Last reviewed:
Reserve Building Area Designation Annulment (Law No. 6306): Time Limit and Stay of Execution in Türkiye
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, a reserve building area is an area designated by the Ministry, at the request of TOKİ or the Administration or of its own motion, for use in implementations carried out under Law No. 6306 (art. 2/1-c); Law No. 7471 removed the words “as a new settlement area” from the definition. An action may be brought in the administrative courts within thirty days of notification against administrative acts taken under the Law (art. 6/9). In a case on an urgent expropriation decision taken by Presidential decision, the Council of State applied the general sixty-day limit because the special time limit under art. 20/A of the Administrative Procedure Law had not been stated in the act; that decision did not address the period in art. 6/9. Since the Constitutional Court annulled the sentence barring a stay of execution in these actions, a stay may, as a rule, be requested under the conditions of art. 27 of the Administrative Procedure Law.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Under Turkish law, a reserve building area is an area designated by the Ministry for use in implementations under Law No. 6306; an action may be brought before the administrative courts within thirty days of notification against acts taken under the Law. The article explains the definition amended by Law No. 7471, the suspension of zoning procedures, the majority decision, stay of execution and decisions of the Council of State and the Constitutional Court on urgent expropriation.
What an owner in Türkiye whose property has been designated a reserve building area under Law No. 6306 should know: the legal basis of the designation and the definition amended by Law No. 7471, the consequences of the designation, the time limit for an annulment action, stay of execution and decisions of the Council of State.
What Is a Reserve Building Area?
Law No. 6306 on the Transformation of Areas under Disaster Risk uses three separate statuses: risky building, risky area and reserve building area. A risky building concerns a single building; designation, objection and the majority decision are explained in a separate article (Risky Building Designation under Law No. 6306). A risky area is decided by the President. A reserve building area is designated by the Ministry.
“c) Reserve building area: areas designated by the Ministry, at the request of TOKİ or the Administration or of its own motion, to be used … in implementations carried out under this Law,”
Under the same article, the “Ministry” is the Ministry of Environment, Urbanisation and Climate Change; the “Administration” means the municipality within municipal and adjacent-area boundaries, the special provincial administration outside them, and the metropolitan municipality in metropolitan cities. A designation may concern one property or many parcels. In the Council of State decisions discussed below, both a single parcel and an area of hundreds of hectares were designated as reserve building areas.
In the original text of the Law, a reserve building area was an area to be used “as a new settlement area”. In its 2014 decision the Constitutional Court explained the concept as a new settlement area created so that settlements under disaster risk could, where necessary, be relocated (E.2012/87, K.2014/41). That explanation rests on the wording of the definition at the time.
The Definition Amended by Law No. 7471
Law No. 7471 of 7/11/2023 removed the words “as a new settlement area” from the definition. In the current text only an omission mark “(…)” stands in their place. The Council of State records the amendment in the same way:
“By article 6 of Law No. 7471 the words ‘as a new settlement area’ were removed from the definition, and a reserve building area was defined as areas designated by the Ministry, at the request of TOKİ or the Administration or of its own motion, to be used in implementations carried out under this Law. … it was concluded that the reserve building area of the parcel in dispute was declared at the request of the parcel owners, and that the reserve building area declaration aimed to create a healthy and safe living area complying with scientific and technical norms and standards within the purpose of the Law.”
In that case an empty parcel in Ankara had been declared a reserve building area at the request of its co-owners, and zoning plan amendments allowing commercial, tourism and residential use had been made. The administrative court annulled the declaration and the plans on the ground that there was no concrete technical data showing that the declaration served the housing needs of people living in areas under disaster risk, and the regional administrative court dismissed the appeal. The Council of State reversed. Its reasoning noted that, under the Implementing Regulation provision quoted in the decision, income-generating implementations may also be carried out in reserve building areas. This provision (Implementing Regulation art. 4/4-b) remains in the current text; however, art. 4 was amended on 21/5/2024 after the decision: a request by private persons now requires consent to transfer thirty per cent of the land area to the Presidency or payment of its value. This is a provision of a regulation, not of the Law. The decision was final and given by majority. Dissenting members considered that the regional administrative court’s decision (that is, the annulment of the designation) should be upheld; one dissent limited this to the part concerning the zoning plans. In addition, two members considered that the claimant, who had no parcel adjoining the parcel in dispute, lacked standing.
In the same decision the Council of State stated that designating an area as a reserve building area transfers the power to make zoning plans for it directly to the Ministry, and accepted that the action against the designation was subject to appeal on points of law under art. 46 of the Administrative Procedure Law.
Removing the purpose from the definition makes the question of what grounds a designation must rest on more important for judicial review. The search did not reveal a settled line of the Council of State on the standard of review after the amendment; this is this article’s inference, and the decisions below concern individual cases.
Consequences of the Designation for Owners
Suspension of zoning and building procedures. The first concrete consequence for an owner in a reserve building area is that permits and similar zoning procedures may be suspended temporarily.
“The Presidency or, where it carries out the implementation, TOKİ or the Administration may temporarily suspend all zoning and building procedures in risky areas and reserve building areas for a period of two years. Where the implementation so requires, the temporary suspension of zoning and building procedures may be extended for one more year.”
This limit came later. The original text said the suspension would continue “throughout the projects and implementations”. The Constitutional Court annulled that provision as a disproportionate restriction of the right to property because it created an open-ended zoning ban, and the provision was re-enacted by Law No. 6704 as two years plus a one-year extension.
“Accordingly, the zoning ban to be applied under the rule has no foreseeable maximum upper limit on its duration.”
Majority decision and sale of shares. In the stage or block where implementation takes place in a reserve building area, rebuilding, the sale of shares and methods such as flat-for-land are decided by an absolute majority of the co-owners in proportion to their shares. The land share of an owner who does not join the decision is sold by public auction to the agreeing co-owners for not less than its market value. Unlike risky buildings, if the share cannot be sold to the other co-owners, the authority buys it at market value:
“… Where a sale to the co-owners cannot be achieved in this way, those shares are bought by the Presidency, the Administration or TOKİ, which will carry out the transformation project, by paying the market value determined in risky areas and reserve building areas.”
Plans and objections to plans. Under sentences added by Law No. 7471, there is a separate and short objection route against zoning and parcelling plans approved for areas within the scope of the Law:
“Zoning and parcelling plans approved for areas and parcels within the scope of this Law are posted for fifteen days at the relevant provincial directorate of environment, urbanisation and climate change. Objections to these plans are made to the relevant provincial directorate within the posting period and are assessed by the Ministry within five days. If the objections are rejected, the plans become final on the date of the rejection decision without any further approval.”
Expropriation. The Law provides that if no agreement is reached by absolute majority within thirty days of the notification made to the owners of land whose building has been demolished, the Presidency, TOKİ or the Administration may also resort to urgent expropriation (art. 6/2). In the files underlying the Council of State decisions below, urgent expropriation in a reserve building area was carried out by Presidential decision under art. 27 of the Expropriation Law; the Chamber held that art. 6/2 does not prevent this. For the general rules on expropriation see Expropriation and the Owner’s Rights.
The Annulment Action and the Time Limit
A reserve building area designation is a unilateral administrative act of the Ministry. An annulment action may be brought in the administrative courts against it and against zoning plans, sales or expropriation acts based on it; in the decisions below, actions against urgent expropriation decisions taken by Presidential decision were heard at first instance by the Council of State’s 6th Chamber; for the conditions of the action see The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction. There is a special rule on the time limit:
“An action may be brought under the Administrative Procedure Law No. 2577 of 6/1/1982 within thirty days of the date of notification against administrative acts taken under this Law.”
The Constitutional Court did not consider the thirty-day limit a disproportionate restriction of the right of access to a court (decision box below). The period runs “from the date of notification”. A reserve building area designation may not be notified to each owner individually. The rules of the Administrative Procedure Law on publication and knowledge then come into play:
“For regulatory acts that must be published, the time limit for an action starts from the day following the date of publication. However, upon the application of these acts, those concerned may bring an action against the regulatory act or the act applied, or both together.”
The search did not reveal a Council of State decision ruling directly on whether a reserve building area designation is a regulatory or an individual act. It is therefore this article’s inference that the designation should also be challenged in an action against a plan, sale or expropriation act taken in its application. In a case concerning urgent expropriation in a reserve building area carried out by Presidential decision under art. 27 of the Expropriation Law, the Council of State applied the following principle regarding the special time limit in art. 20/A of the Administrative Procedure Law:
“where, although the act is subject to a special time limit, this is not stated in the administrative act, the general sixty-day time limit, and not the special time limit, must be applied from the date of notification of the administrative act in dispute.”
The Chamber based this principle on article 40 of the Constitution; it held that a Presidential urgent expropriation decision published in the Official Gazette does not amount to notification to those concerned, and that, since no proof of notification was submitted, the action brought within sixty days of learning of the decision was in time. The decision does not mention art. 6/9; it concludes that art. 20/A of the Administrative Procedure Law cannot be applied. A Council of State decision applying the thirty-day limit in art. 6/9 to a risky building decision, and dismissing an action brought after it expired, is discussed in Risky Building Designation under Law No. 6306. The thirty days in art. 6/9 should therefore be taken as the basis; whether the sixty-day principle extends to art. 6/9 must be assessed in each case.
Stay of Execution
The original text of the ninth paragraph of art. 6 had a second sentence: no stay of execution could be ordered in these actions. The Constitutional Court annulled that sentence and did not find the thirty-day limit unconstitutional:
“In actions against administrative acts taken under the Law, the thirty-day period starting from notification … does not impose a disproportionate restriction on the right of access to a court. … In that case, it cannot be said that, in creating an exception to ordering a stay of execution for administrative acts taken under the Law, there is an overriding public interest requiring immediate realisation that would justify disregarding the irreparable or impossible-to-remedy harm that a clearly unlawful administrative act would cause to the individuals who are parties to the action until the action is concluded.”
In the current text the annulment note stands in place of the second sentence of the ninth paragraph of art. 6. A stay of execution in an action against a reserve building area designation and acts based on it is therefore requested under the general rule:
“The Council of State or administrative courts may, giving reasons, order a stay of execution after the defendant administration’s defence has been received or the time for the defence has expired, where the conditions that the implementation of the administrative act would cause irreparable or impossible-to-remedy harm and that the administrative act is clearly unlawful are met together.”
Both conditions are required together. Under the same article, bringing an action does not by itself stop the execution of the act; stay orders are, as a rule, given against security, and an objection may be made once within seven days against the order (art. 27/1, 6, 7). Consequences that are hard to reverse, such as demolition, sale or seizure, matter in describing the “irreparable harm” condition concretely.
Reserve Building Areas in Council of State Decisions
In urgent expropriation decisions based on a reserve building area, the Council of State has assessed whether the designation can support the urgency requirement, without separately reviewing the lawfulness of the designation itself. In an action against an urgent expropriation decision taken to move a district in Kocaeli to a reserve area, the 6th Chamber dismissed the action and the Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers upheld that decision:
“rather than the lawfulness of the ‘Reserve Building Area’ declaration, what had to be assessed was whether the declaration of the area where the property in dispute lies as a ‘Reserve Building Area’ constitutes a sufficient basis for the existence of the urgency required for urgent expropriation, … it is clear that declarations concerning a ‘Reserve Building Area’ have the character of a settlement project”
The Plenary upheld the Chamber decision without giving separate reasons; the quoted assessment is the Chamber’s reasoning. The Chamber found that the area lies in a first-degree earthquake zone and that the aim of moving the district to a new settlement area were sufficient for urgency. The Chamber decision of 30.04.2024 on the same area, cited above on the time limit, reached the same result.
The decision was given by majority. The dissent treated review of the designation as a condition of urgent expropriation:
“Therefore, establishing whether the urgency and public interest conditions required for urgent expropriation are met is possible only by reviewing whether the ‘Reserve Building Area’ declaration rests on concrete, technical and scientific data.”
The dissent stressed that the file contained no technical report showing that the buildings in the area carried disaster risk, and no risky area decision or risky building designation. The majority did not adopt this view. Accordingly, for an owner challenging an urgent expropriation decision in a reserve building area, having also brought a separate action against the designation may matter for the review of technical deficiencies in it; this is this article’s inference. For the effect of annulling an urgent expropriation decision on the price determination and registration action, see Annulment of an Urgent Expropriation Decision.
Practical Points
- Record the date of the designation and when and how it was notified to you or how you learned of it. The statutory limit is thirty days from notification; plan to bring the action within that period. The Council of State decision applying sixty days concerned the art. 20/A limit of the Administrative Procedure Law for an urgent expropriation by Presidential decision.
- When a zoning plan, sale or expropriation act based on the designation arrives, consider whether to challenge the designation as well. In urgent expropriation actions the Council of State did not separately review the lawfulness of the designation.
- Zoning and parcelling plans under the Law are posted for fifteen days at the provincial directorate; objections are made to the directorate within that period.
- The suspension of zoning and building procedures lasts two years, at most three years with the extension (art. 4/1). Monitor when it starts and any extension decision.
- When requesting a stay of execution, explain concretely and together both that the act is clearly unlawful and the irreparable harm its implementation would cause.
- Standing may be disputed: in the Council of State decision above, two members considered that a claimant with no adjoining parcel lacked standing. If you are not an owner, show your interest in the designation clearly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the time limit for an action against a reserve building area designation in Türkiye?
Under Turkish law, an action may be brought in the administrative courts within thirty days of notification against administrative acts taken under Law No. 6306 (art. 6/9). In a decision given by majority, which may not be final, on an urgent expropriation decision taken by Presidential decision, the Council of State’s 6th Chamber applied the general sixty-day limit because the special time limit under art. 20/A of the Administrative Procedure Law had not been stated in the act; it did not address the thirty-day limit in art. 6/9. When the period starts depends in each case on notification, publication or the date of knowledge.
Can a stay of execution be requested in an action against a reserve building area designation in Türkiye?
Yes. The original text of Law No. 6306 barred a stay of execution in actions brought under it; the Constitutional Court annulled that sentence by its 2014 decision E.2012/87, K.2014/41. Today, as a rule, a stay may be ordered under art. 27 of the Administrative Procedure Law where the act is clearly unlawful and its implementation would cause irreparable or impossible-to-remedy harm, both conditions being met together.
What did Law No. 7471 change in the definition of a reserve building area under Law No. 6306?
Law No. 7471 of 7/11/2023 removed the words “as a new settlement area” from the definition. Under Turkish law as now worded, a reserve building area is an area designated by the Ministry, at the request of TOKİ or the Administration or of its own motion, for use in implementations carried out under the Law (art. 2/1-c). In a decision recording this amendment, the Council of State’s 6th Chamber found lawful the designation of an empty parcel declared at the co-owners’ request.
For how long can zoning and building procedures be suspended on property designated a reserve building area in Türkiye?
Under art. 4/1 of Law No. 6306, the Presidency or, where it carries out the implementation, TOKİ or the Administration may temporarily suspend zoning and building procedures in reserve building areas for two years; where the implementation requires, this may be extended by one more year. The original text had no time limit; the Constitutional Court annulled the open-ended zoning ban as contrary to the right to property, and the provision was later re-enacted with these periods.
Can urgent expropriation be carried out in a reserve building area under Turkish law?
According to the 6th Chamber reasoning upheld by the Council of State’s Plenary Session of the Administrative Law Chambers, declarations concerning a reserve building area have the character of a settlement project, and urgency exists provided the other expropriation requirements are met. The decision was given by majority; the dissent argued that whether the designation rests on concrete, technical and scientific data must also be reviewed. The outcome may differ in each case depending on the reasons for the act and the documents in the file.
Related Articles
- Risky Building Designation under Law No. 6306 in Türkiye: Owners' Rights, Agreement and Legal Remedies
- The Annulment Action in Administrative Jurisdiction
- Expropriation and the Owner’s Rights
This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.
Author: Urban regeneration attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Urban Regeneration & Construction Law
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Reserve Building Area Designation Annulment (Law No. 6306): Time Limit and Stay of Execution in Türkiye”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-15, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/reserve-building-area-annulment-law-6306-turkiye

























