Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 12 min read

Last reviewed:

The Pre-emption (Şufa) Action and Sham Transactions: Constitutional Court Annuls the Market-Value Rule

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, a pre-emptor currently pays the market value of the share set by the judge, under the rule introduced by Law No. 7571; the Constitutional Court has annulled that rule, but the annulment takes effect on 6 August 2027 and the market-value rule continues to apply until then. Where a co-owner sells their share in an immovable to a third party, the other co-owners may exercise their pre-emption right by bringing an action against the buyer (Civil Code Arts. 732 and 734). The pre-emptor must deposit the market value determined by the judge, together with the land-registry costs borne by the buyer, within the final period set; otherwise the share cannot be registered in their name. The sale is notified to the other co-owners through a notary by the buyer or the seller; the pre-emption right lapses three months after notification and in any event one year after the sale (Art. 733). Before Law No. 7571 the registry sale price was paid, so an allegation of a sham price was decisive and, according to the Court of Cassation, had to be proven by the party making it; under the market-value rule that debate carries less weight, and which price will apply after the annulment depends on new legislation. The action is brought before the civil court of first instance where the immovable is located.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

The pre-emption (şufa) action and sham transactions: the statutory pre-emption right of other co-owners when a co-owner sells their share to a third party (Civil Code Art. 732), the three-month/one-year forfeiture periods and notarial notice (Art. 733), the market-value rule introduced by Law No. 7571 of 24/12/2025 (Art. 734) and the Constitutional Court decision annulling it with effect from 6 August 2027, sham in the sale price and the burden of proof, the competent court, and Court of Cassation decisions.

The pre-emption (şufa) action and sham transactions — the statutory pre-emption right of other co-owners when a co-owner sells their share to a third party (Civil Code Art. 732), the forfeiture periods (three months / one year), the market-value rule introduced by the 24/12/2025 amendment (Art. 734) and its annulment by the Constitutional Court, sham in the sale price and concealment of the real price, the competent court, and Court of Cassation decisions.

The pre-emption (şufa) right allows the other co-owners, where a co-owner sells their share in a jointly owned immovable to a third party, to purchase that share with priority. Its aim is to prevent unwanted outsiders from entering the co-ownership. In practice the most contentious aspect of pre-emption actions is the sale price being shown untruthfully (in a sham) in the land registry. This article addresses the conditions, periods, the 2025 statutory amendment, the Constitutional Court decision annulling it, and the sham problem, in the light of verified Court of Cassation decisions. See also our articles Dissolution of Co-ownership (Partition) and Pre-emption in a Neighbouring Agricultural Parcel under the Soil Protection Law.

What Is the Pre-emption (Şufa) Right?

The statutory pre-emption right arises from co-ownership and from the law; it is effective even without registration. It arises only where the share passes to a third party by sale; as a rule it cannot be used in cases of gift, exchange or forced sale.

Relevant provision — Civil Code Art. 732 (unofficial translation)

“Where, in co-ownership, a co-owner sells their share in the immovable wholly or partly to a third party, the other co-owners may exercise the pre-emption right.”

Conditions and Forfeiture Periods

The periods for exercising the pre-emption right are forfeiture periods and missing them ends the right. The sale must be notified to the co-owners through a notary; the pre-emption right lapses upon the passing of three months from the notification to the right-holder and, in any event, of one year from the sale. The right cannot be used in sales under the State Tender Law or in forced auctions; waiver of the right is subject to official form and a land-registry annotation.

Relevant provision — Civil Code Art. 733 (unofficial translation)

“(First paragraph as amended on 24/12/2025 by Law No. 7571, Art. 35) The pre-emption right cannot be used in sales under the State Tender Law No. 2886 dated 8/9/1983 or in forced auctions. Waiver of the pre-emption right must be made in official form and annotated in the land registry. A waiver of the pre-emption right for a particular sale is subject to written form and may be made before or after the sale. The sale is notified by the buyer or the seller to the other co-owners through a notary. The pre-emption right lapses upon the passing of three months from the notification of the sale to the right-holder and, in any event, of one year from the sale.”

The Amount Payable: Sale Price, Market Value and the Constitutional Court's Annulment

The pre-emption right is exercised by bringing an action against the buyer. As to the amount payable, three periods must be distinguished:

  • Before Law No. 7571: the pre-emptor paid the sale price shown in the land registry and the land-registry costs borne by the buyer. The Constitutional Court had found this “sale price” basis compatible with the Constitution (Constitutional Court, E.2023/77, K.2023/190, 08.11.2023).
  • Since 25.12.2025 (Law No. 7571): Law No. 7571 of 24/12/2025 entered into force on 25.12.2025, the date of its publication in the Official Gazette. Under it, the market value of the disputed share is determined by the judge; the pre-emptor deposits that value, together with the buyer's land-registry costs, in cash within the final period set by the judge, failing which the share cannot be registered in their name. The amendment also applies to actions brought before it entered into force (provisional Art. 1(2)).
  • Annulment by the Constitutional Court: the Constitutional Court annulled, by majority, the words “market value” in Art. 734(2) as contrary to Articles 5 and 35 of the Constitution; it also annulled the words “without delay” and “final period”, the rest of the paragraph and provisional Art. 1(2), which applied the rule to pending actions, since they could no longer be applied (Constitutional Court, E.2026/23, K.2026/162, 16.07.2026). The decision was published in Official Gazette No. 33422 of 06.11.2026. The annulments take effect nine months after publication, on 6 August 2027; the request for a stay was rejected. Until 6 August 2027, Art. 734(2) and provisional Art. 1(2) continue to apply.
Relevant provision — Civil Code Art. 734 (unofficial translation)

“The pre-emption right is exercised by bringing an action against the buyer. (Second paragraph as amended on 24/12/2025 by Law No. 7571, Art. 36) The market value of the disputed share is determined by the judge without delay. The pre-emption right-holder is obliged to deposit, in cash, the determined market value together with the land-registry expenses falling on the buyer, within a strict period, to the place designated by the judge to be invested for yield. If this obligation is not fulfilled within the strict period, the share cannot be ordered to be registered in the name of the pre-emption right-holder. The deposited amount is paid, together with its yield, to the relevant person upon the judgment becoming final.”

According to the Constitutional Court, pre-emption rests on the pre-emptor taking over, unchanged, the terms of sale accepted by the buyer, whereas the market-value rule sets aside the price the parties freely agreed. The buyer may therefore gain by receiving more than they paid or suffer a loss by receiving less, and the pre-emptor learns the amount payable only at the end of the proceedings; the Court concluded that no fair balance was struck between the parties' interests. The decision says nothing about which price will apply after 6 August 2027; the Court deferred the effect of the annulment because the resulting gap would harm the public interest. The legislature is expected to adopt new rules in the meantime; if it does not, the resulting position is open to debate. In pending actions, too, the market-value rule applies until the annulment takes effect; how actions still pending on that date will be decided depends on any new legislation and on case law.

Sham in the Sale Price and Concealing the Real Price

The classic problem of pre-emption actions is the sale price being shown in a sham in the registry. In the period when the amount payable was the registry sale price, the seller and buyer could show the price far above the truth to deter pre-emption, while the right-holder asserted a sham in the price in order to pay over the “real sale price”. On the settled approach of the Court of Cassation, the party asserting a sham in the price must prove it; if not proven, the registry price was taken as the basis. By turning the amount payable into market value, the 2025 amendment has reduced the practical weight of the price-sham debate, since, while the market-value rule applies, the basis is not the registry price but the market value set by the judge. The Constitutional Court annulled that rule because it sets aside the sale price agreed by the parties; if, after the annulment takes effect on 6 August 2027, rules based on the sale price are adopted, the price-sham debate may regain importance. Nevertheless, other forms of sham (the sale being in truth a gift/transfer, or a collusive transaction to evade pre-emption) remain on the agenda.

Competent Court

Because the pre-emption action concerns the substance of the immovable, it is brought before the civil court of first instance of the place where the immovable is located (exclusive jurisdiction). The action is directed against the third-party buyer and seeks cancellation of the title and registration in the name of the pre-emption right-holder.

Court of Cassation Decisions

The claim that the price was shown high in the official deed to obstruct pre-emption may be proved by the pre-emptor by any evidence, including witnesses

Court of Cassation

“Although the defendant, as a party to the legal transaction for the sale of the share in dispute, cannot raise a plea of sham in the price against the plaintiff, who is in the position of a third party, the plaintiff may claim that the sale price was shown high in the official deed of sale in order to obstruct the pre-emption right, and may prove this claim by any evidence, including witnesses. … Although the plaintiff relied on witness evidence, it did not submit its list of witnesses and did not rely on any other evidence capable of proving the sham claim. In that case, it cannot be said that the plaintiff proved the sham claim.” (unofficial translation)

The party asserting a sham in the price must prove it; if unproven, that assertion is not given credit

Court of Cassation

“… although [the plaintiff] asserted that the sale price was shown as a sham in order to obstruct the pre-emption right and that the real sale price was …, since it could not prove the assertion of a sham in the price …” (unofficial translation)

Frequently Asked Questions

Within what period must I exercise the pre-emption right?

If the sale was notified to you through a notary, you must sue within three months of the notification and, in any event, within one year of the sale. These are forfeiture periods; if missed, the right ends.

Can I use pre-emption for a share transferred by gift?

As a rule, no. The pre-emption right arises only on a sale of the share; it cannot be used in gift, exchange or forced/auction sale. However, if it is ostensibly a gift but in truth a sale (sham), this may be asserted by proving it.

What did the 2025 amendment and the Constitutional Court decision change in pre-emption?

Law No. 7571 of 24/12/2025 amended Art. 734; the right-holder deposits not the registry sale price but the market value set by the judge, together with the land-registry expenses, within a final period. The Constitutional Court has annulled that rule; since the annulment takes effect on 6 August 2027, the market-value rule applies until then.

The sale price is shown very high in the registry; what can I do?

Before Law No. 7571 the amount payable was the registry price, so the sham assertion was critical and had to be proven. Since 25.12.2025 the basis is market value, so a high stated price is not decisive on its own; even so, whether the transaction is truly a sale may be discussed. As the market-value rule ceases to have effect on 6 August 2027, a price sham may regain importance under the rules that apply after that date.

Against whom and where is the pre-emption action brought?

The action is brought against the third-party buyer, before the civil court of first instance of the place where the immovable is located, and seeks cancellation of title and registration in your name.

Çapar Law Office pursues pre-emption (şufa), title-cancellation and registration actions within Real Estate Law.

Related Articles

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are from the official Legislation Information System; the decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Real Estate Law

All Real Estate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “The Pre-emption (Şufa) Action and Sham Transactions: Constitutional Court Annuls the Market-Value Rule”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-17, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-action-sham-transactions

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›