Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 12 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Good-Faith Buyers from the Contractor Keep Their Title: Turkish Court of Cassation on Flat-for-Land Deals

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under the Turkish Civil Code, the acquisition of a third party who, relying in good faith on the land register, buys an independent unit from the contractor to whom the title was transferred is protected. This applies in a build-for-land-share construction contract (arsa payı karşılığı inşaat sözleşmesi) under Civil Code art. 1023; the outcome does not change even if the contract is later terminated retroactively. In its decision of 23.02.2026, the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay 6. Hukuk Dairesi), stating that it had departed from its earlier case-law through the unification of case-law, treated the buyer’s good faith as presumed: unless the landowner proves that, at the moment of acquisition, the buyer knew or should have known that the transfer was made under the construction contract, he cannot have the title annulled. The judgment annulling title was reversed unanimously.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation held that a third party who, relying on the land register, buys an independent unit from the contractor in a build-for-land-share project is presumed to be in good faith and protected by Civil Code art. 1023, and that the landowner may obtain annulment of title only by proving that the buyer knew or should have known that the transfer was made under the contract; it unanimously reversed the judgment annulling the buyers’ titles.

Under Turkish law, the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that the good faith of a person who, relying on the land register, buys an independent unit from the contractor in a build-for-land-share project is presumed, and that the landowner must prove bad faith.

The Dispute

In 1993 the plaintiff landowner concluded a build-for-land-share construction contract with the defendant contractor and transferred the title to the land to the contractor. The building was constructed contrary to the project and the municipality had issued a demolition order for it; according to the plaintiff, no occupancy permit could be obtained either. The plaintiff sought annulment of the land register entries created in the defendants’ names following the establishment of construction servitudes (kat irtifakı) and re-registration in his name in proportion to his land share, as well as compensation. The persons who had bought independent units from the contractor were also joined to the case; they argued that they were in good faith under Civil Code art. 1023, that the contract had not been annotated in the land register and that the register carried no annotation preventing the sale.

In 2014 the first-instance court ordered annulment of title and re-registration. In 2019 the (now closed) 23rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed that judgment so that it could be investigated whether the deviations from the project could be remedied under the zoning amnesty. Complying with the reversal, the court found the building registration certificate insufficient and stated that registration in the names of those who had bought from an unlicensed building would not be lawful; it again ordered annulment of title and re-registration and dismissed the claim for compensation. Both sides appealed directly to the Court of Cassation; on the plaintiff’s side were the landowner’s heirs.

Outcome of the Decision

On 23.02.2026, after a hearing, the 6th Civil Chamber unanimously reversed the judgment in favour of the defendants; the parties’ other grounds of appeal (such as limitation and compensation) were not examined for the time being. The local court will give the landowner’s heirs a reasonable time to prove that, at the moment they took over ownership, the appealing defendants knew or should have known that the title had been transferred to the contractor under the construction contract, and will decide according to the outcome. The decision was given subject to rectification of decision (karar düzeltme), which could be requested within 15 days of service.

Reasoning

The Chamber stated that, by the decision Grand General Assembly for the Unification of Case-Law of the Court of Cassation, E. 2024/1, K. 2025/2, 16.05.2025, published in the Official Gazette of 18.07.2025, it had departed from its earlier case-law, which on retroactive termination did not hear the good-faith claims of third parties who had bought from the contractor or in whose favour a mortgage had been established. That decision, given unanimously, held that, where the contract is terminated retroactively or found invalid, third parties’ claims of good faith are to be heard and their acquisitions protected, “but that, where it is understood in the concrete case that the third parties were not in good faith, the immovables may return to the landowner”. The Chamber explained the binding effect of that decision as follows:

Court of Cassation Decision
6th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/2714, K. 2026/655, 23.02.2026 (binding effect of the decision on the unification of case-law)

“…under Article 45(5) of the Law on the Court of Cassation, decisions on the unification of case-law bind the General Assemblies of the Court of Cassation, its chambers and the courts of justice on similar legal issues. Even if there was a reversal decision to the contrary before the unification of case-law, it must be applied as an exception to procedural acquired rights.”

The Chamber applied the principle of reliance on the land register to build-for-land-share construction as follows:

Court of Cassation Decision
6th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/2714, K. 2026/655, 23.02.2026 (buyer in good faith and retroactive termination)

“Under Articles 3 and 1023 of the TMK, if the third party who takes over a land share or an independent unit from the contractor is in good faith, the transfer must be accepted as valid even if the registration made in the contractor’s name was wrongful from the outset or later became wrongful through retroactive termination. For if the principle of reliance on the land register is not protected, the security of legal transactions, and therefore the principle of legal certainty, one of the most fundamental principles of law, will also be violated.”

Also stating that the title transferred to the contractor cannot be characterised as an “advance title”, the Chamber did not treat the transfer, up to the landowner’s withdrawal from the contract, as a wrongful registration:

Court of Cassation Decision
6th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/2714, K. 2026/655, 23.02.2026 (nature of the transfer to the contractor)

“The landowner’s transfer of the title to the contractor cannot be regarded as a wrongful registration either. … Even if the landowner later withdraws from the contract, he will have no right to claim annulment of title and re-registration, on the ground of ‘wrongful registration’, from a third party who acquired a right in rem from the contractor in good faith.”

It drew the limit of the rule as follows:

Court of Cassation Decision

“For the reasons explained, the acquisition of a third party in good faith who, relying on the land register, buys a land share or an independent unit from the contractor, or in whose favour a mortgage is established, must be protected under Article 1023 of the TMK. However, if the landowner proves, under Article 3(2) of the TMK, that at the moment the third party bought the immovable or the mortgage was established in his favour, he knew or should have known ‘that the title had been transferred to the contractor under the build-for-land-share contract’, the landowner’s claim for annulment of title and re-registration may be allowed.”

Significance and Practical Effect

According to the Chamber, on retroactive termination the parties may reclaim what they have given under the rules on unjust enrichment, whereas the transfer to a buyer in good faith remains valid. The general conditions of the protection under Civil Code art. 1023, the circumstantial presumptions of bad faith and the effect of land register annotations are explained in the article Good-Faith Third Parties in Actions for Annulment of Title and Re-Registration.

In practice, the burden of proof is decisive: the buyer’s good faith is presumed and the landowner must prove bad faith with concrete evidence and facts. Since at one point in its reasoning the Chamber also refers to the buyer knowing that the contract could be terminated retroactively if the contractor failed to perform, what has to be proved should be identified carefully in each case.

According to the reasoning of the decision on the unification of case-law, the landowner can defeat third parties’ claims of good faith by having it annotated in the declarations section of the land register that the transfer was made under the contract. The same test was adopted unanimously by the Court of Cassation in Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/248, K. 2026/388, 18.06.2026: the Assembly stated that the acquisition of a third party in good faith who buys an independent unit from the contractor is protected and that this principle may be departed from only if the buyer’s bad faith is proven. Among the decisions of the 6th Civil Chamber (up to 01.07.2026) and the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation given after the date of this decision and reached in the search, none changes this test.

Even where the transfer appears in the land register as a sale, the buyers’ good faith must be examined; the landowner must produce evidence of bad faith

Court of Cassation, Assembly of Civil Chambers (the Assembly’s reasoning)

“…it is understood that the share transfer made by the claimant was carried out because of the construction contract in return for land share. … it must be examined whether those defendants had, at the moment they acquired ownership in the land register, the good faith to be protected within the meaning of Article 1023 of the Civil Code; in other words, the claimant landowner must be asked to submit its evidence proving that they were in bad faith at the time the shares were registered…” (unofficial translation)

In the case, the landowner company had transferred its share in a co-owned plot to the contractor by way of a “sale” in an official deed stating a price; the contractor soon sold the share on to other persons and never started construction. Relying on a construction contract in ordinary written form, the landowner sought retroactive termination and annulment of the buyers’ titles. The first-instance court dismissed the action, holding that a contract with the claimant had not been proved and that the buyers were in good faith. The 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation reversed by majority, holding that the contractual relationship had been proved, that the transfer was an advance and that, since the contractor had not performed, the buyers could not benefit from the protection of art. 1023 of the Civil Code; the court insisted. Assessing together the co-ownership title record, an accountant expert’s report showing that no payment had been made to the claimant, and the testimony of the contractor’s spouse, the Assembly accepted that the transfer was in reality made under the construction contract and not as a sale. As to the buyers, however, departing from the Chamber and also referring to the Grand General Assembly’s unification decision E. 2024/1, K. 2025/2, it held that their good faith at the time of registration must be examined and that the landowner must be asked for evidence to prove bad faith. The insistence judgment was reversed unanimously on different grounds. The decision does not determine whether the buyers will ultimately be protected; that is left to the first-instance court’s examination.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 1023 (As against good-faith third parties) (unofficial translation)

“The acquisition of a third party who acquires ownership or another right in rem relying in good faith on a registration in the land register is protected.”

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 3 (Good faith) (unofficial translation)

“Where the law attaches a legal consequence to good faith, the existence of good faith is presumed.

However, a person who has failed to exercise the care required of him by the circumstances cannot claim good faith.”

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the title of a flat bought from the contractor be annulled?

In an action by the landowner, as a rule, no; the acquisition of a person in good faith who, relying on the land register, buys an independent unit from the contractor is protected by Civil Code art. 1023. According to the Chamber, if the landowner proves that the buyer knew or should have known that the transfer was made under the construction contract, annulment of title may be allowed.

Does the buyer lose the title if the contract is terminated retroactively?

According to the Chamber, no; even if the termination makes the registration in the contractor’s name wrongful, the transfer to the person in good faith remains valid.

Who must prove the buyer’s good faith?

Good faith is presumed (Civil Code art. 3(1)); the landowner must prove bad faith. A person who has not exercised the care required cannot claim good faith (Civil Code art. 3(2)).

Is the title given to the contractor an “advance title”?

According to the Chamber, no; the concept has no place in the Turkish law of property, and a transfer of title cannot be made conditional.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Real Estate Law

All Real Estate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Good-Faith Buyers from the Contractor Keep Their Title: Turkish Court of Cassation on Flat-for-Land Deals”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-19, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/title-annulment-flat-bought-from-contractor-good-faith

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›