Last reviewed:
Case NoteYear-Round Beach Occupation: Ecrimisil Due for Whole Year
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State, ecrimisil (compensation for unlawful occupation) for State beach land occupied and operated all year covers the whole year. This applies where an area under the sovereignty and disposal of the State is occupied as a beach, the business is open all year and the occupation continues throughout the year; the fact that the area can be used in summer does not shorten the period but is taken into account as a negative factor in the amount. According to the Assembly, a unit value fixed by a court decision for a comparable property for a different period cannot be taken directly as the basis of the calculation either. The decision of insistence endorsing the seasonal calculation was reversed in the administration’s favour; the decision is final and its reasoning was adopted by majority.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State held that where an area under the sovereignty and disposal of the State is occupied as a beach, the business is open all year and the occupation continues throughout the year, ecrimisil is calculated for the whole year and not only for the summer season. The Assembly also held that a unit value fixed by a court decision for a comparable property for a different period cannot be taken directly as the basis of the calculation.
A decision of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Turkish Council of State on whether ecrimisil for public land occupied as a beach is calculated for the season or for the whole year (State Tender Law (Law No. 2886) art. 75).
The Dispute
The National Property administration, stating that 13,200 m² of an unregistered area under the sovereignty and disposal of the State in Sarıyer, Istanbul, had been occupied by the claimant company as a beach, claimed TRY 2,913,614.30 in ecrimisil for the period 01.01.2018–22.08.2020; the company brought an action for annulment of the corrected ecrimisil notice.
After an on-site inspection, the expert, using a monthly unit value of TRY 3/m² for 2018 and the revaluation rates, calculated TRY 1,527,633.45 for the period of occupation. The administrative court, however, accepting that beaches can be used only in summer, took the period 25 July–31 October for each year and annulled TRY 2,574,047.06 of the notice; the appeals were dismissed.
The 4th Chamber of the Council of State reversed the annulled part, stating that the unit values for the nearby beach property taken as comparable by the administration had become final by court decision and that, since the occupation continued all year, ecrimisil had to be calculated for the whole year. The regional administrative court insisted on its decision, stating that the comparable site was a Treasury property whereas the land in dispute was under the sovereignty and disposal of the State, that the comparable site had a single-storey building whereas no fixed structure had been found here, and that the use was seasonal; the administration appealed.
Outcome of the Decision
By its decision of 10.11.2025, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers allowed the administration’s appeal and reversed the part of the decision of insistence dismissing the administration’s appeal; the file was sent to the regional administrative court. The decision was given as final, with its reasoning adopted by majority: the dissenting opinion disagrees with the reasoning, taking the view that the decision of insistence should have been reversed along the lines of the 4th Chamber’s reversal decision.
Reasoning
The Assembly noted that, since the existence of the occupation and the size of the area were not disputed, the dispute centred on the amount. The ground for reversal was the seasonal calculation:
“… the expert report stated that part of the immovable was a beach area and that part of it was used as the business’s garden, and since the claimant’s business is open all year and its occupation continues throughout the year, it is clear that the ecrimisil must be calculated for the whole year. Moreover, the possibility of using the immovable in the summer period depending on weather conditions was assessed as a negative factor in determining the ecrimisil and taken into account in the calculation, and calculating the ecrimisil on a seasonal basis is not lawful.”
On comparables, however, the Assembly departed from the 4th Chamber. Article 85 of the Regulation also lists final court decisions concerning comparable properties among the data to be taken into account; the Assembly drew the limit of that provision as follows:
“… although final court decisions concerning comparable immovables are one of the data to be taken into account in determining the amount of ecrimisil, it is clear that that provision cannot be interpreted so as to result in a unit value fixed by a court decision for a comparable immovable, for a different period, being taken directly as the basis of the ecrimisil calculation; the contrary would mean that circumstances specific to the case, such as the manner in which the occupier uses the immovable, its factual and legal situation and any income derived from the occupation, are not taken into account in determining the amount of ecrimisil.”
The expert report obtained by the court had assessed the land’s location, use, rental yield and positive and negative factors, and had used comparable decisions for information only; the Assembly found that this report could be relied on.
Significance and Practical Effect
The decision lays down two tests for actions against ecrimisil claimed by the National Property administration under art. 75 of Law No. 2886: if the occupation continues all year, ecrimisil is calculated for the whole year, and seasonality becomes a negative factor in the unit value; and where the land’s situation can be established, a value fixed by a court decision for another property for a different period cannot simply be updated and used as the amount.
The limits of the decision are also clear: the Assembly relied on the business being open all year and part of the area being used as a garden; use confined to the season was not discussed. The 4th Chamber likewise, for an area in Bodrum used as a café and tea garden, held that since photographs showed active use in the winter months as well the occupation was not seasonal, and reversed the part based on a calculation that deducted the winter months for the open areas (Council of State, 4th Chamber, E. 2025/4447, K. 2025/6047, 19.11.2025). In that case a unit value that had become final for an earlier period of the same land had been adapted; the Assembly’s test on comparables, by contrast, concerns another property. In our assessment, what is decisive is a concrete finding of the months in which the occupation continues.
For ecrimisil claims between private persons, see our guide Ecrimisil (Compensation for Unlawful Occupation).
In a search of Council of State decisions published in the official case-law database from the date of the decision to the date of this article, conducted on search results and summaries, no decision departing from this test was found. In the database, decisions of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers appear up to 15.01.2026 and those of the 4th Chamber up to 12.03.2026.
Relevant Legislation
“Where immovable property in the private ownership of the State or under the sovereignty and disposal of the State … is occupied by real or legal persons, ecrimisil shall be claimed from the unauthorised occupier … as determined and assessed for a period not exceeding five years back from the date of determination. …”
“In determining and assessing ecrimisil, … account shall be taken of the manner in which the occupier uses the immovable, its factual and legal situation and any income derived from the occupation, the rents or ecrimisil established for comparable immovables in the same place and locality, any final court decisions concerning them, … and all factors that will affect the value of the immovable. …”
“ğ) Treasury immovable: immovables in the private ownership of the Treasury and places under the sovereignty and disposal of the State, …”
Under the Regulation, “Treasury immovable” also covers places under the sovereignty and disposal of the State. In our assessment, the distinction stressed by the regional administrative court therefore does not prevent the definition of unauthorised occupier relied on by the Assembly from applying to the area in dispute. The position of titled land inside the shore edge line is addressed in our article on property inside the shore edge line: title cancellation and compensation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is ecrimisil for public land occupied as a beach claimed only for the summer months?
Not in this case. Since the business was open all year and the occupation continued throughout the year, the Assembly held that ecrimisil must be calculated for the whole year.
Is the fact that the area can be used only in summer not reflected in the amount?
It is, but in the unit value rather than the period. According to the Assembly, the possibility of summer use had been taken into account as a negative factor in determining the ecrimisil.
What if the use is genuinely limited to the season?
This decision does not resolve that situation. The 4th Chamber of the Council of State decided whether an occupation was seasonal by looking at whether the land was actually used in the winter months.
Can the administration directly apply the unit value in a final court decision on a comparable property?
According to the Assembly, no. That decision is one of the data to be taken into account; but a value fixed for a different period cannot simply be updated and used as the amount without regard to the case-specific circumstances.
Is the decision final, and what happened to the file?
The decision is final and its reasoning was adopted by majority. The part of the decision of insistence that went against the administration was reversed and the file was sent to the regional administrative court.
- Ecrimisil (Compensation for Unlawful Occupation): The Bad-Faith Possessor's Liability, Prohibition of Use Among Co-owners, the Five-Year Prescription, and the Calculation of Ecrimisil
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- De Facto Expropriation Claims in Türkiye: Compensation, Injunction and Mesne Profits
Related Articles
- Ecrimisil (Compensation for Unlawful Occupation): The Bad-Faith Possessor's Liability, Prohibition of Use Among Co-owners, the Five-Year Prescription, and the Calculation of Ecrimisil
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- De Facto Expropriation Claims in Türkiye: Compensation, Injunction and Mesne Profits
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Title deed cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Real Estate Law
- Turnkey Home Purchases in Türkiye: Off-Plan Sale Contracts, Late Delivery, Withdrawal and Title
- Revoking a Gift of Real Estate in Türkiye: Conditional Gifts, Grounds and the One-Year Period (TCO 295–297)
- Promise to Sell Real Estate in Türkiye: Registration Action, Termination, Limitation and Informal Sales
- Short-Term Tourist Rentals in Türkiye: The Permit, Flat Owners' Unanimous Decision and Administrative Fines
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Year-Round Beach Occupation: Ecrimisil Due for Whole Year”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/beach-occupation-ecrimisil-whole-year-not-seasonal

























