Skip to content
+90 258 241 55 54Request a Meeting
TR EN
Published · Updated · 11 min read

Last reviewed:

Case Note

Pre-emption Price Valued at Filing Date or 25.12.2025: Turkish Court of Cassation on Law No. 7571

Text sizeTheme

Short answer: Under Turkish law, Law No. 7571 replaced the sale price shown in the land registry with the market value of the share in dispute as the pre-emption price, but did not regulate as at which date that market value is to be determined; the Constitutional Court has annulled that market-value rule, with effect from 6 August 2027. According to the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, the market value at the filing date applies in actions brought after 25.12.2025, the date the amendment entered into force, and the market value as at 25.12.2025 applies in actions pending on that date. In a pending action, the amount previously deposited and accrued is set off and any shortfall is deposited. The reasoning was adopted by majority; the dissenting opinion argues for the market value at the date of sale. Until 6 August 2027, the market-value rule and the Chamber’s criterion continue to apply.

This article explains Turkish law. It is an English translation of the Turkish original; in case of any discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.

In brief

Under Turkish law, according to the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, the market value forming the pre-emption price is assessed as at the filing date in actions brought after 25.12.2025 and as at 25.12.2025 in actions pending on that date; amounts already deposited are set off with their yield. The reasoning was adopted by majority. The Constitutional Court has annulled the market-value rule and its application to pending actions, with effect from 6 August 2027.

A decision of the 7th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation, with a dissenting opinion, on the valuation date of the pre-emption price that Law No. 7571 left unregulated (Turkish Civil Code art. 734(2), provisional art. 1).

The Dispute

The claimants are co-owners of an immovable held in shared ownership. In 2021 the defendant bought a share in that immovable. Claiming that the sale had not been notified to them through a notary, the claimants relied on their right of pre-emption and sought cancellation of the land registry entry for the share in the defendant’s name and its registration in their own names.

The Antalya 1st Civil Court of First Instance allowed the action; under the provision then in force, the price was the sale price shown in the land registry plus the land registry costs borne by the buyer. The 5th Civil Chamber of the Antalya Regional Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on the merits. On appeal on points of law, the defendant argued that the forfeiture period had expired and that depositing the price two and a half years after the sale led to unjust enrichment.

Outcome of the Decision

By its decision of 05.03.2026, the 7th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation set aside the Regional Court of Appeal’s decision and reversed the first-instance judgment. The reversal concerns the pre-emption price; the defendant’s other objections were not examined for the time being. The decision is final and was given unanimously as to the outcome and by majority as to the reasoning: the dissenting member agreed with the reversal but not with the reasoning on the valuation date.

Reasoning

The Chamber first set out the new text of Turkish Civil Code art. 734(2) and provisional art. 1(2), which makes the amendment applicable also to actions brought before it entered into force, and then identified the gap in the statute.

Court of Cassation Decision

“In that amendment, the legislature made no provision as to the date by reference to which the market value of the share subject to the pre-emption right is to be determined in pre-emption actions, and left the determination of that date to practice.” (translation)

The Chamber filled the gap by relying on arts. 1 and 4 of the Turkish Civil Code and on the right of property under art. 35 of the Constitution: in determining the pre-emption price a fair balance must be struck between the parties, avoiding outcomes that enrich the claimant beyond the purpose of the right and impoverish the defendant. The rule derived from this is as follows:

Court of Cassation Decision

“Having regard to the statutory provisions and principles explained above, since the second paragraph of Article 734 of the Turkish Civil Code as amended by Law No. 7571 contains no provision on the matter, it is consistent with the purpose of the law and the general principles of law to take as the basis for determining the market value of the share subject to the pre-emption right the filing date for actions brought after the amendment entered into force, and the date on which the amendment entered into force for actions brought before that date and pending on it.” (translation)

Since the action had been brought before the amendment, the Chamber directed the first-instance court as follows:

Court of Cassation Decision
7th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/3855, K. 2026/1287, 05.03.2026 (the Chamber’s ground for reversal)

“…the market value of the share subject to the pre-emption right is to be determined as at 25.12.2025, and if the pre-emption price so determined exceeds the amount previously deposited and accrued, the total amount previously deposited and accrued is to be set off against the pre-emption price and the balance deposited into the same account to accrue interest…” (translation)

For the dissenting member, by contrast, pre-emption creates a sale relationship on the terms of the original sale; the statute merely replaced the sale price shown in the land registry with the real value at the date of sale.

Court of Cassation Decision

“…in pre-emption actions brought after the date on which Law No. 7571 entered into force, the market value of the share subject to pre-emption must be determined by reference to the date of sale, as before the statutory amendment…” (translation)

Significance and Practical Effect

Before Law No. 7571, the price was the sale price in the land registry plus the land registry costs, and no valuation-date question arose. Once market value became the yardstick, three candidate dates emerged: the date of sale, the filing date and the date of entry into force. The Chamber chose the date of entry into force for pending actions and the filing date for new actions.

  • Pending actions: The value of the share as at 25.12.2025 is determined through an on-site inspection and a panel of court experts; if it exceeds the amount deposited plus its yield, the difference must be deposited. If the price is not deposited within the peremptory period, registration in the claimant’s name cannot be ordered (Turkish Civil Code art. 734(2)).
  • New actions: The market value at the filing date applies; if the value has risen since the sale, the claimant also pays that increase. The action must be brought within three months of notification of the sale through a notary and in any event within one year of the sale (Turkish Civil Code art. 733); the one-year outer limit does not apply to sales made before 25.12.2025 (provisional art. 1(1)).

Current position (November 2026): The Chamber’s criterion rests on the market-value rule introduced by Law No. 7571 and on provisional art. 1(2), which applies that rule to pending actions. The Constitutional Court annulled, by majority, the words “market value” in Turkish Civil Code art. 734(2) as contrary to Articles 5 and 35 of the Constitution; since they could no longer be applied, it also annulled the words “without delay” and “final period”, the rest of the paragraph and provisional art. 1(2) (Constitutional Court, E.2026/23, K.2026/162, 16.07.2026). The decision was published in Official Gazette No. 33422 of 06.11.2026. The annulments take effect nine months after publication, on 6 August 2027; the request for a stay was rejected. Until then, the market-value rule also applies in pending actions and the valuation-date question remains. In the Court’s view, pre-emption rests on taking over the terms of sale accepted by the buyer unchanged; the market-value rule sets aside the price agreed by the parties, and the pre-emptor learns the amount payable only at the end of the proceedings. The decision says nothing about which price will apply after 6 August 2027 or about actions still pending on that date; the legislature is expected to adopt new rules in the meantime, and if it does not, the resulting position is open to debate.

The dissenting opinion also notes that, if several co-owners bring separate actions for the same share, a filing-date criterion would produce a different price in each action. The Chamber has repeated the same reasoning, and the same dissent, in many decisions given in 2026; for example, 7th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/5945, K. 2026/2870, 02.06.2026. The Assembly of Civil Chambers, for its part, reversed a first-instance court’s decision to maintain its earlier judgment, stating that the new rule also applies to pending actions, but did not lay down a criterion for the valuation date (Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2025/216, K. 2026/195, 01.04.2026). The majority view currently guides practice; since it is contested, it could change through a decision of the Assembly of Civil Chambers or a decision unifying case law.

Relevant Legislation

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) art. 734(2) (Exercise; amended: 24/12/2025, Law No. 7571 art. 36) (unofficial translation)

“The market value of the share in dispute is determined by the judge without delay. The holder of the pre-emption right must deposit in cash the market value so determined, together with the land registry costs borne by the buyer, at the place designated by the judge, to accrue interest, within the peremptory period given. If this obligation is not fulfilled within the peremptory period given, registration of the share in the name of the holder of the pre-emption right may not be ordered. The amount deposited is paid to the person concerned together with its accrued interest once the judgment becomes final.”

Statutory Provision — Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721) provisional art. 1(2) (Added: 24/12/2025, Law No. 7571 art. 37) (unofficial translation)

“(2) The amendments made to Article 734 of Law No. 4721 by the Law introducing this article also apply to actions brought before the date on which those amendments entered into force.”

Frequently Asked Questions

How is the pre-emption price determined after Law No. 7571?

The market value of the share in dispute is determined by the judge without delay; the holder of the right must deposit that amount, together with the land registry costs borne by the buyer, in cash within the peremptory period given (Turkish Civil Code art. 734(2)). The Constitutional Court has annulled that rule; since the annulment takes effect on 6 August 2027, it applies until then.

As at which date is the market value assessed in a pre-emption action?

According to the 7th Civil Chamber of the Turkish Court of Cassation, the market value at the filing date applies to actions brought after 25.12.2025, and the market value as at 25.12.2025 applies to actions pending on that date. The statute contains no express rule on this point.

What happens to the amount already deposited in a pending action?

The amount deposited and its yield are set off against the market value of the share as at 25.12.2025; any shortfall is deposited into the same account (Turkish Civil Code provisional art. 1(2)). Provisional art. 1(2), which applies the rule to pending actions, has also been annulled by the Constitutional Court, with effect from 6 August 2027.

Has the Assembly of Civil Chambers fixed the valuation date?

No. In its decision of 01.04.2026, the Assembly of Civil Chambers stated that the new price rule also applies to pending actions, but did not lay down a criterion for the valuation date.

Related Articles

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Statutory texts are taken from the Official Legislation Information System and decisions from the official case-law database. The decisions cited are not cases handled by the firm.

Author:

If you have a question on this topic

This article was written by Av. Bayram Can Çapar. At Av. Bayram Can Çapar · ÇAPAR Hukuk, we provide legal services with our team in Denizli, İzmir, Aydın, Muğla, Manisa, Uşak, Afyonkarahisar, Kütahya, İstanbul and Ankara, Türkiye.

+90 258 241 55 54 · info@capar.av.tr · Send a message

Other articles in Real Estate Law

All Real Estate Law articles →

Cite as: Av. Bayram Can Çapar, “Pre-emption Price Valued at Filing Date or 25.12.2025: Turkish Court of Cassation on Law No. 7571”, ÇAPAR Hukuk, 2026-11-17, https://capar.av.tr/en/article/pre-emption-price-market-value-valuation-date-turkiye

← All articles

Latest Articles

All articles ›