damage suffered by those harmed. Where the damage results from the conduct of more than one person, they are jointly and severally liable for the damage.

Art. 58 distinguishes two types of claimant. Buyers (for example those who bought goods or credit at a cartel price) may claim the difference between the price they paid and the price they would have paid had competition not been restricted. Competing undertakings affected by the restriction claim their entire loss, calculated by taking into account all profits they expected to earn and the balance sheets of previous years. In the competitor cases reviewed, court experts calculated a hypothetical loss by comparing market shares before and during the infringement and examining commercial books.

Statutory Provision — Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition art. 58 (Compensation for Damage)

Those harmed as a result of the prevention, distortion or restriction of competition may claim as damages the difference between the price they paid and the price they would have paid had competition not been restricted. Competing undertakings affected by the restriction of competition may claim compensation for their entire loss from the undertaking or undertakings restricting competition. In determining the damage, it is calculated by taking into account all profits that the injured undertakings expected to obtain, including the balance sheets of previous years.

Where the resulting damage arises from an agreement or decision of the parties or from cases involving their gross negligence, the judge may, at the request of those harmed, award compensation of three times the material loss suffered or of the profits gained or likely to be gained by those who caused the damage.

The claimant need not have complained to the Competition Authority. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed an appellate judgment that had dismissed the claim of a competitor not listed as a complainant in the Board decision on the ground that “the precondition” for claiming damages “is an Authority decision” and that no such finding existed for that company:

Court of Cassation Decision

“in providing that all damage of those harmed must be compensated where competition is restricted by agreements, concerted practices and decisions … the legislator did not specify, as a precondition, that an application must have been made to the Competition Authority for the determination of the unlawful acts restricting competition. Therefore, since the Competition Board decision finding the abuse of dominant position has become final, it must be accepted that everyone harmed has the right to claim compensation for their damage.”

The reasoning rests on the Board decision being final. The judgment rendered after the reversal was upheld by the same Chamber’s decision E. 2024/752, K. 2025/1498.

Treble Damages (art. 58(2))

Under the statutory text there are three conditions: (1) the damage must arise from an agreement or decision of the parties or from their gross negligence; (2) the injured party must request it; (3) the judge “may” award it, so the decision is discretionary. The basis of calculation has two alternatives: the material loss suffered, or the profits gained or likely to be gained by those who caused the damage. In the cases reviewed, claimants asked for the higher of the two; in one case the first instance court took the claimant’s loss as the basis, stating that, because the infringement targeted all competitors in the market, it could not be determined how much of the defendant’s profit resulted from the conduct towards the claimant.

Among the decisions reviewed there is no principle decision containing the Court of Cassation’s own reasoning on how the discretion is to be exercised. In the 2023 case the regional court of appeal accepted that the judge may award single or treble damages and listed the repetition and duration of the infringement, the defendant’s market power and its decisive role in the infringement; the Court of Cassation rejected the objection because “the reasons for the treble award were stated in the judgment”. In this article’s assessment, a treble award should clearly show that the damage arose from an agreement or decision of the parties or from their gross negligence, and why the multiple was chosen.

Proof of Infringement and Loss (art. 59)

Because competition infringements are often secret, art. 59 gives the injured party two forms of relief. First, a presumption for concerted practices: if the injured party submits evidence giving the impression that an agreement exists or that competition in the market is distorted, the burden of proving that the undertakings were not engaged in a concerted practice shifts to the defendants. The Law gives as examples the de facto sharing of markets, price stability observed in the market over a long period and price increases by undertakings at close intervals. Second, the existence of restrictive agreements, decisions and practices may be proved by any kind of evidence.

Statutory Provision — Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition art. 59 (Burden of Proof)

Where those harmed submit to the judicial authorities evidence giving the impression of the existence of an agreement or of the distortion of competition in the market, such as in particular the de facto sharing of markets, price stability observed in the market for a period that may be regarded as long, or price increases at close intervals by the undertakings operating in the market, the burden of proving that the undertakings are not engaged in a concerted practice shifts to the defendants.

The existence of agreements, decisions and practices restricting competition may be proved by any kind of evidence.

The presumption concerns whether the undertakings engaged in a concerted practice; art. 59 provides no separate relief as to the amount of the loss or the causal link. In the cases reviewed, defendants mainly disputed causation, and in competitor cases the loss was determined on the basis of expert reports examining loss of market share during the infringement and commercial books. On the evidential value of commercial books, see the article on commercial books as evidence.

Competition Board Decision: Procedural Requirement or Preliminary Question?

Arts. 56–59 of the Law contain no provision making the damages action dependent on a Board decision. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed a first instance judgment that had dismissed the action “for lack of a procedural requirement” because the Board decision was not yet final:

Court of Cassation Decision

“However, it is not possible to accept the finality of the Competition Board decision as a precondition for bringing the damages action. Since the claimant applied to the Competition Board on 23.11.2010, before this action was brought, the outcome of the proceedings the Competition Board will conduct on the application alleging that the defendant abused its dominant position must be treated as a preliminary question in this action.”

In other words, the action may be filed, but judgment on the merits should not be given before the Board decision and the related administrative court proceedings are concluded. The fate of the Board decision then determines the outcome. In a cartel case concerning loan interest, the first instance court treated a final Board decision as a “special procedural requirement”; the regional court of appeal dismissed the appeal on the ground that the underlying Board decision had been found unlawful by the administrative courts, and the Court of Cassation upheld it without addressing the procedural requirement issue:

Court of Cassation Decision (upheld reasoning of the regional court of appeal)
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2023/6712, K. 2024/7799, 06.11.2024 (Upheld reasoning of the regional court of appeal)

“that the Competition Board decision on which the claimant based the damages claim was determined by an administrative court judgment to be unlawful and that competition was not infringed within the scope of the loan agreement made with the claimant”

Similarly, in another case concerning the same bank cartel the appellate judgment was upheld by 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/4784, K. 2026/1751. In a tender dispute where there was no Board decision at all, the regional court of appeal, having found that unfair competition was not proven, further stated that a damages claim based on Law No. 4054 requires the infringement to be established by the Competition Board, and that judgment was also upheld by 11th Civil Chamber, E. 2022/5830, K. 2024/2078. These are general upholding decisions that leave the reasoning to the appellate judgment.

Among the decisions reviewed for this article there is no Court of Cassation decision discussing in its reasoning whether a civil court may itself establish the infringement where there is no Board decision at all; the upheld appellate judgments required a Board finding.

Limitation

Arts. 56–59 of Law No. 4054 contain no limitation period. Since the Court of Cassation treats this action as tort liability, the general rule is art. 72 of the Turkish Code of Obligations: two years from knowledge of the damage and the person liable, and in any case ten years from the act. Under the same article, if the claim arises from an act requiring a penalty for which criminal laws provide a longer limitation period, that period applies.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098) art. 72(1) (Limitation — Rule)

A claim for compensation is time-barred upon the expiry of two years from the date on which the injured party learned of the damage and the person liable for compensation and, in any event, ten years from the date on which the act was committed. However, if the compensation arises from an act requiring a penalty for which criminal laws provide a longer limitation period, that limitation period applies.

Art. 16(3) of Law No. 4054, as quoted by the Chamber, provides for an administrative fine proportional to annual gross revenue for infringements of arts. 4 and 6; the Chamber treated these acts as misdemeanours within the meaning of the Misdemeanours Law. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, accepting that misdemeanours also fall within an “act requiring a penalty”, applied the eight-year period in the Misdemeanours Law to an abuse of dominance entailing a proportional administrative fine and reversed a dismissal based on expiry of the one-year period:

Statutory Provision — Misdemeanours Law (Law No. 5326) art. 20(3) (Limitation for investigation)

(3) The limitation period for misdemeanours requiring a proportional administrative fine is eight years.

Court of Cassation Decision

“deciding to dismiss the action on limitation grounds without considering that a damages action brought because of the defendant’s act requiring a proportional administrative fine is subject to the eight-year limitation period under article 20/3 of Misdemeanours Law No. 5326 was not found correct and required reversal.”

This case had been sent back to the Chamber by Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/19, K. 2018/1151. The Assembly did not examine the merits; it treated the judgment as a new judgment and left it to the Chamber; the eight-year rule is the Chamber’s view. In a 2025 decision the Chamber also upheld on this point, without reasons of its own, an appellate judgment relying on the eight-year period in the Misdemeanours Law (the regional court of appeal cited “20/4”; in the current text the eight-year period is in the third paragraph of art. 20). Note: the eight-year rule concerns infringements entailing a proportional administrative fine; when the period starts (knowledge, the complaint to the Board or the Board decision) has been disputed from case to case.

Competent Court and Interest

Law No. 4054 does not designate a competent court, and Law No. 4054 is not among the matters listed in art. 4 of the Turkish Commercial Code as commercial cases regardless of whether the parties are merchants. Jurisdiction therefore depends on the parties. Disputes relating to the commercial enterprises of both parties (for example an action between competing companies) are commercial cases under art. 4(1) of the Commercial Code; under art. 5(1), unless otherwise provided, the commercial court of first instance hears commercial cases. Two of the competitor cases reviewed for this article were heard by commercial courts. In commercial cases whose subject is a sum of money, such as damages claims, applying to a mediator before filing the action is a procedural requirement (art. 5/A).

Statutory Provision — Turkish Commercial Code (Law No. 6102) art. 4(1) (Commercial cases — General)

(1) Civil actions and non-contentious matters arising from matters relating to the commercial enterprises of both parties, and, regardless of whether the parties are merchants, civil actions and non-contentious matters arising from matters provided for in … are deemed commercial cases and non-contentious matters of a commercial nature.

Where the claimant is a consumer (for example a person who took out a loan at cartel interest), jurisdiction depends on the nature of the contract. The 19th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed a consumer court’s decision declining jurisdiction without examining the contract:

Court of Cassation Decision

“whereas the claimant should have been asked to state what type of contract existed between the parties and, once that contract was obtained, it should have been determined according to its scope whether it qualifies as a consumer contract, the merits being examined if it is a consumer contract and otherwise a decision being given again on jurisdiction, giving the judgment as written on incomplete examination was not correct and the judgment had to be reversed.”

This decision dates from 2017. The cartel interest case upheld in 2024 was heard by a consumer court and reviewed on appeal by the 11th Civil Chamber. On the distinction between commercial and consumer jurisdiction, see the article on the competent court in commercial and consumer cases.

As to interest, the Court of Cassation required interest to run not from the date of the Board decision but from the date on which each tortious act occurred:

Court of Cassation Decision
11th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/1873, K. 2025/7299, 04.12.2025 (Chamber’s reasons for upholding as corrected)

“The existence of the tort has been established by the Competition Board decision, and interest must run on the receivable awarded for the defendant’s tortious acts from the date on which each act occurred.”

Case Law: From a Board Decision to a Damages Award

An investigation in the rakı market clearly shows the relationship between a Board decision and a damages action. In its decision of 12.06.2014 numbered 14-21/410-178, the Competition Board found that a spirits producer holding a dominant position in the rakı market excluded its rivals through discounts and advance payments granted to points of sale and practices limiting the visibility of rival products. The Board decided unanimously that the undertaking infringed art. 6 “by abusing its dominant position through practices having the object and effect of hindering its competitors’ activities in the market”, and by majority to impose an administrative fine of 1.5 per cent of its revenue. The Board saw no need to impose a separate fine under art. 4 for the same practices.

A Board decision is not a court judgment. According to the first instance court’s reasoning quoted in the Court of Cassation’s 2025 decision, this decision became final by an upholding judgment of 14.03.2019. In the competitor actions based on it the results were as follows:

  • In the action of the competitor that complained to the Board and of a second claimant company that was not a complainant, the loss was calculated on the basis of market share losses during the infringement and treble damages were awarded. The Court of Cassation reversed the dismissal regarding the non-complainant company (2023), and the judgment rendered in compliance with the reversal was upheld (2025).
  • In another action based on the same Board decision, the first instance court determined the loss on the basis of an expert report and trebled it, applying the eight-year limitation period; the judgment was upheld as corrected only on the starting date of interest (2025).

The counter-example is the bank cartel cases in which the Board decision was stated to have been found unlawful by the administrative courts: the consumers’ actions were dismissed and the judgments upheld (2024, 2026).

Practical Points

  • Follow the Board proceedings: where the action is filed before the Board decision becomes final, a stay pending the preliminary question should be requested; the outcome of the annulment action directly affects the damages action.
  • Calculate limitation early: the eight-year period rests on Chamber decisions; since its starting point may be disputed, it is safer to act on the shortest possibility (this article’s own assessment).
  • Frame the claim according to the claimant: a buyer claims the price difference; a competitor claims its entire loss including expected profits.
  • Give reasons for a treble claim: set out the link to an agreement, decision or gross negligence and criteria such as the duration and repetition of the infringement.
  • Collect evidence early: commercial books, market share data and the findings in the Board decision are the basis for calculating loss.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are treble damages always awarded in a competition law damages action under Turkish law?

No. Under art. 58(2) of Law No. 4054, the damage must result from an agreement or decision of the parties or from their gross negligence, and the injured party must request it; the judge “may” award treble damages, so the court has discretion. In a 2023 decision the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation rejected an objection on this point because the reasons for the treble award had been stated in the judgment. In this article’s assessment, a treble award without reasons may be challenged on appeal.

Must a Competition Board decision be final before a competition damages action is filed in Türkiye?

In a 2016 decision the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that finality of the Competition Board decision is not a precondition for the action and required the outcome of the Board proceedings and the objection to be treated as a preliminary question. However, where the regional court of appeal stated that the underlying Board decision had been found unlawful by the administrative courts, appellate judgments dismissing the action were upheld; an appellate judgment requiring a Board finding where no Board decision existed was also upheld. The Board proceedings and any annulment action should therefore be followed closely.

What is the limitation period for a competition law damages action under Turkish law?

Arts. 56–59 of Law No. 4054 contain no separate period; the general rule is the two-year and ten-year periods in art. 72 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, but if the act requires a penalty subject to a longer limitation period under criminal laws, that period applies. In a 2022 decision the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that the eight-year period in the Misdemeanours Law applies to an abuse of dominance that entails a proportional administrative fine. When the period starts is assessed separately in each case.

Can a competitor that did not complain to the Competition Board claim damages for a competition law infringement in Türkiye?

Yes, according to a 2023 decision of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation. The Chamber stated that the legislator did not make an application to the Competition Authority a precondition for damages and that, since the Board decision finding an abuse of dominance had become final, everyone injured may claim compensation. On that ground it reversed the dismissal of the claim of a competitor company that was not listed as a complainant in the Board decision.

Which court hears a competition damages action against a bank for cartel interest in Türkiye?

In a 2017 decision the 19th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that the court may not decline jurisdiction without first obtaining the parties’ contract and determining whether it is a consumer contract; if it is, the consumer court decides the merits. However, in the cartel interest cases reviewed, appellate judgments dismissing the claims were upheld in 2024 and 2026 because the regional court of appeal stated that the underlying Board decision had been found unlawful by the administrative courts.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database and the official website of the Competition Authority. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Competition Law

All Competition Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Competition Damages in Türkiye: Treble Damages, Proof, Board Decisions, Limitation (Law No. 4054 Arts. 56-59)”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/competition-law-damages-action-treble-damages-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›