Last reviewed:
Decedent's Simulated Transactions (Muris Muvazaasi): Title Annulment in Turkish Court of Cassation Case-Law
Speech is produced by your browser’s own speech engine.
Short answer: Under Turkish law, muris muvazaasi occurs where a decedent, in order to deprive his or her heirs of their inheritance, transfers registered real property that is in truth a gift while disguising it at the land registry as a sale or a care-until-death contract. Under the Court of Cassation’s Unification of Case-Law Decision No. 1/2 of 01.04.1974, the apparent transaction is invalid because of the simulation and the hidden gift is invalid for lack of the official form; every heir whose inheritance rights are infringed, whether or not holding a reserved share, may bring an action for annulment of title and registration after the decedent’s death. According to the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, this action is not subject to any limitation or forfeiture period; the heirs may prove the simulation by any evidence, including witnesses. If the transfer was made not to conceal assets from the heirs but, for example, against a genuine debt, a price or care, the action is dismissed; property never registered in the decedent’s name and transfers of cooperative shares also fall outside the Unification Decision.
This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.
Muris muvazaasi (concealing assets from heirs) occurs where a decedent transfers real property that is in truth a gift, disguising it as a sale or a care-until-death contract. This article explains the requirements of the action, the evidentiary criteria, the no-limitation rule and the leading precedents of the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation under Article 19 of the Turkish Code of Obligations and the Unification of Case-Law Decision No. 1/2 of 01.04.1974, together with case-duration observations derived from the reviewed decisions.
What is muris muvazaasi (a decedent's simulated transaction to deprive heirs); requirements of the action for annulment of title, the scope of the Unification of Case-Law Decision No. 1/2 of 01.04.1974 and its exclusions, standing, competent court, the no-limitation rule, evidentiary criteria, the leading precedents of the 1st Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, and case-duration observations derived from the decisions.
What Is a Decedent's Simulated Transaction?
Muris muvazaasi — in everyday usage, concealing assets from heirs — occurs where a decedent, in order to deprive his or her heirs of their inheritance rights, transfers registered real property that is in truth a gift while disguising it at the land registry as a sale or a care-until-death contract. In the settled characterisation of the Court of Cassation this is a relative (qualified) simulation: the decedent genuinely intends a transfer, but conceals its true nature.
Two transactions are intertwined: the apparent transaction (sale or care contract) is invalid because it does not reflect the parties' true intent, while the hidden transaction (gift) is invalid for lack of the official form required for registered land. The resulting registration is therefore an unlawful registration, and heirs whose inheritance rights are infringed may sue for annulment of the title deed and registration in their names.
Legal Basis: TCO Art. 19, TCC Art. 706 and the 1974 Unification Decision
The statutory bases are Article 19 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 (simulation) and Article 706 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 (official form for transfers of immovables). The case-law basis is the Unification of Case-Law Decision No. 1/2 of 01.04.1974 of the Grand General Assembly of the Court of Cassation, cited verbatim in the verified chamber decisions quoted below.
“In determining and interpreting the type and content of a contract, the true and common intent of the parties shall be taken as basis, without regard to the words they used mistakenly or to conceal their true purpose.”
“The validity of contracts aimed at the transfer of ownership of immovable property is subject to their execution in official form.”
Since a registration resting on a simulated transfer lacks a valid legal ground, the claim for correction of the land register rests on Articles 1024 and 1025 of the Civil Code:
“Where a real right has been registered unlawfully, a third party who knows or ought to know of this may not rely on the registration. A registration based on a non-binding legal transaction or lacking a legal ground is unlawful. A person whose real right is impaired by such a registration may invoke its unlawfulness directly against third parties acting in bad faith.”
“Where a real right has been registered unlawfully, or a registration has been unlawfully deleted or altered, the person whose real right is impaired thereby may bring an action for correction of the land register. Real rights acquired by third parties in good faith in reliance on the registration, and all claims for damages, are reserved.”
Requirements and Elements
1. The apparent transaction
The decedent has executed an official transfer at the land registry, most commonly appearing as a sale or a care-until-death contract. This apparent transaction is invalid because it does not match the parties' true intent.
2. The simulation agreement
There is an express or implied understanding between the decedent and the transferee that the apparent transaction shall not take effect; the transferee knows the transfer is in truth a gift.
3. The hidden transaction (gift) and its formal defect
The transaction actually intended is a gift. As gifts of registered land are themselves subject to official form, the gift hidden inside a deed of sale fails the form requirements of TCC Art. 706, TCO Art. 237 and Art. 26 of the Land Registry Law, and is invalid.
4. Intent to deprive heirs
This is the pivotal element. The 1974 Unification Decision applies only where the decedent's true intent was to remove assets from the reach of heirs. Where the transfer was made under a construction contract, against a genuine debt, for value, or to a caregiver out of gratitude in return for care, the action fails. The Court accepts that consideration need not be money: services or labour may also constitute the price (1st Civil Chamber, E. 2016/13155, K. 2019/5597).
Situations Outside the 1974 Decision
The 1974 Decision applies only to the decedent's transfer of immovable property registered in his or her own name. Recent decisions of the 1st Civil Chamber exclude, in particular:
Property never registered in the decedent's name: where the decedent paid the price but had title registered directly in a relative's name, there is no transfer by the decedent of registered land; the transaction qualifies as a gift of movables (money), subject only to abatement (tenkis) if its conditions are met (1st Civil Chamber, E. 2026/1386, K. 2026/2216). Transfer of a cooperative share: the assignment of a cooperative membership share — a personal right — likewise falls outside the Decision; moreover, where the Decision is inapplicable, a damages claim based on muris muvazaasi cannot be entertained either (1st Civil Chamber, E. 2026/800, K. 2026/1457). The same applies to unregistered land and to movables such as money or vehicles; there the heir's remedy is abatement and hotchpot.
Who May Sue?
One of the most significant consequences of the 1974 Decision is the breadth of standing: every heir whose inheritance right is infringed may sue, whether or not entitled to a reserved share. The claimant sues not as the decedent's successor but in his or her own right, as a person injured by the infringement of the inheritance right; accordingly, the right of action arises upon the decedent's death and no action lies during the decedent's lifetime. Each heir may sue alone for his or her own share; in such actions the co-claimants are permissive, not compulsory, joint litigants (1st Civil Chamber, E. 2021/6928, K. 2022/1878). Persons who renounced the inheritance, waived it by contract or were disinherited lack standing.
Procedure: Competent Court and Value of the Claim
The action for annulment of title and registration is heard by the civil court of first instance (asliye hukuk mahkemesi); venue lies exclusively with the court of the place where the immovable is situated (CCP Art. 12). The claim is subject to a proportional fee over the value determined by survey and expert examination. The Court of Cassation holds that in actions brought for individual shares, the monetary threshold for appellate review is measured by the value corresponding to each claimant's share of the estate, not the value of the whole property (1st Civil Chamber, E. 2021/6928, K. 2022/1878). If the property is transferred to a third party during the proceedings, the action may continue against the transferee or be converted into a claim for the monetary value.
Time Limits
Under the settled case law, an action based on muris muvazaasi is subject to no statute of limitations and no preclusive period; it may be brought at any time. A simulated transaction produces no effect and does not become valid with the passage of time. Indeed, among the reviewed decisions, a transfer executed under a 1957 power of attorney (E. 2015/11864, K. 2018/10988) and a 1970 transaction (E. 2026/1386, K. 2026/2216) were litigated decades later. By contrast, an abatement (tenkis) claim raised in the alternative is subject to statutory periods — a distinction that must not be overlooked.
Proof
The burden of proof lies, under the general rule, on the heir alleging simulation:
“Unless the law provides otherwise, each party bears the burden of proving the facts on which it bases its right.”
Because the action is treated as founded on a tort against the estate, heirs are third parties to the deed and may prove the simulation by any evidence, including witnesses; the written-evidence rule does not apply. As the decedent's concealed intent is inherently difficult to establish, the Court requires an overall assessment in light of: local customs and traditions, social tendencies, the ordinary course of events, whether the decedent had a just and reasonable ground for the sale, the transferee's financial capacity, the gap between the stated price and the true value, and the personal relationship between the parties and the decedent. In practice, the decedent's economic situation and need to sell, whether the price passed through a bank, the transferee's income, and the decedent's relations with the other heirs are the facts through which these criteria materialise.
Court of Cassation Precedents
All decisions below were verified against their full texts in the official database; quotations are verbatim translations, omissions marked with …
Definition, standing and evidentiary criteria: the Chamber's comprehensive leading decision
“As is known, the simulation described in practice and doctrine as "muris muvazaasi" is by nature a relative (qualified) simulation. Here the decedent genuinely wishes to contract and to transfer his registered immovable; however, in order to deprive his heir of the inheritance right, he conceals his real purpose and transfers the immovable he in truth wishes to donate by declaring, in the official deed, an intent of sale or of care-until-death. In that case, as explained in the settled case law and in the Unification of Case-Law Decision No. 1/2 of 01.04.1974, since the apparent contract does not correspond to the parties' true intent, and the hidden gift lacks the form required by Art. 706 of the Civil Code, Art. 237 of the Code of Obligations and Art. 26 of the Land Registry Law, all heirs whose inheritance rights are infringed — whether or not holders of a reserved share — may sue for a declaration of the invalidity of the official deed and the annulment of the registration based on it. … To that end, recourse must be had to such facts as the customs and traditions of the country and region, social tendencies, the ordinary course of events, whether the decedent had a just and reasonable ground for making the contract, whether the transferee had the means to buy, the difference between the sale price and the true value at the date of the contract, and the personal relationship between the parties and the decedent.”
In the same decision the Chamber held that the price need not be money — services or labour suffice — and, on the facts (the defendant daughter-in-law had cared for the 84-year-old decedent), found the transfer to have been made out of gratitude in return for care, not to defraud heirs, requiring dismissal (reversal).
No intent to deprive heirs — the 1974 Decision does not apply
“Turning to the concrete case, it is clear that the decedent's purpose was not to remove assets from the other heirs but to have a building constructed on parcel 1245 and to receive three flats. … It is clear that Article 19 of the TCO No. 6098 and the Unification Decision No. 1/2 of 01.04.1974, which form the legal basis of muris muvazaasi, can apply only where the decedent aimed to remove assets from the reach of his other heirs.”
No limitation or preclusive period; the right of action arises on death
“Moreover, it is accepted by unwavering case law and concurring doctrine that actions based on muris muvazaasi, being in the nature of a tort against the estate and of an unlawful registration, may be brought at any time, subject to no statute of limitations or preclusive period. A simulated transaction produces no effect, and the apparent void transaction does not become valid through the disappearance of the ground of simulation or the passage of time. As emphasised in the Unification Decision No. 1/2 of 01.04.1974, the claimant sues not as the decedent's successor but as a person injured by the infringement of the inheritance right, relying on his own inheritance right. The right of action arises upon the decedent's death.”
The Court reversed a judgment that had dismissed, on ten-year limitation grounds, a claim concerning a transfer executed under a 1957 power of attorney.
Procedure: permissive joinder and the appellate threshold
“It must be noted at once that, since claimants in muris muvazaasi actions brought for individual shares are permissive rather than compulsory joint litigants, the value of the claim is beyond doubt the value corresponding to the share of each claimant heir.”
Property never registered in the decedent's name: outside the Decision — gift of movables and abatement
“… it being established by the claimant's own statement and the land records that the property was not transferred by the decedent to the defendants' predecessor, but was registered in the predecessor's name with the price paid by the decedent, the Unification Decision No. 1/2 of 01.04.1974 is inapplicable to the present case, and the dismissal of the claim for annulment of title and registration is in accordance with procedure and law …”
The first-instance court characterised the transaction as a gift of movables, subject to abatement if its conditions are met; that determination survived both appellate reviews.
Cooperative share transfers are outside the Decision; nor may damages be claimed
“… the Unification Decision No. 1/2 of 01.04.1974 has no application to the transfer of a cooperative (membership) share, which is the assignment of a personal right …” — “… particularly since, where the Unification Decision is inapplicable, a damages claim based on muris muvazaasi cannot be entertained either …”
Not every form of care counts as consideration: ordinary care is a moral duty, while care requiring special attention may be consideration (Assembly of Civil Chambers)
“However, it should not be concluded from this explanation that every kind of care or service will be accepted as the price/consideration. For just as it is a moral duty for a child to care for and help his or her parents as far as possible, it is also a requirement of the marital union for spouses to care for and support one another. Therefore, care and services provided where the parent or spouse needed special attention and care beyond ordinary care, and the limit of duty was exceeded, must be regarded as consideration.” (unofficial translation)
Acting through an attorney and in the form of a sale, the deceased transferred to a daughter-in-law the bare ownership of the only immovable the deceased owned, retaining usufruct; the defendant argued that the transfer rewarded years of care and attention. The 1st Civil Chamber reversed, holding that the defendant had cared for the deceased and that it was contrary to the ordinary course of life to deprive children with whom there was no dispute, so the action should be dismissed. The Assembly of Civil Chambers instead assessed together that the deceased lived at home with a second spouse, who provided the care; that the defendant lived in a separate flat in the same building; that the deceased, who had a pension and social security, remained in good health until death with no evidence of a need for special care; that there was no legitimate and reasonable ground for transferring her only immovable; and that no price was paid. Noting that petitions by some heirs consenting to the transfer did not change this conclusion, the Assembly upheld by majority the insistence judgment finding a simulated transfer made to deprive heirs, and sent the file to the 1st Civil Chamber to examine the remaining grounds of appeal. The decision was rendered with no further rectification remedy and is final.
In a transfer made in return for lifelong care, intent to divert assets may be found where the share of the transferred property in the whole estate exceeds a reasonable limit (Assembly of Civil Chambers)
“For this purpose it is necessary to rely on facts such as whether the deceased had a legitimate and reasonable ground for concluding the contract, the deceased’s relations with the care provider and the other heirs, the deceased’s age and state of health, and the ratio of the transferred property to the deceased’s whole estate. … while the deceased could have met the need for care by giving shares in fewer immovables, the deceased transferred far more immovables than could be regarded as reasonable, a further immovable was transferred to the same defendants by way of gift through a power of attorney given shortly before death, and, considering the ratio of the total value of the transferred immovables to the value of the immovable left behind, the reasonable limit was exceeded…” (unofficial translation)
The deceased had transferred, in 2001, shares in three immovables to two daughters under lifelong care contracts and, in 2009, through a power of attorney given shortly before death, a share in a further immovable by way of gift; a single co-owned immovable was left in the estate. The children of a predeceased son sued for cancellation of title and registration on the ground of muris muvazaasi, or alternatively for reduction. The first-instance court, finding that the care obligation had been performed, dismissed the claim for the immovables transferred under the care contracts, allowed reduction for the gifted share, and insisted on its judgment after reversal by the 1st Civil Chamber. The Assembly accepted that a care contract does not require a special need for care at the date of the contract, but, noting that the deceased could have met the need for care with fewer immovables yet transferred far more than a reasonable measure, and that relations between the deceased and the claimants’ mother were poor, held that intent to divert assets had been proved; adopting the Chamber’s reversal, it reversed the insistence judgment by majority. A view that it is ordinary for a deceased who wants relatives to provide care to transfer a substantial part of the estate, and that the judgment should be upheld, was not adopted by the majority. The decision was rendered under the former Code of Civil Procedure No. 1086 and was open to rectification. The Assembly did not rely on a single criterion; it weighed the proportion transferred together with family relations and the timing of the transfers.
The burden of proof lies on the claimant; a price gap alone does not prove simulation (Assembly of Civil Chambers)
“In other words, in muris muvazaasi actions the burden of proving that the transfer made by the deceased was simulated and made in order to divert assets from the estate lies on the claimant.” — “The difference between the prices shown in the deed and the real values established by on-site survey cannot by itself be regarded as proof of simulation.” (unofficial translation)
Finding that intent to divert assets had not been proved in a sale to a buyer who was not an heir, had no close relationship with the deceased and whose purchasing power was established, the Assembly reversed by majority the insistence judgment that had allowed the claim. The decision shows that the gap between real value and sale price must be assessed together with other facts, such as whether the deceased had a legitimate and reasonable ground for the sale, the buyer’s purchasing power and the relationship between the parties and the deceased.
How Long Do These Cases Take?
Muris muvazaasi litigation is, in practice, lengthy: surveys, expert examinations, extensive witness evidence and near-routine recourse to appellate remedies all add time. The observations below are not official statistics; they are confined to dates read directly from the headnotes and texts of the verified decisions reviewed in this article:
| Decision | Course of proceedings as read from the text | Duration observed |
|---|---|---|
| E. 2016/13155, K. 2019/5597 | Transfer 06.08.2013; death 19.12.2014; file reached the Court of Cassation in 2016, decided 31.10.2019 (reversal — proceedings continued) | Cassation stage alone ≈ 3 years; death to reversal ≈ 5 years |
| E. 2015/11864, K. 2018/10988 | File reached the Court in 2015, decided 04.06.2018 (reversal); disputed transfer based on a 1957 power of attorney | Cassation stage alone ≈ 3 years |
| E. 2020/1465, K. 2021/1286 | Transfer 02.05.2012; judgment for claimant → reversal → compliance and dismissal → second cassation review → affirmance 08.03.2021 | ≈ 8 years 10 months from transaction to final decision (two cassation rounds) |
| E. 2021/6928, K. 2022/1878 | Regional appeal: E. 2019/922 → decided 08.06.2021; cassation petition 29.06.2021 → decision 08.03.2022 | Regional appeal ≈ 2 years; cassation ≈ 8.5 months |
| E. 2026/1386, K. 2026/2216 | Filed 08.08.2023 → first instance K. 2024/329 → regional appeal K. 2025/3306 → final affirmance 25.03.2026; underlying transaction dated 1970 | All three instances ≈ 2 years 8 months |
| E. 2026/800, K. 2026/1457 | Filed 2022 (first instance E. 2022/436 → K. 2023/557) → regional appeal K. 2025/2487 → final affirmance 25.02.2026; related earlier action E. 2017/25 → K. 2020/309 | Present action ≈ 3.5 years; the chain of disputes ran ≈ 9 years (2017–2026) |
Three tendencies emerge from this sample: (i) in pre-2016-system files, the cassation stage alone could take about 3 years; (ii) where a reversal intervened, proceedings stretched to as much as 9 years from the transaction to the final decision; (iii) in files passing through the regional appellate system, all three instances have been completed in roughly 2.5 to 4 years. The duration of any given case depends on the evidence, survey and expert stages, the number of parties and properties, and the remedies pursued — which makes complete evidence-gathering and a sound strategy from the outset all the more important.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who may bring a muris muvazaasi action?
Every heir whose inheritance right is infringed, whether or not entitled to a reserved share. The right of action arises upon the decedent's death; no action lies during the decedent's lifetime.
Is the action subject to a limitation period?
No. It may be brought at any time; transactions dating from 1957 and 1970 were litigated in the reviewed decisions. An alternative abatement (tenkis) claim, however, is subject to statutory periods.
Which transactions fall within the action?
The decedent's transfer of registered land disguised as a sale or care-until-death contract. Cooperative share transfers and cases where the decedent paid the price but title was registered directly in another's name fall outside; there, abatement may be available.
By what criteria is simulation established?
Local customs, the ordinary course of events, whether the decedent had a just and reasonable ground to sell, the transferee's means, the gap between price and true value, and the personal relationship between the parties — provable by any evidence, including witnesses.
Is a transfer made in return for care simulated?
The price need not be money; services or labour suffice. Where the transfer was made out of gratitude in return for care rather than to defraud heirs, the action is dismissed. However, according to the Assembly of Civil Chambers, a child’s ordinary care for a parent is a moral duty; care counts as consideration only where special attention beyond ordinary care was needed.
How long does the case take?
In the reviewed decisions, files passing through the current three-tier system were completed in roughly 2.5–4 years, while older files involving reversals stretched to about 9 years from the transaction to the final decision.
For our practice in real estate and inheritance disputes, see Real Estate Law.
Related Articles
- The Pre-emption (Şufa) Action and Sham Transactions: Constitutional Court Annuls the Market-Value Rule
- Dissolution of Co-ownership (Partition): Division in Kind and Sale
- Division of Property in Divorce: The Participation in Acquired Property Regime
- Certificate of Inheritance and Disclaimer of Inheritance in Turkish Law: Notary or Civil Court of Peace, the Three-Month Period, Deemed Disclaimer and Liability for Estate Debts
- The Pre-emption (Şufa) Action and Sham Transactions: Constitutional Court Annuls the Market-Value Rule
- Division of Property in Divorce: The Participation in Acquired Property Regime
- Dissolution of Co-ownership (Partition): Division in Kind and Sale
- Certificate of Inheritance and Disclaimer in Türkiye: Notary or Civil Court of Peace, Three-Month Period, Deemed Disclaimer and Estate Debts
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are published Court of Cassation decisions and do not relate to files in which this firm acted; the duration observations are a sample derived solely from the headnotes and texts of those decisions and are not official statistics.
Author: Inheritance attorney Bayram Can Çapar, Denizli, Türkiye - ÇAPAR HUKUK
If you have a question on this topic
This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.
Other articles in Inheritance Law
- Foreign Heirs and Property in Türkiye: Inheritance Certificate, Land Registry Transfer, Acquisition Limits
- Turkish Inheritance and Transfer Tax for Heirs Abroad: Filing, Additional Periods, Instalments, Tax Clearance
- How the Turkish Inheritance Law System Works: Heirs, Spouse’s Share, Reserved Shares, Wills, Division
- Turkish Abatement (Tenkis) Actions: Reserved Shares, Calculation, Cassation 7th Civil Chamber Precedents
Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Decedent's Simulated Transactions (Muris Muvazaasi): Title Annulment in Turkish Court of Cassation Case-Law”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-19, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/decedents-simulated-transactions

























