Last reviewed:
Case NoteMining Revenue and Tax Do Not Justify Urgent Expropriation
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, according to the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State, urgent expropriation is an exceptional method; the administration must establish conditions showing urgency beyond the grounds for ordinary expropriation. The revenue, State royalty, tax, current-account-deficit and employment data put forward for a gold mine may show the need for expropriation, but they do not show the extraordinary circumstances required by art. 27 of the Expropriation Law (Law No. 2942). Since the project’s EIA (environmental impact assessment) positive decision had been annulled by an administrative court, the urgent expropriation method cannot be applied either. The urgent expropriation decision was annulled in respect of the immovable in dispute; the decision is final and was given by majority.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Council of State annulled, in respect of the immovable in dispute, an urgent expropriation decision taken for a gold mine, holding that revenue, State royalty and tax data do not show an extraordinary state of urgency and that the project's EIA positive decision had been annulled by an administrative court. The decision is final and was given by majority.
A decision of the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers of the Turkish Council of State on whether urgent expropriation for a mining project can rest on revenue and tax grounds, and on the effect of the annulment of the EIA positive decision (Expropriation Law art. 27, Environment Law art. 10).
The Dispute
By Presidential Decision No. 9050 of 18.10.2024 (Official Gazette, 19.10.2024), the urgent expropriation by the General Directorate of Mining and Petroleum Affairs of the immovables needed to continue production on a site in Balıkesir licensed for Group IV (gold, silver, copper) mining operations was ordered. The claimants sought annulment of the decision in respect of one parcel in İvrindi; the mining company intervened on the side of the defendant administrations.
The 6th Chamber of the Council of State, hearing the action at first instance, dismissed it: in the Chamber’s view, the share of gold imports in the current account deficit and the fact that the largely completed project could not start operations because of the remaining ten parcels showed public interest and a state of urgency. On appeal, the claimants argued that the state of urgency had not been concretely shown and that the project’s EIA positive decision had been annulled by an administrative court.
Outcome of the Decision
By its decision of 29.12.2025, the Assembly allowed the appeal, reversed the Chamber’s decision and, deciding the matter itself, annulled the measure in so far as it concerned the immovable in dispute. The decision is final and was given by majority on both the merits and the reasoning. One dissenting opinion favours upholding the Chamber’s decision. According to the other dissent, which disagreed with the reasoning, the project’s contribution to the economy did create a state of urgency, but with the annulment of the EIA positive decision the basis of the urgent expropriation decision had ceased to exist.
Reasoning
According to the Assembly, urgent expropriation is an exceptional method that, unlike the ordinary procedure, allows the administration to take possession of the immovable before the procedure is concluded. Since the Law lists no specific state of urgency for “cases where urgency is decided by the President”, the court assesses urgency in each specific case; the urgency condition must relate to public order, and the interest pursued must make urgency compelling.
The data relied on by the administration were the current account deficit, net gold imports, an investment of USD 45 million, employment for 156 people and the annual amounts of State royalty and income tax. The Assembly assessed them as follows:
“Although the grounds set out may be accepted as reasons showing the need to expropriate the immovables in dispute so that mining production can continue, it is concluded that these matters cannot be accepted as reasons showing the extraordinary circumstances required for applying the urgent expropriation procedure provided for in Article 27 of Law No. 2942 and the public interest pursued by resorting to that method.” (translation)
Second, the Assembly recalled art. 10 of the Environment Law (Law No. 2872): unless an EIA positive decision is obtained, no approval, permit or licence may be granted for the project and no investment may be started. The project’s EIA positive decision of 05.09.2022 had been annulled by an administrative court:
“…in view of the uncertainty that has arisen concerning the environmental impact assessment of the project on which the urgent expropriation decision in dispute is based, it is concluded that it is not possible, within this project, to carry out an expropriation measure resulting in an interference with the right of property and, consequently, to apply the urgent expropriation method in the course of the expropriation.” (translation)
The Assembly’s conclusion is as follows:
“Given the requirement that, in urgent expropriation, which is an exceptional method, conditions showing the existence of urgency be established beyond the grounds for ordinary expropriation, the data put forward by the defendant administrations on the revenue to be derived from the planned mining activity and on the amounts of State royalty and tax to be paid do not constitute a ground for urgent expropriation; moreover, in the present case, in which the EIA Positive Decision issued for the project on which the urgent expropriation decision in dispute is based has also been annulled by the Administrative Court, it is understood that there is no state of urgency requiring urgent expropriation.” (translation)
Significance and Practical Effect
The decision distinguishes the reasons that justify expropriation from the reasons that justify the urgent procedure: economic returns may show the need for expropriation but do not by themselves justify urgent taking of possession.
- Settled line: In an earlier case concerning an urgent expropriation decision taken for a lignite mine, the Assembly likewise found grounds based on revenue, State royalty, employment and coal supply contracts insufficient and unanimously upheld the annulment; in that case the company’s notice that it had abandoned the expropriation of the immovable was also taken into account (Council of State, Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers, E. 2024/2347, K. 2024/3072, 28.11.2024).
- Effect of the EIA annulment: The annulment of the EIA positive decision was raised at the appeal stage and taken into account by the Assembly. The decision does not state whether that annulment had become final; the Assembly reasons from the “uncertainty” that had arisen.
- Scope of the annulment: The Assembly annulled only the urgent expropriation decision, in respect of the immovable in dispute; the public-interest decision taken by ministerial approval, mentioned in the dissent, was not the subject of the action. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, annulment of an urgent expropriation decision does not end the price determination and registration action as long as the public-interest and expropriation decisions stand (see our note on that decision); how that action works is explained in a separate guide.
In a search of Council of State decisions published in the official case-law database since the date of the decision, conducted on search results and summaries, no decision departing from this test was found (decisions of the Assembly appear up to 15.01.2026 and those of the 6th Chamber up to 05.01.2026).
Relevant Legislation
“…in cases where urgency is decided by the President or in extraordinary situations provided for by special laws, in the expropriation of the immovables required, the steps other than valuation being completed afterwards, upon the request of the administration concerned, possession of that immovable may be taken by the administration depositing in the name of the owner … in the bank specified the value of that immovable … to be determined by the court within seven days.”
“Unless an Environmental Impact Assessment Positive Decision … is obtained, no approval, permit, incentive, construction or occupancy licence may be granted for these projects; no investment may be started for the project and it may not be put out to tender. … However, this does not prevent applications being made in the incentive, approval, permit and licence processes concerned.”
The last sentence was added by Law No. 7554 of 19.07.2025; the Assembly’s decision does not address it.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can an urgent expropriation decision be challenged?
Under Turkish law, an action is brought before the administrative courts for annulment of the presidential urgent expropriation decision in respect of the immovable. In this case the 6th Chamber of the Council of State heard the action at first instance and the Assembly of Administrative Law Chambers reviewed the appeal.
Do revenue, tax and employment data justify urgent expropriation?
According to the Assembly, they do not. Such data may show the need to expropriate the immovable, but they do not show the extraordinary circumstances required for the urgent procedure or the public interest pursued by that procedure.
Can urgent expropriation be carried out if the project's EIA positive decision has been annulled?
The Assembly held in this case that it cannot: in view of the uncertainty created by the administrative court's annulment of the EIA positive decision, the urgent expropriation method cannot be applied. The decision does not state whether the annulment of the EIA decision had become final.
Was the decision unanimous?
No. The decision is final and was given by majority on both the merits and the reasoning. One dissenting opinion favours upholding the dismissal; the other favours annulment on the EIA ground alone.
Related Articles
- Urgent Expropriation Annulment Does Not End Price Suit: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers, While the Expropriation Stands
- Expropriation and the Owner’s Rights
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Title deed cases attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Real Estate Law
- Turnkey Home Purchases in Türkiye: Off-Plan Sale Contracts, Late Delivery, Withdrawal and Title
- Revoking a Gift of Real Estate in Türkiye: Conditional Gifts, Grounds and the One-Year Period (TCO 295–297)
- Promise to Sell Real Estate in Türkiye: Registration Action, Termination, Limitation and Informal Sales
- Property Inside the Shore Edge Line in Türkiye: Title Cancellation, Compensation and Legal Remedies
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Mining Revenue and Tax Do Not Justify Urgent Expropriation”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-09, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/urgent-expropriation-mining-revenue-tax-eia

























