Last reviewed:
Ecrimisil (Compensation for Unlawful Occupation): Bad-Faith Possessor, Co-owners, Prescription, Calculation
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, ecrimisil is the compensation for unlawful occupation that a bad-faith possessor who occupies property without the owner’s consent and without lawful ground must pay to the owner (TMK art.995); a good-faith possessor, by contrast, owes no compensation for use and enjoyment (TMK art.993). Co-owners cannot claim ecrimisil from one another unless the prohibition-of-use (intifadan men) condition is met, which requires the claimant co-owner to have notified the other, before the period claimed, of the wish to use the property or its income. Ecrimisil actions are subject to a five-year prescription period running backwards from the action date; since prescription is a plea, the court does not take it into account of its own motion if the defendant does not raise it. Ecrimisil is calculated by determining, through comparable leases and expert examination, the rent the property could have earned on the open market in the first period, and by applying the full PPI increase to that amount for later periods. The competent court is the civil court of first instance, regardless of the value of the claim (HMK art.2).
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Ecrimisil is the compensation for unlawful occupation that a bad-faith possessor occupying property without lawful ground or consent must pay to the owner. This article explains, under TMK arts.683, 993, 994 and 995, its nature and elements, the prohibition-of-use condition among co-owners, the competent court and venue, the five-year prescription running backwards from the action date, and the calculation of ecrimisil (first-period rent plus PPI increase), in light of decisions of the Yargıtay 1st and 8th Civil Chambers and the Assembly of Civil Chambers.
What ecrimisil (compensation for unlawful occupation) is; the bad-faith possessor's duty to restore and compensate, the elements of unlawful occupation and its proof, the prohibition-of-use (intifadan men) condition among co-owners, the calculation of ecrimisil (first-period rent plus PPI increase), the five-year prescription and the prescription plea; TMK arts.683, 993, 994 and 995; actions joined with the prevention of interference, competent court and venue, and decisions of the Yargıtay 1st and 8th Civil Chambers and the Assembly of Civil Chambers. (Unofficial translation.)
What Is Ecrimisil (Compensation for Unlawful Occupation)?
Ecrimisil is the compensation that a bad-faith possessor who has no title must pay to the owner where immovable (or movable) property is occupied and used without the owner's or possessor's consent and without any lawful ground. In short, it is compensation that an owner who does not possess may claim from a bad-faith possessor who is not the owner.
In the settled practice of the Court of Cassation, ecrimisil is a special form of loss compensation arising from a tortious (unlawful) act. It represents at least the loss equal to the rental income the property could have generated; depending on the nature of the occupation it may also cover positive loss from use/wear and the benefit (negative loss) of which the owner or possessor was deprived.
Ecrimisil is not a lease; there is no contract between the parties, and an award of ecrimisil does not grant the occupier any right to reside in or use the property. To end the occupation the owner may separately bring an action for prevention of interference (and, where relevant, eviction); ecrimisil is frequently claimed together with the prevention-of-interference action.
Legal Basis
The basis of ecrimisil lies in the Turkish Civil Code provisions on possession together with the rei vindicatio and prevention-of-interference rules protecting ownership. The owner may bring a recovery action against anyone who unlawfully holds the property and may also seek prevention of any unlawful interference (TMK art.683). Compensation for the occupation period rests on TMK art.995, governing the liability of the bad-faith possessor.
“A possessor not acting in good faith must pay compensation for the loss caused to the entitled person by unlawfully retaining the thing it is obliged to return, and for the fruits obtained or negligently failed to obtain. Such a possessor may claim reimbursement only of expenses that were also necessary for the entitled person. So long as the possessor does not know to whom the thing must be returned, it is liable only for loss caused by its own fault.”
“A person who owns a thing may, within the limits of the legal order, use, benefit from and dispose of it as it wishes. The owner may bring a recovery action against anyone who unlawfully holds the thing and may also seek prevention of any unlawful interference.”
“A possessor who in good faith uses or benefits from the thing in its possession in a manner consistent with its presumed right is not obliged to pay any compensation on that account to the person to whom it must return the thing. A good-faith possessor is not liable for the loss, destruction or damage of the thing.”
TMK arts.993 and 994 govern the good-faith possessor: a good-faith possessor pays no compensation for use and enjoyment and may even claim necessary and useful expenses. Ecrimisil, by contrast, concerns only the bad-faith possessor. Whether the occupier acted in good faith is therefore central to the dispute.
The Court of Cassation grounds ecrimisil's tortious character and its temporal limit on the Unification-of-Precedents Decisions of 08.03.1950 no.22/4 and 25.05.1938 no.29/10, which held that unlawful occupation cannot be likened to a lease, must be regarded as a tort, and that ecrimisil actions are subject to a five-year prescription.
Conditions and Elements
1. The claimant is the owner or entitled person
Ecrimisil may be claimed by the person holding ownership or a right of enjoyment over the property (owner, co-owner, joint owner, holder of a limited real right, and in some cases the possessor). The right belongs to the person who owned the property during the period of occupation.
2. The defendant's unlawful occupation
The defendant must have used the property in fact, without the owner's consent and without lawful ground. If a lease, usufruct, loan-for-use or similar relationship justifies the use, the occupation is not unlawful and the claim is not ecrimisil but claims arising from that relationship.
3. The occupier is in bad faith
Ecrimisil arises only for a possessor not acting in good faith (TMK art.995). A person who knows, or ought to know, that they are using the property unlawfully and without the entitled person's consent is in bad faith. For instance, the Court of Cassation accepts that parties to a simulated (collusive) transaction are in bad faith.
4. Loss and claim
Loss to the owner caused by the unlawful occupation is required. Because ecrimisil equals at least the rental-income loss, the rent the property could have generated during the occupation is taken as the basis. The amount is fixed by the court through an expert examination, bound by the relief sought.
Ecrimisil Among Co-owners and the Prohibition-of-Use Condition
The most contested form of ecrimisil arises among co-owners (owners in common or joint owners). As a rule, co-owners cannot claim ecrimisil from one another unless a prohibition of use (intifadan men) has occurred, because each co-owner is in principle entitled to benefit from the whole of the common property; one co-owner's use is not unlawful occupation unless another co-owner expressly objects.
For the condition to be met, before the period for which ecrimisil is claimed the claimant co-owner must have notified the defendant co-owner of its wish to benefit from the property or its income. According to the Court of Cassation this notice need not be in writing; it may be proved by any evidence, including the decisive oath. Indeed, demanding rent from the defendant co-owner also amounts to prohibition of use. The court examines this condition of its own motion at every stage.
There are exceptional cases where the condition is not required — for example where the property is income-generating (leased), certain agricultural land, or where the defendant denies the co-ownership. Hence in co-owner disputes the prohibition-of-use condition must be concretely investigated.
Who Brings the Action and How
The action is brought by the person who owned or was entitled to the property during the occupation. In joint (elbirliği) ownership all co-owners must in principle sue together, or the others' consent or the appointment of a representative for the estate must be obtained; in co-ownership in common each co-owner may claim ecrimisil in proportion to its share.
Ecrimisil is usually claimed together with the prevention-of-interference action but may also be brought independently. The statement of claim must clearly identify the occupied property, the occupation period, the evidence relied on and the amount sought. Where the amount is not initially known, a partial action reserving the surplus may be filed and later increased by amendment after the expert report. However, a partial action interrupts prescription only for the amount actually claimed.
Competent Court and Venue
Because ecrimisil is a monetary (compensation) claim, the competent court is the civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk mahkemesi) irrespective of the amount in dispute (HMK art.2). As ecrimisil does not concern ownership of the immovable, even where joined with the prevention-of-interference action the compensation part remains within the civil court of first instance's jurisdiction.
“(1) Regardless of the value or amount in dispute, the competent court in actions concerning rights of property and rights of personality is the civil court of first instance, unless otherwise provided. (2) Unless otherwise provided in this Code or other laws, the civil court of first instance is also competent for other actions and matters.”
As to venue, the general rule is the defendant's domicile (HMK art.6). However, since the Court of Cassation treats ecrimisil as tortious, HMK art.16 on venue in tort actions may also apply, so that the place where the tort was committed (where the property is located) is likewise competent. When joined with the prevention-of-interference action, the court of the place where the property is located comes to the fore.
“(1) In actions arising from tort, the court of the place where the tort was committed, or where the loss occurred or is likely to occur, or of the injured person's domicile is also competent.”
Time Limit and Prescription
Ecrimisil actions are subject to a five-year prescription, and this period runs backwards from the date the action is filed. Thus the owner may claim ecrimisil for at most the five-year period preceding the action (or the amendment); earlier periods are time-barred.
Prescription is, however, a plea; the court cannot apply it of its own motion. If the defendant fails to raise the prescription plea in time, ecrimisil may be awarded even for periods older than five years. As prescription is not a preliminary objection it may be raised at later stages; but if raised after the reply period, the claimant must not object to the broadening of the defence. Timing is therefore critical: the occupied owner should act promptly, and the defendant should raise the prescription plea properly and in time.
Calculation of Ecrimisil
Calculating ecrimisil requires expertise and is fixed by an expert panel appropriate to the property, through inspection on site, bound by the relief sought. The expert report must rest on concrete information and documents, be open to the scrutiny of the parties and the court, and set out its reasons in conformity with scientific data and HMK arts.266 et seq.
On a rental basis the method is as follows: the rent the property could have generated in its existing condition under free-market terms in the first claimed period is determined by comparison with comparable leases and considering the property's size, nature and surroundings, at local market rates. For subsequent periods ecrimisil is assessed at no less than the amount found by applying the full PPI (producer price index) increase rate to the first-period figure. Ecrimisil must be computed forward from the first period by this method, not backward from the action date.
Proof
The burden of proof rests largely on the claimant, who must prove ownership/entitlement (title deed), the occupation by the defendant, and the occupation period. Occupation may be shown by on-site inspection, witnesses, neighbour statements, photographs, utility records and official records; the potential rental income by comparable leases and expert examination.
In co-owner actions it must additionally be proved that the prohibition-of-use condition occurred — that the wish to benefit was notified to the defendant before the claimed period — which need not be in writing and may be proved by any evidence, including the oath. The occupier's bad faith must also be established by concrete facts.
Decisions of the Court of Cassation
Nature and scope of ecrimisil
“As stated in both doctrine and judicial practice, ecrimisil — that is, compensation for unlawful occupation — is compensation that an owner who does not possess may claim from a bad-faith possessor who is not the owner; the Unification-of-Precedents Decision of 08.03.1950 no.22/4 emphasised that unlawful occupation cannot be likened to a lease founded on the parties' mutually corresponding wills, must be regarded as a tort by its nature, and that the loss caused must be compensated. Being a special form of loss compensation, ecrimisil is at least a loss equal to the rental income.” (Unofficial translation.)
The prohibition-of-use condition among co-owners
“As a rule co-owners cannot claim ecrimisil from one another unless a prohibition of use has occurred. For that condition to be met, before the period for which ecrimisil is claimed the claimant co-owner must notify the defendant co-owner of its wish to benefit from the property or its income. Prohibition of use ... is examined of the court's own motion at every stage of the proceedings and may be proved by any evidence, including the oath. ... Demanding rent also amounts to prohibition of use.” (Unofficial translation.)
Five-year prescription and the prescription plea
“Under the Court of Cassation Decision on the Unification of Jurisprudence dated 25.05.1938 and numbered 29/10 and the settled case law of the Court of Cassation to the same effect, actions for compensation for unlawful occupation (ecrimisil) are subject to a five-year limitation period; this five-year period runs backwards from the date of the action. On the other hand, under Article 140 of the Code of Obligations, where limitation is not raised, the judge cannot take limitation into account of its own motion.”
Calculation of ecrimisil (first-period rent + PPI)
“As a matter of principle, in determining ecrimisil on a rental basis, the rent the property could generate in its existing condition under free-market terms in the first claimed period is fixed by comparison with comparable leases, taking into account the property's size, nature and surroundings, at local market rates. For subsequent periods the value of ecrimisil is assessed at no less than the amount found by reflecting the full PPI increase rate onto the amount determined for the first period.” (Unofficial translation.)
Party to a simulated transaction and bad faith
“As is known, ecrimisil is a kind of compensation for unlawful occupation which a bad-faith possessor is obliged to pay to the owner. It is clear that persons who are parties to sham transactions are in bad faith. That being so, while the compensation for unlawful occupation to be determined should also have been awarded, it is not correct to render a judgment as written on the basis of an erroneous assessment.”
Frequently Asked Questions
How far back can an ecrimisil action be brought?
Ecrimisil actions are subject to a five-year prescription running backwards from the filing date, so as a rule at most the five-year period preceding the action (or amendment) may be claimed. But because prescription is a plea, if the defendant does not raise it in time, ecrimisil may be awarded for older periods too.
Can I claim ecrimisil from my co-owner (e.g. my sibling)?
As a rule, co-owners may claim ecrimisil from one another only if the prohibition-of-use condition has been met. Before the claimed period you must have notified your co-owner of your wish to benefit from the property or its income; demanding rent also serves as such notice.
What is the difference between ecrimisil and rent?
Rent rests on a contract and confers a right to use. Ecrimisil is compensation for unlawful occupation without any contract; it confers no right to use and, even if paid, the occupation remains unlawful.
How is the ecrimisil amount determined?
By determining the market rent the property could generate in the first period through comparable leases and an on-site expert examination. For later years the amount is computed forward by reflecting the PPI increase onto the first-period figure.
Which court is competent for an ecrimisil action?
Because ecrimisil is a monetary (compensation) claim, the civil court of first instance is competent irrespective of the amount (HMK art.2). As to venue, besides the defendant's domicile, the court of the place where the property is located may also be competent given the tortious character.
Must a good-faith occupier pay ecrimisil?
Ecrimisil arises only for a bad-faith possessor. A possessor genuinely believed to have used the property in good faith, relying on an existing right, is as a rule not liable to compensate under TMK art.993. Whether the occupier acted in good faith is therefore the decisive issue.
For our practice area on real property, co-ownership and unlawful-occupation disputes, see our Real Estate Law page.
- Action for Prevention of Interference with Property: Conditions, Interference Between Co-Owners, Encroaching Structures and Joinder with Mesne Profits
- Dissolution of Co-ownership (Partition): Division in Kind and Sale
- Action for Annulment of Title and Re-Registration: Incapacity, Fraud, Abuse of Authority and Wrongful Registration in Light of the Yargıtay 1st Civil Chamber's Precedents
Related Articles
- Action for Prevention of Interference with Property: Conditions, Interference Between Co-Owners, Encroaching Structures and Joinder with Mesne Profits
- Dissolution of Co-ownership (Partition): Division in Kind and Sale
- Action for Annulment of Title and Re-Registration: Incapacity, Fraud, Abuse of Authority and Wrongful Registration in Light of the Yargıtay 1st Civil Chamber's Precedents
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case database. The decisions referred to are Court of Cassation decisions published in the official database and do not relate to files in which the firm was a party.
Author: Title deed cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Real Estate Law
- Turnkey Home Purchases in Türkiye: Off-Plan Sale Contracts, Late Delivery, Withdrawal and Title
- Revoking a Gift of Real Estate in Türkiye: Conditional Gifts, Grounds and the One-Year Period (TCO 295–297)
- Promise to Sell Real Estate in Türkiye: Registration Action, Termination, Limitation and Informal Sales
- Property Inside the Shore Edge Line in Türkiye: Title Cancellation, Compensation and Legal Remedies
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Ecrimisil (Compensation for Unlawful Occupation): Bad-Faith Possessor, Co-owners, Prescription, Calculation”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-10, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/ecrimisil

























