Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · 24 min read

Last reviewed:

Good-Faith Third Parties in Title Annulment Actions: Turkish Civil Code Art. 1023, Bad Faith, Annotations

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, even if a land register entry is wrongful, a third party who acquires ownership or another right in rem such as a mortgage relying in good faith on that entry is protected (Civil Code art. 1023); a person who knew or should have known of the irregularity cannot rely on the registration (art. 1024). Because good faith is presumed, the claimant must prove the third party’s bad faith; but according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation, the law protects the person who is genuinely, not merely apparently, in good faith. Frequent changes of hands at short intervals, a price far below market value, a close relationship between the parties and buying the property without seeing it are treated as circumstantial presumptions of bad faith. A person who acquires a right while a “subject of litigation” (davalıdır) or interim-injunction annotation is on the register cannot claim not to have known of it. If the chain of bad faith was broken at an earlier transfer, the last owner may be protected as well.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, the protection under Civil Code art. 1023, in an action for annulment of title, of a third party who acquired a property or a mortgage relying on a wrongful registration: the presumption of good faith and the duty of care, circumstantial presumptions of bad faith, the effect of litigation, interim-injunction and attachment annotations, the chain of bad faith, sale during the proceedings and compensation, with 2026 decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.

Under Turkish law, the protection under Turkish Civil Code art. 1023, in an action for annulment of title and re-registration, of a third party who acquired a property or a mortgage relying on a wrongful registration: the presumption of good faith and the duty of care, circumstantial presumptions of bad faith, the effect of litigation, interim-injunction and attachment annotations in the land register, the chain of bad faith, sale during the proceedings and compensation; with 2026 decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation.

Who Is a Good-Faith Third Party? The Principle of Reliance on the Land Register

Under Turkish law, ownership of immovable property is, as a rule, acquired by registration in the land register, and the registration must rest on a valid legal ground (such as sale, gift, inheritance or a court judgment). A registration lacking a legal ground is wrongful; the person whose right is impaired may bring an action for annulment of title and re-registration (tapu iptali ve tescil). The general framework of that action is explained in a separate article: Action for Annulment of Title and Re-Registration. This article focuses on the most disputed question in that action: when is a third party who bought the property, or had a mortgage established on it, relying on a wrongful entry protected?

The law answers this question with the principle of reliance on the land register. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the land register is an official register whose content is presumed correct under Civil Code art. 7; since the State keeps the register open to the public and has assumed liability for failing to keep it accurately, it must protect the good faith of a person who acquires property relying on the register (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/473, K. 2026/221, 08.04.2026).

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 1023 (As against good-faith third parties) (unofficial translation)

“The acquisition of a third party who acquires ownership or another right in rem relying in good faith on a registration in the land register is protected.”

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 1024 (As against third parties not in good faith) (unofficial translation)

“Where a right in rem has been registered wrongfully, a third party who knows or should know this cannot rely on that registration.

A registration based on a non-binding legal transaction or lacking a legal ground is wrongful.

A person whose right in rem is impaired by such a registration may invoke the wrongfulness of the registration directly against third parties who are not in good faith.”

Wrongfulness can have many sources. The Assembly of Civil Chambers treats wrongful registration as an umbrella concept and gives as examples the absence of capacity to act or of the power of disposition, formal defects and defects of consent in the transaction, a forged power of attorney or acting beyond the authority granted in a power of attorney, multiple title records for the same property, and intentional conduct or errors of land registry and cadastre officials (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/50, K. 2026/378, 18.06.2026). In the same decision, when the municipal council resolution on which the sale by tender of a municipal property was based was annulled by the administrative court, the registration in the buyer’s name was also held to be wrongful.

The yardstick of protection is the general good-faith provision, Civil Code art. 3.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 3 (Good faith) (unofficial translation)

“Where the law attaches a legal consequence to good faith, the existence of good faith is presumed.

However, a person who has failed to exercise the care required of him by the circumstances cannot claim good faith.”

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/473, K. 2026/221, 08.04.2026 (the Assembly’s explanation of Civil Code art. 1023)

“Under this article, the acquisition of a person who believes that the person named in the land register is the true right holder, or who, despite exercising all the care expected of him, could not have known that that person was not the true owner and that there was an irregularity in the land register, is protected.”

Conditions of Protection

There must be a wrongful registration. If the registration is not wrongful, there is no entry to annul; if it is, the dispute shifts to the good faith of the person who acquired a right relying on the entry.

The third party must have acquired a right in rem relying on the entry. Civil Code art. 1023 protects not only the acquirer of ownership but also the acquirer of “another right in rem”. The Assembly of Civil Chambers assessed under this provision, and protected, a bank that lent to the company registered as owner under a wrongful entry and had a mortgage established on the property (E. 2025/473, K. 2026/221). The position of the first-hand acquirer who obtained the property directly through the wrongful transaction is different: the article Action for Annulment of Title and Re-Registration explains, with a decision of the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, that in a transfer made with a forged power of attorney or forged identity the first-hand acquirer’s plea of good faith is not heard, whereas a later owner in good faith may be protected.

Good faith must exist at the time the right is acquired. The Assembly of Civil Chambers assessed the bank’s good faith by reference to the fact that, on the day the mortgage was established, the former owner (the claimant) had not yet been placed under guardianship and there was no interim-injunction annotation on the register (E. 2025/473, K. 2026/221).

Payment of the price does not by itself decide the matter. According to the Assembly, whether the price was paid does not by itself show whether the protection applies; what is decisive is whether the acquirer knew of the situation or could have known of it had he exercised the care expected of him (E. 2025/50, K. 2026/378).

Family home. Wrongfulness may also arise from the transfer of the family home without the other spouse’s express consent (Civil Code art. 194). According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, the family-home annotation is declaratory; even without an annotation in the register the dwelling retains its character as the family home, and whether the subsequent buyer is protected is decided under Civil Code art. 1023 (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/373, K. 2026/257, 15.04.2026).

Build-for-land-share construction. Where a contract for construction in return for land shares (arsa payı karşılığı inşaat) was found invalid or terminated retroactively, the 6th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation did not hear the plea of good faith of a third party who had bought a land share or an independent unit from the contractor to whom the title had been transferred, or in whose favour a mortgage had been established. By the decision Grand General Assembly for the Unification of Case-Law of the Court of Cassation, E. 2024/1, K. 2025/2, 16.05.2025 (Official Gazette 18.07.2025), that case-law was unanimously departed from: unless bad faith is proven, the ownership or mortgage acquired is protected, “but that, where it is understood in the concrete case that the third parties were not in good faith, the immovables may return to the landowner” (for its application, see Good-Faith Buyers from the Contractor Keep Their Title: Turkish Court of Cassation on Build-for-Land-Share Contracts and Proof of Bad Faith).

How Is Good Faith Assessed? Circumstantial Presumptions

The presumption of good faith protects the acquirer; but since the true owner’s right is sacrificed for the sake of protecting peace and confidence and maintaining public order, the Assembly of Civil Chambers does not accept a superficial and formalistic examination. In the Assembly’s words, the legislator intends to protect “not the person who at first sight appears formally to be in good faith, but the person who is genuinely in good faith”; all the evidence must therefore be gathered and assessed in depth (E. 2025/373, K. 2026/257).

Because bad faith is often hard to prove directly, the claimant may rely on circumstantial presumptions. The facts that stand out in the decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers are:

  • the property changing hands at very short intervals, or being sold at a price far below its market value;
  • kinship, a business relationship or a close social relationship between seller and buyer;
  • buying, without seeing it, a property said to be bought to meet a housing need;
  • buying the property together with the substantial mortgage on it;
  • failure to produce record-based evidence that the price was paid;
  • the event causing the irregularity having been reported, before the transfers, in the local press of the district where the property is located, while the acquirers lived in the same area and owned property there.

These facts are assessed together; none of them is conclusive on its own. An unreasoned, abstract allegation of wrongfulness does not rebut the presumption (E. 2025/373, K. 2026/257); if no evidence of bad faith is produced, the acquirer is protected (E. 2025/473, K. 2026/221). The weight of a local press report is, however, disputed: the dissenting opinions in decision 2026/378 argued that a local newspaper report in a district of more than one hundred thousand inhabitants cannot be assumed to be known to everyone.

Effect of Annotations in the Land Register: Litigation, Interim Injunction and Attachment

The effect of annotations rests on the following two provisions:

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 1020 (Publicity of the land register) (unofficial translation)

“The land register is open to the public.

… No one may claim not to know an entry in the land register.”

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 1010 (Restriction of the power of disposition) (unofficial translation)

“Restrictions on the power of disposition based on the following grounds may be annotated in the land register:

… Court orders for the protection of disputed rights,

… Attachment, a bankruptcy order or the period granted with a composition,

… Once annotated, restrictions on the power of disposition may be invoked against the holders of rights subsequently acquired in the immovable.”

The “subject of litigation” annotation. A last owner who buys the property after the action is filed despite the “davalıdır” (subject of litigation) annotation in the register cannot benefit from the protection of Civil Code art. 1023 (E. 2025/50, K. 2026/378).

Interim injunction and attachment. In decision 2026/221, the property of an owner lacking capacity had been sold to a company, and eight days after the sale a mortgage was established in favour of the bank that lent to the company. The order placing the owner under guardianship and the interim-injunction annotation in the annulment action came after the mortgage; two attachments placed in favour of the company’s creditors came later still. The Assembly protected the mortgage, which had been established before the annotation and in respect of which the bank’s bad faith had not been proven, and upheld the removal of the attachment annotations placed after the injunction. As the file contained no attachment placed before the injunction, the fate of such an attachment was not addressed in the decision.

Intermediate Owners and the Chain of Bad Faith

Where the property has changed hands several times, each acquisition is assessed separately. According to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, where the chain of bad faith is broken the last owner may be protected regardless of whether he himself was in good faith; whether the chain is broken depends on whether the intermediate owners can benefit from the protection of Civil Code art. 1023 (E. 2025/50, K. 2026/378).

In that case a municipal plot had been sold on the basis of a council resolution that was later annulled, then passed through three intermediate owners and was transferred to the last owner during the proceedings. The 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation first accepted that the intermediate owners’ bad faith had not been proven, then reversed in favour of annulment of title, stating that this assessment rested on a material error. The Assembly of Civil Chambers adopted the latter reversal: in view of the transfers made at short intervals and below market value, the use of a commercial loan, the absence of any record that the price was paid, and the annulment of the council resolution having been reported in the local press before the transfers, it held that the intermediate owners could not be regarded as being in good faith and that the chain had not been broken. The decision was taken by majority; three dissenting opinions argued that the burden of proof lay on the claimant and that the intermediate owners’ bad faith had not been proven.

Procedure: Burden of Proof, Sale During the Proceedings and Compensation

Burden of proof. Since Civil Code art. 1023 is a case in which the law attaches a consequence to good faith, good faith is presumed and the claimant must prove that the acquirer was not in good faith (E. 2025/473, K. 2026/221). Relying on two decisions on the unification of case law from 1951 and 1991, the Assembly of Civil Chambers also explains the nature of the allegation of bad faith: “There is no doubt that the allegation of bad faith is not a defence [def’i] but an objection [itiraz], that it may be raised at any time without being subject to the prohibition on expanding claims and defences, and that it is taken into account by the court of its own motion.” (E. 2025/50, K. 2026/378).

Proper defendant, court and time limits. Against whom the action is brought, the competent court and the time limits follow the rules of the general annulment-of-title action; details are in the article Action for Annulment of Title and Re-Registration.

Sale during the proceedings. Unless there is a restriction such as an interim injunction, the property may be sold after the action is filed; the claimant’s options are set out in Code of Civil Procedure art. 125.

Statutory Provision — Code of Civil Procedure (Law No. 6100) art. 125/1 (Transfer of the subject matter of the action) (unofficial translation)

“(1) If, after the action is filed, the defendant transfers the subject matter of the action to a third person, the claimant may exercise one of the following powers:

a) If he wishes, he withdraws his action against the transferor and continues the action against the person who acquired the subject matter. …

b) If he wishes, he converts his action into an action for compensation against the transferor.”

As recounted in the decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers, in the case leading to decision 2026/378 the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation stated that the claimant had to be reminded of this option; the claimant continued the action against the new owner.

Compensation. If the good-faith third party is protected, the true owner cannot recover the property from him; but the law preserves claims for compensation.

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 1025 (In the case of wrongful registration) (unofficial translation)

“Where a right in rem has been registered wrongfully, or a registration has been wrongfully cancelled or altered, the person whose right in rem is thereby impaired may sue for rectification of the land register.

Rights in rem acquired by good-faith third parties relying on that registration, and all claims for compensation, are reserved.”

The State’s liability arising from keeping the land register is regulated separately in Civil Code art. 1007; that is a separate topic, covered in the article State Pays for Land Lost to a Forged Power of Attorney: Turkish Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers on Civil Code Art. 1007.

Decisions of the Assembly of Civil Chambers

A buyer who purchased the family home without seeing it and with a substantial mortgage was not in good faith

The defendant spouse had transferred the family home, without the other spouse’s express consent, to the company of the claimant’s elder brother, and about a year and a half later the company sold it to the last owner, who had a close, kinship-based relationship with the company’s representative. The regional court of appeal accepted that the last owner was in good faith and persisted in its decision against the reversal of the 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation. Assessing together the close relationship and the purchase of the property without seeing it and with a substantial mortgage, the Assembly of Civil Chambers concluded that the last owner knew or should have known of the wrongful registration; the judgment of persistence was reversed unanimously.

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/373, K. 2026/257, 15.04.2026 (the Assembly’s reasoning; the judgment of persistence was reversed unanimously)

“Accordingly, a person who fails to see a fact that anyone could know with the care a reasonable person would exercise, and who acts negligently by disregarding a circumstance that would arouse the suspicion of a prudent person, cannot be regarded as being in good faith. As noted and adopted in Court of Cassation decisions, the purchase, without visiting and seeing it and together with the substantial mortgage existing on it, of a property allegedly bought to meet a housing need must be regarded as suspicious conduct and treated as a circumstance giving rise to doubt with respect to the defendant. Indeed, although an unreasoned, abstract allegation that the entries in the land register are wrongful does not rebut the presumption of good faith, it cannot be said that a person relying on the presumption of good faith has fulfilled the duty of care without carrying out a serious inquiry leaving no room for doubt.”

A mortgage established before the injunction annotation was protected; later attachments were removed

After the title record was annulled for lack of capacity, the owner sought the removal of the mortgage and attachment annotations placed during the period of the previous record (facts in the annotations section). The 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation took the view that all annotations after a transfer void ab initio had to be removed; the regional court of appeal persisted as regards the bank’s mortgage, and the Assembly of Civil Chambers upheld the judgment of persistence.

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/473, K. 2026/221, 08.04.2026 (the Assembly’s assessment of the case; the judgment of persistence was upheld by majority)

“Good faith is the rule, and the defendant bank, which had the mortgage established relying on the entry in the land register, must be accepted as a good-faith third party unless the contrary is proven. Since the claimant has not submitted any evidence capable of proving that the defendant bank acted in bad faith, the claim for removal of the annotation must be dismissed.”

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision

“The land register is public; it cannot be assumed that the person concerned did not know of the annotations in the declarations section of the title record, and the person is deemed to have acquired the property subject to the obligations in the declarations section of the title record. After the annotation, there is no need to prove that the third party knew of the restrictions on the power of disposition, and under art. 1020 of the Turkish Civil Code the third party cannot claim not to have known of the annotation in the land register.”

The decision was taken by majority at the second deliberation. The view put forward during the deliberations and in the single dissenting opinion, that Civil Code art. 1023 does not apply to registrations void from the outset and that they confer no right on the holder of an annotation either, was not adopted by the majority of the Assembly.

A last owner who bought with the “subject of litigation” annotation was not protected because the chain of bad faith had not been broken

The facts are summarised in the section on the chain of bad faith. The Assembly of Civil Chambers first held that compliance with the Chamber’s earlier reversal protecting the intermediate owners did not create a procedural vested right because of a material error, and then that the intermediate owners were not in good faith; the judgment of persistence was reversed by majority on both issues.

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/50, K. 2026/378, 18.06.2026 (the Assembly’s statement of the issues)

“At this stage, another point not in dispute is that the last registered owner, the joined defendant ..., who bought the property in dispute on 16.05.2018, after the action had been filed, with the ‘‘davalıdır’’ [subject of litigation] annotation in the title record, cannot benefit from the protection of art. 1023 of the Turkish Civil Code. … As is known, where the chain of bad faith is broken, the acquisition of ownership may be protected regardless of whether the last registered owner is a good-faith acquirer.”

Court of Cassation Assembly of Civil Chambers Decision
Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/50, K. 2026/378, 18.06.2026 (the Assembly’s conclusion; there are three dissenting opinions)

“… it has been concluded that the defendants ..., ... and ... were in the position of persons who knew or should have known of the wrongful registration under art. 1024 of Law No. 4721, that the chain of bad faith continued and that they cannot benefit from the protection of art. 1023 of the same Law.”

Practical Points

  • Before buying or taking a mortgage, the declarations and annotations sections of the title record should be examined (Civil Code art. 1020).
  • The property should be seen on site and its occupier identified; buying without seeing it has been treated as suspicious.
  • The price should be paid through a bank and documented.
  • For the true owner, having an interim-injunction or “subject of litigation” annotation entered in the register matters.
  • Although the allegation of bad faith is not subject to the prohibition on expanding claims and defences, evidence such as witnesses, correspondence, bank and civil-registry records should be put forward from the outset; one of the dissenting opinions in decision 2026/378 also relied on the claimant’s failure to name witnesses or submit evidence.
  • Note of caution: the view that Civil Code art. 1023 does not apply to entries based on a registration void from the outset was not adopted by the majority in decision 2026/221, but was defended in the dissent.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a good-faith third party protected in an action for annulment of title?

Yes. Under Turkish law, a third party who acquires ownership or another right in rem such as a mortgage relying in good faith on a wrongful registration is protected (Civil Code art. 1023). A person who knew or should have known of the irregularity is not protected (art. 1024).

Who must prove that the third party acted in bad faith?

Because good faith is presumed, the claimant must prove bad faith, relying on circumstantial presumptions such as frequent changes of hands, a sale far below market value, a close relationship between the parties or buying without seeing the property. The allegation of bad faith is an objection and is taken into account by the court of its own motion.

Is a person who buys while a “subject of litigation” (davalıdır) annotation is on the register in good faith?

No. No one may claim not to know an entry in the land register. The Assembly of Civil Chambers accepted as undisputed that a last owner who bought the property with the “subject of litigation” annotation after the action had been filed cannot benefit from the protection of Civil Code art. 1023.

What happens if the property is sold while the annulment action is pending?

Under Code of Civil Procedure art. 125, the claimant may either continue the action against the transferee or convert it into a compensation action against the transferor. Whether the transferee is protected depends, as a rule, on his good faith, in particular on whether an annotation was on the register; however, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, if the chain of bad faith was broken at an earlier transfer, the last owner’s acquisition may still be protected.

Does a bank’s mortgage survive the annulment of title?

The Assembly of Civil Chambers protected a bank mortgage that had been established before the interim-injunction annotation and in respect of which the bank’s bad faith had not been proven, and upheld the removal of the attachment annotations placed after the injunction annotation. The outcome depends on the date of the annotation and the creditor’s good faith.

What can the true owner do if the property stays with a good-faith acquirer?

Civil Code art. 1025 protects the rights of the good-faith third party while reserving all claims for compensation. If the property was transferred while the action was pending, the action may be converted into a compensation action against the transferor under Code of Civil Procedure art. 125/1-b; the State’s liability arising from the land register is regulated separately in Civil Code art. 1007.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Real Estate Law

All Real Estate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Good-Faith Third Parties in Title Annulment Actions: Turkish Civil Code Art. 1023, Bad Faith, Annotations”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-07, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/good-faith-third-party-annulment-of-title-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›