Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 9 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Union Standing Not Judged on Members' Interest Alone: Turkish Constitutional Court on Union Annulment Action

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: In Turkish administrative jurisdiction, an annulment action is brought by those whose interests are infringed by the act. In its individual application decision of 10.05.2023, the Constitutional Court (Anayasa Mahkemesi) found formalistic the dismissal by the courts of instance of a union’s action for lack of standing (ehliyet) on the basis of the members’ common interest alone: the act’s effect on the union’s own legal personality, for example on its membership, had not been discussed at all. The Court unanimously held that the right of access to a court under Article 36 of the Constitution had been violated and ordered a retrial. The decision does not mean that the union won its case.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the Constitutional Court unanimously held that administrative court decisions dismissing a trade union's annulment action for lack of standing, on the basis of the members' common interest alone and without discussing the act's effect on the union's own legal personality, violated the right of access to a court, and ordered a retrial.

Under Turkish law, the Constitutional Court held that decisions dismissing a trade union’s annulment action for lack of standing, by looking only at the members’ common interest and without discussing the act’s effect on the union’s own legal personality, violated the right of access to a court.

The Dispute

The applicant is a trade union established to protect the rights of public servants working in education, teaching and science. In 2017 the union began organising at a university. Four of its members working at the university alleged that, because of their union activities, they were repeatedly subjected to investigations and their posts were changed. On 03.04.2018 the union and these members filed a criminal complaint against university officials, alleging the offence of preventing the exercise of trade union rights (Turkish Criminal Code art. 118). By a decision of lack of jurisdiction of the chief public prosecutor’s office, the file was sent to the Presidency of the Council of Higher Education (YÖK). YÖK decided that no action was required against those complained of; the decision was notified on 17.07.2019.

The union and the members brought actions for annulment of this act. The Ankara 18th Administrative Court dismissed the members’ actions on the merits; those decisions became final. It dismissed the union’s action, however, on 03.06.2020 for lack of standing. According to that court, the act did not infringe the union’s interest, the members whose interests were affected had brought separate actions, and the act did not concern the common interest of all the union’s members. The decision was upheld on 10.09.2020 by the 4th Administrative Law Chamber of the Ankara Regional Administrative Court and became final. The union lodged an individual application on 04.11.2020.

Outcome of the Decision

On 10.05.2023 the First Section of the Constitutional Court declared the application admissible and held that the right of access to a court, within the right to a fair trial protected by Article 36 of the Constitution, had been violated. A copy of the decision was sent to the Ankara 18th Administrative Court for a retrial. Stating that a retrial would provide sufficient redress, the Court rejected the union’s claim for TRY 100,000 in non-pecuniary compensation and ordered payment of TRY 10,346.90 in costs. The decision was unanimous. No decision given in the retrial could be found at the time of writing.

Reasoning

The Court accepted that the dismissal for lack of standing had a legal basis (Administrative Procedure Law arts. 14 and 15) and a legitimate aim; the decisive criterion was proportionality. It first set the limits of its own review:

Constitutional Court Decision

“The task of determining whether the claimant has standing in an action for annulment of an administrative act, and of interpreting the legislation in this respect, belongs primarily to the courts of instance. … The role the Constitutional Court will assume in this matter is to examine, in the light of the circumstances of the specific case, the effect on the right of access to a court of the courts of instance’s interpretations that the administrative act does not affect the individual’s interest…” (unofficial translation)

It framed the question to be answered in the case at hand as follows:

Constitutional Court Decision

“The issue to be examined in the present application, then, is whether the union’s legal personality would be affected by the acts by which mobbing was allegedly applied to its members, and therefore whether the legal person itself has a legal interest in bringing an action. … It is clear that it is possible for the courts of instance to discuss whether the administration’s acts actually had an intimidating effect on the Union’s other members and whether this affected trade union organisation as a whole, and to give a decision on the claimant union’s action according to the outcome.” (unofficial translation)

It noted that the courts of instance had not discussed this question at all:

Constitutional Court Decision

“The courts of instance, however, without going into any examination of the merits, and wholly disregarding the effect the acts in dispute could have on the applicant’s legal personality and the possibility of the applicant union’s own legal personality being harmed by the acts, dismissed the action on procedural grounds for lack of standing, solely on the ground that its members had no common interest. It is seen that, although it is clear that there may be acts that impair the rights of the Union, as a legal person, apart from those of its members, the review of lawfulness was not carried out, by acting with a formalistic approach and with template wording.” (unofficial translation)

It tied its conclusion to the act’s possible effect on the union:

Constitutional Court Decision

“If the allegations that the union’s members were put under pressure by having their posts changed and that the acts concerning the change of posts were annulled are true, it is possible that this produced effects and consequences on the union’s legal situation for reasons such as a decrease in the number of its members. Therefore, the claimant union was deprived of the opportunity to bring before the judicial authorities, as a dispute, an administrative act that can be accepted as affecting its rights and interests. … For this reason, it was concluded that the interference with the applicant’s right of access to a court was disproportionate.” (unofficial translation)

Significance and Practical Effect

Under Article 2/1-a of the Administrative Procedure Law, an annulment action is brought by those whose interests are infringed by the act. The decision shows that, in an action brought by a trade union, this interest can be sought from two separate angles: the members’ common interest and the union’s own legal personality. If the court looks only at the first and does not discuss the second at all, a dismissal for lack of standing may violate the right of access to a court.

According to the reasoning of the 8th Chamber of the Council of State (Danıştay), upheld by the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, public servants’ unions may bring actions in their own right against acts concerning their legal personality and against acts infringing the common rights and interests of their members, and, on behalf of their members, against individual acts concerning those members (Council of State, Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2023/3213, K. 2024/1247, 30.05.2024). In that case the Chamber dismissed for lack of standing an action against a Presidential Decision on establishing faculties at a university, stating that it concerned the union from neither angle, and the Assembly upheld that decision by majority.

In practice, it is important for a union to explain concretely in its statement of claim how the act affects its own legal personality; the Constitutional Court mentioned in this context a decrease in membership and the effect on trade union organisation as a whole. The Court did not find that these allegations were true. In the Constitutional Court’s individual application decisions accessible after this decision, no decision departing from this approach could be found.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Administrative Procedure Law (Law No. 2577) art. 2/1-a (Types of administrative action) (unofficial translation)

“The types of administrative action are as follows:

a) … Annulment actions brought, for the annulment of administrative acts on the ground that they are unlawful in respect of one of the aspects of competence, form, cause, subject matter or purpose, by those whose interests are infringed, …” (unofficial translation)

Constitutional Provision — Constitution of the Republic of Türkiye (Law No. 2709) art. 36/1 (Freedom to claim rights) (unofficial translation)

“Everyone has the right of litigation either as plaintiff or defendant and the right to a fair trial before the courts through legitimate means and procedures.” (unofficial translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a trade union bring an annulment action against an act concerning its members?

Yes, but under Turkish law, Article 2/1-a of the Administrative Procedure Law requires that the act infringe its interest. In this decision, the Constitutional Court accepted that, where the union argues that the act also affects its own legal personality, the court must discuss that interest not only in terms of the members’ common interest but also from that angle.

If the members have sued separately, will the union’s action be dismissed?

In this case, the administrative court made the members’ separate actions one of its grounds for dismissal. The Constitutional Court accepted that this approach pursued a legitimate aim, but found disproportionate a dismissal given without discussing the effect on the union’s own legal personality.

Did the Constitutional Court decide that the union won its case?

No. The Court only found that the right of access to a court had been violated. Whether the act was lawful and whether the union was actually affected by it will be decided by the administrative court in the retrial.

What happens after the finding of a violation?

The decision was sent to the administrative court for a retrial. According to the Constitutional Court, what must be done is to give a new decision removing the reasons that led to the violation (Law No. 6216, art. 50/2).

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Administrative Law

All Administrative Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Union Standing Not Judged on Members' Interest Alone: Turkish Constitutional Court on Union Annulment Action”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/trade-union-standing-annulment-action-access-to-court

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›